Digital Banking Regulations A Comparative Review B

Finance & Accounting Research Journal, Volume 6, Issue 3, March 2024
`
OPEN ACCESS
Finance & Accounting Research Journal
P-ISSN: 2708-633X, E-ISSN: 2708-6348
Volume 6, Issue 3, P.No. 347-371, March 2024
DOI: 10.51594/farj.v6i3.897
Fair East Publishers
Journal Homepage: www.fepbl.com/index.php/farj
DIGITAL BANKING REGULATIONS: A COMPARATIVE

REVIEW BETWEEN NIGERIA AND THE USA
Onyeka Chrisanctus Ofodile¹, Olubusola Odeyemi², Chinwe Chinazo Okoye³,
Wihelmina Afua Addy⁴, Adedoyin Tolulope Oyewole⁵, Omotoya Bukola Adeoye⁶,
& Yinka James Ololade7
¹Sanctus Maris Concepts Nigeria Ltd

²Independent Researcher, Nashville, Tennessee USA
³Access Bank Plc, Nigeria
⁴Independent Researcher, Maryland USA
⁵Independent Researcher, Athens, Georgia, USA
⁶Independent Researcher, Chicago USA
7
Independent Researcher, Addison, Texas, USA
___________________________________________________________________________
*Corresponding Author: Onyeka Chrisanctus Ofodile
Corresponding Author Email: enehnkechi@gmail.com
Article Received: 10-01-24 Accepted: 01-03-24 Published: 17-03-24
Licensing Details: Author retains the right of this article. The article is distributed under the terms of
the Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial 4.0 License
(http://www.creativecommons.org/licences/by-nc/4.0/) which permits non-commercial use,
reproduction and distribution of the work without further permission provided the original work is
attributed as specified on the Journal open access page.
__________________________________________________________________________
ABSTRACT
This paper presents a comprehensive comparative review of digital banking regulations in
Nigeria and the United States of America. The primary objective is to analyze and contrast the
regulatory frameworks governing digital banking in these two countries, with a focus on
understanding their impact on financial stability, consumer protection, and innovation in the
banking sector. The methodology involves a detailed examination of existing literature,
regulatory policies, and legal documents pertaining to digital banking in both Nigeria and the
USA. This is complemented by interviews with key stakeholders in the banking industry,
including regulators, bank executives, and fintech experts.
Key findings reveal significant differences in the regulatory approaches of Nigeria and the
USA. Nigeria's digital banking regulations are found to be more focused on promoting financial
inclusion and mitigating systemic risks, reflecting the country's developing economic status
Ofodile, Odeyemi, Okoye, Addy, Oyewole, Adeoye, & Ololade, P.No. 347-371 Page 347
and the need to address a large unbanked population. In contrast, the USA's regulations are
more comprehensive and sophisticated, emphasizing consumer protection, data security, and
maintaining a competitive market environment. The study also highlights the challenges and
opportunities presented by these regulatory frameworks, particularly in terms of fostering
innovation and adapting to emerging technologies in the banking sector. The conclusion
underscores the importance of a balanced regulatory approach that safeguards the interests of
consumers and the stability of the financial system, while also encouraging innovation and
competition. The paper suggests that both Nigeria and the USA can learn from each other's
regulatory practices to enhance their digital banking ecosystems. This comparative review
provides valuable insights for policymakers, financial institutions, and other stakeholders in
the global banking industry, aiming to navigate the complexities of digital banking regulation
in a rapidly evolving technological landscape.
Keywords: Digital Banking, Regulatory Frameworks, Nigeria, USA, Financial Inclusion,
Cybersecurity, Consumer Protection, Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN), Federal
Reserve, Fintech.
___________________________________________________________________________
INTRODUCTION
Significance of Digital Banking
The advent of digital banking has revolutionized the financial services industry, reshaping how
banks interact with customers and conduct business. This transformation is not just a
technological shift but a fundamental change in the banking paradigm, influencing customer
behavior, business models, and regulatory landscapes. The significance of digital banking lies
in its ability to enhance accessibility, efficiency, and innovation in financial services, making
it a critical area of study in contemporary banking and finance.
Digital banking, encompassing services like online banking, mobile banking, and various
fintech innovations, has significantly impacted the financial performance of banks. A study on
the performance of commercial banks in Zimbabwe highlighted that digital banking platforms
led to an increase in online customer deposits, positively affecting the banks' Return on Assets
(ROA) (The Impact of Digital Banking Services on Performance of Commercial Banks, 2023).
This finding underscores the financial benefits that digital banking can bring to financial
institutions.
In Nigeria, the influence of digital financial services on the economy has been profound.
Research revealed that digital services such as mobile banking and point of sale transactions
positively impacted Nigeria's Gross Domestic Product (GDP), demonstrating the economic
significance of digital banking innovations. This impact is particularly noteworthy in
developing economies, where digital banking can be a catalyst for economic growth and
financial inclusion.
The role of digital banking in enhancing customer experience and financial performance in UK
banks has also been extensively studied. Attributes like perceived value, convenience, and
service quality associated with digital banking were found to improve customer satisfaction
and loyalty, thereby enhancing the financial performance of banks. This research highlights the
customer-centric benefits of digital banking, emphasizing its role in improving the overall
banking experience.
Furthermore, digital banking's role in promoting financial inclusion, especially in Africa, has
been a subject of considerable interest. Digital banking has been identified as a key tool in
bridging the gap between the unbanked and formal financial systems, thereby fostering
economic growth, poverty reduction, and gender equality . This aspect of digital banking is
particularly crucial in regions with significant unbanked populations, where traditional banking
services are limited.
The significance of digital banking extends beyond its economic and financial implications. It
also encompasses challenges such as regulatory complexities, data privacy concerns, and the
need to address the digital divide. As digital banking continues to evolve, these challenges
present opportunities for further research and policy development, ensuring that the benefits of
digital banking are maximized while mitigating potential risks.
Digital banking has emerged as a transformative force in the financial services sector. Its
impact on financial performance, customer experience, economic growth, and financial
inclusion underscores its significance in the modern banking landscape. As the sector continues
to evolve, understanding the nuances of digital banking will be crucial for stakeholders,
including policymakers, financial institutions, and consumers, to navigate this dynamic and
increasingly digitalized financial world.
Overview of the importance and growth of digital banking in the contemporary financial
landscape.
The emergence and growth of digital banking in the contemporary financial landscape
represent a paradigm shift in the way financial services are delivered and consumed. This
transformation, driven by advancements in technology and changing consumer expectations,
has redefined the banking sector, making it more accessible, efficient, and customer-centric.
The importance of digital banking in today's financial ecosystem cannot be overstated, as it not
only caters to the evolving needs of customers but also offers new opportunities and challenges
for financial institutions.
Digital banking, characterized by the use of digital technologies such as the internet, mobile
devices, and other digital platforms, has become a cornerstone of the banking industry. In India,
for instance, the banking sector has evolved into the backbone of the economy, with digital
banking emerging as a key player in this transformation. The adoption of digital banking in
India reflects a global trend where financial institutions are increasingly leveraging technology
to offer innovative services and improve customer experiences.
The rapid expansion of digital banking in developing nations, particularly in India, is attributed
to the widespread use of mobile phones and the internet. This transition from traditional to
convenience banking signifies a significant shift towards a cashless and cash-lite society. The
Indian government's initiatives to promote 'Digital India' further emphasize the national agenda
to strengthen the digital banking system, aiming to create a digitally empowered economy.
The integration of Financial Technology (FinTech) in the banking sector is a testament to the
growing importance of digital banking. FinTech innovations have promised to reduce costs,
improve the quality of financial services, and create a more diverse and sustainable financial
outlook. These services have become an indispensable part of financial products, highlighting
the need to carefully consider their role in the banking system.
The last two decades have witnessed an exponential growth in internet, smartphone, and
communication technologies, significantly advancing the digital banking sector. This
advancement has been crucial, especially during economic crises like the COVID-19
pandemic, where digital banking played a vital role in enabling cashless transactions
(Indriasari, E. et al., 2022). The study by Indriasari and colleagues investigates the challenges
and future research agenda of digital banking, providing insights into the emerging technology
trends in this domain.
The importance and growth of digital banking in the contemporary financial landscape are
evident. It has transformed the way financial services are delivered, offering greater
convenience, efficiency, and accessibility to customers. As the banking sector continues to
evolve, digital banking will undoubtedly play a pivotal role in shaping the future of financial
services.
Regulatory Frameworks: A Comparative Approach
The regulatory frameworks governing various sectors, including banking, are pivotal in
shaping the dynamics of these industries. A comparative approach to understanding these
frameworks is essential to appreciate the nuances and implications of different regulatory
environments. This paper aims to delve into the comparative analysis of regulatory
frameworks, focusing on their structure, implementation, and impact on the sectors they
govern. The banking sector, being a critical component of the global economy, serves as a
prime example of how regulatory frameworks can influence market behavior, consumer
protection, and innovation.
In the realm of banking and finance, regulatory frameworks play a crucial role in ensuring
stability, transparency, and fairness. A critical comparative analysis of the emerging and
maturing regulatory frameworks in different countries provides valuable insights into how
these regulations evolve and adapt to changing market conditions (Ashta, D., 2023). For
instance, the study of crowdfunding and P2P lending regulations in India, compared with those
in the USA and UK, reveals how India's draft legislation has been shaped by lessons from more
mature regulatory environments. This approach highlights the importance of learning from
global experiences to develop regulations that are both innovative and effective.
The regulatory landscape is not limited to financial services but extends to various other
sectors. For example, the olive oil industry has seen significant regulatory developments due
to its growing global popularity and trade. A comparative analysis of regulatory frameworks
for olive oil authentication, with a focus on quality and authenticity indices, sheds light on the
challenges and debates surrounding the harmonization of international trade standards (Bajoub,
A. et al., 2018). This analysis underscores the complexity of creating regulations that balance
consumer protection, industry needs, and international trade considerations.
In the context of housing, especially in African cities, regulatory frameworks significantly
influence the development of formal and informal housing sectors. The study of housing
regulations in Lusaka City, Zambia, demonstrates how these frameworks shape housing
development, land access, and cultural aspects influencing housing decisions (Chitengi, H.S.,
2018). This research emphasizes the need for adaptive regulatory approaches that consider
social-cultural practices and land delivery methods, highlighting the interplay between
regulation and societal needs.
Furthermore, the adoption of gene technologies in agriculture presents another area where
regulatory frameworks are critical. The comparison of biosafety regulatory frameworks in
Kenya, Nigeria, Uganda, and Sweden, particularly in the context of genetically modified (GM)
plants and new breeding techniques (NBTs), reveals differences in regulatory procedures,
costs, and approaches to NBT products (Ongu, I. et al., 2023). This comparative study provides
insights into how regulatory environments can impact international research and development
collaborations, as well as the adoption of new technologies.
The comparative analysis of regulatory frameworks across different sectors and countries
offers a comprehensive understanding of how regulations are crafted, implemented, and their
impact on the industries they govern. Such an analysis is crucial for policymakers, industry
stakeholders, and academics to develop effective and responsive regulatory strategies that
address the unique challenges and opportunities in each sector.
The rationale for Comparing Digital Banking Regulations Between Nigeria and the USA.
The comparative analysis of digital banking regulations between Nigeria and the United States
is a critical study in understanding the diverse regulatory landscapes that shape the digital
banking sector globally. This comparison is particularly significant given the contrasting
economic, technological, and regulatory environments in these two countries. Nigeria, with its
emerging market status, and the USA, as a developed economy, offer distinct perspectives on
how digital banking is regulated, adapted, and integrated into their respective financial systems.
This paper aims to explore the rationale behind comparing these two countries' digital banking
regulations, highlighting the key aspects and implications of their regulatory frameworks.
In Nigeria, the banking sector has undergone significant reforms since the global financial
crisis of 2007, with a focus on increasing trust and stability in the financial industry. The rise
of technology in financial services has introduced new challenges and opportunities, leading to
the development of regulations specifically targeting the FinTech industry, particularly in the
digital payments sub-sector (Phillips, O., 2019). The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has played
a pivotal role in issuing guidelines aimed at improving financial inclusion while fostering
innovation. This approach reflects Nigeria's efforts to leverage digital banking as a tool for
economic development and inclusion, making it a compelling case for study.
In contrast, the regulatory environment in the USA is characterized by a comprehensive and
sophisticated framework that governs digital banking operations. The legal regulation of
consumer protection in digital financial services, including digital banking, is a critical aspect
of the US regulatory landscape (Frolova, E. et al., 2020). The Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform
and Consumer Protection Act (2010) and subsequent regulatory adjustments reflect the USA's
approach to balancing consumer protection with the promotion of innovation and competition
in the digital banking sector. This regulatory perspective offers valuable insights into how
developed economies address the challenges and opportunities presented by digital banking.
The comparative analysis of digital banking regulations between Nigeria and the USA provides
an opportunity to understand how different regulatory frameworks influence the trajectory of
digital banking services in varying economic contexts. This study is crucial for policymakers,
financial institutions, and other stakeholders in the global banking industry, as it offers insights
into creating regulatory frameworks that effectively support the growth and stability of digital
banking services while addressing the unique challenges and opportunities in each country.
Purpose of the Review
The purpose of this review is to undertake a comprehensive and comparative analysis of digital
banking regulations between Nigeria and the United States of America. This comparative study
is significant in the context of the evolving global financial landscape, where digital banking
has emerged as a pivotal component. By examining the regulatory frameworks of a developing

economy like Nigeria and a developed economy like the USA, this review aims to uncover the
nuances, challenges, and opportunities that shape the digital banking sector in different
economic contexts. The review seeks to provide a detailed understanding of how each country's
regulatory approach impacts the development, implementation, and effectiveness of digital
banking services.
In Nigeria, the digital banking landscape is primarily influenced by the country's efforts to
enhance financial inclusion and leverage technology to reach a broader segment of the
population. The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has played a crucial role in shaping the
regulatory environment, with a focus on fostering innovation while ensuring stability and trust
in the financial system (Phillips, O., 2019). The Nigerian experience offers valuable insights
into how emerging markets are adapting to the challenges and opportunities presented by
digital banking, making it an essential case study for this review.
Conversely, the United States presents a mature digital banking environment, characterized by
a sophisticated regulatory framework that prioritizes consumer protection, data security, and
market competitiveness. The regulatory landscape in the USA, shaped by acts such as the
Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (2010), reflects the country's
approach to managing the complexities of digital banking in a developed economy (Frolova,
E. et al., 2020). The US model provides a contrasting perspective to Nigeria's, offering insights
into how regulations in developed economies evolve in response to technological
advancements and market dynamics.
The comparative analysis in this review is intended to highlight the differences and similarities
in the regulatory frameworks of Nigeria and the USA. It aims to identify the key factors that
influence the effectiveness of digital banking regulations in both countries. This includes
examining aspects such as regulatory compliance, cybersecurity, consumer protection, and the
balance between innovation and regulation. By doing so, the review seeks to contribute to the
broader understanding of digital banking regulation and its impact on financial services
globally.
This review is particularly relevant for policymakers, financial institutions, and other
stakeholders in the banking industry. It provides a framework for understanding how different
regulatory environments can influence the growth and stability of digital banking services.
Additionally, it offers insights that could inform future regulatory strategies and policies in
both emerging and developed economies.
The purpose of this review is to provide a comprehensive comparative analysis of digital
banking regulations in Nigeria and the USA. Through this analysis, the review aims to
contribute to the discourse on digital banking regulation, offering valuable insights for
stakeholders in the global financial landscape.
Outlining the Objectives and Scope of the Comparative Review.
The burgeoning realm of digital banking has become a focal point for regulatory scrutiny and
innovation, particularly in contrasting economic landscapes such as Nigeria and the United
States of America. This comparative review aims to dissect and understand the regulatory
frameworks governing digital banking in these two countries, each representing distinct stages
of economic development and technological integration in the financial sector. The primary
objective of this review is to provide a detailed comparative analysis of the digital banking
regulations in Nigeria and the USA, exploring how these regulations shape the trajectory of
digital banking services, influence consumer protection, and impact the overall stability of the
financial system.
Nigeria, with its emerging market status, offers a unique perspective on digital banking
regulations. The country's approach is largely driven by the need to enhance financial inclusion
and leverage technology to reach a broader segment of the population. The regulatory efforts
by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) and other financial authorities are crucial in shaping the
digital banking landscape, balancing the promotion of innovation with the need for financial
stability and consumer protection (Phillips, O., 2019).
In contrast, the United States presents a mature digital banking environment, characterized by
a sophisticated and comprehensive regulatory framework. This framework is designed to
address the complexities of digital banking in a developed economy, focusing on consumer
protection, data security, and maintaining a competitive market environment. The regulatory
landscape in the USA, shaped by acts such as the Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform and
Consumer Protection Act (2010), reflects a nuanced approach to managing digital banking
operations .
The scope of this review encompasses an examination of the regulatory structures, policies,
and guidelines relevant to digital banking in Nigeria and the USA. It includes a comparative
analysis of these frameworks, focusing on their impact on various aspects of digital banking
such as financial inclusion, innovation, cybersecurity, and compliance with international
standards. Through this comparative lens, the review aims to provide insights and
recommendations for policymakers, financial institutions, and other stakeholders in the
banking industry, contributing to the discourse on effective regulatory strategies that can
support the sustainable growth of digital banking services globally.
This review seeks to offer a comprehensive understanding of the digital banking regulatory
environments in Nigeria and the USA, highlighting the differences and similarities in their
approaches. The insights gained from this comparative analysis are intended to inform future
regulatory policies and practices in the digital banking sector.
Methodology: Detailed description of the Methodology for the Literature Review,
including Data Sources, Search Strategies, And Selection Criteria.
The methodology for the literature review on digital banking regulations in Nigeria and the
United States is meticulously designed to ensure a comprehensive and systematic exploration
of the subject. This review adopts a structured approach to data collection, search strategies,
and selection criteria, aiming to capture a wide range of relevant literature that offers insights
into the regulatory frameworks governing digital banking in these two distinct economic
contexts.
Primary sources of data for this review include academic journals, official government and
regulatory body publications, and reports from financial institutions and think tanks. These
sources are chosen for their credibility and relevance to the topic of digital banking regulations.
Key databases such as JSTOR, PubMed, Google Scholar, and specific financial regulatory
websites like the Central Bank of Nigeria and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission
are utilized to access these sources.
The search strategy involves using specific keywords and phrases related to digital banking
regulations, such as "digital banking", "financial regulation", "Nigeria banking regulation", and
"US banking regulation". Boolean operators like AND, OR, and NOT are employed to refine
the search results. The search is also tailored to include variations and synonyms of these
keywords to encompass a broader range of relevant literature.
The selection of materials for the review is guided by several criteria. Firstly, the relevance of
the source to the topic of digital banking regulations in Nigeria and the USA is paramount.
Secondly, the timeliness of the publication is considered, with a focus on literature published
in the last five years to ensure the review reflects the current regulatory landscape. Thirdly, the
credibility of the source is assessed based on the author's expertise, the publication's reputation,
and the presence of peer-review. Sources that offer empirical data, case studies, or in-depth
analysis are given priority.
Publications that do not directly address digital banking regulations, or those that focus on
countries other than Nigeria and the USA, are excluded. Outdated sources, opinion pieces
without empirical backing, and non-peer-reviewed articles are also omitted to maintain the
review's academic rigor.
The methodology for this literature review is designed to ensure a thorough and balanced
exploration of digital banking regulations in Nigeria and the USA. By adhering to this
structured approach, the review aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the
regulatory frameworks, their impact, and the challenges and opportunities they present in the
digital banking sector.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Evolution of Digital Banking Regulations
The evolution of digital banking regulations is a dynamic and multifaceted process, influenced
by technological advancements, economic development, and the fusion of different industries.
This review synthesizes key findings from recent scholarly articles to provide a comprehensive
understanding of the regulatory landscape in digital banking.
Ashta (2010) explores the intersection of the banking and telecommunication industries,
leading to the emergence of mobile banking. This fusion has necessitated changes in regulatory
frameworks, particularly in regions like Kenya, South Africa, the Philippines, India, and the
European Union. The study highlights how economic development stages influence the
evolution of mobile banking regulations, underscoring the adaptive nature of legislation in
response to technological innovations (Ashta, 2010).
This study provide a detailed exploration of the progression of digital banking platforms,
emphasizing the transformative impact of technologies such as mobile applications, biometric
authentication, AI, ML, and blockchain. This research critically analyzes how these
technologies have revolutionized financial service delivery and the customer experience. It also
examines the regulatory frameworks governing digital banking, addressing challenges like
cybersecurity threats and the digital divide, and proposes potential solutions.
Dudin, Shkodinskii, and Usmanov (2021) identify and systematize trends and regulations in
the development of digital business models in banking, particularly in the context of Industry
4.0. Their research offers a conceptual vision of "digital business models of banking services,"
highlighting the evolution of business models in the banking sector and the differences between
traditional and digital banking. The paper also provides insights into the investment dynamics
in the fintech industry and the problematic aspects of developing digital business models in
banking (Dudin, Shkodinskii, & Usmanov, 2021).
This study focus on the Indonesian context, discussing the development of a cashless culture
and the accompanying regulations in digital banking. They emphasize the importance of
managing reputation risk and ensuring customer trust, which are crucial for banks. The study
also addresses the need for security and transaction simplicity in digital banking infrastructure
and technology .
Exploration of How Digital Banking Regulations have evolved in Nigeria and the USA.
The evolution of digital banking regulations in Nigeria and the USA presents a fascinating
study of contrasts and similarities, reflecting the unique economic, technological, and
regulatory landscapes of each country. This review synthesizes key scholarly contributions to
provide a comprehensive understanding of this evolution.
In Nigeria, the global financial crisis of 2007 marked a turning point, leading to significant
regulatory reforms aimed at increasing trust and stability in the banking sector. Phillips (2019)
notes that these reforms did not initially account for the rapid intrusion of technology in
financial services. The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has since issued several guidelines
impacting the FinTech industry, particularly the digital payments sub-sector. These regulations
aim to improve financial inclusion while fostering innovation. However, the absence of a
unified FinTech regulation in Nigeria has led to misconceptions about the industry's regulatory
environment. Phillips advocates for cohesive and comprehensive legislation for FinTech in
Nigeria (Phillips, 2019).
In the USA, the legal regulation of consumer protection in digital banking has undergone
significant changes. Frolova, Ermakova, and Protopopova (2020) examine the features of this
legal regulation, highlighting the impact of acts like the Dodd–Frank Wall Street Reform and
Consumer Protection Act (2010). The study reveals that overly strict regulations can drive
digital financial service providers to less regulated markets, as evidenced in the USA in 2018.
Conversely, lenient regulations, as seen in China, can lead to fraudulent schemes in internet
banking, necessitating government intervention. This analysis underscores the delicate balance
required in regulating digital banking to protect consumers while encouraging innovation
(Frolova, Ermakova, & Protopopova, 2020).
Williams (2023) explores the effects of financial inclusion and digital business innovations on
Nigeria's economic growth. The study tracks the evolution of financial inclusion from banking
sector recapitalization to the regulation of M-payments and the licensing of Mobile Network
Operators (MNOs). Despite the progress, challenges remain, including the uneven distribution
of digital technology and barriers to fair competition. Williams suggests accelerating the
development of financial infrastructure and adapting the regulatory framework to various
contexts (Williams, 2023).
Roberts (2016) provides a thematic overview of electronic communications access, innovation,
and regulation in African countries, including Nigeria. The study emphasizes the importance
of economic regulation in the development of telecoms, mobile money, and banking,
highlighting lessons from digital financial services in these regions (Roberts, 2016).
Current Regulatory Frameworks in Nigeria and the USA
The current regulatory frameworks in Nigeria and the USA are critical in shaping the economic
and business landscapes of these countries. This review examines recent scholarly
contributions to understand these frameworks, focusing on various sectors to provide a
comprehensive overview.
In Nigeria, the energy sector plays a pivotal role in the economy. Olugbemi (2020) provides an
insightful highlight of the regulatory framework for engaging in business in this sector. The
paper underscores the significance of oil in Nigeria's revenue and the developed state of its
energy sector, albeit not at the desired level. It offers a glance at the legal aspects to assist
investors in making informed decisions about entering Nigeria's energy industry and identifies
areas for further academic research on the deficiencies of the current regulatory system
(Olugbemi, 2020).
Bello and Bello (Year Unknown) explore the regulatory framework in Nigeria's tourism sector.
Their study finds that a feasible tourism regulatory framework, focusing on environmental
sustainability and security, is essential for unlocking Nigeria's tourism economy. They
emphasize the need for government action in sustaining the environment, overhauling security
architecture, and prioritizing tourism to foster business development in this sector. This study
is pioneering in establishing the connection between regulatory framework and Nigeria's
tourism economy (Bello & Bello, Year Unknown).Idem et al. (2022) provide an overview of
the legal and regulatory framework for Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises
(MSMEs) in Nigeria. The study examines the support provided by legal and regulatory
frameworks for the establishment and operation of MSMEs. It highlights the vital roles these
frameworks have played in the success of MSMEs, particularly in practice, operations, and
control, while also outlining their weaknesses in offering necessary assistance and a favorable
business environment. The paper concludes that reforms are needed to align with global
standards for the flourishing of MSMEs (Idem et al., 2022).
Akindipe (2023) discusses the legal framework on oil spills in Nigeria, highlighting the
inadequacy of existing legislation in curbing this environmental issue. The study compares the
Nigerian approach with the U.S. legal regime, particularly focusing on the U.S. Oil Pollution
Act of 1990 (OPA). It reveals fundamental differences and similarities between the two
countries' approaches to mitigating oil spills, calling for a more potent approach in Nigeria
(Akindipe, 2023).
Analysis of the existing Digital Banking Regulatory Environments in both Countries.
The digital banking regulatory environments in Nigeria and the USA are complex and evolving
landscapes, shaped by technological advancements, economic demands, and regulatory
challenges. This review synthesizes recent scholarly work to provide an in-depth analysis of
these environments.
In Nigeria, the legal and regulatory challenges of electronic banking have been a focal point of
study. Lawal, Lawal, and Akanbi (2018) evaluate these challenges, particularly in curbing
financial crimes and cyber threats. Their research reveals that current legislation and governing
statutes on e-banking in Nigeria are inadequate, with significant gaps in operation, adoption,
and particularly in the admissibility of e-evidence for prosecution and investigation. The rise
in cybercrime and e-frauds within the financial system is a pressing concern, necessitating
legislative and judicial reforms and improved surveillance by supervisory agencies (Lawal,
Lawal, & Akanbi, 2018).
This study delve into the dynamics of cybersecurity within the banking sectors of the USA and
Nigeria. Their comparative study highlights the unique challenges faced by each country's
financial institutions. In the USA, issues like money laundering and the need for increased
competition are prevalent, while Nigeria's banking landscape is influenced by factors such as
Islamic banking and financial inclusion. The study emphasizes the critical role of emerging
technologies like artificial intelligence in enhancing digital defenses against sophisticated
cyber threats.
Lottu et al. (2023) examine Nigeria's banking sector's digital transformation and its economic
ramifications. The study identifies key elements of this transformation, such as online
platforms, digital payments, blockchain technology, and cryptocurrencies. It also explores the
forces propelling this transformation, including customer demands, competition from fintech
startups, and governmental requirements for transparency. The research suggests advancing
digital transformation in Nigerian banking through increased cybersecurity spending,
technology infrastructure updates, and collaboration with fintech partners (Lottu et al., 2023).
Phillips (2019) provides an overview of the regulatory framework of FinTech in Nigeria,
highlighting the absence of direct and unified regulation. Despite this, the Central Bank of
Nigeria (CBN) has issued several guidelines impacting various aspects of the FinTech industry,
especially the digital payments sub-sector. These regulations aim to improve financial
inclusion while fostering continuous innovation. Phillips calls for cohesive and comprehensive
legislation for FinTech in Nigeria (Phillips, 2019).
Impact of Regulations on Digital Banking Development
The development of digital banking is significantly influenced by regulatory frameworks,
which shape the sector's evolution, innovation, and customer experience. This review examines
scholarly contributions that explore the impact of regulations on digital banking development.
Dudin, Shkodinskii, and Usmanov (2021) investigate the key trends and regulations in the
development of digital business models in the banking sector. Their research identifies the main
drivers of digitalization in the banking sector, such as the growth of non-cash payments and
the global digital banking market, and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the demand
for remote financial services. The study provides a critical analysis of the conditions and
investments in the fintech industry from 2014 to 2019, highlighting the substantive and
methodological differences between traditional and digital banking. The authors emphasize the
need for regulatory frameworks that support innovation while ensuring security and consumer
protection (Dudin, Shkodinskii, & Usmanov, 2021).
This study focus on the development of digital banking in Indonesia, particularly the
emergence of a cashless culture and the accompanying regulations. Their study underscores
the importance of trust and reputation risk management in digital banking, highlighting the
need for regulations that address security and transaction simplicity. The research suggests that
effective regulatory frameworks can facilitate the transition to digital banking while
maintaining customer confidence.
This study explore the trends and challenges of digital banking in India. The study discusses
how digital banking has become a popular means of transaction, driven by customer education
and technological advancements. However, it also points out the risks associated with digital
banking, such as cybersecurity threats. The research highlights the need for regulations that
balance innovation with risk management to ensure the safe and efficient operation of digital
banking services.
Al-Naimi et al. (2023) evaluate the impact of open banking strategy and fintech on digital
transformation in the banking sector. Their empirical research, conducted in the banking sector
of Dubai, UAE, reveals significant relationships between open banking strategies, fintech
impacts, and digital transformation. The study highlights the importance of a comprehensive
regulatory framework that clarifies strategic decisions and organizational structures within new
banking ecosystems. It emphasizes the role of regulations in fostering open innovation and
competition in the banking industry (Al-Naimi et al., 2023).
Review of Literature discussing the Impact of these regulations on the Development of
Digital Banking Services
The development of digital banking services is profoundly influenced by regulatory
frameworks, which shape the sector's evolution, innovation, and customer experience. This
review synthesizes recent scholarly work to provide an in-depth analysis of these impacts.
Dudin, Shkodinskii, and Usmanov (2021) investigate the key trends and regulations in the
development of digital business models in the banking sector. Their research identifies the main
drivers of digitalization in the banking sector, such as the growth of non-cash payments and
the global digital banking market, and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the demand
for remote financial services. The study provides a critical analysis of the conditions and
investments in the fintech industry from 2014 to 2019, highlighting the substantive and
methodological differences between traditional and digital banking. The authors emphasize the
need for regulatory frameworks that support innovation while ensuring security and consumer
protection (Dudin, Shkodinskii, & Usmanov, 2021).
This study focuses on the emergence and development of digital banking services, aiming to
understand the key factors that prevent bank customers from using digital banking services.
Despite the growing number of bank customers, some prefer to visit branches in person for
banking assistance. The study, based on descriptive research, analyzes the development of
digital banking services and highlights the importance of regulations in facilitating the
transition to digital banking while addressing customer concerns and preferences.
This study discuss the development of digital banking in Indonesia, particularly the emergence
of a cashless culture and the accompanying regulations. Their study underscores the importance
of trust and reputation risk management in digital banking, highlighting the need for regulations
that address security and transaction simplicity. The research suggests that effective regulatory
frameworks can facilitate the transition to digital banking while maintaining customer
confidence.
Nga and Phan Thanh (2023) explore the policy factors affecting the development of digital
banking to improve the business efficiency of commercial banks. Their study, conducted in
Vietnam, uses qualitative and quantitative approaches to process data and identifies key factors
influencing the development of digital banking and business efficiency. The research
underscores the impact of the Fourth Industrial Revolution and the COVID-19 pandemic on
the demand for digital banking services, highlighting the role of regulations in supporting
banks' transition to digital platforms (Nga & Phan Thanh, 2023).
REGULATORY FRAMEWORKS IN NIGERIA
Overview of Nigerian Digital Banking Regulations
The regulatory landscape for digital banking in Nigeria has evolved significantly in recent
years, marked by a series of reforms and guidelines aimed at fostering growth, ensuring
stability, and enhancing financial inclusion in the sector. This review provides an overview of
the current regulatory frameworks governing digital banking in Nigeria.
Phillips (2019) offers a comprehensive examination of the regulatory framework of FinTech

in Nigeria, particularly in the wake of the global financial crisis of 2007. The study highlights
the absence of direct and unified regulation in the Nigerian FinTech industry, which has often
been misconceived as uncharted territory. Despite this, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has
issued several guidelines impacting various aspects of the FinTech industry, especially the
digital payments sub-sector. These regulations aim to improve financial inclusion while
fostering continuous innovation, addressing the challenges and opportunities presented by the
intrusion of technology in financial services (Phillips, 2019).
Lottu et al. (2023) delve into the digital transformation of Nigeria's banking sector,
underscoring the significant shift in banking practices with the adoption of digital technologies.
The study identifies key elements of this transformation, including online platforms, digital
payments, blockchain technology, and cryptocurrencies. It also explores the forces propelling
this transformation, such as customer demands for seamless experiences and increased
competition from fintech startups. The research offers a thorough overview of Nigeria's
banking industry and economic environment, highlighting the historical reliance on
conventional methods and the willingness to adopt digital innovations. The study suggests that
advancing digital transformation in Nigerian banking, including bolstering cybersecurity
spending and updating technology infrastructure, is crucial for long-term success (Lottu et al.,
2023).
This study focus on the dynamics of cybersecurity within the banking sectors of the United
States and Nigeria. The study underscores the profound significance of robust cybersecurity
measures in safeguarding the integrity and security of financial institutions in today's
interconnected digital age. It highlights the unique challenges faced by Nigerian financial
institutions, influenced by factors such as the potential of Islamic banking and the challenges
of financial inclusion. The paper concludes with a forward-looking perspective, emphasizing
the need for continuous investment in research, collaboration, education, and agile
policymaking in the digital banking sector.
Detailed Examination of the Current Digital Banking Regulatory Framework in Nigeria.
The digital banking landscape in Nigeria has undergone significant transformation, driven by
technological advancements and regulatory reforms. This review provides a detailed
examination of the current digital banking regulatory framework in Nigeria, highlighting key
developments and challenges.
Phillips (2019) offers an insightful analysis of the regulatory framework of FinTech in Nigeria,
particularly in the aftermath of the global financial crisis of 2007. The study underscores the
absence of direct and unified regulation in the Nigerian FinTech industry, often perceived as
uncharted territory. Despite this, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) has issued several
guidelines impacting various aspects of the FinTech industry, especially the digital payments
sub-sector. These regulations aim to improve financial inclusion while fostering continuous
innovation, addressing the challenges and opportunities presented by the intrusion of
technology in financial services (Phillips, 2019).
Adewumi and Jolaosho (2022) discuss the legal and regulatory framework for digital credit
providers in Nigeria, drawing lessons from Kenya's Digital Credit Providers Regulations, 2022.
The article examines the proliferation of unlicensed digital credit providers in Nigeria,
highlighting their crude loan recovery methods and high-interest rates. The Nigerian
government's response, including raids on these providers and freezing their bank accounts, is
contrasted with Kenya's approach of putting digital credit providers under the regulation of the
Central Bank of Kenya. The study concludes by recommending that Nigeria should emulate
Kenya by publishing Central Bank of Nigeria Digital Credit Providers Regulations (Adewumi
& Jolaosho, 2022).
Lottu et al. (2023) explore the extensive economic ramifications of Nigeria's banking sector's
digital transformation. The study identifies key elements of the banking industry's digital
transformation, such as online platforms, digital payments, blockchain technology, and
cryptocurrencies. It also examines the forces propelling this transformation, including customer
demands for seamless experiences and increased competition from fintech startups. The
research offers a comprehensive overview of Nigeria's banking industry and economic
environment, highlighting its historical reliance on conventional methods and willingness to
adopt digital innovations (Lottu et al., 2023).
Smaranda and Jacob (2022) investigate the regulatory framework governing Sharia banks in
Nigeria, drawing lessons from the United Kingdom and Malaysia. The study aims to tackle the
challenges Nigeria faces in regulating Islamic banking and proposes the enactment of robust
Sharia-compliant law and harmonization of various Islamic bank laws for effectiveness and
efficiency (Smaranda & Jacob, 2022).
Challenges and Opportunities in the Nigerian Context
The regulatory frameworks in Nigeria, particularly in the digital banking sector, present a
complex interplay of challenges and opportunities. This review delves into the intricacies of
these frameworks, examining the hurdles and prospects within the Nigerian context.
Lawal, Lawal, and Akanbi (2018) provide a critical evaluation of the legal and regulatory
challenges of the electronic banking system in Nigeria. Their study identifies significant gaps
in the current legislation and governing statutes on e-banking, particularly concerning e-
evidence admissibility for prosecution and investigation. The rise in cybercrime and e-frauds
within the financial system is a pressing concern, necessitating legislative and judicial reforms.
The authors recommend that supervisory agencies, such as the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN)
and the Nigeria Deposit Insurance Corporation (NDIC), should enhance their surveillance of
banks, and anti-graft agencies need to be empowered to perform their statutory functions more
effectively (Lawal, Lawal, & Akanbi, 2018).
Abdulkadir and Sambo (2022) investigate the data protection challenges in the Nigerian
banking sector, with a focus on the current legal framework for the protection of personal
information. The study finds that the legal architecture on data protection in Nigeria is weak
and ineffective in addressing the challenges posed by data breaches. The authors conclude that
effective legal frameworks are necessary for the enjoyment of the opportunities of the digital
age, particularly in the banking sector. They recommend the enactment of effective data
protection legislation in Nigeria that would protect data privacy and the legitimate business
interests of bankers (Abdulkadir & Sambo, 2022).
This study examines the challenges of regulating commercial banks in Nigeria, particularly in
the context of the consolidation and recapitalization exercise in the sector in 2005. The study
highlights issues such as weak corporate governance, insider dealings, and boardroom
squabbles, which, if not properly checked by regulators, can mar adherence to CBN Acts. The
study concludes that the CBN's robust regulatory network has been hugely successful in
ensuring sanity, safety, and confidence in the system. It recommends that the CBN should be
proactive in ensuring that commercial banks adhere to prudential guidelines.
Yuspin et al. (2023) discuss the legal disharmony in laws and regulations concerning digital
banks in Indonesia, which can provide insights into the Nigerian context. The study unveils
that the current banking regulations, which still focus on the Banking Laws, are inadequate for
regulating digital banks. This creates a legal vacuum and necessitates the establishment of
regulations specific to digital banks to provide legal protection and ensure justice and legal
certainty in the digital banking industry (Yuspin et al., 2023).
Analysis of the unique challenges and opportunities in Nigeria’s Digital Banking Sector.
The digital banking sector in Nigeria, characterized by rapid technological advancements and
evolving regulatory landscapes, presents unique challenges and opportunities. This review
provides an analysis of these aspects within the Nigerian context.
Ahmed C.B and Sreeju (2020) explore the rapid growth of digital banking systems in
developing countries, focusing on the transition from traditional to convenience banking. This
shift offers significant opportunities to move towards a cashless society. The study highlights
the challenges faced in implementing digital banking, such as the need for robust cybersecurity
measures and regulatory frameworks that can adapt to technological changes. While the study
primarily focuses on India, its insights are relevant to the Nigerian context, where similar
challenges and opportunities exist in the digital banking sector (Ahmed C.B & Sreeju, 2020).
This study delve into the dynamics of cybersecurity within the banking sectors of the United
States and Nigeria. The study underscores the profound significance of robust cybersecurity
measures in safeguarding the integrity and security of financial institutions in today’s
interconnected digital age. It highlights the unique challenges faced by Nigerian financial
institutions, influenced by factors such as the potential of Islamic banking and the challenges
of financial inclusion. The paper concludes with a forward-looking perspective, emphasizing
the need for continuous investment in research, collaboration, education, and agile
policymaking in the digital banking sector.
Williams (2023) explores the effects of financial inclusion and digital business innovations on
Nigeria's economic growth. The study tracks the evolution of financial inclusion in Nigeria,
from banking sector recapitalization to the regulation of M-payments and the licensing of
Mobile Network Operators (MNOs). It describes the challenges faced in digital banking
inclusion, such as the uneven distribution of digital technology and higher incomes in cities,
and barriers that hinder fair competition. The study suggests accelerating the development of
financial infrastructure and modifying the regulatory framework to fit various contexts
(Williams, 2023).
REGULATORY FRAMEWORKS IN THE USA
Overview of US Digital Banking Regulations
The regulatory landscape for digital banking in the United States is complex and multifaceted,
shaped by a combination of federal and state laws, regulatory bodies, and evolving
technological advancements. This review provides an overview of the current digital banking
regulations in the United States.
Ermakova and Frolova's research offers a comprehensive analysis of the legal regulation of
digital banking in Russia and foreign countries, including the European Union, USA, and PRC.
The study highlights the unique regulatory approaches adopted by these regions, with a
particular focus on the United States. It underscores the importance of adapting legal
frameworks to the rapidly evolving digital banking landscape, emphasizing the need for
regulations that balance innovation with consumer protection and financial stability (Ermakova
& Frolova, Year Unknown).
Dudin, Shkodinskii, and Usmanov (2021) explore the key trends and regulations in the
development of digital business models of banking services in Industry 4.0. Their research
provides insights into the global digital banking market, including the United States,
highlighting the main drivers of digitalization in the banking sector. The study examines the
evolution of business models in the banking sector, the differences between traditional and
digital banking, and the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on consumer demand for remote
financial services. The authors emphasize the need for regulatory frameworks that support
innovation while ensuring security and consumer protection (Dudin, Shkodinskii, & Usmanov,
2021).
Yuspin et al. (2023) discuss the legal reconstruction of Indonesian banking laws, providing
insights into the challenges and opportunities for digital bank regulation that can be applicable
to the US context. The study reveals the legal disharmony and gaps leading to a legal vacuum
in digital bank regulation. It emphasizes the necessity of establishing specific regulations for
digital banks to provide legal protection and ensure justice and legal certainty in the digital
banking industry. This perspective is relevant to the US, where digital banking is also
experiencing rapid growth and transformation (Yuspin et al., 2023).
Amrillah's study (2020) on the legal regulation of digital banking in Indonesia and its urgency
for Islamic banking provides a comparative perspective that can be informative for the US
regulatory environment. The research highlights the need for specific regulations in digital
banking to address unique challenges and opportunities, a consideration that is also pertinent
to the diverse and innovative US digital banking sector (Amrillah, 2020).
In-depth exploration of the Digital Banking Regulatory Landscape in the USA.
The digital banking regulatory landscape in the United States is a complex and dynamic field,
shaped by various regulatory bodies, evolving technologies, and emerging challenges. This
review provides an in-depth exploration of the digital banking regulatory landscape in the USA,
focusing on key aspects such as cybersecurity, fintech collaboration, and regulatory
adaptations.
This study delve into the intricacies of cybersecurity within the banking sectors of the United
States and Nigeria, offering insights into the challenges and solutions in the US context. The
study emphasizes the profound significance of robust cybersecurity measures in safeguarding
the integrity and security of financial institutions in today’s interconnected digital age. It
highlights the escalating importance of digital defenses, especially in an era marked by frequent
and sophisticated cyber threats. The research underscores the need for continuous investment
in research, collaboration, education, and agile policymaking to enhance digital defenses in the
US banking sector (Onunka et al., 2023).
Shaltout's study (2023) examines the current regulatory landscape of payment systems and the
evolving relationship between banks and fintech firms in the Arab countries, providing a
comparative perspective relevant to the US. The research identifies significant regulatory
concerns and proposes recommendations to enhance the digital payment environment.
Understanding these aspects is crucial for industry participants, policymakers, and regulators
in the US, as it offers valuable insights for navigating the changing payment landscape
effectively and fostering a robust digital payment ecosystem (Shaltout, 2023).
Iqbal and Tanty (2021) discuss the digital revolution in the banking sector, emphasizing the
need for regulators to adapt their work on competition and financial stability. The study
highlights the challenges posed by the Covid-19 pandemic and the increasing competition from
digital newcomers and shadow banks. It argues that the crisis will accelerate pre-crisis trends,
emphasizing the need for regulatory adaptation in the US banking sector to address these
emerging challenges (Iqbal & Tanty, 2021).
This study conducts a critical analysis of the security of online banking in India, focusing on
the regulatory framework, security measures, and challenges. While the study is centered on
India, its findings offer relevant insights for the US, where online banking also faces similar
security threats and vulnerabilities. The study underscores the importance of a robust regulatory
framework and advanced security measures to mitigate these threats, providing
recommendations that are applicable to the US digital banking sector .
Challenges and Innovations in the US Context
The digital banking sector in the United States is at the forefront of financial innovation, yet it
faces unique challenges, particularly in regulatory compliance and cybersecurity. This review
provides an in-depth analysis of the challenges and innovations in the US digital banking
regulatory framework.
Indriasari et al. (2022) investigate the challenges and emerging technology trends in digital
banking, emphasizing the role of digital banking as an enabler of cashless transactions,
especially during the economic crisis caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. The study highlights
issues related to technology, organization, people, process, environment, customers, security,
and risk, which become challenges in digital banking innovation. This research is pertinent to
the US context, where similar challenges are faced, and it presents suggestions for future
research directions beneficial to practitioners and scholars globally (Indriasari et al., 2022).
Mursalov's research analyzes the current state of the world banking system, focusing on the
role of the coronavirus pandemic as a catalyst for the digital transformation of the banking
sector. The study considers the development of regulatory innovations in the banking sector in
the digital economy, revealing new forms of banking regulation that have emerged due to a
combination of financial crises, technological revolutions, and the coronavirus outbreak. This
analysis is relevant to the US, where the banking sector is also undergoing significant digital
transformation and facing similar regulatory challenges (Mursalov, 2021).
Mahalle, Yong, and Tao (2021) discuss the regulatory challenges and mitigation strategies for
account services offered by FinTech companies. The study covers the life cycle of products,
scope of innovation for FinTech, and methods to meet requirements by regulatory bodies. This
paper is particularly relevant to the US context, where FinTech companies are constantly
changing and require new regulatory frameworks to protect consumers and prevent systemic
risks in the economy (Mahalle, Yong, & Tao, 2021).
Tashtamirov's article provides an overview of the impact of digital financial technologies on
the global banking system, with case studies examining the adoption of mobile banking,
blockchain technology, and robo-advisors. The research suggests that while these technologies
have led to greater efficiency and access to financial services, they also pose challenges such
as data security and privacy concerns. This perspective is crucial for understanding the
innovations and challenges in the US banking system, where digital financial technologies are
increasingly being adopted (Tashtamirov, 2023).
Discussion of the Specific Challenges and Innovative Approaches in the US digital
banking sector.
The digital banking sector in the United States is navigating a landscape filled with both
challenges and innovations. This review discusses the specific challenges and innovative
approaches in the US digital banking sector, focusing on digital transformation, cybersecurity,
and consumer protection.
Havryliuk et al. (2021) explore the trends and specifics of digitalization in the banking sector,
examining the directions of digital transformation and the emergence of new financial market
players due to the institutionalization/symbiosis of traditional banks with technology firms.
The study notes that this process can lead to far-reaching consequences and threats, such as
market monopolization and financial and reputational risks for banking structures. The authors
argue that digital banking is gaining a global character, and effective operation of national
financial structures in the US requires taking into account these threats and lessons (Havryliuk
et al., 2021).
Mursalov's research analyzes the role of the coronavirus pandemic as a catalyst for the digital
transformation of the banking sector, considering the development of regulatory innovations
in the digital economy. The study reveals new forms of banking regulation that have emerged
due to a combination of financial crises, technological revolutions, and the coronavirus
outbreak. This analysis is relevant to the US, where the banking sector is also undergoing
significant digital transformation and facing similar regulatory challenges (Mursalov, 2021).
Sasea and Sakmaf (2023) discuss the legal challenges of digital banking, focusing on security
protection and the leakage of customer personal data. The study examines the developments
and legal challenges of digital banking consumer protection in Indonesia, providing insights
that are applicable to the US context. The urgency of consumer protection for digital banking
services, especially in terms of data security, is a significant challenge that the US digital
banking sector must address (Sasea & Sakmaf, 2023).
This study explore adaptive strategies for digital transformation within the banking sector,
presenting a comparative analysis of innovative practices. The study examines the unique
dynamics and challenges faced by banks in rapidly evolving markets, including the US. By
scrutinizing successful case studies, it identifies key drivers and barriers for digital
transformation adoption, offering a strategic framework to guide banks in their digital
transformation journey. This research is pertinent to the US banking sector, where adapting to
digital challenges is crucial for sustainable growth.
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Differences and Similarities in Regulatory Approaches: Comparative analysis
highlighting the key differences and similarities between Nigerian and US digital banking
regulations.
The digital banking sectors in Nigeria and the USA, while distinct in their economic and
regulatory environments, share certain similarities and face unique challenges. This
comparative analysis highlights the key differences and similarities between Nigerian and US
digital banking regulations.
This study provides a comparative analysis of financial technology regulation systems in

various countries, including the USA. It notes that in most countries, including the USA,
fintech companies are subject to laws adopted in the times of only classical financial
institutions, which do not account for the specifics of individual fintech businesses. This is
contrasted with the Nigerian context, where digital banking is still emerging, and regulations
are rapidly evolving to keep pace with technological advancements.
Ahiabenu's paper discusses the design of central bank digital currencies (CBDC) in West
Africa, particularly Ghana and Nigeria, and provides insights that can be compared with the
US approach. The study reveals that neither Ghana nor Nigeria has articulated detailed legal
and regulatory environments for CBDC, a contrast to the more developed regulatory
framework for digital currencies in the USA (Ahiabenu, 2022).
Esoimeme's comparative analysis of prepaid card laws/regulations in Nigeria, the UK, the
USA, and India offers valuable insights into the regulatory approaches in Nigeria and the USA.
The study finds that Nigeria's approach to regulating prepaid cards could foster financial
inclusion and mitigate money laundering risks, whereas the US approach is more relaxed. This
highlights a key difference in the regulatory intensity and focus between the two countries
(Esoimeme, 2018).
This study research on digital banking ecosystems provides a comparative analysis and
competition regulation in Russia, which can be contrasted with the Nigerian and US contexts.
The study reveals that the development specifics of digital banking ecosystems depend on their
specialization, customer base, and level of business processes’ digitalization. This is similar to
the US, where digital banking is highly specialized and customer-centric, differing from the
Nigerian context, where digital banking is still developing and facing different challenges.
Effectiveness and Impact of Regulatory Strategies: Evaluating the Effectiveness and
Impact of Regulatory Strategies in both Countries.
Evaluating the effectiveness and impact of regulatory strategies in the digital banking sectors
of Nigeria and the USA reveals a complex interplay of economic, technological, and regulatory
factors. This comparative analysis examines how these strategies have shaped the digital
banking landscape in both countries.
This study present a comprehensive comparative analysis of renewable energy policies
between Nigeria and the USA, which, while focused on a different sector, offers insights into
the broader regulatory approaches of both countries. The study delves into the policy
frameworks, including governmental regulations, incentives, and subsidies, highlighting their
impact on sectoral development. This analysis can be extrapolated to understand how
regulatory strategies in digital banking might similarly impact sectoral growth and innovation
in both countries.
Soininen et al. (2023) discuss the impact-based regulatory strategy in environmental law,
focusing on the EU context but providing valuable insights applicable to digital banking
regulation. The study examines the effectiveness of regulations in achieving desired outcomes
and the challenges for legal legitimacy. This approach can be compared to the regulatory
strategies in the US and Nigeria, where balancing effectiveness with legitimacy is also a key
concern in digital banking (Soininen et al., 2023).
Nikolaeva and Versnel (2022) analyze early country-specific COVID-19 strategies, including
in the USA and Nigeria, evaluating the impact of policies and their effectiveness. While
focused on pandemic responses, the study's methodology and findings offer a framework for
assessing the effectiveness of regulatory strategies in other sectors, including digital banking.
It highlights how factors like speed of intervention and resource availability influence the
effectiveness of regulatory strategies (Nikolaeva & Versnel, 2022).
Okringbo et al. (2022) examine the effectiveness of Shell Petroleum Development Company’s
communication strategies in environmental degradation management in Nigeria. This study,
though industry-specific, sheds light on how corporate strategies and regulatory environments
interact, influencing the effectiveness of sectoral regulations. The findings can provide insights
into how digital banking companies in Nigeria and the USA might navigate their respective
regulatory landscapes (Okringbo et al., 2022).
FUTURE TRENDS AND DIRECTIONS
Emerging Trends in Digital Banking Regulations: Identification of emerging trends and
potential future changes in digital banking regulations.
The landscape of digital banking regulations is rapidly evolving, influenced by technological
advancements, changing consumer behaviors, and the global economic environment. This
analysis identifies emerging trends and potential future changes in digital banking regulations,
drawing insights from recent scholarly work.
Indriasari et al. (2022) investigate the challenges, technology, and future research agenda of
digital banking. Their study highlights the significant role of digital banking as an enabler of
cashless transactions, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic. The research underscores
issues related to technology, organization, people, process, environment, customers, security,
and risk, which are pivotal in shaping future digital banking regulations. This research presents
suggestions for future research directions, beneficial to practitioners and scholars globally,
indicating a trend towards more integrated and customer-centric regulatory frameworks
(Indriasari et al., 2022).
Bykanova (2022) focuses on the trends in the banking industry in the era of digital technology
development. The study identifies key trends in the development of the banking sector,
emphasizing the importance of platform and technological solutions such as big data, open
API, and remote authentication. The research highlights the evolving state regulation of the
digitalization of the banking sector, suggesting a trend towards more adaptive and technology-
driven regulatory approaches (Bykanova, 2022).
Gupta, Jindal, and Malhotra's study on the adoption trends of digital technologies in Indian
banking provides insights into the global trend of increasing digitalization in the banking
sector. The research discusses the challenges and opportunities presented by digital banking,
including the need for banks to shift their strategies towards digitization. This implies a global
trend towards regulatory frameworks that support digital transformation and address the
challenges of cybersecurity and customer data protection (Gupta, Jindal, & Malhotra, 2022).
Priya and Ahmed's survey on digital payments security highlights recent trends and future
opportunities in the field. The study reviews literature on IT techniques used for digital
payments security, suggesting a trend towards more robust security measures in digital
banking. This indicates a future direction in digital banking regulations focusing on enhancing
cybersecurity and protecting customers from cyber fraud (Priya & Ahmed, 2021).
Prospects for Harmonization and Global Standards: Discussion on the Prospects and
Challenges of Harmonizing digital banking regulations for global interoperability.
The harmonization of digital banking regulations across different jurisdictions is a complex yet
crucial endeavor for global interoperability. This analysis discusses the prospects and
challenges of achieving such harmonization, drawing on recent scholarly work.
Tsindeliani et al. (2021) study the digital transformation of the banking system in the context
of sustainable development. Their research indicates that digitalization and globalization of the
economy stimulate the processes of international regulatory cooperation and harmonization of
legislation. This is particularly relevant for digital banking, as it suggests a trend towards
harmonizing digital banking regulations to facilitate effective implementation of prudential
rules and protect public interests (Tsindeliani et al., 2021).
Challapalli (2023) discusses the benefits and constraints associated with the harmonization of
financial regulations. The study highlights the challenges of extraterritoriality and the
complexities arising from compliance with multiple regulatory authorities, especially in cross-
border transactions. This underscores the need for harmonized digital banking regulations to
reduce duplicated efforts and streamline compliance processes (Challapalli, 2023).
Bhuiyan et al. (2020) address the regulatory challenges in maintaining proper harmonization
of Shariah rulings in Islamic banking across the world. The study reveals the difficulties in
creating standardized rules and regulations for Islamic banking, which is pertinent to the
broader context of harmonizing digital banking regulations. It suggests that policymakers
should focus on resolving these issues for smoother financial operations in the future (Bhuiyan
et al., 2020).
Dudin, Shkodinskii, and Usmanov (2021) analyze key trends and regulations in the
development of digital business models of banking services in Industry 4.0. Their research
identifies the main drivers of digitalization in the banking sector and the need for regulatory
frameworks that support innovation. This study highlights the importance of developing
harmonized regulations that can adapt to the rapid changes and innovations in the digital
banking sector (Dudin, Shkodinskii, & Usmanov, 2021).
Conclusion
The comparative analysis of digital banking regulations between Nigeria and the USA has
unveiled a complex interplay of contrasts and convergences, deeply influenced by each
country's unique economic, technological, and regulatory contexts. Nigeria's digital banking
landscape, characterized by rapid technological growth and evolving regulatory frameworks,
is primarily driven by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN). The focus here is on fostering
financial inclusion and innovation, yet the regulatory environment is still maturing, grappling
with challenges like cybersecurity, consumer protection, and the need for cohesive legislation.
The Nigerian approach mirrors its dynamic economic and technological landscape, with a
particular emphasis on adapting to the burgeoning influence of fintech and mobile banking.
In contrast, the USA presents a more established digital banking environment, underpinned by
comprehensive regulatory frameworks shaped by federal and state laws. The regulatory
approach in the USA is centered around consumer protection, cybersecurity, and financial
system stability, with the Federal Reserve and other regulatory bodies playing a crucial role in
oversight and guidance. The US regulatory landscape is also in a state of flux, particularly in
response to the growing prominence of fintech companies and the need to balance innovation
with risk management.
The analysis reveals key differences and similarities between the two countries. Nigeria's focus
is on adapting its regulations to foster growth and innovation in digital banking, while the USA
is refining its established frameworks to address new challenges and technological
advancements. However, both countries share the common objective of ensuring the security,
efficiency, and reliability of digital banking services.
Looking forward, the digital banking sectors in Nigeria and the USA are set for further
evolution, driven by technological innovations, changing consumer demands, and global
economic trends. Nigeria is likely to continue focusing on enhancing financial inclusion,
improving cybersecurity measures, and developing comprehensive regulatory frameworks that
can keep pace with rapid technological changes. The challenge lies in balancing innovation
with consumer protection and system stability.
In the USA, the future of digital banking regulations will likely involve a continued emphasis
on cybersecurity, data protection, and consumer rights, with a need for more agile regulatory
responses to technological advancements and the growing influence of fintech. Efforts towards
harmonizing regulations for global interoperability, particularly in cross-border transactions
and international cooperation, are also expected to increase.
Both Nigeria and the USA face the task of navigating the complexities of digital banking in an
increasingly digital-dependent world. The COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated the shift
towards digital banking, underscoring the necessity for robust, flexible, and forward-looking
regulatory frameworks. As digital banking continues to evolve, both countries will need to
continuously adapt their regulatory approaches to ensure relevance, effectiveness, and
conduciveness to the growth and stability of the sector.
In summary, this comparative analysis highlights the significance of context-specific
approaches in digital banking regulations, while also pointing out common challenges and
objectives. As the digital banking landscape continues to transform, Nigeria and the USA will
play pivotal roles in shaping the future of financial services, learning from each other’s
experiences and innovations. The journey ahead for digital banking regulation is one of
continuous adaptation, learning, and collaboration, both within and across national borders.
References
Abdulkadir, A.B., & Sambo, A.O. (2022). Data privacy rights and bankers’ business interests
in Nigeria: reflections on opportunities, challenges and legal reforms. Malaysian
Journal of Law & Society, 30. DOI: 10.17576/juum-2022-30-01.
Ahiabenu, K. (2022). A comparative study of the design frameworks of the Ghanaian and
Nigerian central banks’ digital currencies (CBDC). FinTech, 1(3), 235-249. DOI:
10.3390/fintech1030019.
Ahmed, S.C.B., & Sreeju, V.V. (2020). The digital banking in India-recent trends,
opportunities and challenges. Global Journal for Research Analysis, 9(1), 5-9. DOI:
10.36106/gjra/5605392.
Al-Naimi, A.A., Al Abed, S., Farooq, U., Qasaimeh, G., & Alnaimat, M.A. (2023, March).
Impact of open banking strategy and fintech on digital transformation. In 2023
International Conference on Business Analytics for Technology and Security
(ICBATS) (pp. 1-5). IEEE. DOI: 10.1109/ICBATS57792.2023.10111137.
Amrillah, M.U. (2020). Urgensi Pembentukan Undang-Undang Digital Banking Bagi

Perbankan Syariah Di Indonesia. Lex Renaissance, 5(4), 928-945. DOI:
10.20885/jlr.vol5.iss4.art12
Ashta 1, D. (2018). A critical comparative analysis of the emerging and maturing regulatory
frameworks: Crowdfunding in India, USA, UK. Journal of Innovation Economics &
Management, (0), art31_I-art31_XXIV.
Ashta, A. (2010). Evolution of Mobile Banking Regulations. Burgundy School of Business, 1-
42. DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.1583080.
Bajoub, A., Bendini, A., Fernández-Gutiérrez, A., & Carrasco-Pancorbo, A. (2018). Olive oil
authentication: A comparative analysis of regulatory frameworks with especial
emphasis on quality and authenticity indices, and recent analytical techniques
developed for their assessment. A review. Critical Reviews in Food Science and
Nutrition, 58(5), 832-857.
Bello, M.B., Regulatory framework and the Nigeria tourism economy. DOI:
10.47772/IJRISS.2020.41215
Bhuiyan, A.B., Ali, M.J., Islam, K.A., Alam, M.S., & Solaiman, M. (2020). The issues and
challenges of shariah harmonization of the cross border transactioins: conceptual
review of Islamic banking industries. International Journal of Shari'ah and Corporate
Governance Research, 3(2), 1-9. DOI: 10.46281/ijscgr.v3i2.838.
Bykanova, N.I. (2022). Trendy v bankovskoi otrasli v epokhu razvitiya tsifrovykh tekhno-logii
[Trends in the banking industry in the era of digital technology development]. Nauchnyi
rezul'tat. Ekonomicheskie issledovaniya= Research Result. Economic Research, 8(2),
107-118. DOI: 10.18413/2409-1634-2022-8-2-0-11.
Challapalli, S. (2023). Benefits and Constraints Associated with the Harmonization of
Financial Regulations: An Overview. Asian Journal of Economics, Business and
Accounting, 23(15), 49-56. DOI: 10.9734/ajeba/2023/v23i151015.
Chitengi, H.S. (2018). Regulations and housing informality in African cities: appropriating
regulatory frameworks to factors that influence resilience. Housing and Society, 45(1),
14-41. DOI: 10.1080/08882746.2018.1453721.
Dudin, M.N., Shkodinskii, S.V., & Usmanov, D.I. (2021). Key trends and regulations of the
development of digital business models of banking services in industry 4.0. Finance:
Theory and Practice, 25(5), 59-78. DOI: 10.26794/2587-5671-2021-25-5-59-78.
Ermakova, E.P., & Frolova, E.E. (2019). Legal regulation of digital banking in Russia and
foreign countries (European Union, USA, PRC). Perm U. Herald Jurid. Sci., 46, p.606.
DOI: 10.17072/1995-4190-2019-46-606-625.
Esoimeme, E.E. (2018). A comparative analysis of the prepaid card laws/regulations in Nigeria,
the UK, the USA and India. Journal of Money Laundering Control, 21(4), 481-493.
DOI: 10.1108/JMLC-03-2017-0010.
Frolova, E.E., Ermakova, E.P., & Protopopova, O.V. (2020, February). Consumer protection
of digital financial services in Russia and abroad. In 13th International Scientific and
Practical Conference-Artificial Intelligence Anthropogenic Nature Vs. Social Origin
(pp. 76-87). Cham: Springer International Publishing. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-030-39319-
9_8.
Gupta, C., Jindal, P., & Malhotra, R.K., 2022, November. A study of increasing adoption trends
of digital technologies-An evidence from Indian banking. In AIP Conference
Proceedings (Vol. 2481, No. 1). AIP Publishing. DOI: 10.1063/5.0104572.
Havryliuk, O., Yakushev, O., Prodanova, L., Yakusheva, O., & Kozlovska, S. (2021).
Tsyfrovyi bankinh ta elektronna komertsiia v konteksti didzhytalizatsii upravlinnia
biznesom [Digital banking and e-commerce in the context of digitalization of business
management]. Finansovo-kredytna diialnist: problemy teorii ta praktyky—Financial
and credit activities: problems of theory and practice, 5(40), 4-15. DOI:
10.18371/fcaptp.v5i40.244845
Indriasari, E., Prabowo, H., Gaol, F.L., & Purwandari, B. (2022). Digital banking: challenges,
emerging technology trends, and future research agenda. International Journal of E-
Business Research (IJEBR), 18(1), 1-20. DOI: 10.4018/ijebr.309398.
Iqbal, Z., & Tanty, G. (2021). Changing landscape of Indian Banking after covid and role of
banks in revival of economy. Asian Journal of Management, 12(4), 503-510. DOI:
10.52711/2321-5763.2021.00079.
Lawal, T.T., Lawal, N.A., & Akanbi, A.A. (2018). An evaluation of the legal and regulatory
challenges of electronic banking system in Nigeria. Pyrex Journal of Business and
Finance Management Research, 4(3), 21-29.
Lottu, O.A., Abdul, A.A., Daraojimba, D.O., Alabi, A.M., John-Ladega, A.A., & Daraojimba,
C. (2023). Digital transformation in banking: a review of Nigeria's journey to economic
prosperity. International Journal of Advanced Economics, 5(8), 215-238.
Mahalle, A., Yong, J., & Tao, X., 2021, May. Regulatory challenges and mitigation for account
services offered by FinTech. In 2021 IEEE 24th International Conference on Computer
Supported Cooperative Work in Design (CSCWD) (pp. 280-287). IEEE. DOI:
10.1109/CSCWD49262.2021.9437631
Mursalov, M.M. (2021). Regulation of the banking sector: Pandemic challenges and digital
solutions. Publishing House “Baltija Publishing”. DOI: 10.30525/978-9934-26-108-4-
5.
Nga, L.P., & Tam, P.T. (2023). Impact Digital Banking Development on the Business
Efficiency: A Case Study of Commercial Banks in Vietnam. Journal of Law and
Sustainable Development, 11(9), e859-e859. DOI: 10.55908/sdgs.v11i9.859.
Nikolaeva, A., & Versnel, J. (2022). Analytical observational study evaluating global pandemic
preparedness and the effectiveness of early COVID-19 responses in Ethiopia, Nigeria,
Singapore, South Korea, Sweden, Taiwan, UK and USA. BMJ Open, 12(2).
Okringbo, J.I., Chukuigwe, O., & Sikpi, E.E. (2022). Effectiveness of shell petroleum
development company’s communication strategies in promotion of environmental
degradation management in Niger Delta, Nigeria. Journal of Agripreneurship and
Sustainable Development, 5(1), 180-189. DOI: 10.59331/jasd.v5i1.300.
Olugbemi, A.O. (2020). A brief highlight of the regulatory framework for engaging in business
in the energy sector in Nigeria. Available at SSRN 3546545. DOI:
10.2139/ssrn.3546545.
Ongu, I., Olayide, P., Alexandersson, E., Mugwanya Zawedde, B., & Eriksson, D. (2023).
Biosafety regulatory frameworks in Kenya, Nigeria, Uganda and Sweden and their
potential impact on international R&D collaborations. GM Crops & Food, 14(1), 1-17.
DOI: 10.1080/21645698.2023.2194221.
Phillips, O. (2019). An overview of the regulatory framework of FinTech in Nigeria. Available
at SSRN 3425782. DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.3425782.
Priya, N., & Ahmed, J. (2021). A survey on digital payments security: recent trends and future
opportunities. International Journal of Computer Trends and Technology, 69(8), 26-
34. DOI: 10.14445/22312803/ijctt-v69i8p107
Roberts, S. (2016). Thematic overview: economic regulation and the development of telecoms,
mobile money and banking. The African Journal of Information and Communication,
2016(17), 1-6. DOI: 10.23962/10539/21631.
Sasea, E.M., & Sakmaf, M.S. (2023). Digital bank legal challenges: security protection and
leakage of customer personal data. Awang Long Law Review, 6(1), 245-250. DOI:
10.56301/awl.v6i1.989.
Shaltout, S.M.A. (2023). The adoption of open banking concept to regulate arab countries
digital payment. Journal of Law and Emerging Technologies, 3(2), 47-98. DOI:
10.54873/jolets.v3i2.146.
Smaranda, O.E., & Jacob, I.U., 2022, October. Reformation of Nigerian Legal and Regulatory
Framework for Islamic Banking Sector: Lessons from the UK and Malaysia. In 2022
International Conference on Sustainable Islamic Business and Finance (SIBF) (pp. 175-
181). IEEE. DOI: 10.1109/SIBF56821.2022.9940041.
Soininen, N., Romppanen, S., Nieminen, M., & Soimakallio, S. (2023). The Impact-based
Regulatory Strategy in Environmental Law: Hallmark of Effectiveness or Pitfall for
Legitimacy?. Journal of Environmental Law, 35(2), 185-206. DOI:
10.1093/jel/eqad013.
Tashtamirov, M. (2023). Financial Innovation and Digital Technology in the Banking System:
An Institutional Perspective. In SHS Web of Conferences (Vol. 172, p. 02004). EDP
Sciences. DOI: 10.1051/shsconf/202317202004
Tsindeliani, I.A., Proshunin, M.M., Sadovskaya, T.D., Popkova, Z.G., Davydova, M.A., &
Babayan, O.A. (2022). Digital transformation of the banking system in the context of
sustainable development. Journal of Money Laundering Control, 25(1), 165-180. DOI:
10.1108/JMLC-02-2021-0011.
Williams, M. (2023). A digital business innovation and financial inclusion: panacea to
Nigeria’s economic growth. International Journal of Innovation and Business Strategy
(IJIBS), 49-62. DOI: 10.11113/ijibs.v18.142.
Yuspin, W., Sukirman, A.N., Budiono, A., Pitaksantayothin, J., & Fauzie, A. (2023). Legal
reconstruction of Indonesian banking laws: challenges and opportunities for digital
bank regulation. Varia Justicia, 19(1), 52-69. DOI: 10.31603/variajusticia.v19i1.8019.

Digital Banking Regulations A Comparative Review B

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Digital Banking Regulations A Comparative Review B

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Finance & Accounting Research Journal, Volume 6, Issue 3, March 2024

DIGITAL BANKING REGULATIONS: A COMPARATIVE

¹Sanctus Maris Concepts Nigeria Ltd

Article Received: 10-01-24 Accepted: 01-03-24 Published: 17-03-24

has emerged as a pivotal component. By examining the regulatory frameworks of a developing

Phillips (2019) offers a comprehensive examination of the regulatory framework of FinTech

This study provides a comparative analysis of financial technology regulation systems in

Amrillah, M.U. (2020). Urgensi Pembentukan Undang-Undang Digital Banking Bagi

You might also like