Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Utilitarianism centers on maximizing overall happiness. In the business context, this means
prioritizing actions and decisions that bring the greatest benefit to the largest number of
stakeholders. Companies often adopt utilitarian principles to contribute positively to society. For
instance, a company might invest in sustainable practices that benefit the environment and satisfy
consumer demands for ethically sourced products. Notable examples include Ben & Jerry's
commitment to fair trade and Patagonia's environmental initiatives.
On the other hand, Kantian ethics underscores moral duty and respect for individual rights.
Businesses can integrate Kantian principles by aligning their actions with moral duties and
upholding the rights of all parties involved. This may involve ensuring fair labor practices and
safeguarding consumer privacy. Apple's commitment to protecting user data and IKEA's
adherence to ethical sourcing in their supply chain show instances where businesses prioritize
Kantian principles.
Common ethical dilemmas in business include environmental responsibility, fair labor practices,
and product safety. These dilemmas bring utilitarian and Kantian principles into conflict. For
instance, a company facing a choice between cost-effective production methods with
environmental consequences and sustainable but more expensive alternatives encounters a clash
between prioritizing overall happiness and respecting moral duties and individual rights. The
Volkswagen emissions scandal and Nike's past controversies regarding labor practices highlight
instances where businesses faced such ethical dilemmas.
The challenges arise when businesses strive to reconcile these two ethical frameworks.
Conflicting priorities and different approaches can create tension. To navigate this delicate
balance, transparency, stakeholder engagement, and adopting a long-term perspective are vital.
Companies like Unilever, with its Sustainable Living Plan, showcase successful navigation of
this balance. By transparently addressing environmental concerns, engaging with stakeholders,
and committing to long-term sustainability goals, Unilever demonstrates ethical practices that
benefit both society and individual stakeholders.