Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Palmistry
Peter Dayan
I
s Michael Moore liberal America’s brief and (at least judging by the plausible, but misleading, claims under
Rush Limbaugh? If so, is he filling a sales) very glorious, and this story is the radar. Just to give one instance,
much needed, or a much lamented, most entertaining. Don’t miss the it compellingly compares a six year
gap in turning issues that are really cast wonderfully faux naive letter from old hopping from rock to rock in a
in pastel shades into Day-Glo relief? Hawkins to Gordon Moore asking, streambed with a lumbering robot
In this hale monograph, Jeff Hawkins in 1980, to set up a research group failing to do the same task. However,
(rendered by Sandra Blakeslee) within Intel devoted to the brain. That this is a bit unfair. One of Hawkins’
plays exactly this role for theoretical Hawkins prospered in clear opposition self-denying ordinances is to consider
neuroscience. As a pastel practitioner to accepted wisdom is perhaps one of the cortex pretty much by itself. As
myself, but furtively sharing many of the key subtexts of the book. aficionados of the cerebellum (an
Hawkins’ prejudices and hunches The second, and rather less evolutionarily ancient brain region
about computational modelling in satisfying, book is about the philosophy with a special role in the organisation
neuroscience, I am caught between of mind and the history of artificial of smooth, precise, well-timed, and
commendation and consternation. intelligence and neural network task-sensitive motor output) would be
Hawkins is an engineer, approaches to understanding the brain quick to point out, the singular role for
entrepreneur, and scientist who and replicating cognition. With respect the cortex in such graceful behaviour is
founded and led the companies to the fields of artificial intelligence rather questionable.
Palm and then Handspring. He and neural nets, the text seems rather
created, against what must have been to be fighting yesterday’s battles. The
Citation: Dayan P (2004) Palmistry. PLoS Biol 2(11):
considerable obstacles, the first widely importance of learning, flexibility in e394.
successful PDA, and continued the representation and inference, and
development of this platform. He even decentralisation of control has Copyright: © 2004 Peter Dayan. This is an open-access
article distributed under the terms of the Creative
has thus amply earned a bully pulpit. been more than amply recognised in Commons Attribution License, which permits unre-
The autobiographical segments of the inexorable rise of probabilistic stricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any
medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
this book detail that, throughout approaches in both fields.
his career, he has been interested in With respect to the philosophy of Peter Dayan is in the Gatsby Computational Neurosci-
understanding how the brain works, mind, there seems to be something of ence Unit at University College London, London,
United Kingdom. E-mail: dayan@gatsby.ucl.ac.uk
using his substantial knowledge and an enthusiast’s disdain for the niceties
intuition about the architecture and of philosophical pettifogging, even DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.0020394