Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Introduction
In the past so many researchers has done so many researches and presented journals, articles, research
papers and also thesis on this topic but the purpose of this study is to discuss intensively and precisely the
potentials of banana leaf ash as an admixture in the production of concrete. This work will review more
detail regarding banana leaf ash as admixture in concrete production, its advantages and analyze more
valuable information vividly.
Today low cost material is of great importance because of the growing demand for a comfort and
affordable housing especially in underdeveloped and developing countries where there are great rate of
poverty and starvation, people cannot be able to afford buying imported and more expensive materials so
the use of our indigenous and agricultural waste become very important because it is readily available and
more economical.
Most of our modern structures are constructed with concrete such as bridges, houses, tunnels etc. apart
from wood concrete is the widest and oldest material ever used in construction. It is made up of four types
of ingredients namely fine aggregate, coarse aggregate, water and Portland cement, but do to the needs to
have more durable, fast settling time and more stable concrete there arise the need to add another material
called admixtures.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Background
Agricultural waste such as banana leafs deposited in large quantity, if not used for industrial raw material
could course a great damage or hazard to the environment and habitant inhabiting the territory. It is then
very important to find a way of utilizing and recycling this great agricultural material to be useful in the
industries in the production of more important goods and services, that is why this research is very
important because banana leaf ash is readily available and cost little or no amount of money to get.
Similarly natural leaves such as banana leaf have very good properties to improve the performance of
materials such as concrete.
Nigeria alone produce over 5 million hectares of banana plantation, with an average of 600 plants per
hectare, in comparison with what other countries are producing annually, this left tons of banana waste,
which have been left to decompose and emits a very high amount of methane gas and carbon dioxide,
which are harmful to the body when inhaled and also cause global warming.
The water used for the study was obtained from the tap inside the laboratory of the department. We use
clean water which are free from any visible impurities. It confirmed to Bs 3148 (1980) requirement.
➢ Aggregate test
➢ Fresh concrete test
➢ Harden concrete test
3.2. Mix Design for concrete replaced with various percent of banana leaf ash
Mix design was done by mass using mix ratio as stipulated and a targeted strength 25N/mm2 and water
cement ratio of 0.5% for concrete production yielding 1:1.9:3 mix ratio. However, the BLA introduced
into concrete was varied at 0% 5% 10% 20% and 25% fraction (replacement) of cement weight. A total
number of 12 (150mm X 150mm X150mm cubes) were moulded for each input of BLA. Given a total
volume requirement of 0.003375mm2× 12 = 0.0405m3.
Table 1: Design for the Partial Replacement of cement with BLA (12 cubes) per 0.042525m3
Percentage of Water (kg) Sand (kg) Sand (g) BLA (G) Coarse Aggregate (kg)
BLA
0 % BLA 8. 24 16.41 31.07 0 48.34
5% BLA 8.24 15.59 8.24 156 48.34
10 % BLA 8.24 14.77 8.24 312 48.34
15% BLA 8.24 13.95 8.24 468 48.34
20 % BLA 8.24 13. 13 8.24 624 48.34
25 % BLA 8.24 12.31 8.24 780 48.34
4. ANALYSIS, PRESENTATION OF RESULT AND DISCUSSION
4.1 SIEVE ANALYSIS ON FINE AND CAURSE AGGREGATES:
On dry mass processes, were the following results obtained from the sieve analysis carried out on both fine
aggregate and coarse aggregates, as appropriately recorded:
10
% Passing
4.16
1
0.01 0.36 0.1 1 10
0.1
percentage passing
43.07
PERCENTAGE PASSING
10 8.856
1.279
1 sieve size
1 10 100
20
slump(mm)
15
24
23
10
20
17
5
14
0 8
0% BLA
5% BLA
10% BLA
15% BLA
20% BLA
25% BLA
% BLA replacement
Figure 3. Results for slump test
2550
2500
2450
2400 sample 1
sample 2
2350 sample 3
sample 4
2300
2250
2200
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25%
From the table and figure the density decreases from 0% to 25% BLA replacement sligthly with a linear
correlation of 0.6856, 0.6845, 0.6810, 0.6752,and 0.6724 respectively then fall to 0.6724 and0.6621for
20% and 25% respectively. This reduction in density at a moderate rate and minimium average
2398.52kg/m3 which is within the normal concrete density of 2400kg/m3 minimum and maximium ligth
weigth concrete of 1800kg/m3. ASTM C330 table 2. Thus suggesting usage for any type of construction
work nevertheless the 20% and 25% replaced concrete will be perfect for supper structure as its density is
ligther.
0.16
WATER ABSORPTION IN PERCENTAGE
0.14
0.12
0.1
0.08
0.06
0.04
0.02
0
CONTROL 5% BLA 10% BLA 15% BLA 20% BLA 25% BLA
3 DAYS 0.03 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.08 0.13
7 DAYS 0.04 0.05 0.06 0.07 0.09 0.14
14 DAYS 0.06 0.06 0.07 0.08 0.12 0.15
28 DAYS 0.08 0.11 0.12 0.12 0.14 0.16
Axis Title
3 DAYS 7 DAYS 14 DAYS 28 DAYS
The fig showed max of 0.16 which is less than the permissible range of 1.4 for Fcu 25N/mm concrete.
Days 0% BLA 5% BLA 10% BLA 15% BLA 20% BLA 25% BLA
3 21.48 20.44 18.96 16.29 14.22 12.59
7 25.78 24.74 20.74 17.48 15.41 14.67
14 26.96 25.92 21.81 18.16 17.33 16.59
28 28.07 28.52 27.58 25.78 24.15 21.63
Crushing load (N)
Sample using 0% at 3days Fcu =
Surface area (𝑀2 )
From the table 4.13 and figure 4.5 the various compressive strength has a constant and progressive
strength growth from 3days to 7days. At 3days the control was seen to have the highest value followed by
5% concrete and down from 10% strength to 25% but at 7 days the strength of control was higher than
that at 3days and as well decreased uniformly as the % replacement increased from 5% to 25% BLA. At
28 days curing the control exceeded the target mix design of 25N/mm2 thus notifying that the mix at 0.5%
water cement ratio was adequate. Also at this 28days control, 5%, 10% and 15% exceeds stipulated
designed strength but the remaining concrete from 20% and 25% respectively meet up with the stipulated
strength for light weight concrete which is 17N/mm2 as given in ASTM C330-89.Y J Kim, (2010).
25
compressive strength (N/mm2)
20
15
10
0
3 days curing 7 days curing 14 days curing 28 days curing
control 21.48 25.78 26.96 28.07
5% BLA 20.44 24.74 25.92 28.52
10% BLA 18.96 20.74 21.81 27.58
15% BLA 16.29 17.48 18.16 25.78
20% BLA 14.22 15.41 17.33 24.15
25% BLA 12.59 14.67 16.59 21.63
control 5% BLA 10% BLA 15% BLA 20% BLA 25% BLA
4.2.5 The engineering properties of the various concrete samples at 28 days of curing
Table 7: summary of the engineering properties of BLA concrete
% replacement Compressive Density (kg/m3) Slump (mm) Water absorption
strength (N/mm2)
From the table it can be observed that the samples meet the requirements for normal and light weight
concrete. The results have little or no different at 15% level of significance of banana leaf ash
replacement. Therefore from the table the 15% BLA replacement is been recommended as it meet both
strength, moderate density and has a desirable workability in terms of slump.
SUMMARY/CONCLUTION
The purpose of this study was achieved by means of the methods outline in chapter three.
The results were recorded, analyzed and discussed in chapter four. The comprehensive strength and
density of the samples decreased as the level of cement replaced with banana leaf ash increases while the
slump decrease uniformly up to 20% but the concrete still retain its workability due to its plastic nature,
there is need to increase the workability by adequate use of suitable admixture so as to improve
workability and in turns maintains its high strength. Concrete with 15%banana leaf ash material up to
cement replacement of 15-20% by weight could be used for works requiring moderate strength concrete
as it exhibited adequate compressive strength.
The banana leaf ash has a low specific gravity value than normal cement implying that it would make the
resultant concrete lighter with more proportions of cement replaced.
The replacement of cement with banana leaf ash would be beneficial to low income areas due to its high
availability and ease to source and processes which may not afford to keep up with the rising costs and
difficulties in getting cement with total reduction on the average load on structures making other
parameters like foundation work to reduce.
The utilization of this ash material will in turn reduce its effect as environmental pollutant and emission of
gasses which causes global warming when they are being burnt or disposed.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to thank Michael Okpara University of agriculture umudike for providing the enabling
environment to carry out the practical in their laboratory especially the civil engineering department.
REFERENCE