Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
Company meeting : an overview
company meeting means two or more individuals coming together to carry
A
out a legitimate business or to take decisions on the same, like any other group
of people flocking together for a particular purpose. Now, in order to carry out
the business of the company properly, it becomes necessary for the directors
and shareholders of companies to meet as often as necessary and to take
unanimous decisions based on their viewpoints and discussions. Simply put, it is
crucial for companies to hold meetings for the effective functioning of the
company. These meetings hold great importance in the decision-making
process.
oreover, shareholders, who are the owners of the company, have the right to
M
have proper discussions on the affairs of the company and to further exercise
their rights in matters relating to the ongoing activities and future of the
company. Conducting meetings provides this chance to the shareholders and
also gives them an opportunity to keep a check on the activities of the board of
directors, as the directors are obligated to adhere to the decisions taken in the
meetings of shareholders. Also, the management of the company is vested in
the hands of shareholders; hence, it is important that they meet on a regular
basis to take unanimous decisions and function effectively as a team.
Now let us have a look at some of the important aspects of company meetings.
Future policies
hrough meetings, the past policies and experiences of a company can be
T
discussed, and new future policies can be fixed. As stated above, directors are
answerable to shareholders, so via such meetings, the shareholders can learn
about the affairs of the company. The rights of shareholders include:
I n the case ofSharp v. Dawes (1971), a meeting isdefined as “an assembly of
people for a lawful purpose” or “the coming togetherof at least two persons for
any lawful purpose.”
Number of individuals
Definite place
here must be a specific place for the meeting. In the case of official meetings,
T
the meeting must be conducted in the office. Further, in the case of big
meetings that entail a huge involvement of members, like the annual general
meeting of a public company, the meeting can be held in a public hall. Also,
public meetings can be held in public halls, on open grounds, or even on roads,
if required.
Discussion
here has to be some discussion while conducting the meeting, meaning the
T
individuals in the meeting must put forth their viewpoints and opinions on the
agenda of the meeting.
Predetermined topics
sually, in company meetings, the topics or subject matter of the meeting are
U
already notified to the participants, so they can come prepared with their
viewpoints on the same.
4
Decisions
he decisions for the agenda are generally taken in the meeting itself, as getting
T
to a conclusion is the main objective of conducting the meeting. The decisions
occurring in the meeting are binding on the members of the company,
irrespective of whether they were able to attend the meeting or not, were
present or not, or even if they agree with or oppose the inference thus reached.
he decisions are taken either through votes or in the form of resolutions. Also,
T
there are distinct ways of voting. Usually, decisions are not taken at public
meetings, and if they are, they are not binding in any manner whatsoever.
Types
. Private,
1
2. Public, or
3. International (like U.N.O.)
he types of company meetings, which can be private or public, are discussed in
T
depth below.
General notes
1. The meeting does not take place automatically. A meeting has to be
called or convened. In simple words, a notice has to be sent to every
individual with the authority to attend the meeting.
2. In the case of a public meeting, general publicity is necessary. Every
type of meeting has its own procedure to be followed.
3. An accidental meeting of two or more individuals will not be referred to
as a meeting.
4. The secretary is responsible for calling and informing the members and
conducting the meeting.
eetings hold great value in our daily social lives. This is a democratic process
M
that is quite essential in the decision making of any organisation, be it a
5
ompany, a club, or even an association. Further, group discussions play a
c
major role in:
Participants
6
t o send his representative or proxy on their behalf. Whereas, in the case of
public meetings, the general public has the authority to attend them.
Chairman
Secretary
Invitees
part from those who have the authority to attend the meeting, there are some
A
people who are invited, for instance, the press reporters.
Material elements
Quorum
quorum is defined as the minimum number of members that are required to
A
be present as mentioned under the provisions of a particular meeting. Any
business transaction carried out at a meeting without a quorum shall be deemed
to be invalid. The main object of having a quorum is to avoid taking decisions by
a small minority of members that may not be accepted by the vast majority.
Every company meeting has its own number of quorum, the same has been
discussed under separate headings in the upcoming passages.
Agenda
Minutes
8
Proxy
Resolutions
Business transactions in company meetings are carried out in the form of
resolutions. There are two kinds of resolutions, namely:
Meetings of Directors
9
3. Creditors and contributors meeting.
efore we dive deep into the nitty-gritty of each of the categories, here is a
B
pictorial representation of the types of company meetings for your better
understanding-
ow that we have seen the pictorial representation of company meetings, let us
N
have a look at each of the meetings in a more detailed manner.
10
he first category is further divided into three subcategories, each of which is
T
discussed in detail below.
General meeting
he general meeting is subdivided into three categories. Let us have a look at
T
the nitty-gritty of each of them.
Statutory meeting
lease note: Before the enactment of the Companies Act, 2013, the
P
requirements laid down for statutory meetings and reports under
Section 165 were legit. However, after its enactment, the same has
been dropped.
. Private company,
1
2. Company limited by guarantee having no share capital,
3. Unlimited liability company,
4. A public company that was registered as a private company earlier,
5. A company that has been deemed as a public company under Sec. 43
A.
11
he board of directors of a company is duty-bond to forward a notice of the
T
meeting to all the shareholders or members of the company. This has to be
done at least 21 days prior to holding the meeting, and an explicit mention of
‘statutory meeting’ of the company has to be made in the notice. If the board of
directors does not name it the ‘statutory meeting’, it will be a breach of the
provision.
ow that a mention of the statutory report was made above, you might wonder,
N
what exactly is it? Let’s find out.
nder Section 165(3) of the Companies Act, 1956, a prior mention of the
U
contents of a statutory report has been made; it says the report mustcontain:
. The total number of fully paid-up and partly paid-up shares allotted
1
2. The sum of the amount of cash received by the company with respect
to the shares;
3. Information on the receipts, distinguishing them on the basis of their
sources and mentioning the amount spent for commission, brokerage,
etc.
4. The names of the directors, auditors, managers and secretaries along
with their address and occupation, and changes of their names and
addresses, if any.
5. The particulars of agreements that are to be presented in the meeting
for approval, with suggested amendments, if any.
6. The justifications in cases where any underwriting agreement was not
executed.
7. The arrears due on calls from directors and other individuals.
8. The details on the amount of honoraria paid to the directors, managers
and others for selling shares or debentures.
12
ow that we know about the statutory report and its particulars, you might
N
wonder what the proper procedure is for conducting a statutory meeting. The
answer is in the below pointers.
he following are the repercussions of not complying with the provisions on
T
conducting a statutory meeting:
1. If there is any mistake in complying with the provision for holding a
statutory meeting under Section 165, the directors or other officers of
13
t he company who are at fault will be liable to pay a fine that is
extendable up to ₹500.
2. Under Section 43(6) of the Companies Act, 1956, in case the company
errs in conducting the statutory meeting or if the statutory report is not
in compliance with the provisions of the Act, the company may be
compulsorily wound up if the court orders the same. However, under
Section 443(3) of the Companies Act, 1956, the court may pass an
order to conduct a statutory meeting or to send the statutory report,
as the case may be, instead of winding up the company.
ime of holding A
T n AGM has to be held within six An EGM can be held at
the meeting months of the close of the ny time.
a
financial year.
14
ho may call
W he board of directors has the
T he board of directors,
T
such a authority to call such a meeting. along with
meeting? requisitionists, have the
authority to call such a
meeting.
epercussions
R he tribunal may call and
T imilarly, the tribunal
S
of default in impose a fine in case a company may call and impose a
conducting defaults in holding an AGM in a fine in case a company
such a meeting requisite manner. errs in holding an EGM
in the prescribed
manner.
The main purpose of conducting an AGM is to transact the ordinary business of
the company. Ordinary business includes the following:
15
nder corporate law, an annual general meeting is regarded as one of the most
U
important institutions for protecting the members of the company. It is at this
meeting— even though it is held only once in a fiscal year- that the members of
the company get the opportunity to question the management on matters
relating to the following:
I t is only at this meeting that the members of the company have the chance not
to re-elect those directors in whom they have lost faith or confidence. Further,
as auditors also retire at this meeting, members of the company have another
opportunity to think about the re-election of these auditors.
ast but not least, it is at the AGM that members disclose the amount of
L
dividend payable by the company. While talking about dividends, it may be
noted that the board of directors makes recommendations on the amount of
dividend, whereas the members at the AGM declare the dividend. Further, the
dividend cannot surpass the recommended amount by the board of directors.
I f any of these rules are not complied with, the same will be said to be an
offence under the Companies Act, 2013. It has been discussed in the upcoming
passages.
he company has to send a clear 21 days’ notice to its members to conduct the
T
annual general meeting. The notice must mention the day, date, and location of
the meeting, along with the hour at which it is decided to be held. The notice
should explicitly mention the business to be conducted at the AGM. A company
is obligated to send the AGM notice to the following:
16
1. All the members of the company, including the legal representatives of
a deceased member and the assignee of an insolvent member.
2. The statutory auditors of the company.
3. All the directors of the company.
sually, an annual general meeting can be conducted at any time, provided it is
U
during business hours (between 9 am and 6 pm) and the day of the meeting is
not a national holiday. Now, talking about the location of the meeting, it can be
held either at any pre-decided place within the area of the jurisdiction of the
registered office or at the registered office itself.
elow are some of the noteworthy pointers in context to the date, time, and
B
place of holding an annual general meeting:
s per Section 96 of the Companies Act, 2013, a general meeting must be held
A
annually, as the name suggests. It is mandatory that all companies hold such
meetings at regular intervals. When the annual general meeting is held for the
first time after the company’s incorporation, it has to be held within a period of
17
ine months from the date of the closing of the financial year of the company,
n
and in other cases, within six months from the date of the closing of the
financial year. Further, as per Section 96 of the Companies Act, 2013, a
company has no obligation to hold any general meetings until it holds its first
annual general meeting. Such a relaxation is provided so that the company can
set up its final reports for a longer duration. Another provision that is provided
under Section 166(1) is that, with proper authorization from the registrar, the
company can postpone the date of the annual general meeting. The registrar
has the authority to postpone the date for a further three months at the most,
however, such a relaxation does not apply in the case of the company’s first
annual general meeting. Further, a company may not hold an annual general
meeting in a year provided the registrar has consented to it, however, the
justification for such an extension should be reasonable and genuine.
ccording to Section 96 of the Companies Act, the gap between two annual
A
general meetings must not exceed fifteen months. Further, Section 210 of the
Act states that a company must provide a report on the accounts of all the
profits and losses of the company, and if the company does not have any
profits, an income and expenditure report must be submitted.
1. When a company presents its report on profits and losses incurred, it
has to mention all the profits and losses endured by the company
right from the day of incorporation.
2. The account shall have an update of at least 9 months from the date of
the last annual general meeting.
3. A balance sheet along with the account report has to be submitted, as
well.
lso, after conducting the first annual general meeting, the next AGM must be
A
held within 6 months from the end of the financial year. If, due to any
unforeseeable circumstance, the company fails to hold the meeting, the tribunal
may grant an extension of 3 months.
Quorum
Public company
18
The quorum in the case of a public company shall consist of the following:
Private company
I n the case of a private company, only two members who are present will
constitute the quorum.
ny member of the company who has the authority to vote at a meeting will be
A
entitled to appoint a proxy, i.e., another person to attend and vote instead of
himself. The appointment of a proxy shall be inFormNo. MGT.11. Further, an
individual cannot act as a proxy on behalf of members exceeding a total of 50
and holding in aggregate not more than 10% of total capital with the authority
to vote.
fter conducting the annual general meeting, a report in the form of MGT-15
A
within a period of 30 days has to be filed. Further, underSection 121, the report
will include how the meeting was convened, held, and conducted as per the
provisions of the 2013 Act. If the company errs in doing so, a penalty of ₹1 lakh
shall be imposed. Further, on every officer who has erred in following the
procedure of the meeting, a penalty of ₹25,000 minimum shall be imposed, and
in case the issue persists, a penalty of ₹500 for every day after the failure
persists can be imposed, and the same shall be for a maximum of ₹1 lakh.
19
t he same mistakes, and if the provisions under Sections 96 and 97 are not
complied with, a fine of ₹5000 will be imposed on the defaulter until the
problem continues.
I n a company, there are certain matters that are so crucial to be discussed that
they need to be addressed immediately to the members, which is where an
extraordinary general meeting comes into play. Such meetings are discussed
underSection 100of the Companies Act, 2013. An extraordinarygeneral
meeting is any general meeting apart from the statutory meeting, an annual
general meeting, or any adjournment meeting. Such a meeting is held to
discuss special business, especially those businesses that do not fall under the
ordinary business that is discussed at annual general meetings. Such meetings
are usually called for matters that are urgent and for those that cannot be
discussed at annual general meetings. Extraordinary general meetings are
usually called by the following:
hile dealing with the above heading, one might wonder when and by whom an
W
extraordinary general meeting can be called. Let’s find out.
I n cases when the board of directors has some urgent matters to discuss and
such matters cannot be postponed until the next general meeting, the board of
20
irectors may hold an extraordinary general meeting if need be. The same is
d
discussed under Section 100 (1) of the 2013 Act.
embers who own 1/10th of the paid-up share capital of the company on the
M
date of receipt of the requisition on the date of exercising the voting rights.
embers who own 1/10th of the paid-up share capital of the company on the
M
date of receipt of the requisition on the date of exercising the voting rights.
By requisitionists
nder Section 100(4) of the Company Act, 2013, if a board does not, within 21
U
days from the date of receipt of a valid requisition in relation to any matters
thereto, take any steps to call a meeting to consider the matter not later than
forty-five days from the date of receiving such a requisition, then the meeting
may be called upon and conducted by the requisitionists themselves within a
time span of three months from the date of the requisition.
● Notice
he notice must specify the date, day, time, and place of holding the meeting,
T
and must be held in the same city as the registered office and on a working day.
21
rovided the permission is in writing. This can also be done via an electronic
p
request attached to a scanned copy to give such permission.
● N
o need of an explanatory statement to be attached to the
notice
here is no need for any explanatory statement under Section 102 to be
T
attached with the notice of an extraordinary general meeting that is convened
by the requisitionists and the requisitionists.
he notice of the meeting has to be served on all those members whose names
T
are on the list of registered members of the company. It should be served within
three days of the requisitionists depositing a valid request for conducting an
EGM in the company.
he notice of the meeting can be sent through speed mail, registered mail, or
T
even electronic means like emails. If there is an issue with serving the notice or
if some member does not receive the notice for any reason, the meeting shall
not beinvalidatedby any member.
ccording toSection 98of the Companies Act, 2013,if it is not possible to
A
conduct a meeting in the company, the tribunal may eithersuo motoor through
an application submitted by any director or member of the company who has
the authority to vote at the meeting-
1. Instruct to hold and conduct a meeting in a manner the tribunal thinks
fit, and
2. Provideancillaryorconsequentialinstructions asthe tribunal deems fit,
including any directives thus amending or supplementing in matters
relating to the calling, holding and conducting the meeting, the
operation of the clauses of the Act or articles of the company.
uch instructions may also incorporate any command that a member of the
S
company present in person or via proxy shall be deemed to compose a meeting.
22
he meeting held pursuant to such orders shall be referred to as a meeting of
T
the company that is duly called, held, and conducted.
Class meeting
e have already talked about the different types of general meetings above,
W
let’s now discuss what these class meetings are!
lass meetings, as the name suggests, are meetings conducted for shareholders
C
of the company that hold a particular class of shares. Such a meeting is
conducted to pass a resolution that is binding only on members of the
concerned class. Also, only members belonging to that particular class of shares
have the right to attend and vote at the meeting. Usually, the voting rules are
applicable to class meetings as they govern voting at general meetings.
23
uch class meetings can be conducted whenever there is a need to alter or
S
change the rights or privileges of that class as stated in the articles of
association. In order to execute such changes, it is crucial that these
amendments be approved in a separate meeting of the shareholders and
supported by passing a special resolution. UnderSection48of the Companies
Act, 2013, which talks about variations in shareholders’ rights, class meetings of
the holders of the different classes of shares must be conducted in case there
are any variations. Similarly, underSection 232,which discusses mergers and
amalgamations of companies, where a scheme of arrangement is proposed,
there is a requirement that meetings of several classes of shareholders and
creditors be conducted.
Meetings of directors
Board of directors
Board meetings
s perSection 173of the Companies Act, 2013, a company has to hold the
A
meeting of board of directors in the following manner:
1. The first board meeting has to be conducted within a span of thirty
days from the date of incorporation.
2. In addition to the above meeting, every company has to hold a
minimum of four board meetings annually, and there shall not be a gap
of more than one hundred and twenty days between consecutive two
meetings.
3. In matters relating to Section 8 of the Companies Act, with an
exemption by MCA dated 5.06.2015, it was held that the sub clause (1)
of Section 173 will be applicable only to the extent that the board of
24
irectors of such companies hold at least one meeting in every six
d
months.
. For
1 issuing shares and debentures.
2. For making calls on shares.
3. For forfeiting the shares.
4. For transferring the shares.
5. For fixing the rate of dividend.
6. For taking loans in addition to debentures.
7. For making an investment in the wealth of the company.
8. For pondering over the difficulties of the company.
9. For making decisions of the policies of the company.
1. A notice of not less than seven days must be sent to every director at
the address that is registered with the company.
2. Such notice can be sent either via speed post, by hand delivery, or
through any electronic means.
3. The SS-1 (mentioned above) states that if the company sends the
notice by speed post, or registered post, or by courier, an additional
two days shall be added to the notice served period.
4. In situations when the board meeting is called at shorter notice, it has
to be conducted in the presence of at least one independent director.
5. Further, if the independent director is absent, the decision occurred at
must be circulated to all the directors, and it shall be final only after
ratification of decision by at least one independent director.
6. Moreover, in cases where a company does not have its own
independent director, the decision shall be said to be final only if it is
ratified by a majority of directors, unless a majority of directors gave
their approval at the meeting itself.
Agenda
Quorum
I t is pertinent to note that the quorum has to be present not only at the time of
commencement of the meeting but also at the time of transacting business with
the company.
Committee of directors
27
he board of directors has the authority to form committees and delegate
T
powers to such committees; however, it is crucial that such a committee only
consist of directors and no other members. Further, it is mandatory for such
committees to be authorised by the articles of association of the company and
be in lieu of the provisions set out in the Companies Act. The meetings of all
these committees are held in the same manner as board meetings.
I n large companies, the following routine matters are looked after by the
sub-committees of the board of directors:
. Allotment,
1
2. Transfer,
3. Finance.
Other meetings
ebenture holder meetings are generally conducted from time to time to
D
discuss matters where the interest of debenture holders is involved, like at the
time of:
. Reconstruction,
1
2. Reorganisation,
28
. Amalgamation, or
3
4. Winding up of the company.
Creditors meeting
oreover,Section 108of the Companies Act, 2013, discusses the holding of
M
meetings of creditors. It also states that meetings be held in accordance with
the provisions laid down under the following sections of the said Act:
I n the creditors meeting, the creditors can decide to either approve, amend, or
reject the repayment plan. Further, the resolution professional must make sure
that any sort of changes or modifications suggested by the creditors of the
company are approved by the directors of the company before carrying out that
particular change. Furthermore, the resolution professional also has the
authority to adjourn the meeting of the creditors for a period of not more than
seven days at a time.
he notice to creditors must either be sent by post along with the notices
T
regarding the general meeting of the company for winding up. Additionally, with
the notice to the creditors, the company also has to advertise at least once in
the official gazette and once in two newspapers that are circulated in the district
where the company’s registered office or principal place of business is situated.
29
Procedure for conducting a company meeting
hile discussing the procedure for consulting the meeting of the creditors, the
W
following pointers are noteworthy:
hile conducting a meeting, the board of directors must submit a statement on
W
the position of the company’s affairs along with a list of the company’s creditors
and the estimated amount of their claims. The director who is entrusted with
the duty to conduct the meeting of creditors or who is in charge of the same
must attend the meeting and hold it at the same time.
ased on the decision that occurred at the meeting of creditors, the company
B
shall decide its next course of action. The decision could be one of the following:
1. The company would wind up on a voluntary basis if all the parties
agree to it unanimously.
2. In case the company is not able to repay all the debts from the assets
sold in the voluntary winding up of the company, then a resolution can
be passed from winding up the company by involving the tribunal.
Quorum of creditors
meeting cannot be commenced unless the creditors of the company, known as
A
quorum attend the meeting. The requisitequorumisas follows:
30
Quorum in case of creditors
I n the case of creditors, at least one creditor entitled to vote must be in the
quorum.
t times, even a court can pass an order to conduct such a meeting. It should
A
be noted that the term “contributory” encompasses every individual who is
accountable for making contributions to the assets of the company at the time
of winding up.
31
6. It is crucial that proper minutes of the meeting must be prepared.
n EGM is conducted to discuss special businesses, usually those that do not fall
A
under the category of ordinary businesses, which are discussed at AGMs. These
meetings are generally called only in cases of urgent matters or for those
matters that are not discussed at AGMs.
Class meetings
32
Board of directors meeting
board of directors is held for several purposes, namely, for making calls on
A
shares, issuing shares and debentures, forfeiting the shares, for discussing the
difficulties of the company, etc.
ebenture holders meetings are conducted to decide upon matters relating to
D
the reconstruction, reorganisation, amalgamation, or winding up of the
company.
Creditors meeting
reditors meetings are usually conducted for the creditors to either approve,
C
change, or deny the repayment plans of a company when it decides to wind up
voluntarily.
Conclusion
nder the Companies Act, 2013, it is important that companies conduct
U
requisite meetings throughout the year as and when necessary. These meetings
play a major role in shaping the company, as major decisions relating to the
company and its future are taken in such meetings.
here are three main categories of meetings in company law, and each meeting
T
has its own significance. Also, these meetings are further divided into
subcategories. For a recap, let us again take a look at the categories.
n annual general meeting can beheldat any place that is within the
A
jurisdiction of the city, town or village in which the registered office is situated.
34
urther, a government company also has the authority to hold an AGM at any
F
place approved by the Central Government.
o answer the second question, yes, a company can hold an AGM outside India,
T
however, a prior permission from the Central Government is required to carry
out such an activity.
35