Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Control and Regulation of Electrodes
Control and Regulation of Electrodes
Abstract: Some steelmakers companies use Electrical Arc Furnaces (also well-known as Fusion Furnaces) for
the liquid steel fabrication, Sidor is one of them. The efficiency in the furnace will depend on how it is operated
and also on the regulation processes during the calibration adjustment of the electrodes when they are moving
up and down. The correct calibration control loops for the electrodes movement, helps to reduce its wear away,
also reduce the wearing down of the refractory material and help to improve the use of the electrical energy.
The overall contribution of these three aspects is to reduce manufacturing costs. From a maintenance
perspective and starting with a FMEA (Failure Mode and Effects Analysis), a new regulation approach was
developed to obtain a better control of the Sidor Furnace named 1, this was achieved establishing a regulation
according to profiles and load regulation, from alternating electric current to impedance factor.
Keywords: Control, electrodes, furnace, FMEA, maintenance, melting.
valve, see Fig. 1. Every electrode has its own PLC dedicated to
1. INTRODUCTION
create the regulation of the close loops circuit controlling each
An electrical arc furnace (EAF) is a furnace that heats charged one of the electrodes move up and down automatically for
material by means of an electric arc and produces the fusion or regulation of the arc. When a stable regulation is achieved
melting process transforming the received electrical energy, into during the up/down process, this contributes to diminish the
heat (Astigarra 1995). The electrical energy comes from a electrodes wear, also the refractory material will wear in a
network of high voltage alternating current that arrives into a uniform way, which extends its useful life in service. The
main transformer and from there goes to the secondary one and stability generates three more benefits, extend the life of
ended up feeding the electrodes. Three electrodes are arranged refrigeration panels, reduce electrode broken rate during
upon the refractory-lined vessel containing the charge and water- operation and save electrical energy consumption.
cooled, and covered with a retractable roof, through which the
electrodes enter the furnace. The electrical arc between Current Transformer Yokogawa
electrodes jumps going through the load, all this causes that each A
Level 2
electrode in an alternative mode became cathode and anode., the Measurement
mA ABB PC Regulation
charge material is directly exposed to the electric arc, and the transformer Voltage transformer
material. 3
mA ABB
discrepancy disappears the regulation became again by this was done due to the fact this action move the system
impedance. towards the instability so it was decided not to use it. The control
became a PI controller; these parameters are subject to changes
The use of each technique is going to depend on the load profile and will depend on the performance of the furnace since the
done to the furnace. In Sidor two type of load were conditions change, as consequence of mechanical replacement or
predetermined: one is 100% of HRD (direct reduction iron) and the alignment of a new electrode carrier. In cases where changes
the other is 80% of HRD and 20% of scrap iron. The table 7 occurred due to maintenance activities, it is necessary to check
shows the selection of the regulation type depending on the type the parameters and make new adjustments.
of load. According to the type of regulation: impedance or current, the
wished operation points change according to the position of the
Table 7. Profiles to select the type of regulation transformer TAP as seen in table 9 and 10.
REGULATION REGULATION PROFILE CONDICTIONS In order to guarantee protection to the transformer due to the
TYPE TO. OR
DELAYS different condition during the furnace operation, two (2) levels
REGULATION
LOAD TYPE Load 80 –
20
Active energy less or equal to eleven
(11) MWh
of protection in the secondary one exist:
BY Load 100 % Active energy less or equal to one (1)
IMPEDANCE MWh
INTERRUPCTION Less than an Last: two (2) extra MWh to the active
· Instantaneous protection
hour delay energy at the interruption moment · Time-lag protection
More than an Last: eight (8) extra MWh to the active
hour delay energy at the interruption moment (cool
furnace).
Table 8. Parameters of Control, by fusion stages
LOAD TYPE Load 80 – 20 Active energy higher to eleven (11) STAGE CONDITION PROPORTIONAL INTEGRAL DERIVATIVE
REGULATIÓN MWh (P) (I) (D)
BY Load 100 % Active energy higher to one (1) MWh
ELECTRICAL First of Energy F1: 2.2 F1: 0.04 All = 0
CURRENT INTERRUPCTIÓN Less than an Last: from two (2) MWh consumed Impedance smaller to 1 F2: 2.4 F2: 0.08
hour delay alter the interruption. MWh F3: 2.3 F3: 0.04
More than an Last: from eight (8) MWh consumed Second of Energy F1: 1.6 F1: 0.08 All = 0
hour delay alter the interruption. Impedance greater to 1 F2: 2.0 F2: 0.04
MWh and F3: 2.2 F3: 0.01
regulating
by
4. RESULTS Impedance
First of Current Regulating F1: 2.5 F1: 0.01 All = 0
According to the strategy of control used in the melting stages by Current F2: 2.9 F2: 0.0095
different parameters for tuning the control loops were founded. and TAP F3: 2.6 F3: 0.035
different
These parameters can be selected depending on each stage, from one (1)
which is defined based on the consumed energy (MWh). Second of Regulating F1: 2.7 F1: 0.008 All = 0
Current by equal F2: 2.5 F2: 0.008
Current and F3: 2.6 F3: 0.005
In table 8 the parameters values for control of each one of the TAP to one
PID depending on the fusion stages are showed. The values for (1)
the derivative action of the PID are in zero for all the selections,
Table 9. Set point values for Regulation by Impedance. which is an integration of the values of energy sample in each
cycle of the PLC shows that did not happen interruption during
TAP WISHED WISHED WISHED this tap since the line is ascending in continuous way.
IMPEDANCE IMPEDANCE IMPEDANCE
PHASE 1 PHASE 2 PHASE 3
(MOHMS) (MOHMS) (MOHMS) Table 10. Set values Point for Regulation by Current
1 9.987 9.987 9.956 TAP Wished current Wished current Wished current Phase 3
2 9.580 9.580 9.580 Phase 1 (kAmp) Phase 2 (kAmp) (kAmp)
3 9.800 9.800 9.800 1 61.8 62.0 61.0
4 8.726 8.726 8.726
2 63.0 63.0 63.0
5 8.726 8.726 8.726
6 8.626 8.534 8.760 3 63.0 63.0 63.0
7 7.695 7.695 7.695 4 64.0 64.0 64.0
8 7.695 7.695 7.695
5 64.0 64.0 64.0
9 7.587 7.500 7.695
10 7.160 7.160 7.160 6 67.0 67.0 66.0
11 7.160 7.160 7.160 7 66.0 67.0 66.0
12 6.772 6.682 6.772 8 66.0 67.0 66.0
13 7.000 7.000 7.000
9 66.0 67.0 66.0
14 7.000 7.000 7.000
15 8.000 8.000 8.000 10 66.0 67.0 66.0
16 8.000 8.000 8.000 11 68.0 67.0 66.0
17 8.000 8.000 8.000
12 70.0 70.0 68.0
18 8.000 8.000 8.000
19 8.000 8.000 8.000 13 70.0 70.0 70.0
20 8.000 8.000 8.000 14 70.0 70.0 70.0
21 8.000 8.000 8.000 15 52.0 52.0 52.0
16 52.0 52.0 52.0
They protection have been developed by software, programming 17 52.0 52.0 52.0
the PLC controlling the electrode regulation. 18 50.0 50.0 50.0
19 48.0 48.0 48.0
The instantaneous protection in each cycle of the PLC (20 20 46.0 46.0 46.0
miliseg) takes a sample from current and it is compared with the 21 44.0 44.0 44.0
established value on each TAP of the transformer, if the current
is equal or greater to the established, an alarm is generated.
The Figure 4 shows the TAP values, power and consumed
The time-lag protection makes the time-lag to 3 seconds, to energy, which is an integration of the samples values of energy
compare the real current with the established one in the time-lag in each cycle of the PLC, for a tap with a load of 100% HRD. In
table of currents associated to each TAP and, if this is equal or this case after one minute the move to TAP 1 and the control by
greater to this an alarm is generated. electrical current is established.
extinguish the arc in the phases. The adjustment of these TAP ENERGY
(KW)
protections occurred to be a commitment between the protection 190 40 6
protection, instantaneous as much time-lag and the values of 0:56 1:06 1:16 1:26 1:34 1:43 1.53 2:03 TIME(HOURS)
119 96 24
TAP ENERGY
10 37 (KW/H)
96 76 19
POWER
(KW)
18 71 57
5 14
47 38 10
ENENGY POWER TAP
(KW/H) (MW) ENERGY
TAP
16:19 16:27 16:42 16:50 16:58 17:06 17:13 TIME (HOURS) (KW)
24 19 5