Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
J Indon Med Assoc, Volum: 72, Nomor: 4, Agustus - September 2022 174
The Diagnostic Value of the Median Nerve Sonography in Chronic Phase Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
Abstrak
175 J Indon Med Assoc, Volum: 72, Nomor: 4, Agustus - September 2022
The Diagnostic Value of the Median Nerve Sonography in Chronic Phase Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
method, with a sensitivity of 70 – 90 % and divided into CTS and normal subject groups
specificity of 57 – 100% in diagnosing CTS. and both consisted of 20 subjects. This study
The measurement of the CSA of the median was approved by the Ethical Committee of
nerve is considered a sensitive indicator in Research in Health from the Faculty of Med-
wrist ultrasound.6 icine, University of Indonesia (No. 136/UN2.
Previous wrist or forearm ultrasound F1/ETIK/2017).
studies to determine the CSA of the median The inclusion criteria of CTS partici-
nerve in the normal and CTS patients have pants were adults aged 20 – 60 years old with
been conducted. At the wrist, the measure- dominant affected hand and had any CTS clin-
ment is performed at the height of scaphoid ical symptom’s severity ranging from grades
and pisiform bone, known as the inlet, and at 1 to 4. The inclusion criteria of the normal
the height of trapezium bone and hamate bone subjects were adults aged 20 – 50 years old
groove, known as the outlet. The CSA of the with no CTS clinical symptoms found on the
median nerve ranges from 7 to 10 mm2 and 9 dominant hand. The exclusion criteria of nor-
to 15 mm2 in CTS patients.6-9 Hobson-Webb, mal and CTS subjects were patients who had
et al was comparing the wrist-to-forearm ratio a history of surgery on the median nerve or
(WFR) of median nerve area between normal the wrist, median nerve tumor, post-trauma
population and CTS patients and found signif- patient, fracture in the wrist area, pregnant,
icant differences between wrist cross-section- polyneuropathy, carpal tunnel inflammation,
al median nerve area (10.0 ± 2.3 (7-14) in con- cutaneous and subcutaneous wrist edema or
trols and 14.3 ± 4.1 (8-34) in CTS patients), had median nerve anatomical variation fol-
forearm cross-sectional median nerve area lowing ultrasound. Additional exclusion crite-
(9.8 ± 2.4 (7-14) in controls and 6.9 ± 1.6 (3- ria for CTS subjects were patients who had re-
10) in CTS patients), and WFR between these ceived CTS treatment for at least two weeks,
population (1.0 ± 0.1 (0.8-1.3) in controls and whether it was oral conservative therapy, in-
2.1 ± 0.5 (1.5-3.8) in CTS population).10 An- jection therapy, or median nerve surgery.
other study by Burg, et al discovered that CSA NCS and nerve ultrasound were per-
normal values for the median nerve could vary formed on the subjects. CTS diagnosis was
in different demographical factors, including established and graded based on physical
race, age, height, and weight. In Dutch sub- examination and NCS using Bland Criteria.
jects, CSA of the median nerve in both left This study used a 15 MHz linear transducer
(8.3±1.9mm2) and right wrist (8.1±2.0mm2) with adjusted gain, magnification, and depth
was significantly bigger compared to Indian for each subject. A muskuloskeletal radiolo-
subjects’ CSA of the median nerve, which is gist with more than ten years of experience
7.0±1.1mm2 for the left wrist and 7.2±1.1mm2 examined the cross-sectional area of the me-
for the right wrist.11 There were potentially dian nerve from the inlet using an elliptical
different CSA normal values for the median line measured inside the hyperechoic layer.
nerve among Indonesian. However, currently, Median nerve vascularization was also eval-
there is no data regarding the CSA of the me- uated using Color Doppler Ultrasonography
dian nerve in normal and CTS populations in (CDUS) PRF 147 Hz. Other data obtained in
Indonesia. This study aims to find the cut-off this study were median nerve echogenicity
value of CSA of median nerve sonography to and the notch sign.
diagnose CTS. Data obtained were then analyzed by
2010 SPSS. We performed an independent
Methods T-test for normally distributed data and a
Mann-Whitney U test for abnormally distrib-
A comparative cross-sectional study uted data. The cut-off point was determined
using primary data was conducted from Feb- by creating the Receiving Operating Charac-
ruary to March 2017. Clinical examination teristic Curve (ROC Curve).
and NCS were performed in the Neurophys-
iology Clinic, Department of Neurology, Dr. Results
Cipto Mangunkusumo Hospital, Jakarta. The
median nerve ultrasound examination was Subject Characteristics
conducted in the Department of Radiology. A
total of 40 subjects fulfilled the inclusion cri- From a total of 40 participants includ-
teria and did not possess any exclusion criteria ed in this study, the mean age of normal and
included in this study by consecutive sampling CTS group was 38.0 ± 9.1 and 45.5 ± 8.2 years
and were taken written informed consent to old, respectively (p = 0.01). The subject char-
participate in this study. The participant was acteristics of each group are shown in Table 1.
J Indon Med Assoc, Volum: 72, Nomor: 4, Agustus - September 2022 176
The Diagnostic Value of the Median Nerve Sonography in Chronic Phase Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
Groups
Subject CTS Normal P-value
Characteristics
N (%) N (%)
Gender
Men 4 (44.44) 5 (55.56) >0.999
Women 16 (51.61) 15 (48.39)
Age group (years)
≤ 40 5 (31.25) 11 (68.75) 0.053
> 40 15 (62.50) 9 (37.50)
Groups Total
Cut off point of the cross-sectional area CTS Normal N (%)
N (%) N (%)
Above cut-off point (≥ 10,6mm2) 19 (95) 1 (5) 20 (100)
Below cut-off point (< 10,6mm2) 1 (5) 19 (95) 20 (100)
Total 20 (50) 20 (50) 40 (100)
of median nerve cross-sectional area of 10.6 CTS subjects, as shown in Table 3. Vascular-
mm2 with 95% (95%CI: 75.13-99,87%) sen- ization was not detected in any group. Median
sitivity, 95% (95%CI: 75.13-99,87%) speci- nerve ultrasound analysis
ficity, 95% (95%CI: 75.13-99,87%) Positive
Predictive Value (PPV) and 95% (95%CI:
177 J Indon Med Assoc, Volum: 72, Nomor: 4, Agustus - September 2022
The Diagnostic Value of the Median Nerve Sonography in Chronic Phase Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
Groups
Ultrasound CTS Normal P-value
Parameter
N (%) N (%)
Echogenicity
reduction
Yes 12 (100) 0 (0) <0.001
No 8 (28.57) 20 (71.43)
Notch sign
Present 3 (100) 0 (0)
Not present 17 (45.95) 20 (54.05) 0.231
Vascularization
detection
Present 0 (0) 0 (0)
Not present 20 (50) 20 (50) >0.999
179 J Indon Med Assoc, Volum: 72, Nomor: 4, Agustus - September 2022
The Diagnostic Value of the Median Nerve Sonography in Chronic Phase Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
the notch sign standard. If less ratio was used conflict of interest regarding the publication
based on the other study, the more notch sign of this paper.
would likely be detected.
Vascularization was not found in any Funding Sources
subject group. Mallouhi, et al12 obtained 95%
sensitivity, 71% specificity, and 91% accuracy The author(s) received no financial
of the increment of median nerve vasculariza- support for the research, authorship, and/or
tion using Color Doppler Ultrasound (CDUS) publication of this article.
which was confirmed by Power Doppler Ul-
trasound (PDUS) examination. Increased in- Acknowledgement
traneural vascularization of the median nerve
happens in the acute phase of CTS, while no The authors thank the Department of
vascularization is increment seen in the chron- Radiology, Department of Neurology, and De-
ic phase.16 In this study, 20 subjects had felt partement of Community Medicine Faculty of
symptoms of CTS for more than six months Medicine Universitas Indonesia for the con-
which was classified into the chronic phase, tribution to the facilities for the assessment
explaining why no vascularization was de- of median nerve cross-sectional area. We also
tected by the CDUS technique. The litera- thank Dr. Cipto Mangunkusumo National
ture stated that the PDUS examination has a Central General Hospital for the research per-
higher sensitivity to detect the small and slow mission approval.
streams. Evans17 stated that CDUS was not
sensitive to detecting small and slow streams, References
which made PDUS the recommended one.
The absence of intraneural bloodstream of 1. Pecina MM, Krmpotic-Nemanic J, Mark-
the median nerve in both subject groups, par- iewitz AD. Tunnel syndromes, peripher-
ticularly normal subjects, was thought to the al nerve compression syndromes: Carpal
account for the low sensitivity of CDUS to tunnel syndrome. 3rd ed. CRC Press LLC,
detect vascularization of the small stream. Washington DC; 2001. p. 126-44.
2. Demircay E, Civelek E, Cansever T, Ka-
Limitations batas S, Yilmaz C. Anatomic variations of
the median nerve in the carpal tunnel: a
Based on Bland Criteria, most CTS brief review of the literature. Turk Neu-
subjects in this study had a moderate degree rosurg. 2011;21(3):388-396. https://doi.
of severity, which led to a very significant dif- org/10.5137/1019-5149.JTN.3073-10.1
ference in median nerve CSA between normal 3. Aboong MS. Review Article: Pathophys-
and CTS subject groups. The measurement of iology of carpal tunnel syndrome. Neuro-
the CSA was performed only at the level of science. 2015; 20(1): 4-9.
the tunnel inlet, so there was a chance of un- 4. Tana L, Halim FXS, Delima, Ryadina W.
detected nerve entrapment at the distal carpal Carpal Tunnel Syndrome pada Pekerja
tunnel. Garmen di Jakarta. Bul Penel Kesehatan.
2004; 32(2): 73-82.
Conclusion 5. Fu T, Cao M, Liu F, Zhu J, Ye D, et al. Car-
pal Tunnel Syndrome Assessment with
The mean of median nerve CSA at the Ultrasonography: Value of Inlet-to-Out-
level of carpal tunnel inlet in normal subjects let Median Nerve Area Ratio in Patients
was 8.3 ± 1.4 mm2 and it was 15.4 ± 4.4 mm2 versus Healthy Volunteers. PLOS ONE
in CTS subjects. The cut-off point of the me- 10(1): e0116777. https://doi.org/10.1371/
dian nerve CSA at the level of the tunnel in- journal.pone.0116777
let was 10.6 mm2 with 95% sensitivity and 6. Hobson-Webb LD, Massey JM, Juel VC,
95% specificity to predict CTS. Further study Sanders DB. The ultrasonographic wrist-
is needed to measure CSA at the level of the to-forearm median nerve area ratio in car-
tunnel outlet, and to find the relationship be- pal tunnel syndrome. Clin Neurophysi-
tween the median nerve CSA and the severity ol. 2008;119(6):1353-1357. https://doi.
of CTS in the Indonesian population. org/10.1016/j.clinph.2008.01.101
7. Burg EW, Bathala L, Visser LH. Dif-
Conflicts of Interest ference in normal values of medi-
an nerve cross-sectional area between
The authors declare that there is no Dutch and Indian subjects. Muscle
J Indon Med Assoc, Volum: 72, Nomor: 4, Agustus - September 2022 180
The Diagnostic Value of the Median Nerve Sonography in Chronic Phase Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
181 J Indon Med Assoc, Volum: 72, Nomor: 4, Agustus - September 2022