Professional Documents
Culture Documents
When it comes to things like photons and electrons, the answer to the
question "Do they behave like waves or particles?" is … yes.
PARTICLE
At first glance (and even at deeper glances), waves and particles are very
different. A particle is, as best as I can put it, a thing. It's a small, single, finite
object. You can hold a particle in your hand. You can throw a particle at
someone else and watch it bounce off of them. It's localized. You can point to
a particle and say, "Look, the particle is right there, exactly where I'm
pointing."
Particles have momentum and positions. Particles will move in straight lines
until something changes their direction. Particles can bounce off of other
particles, and they can change trajectories. Think of bullets or speeding cars.
They’re not literally small, subatomic particles, but they act like particles when
they hit other things.. Many physical interactions can be described simply as
particles bouncing off of one another.
On the other hand, waves are almost completely different. They're not
localized. If you want to indicate where a wave is, you have to move your
hands around vaguely gesturing, saying, "It's all over there." You can't hold
the wave in your hand. Instead, the wave passes over, around or even
through your hand.
WAVE
This animation shows what happens when two waves (shown in green and blue)
interfere. (Image credit: Wolfgang Christian/Francisco Esquembre/Francisco Esquembre, CC
BY-SA 4.0)
Waves are oscillations, meaning they wiggle. They transport energy from one
place to another. Waves don't really bounce off of, but instead interfere with,
one another. Sometimes, when the waves come together just right, crest meet
crests, and you get double waves. This is called "constructive interference."
But sometimes, the waves cancel each other out, and you get nothing at all —
an interaction known as "destructive interference." Waves can turn corners,
and when they pass through narrow openings, they can fan out, or diffract.
There are many types of waves in our universe, like ocean waves and waves
on a Slinky.
Both waves and particles are described by very, very different sets of
mathematical equations. So, if you want to describe something scientifically,
first you have to decide if it's a wave or a particle; then you can pull out the
correct mathematical tools to make predictions about how it will behave and
act. And for a couple hundred years, this line of thinking was a fine approach
to solving all the physics problems in the world.
This idea was bolstered a few decades later when Scottish physicist James
Clerk Maxwell figured out that electricity and magnetism were actually two
sides of the same electromagnetic coin and, in the process, realized that light
is waves of electricity and magnetism. That gave a conclusive picture as to
what's doing the waving when it comes to light: its electricity and magnetism.
Light is a wave. Book it, done.
Then, in the late 1800s, German theoretical physicist Max Planck threw a
monkey wrench into everything when he studied blackbody radiation. To
explain his observations, he proposed that light can be emitted only in
discrete little chunks. A few years later, Albert Einstein threw his weight into
the matter by studying the photoelectric effect, and proposed that not only is
light emitted in little chunks, but light itself is made of little packets of energy
called photons. In other words, light was behaving as a particle in these
experiments.
It turns out that de Broglie nailed it. At first blush, you may wonder how
electrons could be anything but particles, because you can literally hold them
in your hand, and they do a lot of bouncing. When you shoot electrons
through two slits, you end up with the exact same interference pattern that
you do with lights: alternating vertical stripes of more and fewer electrons.
A famous 1800s physics experiment, the double-slit experiment, revealed that light behaves
like both particles and waves. (Image credit: Jordgette/Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0)
What's going on? Electrons are acting like waves when they don't look
anything like waves. What's doing the waving?
The answer comes through quantum mechanics, and describing that answer
involves interpreting some of the deep mathematics. The most common
picture, called the Copenhagen interpretation, says that the wave that we
associate with matter is a wave of probability representing all the possible
places where a particle might be the next time we go looking for it. This range
of probability is described by an equation that has the same mathematical
bones as that of any other wave equation. In this picture, that's what's doing
the waving: the possible places the particle could be.
So, as the electrons pass through the slits in de Broglie's experiment, they
can't exactly decide where they want to be. Those waves of uncertainty crash
into each other and interfere, merging and canceling each other out just like
any other waves. Then, when an electron's wave hits the back screen, the
particle finally has to decide where to land. Slowly, electron by electron, the
wave pattern builds up.
Just like light, sometimes matter acts like a particle, and sometimes, it acts
like a wave. So, are light and matter made of waves or particles? The answer
is both, sort of.
"The technology to do this experiment has been around for about two
decades; however, to do a nice data recording of electrons takes some
serious effort and has taken us three years," said lead author of the
study Professor Herman Batelaan from the University of Nebraska-
Lincoln.
"It is our task to turn every stone when it comes to the most
fundamental experiments that one can do. We have done exactly that
with Feynman's famous thought-experiment and have been able to
illustrate the key feature of quantum mechanics," continued Batelaan.
When particles are fired at the wall with both slits open, they are more
likely to hit the backstop in one particular area, whereas waves
interfere with each other and hit the backstop at a number of different
points with differing strength, creating what is known as an
interference pattern.
Unlike sound waves and water waves, Feynman highlighted that when
electrons are fired at the wall one at a time, an interference pattern is
still produced. He went on to say that this phenomenon "has in it the
heart of quantum physics [but] in reality, it contains the only mystery."