Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/379652825
CITATIONS READS
0 11
4 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Siddharth Rana on 07 April 2024.
Content
Integrated Urban Transport Planning for Mega Pilgrim Event in India: 112
A Multifaceted Approach
Sukriti Dogra and Shruti H. Kapur
iii
Journal of ITPI, 21 x 1, January - March 2024, ISSN:L0537-9679
Abstract
This research paper discusses the trends in vehicle registration and road accidents in Dehradun district over
the last two decades. This paper can be divided broadly into two parts; the first part of the paper provides
a comprehensive analysis of the trends in vehicle registration in Dehradun district. The second part of the
paper gives detail about the trends of road accidents in the Dehradun district over the last two decades;
it also provides detail about the major black spots of the Dehradun district. Also, various reasons for road
accidents in the study area have been discussed. At last, based on the factors discussed in this research paper
some suggestions and recommendations have been given in the conclusion part.
1. INTRODUCTION
An accident involving at least one vehicle on a public road that results in at least one person
being hurt or killed is referred to as a road accident.(INSEE, 2020). Road accidents are a major
and growing problem in India and across the world. The World Health Organization (WHO)
released its 2018 Global Status Report on Road Safety, which states that over 1.35 million
people die on global roads annually, with 90 percent of these deaths occurring in developing
nations. Children and young adults aged 5-29 years are highly vulnerable to road accident cases.
Pedestrians, cyclists, and motorcyclists are involved in almost half of the deaths which occur
due to road accidents. Under-developed and developing countries has almost 60 percent of the
world’s vehicles, However, these nations account for 93 percent of all road fatalities worldwide.
Most nations lose 3 percent of their gross domestic product to traffic accidents (WHO, 2022).
Road length in India is 63,72,613 km, making it the world’s most extensive road network after
the United States. The figure of fatalities due to road accidents in India is 1, 53, 972 lives per
year, there is an evident asymmetry between the number of vehicle registrations and deaths
due to road accidents in India because India accounts for only one percent of total vehicles in
the world yet the deaths which happen due to road accidents in the world, India accounts for 11
percent of it. There has been an alarming increase in accidental deaths and injuries on Indian
roads over the years. In 2021, every day in India 422 lives were lost in total 1130 accidents
(MORTH, 2021). India is a signatory to the Brasilia Declaration, which was adopted at the second
international high-level conference on road safety held in Brazil in 2015. The declaration calls
for a halving of accident-related deaths and injuries by 2020 and calls for participating nations
Siddharth Rana; Research Scholar, Department of Geography, School of Earth Science, H. N. B. Garhwal University
(A Central University), Srinagar Garhwal
Gaurav; Assistant Professor, Department of Geography, Indraprastha College for Women, University of Delhi,
New Delhi
P. S. Negi; Associate Professor, Department of Geography, D. A. V. P. G. College, Dehradun
M. S. Panwar; Professor, Department of Geography, School of Earth Science, H. N. B. Garhwal University (table
3 and figure 3) (A Central University), Srinagar Garhwal
to incorporate this goal into their 2030 agenda for sustainable development. In India, the most
popular means of transportation for moving both people and freight is the road. With increasing
population, sustained economic growth, and increased per capita income vehicle registration
has also increased but a sufficient amount of road has not been built over the years, causing
excessive vehicle burden on the roads. Although only 2.09 percent of all roads in the nation are
national highways, 31.2 percent of all traffic accidents occur on these routes (MORTH, 2021).
Despite the continuous and concentrated efforts at all levels to contain these, the nation’s
leading cause of hospitalization, disability, and death is still traffic accidents.
2. STUDY AREA
Dehradun district lies between 29°58’00” N and 31°02’30” N latitudes and 77°34’05” E and
78°8’13” E longitudes, covering a total area of 3,088 km2 with an average altitude of 640 m above
MSL (figure 1). The seven tehsils which make the whole Dehradun district are Dehradun Sadar,
Doiwala, Rishikesh, Chakrata, Kalsi, Vikasnagar, and Tyuni (District Dehradun, 2023). In addition,
it is separated into six development blocks, which are Doiwala, Raipur, Sahaspur, Kalsi, Vikas
Nagar, and Chakrata. Dehradun District is the capital of Uttarakhand state; it has a significant
number of vehicles registered here because of a large number of government employees
and officials residing here. The amount of traffic in Dehradun district has increased over the
years, but the infrastructure of the roads has remained the same. There are many educational
institutes like Forest Research Institute, Survey of India, Wadia Institute of Himalayan Geology,
and Indian Military Academy etc. Thousands of tourists visit these institutes and travel to places
like Mussoorie, Robbers Cave, Kalsi Inscription, (table 5) and Sahastradhara during the summer
and winter months. Due to this congregation of vehicles on the roads, cases of road accidents
have also increased. Hence, the Dehradun district has been selected as the study area to analyze
the trends of vehicle registration and road accidents in the Dehradun district.
of vehicle registrations. A total of 8,95,865 vehicles were registered during the time period, and
the total revenue collected was Rs. 1,474.67 Crore in Dehradun RTO. 1,39,356 vehicles were
registered in Rishikesh RTO and the revenue collected amounted to Rs. 241.65 Crore. In the case
of Roorkee, the number of vehicles registered was 1,53,602 and the total revenue collected was
Rs. 205.58 Crore. In the given two-decade (table 5) time period 49,256 vehicles were registered
in Vikas Nagar RTO, and a total of Rs. 51.73 Crore of revenue was collected. The table 2 and figure
2 shows the vehicle registration at different RTO’s in the Dehradun district.
Table 2: Number of Vehicle Registration in Dehradun District at Different RTO’s
Year Dehradun RTO Rishikesh RTO Roorkee RTO Vikas Nagar RTO
2001 18,746 818 68 49
2002 19,967 959 203 91
2003 43,722 1,560 161 158
2004 24,330 3,315 394 71
2005 27,510 1,995 223 87
2006 59,150 4,470 495 163
2007 34,327 4,678 364 124
2008 64,686 8,957 756 275
2009 37,281 5,328 357 140
2010 82,939 6,638 922 325
2011 54,097 7,339 595 199
2012 1,10,387 15,030 1,198 421
2013 54,241 7,140 505 272
2014 55,765 16,787 5,926 4,450
2015 1,15,425 11,490 20,778 10,065
2016 59,990 24,177 45,010 6,629
2017 1,31,988 14,273 25,895 13,381
2018 78,684 30,387 54,945 8,651
2019 64,185 13,787 25,807 9,152
2020 1,11,567 22,189 43,779 6,319
Total Vehicle Registered 8,95,865 1,39,356 1,53,602 49,256
Source: Parivahan.gov.in
Figure 2: Trends of Vehicle Registration in Dehradun District Over the Time Period of (2001-2020)
Figure 3: Trends of Road Accidents in Dehradun District Over the Time Period of (2001-2020)
= 6,477 / 20
= 323.85 accidents per year
The Severity Index for the study area = Total Number of recorded fatalities / Total number of
injured persons
= 2,974 / 5,869
= 0.506
The formulas used above present the data about the road accident frequency and severity
index for the study area. The improvement of modeling techniques has been the main
focus of road safety research in the past, but due to a lack of experience and statistical
expertise, local authorities may not find value in these approaches for road safety evaluation
processes. That’s why preparing an easy-to-use methodology for the analysis of road
accidents is necessary. Road accident frequency for district Dehradun has been calculated
to be 323.85. The severity index has also been calculated for the study area which is 0.506
(Fabio Borghettiet al., 2021b).
accidents. Saharanpur Road, Haridwar Road, and Mussorie Road have been designated as
National Highways by the government (Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, 2019). National
highways are mostly long straight stretches of roads that tempt drivers to run vehicles at a
high speed, due to which most of the road accidents happen in the Dehradun district. Incorrect
locations of the speed breakers and damaged speed breakers increase the chances of road
accidents, especially in the case of two-wheelers. Dehradun district is urbanizing very rapidly
and road encroachment is one of the side effects of this urbanisation. Street vendors and
residents also have usurped the roads due to a lack of space, which has resulted in less space
for sidewalks available for pedestrians. Due to this situation, they are forced to walk on the
road along with the vehicles which increases the chances of road accidents. Because of the
absence of adequate road signs such as the ongoing work, level crossing with a barrier ahead,
roundabout ahead, and uneven road ahead, most of the time, drivers are unaware of the
requirement of the roads which increases the chances of road accidents. Heavy rain, dense
fog, and hail storms are some environmental factors responsible for road accidents in the study
area. They reduce the visibility for the driver and also makes the road slippery which increases
the chances of road accident.
riding were in the age group of 20 to 29 years. Another factor is distracted driving; it is much
more dangerous than drunk driving because drunk driving cases mostly occur at night time but
distraction while driving due to talking on the cell phone or sending a text message can occur
any time of the day or night. This increases the road accident frequency. One of the main
reasons for nighttime traffic accidents is high beam from headlights, especially when they are
used in poor visibility conditions. Even though driving within city limits is forbidden, people
nevertheless use their high beams when it’s not necessary. Helmets, seat belts, and other safety
devices are critical in reducing the chances of road accidents but due to the negligence of these
by the users road accident numbers continue to raise.
4.7 Correlation between Numbers of Vehicle Registration and Number of Road Accidents
In order to examine any possible linear relationship between two continuous variables, a form
of statistical analysis known as correlation is applied. (Mukaka, 2012).
The Pearson correlation evaluates the degree Table 5: Correlation between Numbers of
to which two variables are correlated linearly. Vehicle Registration and Number of
Its range is from ‘-1 to 1’ with ‘-1’ denoting a Road Accidents
completely negative correlation. ‘0’ denotes no
Registration Accidents
correlation and ‘1’ denotes a completely inverse
positive correlation (Williams, et al., 2020). The Registration 1 -0.205
measured correlation between the variables Accidents -0.205 1
of vehicle registration and road accidents is a
negligible correlation with -0.205 (table 5).
5. CONCLUSION
Correct perception and correct judgments are two primary measures for avoiding road accidents
at a pre crash stage and these must be learned by every individual road user. There is an urgent
need to adopt proper traffic management procedures to curb road accidents in the district.
Road accident frequency in the Dehradun district is 323.85 accidents per year. The severity
index for the study area is 0.506 which is less than 1. It shows that the number of injured
people in road accidents is almost double the number of people who died in road accidents.
To reduce the number of fatalities even further the focus should be on raising awareness
about ‘Good Samaritan law’ among the local people. The Good Samaritan Law allow anyone to
voluntarily step up and provide emergency care or immediate assistance to someone injured in
an accident, crash, or emergency medical situation without expecting payment or reward, as
well as without any duty of care or special relationship. The Good Samaritan Law shields good
Samaritans from retaliation for their efforts to save the lives of victims of traffic accidents
(Good Samaritan, Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, Government of India, 2023). Most
of the policies created by the policymakers are based on policies and programs implemented in
developed countries earlier. When such procedures are implemented in developing countries
like India. Such proposed countermeasures are likely to be unsuccessful. Policies for an area
should be created after the scientific study of that particular area. The measured correlation
between the two variables namely vehicle registration and road accidents is a negligible
correlation with -0.205. It shows that there are also other factors responsible for road accidents
in the study area. The heterogeneous mix of road users, inappropriate road design, and low-
budget policing are some of the areas which are neglected most of the time and need to
be focused upon. The sudden surge of tourists during the tourism season should be strictly
scrutinized as the district is the gateway to major tourist places like Mussoorie, Gangotri,
and Yamunotri. One of the main problems in reducing road accidents is the insufficiency of
accurate data, so a road safety information database should be created and properly managed
for the study area. Road safety education and training should be imparted to drivers free of
cost so they can bring a change in their general attitude towards driving and start following
traffic safety regulations more seriously.
REFERENCES
Athiappan, K. et al. (2022) “Identifying Influencing Factors of Road Accidents in Emerging Road
Accident Black spots,” Advances in Civil Engineering, 2022, pp. 1–10. Available at: https://doi.
org/10.1155/2022/9474323.
Borghetti, F. et al. (2021) “A New Methodology for Accidents Analysis: The Case of the State Road 36 in
Italy,” International Journal of Transport Development and Integration, 5(3), pp. 278–290. Available at:
https://doi.org/10.2495/tdi-v5-n3-278-290.
Borghetti, Fabio, et al. (2021) “A new methodology for accidents analysis: the case of the State Road 36
in Italy,” International Journal of Transport Development and Integration, 5(3), pp. 278–290. Available
at: https://doi.org/10.2495/tdi-v5-n3-278-290.
Geethabai and Pai, S. (2016) “A Literature Study on Road Accidents Statistics and Reasoning,” Ijitr, 4(6),
pp. 4979–4984. Available at: http://www.ijitr.com/index.php/ojs/article/download/1401/pdf.
Ghosh, S. K., Parida, M., andUraon, J. K. (2004). Traffic Accident Analysis for Dehradun City Using Gis.
ITPI Journal, Vol.1, No.3 pp.40–54.
Good Samaritan | Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, Government of India (2023). Available at:
https://morth.nic.in/good-samaritan (Accessed: August 1, 2023).
INSEE. (2020, October). Definition - Road accidents. Institut National De La Statistique Et Des Etudes
Economiques. Retrieved May 16, 2023, from https://www.insee.fr/en/metadonnees/definition/c1116
Jacobs, G.D. and Sayer, I.A. (1983) “Road accidents in developing countries,” Accident Analysis and
Prevention, 15(5), pp. 337–353. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/0001-4575(83)90013-1.
Ministry of Road Transport and Highways. (2019). List of National Highways in the Country [Dataset].
Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, GOI. https://morth.nic.in/sites/default/files/Details-of-
National-Highways-as-on-31.03_1.pdf
Mohan, D. (2002) “Road safety in less-motorized environments: future concerns,” International Journal
of Epidemiology, 31(3), pp. 527–532. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/31.3.527.
Mukaka, M. (2012) “Statistics corner: A guide to appropriate use of correlation coefficient in medical
research.,” PubMed [Preprint]. Available at: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23638278.
Road Accidents in India - 2021. In Ministry of Road Transport and Highways. Government of India, Ministry
of Road Transport and Highways Transport ResearchWing.https://morth.nic.in/sites/default/files/
RA_2021_Compressed.pdf
Sharma, S. et al. (2016) “Prevalence and risk factors of non-fatal road traffic accidents in a community
setting of district Dehradun,” The Journal of Medical Research, 6(1), pp. 42–44. Available at: http://
njmr.in/uploads/6_1_42-44.pdf.
Singh, S. (2017b) “Road Traffic Accidents in India: Issues and Challenges,” Transportation Research
Procedia, 25, pp. 4708–4719. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trpro.2017.05.484.
State Transport Department Government of Uttarakhand (2023) F.A.Q.: State Transport Department,
Government Of Uttarakhand, India. Available at: https://transport.uk.gov.in/pages/display/99
Talwar, G. (2016) “123 accident-prone ‘black spots’ identified in Uttarakhand,” The Times of India,
5 October. Available at: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/dehradun/123-accident prone-black-
spots-identified-in Uttarakhand/articleshow/54700623.cms.
Talwar, G. (2017) “Entry of heavy vehicles into Dehradun limits barred till 11pm,” The Times of India,
31 October. Available at: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/dehradun/entry-of-heavy-vehicles-
into-city-limits-barred-till
Tehsil | District Dehradun | India (2023). Available at: https://dehradun.nic.in/tehsils/.
Uniyal, A.K. and Agarwal, S. (2019) “Risk and Road Traffic Accidents in Uttarakhand– Present Scenario,
Analysis, Interpretation, and Preventions.,” International Journal of Innovative Technology and Exploring
Engineering, 8(9), pp. 1374–1379. Available at: https://doi.org/10.35940/ijitee.i8006.078919.
Williams, B. et al. (2020) “Data-Driven model development for cardiomyocyte Production Experimental
failure Prediction,” in Computer-aided chemical engineering, pp. 1639–1644. Available at: https://doi.
org/10.1016/b978-0-12-823377-1.50274-3.
World Health Organization: WHO. (2022). Road traffic injuries. www.who.int. https://www.who.int/
news-room/fact-sheets/detail/road-traffic-injuries