Professional Documents
Culture Documents
settlement. It is obvious that if some amount of solid The long-term settlement behaviour will be characterised
material is decomposed in a fresh landfill, a considerable and a relationship between the remaining amount of set-
amount of settlement should occur. On the other hand, tlement and fill age will be discussed along with the effects
an older MSW landfill no longer has such organic of parameters governing the settlement behaviour.
matter for the decomposition to occur and the remaining
particles are relatively inert. Therefore, the fill age is an
important factor in evaluating the further potential long- Long-term settlement and decomposition
term settlement due to the decomposition in MSW Long-term settlement of MSW landfills
landfills. Immediate settlement due to an applied load may be com-
In MSW landfills, biodegradation is processed in four pleted in a relatively short period in a MSW landfill site.
stages in which solid organic particles are solubilised and However, a considerable amount of long-term settlement
converted to methane and carbon dioxide through occurs for several years and the long-term strain can be
methanogenesis. Once they are converted to a liquid form, expressed as follows (Sowers 1973; Gordon et al. 1986;
the intermediate decomposition products are drained out Sohn & Johnson 1991);
of the landfill or are converted to methane and carbon
dioxide through methanogenesis. Therefore, the decom- (t)long-term=(t)mec+(t)dec (1)
position step that is of concern for geotechnical engineers
is the conversion of refuse organic solids to liquid. Detailed where (t)mec stands for the mechanical secondary
studies of the degradation process indicate that polymer compression which occurs due to long-term slippages,
hydrolysis is responsible for this solubilisation (Barlaz et al. reorientation of particles and delayed compression of some
1990). During the initial stage of decomposition, there is a MSW constituents. On the other hand, dec represents
significant amount of readily degradable soluble substrate the compression that is induced by volume decrease of
present. Therefore, the rate of the overall process should biodegradable organic solids due to biological decomposi-
be governed by methanogenesis. tion activities.
However, once the readily degradable soluble substrates
are exhausted, the overall process is controlled by Effect of decomposition on long-term settlement
hydrolysis. Since the most abundant carbon sources in Wardwell & Nelson (1981) presented the results obtained
municipal waste are insoluble (cellulose and hemicellu- from a series of experiments designed to investigate the
lose), the majority of the decomposition process is limited effects of organic decomposition on the compressive
by hydrolysis (Halvadakis et al. 1983). Common practice strain. They utilised two sets of cellulose fiber, kaolin clay,
by many researchers is to assume that cellulose hydrolysis and water mixtures. One of them was seeded with suffi-
occurs by first order kinetics (Chen 1974; McGowan et al. cient nutrients to give a more efficient decomposition
1988; El-Fadel et al. 1989; Young 1989). Obviously, if this condition. A representative graph of their results (Fig. 1
amount of solid material is converted into a liquid form (a)) shows that after immediate settlement was complete,
and hence can be readily drained out of a landfill, a con- the nutrient-deficient mixtures continued gradual settling
siderable amount of settlement should occur. that diminished with time but the settlement curve of
Park & Lee (1997) proposed a simple mathematical nutrient-efficient sample developed linearly after a time
model that considers the decomposition process (solubili- lapse. When it is expressed in a relationship of strain-log-
sation stage) in relation with the volume decrease. The arithmic time, the settlement curve of nutrient-deficient
decomposition causes larger voids to develop within the mixtures shows an approximately flat linear slope over the
landfill. Therefore, the balance between the voids and the whole range of time, while that of nutrient-efficient
self weights of the landfill materials may be upset due to sample shows a much greater slope after a time lapse. In
the decomposition. They presumed that the phenomenon order to establish relationship between settlement and
(settlement by degradation) can be explained by first- decomposition of municipal waste, Kang et al. (1997) per-
order kinetics. Here, the proposed mathematical model formed lysimeter tests using MSW. One was recycled with
was used to analyse settlement data of seven MSW leachate to give a more efficient decomposition condition
landfills which have various fill ages of from 0 to 25 years. and the other was not. In the logarithmic time and strain
curve (Fig. 1(b)), the two lysimeter test results are the data collected from 24 case histories (Fig. 2). They
same for until several days, but the leachate recycled illustrated that in an early stage of delayed (or long-
lysimeter sample settled at accelerated rates due to the term) compression, the settlement is dominated by
decomposition of organic materials. mechanical interactions such as long-term reorientation
Bjarngard & Edgers (1990) also stated that the field and delayed compression of municipal wastes, but in
long-term compression behaviour could be separated the later stage of compression the logarithmic compression
into two phases, based on an analysis of landfill settlement rates are higher because of the added effects of
decomposition.
Fig. 2. Landfill settlement versus log time relationships for 24 field case (t)mec=C,meclog[(t+t)/t] (2)
histories (Bjarngard & Edgers 1990)
Fig. 3. Typical log time-strain curves for refuse specimens with different Fig. 4. The effects of pressure, density and decomposition level on the
fill ages rate of mechanical secondary compression
The rates of mechanical secondary compression for the Compression due to biological decomposition
results are presented in Table 1. Park & Lee (1997) have proposed a mathematical model
Other tests have been also carried out to establish a that considers the compression process of refuse due to the
guideline for the values of C,mec (Fig. 4). It can be decomposition of organic solids. Biodegradable organic
observed that the rate of mechanical secondary compres- solids convert into intermediate decomposition products
sion is comparatively insensitive to the intensity of of a liquid form in the hydrolysis stage. The decomposition
pressure and density (Rao et al. 1977; Jessberger & Kockel process can be expressed in terms of first order kinetics as
1993; Gabr & Valero 1995). Besides, the C,mec value of follows:
fresh municipal waste is approximately three times greater
– –
than that of old wastes. Landva & Clark (1990) also dS / dt=k –S(t) dS / dt=–k S(t) (3)
observed that the value of C,mec increased with increase in
organic contents. Without taking account of the decom- where S is biodegradable waste solid mass at time t, and
–
position, compression curves of municipal waste specimens k is a first order degradation rate constant (t–1).
with different fill ages are depicted in Fig. 3. As the land- The main geotechnical concern is concentrated on the
fill ages, the amount of organic solids that would affect the solubilisation of biodegradable wastes. As biodegradable
mechanical secondary compression mechanism decreases. solid mass (S tot–dec ) decomposes, it converts into a liquid
Laboratory data (Large compression test) 0.005 8 years old Korea Geotech. Society (1994)
(approximately)
form (and eventually to gas) and thus it causes to reduce since their fill ages are only a few years. Sites D and E
the void space of landfills. The total volume reduction is make up group two or ‘aged’ group since their fill ages
believed to depend upon the amount of biodegradable are approximately 10 years. Site F and G make up group
solid mass (Stot–dec). Since biodegradable solids continue to three or ‘old’ group since their fill ages are greater than
decompose for a very long period, the completion of bio- 25 years.
logical compression may also take long time.
Since the solubilisation process of biodegradable solid Site A (young)
mass can be expressed in the first order kinetics, it can Gandolla et al. (1992) have carried out experiments using
be supposed that the compression process due to three open topped cylindrical concrete lysimeters having
the solubilisation can also be characterised by the dimensions of 1 m internal diameter and 3 m height. The
same kinetics. Then, the equation related to the lysimeters were filled with fresh shredded refuse mixed
compression process due to the solubilisation can be with sludge that amounted 6.8% of the total filling refuse.
expressed as follows: The filled refuse contained 55% water and 60% organic
contents based on the solids portion. The experiment
–dec(tbio)=tot–dec .e–ktbio, tbio=t – tc (4) began on 31/5/83 and measurements had been taken up to
28/11/89. The fill age is zero year. The settlement curve
where –dec, the amount of strain that additionally shows a linear portion relation with a small slope in plots
occurs due to the decomposition of biodegradable solids, of strain versus log-time and then it develops a much
not yet decomposed at time t, is a first order biological greater slope at approximately 300 days after the measure-
strain rate constant (t–1), tot–dec stands for the total ment started.
amount of compression that will occur due to the decom-
position of biodegradable wastes and it will be dependent Site B (young)
upon the total amount of biodegradable organic solids Rao et al. (1977) constructed an experimental cell (3 m
(Wardwell & Nelson 1981), and tbio represents the time square, height: 1.5 m), which was filled with fresh
lapse from the starting point (tc) at which the compression household refuse and covered with approximately 0.5 m of
due to decomposition starts. For fresh MSW landfills, to is soil.
assumed to be the time when the slope of settlement in
plots of strain versus log-time increases. For older MSW Site C (young)
landfills, however, it is not necessary to determine tc, since The refuse fill was placed from 1976 and the majority of its
the biological strain had already occurred when the settle- refuse was domestic. The settlement measurement was
ment monitoring started. performed for 2 years beginning in December of 1980.
Thus, the strain at time tbio caused by biodegraded Analysis was conducted for measured settlement curves of
waste solids can be obtained by: three settlement plates (Cheyney 1983). The fill age is 2
years. Settlement curves have a considerable slope without
(tbio)dec=tot–dec– –dec=tot–dec (1 – e–k tbio) (5) showing any sections having small slopes.
Site D (aged)
The Nanji landfill site, located in Seoul, was approved as
Settlement data of MSW landfills with various a municipal dump site in March, 1978. Until the dumping
fill ages site closed in March of 1993, most of municipal refuse
Settlement data obtained from seven MSW lysimeters collected in the Seoul area was open-dumped. The fill
and landfills with various fill ages were analysed. age is estimated as 8 years. The refuse materials consist-
According to the magnitude of fill age for each landfill, ed of excessive amounts of soil, and the decomposition
the seven MSW landfills can be divided into three process had already progressed considerably. Two lysime-
groups, in which ‘the fill age’ is defined as an elapsed time ter tests (height: 1.9 m, diameter : 0.4 m) were performed
period from the mid-point of fill starting and its comple- for samples collected from the Nanji landfill site
tion. Sites A, B and C make up group one or ‘young’ group (Institute of Environmental Science and Engineering
1994). The average moisture content of the refuse was Application of proposed model
28.8% and the average volatile solids content of the dry An example of model application
refuse was 13%. The temperature was maintained at Park & Lee (1997)’s model was applied to a settlement
37°C during the test period. The refuse settlement was curve of Site C (Fig. 5(a)) where the fill age was 2 years. It
monitored for one year. can be observed that the settlement curve was in a long-
term settlement stage that induces considerable amounts of
Site E (aged) settlement due to decomposition. Therefore, the
This site is located in southern Michigan. The refuse starting point (tc), at which the compression due to the
fill has been in place since 1969. The settlement plates decomposition occurs, was assumed to be 274 days when
were installed in 1985 and data were collected during a the monitoring started. As previously discussed, the
1.2 year period. Analysis was performed for five sets of mechanical secondary component of settlement data could
data. The fill age is estimated as 8 years (Dodt et al. supposedly be represented by the equation of
1987). 0.03•log[(t+t)/t], with the application of a factor of 0.03
for c,mec(refer to Table 1). The net biological strain sepa-
Site F (old) rated from the mechanical portion is presented in Fig. 5(b).
This refuse site is located in western Connecticut. The The proposed model was applied in order to predict the
old “town dump” was excavated and relocated to a new amount of future biological strain. A plot of the logarith-
site. This site was monitored for 5 years. The estimated mic strain rate (log[dec/tbio]) versus time (tbio) has been
fill age is approximately 40 years (Keene 1977). used in order to determine parameters used in the model.
With (tbio), and a linear regression analysis, we can evalu-
Site G (old) ate the slope and intercept as:
The landfill, located in Massachusetts was approved
of as a municipal dump site in 1954. The fill age is
slope = 0.4323k (6)
approximately 25 years. It was reported that the environ-
mental condition of the landfill was mature that the
biological degradation was almost complete (Stulgis et al. Therefore, the model parameters, k and tot–dec can be
1995). estimated from the data. The values of tot–dec and k were
(a) (b)
*C,mec (strain/log time) stands for the rate of mechanical secondary compression
Fig. 7. Plot of log-time versus –dec Fig. 10. Relationship between fill age and tot–dec
References
Barlaz, M.A. and Ham, R.K. and Schaefer, D.M. (1990). “Methane Seminar/Workshop on Environmental Engineering, Kyoto, Japan,
Production from Municipal Refuse: a Review of Enhancement 29–31.
Techniques and Microbial Dynamics,” Critical Reviews in Keene, P. (1977) Sanitary Landfill Treatment. Interstate Highway 84.
Environmental Control. Vol. 19, No. 6, pp 557–584. Proceeding of Geotechnical Practice for the Disposal of Solid Waste
Bjarngard, A., & Edgers, L. (1990) Settlement of Municipal Solid Waste Material, ASCE, 632–644.
Landfills. The thirteenth Annual Madison Waste Conference, Korean Geotechnical Society (1994) Long-term Settlement Characteristics
September, 192–205. for Nan-ji Island landfill. Final Report to Samsung Engineering and
Bjarngard, A. (1989) The Compressibility Characteristics of Landfills. Construction Co., Ltd.
Thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of M.S. in C.E., Tuft University, Landva, A. O. & Clark, J. I. (1990) Geotechnics of Waste Fill. Geotechnics
Medford, MA, May. of Waste Fill - Theory and Practice, ASTM STP 1070. ASTM.
Chen, W.H.(1974). “Time - Settlement Behaviour of Milled Refuse,” PhD Philadelphia, PA., 86–106.
dissertation, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Northwestern University, Lukas, R.G. (1986). Densification of a Decomposed Landfill Deposit”,
Evanston, III. Proc., 10th ICSMFE, San Francisco, Vol. 3, A.A. Balkema,
Cheyney, A.C. (1983) Settlement of Landfill. Third Harwell Waste Rotterdam.
Management Symposium, 13–29. McGowan, K.C. and Pohland, F.G. and Saunders, F.M. and Williams, N.D.
Dodt, M. E., Sweatman, M. B. & Bergstorm, W. R. (1987) Field (1988). “A Microbial Model of Landfill Stabilization,” Proceedings of
Measurements of Landfill Surface Settlement. Geotechnical Practice the 1988 Joint CSCE-ASCE National Conference. Vancouver, B.C.,
for Waste Disposal ’87, Ann Arbor, Mich., 13, 406–418. pp 704-711
El-Fadel, M. and Findikakis, A.N. and Lechie, J.O. (1989). “A Numerical Park, H. I. & Lee, S. R. (1997) Long-Term Settlement Behaviour of Landfills
Model for Methane Production in Managed Sanitary Landfills,” Waste with Refuse Decomposition. Journal of Solid waste Technology and
Management & Research. Vol. 7, pp. 31–42. Management, Vol. 24, No. 4, 159–165.
Gabr, M. A. & Valero, S. N. (1995) Geotechnical Properties of Municipal Rao, S. K., Moulton, L. K. & Seals, R.K. (1977) Settlement of Refuse
Solid Waste. Geotechnical Testing Journal, 18(2). Landfills. Geotechnical Practice for Disposal of Solid Waste Materials,
Gandolla, M., Dugnani, L., Bressi G. & Acaia, C. (1992) The Determination Ann Arbor, Mich., 574–599.
of Subsidence Effects at Municipal Solid Waste. Proceedings, sixth Sohn, K.C. & Johnson, A. M. (1991) Factors Affecting Determination of
International Solid Wastes Congress, Madrid, 1–17. Stability and Settlement of Sanitary Landfills. 5th International
Gordon, D.L., Lord, J.A. & Twine, D. (1986) The Stockley Park Project. Symposium ’91 Solid Waste Management Technology, 207–241.
Proceedings, Building on Marginal and Derelict Land: Institution of Sowers, G. F. (1973). “Settlement of Waste Disposal Fills,” Proceedings, The
Civil Engineers, Glasgow, U.K., 359–381. Eight International Conference of Soil Mechanics and Foundation
Halvadakis, C., Robertson, A., and Leckie, I. (1983). “Landfill Engineering, Moscow, pp. 207-210.
Methanogenesis,” Technical Peport No. 271, Dept. of Civil Stulgis, R.P., Soydemir, C. & Telgener, R.J. (1995) Predicting Landfill
Engineering, Stanford University, Palo Alto, Calif. Settlement. Geoenvironment 2000, Geotechnical Special Publication
Ham, R. K. (1988) Biological and Chemical Processes in Landfills. Sanitary No. 46. ASCE, Vol.2–1, 980~994.
Landfill Design Manual, Engineering Professional Department, Wardwell, R. E. & Nelson, J. D. (1981) Settlement of Sludge Landfills with
University of Wisconsin-Madison. Fiber Decomposition. Proceedings, Tenth International Conference
Hoeks, J. (1983) Significance of Biogas Production in Waste Tips. Waste for Soil Mechanics and Foundation Engineering, Vol. 2, Stockholm,
Management & Research. Vol. 1, 323–335. Sweden, 397–401.
Jessberger, H. L. & Kockel, R. (1993) Determination and Assessment of the Young, A. (1989). “Mathematical Modelling of Landfill Degradation,”
Mechanical Properties of Waste Material. Proceedings of Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology. Vol. 46, pp
International Symposium Green ’93, Bolton, UK, A.A. Balkema, 189–208.
Rotterdam. Yuen, S. T. S., Styles, J. R. & McMahon, T. A. (1995) An Active Landfill
Institute of Environmental Science and Engineering. (1994) Landfills Management by Leachate Recirculation: A Review and an Outline of
Stabilisation Using Lysimeter Test. Final Report to Samsung a Full-scale Project. Proceedings Sardinia ‘95 Fifth International land-
Engineering and Construction Co., Ltd. fill Symposium, 403–418.
Kang, S.T., Shin, H.S., Lee, C.Y. & Lee, N.H. (1997) Relationship between Zeiss, C.A. & Atwater, J. (1989) Waste Facility Impacts on Residential
Biological Decomposition and Landfill Settlement at Various Property Value. ASCE-Journal of Urban Planning and Development,
Leachate Recirculation Rates. Proc., 7th KAIST-NTU-KU Tri-Lateral Vol. 115, No. 2, 64–80.