Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OBSTETRICS OBSTETRIQUE
caused by polymicrobial organisms ascending from the Between December 2019 and November 2020, one MFM
maternal genital tract.1 Chorioamnionitis affects approxi- investigator at each site was invited to complete a 15-ques-
mately 10% of all women in labour, with a markedly higher tion online survey that was designed by MFM specialists
incidence when delivery is before term.2 using ACOG and CPS guideline information.1,3,7,8
Answers were dichotomous or Likert scalable in nature.
Chorioamnionitis is associated with increased maternal and The questionnaire addressed (1) the practices used to man-
neonatal morbidity and mortality, and its diagnosis is criti- age fever in labour and to diagnose chorioamnionitis
cal to prevent early-onset sepsis in newborns.3 However, (7 questions) and (2) the antibiotic therapy prescribed
chorioamnionitis is a tentative diagnosis that is usually con- for clinical chorioamnionitis (6 questions; see
firmed after delivery based on placental pathology or online Appendix). The remaining questions were
administrative. “Reference” antibiotics were those recom- The research ethics board of the CHU Sainte-Justine
mended by ACOG: ampicillin and gentamicin for patients approved the survey and its distribution.
not allergic to penicillin, cefazolin and gentamicin for
patients mildly allergic to penicillin, and clindamycin or RESULTS
vancomycin in combination with gentamicin for patients
with severe penicillin allergy.10 If gentamicin was unavail- Twenty-four of the 29 sites (82.8%) completed and
able, it was replaced with tobramycin. returned the questionnaire. Four participating sites were in
the Atlantic provinces, 13 were in Central Canada, 4 were
The online survey was hosted by the Maternal-Infant Care in the Prairie provinces, and 3 were on the West Coast.
Research Center (Ontario; http://www.micare.ca). Each Overall, 2 sites reported using diagnostic criteria for cho-
site investigator received by email an internet link to access rioamnionitis from a clinical protocol, 2 reported using
the informed consent form and the survey questionnaire. preprinted orders for antibiotherapy for clinical chorioam-
Respondents could review and change their answers before nionitis, and one site reported using both.
submitting them.
Diagnostic Criteria
Descriptive statistics used to summarize the survey find- The use of different diagnostic criteria for clinical cho-
ings were calculated using a Microsoft Excel spread- rioamnionitis was frequent or very frequent at 9 sites
sheet. Categorical variables were presented as (40.9%) and occasional or rare at 10 sites (45.4%). Three
proportions, including the percentage of sites using diag- sites (13.6%) were uncertain about local practices, and data
nostic criteria and antibiotics as per current ACOG/ were missing for 2 sites. The most commonly used defini-
CPS guidelines compared to other cirteria and antibiotics tion of fever in labour was a single oral temperature of
(Table 1). ≥38.0°C (9 sites), which is consistent with the CPS
Table 2. Clinical criteria used for diagnosis of clinical chorioamnionitis among 23 sites of the Preterm Birth Network
No. (%) of sites
Signs or symptoms Yes, always Yes, treating physician dependant No
Uterine tenderness 3 (13.0) 17 (73.9) 3 (13.0)
Maternal tachycardia 9 (39.1) 14 (60.9) 0 (0)
Fetal tachycardia 13 (56.5) 8 (34.8) 2 (8.7)
Foul/purulent amniotic fluid 13 (56.5) 9 (39.1) 1 (4.3)
Maternal leukocytosis 3 (13.0) 13 (56.5) 7 (30.4)
guidelines. Seven sites (30.4%) reported using more than For patients not allergic to penicillin, ampicillin was by far
one definition, one site reported using ACOG criteria, 4 the most frequently prescribed treatment (15 of 23 sites;
sites (17.2 %) had no standard criteria, and the 3 sites that 65.2%), followed by metronidazole (10 of 23 sites; 43.5%)
used diagnostic criteria from clinical protocols had differ- and gentamicin (7 of 23; 30.4%) (Figure A;
ent definitions. online Appendix). Overall, 52.1% of sites indicated “always”
or “mostly” using antibiotic therapy corresponding to first-
At 14 sites (58.3%), isolated fever was most often an indi- line ACOG treatments, namely ampicillin/aminoglycoside,
cation to initiate empiric antibiotic therapy. Maternal tachy- with 4 sites adding either clindamycin or metronidazole to
cardia, foul or purulent amniotic fluid, fetal tachycardia, this combination. The second most common antibiotic ther-
and maternal leukocytosis were the other diagnostic criteria apy was cefazolin and metronidazole (17.4%).
used (Table 2). Duration of membrane rupture was a crite-
rion at 2 sites. Twelve sites did not report how many clini- Antibiotic therapies for patients who are allergic to penicillin
cal criteria in addition to maternal fever were used to are shown in Figure B and the online Appendix. Clindamycin
diagnose chorioamnionitis. Three sites (12.5 %) indicated was the most prescribed antibiotic (14 sites) always in combi-
using one other clinical criterion, 4 (16.7 %) indicated using nation with another antibiotic, preferentially an aminoglyco-
2 other clinical criteria, and 5 (20.8 %) did not have stan- side. A combination of metronidazole and gentamicin was
dard practices. The majority (91.3%) of sites reported also frequently used for patients with severe penicillin allergy,
using the same diagnostic criteria for preterm pregnancies and the recommended alternative, vancomycin/aminoglyco-
as for term pregnancies, always or most of the time. Pla- side, was used at one site only. The combination of cefazolin
cental histology was the most common method used to and gentamicin was used at 4 sites as per ACOG recommen-
confirm chorioamnionitis (15 of 22 sites), followed by dations for patients with mild penicillin allergy.
complete blood cell count (14 of 22 sites) and blood cul-
ture (12 of 22 sites) (Table 3). The most frequently used time points of antibiotic cessa-
tion were 24 hours after return to apyrexia (12 sites),
24 hours after initiation of antibiotics (4 sites), immediately
Antibiotic Therapy after delivery (3 sites), and after one postpartum dose
Twenty-three of 24 sites provided information regarding (1 site). One site reported discontinuing antibiotics
choices of empirical antibiotic therapy for chorioamnioni- 24 hours after return to apyrexia, but only if blood cultures
tis. Only 3 sites reported using “always the same” antibiotic were negative, and 3 sites reported no consensus on when
therapy, 2 of which used preprinted orders. Fifteen sites to terminate antibiotic treatment.
reported that antibiotic therapy differed from patient to
patient “occasionally” or “rarely” for the same diagnosis, DISCUSSION
and 3 sites reported that antibiotic therapy differed “fre-
quently” or “very frequently,” even at one site with pre- Our study shows that considerable differences exist in
printed orders. practices for diagnosing and managing clinical
Figure. Antibiotics used for clinical chorioamnionitis in women without (A) and with (B) penicillin allergy.
chorioamnionitis in tertiary care centres in Canada. Similar in all maternity centres in Canada, and amniotic fluid testing
results have been reported for the United States by the is rarely performed. Regardless, findings from placental histol-
Collaborative Ambulatory Network.13 Given that effective ogy are available postpartum and are of little value when time-
diagnostic and treatment measures exist, these results sensitive clinical decisions need to be made at the bedside.
underscore the difficulties associated with implementing
guidelines once they have been published. We saw considerable differences across sites in the choice of
antibiotics, the duration of antibiotic treatment, and the crite-
The most common criterion for the diagnosis of cho- ria determining treatment cessation. The difficulties in estab-
rioamnionitis and initiation of empiric antibiotic therapy lishing antibiotic treatment guidelines for chorioamnionitis
during labour was a single oral temperature ≥38°C, a prac- from the available literature have been described elsewhere.17
tice that leads to unnecessary antibiotic treatment for Broad antimicrobial coverage has to be ensured owing to the
patients with fever of non-infectious origin (e.g., with use polymicrobial nature of this disease, and alternative recom-
of epidural analgesia)4−6 and to overestimates of the preva- mended regimens based on local antibiotic resistance patterns
lence of actual chorioamnionitis. are suggested in the ACOG guidelines.10 In our survey, and
consistent with ACOG guidelines, ampicillin/aminoglycoside
With NICHD/AGOG criteria, the sensitivity and specific- was the most frequently used broad-spectrum antibiotic com-
ity of diagnosis of clinical chorioamnionitis for confirmed bination. This was followed by cefazolin/metronidazole,
chorioamnionitis has been reported to be 71.4% and which ensures similar coverage and may be a reasonable alter-
40.5%, respectively.14 This could also lead to unnecessary native.11 Some sites that participated in this survey are now
antibiotic treatment in some patients and no treatment in studying patterns of antimicrobial resistance in their commu-
patients who warrant it.14 This is particularly concerning nities to inform their choice of antibiotic combinations.
for preterm deliveries, 40% to 70% of which may be asso-
ciated with histologically confirmed chorioamnionitis and The duration of antibiotic therapy remains a subject of
higher baseline rates of adverse neonatal outcomes.15,16 debate. Based on 2 randomized controlled trials,18,19 ACOG
This suggests that less stringent criteria for the diagnosis recommends discontinuing antibiotics immediately after
of chorioamnionitis should be used in preterm deliveries. delivery for vaginal births, provided no other maternal risk
However, we found that 91.3% of sites use the same diag- factors such as bacteremia or persistent fever are present,7
nostic criteria for term and preterm deliveries, perhaps yet this was practiced at only 3 sites. Two other randomized
necessarily so given that none are specific for the latter. controlled trials showed no difference in the rate of endome-
tritis and postpartum fever between women who received a
ACOG recommends that confirmatory diagnoses be based single antibiotic dose after delivery and those who continued
on a positive amniotic fluid test or placental pathology with antibiotics until afebrile for 24 hours.20,21 In our study most
histologic evidence of infection or inflammation.10 However, sites reported continuing antibiotics for 24 hours after apyr-
placental histologic examination is costly and not carried out exia. We believe that either a single-dose antibiotic or no
antibiotics should be the standard of care for postpartum 5. Riley LE, Celi AC, Onderdonk AB, et al. Association of epidural-related
treatment of women with clinical chorioamnionitis. fever and noninfectious inflammation in term labor. Obstet Gynecol
2011;117:588–95.
Our study should be considered in the context of certain 6. Romero R, Chaemsaithong P, Korzeniewski SJ, et al. Clinical
limitations. First, it involved only tertiary care centres, and chorioamnionitis at term III: how well do clinical criteria perform in the
identification of proven intra-amniotic infection? J Perinat Med
results cannot be generalized to all obstetric centres. Sec- 2016;44:23–32.
ond, we surveyed only one obstetrics/MFM specialist at
7. Gibbs RS. Diagnosis of intra-amniotic infection. Semin Perinatol
each site, and accuracy in reporting could have been 1977;1:71–7.
improved with more respondents. Finally, although we had
8. Gibbs RS, Castillo MS, Rodgers PJ. Management of acute chorioamnionitis.
a high participation rate (82.8%), it is possible that we had Am J Obstet Gynecol 1980;136:709–13.
a small nonresponse bias.
9. Gibbs RS, Dinsmoor MJ, Newton ER, et al. A randomized trial of
intrapartum versus immediate postpartum treatment of women with intra-
amniotic infection. Obstet Gynecol 1988;72:823–8.
CONCLUSION
10. Committee opinion no. 712: intrapartum management of intraamniotic
This study demonstrates that there is considerable variabil- infection. Obstet Gynecol 2017;130:e95–101.
ity in diagnostic and treatment practices for chorioamnioni- 11. Conde-Agudelo A, Romero R, Jung EJ, et al. Management of clinical
tis in Canada and emphasizes the importance of educating chorioamnionitis: an evidence-based approach. Am J Obstet Gynecol
practitioners about this condition. Implementation of clini- 2020;223(6):848–69. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajog.2020.09.044.
cal protocols and standing orders for treating chorioam- 12. Shah PS, McDonald SD, Barrett J, et al. The Canadian preterm birth
nionitis, based on current evidence and local antimicrobial network: a study protocol for improving outcomes for preterm infants and
their families. CMAJ Open 2018;6:e44–9.
data, should be prioritized to improve practices and health
outcomes in pregnant women and neonates. 13. Greenberg MB, Anderson BL, Schulkin J, et al. A first look at
chorioamnionitis management practice variation among us obstetricians.
Infect Dis Obstet Gynecol 2012;2012:628362.
Acknowledgements 14. Ona S, Easter SR, Prabhu M, et al. Diagnostic validity of the proposed
Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human
The authors thank all MFM site investigators for their Development criteria for intrauterine inflammation or infection. Obstet
participation and are grateful to Dr. Christian Band for Gynecol 2019;133:33–9.
his careful review of the manuscript. 15. Yoon BH, Romero R, Moon JB, et al. Clinical significance of intra-amniotic
inflammation in patients with preterm labor and intact membranes. Am J
Obstet Gynecol 2001;185:1130–6.
SUPPLEMENTARY DATA
16. Venkatesh KK, Jackson W, Hughes BL, et al. Association of
Supplementary data related to this article can be found chorioamnionitis and its duration with neonatal morbidity and mortality. J
Perinatol 2019;39:673–82.
at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jogc.2021.06.003.
17. Hopkins L, Smaill F. Antibiotic regimens for management of intraamniotic
infection. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2002;2002:CD003254.
18. Berry C, Hansen KA, McCaul JF. Abbreviated antibiotic therapy for
REFERENCES clinical chorioamnionitis: a randomized trial. J Matern Fetal Med
1994;3:216–8.
1. Higgins RD, Saade G, Polin RA, et al. Evaluation and management of
women and newborns with a maternal diagnosis of chorioamnionitis: 19. Adashek J, Asarat T, Rumney P, et al. The effect of antibiotics after a
summary of a workshop. Obstet Gynecol 2016;127:426–36. vaginal delivery complicated by chorioamniontis in preventing the
development of postpartum endomyometritis: a prospectively
2. Tita AT, Andrews WW. Diagnosis and management of clinical randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial. Am J Obstet
chorioamnionitis. Clin Perinatol 2010;37:339–54. Gynecol 1998;178.
3. Jefferies AL. Management of term infants at increased risk for early-onset 20. Edwards RK, Duff P. Single additional dose postpartum therapy for
bacterial sepsis. Paediatr Child Health 2017;22:223–8. women with chorioamnionitis. Obstet Gynecol 2003;102:957–61.
4. Leighton BL, Halpern SH. The effects of epidural analgesia on labor, 21. Goldberg A, Malik M. Post-partum management of chorioamnionitis:
maternal, and neonatal outcomes: a systematic review. Am J Obstet efficacy of continuation of antibiotics after delivery [13op]. Obstet Gynecol
Gynecol 2002;186:S69–77. 2017;129:5S.