Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract: The authors begin by discussing the changes in patterns of family life that have
occurred over recent years. They cite the increase in the number of working mothers and
the change in what has been considered a traditional family structure. They point out that
most women work out of economic necessity and that they add their job responsibilities to
their traditional ones. Recent literature on maternal attachment has made it necessary to
consider how the separation of mother and child related to the mother working affects the
child. The authors review some of the recent literature in this area and point out that not
only is it the quality of care that is most critical to the child but that there is evidence that in-
fants can form more than one attachment. They cite the mutuality of the relationship be-
tween mother and child and point out the lack of evidence for a relationship between
maternal employment and maternal deprivation. They also review the literature on the im-
pact on older children of mothers' working and report that it appears that maternal employ-
ment has a positive effect, particularly on daughters. Although all of the data is not yet clear,
they conclude that there may be benefits for mothers, children, and families in terms of the
quality of relationships and identifications when mothers work.
Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry, 20: 863-875, 1981.
Dr. Nadelson is Professor and Vice-Chairman, Tufts University School of Medicine, Director of
Training and Education, Department of Psychiatry, Tufts New England Medical Center (171
Harrison Avenue, Boston, MA 02111), where reprints may be requested. Dr. Notman is Clinical Pro-
fessor of Psychiatry, Tufts University School ofMedicine, Director of Psychotherapy Training, Depart-
ment of Psychiatry, Tufts New England Medical Center.
0002-7138/81/2004-0863 $01.16 © 1981 American Academy of Child Psychiatry.
863
864 Carol Nadelson and Malkah Notman
activity about which they may have some choice and from which
they may obtain personal gratification (Bardwick, 1971). These
women often experience role strain as a result of proliferation of
areas of responsibilities (johnson and Johnson, 1976).
Any comparison of the impact on children of working and
nonworking mothers must take into account the actual amount of
time a full-time mother spends with her children. This is important
longitudinally (that is, the years of life taken up by caring for chil-
dren) and horizontally (that is, the amount of time each day spent
in child care). Childbearing and rearing occupy only a small
portion of a woman's lifetime and she is often not prepared for
what will later become a major part of her life, if she prepared pri-
marily for a role as a mother and a caretaker of small children.
Rossi (1972) estimated that the average woman marries at age 22,
has two children two years apart and dies at 74, seven years after
the husband's death at age 67. She thus has 56 years of adulthood
(starting at age 18), of which:
(1) 23% (13 years) are without a husband;
(2) 41 % (23 years) are with a husband but not with children un-
der 18; and
(3) 36% (20 years) are with a husband and at least 1 child under
18.
H we assume that parenting is full-time up to school age (6), then
only 12% of a woman's adulthood (or 7 years) consists of full-time
mothering of preschool children. While these figures continue to
change, it is clear that even the nonworking woman in contempo-
rary society will spend almost 2 times as many years with neither
husband nor dependent children than she will spend carrying re-
sponsibility for preschool children.
Another important consideration is the impact of divorce on
mothers and children, since this has resulted in an increase in the
number of working mothers. The rising divorce rate makes it a dis-
tinct possibility that many women will be alone for an even longer
time than in the past and that they will have to support themselves
and often their children, too. Divorced women suffer greater eco-
nomic difficulty than married women and often cannot maintain
an adequate standard of living. One third of female-headed house-
holds (resulting from divorce or from women never having mar-
ried) have incomes below the poverty level (Pearce, 1978). The
impact of divorce, then, may be greate~ because economic depriva-
tion often accompanies the emotional turmoil, A child may thus ex-
866 Carol Nadelson and Malkah Notman
perience the loss of both parents, one who leaves and the other
who may begin to work, as well as a change in life style.
MOTHER-CHILD RELATIONSHIPS
CONCLUSIONS
REFERENCES
ALMQUIST, E., & ARGRIST, S. (1971), Role model influences in college women's career aspi-
rations. MerriU Palmer Quart. ofBehav. and Development, 17:263-279.
AL-TIMIMI, S. (1976), "Self concepts of young children with working and nonworking
mothers." Ph.D. dissertation, Peabody College.
BARDWICK, J. (1971), Psychology of Women. New York: Harper and Row.
BIRNBAUM, J. (1975), Life patterns and self esteem in family oriented and career committed
women. In: Women and Achievement, ed. M. Mednick, S. Tangri, & L. Hoffman. New York:
Wiley.
BOWLBY, J. (1969), Attachment. New York: Basic Books.
BRAZELTON, B., & KEEFER, C. (in press), The early mother-child relationship. In: The Woman
Patient, vol. 2, ed. C. Nadelson & M. Notman. New York: Plenum Press.
BRONFENBRENNER, U. (1970), Two Worlds of Childhood: U.S. and U.S.S.R. New York: Simon
and Schuster, Pocket Books.
BRIM, O. G. (1975), Macrostructural influences on child development and the need for
childhood social indicators. Am.], Orthopsych., 45:516-524.
CASLER, L. (1961), Maternal Deprivation: A Critical Review of the Literature. Society for Research
in Child Development Monographs, vol. 26, no. 2. Chicago: Chicago University Press.
COUTROT, A. M., & ORMEZZANO, J. (1974), Chers parents. Paris: Laffont.
Cox, M. (1975), "The effects of father absence and working mothers on child." Ph.D. disser-
tation, University of Virginia.
DIZARD, J. (1968), Social Change in the Family. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
FRAIBERG, S. (1977), Every Child's Birthright. New York: Basic Books.
FRIES, M. (1977), Longitudinal study: prenatal period and parenthood.]. Amer. Psychoanal.
Assn., 25: 115-132.
GARLAND, T. N. (1972), The better half?: the male in the dual profession family. In: Toward
a Sociology ofWoman, ed. C. Safelios-Rothchild. Lexington, Mass.: Xerox Publishing Com-
pany.
HOFFMAN, L. (1972), Early childhood experiences and women's achievement motives. Social
Issues, 28:129-155.
HOWELL, M. (1973a), Effects of maternal employment on the child, II. Pediatrics! 52:327-
343.
- - (1973b), Employed mothers and their families, I. Pediatrics, 52:252-263.
JOHNSON, F., & JOHNSON, C. (1976), Role strain in high commitment career women.]. Amer.
Acad. Psychoanal., 4:13-36.
KENNISTON, K. (1977) Review of Every Child's Birthright, by S. Fraiberg. New York Times Book
Review, p. 1 (December 11).
KLAUS, M., & KENNELL, J. (1976), Maternal Infant Bonding. St. Louis, Mo.: C. V. Mosby, Co.
LAMB, M. (1975), Fathers: forgotten contributors to child development. Human Development,
18:245-266.
LEVINE, A. G. (1968), "Marital and occupational plans of women in professional schools."
Ph.D. dissertation, Yale University.
LICHTENBERG, J. (1981), Implications for psychoanalytic theory of research on the Neo-
nate. Int. Rev. Psychoanal., 8:35-52.
MACCOBY, E. (1966), Sex differences in intellectual functioning. In: The Development of Sex
Differences, ed. E. E. Maccoby, Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press.
Women, Work, and Children 875
MARANTZ, S., & MANSFIELD, A. (1977), Maternal employment and the development of sex
role stereotyping in five- to eleven-year-old girls. Child Development, 48:668-673.
MOORE, T. (1963), Effects on the children. In: Working Mothers and Their Children, ed. S.
Yudkin & W. Holme. London: Michael Joseph Ltd.
MORONEY, R. (1978), Note from the editor. Urban and Social Change Review, 11:2.
Moss, H. (1967), Sex, age and state of determinants of mother-infant interactions. MerriU
Palmer Quart. ofBehao. and Development, 13:19-36.
MURRAY, A. (1975), Maternal employment reconsidered. Am. J. Orthopsych., 45:773-790.
NADELSON, C. (1974), Adjustment: new approaches to women's mental health. In: The Ameri-
can Woman: Who Will She Be?, ed. M. McBee & J. Blake. Beverly Hills, Calif.: Bessinger,
Bruce and Glencoe.
- - - (1979), The women's movement and changing sex roles. Am. Handbook Child Psych.,
4:386-396.
- - - & NOTMAN, M. (1973), Medicine: a career conflict for women. Am. j. Psych.,
130:1123-1127.
NOTMAN, M. (1977), The impact of social change. Paper presented to Southern California
Psychiatric Society.
NYE, F. I., & HOFFMAN, L.. (1963), The Employed Mother in America. Chicago: Rand McNally.
PEARCE, D. (1978), The feminization of poverty. Urban and SocialChangeReview, 11:28-36.
PIFER, A. (1978), Women and working. Urban and SocialChange Review, 11:3-11.
RApOPORT, R., & RApOPORT, R. (1971), Dual Career Families. Middlesex, England: Penguin
Books.
- - - - - - (1978), Working Couples. New York: Harper and Row, Colophon Books.
RESCH, R. (1975), "Separation: natural observations in the first three years of life in an in-
fant day care unit." Ph.D. dissertation, New York University.
ROSSI, A. (1972), Family development in a changing world. Am. J. Psych., 128:1057-1066.
RUTTER, M. (1974), The Qualities of Mothering: Maternal Deprivation Reassessed. New York: Ja-
son Aronson.
SANDER, L., CHAPPELL, P., GOULD, j., & SNYDER, P. (1975), An investigation of change in the
infant caretaker system over the first week of life. Paper presented at Biennial Meeting of
Society for Research in Child Development (April).
SCHAEFFER, H., & EMERSON, P. (1964), The Development ofSocialAttachments in Infancy. Society
for Research in Child Development Monographs, vo!' 29, no. 94. Chicago: Chicago Uni-
versity Press.
TANGRI, S. (1969), "Role innovation in occupation choice." Ph.D. dissertation, University of
Michigan, Ann Arbor.
WARSHAW, R. (1976), "The effects of working mothers on children." Ph.D. dissertation,
Adelphi University.
WEISMAN, M., & PAYKEL, E. (1974), The Depressed Woman. Chicago: University of Chicago
Press.
WHITING, B., & EDWARDS, C. (1975), A cross cultural analysis of sex differences in the behav-
ior of children age 3-11. In: Annual Progress in Child Psychiatry and Child Development, ed. S.
Chess & P. Thomas. New York: Brunner/Maze!.
WOOLSEY, S. (1977), Pied Piper politics and the child care debate. Daedalus, 106:127-146
(Spring).
YARROW, L. (1964), Separation from parents during early childhood. In: Review of Child De-
velopment Research, ed. M. Hoffman & L. Hoffman. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
YOUNG, S. (1975), "Paternal involvement as related to maternal employment and attachment
behavior directed to the father by the one-year-old infant." Ph.D. dissertation, Ohio State
University.