CM615- STAKEHOLDER MANAGEMENT IN BUILT

ENVIRONMENT

MAJOR PROJECT

Bandra-Worli Sea Link

04 NOV 2014

SUBMITTED BY

S. No Enrollmen N!m"er# N$me#

1 A1%56&11'(1% R$)$*B$+,$r Am$
/ A1%56&11'(10 B.H$r#$ V$r$n
% A1%550(1'(&& Son,$ O#,
' A1%550(1'(&6 S$#$n B$r$2$3
5 A1%550(1'(&' S!#$n Go#

MBA CPM & CE-S !SEC-B" !#RO$P-2"

SCHOOL O4 CONSTRUCTION
RICS SCHOOL
SCH OOL O4 BUILT ENVIRONMENT
AMITY UNIVERSITY NOIDA
Table of Contents
1 INTRODUC
INTRODUCTION
TION.....
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
................
...................3
........3
2 PROJECT
PROJECT SPECIFI
SPECIFICS..
CS.......
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
................
..................3
.......3
3 STAK
STAKEHOL
EHOLDER
DERS
S IN!OL!
IN!OL!ED..
ED.......
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
................
.......................
...............3
...3
3.1 INTERNAL
INTERNAL STAK
STAKEHOL
EHOLDER
DERS....
S.........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
............
...................
.....................3
.........3
3.2 E"TERNAL
E"TERNAL STA
STAKEH
KEHOLDE
OLDERS..
RS.......
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
................
...................3
........3
# D$NA%IS%
D$NA%IS% IN STA
STAKEHOLDE
KEHOLDER
R INFLUENC
INFLUENCE....
E.........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..............
.....................
.....................3
.........3
#.1 PO&ER
PO&ER INTERES
INTEREST
T 'RID
'RID ( PHASE
PHASE 1.......
1............
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
.......3
..3
#.2 PO&ER
PO&ER INTERES
INTEREST
T 'RID
'RID ( PHASE
PHASE 2.......
2............
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
.......3
..3
#.3 PO&ER INTEREST
INTEREST 'RID ( PHASE 3 ..................................................................
.................................................................. ...... 3
) ACTION..
ACTION.......
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
...........
................3
..........3
).1 EN'A'E%
EN'A'E%ENT
ENT RISK
RISK PROFILE..
PROFILE.......
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
.......3
..3
* E!AL
E!ALUA
UATIO
TION
N AND
AND LEARNIN
LEARNIN'...
'........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
................
..............#
...#
+ STAK
STAKEHOL
EHOLDER
DER EN'A'E%E
EN'A'E%ENT
NT PLAN...
PLAN........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
...........
...........#
.....#
, O-SER!
O-SER!A
ATIONS.
TIONS......
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
............
...................
......................#
..........#
 CONCLUS
CONCLUSIONS
IONS.....
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
............#
.......#
1/ REFERENC
REFERENCES.
ES......
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
................
.......................
.....................#
.........#
11 APPENDI
APPENDI"...
"........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
..........
............
............
.....##

Table of
o f Abb0eatons
Abb0eaton s

• -&SLP ( -an0a4&o0l sea ln5 60o7e8t

• EIA 4 En0on9ental 96a8t assess9ent
• %oEF 4 %nst0: of en0on9ent an fo0est
• EPA 4 En0on9ent 60ote8ton a8t
• %PC- 4 %a;a0as;t0a 6oll<ton 8ont0ol boa0
• -EA' 4 -o9ba: en0on9ental a8ton =0o<6
• %%RDA 4 %<9ba 9<n86al 0oa eelo69ent a<t;o0t:
• IPT ( Inan Peo6les T0b<nal
• CR> 4 8oastal 0e=<laton ?one
• C&PRS 4 Cent0al 6o@e0 an 0esea08; nstt<te

1 INTRODUCTION
 T;e -an0a(&o0l
-an0a(&o0l Sea Ln5 also off8all:
off8all: t;e Ra7 'an; Sea Ln5 s a 8able4
sta:e b0=e @t; 60e4st0esse 8on80ete a<8t a660oa8;es @;8; ln5s -an0a an
t;e @este0n s<b<0bs of %<9ba @t; &o0l an 8ent0al %<9ba. T;e Sea Ln5 0e<8es
t0ael t9e bet@een -an0a an &o0l f0o9 #)(*/ 9n<tes to + 9n<tes. T;e ln5 ;as an
ae0a=e al: t0aff8 of a0o<n 3+)// e;8les
e;8les 6e0 a: an s #.+59s lon=. T;e -an0a
&o0l Sea Ln5 Roa P0o7e8t B-&SLP s a 6a0t of t;e &este0n F0ee@a: Sea P0o7e8t
@;8; n t<0n s 6a0t of a la0=e0 60o6osal
60o6osal of <6=0ae t;e 0oa t0ans6o0taton
t0ans6o0taton net@o05 of
=0eate0 %<9ba as 6e0 t;e 0e6o0t 60e6a0e b: t;e Cent0al Roa Resea08; Staton
@;8; ;a been 8o99ssone b: t;e %a;a0as;t0a 'oe0n9ent. T;e 60o7e8t s 6lanne
@t; a e@ to 60oe an atonal 8o00o0 fo0 t;e f0ee flo@ of t0aff8 f0o9 -an0a to
&o0l n t;e f0st 6;ase an &o0l to Na09an Pont n t;e se8on 6;ase. T;e ln5 s
9eant 609a0l: to 60oe an alte0nate to t;e %a;9 Ca<se@a: 0o<te t;at s 60esentl:
t;e onl: 8onne8ton bet@een t;e Islan48t: an t;e &este0n an Cent0al s<b<0bs.
T;e 8ost of t;e 60o7e8t 1*3# 80o0e 0<6ees t;o<=; t;e 60o7e8t @as est9ate to be abo<t
3// 80o0e B#3/ 8ost oe00<n. T;e 60o7e8t @as ) :ea0s be;n s8;e<le. P0o7e8t @as
8o96lete n 2/1/. Const0<8ton be=an n t;e :ea0 2/// an @as 8o96lete on 2#t;
9a08; 2/1/. C;a0=n= a toll of al9ost Rs 1/ 6e0 one 5lo9et0e t;e ).*459 sea ln5 s
one of t;e ;=;est tolle 0oas n t;e state.

-an0a&o0l Sea4Ln5.
2 PROJECT SPECIFICS
T;e 60o7e8t @as 8o99ssone b: %a;a0s;t0a state 0oa Deelo69ent Co06o0aton
B%SRDC. HCC BHn<stan Const0<8ton Co06o0aton @as t;e 8ont0a8to0 fo0 t;e
60o7e8t. T;e 8ont0a8t ;as been =en on -<l4O6e0ate4T0ansfe0 bass. In 2//1 Da04Al4
Hanasa; @as 8;osen as t;e 60o7e8t 9ana=e9ent 8ons<ltants afte0 0e6la8n=
See0<6 8ons<ltants @e0e 0o66e fo0 fal<0e to 60oe a 8o96etent 60o7e8t
9ana=e9ent. It s Inas f0st b0=e to be 8onst0<8te n o6en4sea 8ontons. It s #.+
59 lon= @t; t@n #4lane ne6enent 8a00a=e@a: b0=e a80oss t;e o6en sea. So9e
f<0t;e0 en=nee0n= s6e8f8atons a0e as follo@s
• 1*4lane toll 6la?a @t; 2/49 @e 60o9enae to=et;e0 @t; state4of4t;e4a0t t0aff8
9onto0n= s<0ellan8e nfo09aton an 8ont0ol s:ste9s
• U6 to 2)49 ;=; 6e0 n o6en sea =n= a96le ;ea0oo9 to 9a0ne t0aff8.
• 23#2 60e48ast se=9ents fo0 total b0=e @t; a0e @t;.
• La0=est s6an fo0 8able4sta:e b0=e n Ina.

T;e ent0e 60o7e8t @as o0=nall: 8on8ee as one la0=e 60o7e8t 8o960sn= ffe0ent
8o96onents b<t n o0e0 to a88ele0ate t;e oe0all 8onst0<8ton s8;e<le t;e 60o7e8t
;as been e nto fe 8onst0<8ton 6;ases 4

• P;ase I Const0<8ton of fl:oe0 oe0 Loe '0oe 7<n8ton at &o0l.

• P;ase II Const0<8ton of 8loe0leaf nte08;an=e at %a;9 nte0se8ton.
• P;ase III Const0<8ton of sol a660oa8; 0oa f0o9 t;e %a;9 nte0se8ton <6 to
t;e sta0t of t;e Toll Pla?a on t;e -an0a se an a 6<bl8 60o9enae.
• P;ase I! Const0<8ton of Cable4Sta:e -0=es to=et;e0 @t; a<8t
a660oa8;es eGtenn= f0o9 &o0l <6 to t;e Toll Pla?a at -an0a en Intell=ent
-0=e S:ste9 BI-S.
• P;ase ! I960oe9ent to K;an Ab<l 'affa0 K;an Roa.

P;ase I! s t;e la0=est an 9an 6;ase of -an0a4&o0l Sea Ln5 P0o7e8t. T;e @o05
<ne0 t;s 6;ase @as a@a0e to HCC. %an feat<0es of t;s te8;n8all: 8;allen=n=
6;ase @e0e
 • Cable4Sta:e -0=e n8l<n= a<8t a660oa8;es eGtenn= f0o9 &o0l <6
to Toll Pla?a at -an0a en
• %oe0n Toll Pla?a

#oal% o Bandra-Worli %ea link'

1. San=s n t0aelln= t9e an 0e<8ton of e;8<la0 t0aff8.

2. Re<8ton n a0 an nose 6oll<ton nea0 0esental a0eas of %a;9 P0ab;ae
Daa0.
3. Re<8ton n n<9be0 of a88ents b: <6=0an= t;e 0oa t0ans6o0taton net@o05.

T(e )i%*or+ o *(e Pro,e* *ill o..ene.en* o /ro,e*'

1,3

Cent0al Roa Resea08; Instt<te 8o99ssone b: t;e state of %a;a0as;t0a to 8a00: o<t
a st<: of t;e 0oa t0ans6o0taton net@o05 of t;e %<9ba %et0o6oltan Re=on. Fo<0
9a7o0 0oas 60o6ose as an nte=0ate sol<ton n8l<n= t;e &est Islan F0ee@a:
ln5n= t;e -an0a4Na09an Pont 0oa of @;8; t;e -an0a4&o0l Sea Ln5 fo09s an
nte=0al 6a0t.

Feb0<a0: 11

T;e Cent0al 'oe0n9ent t;0o<=; ts %nst0: of En0on9ent an Fo0ests ss<es a
notf8aton 0e=a0n= t;e Coastal Re=<laton >one BCR> Notf8aton @;8; 60o;bts
0e8la9aton bet@een t;e ;=; te lne an t;e lo@ te lne an @;8; @o<l 80eate an:
obst0<8ton n t;e flo@ of tal @aes of t;e sea.

1* %a08; 11

%an=0oes an nat<0e 6a05 a0eas of a0o<n 1,#.1# ;a. In %a;9 80ee5 e8la0e as
60ote8te fo0est b: a %a;a0as;t0a 'a?ette Notf8aton <ne0 t;e Inan Fo0est A8t

O8tobe0 12

-%RDA 60e6a0es a ne@ 6lan an 60e6a0es a feasblt: 0e6o0t fo0 t;e sea 0o<te ln5
bet@een -an0a an &o0l. At t;s 6ont no not8e @as ss<e ntn= 6<bl8 ob7e8tons
an s<==estons an no 6lan @as 6<bls;e.
J<ne 13

%a;a0as;t0a 'oe0n9ent t;0o<=; ts 6<bl8 @o05s e6a0t9ent a660oa8;e t;e Cent0e
fo0 En0on9ental 8lea0an8e of t;e 60o7e8t. T;e Unon 'oe0n9ent e8lnes to san8ton
t;e 60o7e8t.

Se6te9be0 13

-%RDA ntes 3/ sele8t 6e0sons fo0 a se9na0 on t;e -an0a4&o0l 60o7e8t 9ost of
@;o9 a0e et;e0 =oe0n9ent o0 9<n86al off8als an onl: fe 0e60esentn= N'Os.

2+ Jan<a0: 1#

%nst0: of En0on9ent an Fo0est Notf8aton <ne0 t;e En0on9ent P0ote8ton A8t
60es80bn= t;at no 9oe0n?aton of an: a8tt: @;8; @o<l n80ease t;e 6oll<ton leel
o0 an: ne@ 60o7e8t @;8; @o<l fall <ne0 S8;e<le 1 to t;e Notf8aton @o<l be
<ne0ta5en n an: 6a0t of Ina @t;o<t ben= =en en0on9ental 8lea0an8e b: t;e
Cent0al 'oe0n9ent n a88o0an8e @t; t;e 60o8e<0e 60es80be.

# %a: 1#

F<0t;e0 notf8aton of t;e %oEF 9of:n= t;e notf8aton ate 2+ Jan<a0: 1#
=n= t;e Cent0al 'oe0n9ent s80eton to s6ense @t; t;e 0e<0e9ents of 6<bl8
not8e f satsfe t;at t;e sa9e @as n t;e 6<bl8 nte0est.

1)

T;e %a;a0as;t0a =oe0n9ent fo0@a0s ts Coastal >one %ana=e9ent Plan to t;e
Cent0al 'oe0n9ent fo0 ts a660oal as 0e<0e b: t;e CR> notf8aton. T;s 6lan
n8l<e t;e 6ossble 8onst0<8ton of t;e -an0a4&o0l Sea Ln5 60o7e8t b<t t;e al=n9ent
as <ote n t;e 0e6o0t 9a: be a88e6te as 6a0t of t;e C>%P.

2+ Se6te9be0 1*

T;e Cent0al %nst0: of En0on9ent an Fo0ests a660oes t;e Coastal >one

%ana=e9ent Plan s<b7e8t to te09s an 8ontons as a 0es<lt of @;8; t;e san8ton to

t;e sa -an0a &o0l Sea Ln5 s 0ef<se an all 9an=0oes @t; an a0ea of 1/// s.
9et0es o0 9o0e a0e to be 8lassfe as CR>4I @t; a b<ffe0 of at least )/ 9ete0s an

a0eas n t;e %t; 0e0 est<a0: also 8lassfe as CR>4I

1/ A60l 1+

%oEF notf8aton 60es80bn= t;at ee0: a66l8aton fo0 En0on9ental Clea0an8e @as
0e<0e to be a88o96ane b: etals of 6<bl8 ;ea0n=.

 J<l: 1+

CR> notf8aton a9ene so as to 6e09t 0e8la9aton an b<nn= fo0 t;e 8onst0<8ton
of b0=es sea ln5s an ot;e0 fa8ltes essental fo0 a8ttes 6e09ssble <ne0 t;e
notf8aton o0 fo0 8oastal e0oson 8leann= of @ate0 @aes sto09 @ate0 0ans et8.

, %a: 1,

Lette0 f0o9 t;e Natonal Fs; &o05e0s Fo0<9 to t;e Se80eta0: U0ban Deelo69ent
De6a0t9ent as5n= fo0 t;e P0o7e8t Re6o0t an Plans ( No 0es6onse @as 0e8ee f0o9
t;e 'oe0n9ent.

1,

Hea0n= =en to t;e %<9ba En0on9ental A8ton '0o<6 @t; 0e=a0 to t;e -an0a
&o0l P0o7e8t @t;o<t 60on= t;e9 @t; an: 6a0t8<la0s 6lans 9a6s o0 nfo09aton.

+ Jan<a0: 1

T;e Cent0al =oe0n9ent =0ants En0on9ental Clea0an8e of t;e sa 60o7e8t @t;o<t
;oln= a 6<bl8 ;ea0n= s<b7e8t to st08t 8o96lan8e of ts te09s an 8ontons.

11 Jan<a0: 1

%0. S<0es; P0ab;< anno<n8e t;e san8tonn= of t;e 60o7e8t n %<9ba

12 Jan<a0: 1

%a;a0as;t0a %a8;9a0 K0t Sa9ts lette0 to t;e C;ef %nste0 ob7e8tn= to t;e
8lea0an8e of t;e 60o7e8t
Jne 1'

Work on *(e Bandra-Worli Sea link o..ene%

 J<l: 1

H<n0es of fs;e09en ;ol e9onst0atons on t;e ste of t;e 60o7e8t an e9an ts
8an8ellaton.

2 O8tobe0 1

Pea8ef<l e9onst0aton of ;<n0es of fs;e0fol5 ;el on 'ene0al A0<n K<9a0 !a:a

Roa nea0 %a;9 Ca<se@a:.

23 Noe9be0 1

%o08;a ;el b: fs;e0 fol5 an ot;e0 so8al an en0on9ental =0o<6s Labo<0 Unons
et8. A0o<n #// 6e0sons a00este an 6<t n -an0a 6ol8e 8<sto:.

A*er Co..ene.en*'

T;e 60o7e8t @as a660oe n %a: 11 afte0 + :ea0s of ela:s an feasblt:
st<es. T;e b<=et a660oe n 1 @as *)/ 80o0e <6 f0o9 ntal 3// 80o0es @t;
slate 8o96leton n n 942//1. -<t t;e @o05  not 8o99en8e tll De8e9be0 1.
T;e @o05 @as ela:e <6tl 2//1 an @as fa8n= 8onst0<8ton ss<es n 9onsoon. In
late 2//1 t;e 60o7e8ts 609e 8ons<ltant See0<6 @as 0o66e fo0 fal<0e to 60oe a
8o96etent 60o7e8t 9ana=e9ent. T;e 0e6la8e9ent Da0 Cons<ltants 9ofe t;e 60o7e8t
es=n b: an= 2., 59s to ts len=t; an s6lttn= t;e t@o e=;t lane b0=e nto t@o #
lane b0=es. -: 2//2 t;e s8;e<le ele0: ate ;a s;fte to 2//#. In O8tobe0 2//#
t;e 8ost t;e 8ost n80ease b: )/ 80o0es. D<e to 6a<8t: of f<n t;e 60o7e8t @as
ela:e. A late0 ba 9onsoons an <n60e8table @o05 6la:e s6ol s6o0t sto66n=
@o05. %eant9e fs;e09ans 8on8e0n abo<t nte0fe0en8e an loss of lel;oo ss<es
80eate <n8e0tant: oe0 60o7e8t 8o96leton. Fs;e09en 80e fo<l oe0 loss of boat
6a05n= s6a8e an t;e nee ;a 0sen fo0 t;e9 to @al5 al: to an alte0nate boat
6a05n= 8a<sn= lot ssatsfa8ton a9on= t;e fs;e09en. T;e 60o7e8t ele0: @as no@
n 2//). %ean@;le 8o96lants f0o9 en0on9entalsts 0e=a0n= a9a=e to 9a0ne
e8olo=: =0e@. HCC t;e 609a0: 8ont0a8to0 0e<este an atonal 3// 80o0es to 8oe0
ela:s an es=n 8;an=es b<t t;e =oe0n9ent @as 0ea: to offe0 12/ 80o0es. -: J<ne
2//) t;e 60o7e8t 8ost ;a 0sen to 13/*. -<t t @as not <ntl J<ne 2// t;at t;e 60o7e8t
@as 8o96lete. T;e 60o7e8t n t;e en s 8o96lete n 1*// 80o0es. A etale s<99a0:
s eG6lane f<0t;e0 a;ea n t;e 6a6e0.

-an0a4&o0l Sea4Ln5 Lo8aton.

 I9a=e f0o9 9s08.o0=

3 STAKEHOLDERS IN!OL!ED

T;e 60o7e8t ;a fa8e st0on= ela:s b: t;e fs;e09en f0o9 %<9ba on 8la9s of
6ossble loss n t;e0 lel;oo. %nst0: of en0on9ental affa0s @as a660oa8;e b:
t;ese 8o99<ntes. Anot;e0 s<8; 8o99<nt: @as Sae &o0l Sea fa8e 8o99ttee
t;e: @e0e t;e 0esents of t;e &o0l sea f0onta=e an o66ose t;e 8onst0<8ton to sae
t;e0 f0onta=e e@. Hea: o66oston @as one to t;e 60o7e8t base on t;e e8olo=8al
st<0ban8e t;at t;e b0=e 9=;t 8a<se. N'Os an en0on9entalsts ;ae 8la9e
6ossble floon= n -an0a a0ea <e to 0e8la9aton an na00o@n= of %t; Re0. Hen8e
t;e 60o7e8t too5 a lot of t9e n =ettn= t;e en0on9ental 8lea0an8es. T;e state bo:
%a;a0as;t0a 6oll<ton 8ont0ol boa0 @as 9ae 0es6onsble b: t;e 9nst0: of eGte0nal
affa0s to ;ol 6<bl8 ;ea0n=s an 9eetn=s. T;e eGte0nal sta5e;ole0s 8la9e
ob7e8tons to t;e 60o7e8t on 3 ss<es
M Ille=alt: of t;e P0o7e8t Bbase on 6e09ssons an 8lea0an8es
M I96a8t of t;e P0o7e8t on Lel;oo En0on9ent an T0aff8 an
M Unes0ablt: of t;e P0o7e8t.

3lleali*+ o *(e Pro,e*'

1. No P<bl8 ;ea0n=.
2. In8o96lete en0on9ent assess9ent 6lan.
3. P0o7e8t 0e6o0ts <naalable to t;e 6<bl8.
#. CR> olatons <e to 0e8la9aton.

3./a* o *(e Pro,e* on Li5eli(ood6 En5iron.en* and Trai'

1. Dan=e0 to 60ote8te s6e8es <e to t0ee felln=.
2. I96a8t on lel;oo of 8o99<ntes.
3. I96a8t of atonal t0aff8 4 8on=eston n so<t; %<9ba.

$nde%ira7ili*+ o /ro,e*'
1. I96a8t <e to blo85a=e of %t; Re0.
 2. Fnan8al !ablt: an Absen8e of Realst8 P0o7e8tons of Cost Re8oe0:.
3. P0oble9s @t; t;e Plannn= an I96le9entaton of t;e P0o7e8t.

He0e s a lst of sta5e;ole0s fo0 t;e 60o7e8ts @t; t;e0 6o@e0 nte0est =0aaton
9a05e
 Inte0est EG6e8tatons
S. No Sta5e;ole0 Role Po@e0 0an5n=
0an5n=
1. %a;a0ast;0a state Sta5e 5ee6e0 an #.))
##
'oe0n9ent s<6e0son
%a;a0ast;0a state 0oa Intato0 of t;e
2.
eelo69ent 60o7e8t )) ))
8o06o0atonB%SRDC
Cont0a8to0
3.
Hn<stan 8onst0<8ton )) #)
8o96an: BHCC
#. P0o7e8t 9an=e0s #)
Da04Al Hanasa; #)
Cent0al &ate0 an
).
Po@e0 Resea08; Staton Resea08; an #) 2)
BC&PRS feasblt:
*. -o9ba: :o<t; Has o66ose t;e 2)
3)
Asso8aton 60o7e8t
+. Sta5e 5ee6e0 #)
-o9ba: ;=; 8o<0t 3)
,. Sta5e 5ee6e0 ))
Cent0al =oe0n9ent 2)
. %nst0: fo0 en0on9ent Sta5e @at8;e0 #)
#)
an fo0est B%oEF
1/. Sae &o0l sea4fa8e In o66oston of 3)
#)
Sa9tee t;e 60o7e8t
11. S<b8ont0a8to0 2)
-a7a7 ele8t08al 3)
%<9ba %et0o6oltan Intato0 an
12.
Re=on Deelo69ent 6lanne0 fo0 t;e 2.)) 3.))
A<t;o0t: 8t:
Akhil Maharashtra Sta5e;ole0 as
13. 0esents of t;e 2)
Machhimar Kriti Samiti #)
(AMMKS) 8nt:
1#. Maharashtra State
2)
Electricity Board 2)
Briham Mumbai %<n86al
1). 8o06o0aton of t;e 3.))
municipal corporation 3)
(BMC) 8t:
1*. Sta5e @at8;e0 2)
Media #)

Bombay Environmental A8tst =0o<6

1+. @at8;n= t;e 2)
Action Group 3)
(BEAG) 60o7e8t
1,. Jacob enineerin !ndia Des=n 2)
2)
pvt limited 8ons<ltants
1. "achel #elice $ 'eote8;n8al 2) 2)
en=nee0n=
 Associates% !nc&
2/. Shiva'i ark akshita A8tst =0o<6 3)
3)
samiti
!ndian eople*s +ribunal
21. A8tst 8o99ttee
on Environment and 3.))
,uman -ihts (!+) 3.))
22. State pollution control %eato0 3)
3)
board (SCB)
23. -atan J Batliboi Cons<ltn= 1)
3)
Architects .+ "imited a08;te8t
2#. Consortium o/ Sverdrup O0=nal 60o7e8t 2)
2)
Civil !nc&% 9ana=e9ent
2). Cons<ltants
Shrikhande Consultants% 3)
3)
2*. Cons<ltants
KMG 2)
1.))
2+. Cons<ltants
,0+B 2)
1.))
2,. Cons<ltants
Mott Mc onald 2)
1.))
2. Cons<ltants
Schlaich Berermann
Society /or Clean
3/. En0on9entalsts 2)
Environment 3)
(S1C"EE0)
31. ublic 2orks
2)
epartment (2) '<an8e 1.))
32. Central -oad -esearch
3)
!nstitute (C--!) Feasblt: 1)
33. &o0l ban
2&S& Atkins 2.))
8ons<ltants 1)
3#.
Kirloskar pvt ltd 2.))
Cons<ltants 1)
3). 2alkers ecoloical
2)
movement En0on9entalsts 2.))
 1. INTERNAL STAKEHOLDERS

T;e 60o7e8t 9ana=e9ent of -&SL 8o960se of t;e nte0nal sta5e;ole0s. HCC

%SRDC an 60o7e8t 9ana=e9ent Da04al4Hansa; @e0e t;e 8o0e 9e9be0 of t;e
60o7e8ts. It s nte0estn= to note t;at t;e o0=nal 60o7e8t 9ana=e9ent See0<6 @as
0o66e f0o9 t;e P%C 0ole n 2//1 on ffe0en8es on 60oso of en=nee0n= ss<es.
T;e f<ns 0e<0e b: %SRDC @as 0ase b: t;e %a;a0as;t0a state =oe0n9ent.
%a;a0as;t0a state =oe0n9ent @as 0es6onsble fo0 =n= t;e 60o7e8t to t;e %SRDC
oe0 %%RDA @;8; s t;e bo: 0es6onsble fo0 eelo69ent of t;e 9et0o6oltan 0e=on.
As 9entone SPC- @as 0es6onsble fo0 ;oln= 6<bl8 ;ea0n=s an @as ass=ne b:
t;e 9nst0: of en0on9ental affa0s to 6la: t;s 0ole. Ratan J -atlbo @as t;e a08;te8t
;0e b: t;e -S&L to =es 8ons<ltan8:. A6a0t f0o9 t;e9 t;e0e @e0e fe@ ot;e0 nte0nal
sta5e;ole0s @t; 0elatel: less nte0ests n t;e 60o7e8t. -%C @as one s<8; sta5e;ole0.
T;e 9<n86al 8o06o0aton @ante s<88ess fo0 t;e 60o7e8t so as to ease <6 t;e al0ea:
8on=este 0oas. %<9ba 9et0o6oltan 0e=on eelo69ent a<t;o0t: @as anot;e0 s<8;
sta5e;ole0. %%RDA 60o6oses 6lans an oe0sees 8onst0<8ton of nf0ast0<8t<0e an
ot;e0 60o7e8ts n %<9ba 9et0o6oltan 0e=ons.

So9e of t;e s<66le0s as 9entone b: H.C.C n ts 0e6o0t on -an0a4&o0l sea ln5
a0e as follo@s

1. !SL Sn=a6o0e Pt Lt Te8;n8al Cons<ltants

2. Ult0a Te8; S<66le0 of 8e9ent

3. %et8o =0o<6 of 8o96anes S<66le0 of bea0n=s

#. Tata Steel RIN Lt  SAIL S<66le0 of steel

). ELKE% Inte0natonal Lt. No0@a:4base 8o96an: s<66le0 of 980o sl8a

*. SPCC C;na4base 8o96an: s<66le0 of sta: 8able

+. DOKA A<st0ala s<66le0 of Pl:on fo09@o05

 2. E"TERNAL STAKEHOLDERS
T;e eGte0nal sta5e;ole0s @e0e 9an: an ;a =ane 8onse0able 6o@e0 t;0o<=;
t;e 8o<0se of 8onst0<8ton. T;e nat<0e of t;e 60o7e8t @as of a e0: ;=; 60ofle nat<0e
;en8e lot of 6<bl8 attenton @as besto@e <6on t;e 60o7e8t. Lot of eGte0nal
sta5e;ole0s @e0e ssatsfe @t; t;e 60o7e8t an 8la9e base n t;e feasblt:
0e6o0ts to@a0s t;e 8a0 o@nn= elte 6<bl8. T;s 60o7e8t @as 8onse0e b: t;e9 as a
s;o@ of st0en=t; fo0 t;e 8t: of %<9ba to e<al en=nee0n= 60o7e8ts @o0l@e. Inan
6eo6les t0b<nal on en0on9ent an ;<9an 0=;ts BIPT @as t;e so8al a8tst bo:
@;8; @as able to 9obl?e ot;e0 a8tst =0o<6s an b<l a 8ase a=anst t;e 60o7e8t.
Note a08;te8t Da00:l D%onte o8e ;s 8on8e0ns t;0o<=; t;e IPT an t;0o<=; fo0<9
of En0on9ental Jo<0nalsts of Ina BFEJI 8la9n= t;at @;en ,/ of t;e 6eo6le t0ael
b: b<s an lo8al t0ans an onl: 2/ t0aelln= b: 8a0 an nte09eate t0ans6o0t t @as
<nfa0 on a0t of t;e a<t;o0tes to n8<0 s<8; ;<=e a9o<nts of 9one: on t;e 9no0t:
se8ton B60ate 8a0 t0ans6o0t s 11 as of 2//). A 0e6o0t 60e6a0e b: &.S.At5ns
nte0natonal an K0los5a0 8ons<ltants n 2//# 80t8?e t;e 6lannn= of t;e @;ole of
@est slan f0ee@a: of @;8; -an0a @o0l sea ln5 s a 6a0t. T;e 0e6o0t f<0t;e0 8la9e
t;at 8onst0<8tn= on t;e lne of No0t;4So<t; aGs @ll f<0t;e0 t0o<bles fo0 t;e Islan 8t:
0at;e0 an @ea5 east4@est 8o00o0 9<st be eelo6e f at all. T;e &o0l -an5 =ae t;s
ass=n9ent to &.S. At5ns @;o s<b9tte t;e0 Re6o0t n 1# 0e8o99enn= a
8o960e;ense T0ans6o0t St0ate=: fo0 %%R an base on t;s st0ate=: a T0ans6o0t
Inest9ent Plan fo0 t;e 6e0o 1)42/11. T;e 0e6o0t s<==este +2 f<nn= on
0al@a:s an 9et0o an onl: 21 f<nn= fo0 60ate e;8les. T;s f<0t;e0 a=tate t;e
a8tsts an t;e: felt t;at 6eo6les taG 9one: @as ben= @aste.

# D$NA%IS% IN STAKEHOLDER INFLUENCE

T;e 6o@e0 an nte0est of sta5e;ole0s ;as 8;an=e t;0o<=;o<t t;e 60o7e8t. As t;e
60o7e8t 60o=0esse t;e 0esent an a8tst 8o99ttees =ane nte0est an 6o@e0 n
t;e 60o7e8t. -a85e b: t;e 9ea t;e sta5e @at8;e0s @e0e able to n80ease t;e nte0est
of 9o0e a8tsts an @e0e able to en=a=e t;e 9nst0: of en0on9ental affa0s an
-o9ba: ;=; 8o<0t. At t;e fnal sta=es of t;e 60o7e8t t;e nfl<en8e of t;ese a8tsts
0e<8e base on t;e e8sons an 0esol<tons 6asse b: t;e ;=; 8o<0t an 9nst0:
of en0on9ental affa0s. %SRDC -&SL an HCC ;a ntall: ;=; 6o@e0 b<t 0e<8e
as t;e 60o7e8t @ent nto f<0t;e0 sta=es.

) ACTION

1. EN'A'E%ENT RISK PROFILE

T;e bass of t;e 8onst0<8ton of -an0a4&o0l sea ln5 @as 60e6a0e b: Cent0al
6o@e0 an @ate0 nstt<te BCP&RS t;e 0e6o0t t;at t;e: 9ae n 1,# @as base on a
;:0a<l8 9oel st<: @;8; oes not a88o<nt fo0 t;e 6;eno9enon of ;=; an lo@
tes <ne08<00ent te96e0at<0e a0atons 96a8t on 9a0ne lfe 96a8t on 9an=0oes
an on t;e s;o0es. Seasonal 8;an=es @e0e also not fa8to0e. T;e 6lan of a8ton fo0 t;e
60o7e8t la85e a88<0a8: of t;e al: <sa=e t;e 60o7e8t est9ate a <sa=e of +)/// 8a0s
6e0 a: b<t t;e 60o7e8t s able to a8;ee onl: 3)/// 8a0s 6e0 a:. Hen8e t;e a8ton
6lan fo0 t;s 60o7e8t s;o<l n8l<e 9o0e 0ob<st 60e4feasblt: anal:ss an en=a=e9ent
of t;e 8t?ens an 8o99ttees at t;e n8e6ton sta=e.

* E!ALUATION AND LEARNIN'

-an0a4&o0l sea ln5 60o7e8t as of no@ s 8onse0e as best alte0nate o0 s;o0test

0o<te fo0 t0aelln= f0o9 so<t; %<9ba to @est %<9ba an s also n8l<e n one of
Inas 9a0el en=nee0n= b<t t s eent t;at t @as not a 60o6e0l: 9ana=e 60o7e8t n
te09s of ts 6lannn= 6;ases B@;8; also n8l<es ne=l=en8e of sta5e;ole0s an
eGe8<ton 6;ases as @ell.

A6a0t f0o9 en=nee0n= 8;allen=es t;e0e @e0e 9an: ss<es l5e t;e ntal 8ost of
t;e 60o7e8t @as est9ate to be INR 3// C0 an 8o96leton n 2//# @;8; see0el: =ot
ela:e be8a<se of n<9e0o<s 6<bl8 nte0est lt=aton an @as 8o96lete on 2#t; of
%a08; 2/1/. Also t;e est9ate 8ost oe0s;ot to INR 1*// C0 t;at s fe t9es 9o0e
t;an t;e ntal est9aton 8ost.
CP&RS 0e6o0t also states t;at t;e 8onst0<8ton of t;e b0=e @ll not 80eate an: ae0se
8onton alon= t;e 8oast @;8; totall: @as @0on=.

&;en t 8o9es to 96le9entaton toll 6la?a @as s;fte abo<t 1.) 59 f0o9 o0=nal
lo8aton @;e0eas t;e en0on9ental 8lea0an8e @as =en fo0 t;e 60o6ose lo8aton

+ STAKEHOLDER EN'A'E%ENT PLAN

As 9entone n t;e sta5e;ole0 en=a=e9ent 6lan belo@ t @as essental fo0 t;e 60o7e8t
9ana=e9ent to nole t;e =ene0al 6<bl8 an 0esents b: @a: of 6<bl8 b0efn=s 8o99<nt:
fa0s fel t06s an 9ea 0eleases. T;s @o<l 0es<lt n 0e<8ton of ssatsfa8ton n t;e
=ene0al 6<bl8 @o<l 0es<lte n 8onse0able a9o<nt of san=s fo0 t;e 9ana=e9ent b: @a: of
t9e an 9one:. Ct?en 8o99ttees fs; bo@ln= 8onsens<s 8onfe0en8e a0e 0e<0e to be
one <ne0 t;e 8ons<ltaton 60o8ess fo0 t;e sta5e;ole0 @;8; @e0e le=t9ate as @ell as
nte0este n t;e 60o7e8t. P<bl8 nole9ent s8ena0o testn= an 8onsens<s 8onfe0en8es s
0e<0e fo0 sta5e ;ole0 @;8; ;ae lttle 6o@e0 an nte0est an le=t9a8:.

T;e 6o@e0f<l sta5e;ole0s @e0e al0ea: loo5e at 60o6e0l: n t;e 60o7e8t. Eno<=; sonn=
@as one b: t;e 60o7e8t 9ana=e9ent an t;e0 8on8e0ns @e0e ta5en fo0@a0. -0ansto09n=
@as one b: C&PRS an 9an: 8ons<ltants n8l<n= TCS an ATKINS @t; ;el6 of &o0l
-an5. Inan 6eo6les t0b<nal on en0on9ental an ;<9an 0=;ts ;a 8l<bbe all t;e 8onfl8t
8a<sn= sta5e;ole0s f0o9 ffe0ent se8tons an 60oble9s on one 6latfo09 to n80ease t;e leel
of ssatsfa8ton a9on= t;e 0esents of %<9ba
, O-SER!ATIONS

Sta0tn= f0o9 ts 6lannn= 6;ase -&SLP la85s 60o6e0 9ana=e9ent t ;as olate
a0o<s no09s fo0 en0on9ental 8o96lan8es t;at ;as to be follo@e n Ina. An t;e:
a0e as lste belo@

1. P<bl8 ;ea0n=

It s to be note t;at 6<bl8 6a0t86aton s an eGt0e9el: 80<8al 8o96onent of

=oe0nan8e an ;as to be t0eate se0o<sl:. Aboe all t;e affe8te 6o6<laton ;as a
0=;t to be nfo09e abo<t an: 60o7e8t t;at ;as been <ne0ta5en. -<t all t;e 9e9be0s of
lo8al 8o99<nt: an ot;e0 8on8e0ne 8t?ens ;ae state t;at t;e: @e0e not 8ons<lte.

-o9ba: en0on9ental a8ton =0o<6 ntate an sent a lette0 to %<9ba 9<n86al 0oa
eelo69ent a<t;o0t: B%%RDA 0e=a0n= t;e0 ob7e8tons 8o99ents an s<==estons
;o@ee0 no 0es6onse @as 0e8ee.

-EA' also sent a lette0 ate ,t; of Se6te9be0 1, to 9nst0: of en0on9ent an
fo0est statn= t;e0 ob7e8tons an s<==estons an een t;s t9e t;e0e @as no
0es6onse.

All t;ese n8ents 8lea0l: 6ont to t;e fa8t t;at t;e en0on9ental 8lea0an8e @as =en to
t;e 60o7e8t @t;o<t ;oln= a 9anato0: 6<bl8 ;ea0n=.

2. P0o7e8t 0e6o0t not a88essble fo0 6<bl8

A88o0n= to s8;e<leB of not8e ate 1/t; A60l 1+ ss<e b: 9nst0: of

en0on9ent an fo0est @;oee0 a66les fo0 en0on9ental 60o7e8ts ;as to s<b9t 2/
sets of s<99a0: of t;e salent feat<0es of t;e 60o7e8t to t;e 8on8e0ne state 6oll<ton
8ont0ol boa0. So t;at t 8an be 9ae a88essble fo0 6<bl8 ;ea0n=. -<t no 6a0t8<la0s
9a6s o0 ot;e0 nfo09aton @as f<0ns;e to -EA' b: %oEF.

3. Coastal 0e=<laton ?one olaton

T;e state of %a;a0as;t0a an %%RDA =ae an <ne0ta5n= t;at no 0e8la9aton s;o<l
be 8a00e o<t n t;e -an0a4K<0la 8o96leG a0ea an no 9an=0oe n t;e %t; Re0 o0
ts est<a0: @o<l be est0o:e. Ho@ee0 t;e0e ;as been a blatant olaton of t;e te09s
an 8ontons of t;e en0on9ental 8lea0an8e ate +t; Jan<a0: 1.

#. Lo8al 8o99<ntes not 8ons<lte

T;e fs;e09en affe8te b: t;s 60o7e8t @e0e net;e0 8ons<lte no0 t;e0 8onsent
obtane. No atte96ts @e0e 9ae to ae<atel: 0e;abltate an 8o96ensate t;ese
fs;e09en fo0 t;e 0es<ltant loss of t;e0 lel;oo. Re8la9aton 8a<se 8;an=e n t;e
0e=<la0 6a05n= of boats n t;e nea0 t;e %a;9 ba: to s;ft f<0t;e0 a@a: 8a<sn= t;e
fs;e09en to @al5 9o0e to 0ea8; to t;e0 boats.

). En0on9ental 96a8t assess9ent

EIA s a tool to ens<0e t;at fnte nat<0al 0eso<08es a0e <tl?e @t;n t;e 8a00:n=
8a6a8t: of t;e e8os:ste9. It s <se to 9n9?e t;e ;a09f<l effe8ts of t;e eelo69ent
a8tt: on t;e en0on9ent. A88o0n= to t;e notf8aton ate 1/t; A60l 1+ ss<e b:
t;e %oEF t;e I96a8t assess9ent a=en8: s;o<l 60e6a0e a set of 0e8o99enatons
base on t;e te8;n8al assess9ent of o8<9ents an ata f<0ns;e b: t;e 60o7e8t
a<t;o0tes an s<66le9ente b: ata 8olle8te <0n= sts to fa8to0es an stes f
<ne0ta5en an etals of t;e 6<bl8 ;ea0n=. F<0t;e0 EPA of 1,* an CR> of 11
@e0e also not 8onse0e.

 CONCLUSIONS

T;e 60o7e8t @as a s<88ess on an en=nee0n= an a08;te8t<0al leel b<t ;as fale
on 60o7e8t 9ana=e9ent leel. T;e 8ost 0e8oe0: est9aton of t;e 60o7e8t ;as fallen
s;o0t of t;e eG6e8tatons. T;e 60o7e8t @as 8on8ee @t; a al: t0aff8 of +)///
e;8les b<t onl: 3)/// e;8les t0ael al: affe8tn= t;e 0een<e =ene0aton. -ette0