Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
This article reports on 3D bioprinting of dissolved cellulose to produce small feature structures with a tailored design of
regenerated cellulose. The process consists ofdissolving cellulose with different origins and molecular weight in an ionic liquid
(l -ethyl-3 -methylimidazolium acetate), c ntrolled multilayered dispensing, and coagulation. The printability was examined by
studying the viscosity of cellulose solutio ns and by varying the settings of the printer setup regarding flow rate and needle
dimensions. Water was added as a nonso Ivent, enabling a coagulation process to form a gel structure of the printed solutions.
By printing on a coagulating gel, the printed solutions were regenerated within afew seconds. Rheology analysis showed that
higher concentrations of cellulose and cellulose ofa high molecular weight were shear thinning; providingfavorable printing
properties. Printing3D structures ofcellulose dissolved in an ionic liquidfollowed by coagulation by a nonsolvent was possible.
Both complex patterns of2D structures as well as multilayered prints were created to obtain 3D structures. This novel method
allows for theproduction ofspatially tailored 3D gels or membrane structures madefrom cellulose.
Introduction applications. Henke et al. have shown the Cellulose (1,4 -glucan) is apolysaccharide
feasibility to use wood -based bulk that shows several desirable properties
THE USE 0F 3D PRINTING as a bottom -up materials in a 3D printing process to such as renewability biodegradabfflty
fabrication method is increasing and is generate macroscaled 3D and high mechanical performance.
becoming more user-friendly and bioprinting is an emerging technology in Cellulose and cellulose -based materials
affordable. A wide range of materials can which suspensions, hydrogels, or have a very broad field of applications,
be printed using multiple different solutions are dispensed by a syringe -
for example, papers, tissues, hygiene
methods.' The common 3D printing needle system or an ink-jet nozzle. The products, packages, and food and drug
technologies such as ink-jet printing,2 print is solidified by physical or chemical compounds.I The supermolecular
fused deposition modeling,3 and selective crosslinking, or phase transition structure of cellulose'2"3 makes it
laser sintering4 are based on fusing processes such as coagulation or insoluble in most solvents at moderate
powdered materials or extrusion of precipitation. 3D bioprinting technology conditions, and the processing of
thermoplastic materials. There are also can be used for fabrication of acellular cellulose is therefore restricted to the use
some methods to solidify curable scaffolds for tissue engineering or when of fibers, fibrils, or microcrystals. In
polymers with laser or UV, called used with cells to fabricate living tissues recent years, research has shown that
stereolithography.5 3D printing has been and organs. The applications go far ionic liquids (ILs), for example, 1 -ethyl -
used to produce relative complex bilayer beyond the biomedical field since 3D 3 -methylimidazolium acetate (EminiAc),
tablets,6 force sensors,7 soft dielectric bioprinting enables the fabrication of 3D can be used to dissolve cellulose'4 in a
actuators,8 and soft scaffolds for tissue objects with high resolution and more environmentally friendly way
engineering,9 just to mention a few multiflinctionality compared with other solvents, which
Kopie von subito e.V., geliefert für Bibliothèque nationale du Luxembourg (SLIO3XOO241E)
Markstedt et al.
often are volatile, toxic, costly, or difilcult pulp (Domsjö AB; DP 750), and BNC The pressure drop in the needle, AP, the
to recover. (DP 2000 -8000") --was dissolved in the length of the needle, L, the radius of the
IL EmimAc (BASF ~90%; Sigma needle, R, and the viscosity; j, are all
Previously, cellulose dissolved in ILs has Aldrich). Three different concentrations constants.
mainly been studied to produce thin (1%, 2%, and 4% cellulose [w/wl) ofeach ¯ dv 4PR
hirns and fibers ofrecovered cellulose)'7 type of cellulose were prepared. The (1)
If cellulose is to be successful as an cellulose was slowly added to a 50 ml
alternative to polymers based on fossil bottle containing Emin,Ac kept at 85°C, For non -Newtonian liquids the power -
fuels,'8 it is important to develop ways to in order to minimize the risk of thermal law viscosity model is used (Equation 2),
control the structure and properties of degradation of the cellulose.24 The which describes the dependence of
the materials made from cellulose. This samples were stirred until all cellulose viscosity on shear rate,26 where k and n
would enable applications where a was completely dissolved and a clear are two fitting parameters.
defined structure ofthe cellulose material homogenously flowing solution was n-1
is necessary; for example, in packaging, attained (-'3 h for Avicel). The dissolving (2)
medicine tablets, scaffolds for tissue pulp and BNC samples were stirred at
engineering, and sensors.° 50°C overnight. The solutions used for The fitting parameters were determined
printing were dyed dark blue by adding by linear regression of the graphs from
The aim of the study was to control the blue mineral pigment Ultramarin the rheological measurements. To decide
structure and properties of cellulose via (Villafärg) to the EmimAc before for which region of the graph to perform
bottom -up fabrication. Because cellulose addition of cellulose in order to better the linear regression, an apparent shear
cannot be melted, extruded 3D visualize the prints. rate at the wail, 7app,25 was calculated,
bioprinting technology was found defined as in Equation 3, where Q is the
suitable to use when investigating the Rheological Measurements flow rate and R is the radius of the needle.
feasibility of printing 3D structures of
cellulose. The printability was examined For evaluation of the viscoelastic 7app (3)
by studying the viscosity of the cellulose properties of the IL solution, rheology 2rR3
solutions and by varying the settings of studies were performed on a Bohlin
the printer setup regarding pump rate, Rheometer CS 30 (Malvern Instruments). Printing
printing speed, and needle dimensions. The measurements were taken using a
To retain the 3D structure of the cone -and-plate geometry with a diameter Printing was done by a customized
dispensed solutions, water was added, of 25 mm and a cone angle of 5.4°. commercial available printer (MakerBot
enabling a coagulation process turning Steady-state sheer viscosity was ReplicatorlM2; MakerBot) where the
the print into a geL measured at shear stresses in the range of heating element and the filament head
0.24-370 Pa. IL solutions prepared from were removed and a syringe holder was
Avicel, dissolving pulp, and BNC with fitted. The parts needed for the syringe
cellulose concentrations of 1%, 2%, and holder were designed in Pro/Engineer
Materials and Methods 4% (w/w) were measured at room (Wildfire 4.0; PTC) and produced in a
temperature (25°C). The solutions were MakerBot ReplicatorTM2 (MakerBot).
Bacterial Nanocellulose kept in dosed containers until analysis to The syringe holder held both the 5m1
Biosynthesis minimize potential ambient moisture syringe containing the IL cellulose
absorption. Measurements at 50°C and solution and a vertical syringe actuator
Production and cleaning of the bacterial 80°C were conducted for solutions of 4% controlled by a syringe pump
nanocellulose (BNC) was done according dissolving pulp, 2% BNC, and 4% BNC (Alladin -1000; World Precision
to previously described protocols.21a2 (w/w). Both oscifiatory measurements Instruments) (Figure 3B). Attached to
The clean BNC was homogenized (IKA and stress viscosity measurements were
T25; Fisher Scientific) for 20mm at the syringe was a dispensing needle with
taken for each solution. a flat tip (Drifton AIS). Three sizes of
25,000 rounds per minute, and the
suspension was then frozen at -80°C. The dispensing needles were tested (Table I).
BNC was freeze-dried (Heto PowerDry Flow Rate, Pressure, and Needle To ease the filling of the syringe, the
PL3000). The dry BNC sponges were kept Size Simulation solutions were heated to 50°C to reduce
at 0% relative humidity (RH) until use.
the viscosity. During printing, the flow
MatLab (R2013b; MathWorks) was used rate of the syringe pump was set to
The BNC was torn into small flakes to simulate shear rates and pressures for
before being added to the IL. 10 il/min and printing was controlled by
different needle sLzes based on results MakerWare software (Version 2.2.2.89;
from the rheological measurements to MakerBot) (Figure 3A). The printing
Dissolution of Cellulose in EmimAc ensure an optimized setup when speed was set to 10mm/s.
printing. The theoretical shear rate and
Cellulose with three different degrees of the pressure in needles with different Coagulation
polymerization (DP) -for example, limer radius were calculated by assuming
molecular weight (Avicel PH -101; Fluka -
capillary flow. For Newtonian liquids, Water was used as a nonsolvent for
Sigma Aldrich; DP 150-30(Y1), dissolving the shear rate, t is given by Equation 1.25 coagulation of dispensed solutions.
Kopie von subito e.V., geliefert für Bibliothèque nationale du Luxembourg (SLl03X00241E)
3D Bioprinting of Cellulose Structures
Kopie von subito e.V., geliefert für Bibliothèque nationale du Luxembourg (SLIO3XOO24IE)
Markstedt et al.
A 10000
I A4%BNC
A2%BNC
I B 10000
IA4%BNC2Sl
I £4%BNC50C I
A
Lt AAAALAAA £1%BWC I Ia4%BNCUOC I
AA
L A I U4%Diss.Pulp I 1.4% DIss. Pulp 21' CI
1000 L
A ¯2% Ois,. Pulp 1000
A
A I.4%Dls5.Pulp50'CI
A AAA A A I U4% Diss. Pulp80'Cl
¯1% Diss. Pulp U)
£ALAAAAALAAAA ALLA
II2%BNC50C
£
t8 ¯4 Avicel II e ¯2%BNC2SC I
100
u
uaPAU!!rrnInn!ft!II. A
I
I
I
¯2%Avlcel
¯1%Avlcel
I
0.
100
AAAALAA4AAAAALALA A
L
1.2% BNCU0 C J
I
u,
u, o ¯.
8 o
__________
10 11 10
5
AAAMAAAAAAAAAAAAA A >
.IL--
I..-
t
0,1 4- 0,1 4-
0,001 0,01 0,1 1 10 100 1000 0,001 0,01 0,1. 1 10 100 1000
Shear rate (.1) Shear rate (s.4)
Figure'l. (A) Shear viscosity graph of BNC, dlssoMng pulp, and Avicel dissolved In Emlrn,c at concentrations of 1%, 2%, and 4% (wtw). .AJl
measurements were taken at 25'C. (B) Shear viscosity graph showing temperature dependence for 4% BNC, 4% dissoMng pulp, and 2% BNC
IwIw) at three difterent temperatures: 25cC, 505C, and 805C. BNC, bactefal nonoceilulose; Emirr,c, 1 -efhy1 -3-meth1lmidazollum acetate, Color
Images available onine at ww.lIebertpub.corrV3dp -
was made for shear rates between 0.1 ¯ (3n+1 . (3n+1) Q sizes. Figure 2A and B shows that the
and 100 s. The linear regression follows (5) shear rate and pressure required for the
i, 4n )
the equation 0.2 -mm-diameter needle is almost 6 bar
for aflow rate of 10 pl/min. The dispensing
J1=93.991y
-0.428
(4) By combining Equations 1 and 2 and needles should not be used at pressures
using the expression for shear rate from above 6 bar and therefore printing at
where the constants correspond to Equation 5, the expression for the pressure lower pressures is preferred. The
the fitting parameters in Equation 2; as a function of the flow rate is derived. 0.25 -mm -diameter needle shows a much
k = 93.991 and n = 0.572 for (n 1) = -
lower pressure at the same flow rate, and
-0.428. =1Q(3n+1)1 2kL (6) at the same time it still has a shear rate
L nirR3 ] above 100s', which reduces the viscosity
The fitting parameters were used to From Equation 6 it is seen that shorter Dispensing
calculate the shear rate and pressure ofthe needle lengths, L, reduce the pressure
non -Newtonian liquid during capifiary needed to achieve the desired flow. The Experimentally it was found that 4%
flow. By using Rabonowitsch correction shear rate (Figure 2A) and the pressure dissolving pulp worked best for printing.
in Equation 3, the true shear rate as a (Figure 2B) are plotted as a function of It had a viscosity high enough to keep its
function of the flow rate, Q, is given by the flow rate for needles ofthree different shape after dispensing while the pressure
A 1000 B14
.** 10.2mm
12
...e.
________
800 10.2mm °L¯'
.
.¯ .. 10
(0 .. e
.
600
e s
0. 8 e.
e e
.
e
JA A
0
0)
e 000000
Q)
.-
0OO0OS
4 e 0000000
200
e
... O 10.41mm øl 2
e
00
0000000 c.A.AA4AAAAA 10.41mm 01
AAAAAAAA
__________
0l 10 20 30 40 10 20 30 40
Flow rate, Q (t hmm) Flow rate, Q (& hmm)
Figure 2. Graphs of shear rate and pressure as a funcflon of flow rate of 4% (wfw) dlssoMng pulp dissolved in EmirnAc. The three different curves
represent needles of different sizes. The needle length Is 12.7mm and the Inner diameters are 0.2, 0.25, and 0.41 mm. (A) Shear rate as a funcflon
of flow rate. (B) Pressure as a function of flow rate. Color images available online at www.liebertpub.com/3dp
Kopie von subito e.V., geliefert für Bibliothèque nationale du Luxembourg (SL103X00241 E)
3D B)oprinhing of Celulose Structures
Coagulating Gel
By printing the IL solution onto an agar
gel, a good interchange with the
nonsolvent was achieved. The solution
coagulated within seconds after it was
printed onto the gel (Figure 3C and E,
and Supplementary Videos Vi and V2),
ensuring high resolution as seen in
Figure 4A, where a print on glass is
compared with a print on gel. The
nonsolvent diffuses through the print
from the bottom up, so when another
layer of solution is added, the top of the
first layer is not completely gelled or
covered in nonsolvent, making it possible
for the next layer to adhere to the first
one. While printing, water keeps on
Figure 3. OvervIew of the printing process. (A) Printing controlled by MakerWare software utiulng diffusing from the gel and through the
stereolithography file format (Sm) flies. (B) Customized MakerBot 3D ptinter, set up to print ionic print so that every added layer comes in
liquid solutions on agar gel. (C) Printing of 4% (w/w) dissolving pulp dissolved in EmimAc on an contact with the nonsolvent.
agar plate to obtain instant coagulation. (D) A close-up showing how the 'Ascous liquid is
dispensed layer upon loyer, (E) Schematic showing the diffusion of water from the agar plate to
the ptinted structure. Color images available online at www.liebertpub,conV3dp At approximately six deposited layers,
the print reached a critical height of
about 8mm, where the passive diffusion
needed for dispensing was low enough to multilayer interconnected prints. of nonsolvent through the print did not
be produced by the syringe pump. The Applying the nonsolvent by spraying coagulate at a sufficient speed, causing
customized printer ensured continuous using an atomizing nozzle ensured good the top of the print to slide and
flow, constant speed, and an even resolution retainment but caused subsequently collapse. The print height
movement enabling printing of complex complications when multiple layers were could be extended by progressively
shapes. To achieve the flow rates needed extruded on top of each other because decreasing the print speed, but eventually
for high -quality prints, needles with a of poor adhesion between layers. the print came to an almost halt. In order
minimum inner diameter of 0.41mm
were used. Figure 3 shows a schematic
image of the printing process.
Stereolithography file format (.STL) files
loaded to MakerWare software (Version
2.2.2.89; MakerBot) (Figure 3A) were
used to control the movement of the
customized printer (Figure 3B). The
patterns printed had complex geometries,
and Figure 3C shows an example of a
pattern extruded and coagulated on an
agar gel. The alignment of sequential
layers was also good, enabling multilayer
prints as seen in Figure 3D.
Coagulation 20 mm
Figure 4. (A) Ptinted tree of 4% (w/w) dissoMng pulp In EmimAc. The left halt shows ptinted
Water was used as a nonsolvent for solution without coagulation on a glass plate. In compaison, the right hait has been Instantly
coagulation of dispensed solutions. The coagulated by the agar gel. (B) Cylinders ptinted using vertical agar supports where the highest
nonsolvent application method turned structure is about 25mm. (C) Top view of the cytnders in Figure 4B. Color images available
out to be critical in order to achieve online at ww,lieberipub.corrV3dp
Kopie von subito e.V., geliefert für Bibliothèque nationale du Luxembourg (SL103X00241 E)
Markstedt et ai,
Kopie von subito e.V., geliefert für Bibliothèque nationale du Luxembourg (SLIO3XOO24IE)
3D Bioprinting of Cellulose Structures
and versatile platform for cellulose regeneration. Acta Biomater 27. Gericke M, Schiufter K, Liebert T,
processing and derivatization. Chem Eng 2010;6:2540-2547. et al. Rheological properties of
J 2009; 147:13-21. 22. Matsuoka M, Tsuchida T, Matsushita cellulose/ionic liquid solutions: from
16. Sundberg J, Toriz G, Gatenhoim P. K, et al. A synthetic medium for bacterial dilute to concentrated states.
Moisture induced plasticity of cellulose production by Acetobacter Biomacromolecules 2009;10: 1188-1194.
amorphous cellulose films from ionic xylinum subsp. sucrofermentans. Biosci 28. Sescousse R, Le KA, Ries ME, et al.
liquid. Polymer 2013;54:6555-6560. Biotechnol Biochem 1996;60:575-579. Viscosity of cellulose-imidazolium -
17. Kosan B, Michels C, Meister E 23. Härdelin L, Thunberg J, Perzon E, based ionic liquid solutions. J Phys Chem
Dissolution and forming ofcellulose with et al. Electrospinning of cellulose B 2010;114:7222-7228.
ionic liquids. Cellulose 2008;15:59-66. nanofibers from ionic liquids: the effect 29. Kuang Q -L, Zhao J-C, Niu Y-H, et al.
18. Zhu S. Use of ionic liquids for the of different cosolvents. J App! Polym Sci Celluloses in an ionic liquid: the
efficient utilization of lignocellulosic 2012;125:1901-1909. rheological properties of the solutions
materials. J Chem Technol Biotechnol 24. Mäki-Arvela P, Anugwom I, Virtanen spanning the dilute and semidilute
2008;83:777-779. P, et al. Dissolution of lignocellulosic regimes. J Phys Chem B 2008;l 12:10234-
19. Pacquit A, Frisby J, Diamond D, et al. materials and its constituents using ionic 10240.
Development of a smart packaging for liquids -a review. md Crops Prod
the monitoring of fish spoilage. Food 2010;32:175-201. Address correspondence to:
Chem 2007;102:466-470. 25. Collyer AA, Clegg DW. Rheological Paul Gatenholm
20. Kim J, Yun S, Ounaies Z. Discovery of Measurement, 2nd ed. Chapman & Hall, Arvid Waligrens Backe 20, lvi 4
cellulose as a smart material. London, 1998. SE-41346 Göteborg
Macromolecules 2006;39:4202-4206. 26. Goodwin JW, Hughes RW. Rheology Sweden
21. Zaborowska M, Bodin A, Bäckdahl for Chemists: An Introduction. Royal
H, et al. Microporous bacterial cellulose Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, United E-mail: paul.gatenholm@chalmers.se
as a potential scaffold for bone Kingdom, 2000.
MARYANNL1E8ER1 INC. ¯
VOL. 1 NO.3 ¯
2014 ¯
DOl: 10.1089/3dp.2014.0004 30 PRINTING 121
Kopie von subito e.V., geliefert für Bibliothèque nationale du Luxembourg (SL103X00241 E)