Professional Documents
Culture Documents
January 2024
THE NIGERIAN ECONOMY.
All economies in the world are concern with maximization of opportunities in
their settings. The Nigerian economy is concerned with optimal resource
mobilization and allocation for the production of goods and services with a
view to generate wealth for the well-being of her people to make Nigeria
one of the largest economies.
The Nigerian economy has undergone changes over the years largely
dictated by the needs of its chequered history. The changes were driven by
law and various policy considerations. In the 1960s, the emphasis was on
Nationalisation to complement the political autonomy following the grant of
independence in 1960 and republican status in 1963. See Chapter X,
Companies Act, 1968.
PRIMARY/SECONDARY MARKET.
Broadly, the capital market is classified into commodities market and
securities market. The commodities market is the market for tangible
products. This market is further subdivided into two. The market for soft
agricultural products falls into the classes of grains, oil and meals, livestock,
forest products, textile and foodstuffs. The markets for hard products are
the market for metallurgical products and soil endowments in the form of
metals and petroleum.
The securities markets are markets for intangible commodities that are
choses in action. Functionally, the securities market may be a primary market
or the secondary market. The primary market is first section or the original
point of call in the capital market for companies seeking to raise funds. This
market finds buyers for new shares, at the same price, funds raised go the
issuer of the securities and the market is hardly identifiable with any
particular location. Any transaction on shares purchased in this market
facilitates a secondary market transaction. The primary market essentially is
an economic framework embodying a network of financial institutions at
work to transmit economic resources from savers to users. The issuing house
is the main capital market intermediary for this market. When First Bank of
Nigeria PLC issues shares to raise funds it is said to have access the primary
market.
The secondary market is the second or latter section of the securities market.
It is a consequential market where securities as evidenced by share
certificate are sold and purchased. In this market, holders of instruments
from the primary market sell their securities to other holders or to completely
new investors. Here investors sell their holdings at different times and prices
depending on the market, proceeds of the sale go to holder and not the
company, securities sold are not new, and the market is largely identifiable
with a particular location. The Stock Exchange is an example of the
secondary market in Nigeria. For companies that are not quoted their shares
are marketed in the Over the Counter (OTC) Market. The stockbroker is the
main capital market intermediary in the secondary market.
USERS OF THE MARKET
Duly incorporated companies or statutory corporations can access funds in
the capital market. Companies that have attained corporate status via
incorporation process enjoy the effect and powers under CAMA. At the stage
of formation, the authorized share capital of the company is to be divided
into shares of fixed amount to be held by the share holders. See Section 36
CAMA. Also by virtue of section 191 CAMA, companies can borrow for the
purpose of its business. This the company can do through the issuance of
debentures.
Sovereign authorities listed in Part 1 of the 1999 Constitution are persons
known to law and can access fund in the capital market for development.
The bodies contemplated are the Federal Government of Nigeria, the 36
States and 768 local Government Areas listed therein. These bodies can raise
funds in the market through the issuance of sovereign bonds. Part XV
ISA,2007 provides the regulatory framework for raising of funds by municipal
bodies through borrowing from the capital market.
CAPITAL MARKET
Capital has become the lifeline and creditworthiness of a company .It
now fixes the minimum value of the assets which must be raised initially,
and then, so far as possible, retained in the business. The capital of the
company is the creditors’ guarantee fund. Consequently, company law by its
capital maintenance doctrine progressively seeks to protect corporate
investors by ensuring that a company’s capital is raised and only employed
to generate wealth for the company which may trickle to the corporate
stakeholders.
`Market` in the most literal and immediate sense is a place where
things are bought and sold. In modern commerce, it has expanded to include
the whole geographical area in which sellers compete with each other for
customers. The advantages of choice and mobility have increasingly
positioned a market as a framework within which buyers and sellers transact
business.
According to Black’s Law Dictionary 1 , capital market is defined as
“financial markets in which long term securities are bought and sold”. This
definition throws up the pertinent question as to what period or time
constitutes long term. In what appears to be an improvement over this
definition, the Capital Market Glossary2 defines capital market as “financial
markets which trades in medium to long term financial instruments (stocks
and bonds) with maturity in excess of one year”.
Capital market exists solely for trading in securities. Market for the
purpose of securities trading is a peculiarity of the capital market. Broadly,
the capital market may be a securities market or commodities market.
SECURITIES MARKET
Securities by their legal nature are chooses in action which though do
not confer possession of physical things describe a mass of interest or rights
vested on their holders. Functionally, the securities market may be a primary
market or secondary market.
1
Black, H.C., Black`s Law Dictionary (West Group,1990, 6th edn. Centennial edn.(1891-1991) ) P.209.
2
Securities and Exchange Commission; Capital Market Glossary( Capital Market Education Series,SEC) P.10
creation and marketing of completely new securities by the issuer; a
particular security is offered at the same price and time to the public; except
on rare occasions where there are more than one call, the offer is made
once; the proceeds of the offer go to the issuer; this market is not identifiable
with any particular location; and efforts to dispose of purchases in this
market facilitates activities in the secondary market.
The primary market essentially is an economic framework embodying
a network of financial institutions at work to transmit economic resources
from savers to users. Of the key financial institutions in the capital market,
the issuing house is the hub of the primary market. A consideration of the
activities of the issuing house is inevitable at this point.
Issuing Houses
Issuing Houses are firms of professionals and specialists registered
by the Securities and Exchange Commission as capital market operators.
The business of issuing house is mostly dominated by investment banks
involved in capital restructuring of companies for good financial leverage.
They assist corporate and government bodies to access long term
funds by packaging issues for subscription on their behalf. It is the
responsibility of these operators to inform prospective issuers on the most
appropriate instruments and the best method to raise funds depending on
the verified needs of their clients.
The issuing house assembles and coordinates the functions of all other
operators whose services are usually required in the issuing process. These
operators are usually referred to as “parties to issue”. In coordinating the
parties to the issue, the issuing houses ensure that statutory requirements
are met.
THE PROSPECTUS.
Companies can only make offers of their securities to raise funds in the
primary market and no other place. The prospectus is a constant feature of
the primary market and is the main instrument of regulation of public issue.
It must accompany any invitation to the public to subscribe or purchase
securities of any company. According to Section 67 ISA, 2007 it shall not be
lawful to issue any form of application for securities in a public company
unless the form is issued with a prospectus. The prospectus shall state the
matters specified in Part I of the Third schedule and set out the report
specified in Part II, Third schedule to the Act.
THE SECONDARY MARKET
This is the second or latter section of the securities market. It is a
consequential market where securities as evidence by share certificates are
exchanged for funds. In this market, holders of the instruments from the
primary market sell their securities to other holders or to completely new
investors in the secondary market. It is regarded as secondary market
because it cannot exist without the primary market. Here, different investors
sell their holdings of the same or different securities art different times and
possibly at different prices; the proceeds of sale go to the holder of the
instrument and not the company; the instruments traded in this market are
not new; and the market is largely identifiable with a particular site popularly
called trading floor of the stock exchange. There are two broad classifications
of the secondary market; the centralized auction market and the dealers
market.
The stock exchange is a centralized auction market with regulations
and procedures for the buying and selling of securities. It is called a Stock
Exchange not because an investor can exchange one security for another,
but because investors can exchange securities for cash or vice-versa.
The Stock Exchange regulates its own market as well as its members.
For the purpose of accessing the market, the Stock Exchange has listing
requirement which a company seeking quotation must meet. Once the stock
exchange is satisfied that all its requirements have been met, it grants listing
to the security and the stage is then set for secondary transaction on the
securities.
A stock exchange may have a single board or classes of markets. The
Nigerian Stock Exchange (NSE) now demutualised is known and called
Nigerian Exchange (NGX)
The dealers market is not centralized. Unlisted securities account for
the overwhelming majority of securities traded in the dealers market. These
are securities that are variously traded largely, at the counters/screens of
issuing houses or by brokers appointed by the issuer3.
The dealers market developed over the period from simple telephone
communication to sophisticated linkages through complex electronic
communication machines linking up investors and finance houses. In
developed markets, an association of securities dealers may obtain
incorporation to operate and regulate an over the counter (OTC) market and
any other sub markets in the dealers market. The National Association of
Securities Dealers Automated Quotation (NASDAQ) was established by the
National Association of Securities Dealers (NASD) in the United Stated of
America. It is the largest self-regulatory organization in the United States
securities market. This is a dealers’ market where transactions are carried
out through routing of orders using computers supported by telephones for
negotiations. Only equities of companies are listed on NASDAQ. In Nigeria,
the NASD and FMDQ are OTC markets and regulated by the SEC.
OTC market has no central meeting point, transactions are done
through telephones and computer screens. The gateway into the secondary
market is the stock broker. This is the main intermediary in the secondary
market.
STOCKBROKER
Stockbrokers are capital market operators licensed by Stock Exchanges
and registered by the apex regulatory agency of the capital market. They
buy and sell securities quoted on the Exchange on behalf of their client as
agents and at times on their own account as dealers. They are the major
players in the secondary market and offer for the secondary market what
the issuing houses facilitate for the primary market. As a secondary market
intermediary, stockbrokers transact business on the floor of the Stock
Exchange or in the OTC market.
Generally, a broker is an intermediary between two or more parties. In
commercial relations he is an agent of a principal and receives commission
for his services. Rowlatt, J., in Christopher Baker & Sons v
3
Ekiran, O., Basic Understanding of Capital Market Operations.(Deacon Oba Ekiran,Lagos,1999) P.34
Commissioner of Inland Revenue 4; captured his role in the following
words
“…what a stockbroker does is to buy and sell a
commodity on the market. It is true that he does not
expect to have to pay for it himself or to be responsible
ultimately to satisfy the contract himself, as he is a
buyer and seller for an undisclosed principal”
The stockbroker is the prime mover of the secondary market. He is on
the floor of the exchange or by the screen in the screen based market. He
is a member of the exchange or other recognized markets. On the whole,
the stockbroker is expected to display a high degree of professionalism and
probity in his operation so as to retain the confidence of the investors in the
capital market and indeed in the financial industry as a whole. The stock
broker’s motto is “my word is my bond”
The relationship between a broker and a client is deeply rooted in trust
and confidence. It is a fiduciary relationship of uberrimae fidei firmly
entrenched in Law and Equity. Flowing from this relationship, the stock
broker owes certain duties at law to his client.
The stockbroker is obliged to perform or execute the client’s mandate
as expressly or impliedly stipulated by the client. He is also bound to obey
all lawful instructions from the client.
No person shall practice the profession of stock brokerage unless
registered by the apex regulatory body and licensed by the Stock Exchange
where he shall ply his trade. He can only practice his trade under a
stockbrokerage firm.
To qualify to practice as a chartered stockbroker, an applicant must
satisfy requirements of the Chartered Institute of Stockbrokers (CIS) set up
by the Chartered Institute of Stockbrokers Act5. This Institute has the general
duty of determining from time to time what standards of knowledge and skill
are to be attained by persons seeking to become chartered members of the
profession. The CIS is a corporate body with perpetual succession and
4
(1893)AC 282 HL
5
Chapter 105, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria, 2004.
common seal. Administration and general management of the institute is
vested on the Governing Council6.
INSTRUMENTS
6
Ibid, Section 3.
Instruments in the capital market are also referred to as securities. They
represent the interest of investors in the issuer and determine the nature of
the legal relationship between the holder and the issuer of the securities.
These securities also measure the quantum of investors’ interest in the
issuer.
Traditionally, securities are classified into ownership and debt securities. By
their legal nature, while the ownership securities confer proprietary rights on
the holders, debt securities create debtor/creditor relationship between the
issuer and the holder of the debt securities.
OWNERSHIP SECURITY
Ownership security constitutes its holder a member of the enterprise. In
casual parlance a holder of an ownership security is considered part-owner
of the venture. In law such a holder has rights in the concern. A classic
example of ownership security is a ‘share’ in the authorized share capital of
a company.
Legally, a share is regarded as a chose in action. A perspective on the
definition of `share` was given thus by Lord Wrenbury in BRADBURY v
ENGLISH SEWING COTTON CO.LTD (1923) AC 744:
A share is …a fractional part of the capital. It confers upon
the holder certain right to a proportionate part of the assets
of the corporation whether by way of dividend or distribution
of assets in winding up. It forms, however, a separate right
of property .The capital is the property of the corporation.
The share, although it is a fraction of the capital is the
property of the corporator. The aggregate of all the fractions
if collected in two or three hands does not constitute the
corporators the owners of the capital-that remains the
property of the corporation. But nevertheless the share is a
property in a fractional part of the capital…
Much earlier, Farewell J in BORLAND TRUSTEE v. STEEL BROS & CO
LTD(1901) 1 Ch..279 gave a conceptual framework of the word as follows:
A share is the interest of a shareholder in the company
measured by a sum of money, for the purpose of liability
in the first place, and of interest in the second. But also
consisting of a series of mutual covenants entered into
by all the shareholders inter se…The contract contained
in the Articles of Association is one of the original
incidents of the share. A share is not a sum of
money…but is an interest measured by a sum of money
and made up of various rights contained in the contract
including the right to sum of money of a more or less
account.
Today shares are recognized dejure and defacto as property in the nature of
personal estate7 which can be bought, sold, mortgaged and bequeathed.
Specifically Section 27(2) (a) CAMA provides
The memorandum shall also state the amount of the
minimum issued share capital which shall not be less than
N100,000 in the case of private company and N2,000,000
in the case of a public company with which the company
proposes to be registered, and the division thereof into
shares of a fixed amount.(underlining for emphasis.)
Under section 37, the statement of the initial issued share capital and
shareholding shall indicate the number and nominal value of each share held
by the member. The fixed amount of a share is its nominal value or par
value. Such shares are known as par value shares. On the other hand, shares
are described as no par value if the price at which a share is issued is not
permanently fixed at any nominal value but is in fact determined by market
consideration.
DEBT SECURITY
Debt securities create a legal relationship of debtor and creditor. A debt
security holder is in law not a member of the issuer having rights in it but a
creditor having rights against it. The debt securities markets have become
veritable channels of funding developments by municipal bodies’ globally.
A debt security may take the form of bond or debenture. A bond simply put
is a promise to pay whereby the lender holds the bond until his money is
completely paid with the agreed interest. Structurally, the investor lends the
issuer specified amount of money (principal) for a specified period. In
exchange, the investor receives fixed payment of interest (coupon) on a
regular schedule for the life of the bonds with the full principal returned at
an agreed date in future (maturity date).
Bonds have features that make them attractive to investors. Bonds provide
steady income at regular intervals, which comes in form of interest. A
corporate bond, usually offers higher yields than government bonds. The
higher yield potentials of corporate bonds is generally accompanied by
higher risks. Bonds provide dependable income. Investors, who want steady
income from their investments, while preserving their principal, include
bonds in their portfolios.
Safety and reliability are attractive qualities of bonds. Government bonds are
long dated and relatively risk free instruments. Corporate bonds are
evaluated and assigned rating based on credit history and the ability of the
issuer to repay obligations; the higher the rating, the safer the investment.
Debenture is specie of debt security. The expression `debenture` is applied
indiscriminately to the instrument creating or evidencing indebtedness and
to the debt and the bundle of rights vested in the holder to secure its
discharge. These rights may include a charge on all or some of the company’s
assets. In the absence of any charge, it may be described as a bond or loan
note.
The legal relationship between a company and its debenture holders is
simply the contractual relationship of debtor and creditor. In contrast with
shareholder, the debenture holder is in law not a member of the company
having rights in it, but creditor having rights against it.
According to Chitty J. in LEVY v ABERCORIS SLATE & SLAB CO (1887)
37 Ch. P.260,264 “ [it is] a document which either create debt or
acknowledges it”. The ISA does not define the word ‘debenture’ but admits
in section 315 that debenture is a security. According to Section 868 CAMA;
“debentures” means a written acknowledgment of indebtedness
by the company, setting out the terms and conditions of the
indebtedness and includes debenture stock, bonds and any other
securities of a company whether constituting a charge on the
assets of the company, or not.
Specifically Section 191 CAMA provides:
A company may borrow money for the purpose of its business or
objects and may mortgage or charge its undertaking, property
and uncalled capital or any part thereof and issue debentures,
debenture stock and other securities whether outright or as
security for any debt, liability or obligation of the company or of
any third party.
DERIVATIVE SECURITY
This class of securities is emerging in the capital market. They derive their
being from the two traditional securities and have sometimes been called
shadow instruments. Examples of this include futures, options, rights offer.
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEME
LEGAL FRAMEWORK FOR REGULATING THE NIGERIAN CAPITAL
MARKET
INVESTMENT AND SECURITIES ACT, NO.29, 2007
Five years of the implementation of the Investment and Securities Act 1999,
the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) observed areas in the ISA
requiring review. The review was considered necessary to strengthen its
provisions, remove ambiguities, and enhance the Federal Government
economic reform initiatives as well as the international competitiveness of
the Nigerian Capital market.
Generally, the ISA, 2007 regulates all the basic features of a capital market.
Specifically, the tripod of every capital market; operators, markets and
instruments are clearly regulated.
All securities to be offered to the public through the medium of offer for
subscription, offer for sale, rights offer, bonus issue, offer by introduction,
private placement by public companies must first be registered with the SEC.
Debenture/loan stock, State and Local Government bond must also be
registered with the SEC before issuance for public participation.
A person who contravenes these requirements commits an offence and liable
on conviction to a fine of one million naira or to a term of imprisonment of
three years or to both such fines and imprisonment. The Commission may,
in lieu of prosecution impose a penalty of one million naira and a further fine
of five thousand naira for everyday of the violation.
If as a result of any such contravention any person acquires or disposes of
any securities he shall be entitled to proceed against the defaulter. He may
rescind such transaction and or recover compensation for any loss sustained
by him from any person who is liable.
The SEC is empowered to halt the circulation of any unregistered securities
offered to the public. This is to prevent issuers unduly leveraging on the
knowledge disparity in the market to induce unsuspecting investors to invest
their resources in worthless securities.
No Securities Exchange or Capital Trade Point shall commence operation
unless it is registered with the SEC. The Securities Exchange may be a Stock
Exchange, Commodity Exchange, Over the Counter Market, Metal Exchange,
Petroleum Exchange, Option, Futures and Derivative Exchange or Capital
Trade Point. These are user regulatory organizations providing market
facilities for stakeholders.
What constitutes a forum a Securities Exchange is registration with the SEC.
Section 30 ISA, 2007 empowers the SEC to revoke the certificate of
registration of a Securities Exchange when the need arises. This will
necessarily arise if the body ceases to operate as Securities Exchange or
Capital Trade Point; or is undergoing process of winding up or operating in
a manner detrimental to public interest.
The SEC is at liberty in the public interest to issue directives with respect to
trading on or pertaining to any listed security or with respect to the manner
in which the Securities Exchange carries on business or any other matter
necessary for the effective administration of the law. The Securities
Exchange shall comply with any such directives. Failure to comply with such
directives attracts a penalty of one million naira and to a further penalty of
fifty thousand naira for every day of default. Where an executive officer of a
Securities Exchange willfully contravenes or without reasonable justification
failed to enforce compliance with directives issued by the SEC, the
Commission may remove such officer or direct the Exchange in writing to
remove such officer. No action before any Court of law with regard to any
such directive by the SEC shall be competent unless the SEC is joined as a
party to such action.
Furthermore, Section 36 ISA, 2007 authorizes the SEC to prohibit trading on
the securities of a company where it thinks it is necessary for the protection
of the public.
The operators of the market are also subject to a regime of strict regulation.
Securities dealer, stockbrokers, share transfer agents, bankers to issue,
market trustee(s) of a trust deed, registrars to an issue, merchant bankers,
issuing houses, underwriters, portfolio managers, investment advisers are
intermediaries in the securities industry. These are the experts in the capital
market that facilitate the search, mobilization and allocation of resources
between the surplus and deficit ends in the economy.
According to Section 38(1) ISA, 2007, no person shall operate in the Nigerian
Capital Market as an expert or professional or in any other capacity as may
be determined by the Commission; or carry on investment and securities
business unless the person is registered in accordance with the Act.
Specifically, the SEC shall register and regulate corporate and individual
capital market operator as defined by the Act.
The reason for supervising the activities of these persons is not far-fetched.
In reaching investment decisions, investors usually rely on information about
an issuer and or issue supplied by its management. The information provided
are verified by professionals such as auditors, reporting accountants,
registrars, issuing houses, stock brokers, trustees, solicitors to the issuer and
to the issue. It is necessary that those saddled with verification, dutifully
and responsibly ensure that the information supplied to the investing public
is true and accurate, free from any material misstatement, concealment of
facts or deliberate misrepresentation of facts about the issuer.
8. Ibid, Section 1
The privilege of limited liability is the most pervasive incident of
incorporation. This has made the corporate form of enterprise the
functionally dominant mode of carrying on business in Nigeria, and indeed
the capitalist commercial system. It is this limitation of liability that has
encouraged the phenomenal growth of the modern company in its
unfettered spirit of adventure.
The economic advantage of limitation of liability is that it defines the
extent of investment risk and loss. It thereby provides the means of
escape from risk of loss or even ruin to big and small traders which they
would otherwise be exposed to. This insulation from the burden of
indeterminate liability has made corporate enterprise a necessary
instrument of commercial progress.
9
Ibid, Section 243
provides the list of superior Courts of record in Nigeria. Although Section
6(4)(a) of the Constitution empowers the National Assembly or State Houses
of Assembly to establish other Courts, such Courts however shall be of
subordinate jurisdiction to the High Court. It is canvassed that the said
Section 6(5), as it stand, has closed the gate to the creation of any superior
court of record in Nigeria. To the extent that the ISA seeks to establish the
IST as a Court of coordinate jurisdiction with the Federal High Court, and
thus a superior Court of record, it is inconsistent with the Constitution. To
the extent of this inconsistency, the Sections concerned stand null and void.
On the other hand, a careful digest of Section 6(5)(J) of the same
Constitution shows that the judicial powers of the Federation shall also vest
on such other Courts as may be authorized by law to exercise jurisdiction on
matters to which the National Assembly may make laws. The ISA which
came into effect on the 26/05/1999, before the enactment of the 1999
Constitution on the 29/05/1999 is an existing law deemed passed by the
National Assembly. Fully aware of its provisions before the promulgation of
the 1999 Constitution, ISA is deemed to convey the legislature’s intention
otherwise steps would have been taken to abrogate or amend the ISA in the
Constitution which came subsequently. Afortiori, Section 240 of the
Constitution contemplates appeals from the Tribunal being heard by the
Court of Appeal.
The establishment and jurisdiction of the Investments and Securities
Tribunal have been the subject of intense debate and conflicting judgment
of the courts in Nigeria.
See Augustine Robert Agom (2022) “Case Law and Commentaries on
Nigerian Capital Market” Chapter 5
Augustine Robert Agom 30/09/2023 “Capital Market Adjudication: Judging
Judicially and Judiciously”
Benefits of quotation
Quotation is the formal listing of a company on a Stock Exchange. This
enables the securities of the company to be traded on the floor of the
Exchange. The benefits of listing are immense.
1. Quotation increases marketability of securities.
2. A company quoted on the Stock Exchange enjoys greater confidence
from investors and creditors.
3. Quotation gives opportunity to existing shareholders to share part of
their investment risks (and yet retain control of the company if so
desired). Effectively, this broadens ownership base of assets and
creates a buoyant private sector.
4. Quotation provides acquisition opportunities.
5. Quotation attracts quality personnel.
6. In Nigeria for companies seeking quotation on the emerging market,
the cost of quotation is tax deductible.
7. Quoted companies enjoy free advertisement.
8. The Stock Exchange has become a market for corporate control.
1. In relation to investment, give four (4) concrete reasons why any one
of the three under mentioned literatures is truly a classic.