Advantage of steel

Numerous industries make extensive use of structural steel due to its numerous benefits. Steel is utilized in
structures such as buildings, bridges, high-rise buildings, and warehouses. Steel is also used in
manufacturing equipment and completed goods. The use of structural steel in building construction comes
with a multitude of benefits(Northern Weldarc 2018).
Since steel has a high strength-to-weight ratio compared to other building materials, buildings made of steel
may be relatively tiny and lightweight despite the total size of the structure. This is a significant advantage
over other construction materials. It is simple to create steel sections and make them in large quantities off-
site on shop floors, which saves time and increases the construction industry's overall
efficiency(Constroquick 2021).
Steel is advantageous for a number of reasons, one of which is that it can be formed into any shape without
compromising its inherent characteristics. Because of this, architects may unleash their creative ideas in the
design of both residential and commercial buildings, making it an appealing alternative for architects who
are looking for a way to ensure that their structures are strong and safe(Monalisa Patel 2019).
Steel is not only long-lasting but also resilient, since they are unaffected by natural disasters such as
earthquakes, thunderstorms, and cyclones. If they are properly maintained, well-built steel buildings have
the potential to survive for up to 30 years(Advincula Jericson 2015). Steel is an option that is long-lasting
since it does not rust and is not susceptible to damage from termites, mildew, bugs, mould, or fungus
contamination(Monalisa Patel 2019).
Steel is superior to those made of wood and concrete when it comes to their ability to withstand fire. Steel
already has a great degree of fire resistance, but this quality may be further improved with specific coatings
that are flame-retardant (Monalisa Patel 2019). In contrast to concrete, which can virtually never be recycled,
and wood, which can only be partially recycled, steel is an ecologically preferable alternative due to its
ability to be recycled and its high efficiency in terms of energy use(Neelmani 2014).
Steel is much lighter in weight, which helps to reduce both transportation expenses and the amount of time
needed to complete a project. Steel is also very cost-effective. In addition, steel may be adapted to carry
certain loads in a variety of building configurations and sizes (Advincula Jericson 2015).
Lastly, steel have ductility, which indicates that they can bend without collapsing when subjected to
enormous pressures(Neelmani 2014). This enables them to provide warning indications far in advance of
any possible breaking danger. Steel is made safer in regions that are prone to earthquakes as a result of this,
particularly bridges and tall skyscrapers.

Disadvantage of steel
The presence of iron in steel makes it susceptible to corrosion since iron is a corrosive element. On the
other hand, the implementation of anti-corrosion applications makes it possible to mitigate at least some of
the detrimental impacts brought about by this problem (Steel Structure 2020). In addition, the fact that steel
has to be coated to prevent it from rusting results in considerable additional costs related with its
maintenance. Buildings built of steel suffer much greater costs for fireproofing in comparison to structures
made of other materials. This is due to the fact that steel is not inherently fireproof and that its properties
change when it is subjected to high temperatures (Monalisa Patel 2019). Buckling is another issue that may
arise with steel structures if they are not properly maintained. It is essential that you keep this in mind since
the possibility of the steel column buckling grows proportionately with the length of the column. In addition,
steel has a high expansion rate, which, depending on the temperature, may either be advantageous or
detrimental to the structure as a whole when it comes to the overall construction (Constroquick 2021).

Advantage of aluminum
Aluminum, which was discovered more than 200 years ago, is the metal that is utilised in the greatest
quantity in construction. Because of its resistance to corrosion and its low weight, it is often considered in
the building industry for beam design and brace columns. Moreover, it can be recycled, has a low cost, and
is good for the environment(Martin Perry Associates 2022).
When aluminium is exposed to air, a protective coating of aluminium oxide forms on its surface. This layer
makes aluminium resistant to corrosion(Sakshee Gaikwad 2022). Aluminum is a material that is perfect for
use in the construction business because of its longevity, strength, and light weight. It can be processed in
a variety of methods, including as melting, machining, forming, extruding, and casting, and it is a great
material for use in this sector(Martin Perry Associates 2022). It can be bent, extruded, and cut into a variety
of forms because to its flexibility, and since it is resistant to corrosion, it does not need protection for the
edges that have been trimmed.
Cladding systems are often used to improve the exteriors of buildings, such as the external facades, roofs,
stairs, railings, walls, shelves, windows, and doors. Aluminum is a popular material for usage in cladding
systems(Martin Perry Associates 2022). Its adaptability allows it to be used in a wide variety of different
contexts as well. In addition, because to the reflective characteristics of aluminium, buildings are able to
maintain a lower temperature during the year's warmer months. This helps to cut down on the amount of
money spent on energy and contributes to the development of more environmentally friendly building
designs(Sahana 2022).
Aluminum is capable of sustaining thick glass panes in structures without causing an excessive amount of
weight to be added to the structure due to the material's strength and durability despite its low weight(Weerg
2021). Because of this, it is quickly becoming one of the most popular construction materials on a global
scale and is making an even bigger contribution to the development of environmentally friendly building
designs.(Martin Perry Associates 2022)
Disadvantage of aluminium
Aluminium has numerous downsides. To begin, the cost is much higher than that of other materials such as
steel. Since aluminium has a lower stress tolerance in comparison to steel, it is possible that a greater amount
of aluminium will be required to assure the structural strength of some designs, which will result in higher
prices in the long run(Sahana 2022). Second, the technique of welding aluminium presents a number of
unique challenges. Since it has a lower melting point in comparison to other metals, the material will often
burn before it really melts. Moreover, because it has a high thermal expansion coefficient, welding it might
be challenging. In addition to this, while molten, aluminium absorbs hydrogen, which leads to the formation
of a porous solid (Sakshee Gaikwad 2022). Moreover, since aluminium has a strong affinity for oxygen, it
must be well cleaned of oxides before welding. Aluminum is notoriously difficult to manipulate in the
welding process due to all of the aforementioned reasons(Steel Structure 2020). Last but not least, despite
the fact that aluminium has a strong strength-to-weight ratio, steel outperforms it in terms of pure strength.
As a consequence of this, steel is favoured over aluminium in construction projects in which weight is not
a primary consideration. In addition, aluminium is ductile and has a high degree of malleability; these
properties make constructions built of aluminium prone to dents and scratches (harsh jain 2020).
Advantage of titanium
Titanium is a refractory metal that is in great demand and finds several uses across a variety of sectors.
These industries include the industrial processes industry, aerospace and military industry, and the medical
business(SMF n.d.). Since a thin coating of oxide develops on its surface when it is exposed to air, it has
exceptional resistance to corrosion. This makes it very durable even in demanding settings like as maritime
applications, where it is often used (Mikalor 2021). Titanium has a strength-to-density ratio that is higher
than that of any other metallic element on the periodic table, making it one of the strongest metals on the
planet and competing with steel for the title of one of the strongest metals on the world(One Monroe 2016).
Titanium is a common option in the aerospace sector and for the creation of structural frames because
despite its strength, it is lightweight owing to its low density. This makes titanium an attractive material
(SMF n.d.).
Titanium is advantageous for a number of reasons, one of which is that it is non-toxic due to the fact that it
is biocompatible and does not trigger any unfavourable responses in the human body (One Monroe 2016).
Because of this, it is an excellent material for use in medical applications, such as implants and dental
implants. Titanium also has a low coefficient of thermal expansion, which indicates that it expands and
shrinks at severe temperatures far less than the majority of other materials, hence offering better structural
stability (Energy Titanium 2022). Due to the fact that it is both robust and lightweight, it is well suited for
use in architectural applications where fire safety is of the utmost importance, such as in the construction
of skyscrapers (Energy Titanium 2022)
Titanium is advantageous for use in high-temperature applications such as foundries, turbine jet engines,
and satellites because it has a high melting point (Delaram et al. 2023). Titanium, despite its strength, is
comparatively soft and ductile, which makes it an excellent material for the creation of metal parts and
components due to its ease of machining. Since it is resistant to oxidation, it may also be seam welded and
welded in open air without the need of flux agents (SMF n.d.).
Disadvantage of titanium
Titanium could have a relatively high cost when compared to the cost of other metals. Titanium may be
difficult to get in some places because of its limited availability and high demand. As a result, it can be
challenging to acquire titanium fast or in big quantities at a price that is affordable(Energy Titanium 2022).
Titanium is notoriously difficult to work with owing to its extraordinarily high level of hardness as well as
its resistance to corrosion. As a result, it is challenging to shape titanium into the desired shape. As a direct
consequence of this, the total cost of manufacturing may rise, both in terms of the amount of time and the
amount of money (harsh jain 2022).

Titanium is notoriously difficult to weld owing to the material's high melting temperature as well as its
reactivity with air, which results in oxidation(Jordan layne 2019). Because of this, welding titanium requires
a specific talent that is not always easy to come by. This is especially true for bigger products or more
intricate designs, both of which call for welders with a high level of expertise. Titanium has a number of
drawbacks, one of which being its price, which is much more than the average price of steel (Coalition
Brewing n.d.). This may add considerable expenditures to a product, particularly when big quantities are
needed. In addition, the manufacturing process for items made of titanium is more complicated than that of
steel, which results in greater expenses associated with manufacture(One Monroe 2016).

In addition, welding titanium is complex and needs both specialised equipment and a high level of
competence(harsh jain 2022). Welding errors may greatly weaken the material, making it difficult to utilise
on bigger pieces where the likelihood of weld problems increases. Any mistakes made during welding are
difficult to repair, and weld mistakes can severely weaken the material. Titanium's restricted formability
stems from the fact that, in order to be shaped, the material must first be brought to very high temperatures
and then quickly cooled. Titanium, on the other hand, does not compare well to the strength of certain other
metals, such as steel, and it is comparatively lightweight (Delaram et al. 2023).

Titanium has a lower resistance to corrosion in comparison to other metals, which implies that areas that
need to be protected from the environment can be better served by using a different metal(Energy Titanium
2022).
References
Advincula Jericson. 2015. “Give at Least 10 Advantages Aasdnd 10 Disadvantages of Steel As A Structural
Material.” SCRIBD. July 23, 2015. https://www.scribd.com/doc/272400761/Give-at-Least-10-
Advantages-aasdnd-10-Disadvantages-of-Steel-as-a-Structural-
Material?utm_medium=cpc&utm_source=google_pmax&utm_campaign=3Q_Google_Performance
-
Max_RoW&utm_term=&utm_device=c&gclid=CjwKCAjwue6hBhBVEiwA9YTx8Ffw7INAxhmuXUoZh
N73Cq-XuGpDjoSchlVdKC4LHPd--QmztQi15BoCqHgQAvD_BwE#.

Coalition Brewing. n.d. “What Are the Disadvantages of Using Titanium?” COALITION BREWING.
Accessed April 16, 2023. https://www.coalitionbrewing.com/what-are-the-disadvantages-of-using-
titanium/.

Constroquick. 2021. “Advantages and Disadvantages of Structural Steel.” Constroquicks. February 24,
2021. https://constroquicks.com/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-structural-steel/.

Delaram, Behnaz, Faezeh Mokari, Mostafa Gholizadeh, and Yahya Absalan. 2023. “Use of the Advantages
of Titanium in the Metal: Organic Framework.” In Titanium Alloys - Recent Progress in Design,
Processing, Characterization, and Applications. IntechOpen.
https://doi.org/10.5772/intechopen.106947.

Energy Titanium. 2022. “The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Titanium.” ET. April 14, 2022.
https://energy-ti.com/the-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-titanium/.

harsh jain. 2020. “3 Main Disadvantages Of Aluminium.” THE PIPING MART. November 30, 2020.
https://blog.thepipingmart.com/metals/3-main-disadvantages-of-aluminium/.

———. 2022. “3 Disadvantages of Titanium.” THE PIPING MART. December 10, 2022.
https://blog.thepipingmart.com/metals/disadvantages-of-titanium/.
Jordan layne. 2019. “Interesting Titanium Pros and Cons.” Medium. December 13, 2019.
https://medium.com/sustainableworld/interesting-titanium-pros-and-cons-9caf565c1a7b.

Martin Perry Associates. 2022. “Advantages and Disadvantages of Aluminium in Structures.” MPA. 2022.
https://mperryassociates.com/2022/11/16/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-aluminium-in-
structures/.

Mikalor. 2021. “What Are the Advantages of Titanium?” Mikalorcompany. January 18, 2021.
https://mikalorcompany.com/fr/support-technique/what-are-the-advantages-of-titanium-2.

Monalisa Patel. 2019. “Advantages and Disadvantages of Steel Structures!” Ghar Pedia. August 2, 2019.
https://gharpedia.com/blog/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-steel-structures/.

Neelmani. 2014. “Advantages and Disadvantages of Steel Structures.” Civil Engineer. March 25, 2014.

Northern Weldarc. 2018. “Advantages and Disadvantages of Structural Steel Structures.” NWL. January 4,
2018. https://northern-weldarc.com/advantages-disadvantages-structural-steel-structures/.

One Monroe. 2016. “What Are the Pros and Cons of Titanium?” Monroeengineering. May 11, 2016.
https://monroeengineering.com/blog/pros-and-cons-of-
titanium/#:~:text=It’s%20strong%2C%20durable%20and%20naturally,right%20choice%20for%20yo
ur%20applications.

Sahana. 2022. “Advantages and Disadvantages of Aluminum.” Tech Quintal. March 31, 2022.
https://www.techquintal.com/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-aluminum/.

Sakshee Gaikwad. 2022. “5 Advantages and Disadvantages of Aluminium.” THE PIPING MART. December
20, 2022. https://blog.thepipingmart.com/metals/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-aluminum/.

SMF. n.d. “TITANIUM ADVANTAGES.” SPECIAL METALS FABRICATION. Accessed April 16, 2023.
https://special-metals.co.uk/titanium-advantages/.

Steel Structure. 2020. “Advantages & Disadvantages of Steel Construction.” Structural Community. April
2, 2020. https://structural.community/articles/advantages-of-steel-construction/.

Weerg. 2021. “ALUMINIUM: PROPERTIES AND ADVANTAGES.” Weerg. July 13, 2021.
https://www.weerg.com/guides/aluminum-properties-and-advantages-of-aluminum.