Professional Documents
Culture Documents
00
DJIA 37753.31 g 45.66 0.12% NASDAQ 15683.37 g 1.1% STOXX 600 498.52 À 0.1% 10-YR. TREAS. À 18/32 , yield 4.584% OIL $82.69 g $2.67 GOLD $2,371.70 g $19.10 EURO $1.0674 YEN 154.39
What’s
On Their Tippy Toes, Ballerinas Hit the Tip Top Biden
News Pushes
Business & Finance To Boost
Tesla’s board asked
shareholders to vote again in
Chinese
favor of Chief Executive
Musk’s multibillion-dollar pay
package after a court struck
down an earlier approval,
Steel Tax
calling the endorsement pro- Key tariff rate on
cess “deeply flawed.” A1
metals would be
An April stock selloff
deepened as the S&P 500, tripled as Beijing
Nasdaq and Dow industrials unleashes exports
retreated 0.6%, 1.1% and
0.1%, respectively. B10
BY ANDREW DUEHREN
The UAW’s historic effort AND BOB TITA
to unionize more than a
dozen factories outside De- President Biden called for
troit faces its first test this raising tariffs on imports of
week, as workers at VW’s steel and aluminum from
lone U.S. plant cast ballots. B1 China, beginning what is ex-
pected to be a broadside of pro-
Companies that unlock
JOHN NACION/GETTY IMAGES
he’s now thinking one “where the wind comes ment of troops. Halting ar- mental-aid package and Kyiv
CONTENTS Markets..................... B10 should top out at 1,907— sweepin’ down the plain.” mored columns depends largely has dithered over calling up
Arts in Review..... A11 Opinion................ A13-15
Business & Finance B2 Personal Journal A9-10
more than twice the height Matteson insists the on small explosive drones, more men.
Business News.. B3,5 Sports.......................... A12 of the tallest building in mostly residential, 134-story given meager supplies of artil- Without infusions of fresh
Crossword................ A12 Technology................ B4 town, and the biggest in tower can work given the lery shells. manpower and Western mili-
Equities........................ B8 U.S. News.............. A2-5 the U.S. city’s strong growth and “We are short of every- tary equipment, Ukraine could
Heard on Street... B11 World News......... A6-7
“We figure it would be says the project is fully fi- thing,” said one company com- lose more land and its best
iconic,” said Matteson, a nanced, though he de- mander operating around the troops, dimming hope of taking SPORTS
> California-based developer clined to provide details embattled city of Chasiv Yar. back the nearly 20% of its terri- NBA bans Raptors’
who briefly made tabloid on his backers. The war in Ukraine is at a tory already occupied.
news by dating one of the And then there is the critical moment as it ap- Please turn to page A7
Jontay Porter for life
Real Housewives of Or- notable weather. proaches a third summer. Rus- for betting on
s 2024 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
ange County. Talking “I’ll ask you the sia’s size is weighing on its Johnson sets up aid games. A12
All Rights Reserved Many offer other names it up Please turn to page A8 smaller neighbor, with waves of showdown in House ...... A4
A2 | Thursday, April 18, 2024 * * THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
U.S. NEWS
Justices Back
Probability of a recession, next 12 months April survey
Source: Wall Street Journal surveys of economists 63% 29%
Workers on 21%
FEDERAL RESERVE RATE INCREASES
CORRECTIONS
Chinese Among the steps the president
called for Wednesday was for
Mexico to prevent the flow of AMPLIFICATIONS
Steel Tariff Chinese steel into the U.S.
through its borders. Some law-
makers and companies are Reporter Summer Said’s
Continued from Page One Biden is also opposing Japa- broader warfare in the Mideast.
A recent surge in Chinese nese company Nippon Steel’s
exports has alarmed the Biden effort to buy U.S. Steel, repeat- Readers can alert The Wall Street
Journal to any errors in news articles
administration, helping resolve ing his argument that the in- by emailing wsjcontact@wsj.com or
internal debates over the eco- dustrial icon should remain by calling 888-410-2667.
nomic wisdom of tariffs. Trea- domestically owned. The presi-
sury Secretary Janet Yellen, dent has the ability to block THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
who had previously sought to the transaction under national-
(USPS 664-880)
lower tariffs on Chinese goods, security powers, though Biden (Eastern Edition ISSN 0099-9660)
was in China last week casti- President Biden spoke at the United Steelworkers headquarters in Pittsburgh. hasn’t committed to actually (Central Edition ISSN 1092-0935)
gating officials for threatening doing so. (Western Edition ISSN 0193-2241)
U.S. industry with a rush of in- Canada establish after months of care- Yellen leads the Committee Editorial and publication headquarters:
1211 Avenue of the Americas,
expensive exports. ful diplomacy. on Foreign Investment in the New York, N.Y. 10036
Mexico
“In manufacturing sectors Steel imports from China U.S., the national-security Published daily except Sundays and general
like steel, China’s already pro- Brazil have already fallen signifi- panel that can recommend the legal holidays. Periodicals postage paid at
ducing more than China or the South Korea cantly under the weight of tar- president block mergers. She New York, N.Y., and other mailing offices.
world can easily absorb,” Lael Japan iffs. In 2023, 598,000 tons of declined to comment Tuesday Postmaster: Send address changes to
The Wall Street Journal, 200 Burnett
Brainard, the director of the Germany steel were imported from on how the panel would view Rd., Chicopee, MA 01020.
White House’s National Eco- China, down 8.2% from 2022, the deal.
China U.S. imports of steel All Advertising published in The Wall
nomic Council, said. “China’s according to the U.S. Census “I certainly accept the pres- Street Journal is subject to the applicable
subsidies and other forms of Taiwan mill products in 2023 Bureau and the American Iron ident’s view, which he has rate card, copies of which are available
support lead to exports flood- Vietnam by country of origin and Steel Institute. By compar- stated, that the company from the Advertising Services Department,
Dow Jones & Co. Inc., 1211 Avenue of the
ing global markets at artifi- Netherlands ison, the U.S. imported 6.9 mil- should remain in American Americas, New York, N.Y. 10036. The
cially low prices, undercutting lion tons of steel from Canada hands. He hasn’t said specifi- Journal reserves the right not to accept
Italy an advertiser’s order. Only publication of
American steel.” and 4.2 million tons from Mex- cally that it is an issue of na- an advertisement shall constitute final
China’s response to the India ico, the two biggest sources of tional security, but one that acceptance of the advertiser’s order.
backlash has been to decry ris- Turkey foreign steel. has to do with the good of the Letters to the Editor:
ing protectionism, arguing Spain Kevin Dempsey, president of workers and the country,” she Fax: 212-416-2891; email:
their exports are the result of the American Iron and Steel said at a news conference. wsj.ltrs@wsj.com
Austria Need assistance with your subscription?
market dynamics. Institute, a trade group, said As part of Wednesday’s an-
All others By web: customercenter.wsj.com;
The trade moves come dur- Chinese steel exported to other nouncement, the U.S. Trade By email: support@wsj.com
ing a complicated political and 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 million countries can still undercut Representative will also open By phone: 1-800-JOURNAL
diplomatic moment for the NET TONS U.S. industry. He applauded Bi- an investigation into Chinese (1-800-568-7625)
White House. Biden is facing Sources: Census Bureau data, American Iron and Steel Institute den’s statement. shipbuilding practices. A group Reprints & licensing:
By email: customreprints@dowjones.com;
off against a Republican oppo- “China disrupts world mar- of unions had asked for the ad- By phone: 1-800-843-0008
nent who first put into place tariffs at the Pittsburgh head- workers,” said David McCall, kets both by subsidizing the ministration to study whether WSJ back issues and framed pages:
broad tariffs on Chinese goods quarters of the United Steel- the president of the union. production of steel and other the Chinese shipbuilding in- wsjshop.com
and is now campaigning on workers, a union that recently At the same time, Biden has products and by dumping dustry was using unfair prac- Our newspapers are 100% sourced from
raising them even more. Biden endorsed the president for re- sought to stabilize relations those products in the U.S. and tices that harmed U.S. firms sustainably certified mills.
and Trump are competing for election. “We’re grateful that with Beijing, and raising tar- other markets,” he said. and workers.
the support of unions who fa- President Biden is continuing iffs on Chinese goods could eat The concerns about steel —Ken Thomas GOT A TIP FOR US?
vor protectionist measures. to take bold action to ensure a up the good will the two su- are also spilling over into rela- and Catherine Lucey SUBMIT IT AT WSJ.COM/TIPS
Biden advertised the steel level playing field for American perpowers have managed to tions with allies and partners. contributed to this article.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Thursday, April 18, 2024 | A3
U.S. NEWS
Maui Fire Report Highlights Power Lines Origins of the Lahaina Wildfire
Destroyed building
BY DAN FROSCH wind played. about when its power lines ously served subpoenas to var- Fire perimeter
AND CHRISTINE MAI-DUC “The origin of the Lahaina were de-energized. ious Maui County departments, Pacific Ocean
Fire can be traced back to 6:35 Even before the Lahaina fire saying local officials’ lack of
A Maui County emergency a.m., when a fast-moving sparked that day, Hawaiian response had slowed the inves-
dispatcher called Hawaiian brush fire, later dubbed the Electric was dealing with dam- tigation. The county has said it MOUNTAIN
S
Electric early on Aug. 8 last ‘Lahaina AM Fire’ ignited,” aged poles from high winds is fully cooperating with the WEST MAUI
year and said one of the util- said the report, which was pro- and another blaze that had attorney general’s probe.
ity’s power lines had broken duced by the Fire Safety Re- sparked near downed lines on Shares in Hawaiian Elec-
and started a fire near La- search Institute in Columbia, the other side of the island. tric Industries have fallen
haina, according to a new re- Md., at the request of Lopez. “The rate of the fire’s 10.1% over the past five days,
port issued by the Hawaii at- Maui firefighters reported growth would ultimately im- amid investor anticipation of
torney general’s office. that blaze was extinguished pede the crew’s work in many the report. They rose 2.63% 6:35 a.m.
The blaze, which ultimately and returned to their quarters areas of Lahaina,” the report Wednesday, closing at $9.77. Fire breaks out around a Wi nd
Wind
destroyed the historic Maui at around 2 p.m. A second fire said. The Lahaina blaze de- Hawaiian Electric utility pole at
town later that day and killed was reported at around 2:55 Conditions deteriorated so stroyed more than 2,200 this intersection. Fire officials
at least 101 people, can be p.m., at the same location as dramatically that water pipes structures and caused an esti- later reported the fire was out.
traced back to that morning the earlier incident, according failed, and in some parts of mated $5.5 billion in damages,
incident, the report said. to the report. Lahaina, there was no water displacing more than 6,000 of 3:23 p.m. 1 2:55 p.m.
The 376-page report, re- A representative for Hawai- coming from fire hydrants. the town’s 13,000 residents. Carried by wind, the fire
leased by Hawaii Attorney Gen- ian Electric said the report’s 2 A fire in the same
Fire crews had to rely on As of February, Hawaiian jumps a main road and area as before ignites.
eral Anne Lopez on Wednes- description of the early-morn- scarce private water tankers Electric had been named in at burns seveal homes.
day, includes transcripts of ing fire aligns with what it instead, the report said. least 101 lawsuits by plaintiffs 3
communication from Hawaiian has said publicly. The com- Some fire crews became claiming losses related to the
Electric and emergency re- pany has previously said that trapped. Heat from the fire fire. Maui County has also been Lahaina
sponders about where the fire its power lines likely caused melted their boots and sealed sued by people seeking dam- 4
ignited and whether the util- that fire, but that its lines had shut the compartment doors ages resulting from the fire.
ity’s power lines had been de- been shut off for more than on one engine. Two additional reports 5 p.m. HAWAII
energized in high winds. six hours by the time the af- One firefighter used a po- about the Lahaina fire by the The fire reaches
While the report doesn’t ternoon blaze erupted. That lice SUV to rescue seven col- Fire Safety Research Institute Lahaina’s downtown. Auau Area of
assign blame for the disaster, second blaze, the company leagues, including an uncon- are expected to be released Channel detail
it provides the most compre- stated in response to a lawsuit scious officer who received later this year by the Hawaii
hensive account thus far of filed by Maui County, was the CPR, according to the report. attorney general’s office. Note: Building destruction based on analysis of satellite images taken Aug. 17
Sources: County of Maui (imagery); Associated Press (photo); OpenStreetMap (buildings);
the deadliest U.S. wildfire in a one that destroyed Lahaina. Wednesday’s report took —Katherine Blunt USGS (elevation); National Interagency Fire Center (fire perimeter);
century, including the roles Wednesday’s report doesn’t months to complete and faced and Jim Carlton Fire Safety Research Institute (timeline)
that downed power lines and address the utility’s claims delays. Lopez’s office previ- contributed to this article. Carl Churchill/THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
A4 | Thursday, April 18, 2024 P W L C 10 11 12 H T G K R F A M 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 O I X X ***** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
U.S. NEWS
Senate Dismisses
Republican Bid to
Remove Mayorkas
BY KATY STECH FEREK said Sen. Joni Ernst (R., Iowa)
AND MICHELLE HACKMAN on social media.
Mayorkas has called the al-
WASHINGTON—The Demo- legations false and defended
cratic-controlled Senate his record, and critics of the ef-
wrapped up the impeachment fort say the accusations
trial of Homeland Security amount to policy disagree-
Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas ments or performance failings,
in a matter of hours Wednes- but not impeachable crimes for
day, quickly rejecting the which he should be removed.
GRAEME SLOAN/BLOOMBERG NEWS
pected to need Democratic powers—always limited be- to combat the border crisis,” were threatening to sign the
votes to pass the rule tied to the cause of his narrow majority the hard-line House Freedom Democrats’ petition, people fa-
legislation, a once-routine pro- in the chamber and reliance on Caucus posted on social media. miliar with the discussions
cedural step that has repeatedly Democrats to pass key legisla- Rep. Andy Ogles (R., Tenn.), a said, and Democratic leaders
been blocked by GOP holdouts tion—were at a new low. On member of the group, said were encouraging members to
in this Congress. He said he Tuesday, a second GOP law- “Ukraine can go panhandle for reach out to GOP colleagues.
wasn’t seeking Democratic pro- maker, Rep. Thomas Massie money somewhere else.” Nearly all Democrats have
tection to keep his job. (R., Ky.), signed on to a motion Johnson has said for weeks signed the petition. Alejandro Mayorkas at an event in New York on Wednesday.
JOURNALISTS DON’T
Tesla Asks package, which consisted of a suit, didn’t return a request for
10-year grant of stock options comment Wednesday.
with 12 vesting tranches based Tesla said Wednesday that a
stockholders from whom we
already have heard—as funda-
mentally unfair, and inconsis-
‘JUST WRITE STORIES.’ Stockholders on the company reaching a vote in favor of the pay pack-
market capitalization of at age “could avoid a prolonged
least $650 billion while also period of uncertainty regard-
tent with the will of the stock-
holders who voted for it.”
THEY RECORD HISTORY. To OK Pay hitting various revenue and ing the company’s most impor-
profit targets. The company tant employee.”
cleared the last of those hur- Under the proposal, Musk
Special committee
In the proxy filing, Tesla in-
dles in 2022. has to hold on to the stock for cluded a report from a special
Continued from Page One Musk’s past equity five years after the options committee of the board, which
fect the pay case because it re- awards—the most recent of are exercised, incentivizing laid out the details of the Dela-
lates to actions taken while which is the contested 2018 him to keep working hard on ware court ruling compared
Tesla was incorporated in Del- option grant—have gained Tesla’s behalf. with the pay package, making
aware, legal experts said. more than $49 billion in value The judge in the Delaware the case that shareholders can
since 2020, including $1.4 bil- case, Chancellor Kathaleen Mc- use the details to make an in-
lion during 2023, measuring Cormick, criticized the process formed decision.
Upping the ante through year-end or the date for securing approval of “We suggest simply subject-
The proposals up the ante of vesting, the Musk’s compen- ing the original 2018 package
over Musk’s pay at a time company said in sation, citing to a new shareholder vote, ac-
$55.8B
when Tesla’s shares are sliding its filing. Musk’s “exten- companied by expansive dis-
and the company has lost bil- In urging sive ties” with closure as to the process un-
lions of dollars in market cap. shareholders to board members dertaken and the potential
The automaker’s growth is approve the and agreed to conflicts of interest that were
slowing as the market for EVs 2018 equity Maximum value of rescind the considered at the time,” the
cools. And the company is in award, Tesla ar- package, which special board committee’s re-
the midst of cutting 10% of its gues it could
the pay package at the time was port said.
staff as it recalibrates to a undercut the proposed for Tesla valued at a Tesla said there is only one
lower demand for its cars. eventual legal CEO Elon Musk maximum of Tesla board member on the
The vote is likely to reignite fees for the at- $55.8 billion. special committee: Kathleen
questions over Musk’s close torneys repre- A spokesman Wilson-Thompson. She has a
ties to the Tesla board and senting Richard for Delaware’s team of advisers. Rock, the
how it plans to compensate its Tornetta, the shareholder chancery court, where the pay- NYU law professor, said it is
chief executive, a serial entre- whose lawsuit put that pay in package case was heard, de- unusual for committees to
preneur with an array of other question. clined to comment Wednesday. have fewer than three board
business interests. Tornetta’s attorneys are Tesla said it plans to appeal members.
Separate from the 2018 pay seeking payment at least in the Delaware ruling. Tesla said many of its stock-
package, Musk has been seek- part on the grounds that by Robyn Denholm, the chair of holders disagreed with the
ing more voting power in fighting to reject the pay pack- the board, asked shareholders court’s decision and four of its
Tesla. The billionaire owned age, they helped Tesla save in a letter released Wednesday 10 largest shareholders asked
about 21% of Tesla including compensation it would have to vote to approve Musk’s pay for a meeting with the board
unexercised options as of otherwise been obligated to package. “Because the Dela- chair to discuss the issue.
March 31, according to the fil- give Musk. If shareholders ap- ware Court second-guessed Courts typically give boards
Learn more about the impact your ing. He is the largest share- prove that package, the benefit your decision, Elon has not deference on pay decisions,
journalism career can have on the world. holder in Tesla, the world’s vanishes, and with it the law- been paid for any of his work and it is rare for a judge to
Wall Street Journal reporter Erin Ailworth most valuable automaker. yers’ argument for high fees, for Tesla for the past six years strike down a compensation
and others share career advice at
Ahead of its annual share- Tesla said. that has helped to generate deal. McCormick said Musk
dowjonesnewsfund.org/careers.
holder meeting in June, Tesla A lawyer for Tornetta, who significant growth and stock- and Tesla couldn’t prove that
has proposed that sharehold- Tesla said owned nine shares holder value,” she wrote. “That shareholders were sufficiently
ers ratify Musk’s 2018 pay at the time he filed the law- strikes us—and the many informed about the deal.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * * Thursday, April 18, 2024 | A5
U.S. NEWS
mechanisms were not up to the botched their responses to complaints, which were
scale of this challenge,” Shafik Nassar—and bring the total brought to the Indianapolis
said. “They were designed for a price tag of legal payouts over field office on July 28, 2015, by
very different world.” liability for his actions to al- USA Gymnastics, the sport’s
Shafik, who became Colum- most $1 billion. national governing body.
bia’s president last July, faced The Federal Bureau of In- Indianapolis agents were
pointed questions from com- vestigation’s settlement was unsure if the allegations
mittee members critical of the reached in the fall and has against Nassar represented a
school’s response to instances Nemat ‘Minouche’ Shafik, left, president of Columbia University, told a House panel that the been accepted in principle by possible federal crime, accord-
of antisemitism on campus school’s systems ‘clearly have not been equipped to manage the unfolding situation.’ the women and girls who filed ing to the report. They were
since the outbreak of war in administrative also unsure
the Mideast in October. and speaking invitations from President Elizabeth Magill. Shafik and the other Colum- tort claims how to handle
The questions were part of a student groups to members of At that hearing, lawyerly an- bia officials conceded the against the concerns that
31/2 -hour hearing by the House foreign terrorist groups. swers to questions asked by school has more work in front agency in 2022 Agents were had been
Committee on Education and At the outset of the hearing, Rep. Elise Stefanik (R., N.Y.) of it. “The last six months on but hasn’t yet unsure if the brought to
the Workforce. The same com- committee chairwoman Rep. sparked a backlash from politi- campus have served as an ex- been finalized, them in India-
mittee in December elicited re- Virginia Foxx (R., N.C.), called cians, alumni and donors. Of treme pressure test,” said Ship- say people fa- allegations napolis—the
sponses from two Ivy league Columbia a hotbed of antisemi- the three university presidents man. “Our systems clearly have miliar with the city where USA
presidents that led to their tism. “Columbia stands guilty at the hearing that day, only not been equipped to manage matter.
represented a Gymnastics is
eventual resignations. of gross negligence, at best, Massachusetts Institute of the unfolding situation.” The claim- federal crime. based—when
The fallout from the war in and at worst has become a Technology’s Sally Kornbluth In their questions, some ants include Si- there were no
Gaza has been particularly in- platform for those supporting has retained her position. committee members focused mone Biles, Mc- allegations of
tense on college campuses, with terrorism and violence against Shafik appeared Wednesday on statements by Columbia Kayla Maroney, Nassar treating
many students torn over the the Jewish people,” Foxx said. morning with the co-chairs of professors attacking Israel. Maggie Nichols and Aly Rais- gymnasts there.
Oct. 7 attacks and Israel’s re- Committee members repeat- the school’s board of trustees, Rep. Tim Walberg (R., Mich.) man, the elite gymnasts who According to the report, the
sponse. Universities have faced edly probed decades of faculty Claire Shipman and David singled out Prof. Joseph Mas- were first identified in the Indianapolis agents didn’t for-
the challenge of balancing attacks on Israel that they said Greenwald, and David Schizer, sad, who teaches Arab politics. summer of 2015 as having mally document their meeting
speech rights with the rights of had set the stage for the anti- a law professor and former According to Walberg, Massad been potentially abused by with the USA Gymnastics offi-
students to attend school with- semitism that burst forth on dean of Columbia’s law school. said foreigners who join the Is- Nassar as well as dozens of cials, which came after the
out feeling harassed. campus after Oct. 7. During testimony Wednesday, raeli military are “baby-killing patients sexually assaulted by gymnastics body had con-
Jewish students at Columbia Shafik responded that the Shafik and others emphasized Zionist Jewish volunteers for Is- him for more than a year after ducted its own five-week in-
have alleged incidents of as- school continues to ramp up the steps the school has taken raeli Jewish supremacy.” the FBI was alerted to the ternal inquiry into concerns
sault, antisemitic graffiti such processes to address antisemi- since Oct. 7 to clamp down on Prof. Massad called Wal- gymnasts’ concerns. about Nassar. And after the
as swastikas, calls for the de- tism on campus and that pro- antisemitism. Shafik said the berg’s description of his work Michigan State University, meeting, Indianapolis agents
struction of Israel at rallies, fessors who have expressed an- school has revised its policies on and words false and defama- where complaints about Nas- spoke with only one gymnast:
tisemitic viewpoints wouldn’t student behavior and had sus- tory and said Shafik’s insinua- sar had been dismissed and McKayla Maroney. The report
be hired under her watch. pended 15 students and put six tion that he had been repri- buried several times, agreed to says the interview wasn’t
Watch a Video The hearing comes four on disciplinary probation for vi- manded was false. settle claims with hundreds of properly documented until
Scan this code months after heated exchanges olating them. At the end of the —Melissa Korn victims for $500 million in February 2017, which is
for a video before the same committee hearing Rep. Foxx chastised contributed to this article. 2018 and paid a $4.5 million around the time The Wall
about Shafik’s prompted the resignations of Shafik for misleading the com- fine to the Education Depart- Street Journal first docu-
testimony to Harvard President Claudine Gay mittee and said only two stu- NPR editor who criticized ment for violating federal mented the delays in the in-
the committee. and University of Pennsylvania dents had been suspended. coverage quits..................... B1 crime-reporting guidelines vestigation.
U.S.WATCH
WEATHER
THE RAIN
MATAYAH UTRAYLE-SHAYLENE SMITH/ASSOCIATED PRESS
Viola, an elephant with the Jordan World Circus, took a stroll through Butte, Mont., after being
spooked by a loud noise and breaking through a fence. She was recaptured in short order.
WORLD NEWS
Tehran Braces for Retaliatory Israeli Attack
U.S. and Europe are to raise government revenues.
In a sign Israel is consider-
pressing Netanyahu ing the U.S. and its allies’
to temper response message, Israeli officials as-
sured Gulf states and other
to weekend assault Arab countries on Monday
that its response to Iran’s at-
DUBAI—Iran is bracing for a tack wouldn’t endanger their
retaliatory Israeli attack on its security and would likely be
territory or proxies, as the U.S. limited in scope, The Wall
and European nations press Is- Street Journal reported.
rael for a response that avoids Already, Iran’s IRGC has en-
acted emergency measures for
By Rory Jones, its facilities across Syria.
Summer Said Some IRGC members have
and Laurence Norman evacuated their bases in Syria.
Only a few soldiers are staying
an escalation in tensions behind to defend arsenals.
caused by Tehran’s weekend Iran-linked facilities in Syria
WORLD NEWS
Ukrainian front line
Russian forces April 15
RUSSIA
R
RUS SII A
SIA
Kharkiv
Khark
Kharki
iv
Kupyansk
py k
RUSSIAN
OFFENSIVES
UKRAINE
UK
UKR
K AINE
E Lyym
Lyma
Lym
Lyman
yman
man
an
Dnnipro
D
Dnipro
pro
Avdiivka
Avd
Avdiiv
ivka
iv ka
SERHII KOROVAYNY FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Robotyne
Roboty
obot
oobotyne
tyyne
Mariupol
Mariup
Mar
Ma
M a iuppol
50 miles
Sea of Azov
50 km
Sources: Institute for the Study of War and AEI’s Critical Threats Project; staff reports
A Ukrainian soldier checks a vehicle in between missions in the Donetsk region of Ukraine. Andrew Barnett/THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
WORLDWATCH
AMR ALFIKY/REUTERS
Rain drenched Dubai on Tuesday, flooding highways and causing flight cancellations and delays.
Punishes
$12 trillion
10
Debtors 8
6
Continued from Page One
pay money back or are
deemed to be not cooperating 4
with legal proceedings.
Unlike in the U.S., China 2
doesn’t allow most people to
declare bankruptcy to write
0
off bad debts and move on
with their lives, a policy some 2010 ’15 ’20 ’24
Chinese scholars are criticiz- Source: CEIC
ing as unfair.
Household debt has surged calls from debt collectors have
by 50% in the past five years, become a daily occurrence.
to around $11 trillion. While With no option of bank-
that is lower than the $17.5 ruptcy, Qin concluded that a
trillion Americans owe, it is a new job was her only way out
huge sum in a country where of trouble. “As long as I’m still
LI RAN/XINHUA/ZUMA PRESS
people earn far less. living and have a life, I can work
With home prices falling, hard to earn the money back.”
deflation risks becoming en- That path has faced unex-
trenched and unemployment a pected difficulties. In 2021,
persistent challenge, Chinese while preparing for a business
leaders are eager to get people trip to Shanghai, more than
spending more. But funds go- People with bad debts are subject to a government blacklist, which bars them from the Fuxing bullet train, among other things. 700 miles northeast of Guang-
ing to pay for debt take away zhou, Qin realized she had lost
from those that could be used estate research firm China In- technology apps such as Ali- study the issue said China ur- A few years later, Qin se- her access to high-speed rail,
to splurge on new clothes or dex Academy. pay and WeChat also started gently needs a nationwide cured her first credit card. where a government I.D. is re-
pay for a vacation. The threat The increase in personal helping consumers secure personal-bankruptcy system With it, she bought a com- quired to buy a ticket. She
of punishment for falling be- debts is also partly a result of loans as their digital payment to achieve leader Xi Jinping’s puter to teach herself to type took the slow train—and later
hind on debt is making many more people using credit systems soared in popularity. goal of making the country so she could land a better job. quit that job in part because
families more conservative cards or tapping personal But when debts go unpaid, more equitable, by forcing When the bill was paid, Qin the travel restrictions were
with their money. credit lines to handle expenses a person’s income can be creditors and debtors to share said she tried to cancel the making it impossible.
Retail sales of consumer as the economy stagnates. seized by the state to cover the costs of soured loans. card. “Keep it for an emer- Local officials didn’t re-
goods in China rose 4.7% year- Many economists said a their liabilities, leaving debt- “A personal-bankruptcy gency,” the bank clerk told her. spond to questions about Qin’s
over-year in the first quarter, U.S.-style financial crisis is un- ors with a small allowance. system is a mechanism for Qin’s career flourished and case, and The Wall Street
the government said Tuesday, likely in China soon. State con- A 38-year-old man petitioned the redistribution of wealth,” she eventually moved to the Journal wasn’t able to verify
lagging behind total economic trol of the banking system courts in the southern city of Li Shuguang, a scholar who metropolis of Guangzhou. By some details of her account.
growth of 5.3%. As many in means the government can ab- Guangzhou to raise his monthly has advised the government 2010, she said, she was man- Today, Qin is working in a
China curtail spending, the sorb losses and inject capital in allowance to on bankruptcy aging bidding for a company shop in Foshan, south of
government is giving priority an emergency. Household 12,000 yuan, policy, wrote in that supplied fire-safety equip- Guangzhou, selling traditional
to turbocharging manufactur- debts have also largely pla- equivalent to a Chinese mag- ment to real-estate projects. Chinese medicines. With a base
ing and exports, a strategy teaued over the past two years, around $1,600, China’s housing azine commen- Her nest egg steadily grew salary of about $400 a month,
that is exacerbating trade ten- as many people give priority to from 9,500 yuan boom was a big tary online last from lucrative commissions. she has found it tough to put a
sions with the West. using extra cash to pay down to help pay for a summer. When the property sector dent in her debts, but said she
With so many Chinese con- liabilities rather than shopping newborn child. cause of the rise Movement slowed, she jumped industries. has managed to pay back two
sumers under financial pres- or investing in stocks. Judges denied on the issue An acquaintance had been in- of her credit cards so far, with
sure, Western companies in- The prevalence of large his request late
in personal has been sty- volved in a startup that was de- about $40,000 still to go.
cluding Apple, Estée Lauder personal debts is a problem last year, and in- debts. mied in part by veloping software to help small- Qin is trying to stay opti-
and General Motors have re- for China’s leadership. stead concluded opponents who business owners collect WeChat mistic, hoping that medicine
ported weaker sales in China. “Household debt booms tend that his allow- believe such a data to generate more foot traf- will be in high demand as
Chinese officials didn’t re- to lead to bad macroeconomic ance should be system would fic and aid marketing efforts. China’s population ages, open-
spond to questions about the outcomes, even in the absence cut by nearly 40% because he only encourage more people to Qin said she invested the ing the door to bonuses and
blacklisting system. The gov- of a financial crisis,” said Amir was already getting too much, shirk their debts. equivalent of around $150,000 potentially even running her
ernment has said previously it Sufi, a University of Chicago court records show. of her savings into the ven- own shop. Still, she has had to
only seeks to target those who economist. China has no simple A black market has emerged ture. The startup burned get creative to earn the cash
have the ability to repay their fix. “Once the cycle starts, it’s to serve people on the black- One woman’s saga through her initial investment to pay her debts.
debts but refuse to do so. usually one in which it’s pain- list. In one case, Shanghai au- For Qin, the former factory as it tried to get the software Her current role requires
China’s long housing boom ful, long and difficult to predict thorities busted a ring of scalp- worker, easy access to credit up and running. Qin said she Qin to collect payments from
was a significant cause of the when it will end,” Sufi said. ers who were booking high- backfired badly. then agreed to start putting customers using a digital wal-
rise in personal debts, because speed rail tickets on behalf of As a 16-year-old in 1999, some of its expenses, includ- let on WeChat. But she said
many people had to borrow debtors who were barred from Qin boarded an overnight bus ing office supplies, rent and that function on her account
more to afford homes. Some Tough system doing so. In early 2021, author- to the grimy manufacturing employee salaries, on her has been frozen several times
buyers took on extra debt to China has tried for years to ities tracked down a debtor hub of Dongguan, north of credit cards, and to tap per- since 2022, leaving Qin to seek
buy more properties for in- lift personal spending to ease who had been using the service Hong Kong, from her home in sonal credit lines she had ob- help from her family.
vestment purposes. Now that its economy’s traditional reli- and took him into custody, ac- rural southern China. tained via WeChat and Alipay. She decided not to tell her
the boom is over and prices ance on infrastructure and cording to a local court. Her parents, who are farm- A roadshow by the com- parents about the full scale of
are falling, many are stuck real-estate growth. Its banks The current system gives ers, couldn’t afford a payment pany was warmly received, she her troubles, however. If they
with debts they can’t handle. issued tens of millions of new priority to protecting credi- of less than $15 needed for said. But its prospects dimmed knew the truth, Qin said, they
The number of foreclosed credit cards each year, with tors—often powerful, state- her to take a high-school en- after the pandemic hit. “wouldn’t be able to sleep.”
homes listed for sale rose 43% outstanding balances jumping owned institutions—at the ex- trance exam. She vowed to The company’s struggles —Grace Zhu
in 2023 to about 400,000 50% between 2018 and 2023 to pense of helping struggling make it on her own and found left Qin with tens of thou- and Zhao Yueling
properties, according to real- well over $1 trillion. Private individuals. Scholars who work in factories. sands of dollars of debt. Phone contributed to this article.
being sucked away. “It is team and a pro-soccer sta- lication NonDoc, learned the nice Midwest feel to it, and a
probably one of the safer dium, bode well for the proj- building’s height was chosen supertall building would just
places to be,” he said. ect, Matteson said. to honor Oklahoma’s 1907 be obnoxious. And are we into
“I don’t know if you’re go- Still, his ambitious plans founding, he had a question: obnoxious?” A rendering of the proposed skyscraper in Oklahoma City.
ing to catch me at the top,” fall short for some.
quipped Pennington. “LMAOOOOO,” tweeted
Meeting at City Hall, com- Hayden Clarkin, a New York- Standing Tall
missioners had already ap- based transportation consul- Oklahoma City's Legends Tower would be more than twice as tall as the second-tallest building in the city, a big contrast
proved zoning for a carwash tant who goes by the Transit with other cities with tall buildings.
for tractor trailers by the time Guy on social media, after see-
they reached the skyscraper ing how the building would OKLAHOMA CITY NEW YORK CITY CHICAGO PHILADELPHIA LOS ANGELES SAN FRANCISCO
(Population: 0.7 million) (8.3 million) (2.7 million) (1.6 million) (3.8 million) (0.8 million)
project, glamorously dubbed tower over the vast expanse of
as a SPUD, or Simplified the city, with a few much
Planned Unit Development. smaller buildings peeking up
from downtown. Height
“If you talk to 1,000 Ameri- difference 226 ft.
‘A bit tacky’ cans and say, ‘Where do you 1,063 ft.
62 ft.
After hashing it out for think the tallest building in
about an hour, they ultimately America should be?’ I don’t
82 ft.
recommended the city council think anyone would pick Okla- 138 ft.
approve removing the height homa City,” he said. 217 ft.
restrictions for the $1.6 billion Economist Jason Barr,
four-building project, which whose book “Cities in the Sky”
also includes a lagoon and comes out next month, said
boardwalk amid restaurants the proposed tower stretches
and entertainment. (Penning- beyond what he calls the eco-
ton says he hopes the building nomic height of a building— Legends Devon One World Central Willis Trump Comcast Comcast Wilshire U.S. Bank Salesforce Transamerica
happens, despite his fear of the height that makes eco- Tower Energy Trade Center Park Tower International Technology Center Grand Tower Tower Pyramid
heights.) nomic sense—and goes well (Proposed) Center Tower Hotel and Tower Center Center
But they put off a decision into ego height. Ht.: 1,907 ft. 844 ft. 1,776 ft. 1,550 ft. 1,451 ft. 1,389 ft. 1,112 ft. 974 ft. 1,100 ft. 1,018 ft. 1,070 ft. 853 ft.
on large LED-style signs that “It would pencil out in New Note: The height of Willis Tower doesn't include its antennas, while other buildings in the group have spires that are counted toward their total height. Population is 2022 estimates.
would be draped above street York, it would pencil out in Sources: Census Bureau (population); Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat (building heights) Elizaveta Galkina/THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
PERSONAL JOURNAL.
© 2024 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved. THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, April 18, 2024 | A9
G
in Poughkeepsie, N.Y., says losing
rief is well recognized her middle-school teaching job
as a process people go ‘devastated my life.’
through after losing a
loved one. But less at-
tention is paid to the mized within the community of
grief of people with disabled people, Gurza says. “I re-
chronic illnesses and disabilities ally kind of fought back against
for the losses they’ve suffered. the toxic positivity that we some-
The grief of those with chronic times see” among disabled people,
health issues—for the loss of capa- Gurza says, “where it’s like, ‘You
bilities, for changed or ruptured can do anything if you put your
relationships, for changes in ap- mind to it.’ ”
pearance, for the forced end of a Some patients and therapists
career, or for former dreams for say that it can be helpful to find a
the future—can last for long peri- name for the experience and to
ods and recur often, as losses and know how common it is. With her
uncertainty become a constant clients, Mills emphasizes recogniz-
feature of life. ing the grief and working through
“What’s the next thing that [my it. “Embrace it. Feel it. Feel the
conditions are] going to take from feeling,” she says.
me?” asks Andrew Gurza, a disabil- She recommends other thera-
ity-awareness consultant who has peutic exercises as well, like talk-
cerebral palsy and chronic illness. ing to a photo of yourself from the
“What’s the next thing that I’m not past—a version of the self that
able to do anymore?” you are grieving. “Looking at it,
People who have intimate saying, ‘I love the way that you
knowledge of the grief that comes were, I miss you,’ ” she says.
with chronic health issues say it “Things that you’re feeling about
has a trajectory all its own—a tra- your past self.” She also recom-
jectory that many mental-health mends coping by taking up jour-
professionals, friends and family naling, creative hobbies and physi-
often don’t understand. The idea cal activity, if possible.
that everyone goes through five Sweeney feels her friendships
stages of grief—denial, anger, bar- with other chronically ill people
gaining, depression and accep- are crucial. “There’s so much con-
tance—doesn’t ring true for many sideration from my disabled
disabled people. Chronic illness, friends. I like to call us the magi-
other disabilities and the grief cians of compassion and empa-
they bring often run an unpredict- thy,” she says. “Because in every-
able course, easing but then flar- thing that we do, the superpower
ing up again, a cycle that can re- is that we’re always thinking
cur over time. about each other.”
Rouge, La., says she toms and the risk of nesses may face pressures from all not always be a negative or debili-
was enraged. “It was reinfection. sides to minimize their experience tating experience. “You can be in
one thing that I had “As soon as I of loss. Grief related to health con- grief and be a strong person,” Se-
dreamt about above couldn’t be that per- ditions may not be understood by bastiani says.
anything else in my son to them any- family and friends or may even be “Grief is a powerful tool and
more, they evapo- discouraged as a topic of discus- coping mechanism to realize
rated,” she says. Her sion. Mental-health professionals where you are in the moment,
Sweeney, who has grief for that loss often lack knowledge of the health where your life is a reflection on
long Covid, says she would recur when conditions clients are seeking help your life in the past,” she says.
has lost friends by she looked at photos coping with, compounding the “And it’s kind of a gift in that
not being present at of brunches and problem. sense, because many healthy peo-
in-person events. other events her Sometimes grief is even mini- ple never reflect on any of that.”
Successor beneficiaries
Heirs Get More Time for IRA Withdrawals Things get even more complicated
for successor beneficiaries, those
who inherit an inherited account.
Consider a 75-year-old grand-
BY ASHLEA EBELING the details could be finalized, essen- mother who inherited an IRA before
M
tially allowing these inheritors to 2020 from an older brother. She
any Americans who inher- skip taking money out. That re- started taking annual distributions
ited retirement accounts prieve has now been extended based on her life expectancy. Then
since 2020 won’t be required through 2024. she died in 2020 and left her inher-
to start pulling money out this year The penalty for failing to take re- ited IRA to her granddaughter. The
after the Internal Revenue Service quired IRA payouts is assessed at granddaughter is required to con-
said it was further postponing en- 25% of the amount that should tinue taking annual distributions
forcement of a law passed in 2019. have been taken out. and deplete the inherited IRA by
Part of the law required most in- “It’s very difficult at best to fig- the end of 2030, using the grand-
heritors other than ure it out,” said Larry mother’s life expectancy. She will
spouses to empty Steckmest, a retired get the reprieve for 2021, 2022,
IRAs within 10 years, lawyer in Novato, Ca- 2023 and 2024, leaving six years to
not over their life- The timing of lif. He inherited a empty the account.
times, as was previ- retirement modest IRA from his If the brother had been younger
ously allowed. Many mother who died at than the grandmother and died
heirs interpreted this distributions age 101 in 2022. He while taking distributions, the
to mean that they didn’t take any granddaughter would still have to
could hold off pulling
matters for tax money out for 2023 empty the account by the end of
money out until year strategy. because of the IRS 2030, but she would take annual
10, allowing them to delay and has been distributions based on his longer life
time their withdraw- waiting for the final expectancy, increasing the amount
als to lower their rules to decide what the IRA could grow tax deferred.
Most nonspouse heirs have to pull money from inherited retirement
taxes while the balances continued to do for 2024 and beyond.
accounts within 10 years under a law passed in 2019.
to grow. “You need to know what you’re re- Who still has to take a
Then, in February 2022, the IRS quired to do, and then you can decide 2024 required distribution?
proposed rules mandating annual what you want to do,” he said. treated as income by the IRS, so would have had to take out about This latest notice doesn’t change
withdrawals for these inheritors Assuming the final rules don’t the timing of these distributions $26,000 so far if it weren’t for the the rules for spouses and certain
during that 10-year period, if the change things, Steckmest will have matters for tax strategy. For some- IRS relief through 2023. The 2024 other beneficiaries, including the
original account owner had already to start taking annual distributions one on the cusp of retirement, the required distribution would have chronically ill, who generally must
been taking distributions. in 2025, based on his life expec- delay could reduce taxes. been about $9,000. still take annual minimum distribu-
After complaints from taxpayers tancy, and drain the account by Dec. “What you have to remember is “It becomes a tax question,” Ap- tions over their expected lifetimes.
and financial-services companies 31, 2032. you still have 10 years to deplete pleby said. In some cases, it might Heirs who inherited accounts before
over how to follow the new rules, the account,” said Denise Appleby, pay to wait to take distributions, 2020 are still subject to the old
the IRS said it wouldn’t impose When to take distributions an IRA consultant in Grayson, Ga. while in others, it might be more rules, which means they generally
penalties for missing required mini- Withdrawals from traditional inher- A 66-year-old who inherited a tax-efficient to time the distribu- must take annual withdrawals over
ISTOCK
mum distributions, or RMDs, until ited retirement accounts are parent’s $200,000 IRA in 2020 tions over the 10 years. their expected lifetimes.
A10 | Thursday, April 18, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
PERSONAL JOURNAL.
A
t a waste-management
facility in Morrisville,
Pa., workers load in-
cinerated trash into in- Waste firm sorts through incinerated trash for some of the $68 million in coins thrown away yearly
dustrial machinery
that separates and
sorts metals, then sends them to
get hosed down. The reward:
buckets of quarters, dimes, nickels
and pennies.
Americans toss as much as $68
million worth of change each year,
according to Reworld. The sus-
tainable-waste processing com-
pany is on a treasure-hunt to find
it. The company says that in the
seven years since it started the ef-
fort, it has collected at least $10
million worth of coins.
Coins are as good as junk for
many Americans. Buses, laundro-
mats, toll booths and parking
meters now take credit and debit
cards and mobile payments. Using
any form of physical currency has
become more of an annoyance, but
change is often more trouble than
it is worth to carry around. The
U.S. quarter had roughly the buy-
ing power in 1980 that a dollar
has today.
“If you lost a $100 bill you’d
look for it. If you lost a $20 bill
you’d look for it. If you lost a book
you’d look for it,” said Robert
Whaples, an economics professor
at Wake Forest University. “But a
penny, you’re just not going to
look for it.”
Whaples has encouraged the
government to kill the penny,
which costs about three times its
value to make. The U.S. Mint spent
$707 million making
coins last year. Canada,
New Zealand and Aus-
tralia have removed More than 20,000 of
their 1 cent pieces from the pennies came from
circulation. jars that Sara’s father
Because coins can and brother-in-law kept
be hard to spend, they in their closets. They
circulate slowly bought the rest of the
through the economy— pennies they needed in
or don’t circulate at all. 2,500 increments
More than half of the through their local
coins in the U.S. are sit- bank. In addition to the
ting in people’s homes, $655 they spent on
according to the Fed- pennies, they also
eral Reserve. spent $1,195 on sup-
plies such as glue and
Spotting change epoxy.
Many coins are also In one social-media
getting left behind. At video where they posted
airport checkpoints, the about the yearlong pro-
Transportation Security cess of building the
Administration collects floor, they tossed a
hundreds of thousands of dollars cents, coins from Kuwait and D.C. handful of pennies onto
worth of them each year. Coins metro tokens. the finished product
are left in couch cushions or cars, In a trailer, human checkers and watched them prac-
then sucked into vacuums and wearing gloves sorted through tically vanish.
sent to landfills, said Dominic buckets of this material, separat- Reworld employees
Rossi, Reworld’s director of fi- ing the good coins from every- Reworld started in 2017 an low customer use. In 2016, TD also have a soft spot for hard cur-
nance and business support. thing else. operation to recover some of the Bank pulled the plug on its coin- rency. They set aside the buffalo
Reworld started collecting Because the trash was inciner- millions of dollars worth of coins counting machines after an inves- nickels they find. These coins were
change in 2017 after noticing more ated before it reached the facility, that are thrown away every year. tigation found that it was giving only made between 1913 and 1938,
of it in the trash. The company re- some coins were mangled beyond Coins and other metals are filtered customers less money than they and they can be worth thousands
covers 550,000 tons of metals an- recognition. Of the $10 million in through multiple machines. were putting in. of dollars.
nually, including soda cans, old coins the company has recovered, Today many people cash in “As a child I used to get excited
pipes, keys and silverware. some $6 million has been in good their coins at Coinstar kiosks in about buffalo nickels, I thought
On a recent Monday, a bucket enough condition to use. tirely with bags of change. grocery stores and gas stations. they were rare,” said Angelo Ger-
loader lifted trash from its waste Reworld gathers anywhere On busy days, Raposo helped The company has said it operates aci, the facility’s operations super-
CAROLINE GUTMAN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL (3)
facilities into various sorting ma- from $500,000 to $1 million in them count every coin. Sometimes, more than 24,000 kiosks across visor. “Here we have jars and jars
chines. A rattling gray one sepa- coins a year, which it turns over to they counted twice to double check, the country and has processed of buffalo nickels.”
rated out anything that was the a third party to count and deposit while she looked apologetically at more than 800 billion coins. The coin recovery program is
color of a coin. Another one sepa- to local banks. the other waiting customers. just a small part of Reworld’s rev-
rated anything round and flat, like “I could feel the annoyance and One person’s treasure enue. The company makes most of
a coin. And another machine sepa- Checkout annoyances almost even rage,” said Raposo, This year, Sara and Justin Ilse fin- its money from operating incinera-
rated heavier metals like coins Most coins don’t end up in the now a copy editor in Rhode Island. ished building a floor for their tion facilities that burn trash to
from lighter metals like aluminum. trash. But that doesn’t mean they People tend to bring their extra home’s 230-square-foot entryway generate fuel.
It took 35 minutes to clean are wanted, either. change to the bank to trade in, but out of 65,507 pennies. Employees believe that one day
what the machines spat out. Then, When Cassandra Raposo worked it is getting harder to do even “It was a way to encase some- coin usage will cease altogether,
squeaky clean coins were spread as a Dollar Store cashier, customers that. Capital One and PNC re- thing that doesn’t get viewed with and so will the collection opera-
out on an iron rack to dry. They would often come to the register to moved their coin-counting ma- much value in daily life,” Justin tion. But they’ll always have the
were still mixed in with euro pay for $5 to $10 purchases en- chines about a decade ago due to said. buffalo nickels.
E
Most commenters voiced apprecia-
mily Holtzman, a 27-year-old tion for the rule. Some, however, de- Phone problems
yoga instructor in New York, is fended the right to film. Working Kayla Kleinman taught at various
frustrated that her students out is a great opportunity to share New York studios until last June.
won’t stop bringing phones to her online, they say. People can feel mo- When she posts fitness-related con-
class. tivated to try a new class by watch- tent on Instagram, she only takes
So she put a note on her class ing someone else’s workout videos. photos before or after—but not dur-
door: “Please no phones! Especially “The broader issue is how much ing—her workouts.
no filming yourself working out.” of our life do we need to be sharing Before the pandemic, she’d see a
She didn’t expect the note would online?” Holtzman says. phone in the studio only once in a
stir so many emotions. while, with people apologizing for
Many people think phones have No consent bringing it in.
gotten out of hand. Documenting Corinne Keogh, a 25-year-old self- In the summer of 2021, when in-
our lives for social media or group employed home-goods designer in person classes returned, people be-
texts has become the norm. Few New York, has noticed more people came more combative, says the 33-
moments exist now where people filming themselves during workout year-old. She told one person to put
don’t whip out their phones to take classes during the past year and a videos (that she knows of). to avoid capturing other people. her phone in a locker and the
a photo or video. half. She finds it “off-putting.” Many chains, such as 24 Hour Garza sees filming herself as a woman just responded, “No.” When
The gym had been a holdout in “It’s a little daunting going in Fitness, New York Sports Club and necessary part of her job as a Kleinman stood her ground, the
our phone-obsessed society. Taking those workout classes where every- Life Time, prohibit filming of other beauty and lifestyle content creator. woman finally put it away.
out a device during a workout used one is super fit,” Keogh says. “The people without their consent. She also records herself throughout Jacob Reynolds, a 32-year-old
to be met with side-eye from nearly last thing I would want is to be on Others have looser restrictions, the day doing other things, such as yoga instructor in New York, says
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL, ISTOCK (2)
everyone in the room. someone’s viral video.” opening up the possibility that peo- getting coffee or studying. he won’t begin class without asking
Now, more people are throwing She doesn’t believe the people do- ple will be filmed without giving Liv Schreiber, a 27-year-old con- students to turn their phones off.
that old etiquette away and using ing it are being rude or mean. consent to appear in their fellow tent creator and event-company On several occasions, people have
their phones in yoga studios, in They’re just so used to putting every classmates’ videos. founder, routinely works with stu- yelled at him.
workout classes and at the squat part of their lives online that they Ana Gaby Garza, a 21-year-old ju- dios and gyms to film her workouts, “Honestly, there is probably not a
rack. The movement has other gym might forget others don’t like it. To nior marketing major at Texas A&M in exchange for pay or comped month that goes by that I don’t
goers questioning their filming coun- avoid being on camera, she picks a University, regularly films herself classes. She says she takes care not have to deal with someone like
terparts online and in person. It has spot in the front of the class. She during workouts. She tries to sit on to catch anyone else on camera. that,” says Reynolds, who has been
sometimes led to confrontations. hasn’t spotted herself in any TikTok the side or at the back of the class, She often films at CorePower an instructor for 11 years.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. NY Thursday, April 18, 2024 | A10A
A10B | Thursday, April 18, 2024 NY / NE THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
Everyone
should be
welcome at
the table.
We’re on a mission to provide a billion meals by
2030. Because over 30 million Americans don’t
know where their next meal is coming from. It could
be anyone, even your neighbors. Let’s break the
cycle of hunger, together.
NourishingNeighbors.com
Nourishing Neighbors is a program of Albertsons Companies Foundation,
a 501 (c)(3) designated nonprofit.
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, April 18, 2024 | A11
ARTS IN REVIEW
Brancusi’s ‘The Kiss’ (1907), left; ure also emerging, in the same
‘Sleeping Muse’ (1910), above; and year, from the elemental form of
‘La Timidité’ (1917), below. the cube. And then there’s Rodin,
whose 1894 “Sleep” is paired with
Brancusi’s rendering of the same
tial reconstruction of Brancusi’s subject in 1908. In both, we bear
studio featuring a workbench, witness to the same transforma-
tools and the artist’s handmade tion: the smooth visage of the re-
forge. The stools that Brancusi de- posing figure emerging from the
signed for his studio were some- rough marble. A short distance
times repurposed as plinths. Some away, we find a better-known
are displayed here alongside ex- work: “Sleeping Muse” (1910), a
amples of traditional Romanian polished oval bronze whose facial
woodwork. features are delicately hinted at.
But as fascinating as this sup- By placing these works in close
plemental material is, it rarely proximity, the exhibition suggests
ART REVIEW deepens one’s understanding or an artistic genealogy of sorts.
A Singular Sculptor
appreciation of Brancusi’s star- What astonishes is how quickly
tling originality. For that, there’s and confidently Brancusi was able
no substitute for a direct confron- to find his individual style based
tation with the sculptures that are on endless refining and a new em-
grandly displayed in the exhibi- phasis on the materiality—the
tion’s sprawling galleries. rough or smooth wood, stone and
An exhibition focuses on the timeless works of Constantin Brancusi In addition to the sheer volume bronze surfaces—of his work.
of works on display, Through his art, Brancusi
the show’s best and strove to arrive at “the very es-
BY A.J. GOLDMANN he sold his watch in Basel for food most revealing feature sence of things.” Yet however sim-
and came down with a debilitating is the airy presentation plified his human and animal
Paris fever in Alsace before arriving in that makes it possible forms appear, however great the
‘ART—THERE STILL HASN’T BEEN the City of Lights on July 14—Bas- to walk around a great distance between them and the re-
any art—art is just beginning,” tille Day—1904. Paris remained his many of the sculptures. alistic sculpture of the past, it also
Constantin Brancusi said in 1927. home for the rest of his life. In It’s a rare invitation to feels wrong to call Brancusi an ab-
Despite the quote’s braggadocio Paris, Brancusi quickly matured as examine Brancusi’s stract artist. The meaning of his
and panache, it’s not entirely clear an artist. He would spend the next works from all sides work—birds in flight, endless col-
why the Centre Pompidou has cho- half century living in the city, cre- and one that deepens umns connecting the earth to the
sen it as the slogan of its sprawl- ating the majority of his works in our appreciation of sky—is right on the surface. But
ing Brancusi retrospective; it rubs several ateliers on Impasse Ron- how boldly he con- while his own work is neither ab-
against and sometimes contradicts sin, a cul-de-sac in Montparnasse. ceived of his works as stract nor conceptual, Brancusi
much of what one discovers in In 1956, a year before his death objects in space, sub- paved the way for both develop-
this stunningly arrayed and mus- at age 81, he bequeathed the con- ject to the dynamic in- ments in 20th-century art.
cularly installed display of work tents of his studio to the French terplay of light, materi- All of which brings me back to
by the Romanian visionary, whose state on the condition that it be ality and movement. Brancusi’s nearly century-old
new and immediate artistic lan- reassembled and put on display. An intimate early claim that “art is just begin-
guage, based on simple forms and Ever since, the atelier’s various re- gallery that focuses on ning.” We can share in the utopian
direct carving, has led many to constructions have become artistic Brancusi’s affinity with hope that there are masterpieces
consider him the father of modern pilgrimage sites. The most recent, art both ancient and to come, that the muses have more
sculpture. in a Pompidou annex designed in modern is among the to reveal. As the exhibit makes
Assembled by a curatorial team 1997 by Renzo Piano, closed this show’s most compel- clear, Brancusi was not suggesting
led by Ariane Coulondre, head of past fall ahead of a complete reno- ling. Thus, we find his that art of the past was but a pro-
modern collections of the Musée vation of the Pompidou that is to “Torso of a Young Girl logue to his own efforts, but giv-
national d’art moderne, “Brancusi” begin next year and is projected to III” (1925) sharing a ing voice to the idea of the artist—
is the sculptor’s first major retro- last until 2030. display case with the and of art—that perpetually
spective in nearly three decades. Works from the Atelier Bran- sleek marble head of strives for formal and spiritual pu-
The last one, organized in 1995 cusi form the core of the retro- over 120 sculptures is a trove of an idol from 2600-2400 B.C. found rity. That goal is, by definition, out
and also at the Pompidou, in- spective. But there are also impor- photographs, documents, films, on the small island of Keros in the of reach, but Brancusi’s uncompro-
cluded nearly a quarter of Bran- tant loans from the Tate Modern, paintings and, in one of the show’s Cyclades. The smooth ovoid shape mising and radically original body
SUCCESSION BRANCUISI/ADAGP, PARIS (3)
cusi’s roughly 400 sculptures and the National Museum of Art of Ro- few missteps, music. Hearing the and the high polish of Brancusi’s of work, which strikes a contem-
traveled to the Philadelphia Mu- mania, the Museum of Modern Gymnopédies by the composer onyx work suggest his deep famil- porary viewer as remarkably fresh,
seum of Art. The new retrospec- Art, the Art Institute of Chicago Erik Satie, who was a friend of iarity with Cycladic art. For a more came miraculously close.
tive, by contrast, won’t be seen and the Philadelphia Museum of Brancusi’s, waft through the gal- modern confrontation, his first ver-
anywhere else. Art. (After Paris, Philadelphia is leries can put one in mind of an sion of “The Kiss” (1907), whose Brancusi
After leaving Romania in 1903, the city with the most Brancusis, immersive exhibition. In the con- lovers are united in a single stone, Centre Pompidou, through July 1
Brancusi set out on foot from Mu- thanks to the enthusiasm of the text of this dignified presentation, is displayed alongside “Crouching
nich to Paris 120 years ago. Ac- collectors Louise and Walter the beautiful yet overfamiliar tune Man,” André Derain’s sandstone Mr. Goldmann writes about
cording to his account of the trek, Arensberg.) Supplementing the is distracting. There’s also a par- sculpture of a coiled crouching fig- European arts and culture.
A
initiated now will adhere to exact- specialist the truly extraordinary
ncient Pompeii has never ing professional standards. Early feature is that black background—
ceased to astonish. During one last year an extensive and well- the usual Roman practice was to
of the very earliest excava- funded dig was launched under the cover most of the wall with
tions there, in 1772, participants supervision of Gabriel Zuchtriegel, painted decoration. This all prom-
were stunned by the impressions director of the Pompeii archaeologi- ises to be wholesome grist for the
left in the hard debris by the bodies cal park, assisted by an interna- art historians’ mill.
of Pompeians trying desperately to tional team of scholars, with its ini- Since the 19th century, scholars
flee the destruction of their city dur- tial focus on houses in a sector of have invested huge and ingenious
ing Vesuvius’ eruption in A.D. 79. De- the Via di Nola tentatively probed in efforts to create an elaborate history
spite their best efforts, the excava- the late 19th century. This new en- of Roman art (based, in fact, very
tors managed to terprise has already largely on the evidence from Pom-
extract only a single lived up to expecta- peii), recognizing four major chrono-
impression, of the tions, and it caused logical phases, with an ever-increas-
breast of a sadly Archaeologists something of a me- ing number of subdivisions within
anonymous woman. in Italy recently dia frenzy last June those phases. This has provoked,
Carefully preserved when excavators re- hardly surprisingly, a sizable number
and displayed in the discovered ported the discovery of fresco paintings, with scenes A scene from the magnificently of scholarly skeptics who find the
local museum, it be- of a fresco depicting drawn from an almost unlimited preserved frescoes that adorn the whole scheme too clever by half.
came a tourist sensa-
a stunning a circular flat bread range of themes—exotic landscapes, hall’s black walls. These new finds might well prompt
tion, even inspiring banquet hall. on a silver tray, with architectural fantasies, terrifying yet another subtle variant of one of
“Arria Marcella,” the some sort of topping, beasts, or simple domestic events part of his campaign to woo her, the later phases (in the absence of
highly acclaimed no- perhaps cheese and like trips to the baker. But the Apollo granted Cassandra the subsidiary decoration it is hard to
vella by the noted fruit—quickly dubbed, newly discovered examples are dif- power of true prophecy, but when say precisely which one). But the ex-
19th-century French writer Théophile with much culinary license, the ear- ferent. The individual scenes are she ultimately rejected him he cavators have a more mundane ex-
Gautier. The breast has since disap- liest ever painting of a pizza! isolated within huge black back- added a curse that those same planation: The walls were left black
peared, but Pompeii has steadfastly The announcement this month of grounds that occupy almost the en- prophecies would never be believed. just to disguise the sooty deposits
ITALIAN CULTURE MINISTRY/ASSOCIATED PRESS
remained the Old Faithful of archae- the team’s most recent discoveries tire wall, something unparalleled in When Paris returned to Troy with from the oil-burning lamps.
ological sites, offering up rich spec- is in its own way even more sensa- Pompeii. Helen, the wife of the Spartan King The debate promises to be
tacles at regular intervals, and amaz- tional. The focus is on the unearth- Two images stand out, facing Menelaus, Cassandra correctly but drawn out, and, in the time-honored
ing us with images ranging from ing of a spacious banqueting hall. each other on opposite walls of the fruitlessly foretold that his action academic tradition, bitterly conten-
plaster casts of doomed humans and Its mosaic floor, with more than a hall, both related to the preliminar- would provoke a war. This takes us tious. In the meantime, the rest of
animals writhing in their death million small white tiles, is impres- ies of the Trojan War. In one, a male to the second scene, of a young us can simply enjoy the haunting
throes to raunchy paintings of vivid sive enough, but the real treat is to can be clearly identified by his lyre man encountering a woman and beauty of the art.
and richly imaginative sex scenes. be found on the walls, with their as the god Apollo. He faces a young her female attendant. Here the
Surprisingly, some 250 years af- magnificently preserved frescoes. woman reclining on an ornate chair, identifications might have been Mr. Barrett is emeritus professor of
ter those initial explorations, about Over the years excavators of almost certainly Cassandra, daugh- more tricky, but the artist has classics at the University of British
a third of the site remains unexca- Pompeii have found vast quantities ter of the Trojan king Priam. As kindly added labels, in Greek, widely Columbia, Vancouver.
A12 | Thursday, April 18, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
SPORTS
LeBron James’s Newest Teammate Is a Podcaster
JJ Redick was a role player during his 15-year NBA career. But in the new age of sports media, he’s a superstar.
BY ROBERT O’CONNELL game, it’s a breath of
fresh air.”
J
J Redick would have enjoyed Just once, Redick
playing basketball with LeBron said, he was nearly an
James. Over his 15-year NBA on-court teammate of
career, Redick made his living mak- James’s. In 2018, he
ing 3-pointers, and sharing the was a free agent, and
court with James would have pro- the Lakers could have
duced plenty of open looks. used an influx of
But as it turned out, it took re- shooting. The Lakers
tiring from professional basketball ultimately went in a
for Redick to finally become different direction,
James’ teammate. When the NBA’s though, and Redick
all-time leading scorer decided he was glad to stay in
wanted to record a podcast about Philadelphia, where
the strategy and nuances of his his family was already
sport, he joined forces with an ex- located.
player who had never so much as “‘LeGM’ never
made an All-Star roster. traded for me,” said
That’s because Redick’s hum- Redick, using a nick-
bler playing career prepared him name for LeBron that
for a starring role in the sport’s highlights his sway
new media ecosystem. with front offices. “So
If you care about basketball at that’s on him.”
all in 2024, you’re hearing plenty “Mind the Game” is
from Redick. As a game analyst, he a simple podcast
was recently promoted to ESPN’s about complex ideas.
top broadcast team. He makes reg- In each episode, James
ular appearances on the highly and Redick sit in a
rated “First Take” show. He’ll be sparsely decorated
announcing the NBA Finals in studio, sip wine and
June. dive deep into basket-
Now he’s landed the kind of in- ball’s granular details.
terview that journalists who have Subjects include indi-
dedicated their lives to covering Lakers star LeBron James, left, chats with JJ Redick during a taping of their podcast ’Mind the Game.’ vidual play calls and
basketball can only dream of—a the NBA’s broad strategic evolu-
regular one-on-one with James, in tion, from the Golden State War-
which Redick picks the brain of the James has seldom revealed the itous route. After an All-American As his own playing career riors’ passing to James’s own
greatest player of his generation. inner workings of his basketball run in college, Redick struggled to wound down, Redick started pod- championship-saving block in the
“Mind the Game” has become a hit mind. Though he has flashed a find his footing in the NBA, spend- casting and found an eager audi- 2016 Finals.
among hoops nerds and casual photographic memory at press ing his first couple of seasons with ence. Eventually he launched his Together, the two can recall se-
fans alike, zooming up the podcast conferences, he only occasionally the Orlando Magic glued to the own company, ThreeFourTwo Pro- quences more than a decade old
charts and racking up millions of appears on a podcast, even though bench. ductions. (James’s is called Unin- with absolute precision. Remem-
views on YouTube. numerous active NBA players now So Redick refined his jump shot terrupted, and “Mind the Game” is bering a play he ran with the
“It’s a high,” Redick said of host them. and studied plays until they be- a collaborative venture between Cleveland Cavaliers in the late
geeking out with James. “And it’s So when James decided to start came second nature, transforming the two of them.) 2000s, James initially positioned a
just rooted in this love and obses- a show of his own, a time when he from a rookie who couldn’t get Suddenly, an athlete who had teammate in the corner nearest the
sion with a silly sport that we all could have chosen just about any- onto the floor to a veteran who been widely loathed when he was dribbler. “You know what, I take
obsess over.” one in the world as his co-host, performed his job to perfection. the face of the Blue Devils was the that back, I’m sorry,” James
On “Mind the Game,” James there was only one person he That evolution gave him a spot in toast of the basketball intelligent- quickly corrected himself—that
and Redick speak a refined dialect wanted on the other microphone. the record books—his 1,950 career sia. Redick got players to open up teammate, some 15 years ago, had
of basketball language, one that’s In podcasting, Redick is the sport’s 3-pointers are the 20th-most in about the difficulties of life in the been on the opposite side of the
vaguely familiar but much more biggest star. NBA history—and the all-angle NBA and could break down a pick- floor.
advanced than you would hear Redick and James first met over view of the sport that every pro- and-roll play with the seriousness Redick compares such moments
during national NBA broadcasts. two decades ago, when they were fessional analyst seeks. of a math professor working to being in the flow as an athlete,
James casually mentions “two-nin- both high-school prodigies—Redick “That’s what makes it work,” through a proof. when preparation and creativity
ing”—staying in the lane just shy destined for Duke, James headed Redick said. “Outside of being a “Most guys don’t pay attention are working in perfect sync. “You
17 18
14 15 16
19
24 Back muscle
25 “Respect
For Life for Betting on Games
for Acting”
author BY ROBERT O’CONNELL participation in one or more amid a rush of legal sports
20 21 22 games for betting purposes, gambling in America. Sev-
Hagen
THE NBA BANNED Toronto and betting on NBA games.” eral NFL players have been
23 24 25 26 27 28 29 26 Becomes Raptors forward Jontay Por- Porter’s representatives suspended for betting—ei-
annoyed ter from the league on didn’t immediately respond ther by placing bets on foot-
30 31 32 33 28 Not natural Wednesday, in the fallout to a request for comment. ball or for betting within
for from a gambling scandal. The league also found team facilities. Ippei Mizu-
34 35 36 37 31 Leisure Porter won’t be eligible for that Porter had broken the hara, the interpreter for Los
activity, for reinstatement. cardinal rule of professional Angeles Dodgers superstar
38 39 40 Last month, the NBA athletes by betting on his Shohei Ohtani, has been ac-
short
launched an investigation own sport. Just this calen- cused of stealing millions
41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 32 Brillo rival
into suspicious activity dar year, Porter had bet from Ohtani to place bets
36 Complete lack around Porter’s perfor- more than $54,000 on the with an illegal bookmaker.
49 50 51 52 of evidence, mances. The 24-year-old for- NBA and won payouts of Mizuhara was fired, and
say ward, a little-used player more than $76,000, accord- Ohtani hasn’t been accused
53 54 55 56 39 Move for les who bounced between the ing to the league’s investiga- of any wrongdoing.
danseurs Raptors and their G-League tion. Porter is the brother of In a press conference this
57 58 59 60 affiliate, had attracted un- Michael Porter, Jr., a starter month, Silver noted the seri-
40 Ashes holder
usually heavy betting inter- for the defending-champion ousness of Porter’s alleged
61 62 63 64 65 66 67 41 Horace’s
est. On a March 20 game, Denver Nuggets. offenses while saying “You
“Ars ___” one bettor placed an “There is nothing more can’t turn the clock back” on
68 69 70 42 Like some $80,000 wager that Porter legal sports betting.
important than protecting
irretrievable would fall short of certain the integrity of NBA compe- “At least in a legalized
71 72 73 files statistics. When he checked tition for our fans, our structure, there’s transpar-
43 Their backs out of the game early, claim- teams and everyone associ- ency,” Silver said. “Just as in
show ing he was ill, it suggested ated with our sport,” NBA cases we’ve dealt with
IT’S A ROBBERY! | By Alan DerKazarian cooperation between Porter commissioner Adam Silver where very sophisticated
Monticello
Across 34 Part of a New 59 ___-Magnon 8 Phillies 46 By means of and the bettors. said, “which is why Jontay computers, when there’s ab-
1 Apes York borough 61 “___Seen All baseman The NBA said on Wednes- Porter’s blatant violations of errational behavior, you be-
name Bohm 47 Election day that they were banning our gaming rules are being come aware of that rather
7 Tight spot Good People“ winners
35 H+, e.g. (Yes song) 9 Slayer’s Porter for “disclosing confi- met with the most severe than betting that takes place
10 Well- 48 Gray, in a dential information to sports punishment.” in the shadows or under-
produced 37 Cartoonist 62 See 57-Across genre
way bettors, limiting his own Porter’s activity comes ground.”
substance Thomas 68 Cartoon 10 It began
50 “I didn’t do it!”
13 Leopardus 38 •Earner of collectible with the
52 Off-color
pardalis, merit badges 69 Musk of 1968 British
familiarly SpaceX Hard Court 54 Intact
41 Many dad
14 Lab coat jokes 70 Tidies up Champion- 58 Slaughter on
problem? ships a baseball
44 Mum’s mum 71 Spots on
11 Their diamond
16 Country club 45 Fodder screens
figure workload is 60 Just
for many 72 Approx. fig.
decreasing 63 Tolkien’s
17 •Aces, in crossword 73 Someone
poker slang 12 Does poorly Leaflock or
clues who’ll help you
in, in the Skinbark
19 Mother of 49 Bagel choice to look better,
informally casino 64 Ruby in the
the winds 51 •Scorpion 15 Up to the movies
Boreas, attack Down
Zephyrus, present 65 “Gnarly!”
53 Third-party 1 Unruly
Notus and assembly 18 Spanish 66 Neapolitan
Eurus account flower number
55 Bit in a horse’s 2 Post-E.R.
20 “Dude!” place 22 Twilight, 67 Foreign policy
mouth
21 •Support 3 EGOT winner
quaintly advisory grp.
staff 56 Facilitate
Brooks Previous Puzzle’s Solution
23 Swigging 57 With
4 Feverish, say H A T E R O H
O C H I P
sound 62-Across, I R I S H S P U
R P A N E
1976 Steve 5 You might J U M P Y W E B
B S U R F S
27 Wanders in
DAVID ZALUBOWSKI/ASSOCIATED PRESS
OPINION
Reagan Just Saved Israel BOOKSHELF | By Steven McGregor
Allow me to
identify who
saved the
recognized the necessity of
missile defenses than Israel, a
small, population-packed
sensus, said SDI would make
our own nuclear-missile arse-
nal less vulnerable, increasing
position in the House.
The Ukraine trench-war
conflict, with Mr. Putin sacri-
Imperial
people of Is-
rael last
weekend from
Iran’s missile
country that couldn’t afford
the conceit of some U.S. poli-
ticians, then and today, that
the American landmass is
the Soviet Union’s incentive
to launch a pre-emptive first
strike. Reagan insisted he
wasn’t trying to protect mis-
ficing Russian men on a mas-
sive scale, is likely an anom-
aly. More relevant to the
future of war is the calcula-
Overreach
WONDER
barrage: Ron- somehow safe from missile at- siles but the U.S. population. tion by Iran’s Islamic Revolu-
LAND
ald Reagan. tacks. Within two years of If we have learned any- tionary Guard Corps that mis-
Habsburgs on the Rio Grande
By Daniel
In 1983, Reagan’s announcement, Is- thing the past three years, it siles will be the great By Raymond Jonas
Henninger
President rael signed a memorandum of is that Mr. Biden is satu- equalizer, as Yemen’s ragtag Harvard, 384 pages, $35
F
Reagan in a understanding with the U.S. to rated in the don’t-provoke-a- Houthis have proved in the
televised speech proposed develop missile defenses. The response school of foreign Red Sea. or the U.S., the 1840s were a decade of continental
what he called the Strategic fruits of that four-decade policy. By happenstance, the expansion. Texas was annexed in 1845 and soon
Defense Initiative. Its core partnership couldn’t be House Armed Services Com- became the 28th state. In 1848, with the defeat of
idea was that the U.S. would clearer. mittee held a hearing on U.S. Mexico in the Mexican-American War, the U.S. acquired a
build defense systems that Though the U.S. didn’t de- Sen. Biden mocked as missile defense Friday, hours vast swath of territory that included the entire Southwest
could shoot down nuclear- velop a space-based system, before Iran launched its at- and present-day California. The California Gold Rush
armed ballistic missiles, then the technology has enabled ‘reckless’ the idea of tack. The committee mem- started that same year, accelerating westward migration.
expected to be fired by the an arsenal of ground-, air- defending against bers, both Republicans and These events led a French observer to note, in 1851, that
Soviet Union at the U.S. and sea-based interceptors. Democrats, had a prescient Mexico had previously belonged to a people “of Latin
mainland. Israel—with a capable scien- ballistic missiles. complaint, asking Pentagon origin” who were “essentially Catholic.” But U.S. expansion
Democrats and much of the tific establishment dedicated officials about America’s un- meant that the continent was being overtaken by a popula-
defense establishment mocked to the country’s survival—de- derinvestment in its defense tion “of Germanic origin and of protestant religion.” His
the idea, with Sen. Ted Ken- veloped a multilayered mis- He says Israel should “take industrial base and why the remark, says Raymond Jonas, points to the “racial geopoli-
nedy naming it “Star Wars.” sile-defense system. Iron the win” because retaliation Biden defense budget would tics” that drove the French to align themselves with vari-
Sen. Joe Biden summed up Dome protects from short- risks provoking a wider war. cut some $400 million from ous factions in Mexico and thus prevent further Anglo-
the opposition in a 1986 range missiles of the sort Shortly after Hamas’s Oct. 7 the Missile Defense Agency. “I Saxon conquest. The result was the Second Mexican Empire
speech to the National Press fired from Lebanon by Hez- attack on Israel, Mr. Biden al- just don’t understand the ra- —a fascinating episode in imperial ambition and the subject
Club: bollah, which reportedly pos- lowed the expiration of a 2015 tionale behind many of these of Mr. Jonas’s informative “Habsburgs on the Rio Grande.”
“Star Wars represents a sesses more than 100,000 United Nations Security cuts,” Rep. Seth Moulton (D., The empire’s beginnings can be traced to December 1861,
fundamental assault on the missiles and rockets of Ira- Council resolution prohibiting Mass.) said. It’s harder to un- when France, Britain and Spain landed troops in Vera Cruz
concepts, alliances and arms- nian, Russian and Chinese or- Iran from exporting missile derstand this week. to collect debts owed by Mexico, then a republic under the
control agreements that have igin. David’s Sling protects and drone technology. How- Reagan’s missile-defense leadership of President Benito Juárez. Because of civil war,
buttressed American security from short- to medium-range ever symbolic the resolution, legacy does have an important Juárez had only recently regained control of Mexico City.
for several decades, and the missiles, while the Arrow 2 the mullahs couldn’t have advocate: Donald Trump. As (Since independence from
president’s continued adher- and Arrow 3 systems hit mis- missed Mr. Biden’s stand-back president in 2019, Mr. Trump Spain in 1821, Mexico had
ence to it constitutes one of siles at high altitudes. approach. revived the U.S. missile-de- been led by a variety of gov-
the most reckless and irre- Reagan’s experience with From the day Russia in- fense program, and he re- ernments, including the First
sponsible acts in the history the Strategic Defense Initia- vaded Ukraine, Mr. Biden has stated that commitment, cit- Mexican Empire, in 1821-23.)
of modern statecraft.” tive has lessons for the U.S. slow-walked sending military ing Reagan, during this year’s After months of negotiations,
By universal acclamation, today, with the unmissable technology to Kyiv—long- New Hampshire primary. Spain and Britain withdrew.
the hero of last weekend was irony that ardent SDI foe Joe range missiles, Patriot air-de- Mr. Biden deserves credit France, however, pressed on,
Israel’s missile-defense sys- Biden is pocketing its political fense systems, tanks, fighter for helping Israel repel Iran’s moving 6,000 troops inland.
tems. The world watched in benefit this week. jets—for fear it would pro- missiles and drones. It’s clear, Against a force twice their
real time Saturday night as Among the arguments voke Vladimir Putin. though, that the world has size, the French suffered a
Reagan’s commitment to against Reagan’s missile-de- Mr. Biden said he’d provide entered a new era of state- defeat at Puebla, about 80
shooting down missiles pro- fense plan was that it would Ukraine with “whatever it sponsored missile attacks— miles southeast of Mexico City,
tected Israel’s population “provoke a response” from takes, as long as it takes.” If first Russia into Ukraine and on May 5, 1862, an event cele-
from the more than 300 the Soviets. SDI’s develop- he’d done that sooner than now Iran’s swarmed assault brated to this day as Cinco de
drones and ballistic and ment got bogged down in the later, the technology-savvy on Israel. To meet that threat, Mayo. The French, however, re-
cruise missiles fired by Iran politics of arms-control nego- Ukrainians could have Mr. Biden would have to ad- grouped and with reinforcements
and its proxies at cities across tiations between the U.S. and avoided a frozen conflict and mit Reagan was right. That took Mexico City the following year. To solidify French
Israel. U.S.S.R. Reagan’s critics, in- their support likely wouldn’t isn’t going to happen. power, Napoleon III, the French emperor, offered the crown
No nation more quickly cluding a virtual media con- be stalled by Republican op- Write henninger@wsj.com. of Mexico to Ferdinand Maximilian, an Austrian archduke
and a member of the House of Habsburg. He was pro-
claimed emperor of Mexico on April 10, 1864.
Be a Wary Reader in the 2024 Election The Second Mexican Empire did not last long.
Domestically, it was plagued by financial problems. Interna-
tionally, it was never recognized by the U.S. According to Mr.
By Karl Rove J.D. Vance (R., Ohio) were and anti-Muslim messages. It 4,800 Facebook accounts im- Jonas, the turning point came in June 1866, when, near the
A
among those who repeated tricked members of the personating real people—in- town of Camargo just south of the Rio Grande, Maximilian’s
s Speaker Mike Johnson the super-yacht charge. Nei- Trump team and family, who cluding Reps. Nancy Pelosi army was ambushed by the army of the republic, a
maneuvered last week ther has set the record retweeted and cited its posts. (D., Calif.) and Jim Jordan reconstituted force loyal to Juárez (now president in exile).
to bring Ukraine aid up straight or admitted being Despite repeated complaints (R., Ohio)—with content on After barely an hour, the republicans were victorious.
for a vote, two respected hoodwinked. from the actual Tennessee politics and U.S.-China rela- “Long before Camargo,” writes Mr. Jonas, “the end of the
House committee chairmen Thanks to social media, Republican Party, Twitter tions. Still, Russia appears to empire was in view. After Camargo, it seemed inevitable.”
made a disturbing acknowl- false information spreads took its time closing the ac- be most actively involved in Republican forces continued south, where Maximilian met
edgment: Russian disinforma- quicker and further. An count, finally shuttering it in spreading disinformation. them with the remnants of his army. He was defeated,
tion has helped undermine anonymous Twitter user August 2017. One newly discovered Mos- arrested, tried and executed, an act that Mr. Jonas describes
support for Ukraine among claimed earlier this month Russia, Iran, China and cow operation—called “Dop- as “justice.” This is a surprising claim: Maximilian had
some Republicans. that large numbers of people North Korea and their proxies pelganger”—copies content sought to govern with the endorsement of native Mexicans;
Foreign Affairs Chairman had registered to vote in Ari- are undoubtedly working from regular media compa- his fate was decided by a military trial, and his execution by
Michael McCaul admitted zona, Pennsylvania and Texas overtime online to influence nies, then alters them firing squad took place despite international pleas for
that “Russian propaganda has without a photo ID, suggest- this election. They seek to pit slightly to undermine West- clemency. In this respect, his treatment was more about
made its way into the United ing they could be illegal Americans against each other, ern democracies. sending a message to European powers than serving justice.
States” and “infected a good aliens. Arizona and Texas spread lies, and undermine A Sept. 25 Ipsos poll con- Mr. Jonas’s account of the Habsburg venture has many
chunk of my party’s base.” In- confidence in our politics, ducted in 16 countries that strengths. His research is formidable, and he brings to life
telligence Chairman Mike government and institutions. have elections this year characters who have been omitted from other accounts or
Turner said “anti-Ukraine and Disinformation from It’s hard to stop them, but shows the scope of the chal- who tend to receive passing mention. José María Gutiérrez
pro-Russia messages” have there are ways to diminish lenge: Social media is the pri- Estrada, for instance—a member of Mexico’s Conservative
been “uttered on the House Russia and China is their effectiveness. mary or secondary news Party who led the deputation offering the crown to
floor.” evolving and has even JPMorgan Chase CEO Ja- source for 56% of those sur- Maximilian—is shown to be an enterprising diplomat in
To get a sense of the mag- mie Dimon raised one possi- veyed, with television second European courts. And then there is Father Augustín Fischer,
nitude of the problem, con- spread to Capitol Hill. bility this month in his an- at 44% and websites and apps another somewhat peripheral figure, a Catholic priest who
sider one truly ludicrous fic- nual shareholders letter. He third at 29%. tried to settle two million acres of northern Mexico with
tion that GOP lawmakers suggested platforms should Even so, users told Ipsos German immigrants—a plan he abandoned when Maximilian
parroted: that Ukrainian election officials quickly de- “consider enhanced authenti- that they consider social me- sent him on a mission to Rome. Mr. Jonas also makes ample
President Volodymyr Zel- nounced this as false, but cation measures” requiring dia the second most untrust- use of memoirs and archives, allowing him to give voice to
ensky diverted U.S. aid to were too late to keep Ms. users to “identify themselves worthy information source. low-ranking soldiers who supported Maximilian in what is
purchase two super yachts. Greene, Donald Trump and to the platform or to a Only group chats on apps like often presented as a drama of statesmen and generals.
The accusation surfaced in Elon Musk from drawing at- trusted third party.” This WhatsApp or Telegram are
DC Weekly, a Russian website tention to the inaccurate would reduce “impostors, more distrusted. But given
masquerading as a U.S. media posting. It has 64 million bots and possibly foreign po- disinformation’s still-sub- As the U.S. Civil War unfolded, the French
organization. It’s one of many views and counting. litical actors.” He acknowl- stantial influence, it seems emperor offered the crown of Mexico to an
sites aimed at Americans tied America has been wres- edged that the stricter the both voters and platforms
to the media network of Wag- tling for years with foreign authentication process, the should wise up more. Rigor- Austrian archduke. Things did not go well.
ner mercenary chief Yevgeny adversaries’ efforts to sow greater the likelihood it could ous authentication of new ac-
Prigozhin. Prigozhin went discord online. In 2016, many “chill or block speech.” But counts is an essential step,
down in a private jet crash mistook the Twitter account Mr. Dimon suggested plat- but much more must be Yet by over-emphasizing the idea of “racial geopolitics,”
last August, but his troll farm TEN_GOP for that of the Ten- forms could avoid this with done. Our democracy’s health Mr. Jonas causes the nuances of certain figures to disappear.
appears alive and well. nessee Republican Party. tailored “policy and technical depends on it. Estrada, says Mr. Jonas, “was born Mexican, but his soul was
Though the Soviet Union is Though the profile featured solutions” that balance “risks European,” as if his monarchism or Catholicism were less
long gone, America still the Volunteer State’s seal, it and benefits.” Mr. Rove helped organize Mexican than the politics and faith of his republican
seems to be crawling with was really run by the Internet Platforms are already the political-action committee opponents. Or indeed as though republicanism itself were
useful idiots, Westerners who Research Agency, a media working the problem’s edges. American Crossroads and is not also European. Moreover, to pursue his racial-geopolitics
aid Moscow out of ignorance warfare group Prigozhin Meta took down at least five author of “The Triumph of theme, Mr. Jonas must minimize the actions and motivations
or naiveté. Rep. Marjorie Tay- founded. The account poured Chinese fake account net- William McKinley” (Simon & of key leaders, particularly Napoleon III, without whom the
lor Greene (R., Ga.) and Sen. out anti-immigrant, racist works last year. One had Schuster, 2015). Second Mexican Empire would not have existed.
Napoleon III offered the crown of Mexico to Maximilian
not so much to benefit the Latin race as to improve the
A Military Drop Full of Matzo French position in Europe against larger rivals, like the
British Empire, Russia and the unifying German states. The
gift of Mexico would also repair relations between Paris
By Gabriel Scheinmann sia, have joined the effort. bread, sustained the ancient had to inflict 10 plagues on and Vienna after the Franco-Austrian war of 1859. Napoleon
J
That’s grating for many Israe- Israelites in their hurried de- Egypt to move the hard- III’s motives in this regard were less racial than geopolitical.
ews around the world will lis, who don’t understand why parture out of Egypt. Jews hearted pharaoh, the West The historian Thierry Lentz has called Napoleon III a leader
celebrate Passover next their friends are operating be- each year eat it during Pass- must apply more pressure on “moderne et réaliste,” interested in Mexico as an economic
week, marking their an- hind enemy lines as Israeli ci- over and avoid leavened food, Hamas even as its leaders partner and a waystation to the Pacific.
cestors’ escape from slavery vilians are trapped in hellish recalling how their ancestors cling to their messianic views. Pin-pointing the Battle of Camargo in 1866 as the empire’s
in Egypt and deliverance as a conditions. didn’t have time to wait for Though the matzo likely turning point is an intriguing argument but not entirely
sovereign people into the land their bread to rise. Matzo is won’t reach the hostages, persuasive. The battle no doubt gave heart to the army of
of Israel. This year, as many an essential symbol of both symbolism in war is impor- the Mexican republic and damaged the French, but other
as 133 Jews will spend Pass- The hostages in Gaza their struggle for and journey tant. Israelis must know that forces were already in play by then. Following pressure
over in captivity—the hos- are being deprived toward freedom. In the same the U.S. still supports Jewish from the U.S., Napoleon III had decided to abandon his
tages Hamas has trapped in way Jews managed to hold se- freedom. Gazans and their Mexican campaign in late 1865, before Camargo, as his
Gaza’s dungeons since Oct. 7. of a normal Passover. cret seders in Nazi death supporters must be reminded correspondence with his senior commander in Mexico
As we press for their release, camps, one can hope that the that Hamas continues to hold shows. At the same time, the republican army under Juárez
the Biden administration hostages may do so today. women, children and the el- took renewed strength from the U.S. lifting its embargo on
should help them prepare for If the liberal world truly For six months, the hos- derly in diabolical conditions. foreign arms sales. What took place at Camargo confirmed
liberation by having the U.S. cares about all human suffer- tages’ families have led a Hamas must learn that it, too, rather than created the outcome of events in Mexico.
military drop matzo into the ing, the least it could do is global campaign to free their will join the ancient Egyp- That said, “Habsburgs on the Rio Grande” adds to our
Gaza Strip. seek to aid the captives as loved ones, including eight tians, Romans, Babylonians understanding of the Second Mexican Empire by giving us a
Since March 2 U.S. C-17s well as their captors. The next Americans. They have met and Nazis on the ash heap of fuller account of both its rise and dissolution, and it helps us
and C-130s have conducted American airdrop should in- presidents, prime ministers history after failing in its anti- to see anew the importance of an episode, so near the U.S.,
nearly 30 air drops delivering clude enough matzo for the and religious leaders, hoping semitic quest. that is routinely overshadowed by the drama of the Civil War.
855 tons of halal food and wa- hostages to eat until they’re to pressure Hamas and its Ira-
ter for civilians in northern released. That provision nian and Qatari enablers to Mr. Scheinmann is execu- Mr. McGregor is the author, with Brendan Simms, of
Gaza. Several other countries, would be of special signifi- release their family members tive director of the Alexander “The Silver Waterfall: How America Won the War in the
including France and Indone- cance—matzo, or unleavened from bondage. Just as God Hamilton Society. Pacific at Midway.”
A14 | Thursday, April 18, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
OPINION
REVIEW & OUTLOOK LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Will America Let Ukraine Collapse? The Left Blames the Victim, Israel, Yet Again
S
peaker Mike Johnson is forging ahead to he thinks the U.S. may abandon Ukraine. It befuddles me when I hear the of the Iranian regime, stop allowing
pass a bill to support Ukraine, Israel and What would it mean for the Russians to con- left blaming victims for what is hap- bad actors to question our commit-
pening in Gaza (“Elizabeth Warren on ment to our allies, unequivocally sup-
Taiwan, despite threats from his right trol an enormous new border with the North At-
Israel and Genocide,” Review & Out- port Israel’s right to defend itself
rump to topple him. He’s cor- lantic Treaty Organization? look, April 10). Hamas, an Iranian against terrorism and respond appro-
rect on the policy merits, and Speaker Johnson is Mr. Putin would be in a far proxy, started this war with an unpro- priately to acts of war.
he deserves support from stronger position to invade voked terror attack against Israeli ci- A true cease-fire requires both par-
Members of both parties given
stepping up. Failure the Baltic states, which he also vilians on Oct. 7, when they raped and ties to agree. Forcing one side to fully
what a potential Ukrainian de- would haunt U.S. views as rogue Russian prov- murdered women and children and cave in to the demands of the other
feat would mean for U.S. na-
tional security.
security—and the GOP. inces. And that’s for starters.
Those who think Mr. Putin
took innocent people hostage.
Hamas violated the last cease-fire,
isn’t a cease-fire—it’s capitulation.
There is no moral equivalence be-
Mr. Johnson’s plan is to wouldn’t dare confront NATO has rejected every cease-fire proposal tween the only true democracy in the
break the aid bill that has al- have consistently misunder- since, and is still holding Israelis and Middle East and terrorists who kill
ready passed the Senate into four parts—one stood the Russian dictator’s ambitions. They are Americans hostage. Then, over the Jewish civilians in cold blood and
weekend, Iran stepped from the shad- brag about it. President Biden thinks
each on Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan, and one that the same crowd that assured us Mr. Putin
ows to attack Israel directly. Yet some- he can walk a tightrope of appeasing
packages various Republican policy priorities wouldn’t dare go for Kyiv in 2022. how the lack of a cease-fire falls solely an increasingly radical base of his
such as seizing Russian assets. Those that pass Even if Mr. Putin isn’t yet ready to take on on Israel’s hands? Or worse, Israel’s party while upholding the main-
will be packaged and sent back to the Senate. He the West, NATO would still be forced to prepare self-defense constitutes genocide? stream American position of support
hopes for votes on Saturday, which means Mem- for the possibility—and deter it. If Mr. Putin Israel must be the only nation in for Israel.
bers can’t complain they weren’t given the controls Ukraine, “NATO must expect to face the world that is expected to show The problem is the president isn’t
promised 72-hour notice to read the bills. large Russian conventional forces along its en- such restraint after it is attacked— walking a tightrope. He’s trying to
i i i tire border from the Black Sea to the Arctic,” not once, but twice—by terrorists and straddle the Grand Canyon.
The need is urgent because Ukraine’s posi- as Mr. Kagan puts it. their backer, Iran. The Biden adminis- SEN. TIM SCOTT (R., S.C.)
tion is deteriorating. Ukrainian shortages in air That threat would require an enormous tration needs to end its appeasement North Charleston, S.C.
defenses are letting the Russian military domi- change in defense posture on the European con-
nate the air for the first time in two years. tinent on par with the Cold War. More U.S.
Ukraine’s cities are at risk, and its defenses troops, jets, air-defense batteries, tanks and
could take down only seven of 11 Russian pro- surveillance aircraft would be needed to harden The Hidden Costs of College-Debt Forgiveness
jectiles in a recent volley at a power plant. The the alliance’s eastern front. I agree with your editorial “Biden’s taxes I pay being given away to “edu-
other four destroyed the plant. Those assets wouldn’t then be available to Student Loan Howlers” (April 10) that cated folks” who don’t want to repay
Ukraine has lowered the conscription age to manage the Pacific threat from China, which President Biden’s excuses for student- their loans. Gosh, maybe my mort-
25 from 27, and the manpower is sorely needed. Ukraine’s GOP critics claim is their priority. loan forgiveness are great sources of gage company would let me quit pay-
But even the Ukrainians, who have demon- Don’t expect Europeans to heed U.S. pleas to humor. But we’re laughing at the ing on my house and simply give it to
strated that they don’t want to live under Vladi- curb their relationships with China after the symptom, not the disease. The dis- me. Shame on Mr. Biden for going
mir Putin’s boot, will wonder about manning a U.S. leaves a mess in their backyard. This is not ease, the problem, is the government- along with this. I’m a Democrat, but
run student-loan program that loans maybe not for long.
front line if they lack the ammo to shoot back a situation Donald Trump should want to in-
seemingly unlimited amounts of ALLEN WITTIG
at the enemy. herit if he wins in November. money to any student of any school Toano, Va.
“Ukraine cannot hold the present lines now i i i for any curriculum.
without the rapid resumption” of American Mr. Johnson has so far been staring down Solution: Put the program in the Strange how Mr. Biden and the
help, as Fred Kagan noted in a Tuesday report the rump caucus that wants to remove him from hands of bankers again. They can fig- Democrats are all in on college-debt
at the Institute for the Study of War. Only the power, and he is right to do so. They won’t re- ure out what government bureaucrats forgiveness, much of which will reim-
U.S. has the stocks to provide weapons quickly spect him more if he capitulates. If his plan cannot—a degree in electrical engi- burse debt for tuition spent at pri-
and in the numbers required. The Russians have fails, the fallback is a discharge petition that neering from Purdue University is vate, maybe even religious, colleges,
seized an area roughly the size of Detroit since would force a floor vote on the Senate bill. That worth more than a degree in pseudo- but they are adamantly against any
January, and a Russian breakthrough is possible is better than abandoning Ukraine, and we hope social-science from Acme University. government funding to parents who
by summer. enough Republicans would support it if their Now that would spoil Mr. Biden’s want to spend such funding for their
punch line. K-12 students at private schools.
The House Republicans who are threatening colleagues kill the other bills.
HAL DANTONE JOHN F. QUILTER
to oust Mr. Johnson over Ukraine imagine that Mr. Biden, for his part, has an obligation to Kingsville, Texas Eugene, Ore.
they can defeat aid and return without conse- bring along Democrats on the aid bill, and his
quence to pounding Joe Biden about the crisis at op-ed in these pages is welcome, albeit late in Why doesn’t the Biden administra- It would be a service to readers to
the southern border. They are wrong, and the sad shaping the debate. tion promote the military’s student- accent the effect before stating the
irony is that such delusions about the world are Amid all the political infighting on Capitol loan-forgiveness program? The armed action. The debt is transferred from
usually reserved for the progressive left. Hill, Republicans have a binary choice between services are reporting difficulties in the “unlucky” individuals who in-
On current trend the Kremlin will eventually helping America’s friends in Kyiv or abandoning meeting their recruiting goals. Let curred it to everyone else. The mon-
win the war, and Mr. Putin won’t be satisfied with them to Mr. Putin’s empire. The latter would be some of these folks who made the de- ies that are supposedly “canceled” re-
Ukraine’s east. He wants to subdue the entire a disaster for the United States, and the GOP cision to spend tens of thousands of main alive and well in the national
country, as he planned when he first tried to take will own it as thoroughly as Democrats owned dollars on their education go serve debt.
their country for four to six years. MICHAEL MURRAY
Kyiv. He has no incentive to negotiate now that the collapse of Saigon in 1975. Frankly, I’m sick of seeing the Lyndhurst, N.J.
T
he Senate voted on party lines Wednes- Power to try all Impeachments.” Regarding your editorial “Mike I’m not ready to give credit to law-
day to summarily dispose of the two im- The Senate should have at least held a trial Johnson’s Ukraine Moment” (April 8): makers who have put us in this situa-
peachment articles passed by the House of some limited sort, and Democrats could have I will be very relieved if and when tion. It isn’t the Biden administra-
against Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro used it to make the case that Mr. Mayorkas was Republican House Speaker Mike tion, a bipartisan majority in the
Mayorkas, which is one more step in defining innocent. Instead they dismissed the two arti- Johnson finally acts to help Ukraine. Senate or the American people who
It may come this week, but I am refuse to stand up to Russian dicta-
down the constitutional power of impeachment. cles as unconstitutional with separate votes,
ashamed and disgusted that the U.S. tor Vladimir Putin. It’s the Republi-
Republicans will return the disfavor, possibly one of them 51-49, and the other 51-48 with GOP has failed for the past six months to cans in the House. The hawks among
sooner than Democrats expect. Sen. Lisa Murkowski voting present. provide Ukraine with military aid at them give lip service, but they have
While President Biden’s immigration policies “To validate this gross abuse by the House scale. Ukraine’s valiant people suffer yet to deliver.
have been a debacle, the failure is Mr. Biden’s. would be a grave mistake and could set a danger- and its troops die needlessly, some- Mr. Johnson and the GOP’s other
We don’t think the evidence existed to impeach ous precedent for the future,” said Majority times forced to give up ground due to self-proclaimed Ukraine supporters:
Mr. Mayorkas, and given a divided Congress it Leader Chuck Schumer. Yet that’s exactly what lack of ammunition, because of our For the sake of freedom and democ-
was a political maneuver not designed for suc- a future Republican Senate leader might say in abject failure. racy in the world, stand up at long
cess. Yet the Republican House went ahead and refusing to hold a trial on some impeachment ar- last. You’ll never be heroes in my
impeached the Homeland Security chief, send- ticles passed by a Democratic House. Democrats book since you brought us to this
ing the articles over to the Democratic Senate, are now collaborators in diminishing this consti- As an 11-Year-Old, I Beat sorry state of affairs, but it isn’t too
late to turn it around. Wait any lon-
which the Constitution says “shall have the sole tutional check on real executive abuses. Golf Legend Ben Hogan ger and it will be.
As he so often does, Bob Greene ELIZABETH MERRICK
D
Beat Ben Hogan’ Medals” (April 11).
idn’t President Biden promise a better manufacturers that use particular grades of As an 11-year-old in 1954, I was one When Did We Stop Building?
trade policy than his predecessor? Chinese steel without alternatives. of the 147,000 golfers who teed off on
In 1942 the Alaskan Highway—1,700
Well, he now appears to be in a race In any case, neither candidate plans to limit National Golf Day and one of some
miles of new construction through un-
with Donald Trump to be Pro- his protectionism and indus- 2,500 medal recipients.
charted territory—was completed in
tectionist in Chief. Witness his Biden sees Trump’s trial policy to China. Mr. It was the first time I had played a
less than one year. In 1961 President
full 18 holes, and I dragged myself
pitch for new tariffs at a cam- tariffs on metals and Trump has proposed a 10% John F. Kennedy announced that we
and my golf bag up the 18th fairway
paign stop on Wednesday in tariff on all imports. Mr. Biden to finish in 191 strokes. Much to my
were going to the moon. Eight years
Pittsburgh. raises to no good effect. on Wednesday reaffirmed his surprise, as I had never played be-
later, men traveled the quarter of a
Speaking at United Steel- opposition to Nippon Steel’s million miles there and back.
fore, the Callaway Handicap Scoring
workers headquarters—where purchase of U.S. Steel, though One of the many “shovel-ready”
System was applied, eliminating the
else?—Mr. Biden promised to crack down on the Japanese company has promised to honor projects (Letters, April 13) announced
worst holes in a round. Apparently, I
in 2009 was Amtrak service between
Chinese imports. “Chinese policies and subsi- labor agreements and invest $1.4 billion to up- managed a triple bogey or two, and
Chicago and Moline, Ill., on 161 miles
dies for their domestic steel and aluminum in- grade factories. my handicap of 128 produced a net
of existing track. In the 15 years since
dustries means high-quality U.S. products are Mr. Biden also teed up plans on Wednesday score of 63, edging Bantam Ben’s 64.
the announcement, not a single pas-
undercut by artificially low-priced Chinese al- to use tariffs to protect U.S. businesses bur- The local newspaper sent a pho-
senger train has carried a single pas-
ternatives produced with higher emissions,” the dened by his climate agenda. “American compa- tographer who talked me into posing
senger along the route, nor are we
with smug self-satisfaction alongside
White House said in a statement. nies must lead the future of more sustainable seemingly any closer than we were 15
a set of clubs, which served to earn
The Trump Administration tried to leverage steel,” the White House said. It’s not fair that the enmity of my classmates for the
years ago.
tariffs on Chinese goods to get Beijing to reform “U.S. products have to compete with artificially JOSEPH E. PETERSON
next week. But as Mr. Greene reports,
its mercantilist policies. It didn’t work. Yet now low-priced alternatives produced with higher Iowa City
for more than seven decades I have
Mr. Biden is proposing to triple the 7.5% tariff carbon emissions.” been able to say, “I beat Ben Hogan!”
under Section 301 on certain Chinese steel and Steel making is energy-intensive, and Mr. Bi- G. RICHARD WYNN
aluminum imports. He also teed up a trade in- den’s green energy agenda threatens to make Haverford, Pa. Pepper ...
vestigation into Chinese shipbuilding in re- U.S. companies less competitive. U.S. Steel is And Salt
sponse to a petition by the union. challenging the Environmental Protection
While Mr. Biden has scrapped nearly every Agency’s “good neighbor” rule that requires it A Starbucks Label’s Appeal THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
Trump policy, he has maintained most of his to make costly upgrades to reduce ozone in dis- The article “Consumers Finally
predecessor’s tariffs despite their economic tant states. The Supreme Court is considering Test Starbucks on Price” (Heard on
harm. The Detroit Free Press reported in 2019 whether to block the rule. the Street, April 12) compares Star-
that Ford worker profit-sharing checks would Meantime, the Administration touts billions bucks coffee to a “Veblen good,” one
be 10% higher if not for Mr. Trump’s 25% tariffs in subsidies for “green” manufacturing. Last for which high price is part of its ap-
on steel and 10% on aluminum. month the Energy Department awarded steel- peal. I disagree. For coffee lovers, a
Starbucks label assures us of the level
An analysis by the Peterson Institute for In- maker Cleveland-Cliffs $575 million for “two
of quality provided at Starbucks out-
ternational Economics found that each job decarbonization investments” in Ohio and lets, and that is something we are
“saved” by Mr. Trump’s steel tariffs cost con- Pennsylvania. Cleveland-Cliffs’ workers are rep- willing to pay for.
sumers and businesses more than $900,000. resented by the United Steelworkers and it lob- JANE SHAW STROUP
Employment in iron and steel mills has fallen bied the White House to block the Nippon Steel Raleigh, N.C.
by about 3,000 since the Section 232 tariffs deal.
took effect in 2018. Cleveland-Cliffs wants to buy U.S. Steel,
Letters intended for publication should
China’s mercantilism is a special trade prob- which it says will benefit workers. Doubtful. In be emailed to wsj.ltrs@wsj.com. Please
lem, but Chinese steel makes up only 2% of U.S. February it closed a factory in West Virginia include your city, state and telephone
imports and 0.6% of consumption, largely owing that employed 900. Tariffs and subsidies may number. All letters are subject to “Can we move the printer out
to Mr. Trump’s tariffs and antidumping duties. prop up uncompetitive companies for a time, editing, and unpublished letters cannot of the lounge? The coffee embodies
be acknowledged.
Piling on more tariffs will raise costs for U.S. but they harm countless forgotten men. a faint bouquet of toner.”
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, April 18, 2024 | A15
OPINION
I
come less likely by replenishing Is-
ran launched an unprece-
dented attack against Israel
rael’s air defenses and providing
military aid now, so its defenses can
Shadow War
this weekend, with a barrage remain fully stocked and ready.
I
1,500 miles north, Russia continued write blank checks. We’d send mili- Jerusalem
its bombardment of Ukraine, which tary equipment from our own stock- ran’s weekend attack perma-
has intensified dramatically in the piles, then use the money authorized nently altered the strategic pic-
last month. by Congress to replenish those ture in the Middle East. For 45
Both Ukraine and Israel defended stockpiles—by buying from Ameri- years the two countries engaged in a
themselves against these attacks, can suppliers. That includes Patriot “shadow war” via proxies, covert op-
holding the line and protecting their missiles made in Arizona, Javelin erations and clandestine missions.
citizens. And both did it with critical missiles made in Alabama, and artil- Now they are in open conflict. A
help from the U.S. lery shells made in Pennsylvania, range of previously unlikely scenar-
Now is not the time to abandon Ohio and Texas. We’d be investing in ios, from a complete regional melt-
our friends. The House must pass America’s industrial base, buying down to a new Israeli-Arab alliance,
urgent national-security legislation American products made by Ameri- have become possible.
for Ukraine and Israel, as well as can workers, supporting jobs in The shadow war’s great benefit to
desperately needed humanitarian aid President Volodymyr Zelensky and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. nearly 40 states, and strengthening both sides was that it preserved
for Palestinians in Gaza. our own national security. We’d help plausible deniability. Anything that
In this third year of Russia’s war, pably defend their own sovereignty, a new Russian empire. The govern- our friends while helping ourselves. provoked a direct conflagration
Ukraine continues to defy the odds. they depend on American assistance, ment of Iran wants to destroy Israel I’ve been clear about my concerns could have wildly unpredictable con-
Against a much larger military, the including weaponry, to do it. And forever—wiping the world’s only over the safety of civilians in Gaza sequences. But both Iran and Israel
Ukrainians regained more than half this is a pivotal moment. Jewish state off the map. amid the war with Hamas, but this became too successful at waging
the territory that Russia occupied Vladimir Putin is ramping up his America must never accept either aid package is focused on Israel’s shadow war. Iran sponsors Hamas,
after its 2022 invasion. They’ve onslaught with help from his outcome—not only because we stand long-term defensive needs to ensure which on Oct. 7 invaded 22 Israeli
struck the Russian navy time and friends. China is providing Russia up for our friends, but because our it can maintain its military edge villages and murdered 1,200. This
with microelectronics and other security is on the line, too. against Iran or any other adversary. “success” shifted Israel from a de-
equipment that is critical for de- If Russia triumphs, Mr. Putin’s Importantly, this bill has funding fensive to an offensive posture.
Both countries urgently fense production. Iran is sending forces will move closer than ever to that will allow us to continue deliv-
hundreds of drones; North Korea is our North Atlantic Treaty Organiza- ering urgent humanitarian aid for
need U.S. support against providing artillery and ballistic mis- tion allies. “An attack on one is an the people of Gaza as well as others Now that it and Israel are
brazen adversaries that siles. Ukraine, facing ammunition attack on all” means that if Mr. Pu- who have felt the impact of conflicts
fighting openly, anything
shortfalls, is losing hold of territory tin invades a NATO ally, we will around the world.
seek their annihilation. it had regained. come to its aid—as our NATO allies It’s a strong and sensible plan. It is possible, from disaster
After years of backing Hezbollah, did for us after the Sept. 11 attacks. shouldn’t be held hostage any longer
Hamas and other proxies in their at- We should surge support to Ukraine by a small group of extreme Repub- to a new regional order.
again, winning important victories tacks on Israel, including Hamas’s now, to stop Mr. Putin from en- lican House members.
in the Black Sea. And they’ve devel- brutal attack on Oct. 7, Iran croaching on our NATO allies and Mr. Putin has tried relentlessly to
oped innovative weapons, especially launched a direct attack of its own— ensure that he doesn’t draw U.S. break the will of the Ukrainian peo- Where the Israelis had engaged in
drones, to counter Russian forces. hoping to penetrate Israel’s air de- troops into a future war in Europe. ple. He has failed. Now he’s trying to limited surgical battles with Hamas,
Theirs is a fighting force with the fense, including David’s Sling and Likewise, if Iran succeeds in sig- break the will of the West. We can- they now sought to defeat it com-
will and the skill to win. the Iron Dome, which saved count- nificantly escalating its assault on not let him succeed. pletely. The Israel Defense Forces
Meanwhile, as we saw this week- less lives this weekend. Israel, the U.S. could be drawn in. Is- There are moments in history didn’t simply subdue Gaza City and
end, Israel’s military has the tech- Both Ukraine and Israel are under rael is our strongest partner in the that call for leadership and courage. Khan Younis; they destroyed them.
nology and training to defend the attack by brazen adversaries that Middle East; it’s unthinkable that we This is one of them. In December, Israel extended this
country against even an attack of seek their annihilation. Mr. Putin would stand by if its defenses were offensive posture to Hezbollah, Iran’s
unprecedented scope and ferocity. wants to subjugate the people of weakened and Iran was able to carry Mr. Biden is president of the senior proxy in the region. After two
But while both countries can ca- Ukraine and absorb their nation into out the destruction it intended this United States. months of low-intensity fighting, the
IDF began to rout Hezbollah’s forces
in southern Lebanon. The two sides
What Home Buyers Get for Those Agent Commissions exchanged moderate rocket and mis-
sile fire as before, but Israeli defense
sources tell me that more than 90%
By Damian Eales Despite these wins, federal offi- a flood plain or in a region prone to There are better ways to help of Hezbollah’s special Radwan fight-
W
cials seem to want a more aggres- bush fires, the seller’s agent isn’t home buyers save money, policies on ers have fled southern Lebanon, and
ill it become easier or sive solution. In a February court fil- necessarily obligated to tell him which state lawmakers should take that Israel has destroyed almost all
harder to buy a home? The ing, the Justice Department noted about the risks. the lead. Most U.S. states have the group’s border lookout posts.
answer is unclear amid that U.S. commissions are “two to The U.S. model provides lower transfer taxes, which can add thou- As the war evolved, Israeli leaders
widespread confusion over what’s three times more than” those in overall costs and better representa- sands of dollars to the cost of a grew frustrated by Iran’s ability to
happening to real-estate agent com- “other developed countries,” a point tion for buyers and sellers alike. home purchase. Lawmakers should dictate events without consequences.
missions. On April 5, a federal court the media frequently repeats. That Americans chose this model for good either cut these taxes, leading to In December, Israel killed Sayyed
determined that the Justice Depart- gives the impression that federal of- reasons. Before the 1990s, few peo- lower costs and more home sales, or Reza Mousavi, a senior Iranian com-
ment can reopen its investigation ficials want to cut commissions at ple in the U.S. used a buyer’s agent. reduce property taxes after windfall mander, in an airstrike near Damas-
into the policies of the National As- Yet home buyers began to demand gains post-pandemic. State and fed- cus. To avoid Iranian retaliation, the
sociation of Realtors, indicating that representation, especially low-in- eral lawmakers could also ease bur- IDF didn’t take public credit. Rather
the association’s March settlement It’s caveat emptor in some come and first-time buyers who densome licensing, zoning and envi- than respond directly, Supreme
in a separate case may not be the fi- needed help navigating the process. ronmental regulations, all of which Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei re-
nal word on this issue. Yet in their Australian states, where Consumer-rights advocates champi- add nearly $94,000 to the cost of a sponded covertly through terror
effort to deliver lower costs for agents have a fiduciary oned this development. As buyer’s new single-family home and lead de- plots to kill Jews in Asia, Europe and
home buyers, federal officials and agents became more popular, eight velopers to build fewer homes. The elsewhere. He may also have realized
courts may inadvertently undermine duty only to the seller. states even banned the old model of best way to decrease housing’s cost that losing Mousavi was a price
consumer protections without ad- a single agent representing both is to increase its supply. worth paying for the harm Iran al-
dressing the root causes of high parties. Americans effectively gained The alternative is to erode the ready inflicted on Israel.
home prices. least in half as quickly as possible, two agents for the price of one, and hard-fought victory that American On April 1, Israel moved again,
The settlement is a positive de- and the department appears to be that price has fallen from over 6% to home buyers have achieved. While killing senior Quds Force commander
velopment: It could lower real-estate pursuing this goal. Yet dramatically closer to 5% today. the U.S. system is far from perfect, it Mohammad Reza Zahedi with a pre-
agents’ commissions, benefiting slashing commissions can be Discouraging the use of buyer’s serves home buyers better than any cision strike at an Iranian diplomatic
home buyers. It also increases trans- achieved only by reducing the use of agents would reverse this progress. other arrangement, and it’s moving building in Damascus. This time Mr.
parency and negotiating power for buyer’s agents—a move that would Although it would likely lower home in an even better direction after the Khamenei felt compelled to respond
home buyers who use agents for be unwise for a few reasons. buyers’ costs, it would do so at the recent settlement. As federal offi- directly. He no longer cared to save
representation. The settlement will Consider the pitfalls that home price of sacrificing their interests. cials and courts weigh whether to face. He wanted blood.
also increase professionalism among buyers face in countries where Without a buyer’s agent, no one push further, they should remember Two weeks later Iran launched its
agents, who will now sign an agree- buyer’s agents aren’t commonly would be legally required to help that some cures are worse than the attack. The barrage failed, but it
ment detailing their services before used. In Australia, where I grew up, buyers understand their risks and disease. wasn’t meant to fail, as some say. It
showing a buyer a home. These poli- home buyers typically work directly options. There would also be noth- was intended to kill hundreds of Is-
cies should put downward pressure with listing agents, who have a fidu- ing to stop seller’s agents from in- Mr. Eales is CEO of Move Inc., raelis and to destroy critical Israeli
on commission prices, which cur- ciary duty only to the sellers. In creasing their commissions to match which operates Realtor.com. Move air bases. The Arrow missile-defense
rently average 5.3% and are split be- some Australian territories and what previously went to buyer’s Inc. is owned by News Corp, which system performed better than any-
tween buyer’s and seller’s agents. states, if a buyer looks at a home on agents. also owns The Wall Street Journal. one expected and brought down in
the empty desert nearly all of the
long-range munitions Iran had hoped
B
in believing in this programmatic bringing fresh accounts of murders, drugs, car-jack, join street gangs, the day.
oys Town founder Father Ed- solution to urban violence. Not long rapes and robberies, the country re- participate in smash-and-grab at- Iran’s attack ended the shadow
ward Flanagan said “there is ago, after a particularly heavy week- sides under a heavy veil of paranoia. tacks on retail shops, engage in hit- war. The old rules no longer apply.
no such thing as a bad boy.” end of shootings in Englewood, one Parents nervously send their chil- and-runs with stolen cars, go in for Israel has said it will respond, and it
The argument hasn’t gone out of of Chicago’s most crime-ridden dren off to school. City dwellers drive-by street shootings. What pro- must if it hopes to restore deter-
vogue. Brandon Johnson, the neighborhoods, I saw on local televi- look over their shoulders while grams do we have for them? rence. But if the response is too
mayor of Chicago, seems to believe sion a middle-aged resident call out, walking once-safe streets. The el- light, Israel risks inviting future
in it, and rather than put more po- “They better get some programs derly go out at night with trepida- waves of drones and ballistic mis-
lice on his city’s violent streets—or down here quick.” tion. Paranoia? “Even paranoids,” The Chicago mayor seems siles. Then again, if Israel attacks too
renew the city’s contract with I wonder, too, if so many of the the poet Delmore Schwartz, himself aggressively, it risks greater retalia-
ShotSpotter, the gunshot detection nation’s liberal attorneys general and a true paranoid, used to protest, to believe ‘there is no such tion from both Iran and Hezbollah.
system—he prefers what he has prosecutors don’t also subscribe to “have real enemies.” thing as a bad boy,’ but his To date Hezbollah has used up only
called “a more holistic approach” the notion that there is no such thing In 2021, Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker around 3,000 rockets and missiles
to combating crime. as a bad boy. How else to explain argued for and won passage of the reform ideas are hopeless. out of an estimated arsenal of
He would fight crime by provid- their failures to prosecute? How else Safe-T Act, which ended the cash 150,000.
ing more employment for young to account for their freeing on bond bail system in the state. Proponents The U.S. and Israel’s European al-
gang members, mentoring, pro- men who have been found obviously of the bill argued that cash bail was Father Flanagan attained some lies are pressing Israel not to coun-
grams to shore up the family in guilty of serious crimes, many of fundamentally unfair to criminals success in reforming delinquent terstrike. President Biden considers
poor neighborhoods, and anything whom, while out, commit yet further without funds to come up with bail. boys by working with a limited a wider regional war to be a threat
else that promises reform of crimi- crimes, including murder? The real victims, obviously, were number of them, over whom he had to his re-election. On the flip side,
the criminals themselves. (Might full control. But the only govern- Iran’s attack shocked the Saudis out
learning to save for bail be one of ment program I can come up with is of their complacency—they “outed”
Mr. Johnson’s programs?) But, pretrial detention, with the more se- themselves publicly as having as-
PUBLISHED SINCE 1889 BY DOW JONES & COMPANY then, so much of the talk about rious the crime, the less the chance sisted Israel against Iran. Riyadh and
Lachlan Murdoch crime nowadays seems to exclude for bail, and imprisonment for those Washington have both made noises
Executive Chairman, News Corp the victims. convicted. about a grand normalization deal
Rupert Murdoch Robert Thomson
Chairman Emeritus, News Corp Chief Executive Officer, News Corp Given the assumptions behind the Under this program prison terms with Israel, and Mr. Biden may still
Emma Tucker Almar Latour argument that there’s no such thing would be widely announced and im- exit the current chaos with his own
Editor in Chief Chief Executive Officer and Publisher as a bad boy, disrespect for police placably carried out, with no time “deal of the century” going down the
Liz Harris, Managing Editor DOW JONES MANAGEMENT: naturally follows, casting cops in off for good behavior: one year in electoral home stretch.
Charles Forelle, Deputy Editor in Chief Daniel Bernard, Chief Experience Officer; the role of villain. When a police- prison, say, for being part of a These are unusually dangerous
Elena Cherney, Senior Editor; David Crow, Mae M. Cheng, EVP, General Manager, Leadership;
Executive Editor; Chip Cummins, Newswires; David Cho, Barron’s Editor in Chief; Jason P. Conti, man shoots a criminal, the media smash-and-grab mob, two years for and potentially auspicious times.
Andrew Dowell, Asia; Taneth Evans, Associate General Counsel, Chief Compliance Officer; often portrays the cop as the taking part in a car-jacking, three The U.S. and Israel need to play their
Dianne DeSevo, Chief People Officer; Jared DiPalma,
Editor; Brent Jones, Culture, Training & Outreach;
Chief Financial Officer; Frank Filippo, Chief
wrongdoer. Meanwhile, policemen years for mugging a mail carrier, cards perfectly.
Alex Martin, Print & Writing; Michael W. Miller,
Transformation Officer; Artem Fishman, Chief are retiring early and fewer candi- and so on up the ladder of serious-
Features & Weekend; Prabha Natarajan,
Professional Products; Bruce Orwall, Enterprise;
Technology Officer; David Martin, Chief Revenue dates wish to join. Little wonder, ness. This would get the bad boys’ Mr. Bob is senior military analyst
Officer, Business Intelligence; Dan Shar, EVP,
Philana Patterson, Audio; Amanda Wills, Video General Manager, Wealth & Investing; Ashok Sinha, since the police generally are no attention, and is the only program I for the Jerusalem Post and a co-au-
SVP, Head of Communications; Josh Stinchcomb, longer respected. All too often they know with any chance of success. thor of “Target Tehran: How Israel
Paul A. Gigot EVP & Chief Revenue Officer, WSJ | Barron’s
Editor of the Editorial Page are despised. Is Using Sabotage, Cyberwarfare,
Group; Sherry Weiss, Chief Marketing Officer
Gerard Baker, Editor at Large
EDITORIAL AND CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS:
What if there really are bad Mr. Epstein is author, most re- Assassination—and Secret Diplo-
1211 Avenue of the Americas, New York, N.Y., 10036 boys—and not a few bad girls—on cently, of “Never Say You’ve Had a macy—to Stop a Nuclear Iran and
Telephone 1-800-DOWJONES the scene? Young men and women Lucky Life.” Create a New Middle East.”
A16 | Thursday, April 18, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
W O R L D M A L B E C DAY E XC L U S I V E
Discover the
HEIGHTS
OF MALBEC S AV E
$190
OV E R
Malbec is on top of the world. It rose from humble origins in southern France (where it
was typically used in blends) to international stardom in the high-altitude vineyards
of Argentina. To celebrate World Malbec Day (April 17), you’ll taste a dozen of our
Opi Sadler’s family has been crafting
wine in Argentina since the 1800s
deepest, darkest selections with this exclusive offer.
Start in Salta, home to some of the world’s highest vineyards and the hugely popular
Ascencion. From Mendoza (Argentina’s wine capital), enjoy classics from superstar
Opi Sadler and the legendary Zuccardi family. Each has the rich lavor and freshness
to match Argentina’s other great culinary delight…char-grilled steak. Rounding off
your Malbec showcase in style is a silky discovery from Spain.
We’d also like to send you a special gift in celebration of World Malbec Day: two bonus
bottles of a gold-medal French Malbec and a pair of stemless glasses.
A sizzling, lame-cooked steak is the
classic pairing for Malbec Discover Mighty Malbec & More
All this is only $69.99 as your introduction to
the WSJ Wine Discovery Club. Enjoy today’s
collection, then look forward to a dozen exciting YO U R S P E C I A L B O N U S
new releases every three months. Take only
the cases you want—with a savings of at least You’ll also enjoy
20%. You can change wines, delay delivery, skip 2 bottles of this
gold-medal French
or cancel anytime. We’ll also reward you with
Malbec and 2
bonus bottles and other member-only treats. Dartington Crystal
The Zuccardi family are “one of the
stemless glasses
pioneers” of Argentina (Wine Advocate) Give it a try today—and happy Malbec Day.
Worth $58.97
Offer available to first-time WSJ Wine Discovery Club members only and limited to one case per household. Wines and offer may vary by state. 100% money-back guarantee applies to each wine. Offer subject to availability and club
enrollment. All orders fulfilled by licensed retailers/wineries and applicable taxes are paid. You must be at least 21 years old to order. Offer valid in U.S. only (excluding AR, DE, MS, RI, UT). $75 shipping surcharge applies to AK and HI delivery.
CO ($0.28 retail delivery fee per case applies). WSJ Wine is operated independently of The Wall Street Journal and Dow Jones & Company, Inc. Full terms and conditions online. Void where prohibited by law. Please drink responsibly.
BUSINESS & FINANCE
© 2024 Dow Jones & Company. All Rights Reserved.
Bitcoin’s Resurgent
UAW Sets
Miners Look Its Sights
On VW
To Diversify Workers
JAMES JACKMAN FOR THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
grappling with lackluster re- who pay hefty fees for outper- “We fully support an NLRB
turns, an investor exodus and formance. vote so every team member
the acrimonious departure of All eyes are now on whether has a chance to a secret ballot
one of its founders. The firm’s Trian will be able to make vote on this important deci-
money under management money on its biggest bet—on Please turn to page B5
ended last year at its lowest Dove-soap maker Unilever—
point since 2012, a previously and whether Peltz’s days as a Volvo profit beats forecasts
All eyes are now on whether Trian will be able to make money on its biggest bet: Unilever. unreported recent filing shows. Please turn to page B2 on price rises........................ B5
storied news organization in been divided over its Gaza war quality manager who retired in
the Free Press, a media upstart. coverage, culminating with a some products in 2020 and said employees work-
His actions led to a five-day recent investigation into Indonesia. B3 ing on the 787 Dreamliner jets
suspension without pay. Then whether staffers leaked confi- were discouraged from flagging
on Wednesday, he posted his dential information to another problems or recommending
resignation letter on X, in outlet. changes to prevent snafus.
which he accused the public ra- “You see a lot of the editors Irvin’s written account was
dio network’s new chief execu- and publishers just saying, part of a pair of congressional
tive of having divisive views ‘enough,’ ” said Brian McGrory, hearings on Wednesday scruti-
that “confirm the very prob- chair of the journalism depart- nizing Boeing. One included an- Whistleblower Sam Salehpour flagged concerns about 787 parts.
lems” he cited in his Free Press ment of Boston University and other whistleblower, Sam Saleh-
piece. former editor of the Boston pour, who went public last week concerns. last week by Salehpour about
A spokeswoman for NPR de- Globe. He said it is important with his concerns about 787 “I was told, ‘We don’t have production of 787 Dreamliner
clined to comment on person- for newsroom leaders to listen joints, while the second featured enough time to do corrective ac- jets. Deliveries of the jets, made
nel matters. to staff, “but ultimately a news testimony from members of a tions, so don’t write one,’” Irvin at Boeing’s Charleston, S.C., fac-
Berliner’s essay, which said organization can’t be run by a panel tasked with reviewing the said in an interview. In pushing tory, were halted for nearly two
NPR had lost its way by letting committee of 1,000.” MARKETS plane maker’s practices after the company to address issues, years starting in 2020 amid var-
liberal bias skew its coverage, The outcome in each case The S&P 500 falls for a two 737 MAX crashes. “there was always the chance of ious production and regulatory
is the latest sign of a manage- was different. While NPR chose At both hearings, panelists not necessarily getting fired but issues.
ment challenge several major to discipline Berliner, NBC
fourth straight day, and whistleblowers described a moving to a position that would Boeing defended the safety of
newsrooms are dealing with: News cut ties with Ronna Mc- with J.B. Hunt its company culture that discour- be much less important.” the 787 in a two-hour presenta-
how to handle staffers who are Daniel, the former Republican worst performer. B10 ages employees from coming Federal safety officials are in- tion to journalists this week,
willing to go public with con- Please turn to page B4 forward with quality and safety vestigating claims made public Please turn to page B2
B2 | Thursday, April 18, 2024 * **** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
INDEX TO PEOPLE
C I R A now-retired Boeing quality manager said employees working on the 787 Dreamliner were discouraged from flagging issues.
Calhoun, Dave...........................B2 Icahn, Carl.....................................B2 Rossi, Dominic........................A10
Coleman, Denis.......................B11
Cook, Tim......................................B3
D
Iger, Bob..........................................B1
J
Roth, Tony.................................B10
S Boeing Glitch Halts Alaska Air Flights
planes down the assembly line
and employed practices, such as
completing work out of se-
tablished by the Federal Aviation encourage employees to speak ing operations in the wake of a quired too much manpower, he
Administration said the com- up with concerns and is hearing midair blowout of a door plug said.
pany lacked sufficient safe- from more employees. “We on an Alaska Airlines flight in Irvin said the recent death of
Nvidia’s AI chips are crucial to technology guards to prevent retaliation know we have more work to do January. That plane, a smaller John Barnett, another quality
from smartphones to chatbots—but their against employees who flag and we are taking action across 737 MAX, was built at Boeing’s manager who raised concerns
production is outsourced to just one company safety issues. our company,” a spokesman Renton, Wash., factory. about the jet maker, prompted
in Taiwan. Scan this code for a video on how “There was a lack of confi- said. Executives have since ac- him to come forward. Police said
the U.S. is racing to secure the supply chain. dence that, if you were trying to A program in which employ- knowledged that the company at they were investigating Bar-
report it anonymously, that ano- ees can flag concerns anony- times overemphasized moving nett’s death as a suicide.
been pulling out money, The as Hellmann’s mayonnaise. Its around 37 pounds in London— a new target in mind, saying on cial-media platform, X, ahead of
Disney Loss Wall Street Journal reported
last month. The full extent of
$1.5 billion-plus stake is the
firm’s largest position, dwarf-
equivalent to about $46 cur-
rently—when Trian arrived.
CNBC recently that he needed
to finish buying his shares be-
the Disney vote.
“I think the world of him,”
redemption requests isn’t re- ing Trian’s stake in Disney and That is roughly where it is now. fore revealing the company’s Peltz said of Musk. Some read
Adds to flected in the latest number,
people familiar with the matter
consuming about 25% of its
capital.
Peltz and Trian could yet
achieve the success they had
name. In the same appearance,
he fawned over Elon Musk. The
it as a sign that the two could
join forces on an investment
81-year-old failed to win crucial for several years. Some haven’t ered a $68 billion purchase of over the next three years.
support from the big index lived up to Trian’s ambitions. In GlaxoSmithKline’s consumer- A centerpiece of the plan is
funds, BlackRock, State Street 2020, one such vehicle took si- health business that he ulti- spinning off or selling Uni-
and Vanguard, some of which multaneous stakes in Janus mately backed away from. lever’s ice-cream business,
previously backed him. Henderson and Invesco and Peltz joined Unilever’s board which in addition to Ben &
He turned off some of their unsuccessfully tried to get the a few months after Trian Jerry’s includes Breyers, Talenti
top decision makers while cam- asset managers to merge. bought its shares. Investors and Klondike. The unit had rev-
paigning, people familiar with hoped Peltz would work his enue of $8.6 billion last year
the matter said. Peltz raised magic like he had at P&G, but was the company’s slow-
eyebrows with an interview All eyes on Unilever whose stock rose more than est-growing.
The last time Trian raised
#
(
(
with the Financial Times days 50% during his board tenure.
before voting ended in which money from investors for a ma- Trian said it was targeting
Trian 2.0
he questioned why “woke” Dis- jor co-investment vehicle was an annual rate of return of
ney made movies such as “The in 2022, when it made a big bet around 17% over four years, Trian has been working to
Marvels” and “Black Panther” on Unilever, the London-based people familiar with the matter steady itself after Ed Garden,
with primarily female and Black maker of household names such said. The stock was trading one of its co-founders and
casts, respectively. Peltz’s son-in-law, left last year.
Trian’s assets under management* Many had expected Garden to
eventually take over. Instead, he
'
Shrinking assets $12 billion
is no longer speaking to Peltz
Trian’s discretionary assets after a power struggle.
&
10
under management—those they At the time, Trian elevated
have full control over—had
8
Matt Peltz, Nelson’s son, and $%
reached a peak of $12.5 billion 6 another partner, Josh Frank, to
in 2015. But they have declined the roles of co-chief investment
in six of the past eight years, 4
officers. “Since the promotion
including each of the past four, 2 of Trian’s two new co-CIOs and !
hurt by soured bets. As of the the new head of research, per-
end of last year, the firm man- 0 formance has improved and
"
aged $6.1 billion, a late-March 2012 ’15 ’20 ’23 performance of recent positions #
filing with the Securities and has been particularly strong,” a
Exchange Commission showed. Unilever share-price performance since news of Trian’s arrival spokesperson said.
(That excludes nearly $3 billion 20% Still, some on Wall Street
of nondiscretionary assets, pri- wonder if Peltz will take on any
marily Disney shares owned by more proxy fights. # . / 0
Ike Perlmutter, Peltz’s friend Others say he could lay low
who entrusted his voting rights 10 for a bit and return as fierce as ' '
! ) *
to Trian for the proxy fight.) ever. Carl Icahn, another activ-
Assets have since risen to about ist, fell prey to a short-seller at- + # &
$7 billion. tack last year that shaved bil- ,
0
The firm says it had more lions off the value of his firm. - !
money come in than leave in After spending much of the
the past two years. past year doing damage con-
Investors including Califor- –10 trol, he recently struck a deal
nia State Teachers’ Retirement Feb. 2022 ’23 ’24 with JetBlue Airways for seats
System and the New York State *Includes discretionary assets as of Dec. 31, except for 2021 figure, which is as of Feb. 28, 2022. on the airline’s board. !
Common Retirement Fund have Sources: SEC filings (assets under management); FactSet (performance) Peltz has hinted that he has
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * Thursday, April 18, 2024 | B3
BUSINESS NEWS
Chevron, Others
Get U.S. Approval
For Venezuela Oil
BY KEJAL VYAS Antero Alvarado said.
The new policy of requiring
The Biden administration companies to seek individual li-
said Wednesday it would allow censes is likely to benefit large
some American and European oil majors with lobbying power
oil companies to carry on in in Washington. It will also ben-
Venezuela after the U.S.’s ef- efit shipping companies that
forts to coax President Nicolás had helped Venezuela move
Maduro into democratic re- crude on the black market and
forms by lifting economic sanc- whose services may be needed,
tions ended in a hardening of said Alvarado. Venezuela is
his authoritarian regime. producing about 800,000 bar-
After Maduro violated an rels a day.
October agreement with the “The U.S. had to show they
U.S. to stage free and fair elec- were doing something,” Alvar-
tions, the White House was un- ado said of the policy. “But in
der pressure to reimpose sanc- the end, things don’t change all
tions on Venezuela’s lifeblood that much, it just adds a lot
energy industry. more bureaucracy.”
Under the new guidelines re- U.S. officials declined to say
DONAL HUSNI/ZUMA PRESS
Apple CEO Tim Cook didn’t offer a timeline for the investment or say what form it could take.
after the U.S.
lifted sanctions
and issued a
800,000
six-month gen- Number of barrels of pact the new
for licenses.
And it remained
unclear the im-
still expanding in buildings they lysts polled by FactSet expected international coordination
leased during the pandemic $1.84 billion. The company fore- against this egregious viola-
amid red-hot demand for new cast earnings per share attrib- tion of human rights,” said
warehouses. utable to common shareholders Reps. Mike Gallagher (R.,
The dimming outlook came of between $3.15 and $3.35, Wis.), the departing commit-
as Prologis on Wednesday compared with its prior outlook tee chairman, and Raja Krish-
posted earnings attributable to in the range of $3.20 to $3.45 a namoorthi (D., Ill.), its ranking Reps. Raja Krishnamoorthi, left, and Mike Gallagher want the U.S. to lobby Western allies.
common shareholders of $584.3 share. member.
The State Department gen- port of goods linked to forced approves the ban, the matter cerned that goods made by
erally doesn’t comment on labor from around the globe, will go before the Council of Uyghur forced labor continue
TECHNOLOGY WSJ.com/Tech
Miners Bid at their peak in early 2021. ers. Many of them are also
The Marketplace
ADVERTISEMENT
Editor Exits cluding writer Christopher
Rufo—of the Manhattan Insti-
tute, a conservative think
Just Eat
To advertise: 800-366-3975 or WSJ.com/classifieds
NPR After tank—resurfaced her past posts
on X that indicate liberal lean-
ings. In one post from 2020,
Reports
NOTICE OF SALE
Criticizing It she is describing a dream
where she is on a road trip
with Kamala, referring to Ka-
Decline in
mala Harris, who is now vice
Key Metric
NOTICE OF PUBLIC SALE • Property to be Sold 82 362375AK3 GSAA 2006-10 M4 4,579,000.00
83 362375AL1 GSAA 2006-10 M5 2,000,000.00
Public Sale No.1: Tuesday,April 23rd,2024 9:30 a.m.
EDT. The Asset Type for Lots 1-2 is ABS CDO. The Asset 84 362334GW8 GSAA 2006-5 M3 2,000,000.00 Continued from page B1 president. In 2018, she called
Type for Lot 3 is CRE CDO. The Asset Type for Lots 85 362334GX6 GSAA 2006-5 M4 2,000,000.00 National Committee head Donald Trump a racist in a
4-15 is Prime / Alt-A. The Asset Type for Lots 16-17 86 362334GY4 GSAA 2006-5 M5 2,000,000.00
is Scratch and Dent. The Asset Type for Lots 18-35 is 87 362334MJ0 GSAA 2006-6 M1 2,000,000.00 whom the network had hired post that has since been de-
Subprime. The Asset Type for Lots 36-37 is Trups. 88 362334MM3 GSAA 2006-6 M4 3,317,000.00 as a contributor just days ear- leted. BY NAJAT KANTOUAR
PETE KIEHART FOR THE FREE PRESS
The Asset Type for Lots 38-40 is Zero Factor - CDO. 89 362334NJ9 GSAA 2006-7 M4 744,000.00
The Asset Type for Lots 41-138 is Zero Factor - RMBS. 90 43710TAG2 HEAT 2007-3 M2 1,250,000.00 lier, after her appointment “This is a bad-faith attack
Lot # CUSIP Issue Original Face 91 43710TAH0 HEAT 2007-3 M3
92 43710XAG3 HELT 2007-FRE1 M2 13,000,000.00
1,500,000.00 sparked an uproar among em- that follows an established Just Eat Takeaway.com
1 49858YAD7 KLROS 2006-5A B 15,000,000
2 87400PAE7 THOM 2007-2A B 18,750,000.00 93 45257BAK6 IMSA 2006-4 M5 1,925,000.00 ployees. playbook, as online actors with reported a decline in gross
94 45257BAL4 IMSA 2006-4 M6 1,750,000.00
3 47631WAD9 JER 2006-2A BFL
4 17309BAD9 CMLTI 2006-WF2 A2E
7,500,000
5,000,000 95 456610AG9 INDX 2006-AR15 M4 3,000,000.00
As for the Times, its execu- explicit agendas work to dis- transaction value on lower
5 02147FAV8 CWALT 2006-18CB A11 20,000,000 96 45661EAK0 INDX 2006-AR2 M3 2,500,000.00 tive editor said earlier this credit independent news or- orders for the first quarter
6 02148HAL5 CWALT 2006-31CB A11 20,000,000 97 45661EAL8 INDX 2006-AR2 M4 1,500,000.00
7 02148JAF4 CWALT 2006-39CB 1A6 20,000,000 98 45661EAM6 INDX 2006-AR2 M5 1,500,000.00 week that it ended its leak in- ganizations,” the NPR spokes- and backed its full-year guid-
8 12668BUB7 CWALT 2006-6CB 2A13 20,000,000 99 45662DAM7 INDX 2006-AR29 M6 4,178,000.00 vestigation without any conclu- woman said. ance.
9 251510NC3 DBALT 2006-AF1 A4 8,000,000 100 46626LJW1 JPMAC 2006-NC1 M6 2,492,000.00
10 362375AE7 GSAA 2006-10 AF5 7,000,000 101 542514UN2 LBMLT 2006-3 M2 3,000,000.00 sive finding. In a separate in- NPR “Morning Edition” host The Amsterdam-based
11 36244SAD0 GSAA 2006-13 AF4 10,000,000 102 52523KAT1 LXS 2006-17 1M3 7,764,000.00 terview with The Wall Street Uri Berliner had been Steve Inskeep was critical of food-delivery group said
12 36244SAE8 GSAA 2006-13 AF5 10,000,000 103 52523KAV6 LXS 2006-17 1M5 4,852,000.00
13 362334MF8 GSAA 2006-6 AF4 10,000,000 104 52523QAK7 LXS 2006-20 M4 1,822,500.00 Journal, he said traditional suspended over his article. Berliner’s piece. “My col- Wednesday that gross trans-
14 362334ND2 GSAA 2006-7 AF4A 9,500,000 105 52523QAL5
106 52523QAM3
LXS 2006-20 M5
LXS 2006-20 M6
1,822,500.00
3,645,000.00
journalistic values such as in- league’s article was filled with action value—a key metric for
15 452550AB2 IMM 2007-A M1 10,465,000
16 07325NDX7 BAYV 2006-B M4 4,278,000 107 59024UAH4 MLMI 2007-MLN1 M3 4,000,000.00 dependence aren’t ingrained in larizing debate. errors and omissions,” he the industry—for the quarter
17 073879MD7 BSABS 2004-SD4 M1
18 040104SS1 ARSI 2006-W3 A2D
3,868,000
9,512,000
108 61753KAG1 MSAC 2007-HE5 M2 2,735,000.00
109 65538DAH8 NAA 2006-AR4 M2 1,791,000.00
all corners of the Times’s In his essay in the Free wrote on Substack (after get- was €6.55 billion, or about
19 17313EAB1 CMLTI 2007-FS1 2A1A 5,100,000 110 65538DAJ4 NAA 2006-AR4 M3 4,200,000.00 newsroom. Press, a media company ting approval from NPR, the $6.96 billion, compared with
111 65538DAK1 NAA 2006-AR4 M4 1,950,000.00
20 126673VT6
21 29256PAK0
ECR 2005-1 M5
ECR 2005-3 M6
5,000,000
8,000,000 112 65538DAL9 NAA 2006-AR4 M5 2,850,000.00 In November, the Washing- founded by Bari Weiss, a for- company said). €6.665 billion for the same pe-
22 59025RAU1 FFMER 2007-5 2A2 1,673,000 113 65537KAM2 NHELI 2007-1 2M5 1,238,000.00 ton Post removed a cartoon de- mer New York Times opinion Last week, Berliner spoke to riod a year earlier.
23 316599AK5 FMIC 2006-3 M5 3,000,000 114 65537KAN0 NHELI 2007-1 2M6 3,300,000.00
24 316599AL3 FMIC 2006-3 M6 4,015,000 115 68403FAG1 OOMLT 2007-4 M2 1,300,000.00 picting a Hamas spokesman editor, Berliner wrote that Weiss on her podcast about his Just Eat said it processed
25 43710TAF4 HEAT 2007-3 M1 2,000,000 116 68403FAH9 OOMLT 2007-4 M3 5,200,000.00 putting civilians in the line of NPR’s newsroom had lost its decision to write the piece, 214.2 million orders in the pe-
26 46629FAF7 JPMAC 2006-NC2 M2 5,500,000 117 68403HAG7 OOMLT 2007-5 M2 6,000,000.00
27 542514UL6 LBMLT 2006-3 2A4 4,000,000 118 68403HAH5 OOMLT 2007-5 M3 3,000,000.00 fire after several employees culture of open-mindedness which he said “wasn’t easy.” riod compared with 227.8 mil-
28 57646LAB9 MABS 2007-HE2 A3 10,000,000 119 69121PEJ8 OWNIT 2006-3 M6 2,225,000.00 and readers complained that it and no longer offered a diver- He told Weiss he had made lion.
29 64352VQS3 NCHET 2006-1 A2C 10,000,000 120 69121QAG6 OWNIT 2006-4 M2 10,000,000.00
30 76113ABL4 RASC 2006-KS3 M1 5,000,000.00 121 69121QAH4 OWNIT 2006-4 M3 10,320,000.00 was racist. sity of viewpoints. The piece, his views well-known within “Management decided to
31 76113ABM2 RASC 2006-KS3 M2 3,000,000.00 122 76113ABP5 RASC 2006-KS3 M4
123 76113ABQ3 RASC 2006-KS3 M5
3,000,000.00
2,000,000.00
“Journalists have more ways titled “I’ve Been at NPR for 25 NPR and with top news manag- discontinue all operations in
32 863576FL3 SASC 2006-WF1 M4 2,216,000.00
33 863576FN9 SASC 2006-WF1 M6 3,000,000.00 124 86358EE93 SAIL 2006-2 M2 6,000,000.00 to express themselves pub- Years. Here’s How We Lost ers. “I’ve been hammering away New Zealand in the coming
34 81879MAW9 SGMS 2006-FRE1 A2C 1,500,000.00 125 86363LAC7 SARM 2007-4 M1 16,251,000.00 licly—via social media or unaf- America’s Trust,” also said the at these things for years…and weeks. The financial impact is
35 83613AAQ5 SVHE 2007 OPT4 2A2 4,000,000.00 126 86363XAL1 SARM 2007-5 M1 8,494,000.00
36 74042MAC0 PREFERREDTERM XXII 10,000,000 127 86363XAM9 SARM 2007-5 M2 2,533,000.00 filiated websites—so the grum- network had erred in its cover- nothing has changed. I felt like immaterial,” the company’s
37 90342WAE7 USCAP 2006-5A A3 5,000,000.00 128 86359PAK6 SASC 2006-BC3 M6 7,000,000.00
38 28257EAV2 EIRLESTWO LIMITED 242 15,000,000.00 129 86363HAG7 SASC 2007-EQ1 M2 2,000,000.00 bling that used to be confined age of high-profile events, from maybe, it’s better to be public board said.
39 28257EAW0 EIRLESTWO LIMITED 243 7,500,000.00 130 86363HAH5 SASC 2007-EQ1 M3 1,500,000.00 to the company cafeteria now the origins of Covid-19 to about this than to be quietly The company reiterated its
40 296605AB4 ESPF 2006-1A A2 20,000,000.00 131 80556YAG0 SAST 2007-2 M2 7,539,000.00
41 004421XK4 ACE 2006-ASP2 M4 1,000,000.00 132 80556YAH8 SAST 2007-2 M3 2,000,000.00 goes public and viral,” said Bill Hunter Biden’s laptop to the Is- bringing this up in the halls of 2024 guidance for adjusted
42 004421XM0 ACE 2006-ASP2 M6 1,500,000.00 133 81879MAZ2 SGMS 2006-FRE1 M3 2,000,000.00 Grueskin, a professor at Colum- rael-Hamas conflict. the newsroom. Let’s try being earnings before interest,
43 02660TJJ3 AHM 2006-1 1M1 2,821,000.00 134 84751PLR8 SURF 2006-BC2 M2 4,500,000.00
44 02660TJK0 AHM 2006-1 1M2 2,000,000.00 135 83612JAF1 SVHE 2006-EQ1 M2 5,000,000.00 bia Journalism School and a In a note to staff days after open about this.” taxes, depreciation and amor-
45 04012MAG4 ARSI 2006-M1 M6 10,000,000.00 136 83612JAG9 SVHE 2006-EQ1 M3 10,000,000.00 former Journal editor. the piece was published, NPR In an interview Tuesday, tization of €450 million.
46 04013BAF9 ARSI 2006-M2 M2 7,000,000.00 137 93364EAH7 WMHE 2007-HE3 M2 3,000,000.00
47 04013BAG7 ARSI 2006-M2 M3 5,000,000.00 138 93364EAJ3 WMHE 2007-HE3 M3 2,000,000.00 Newsroom managers have Chief Executive Katherine Ma- Weiss said she was “proud that The food-delivery group ex-
48 073870AC1 Balta 2007-2 1M1 11,000,000.00 Dock Street Capital Management LLC, on behalf of Wells Fargo
Bank, National Association, in its capacity as trustee (the
faced all kinds of criticism— her wrote that while asking someone like Uri Berliner pects 2024 constant-currency
49 05530VAE9 BCAP 2007-AA3 1M2 1,250,000.00
50 05530VAF6 BCAP 2007-AA3 1M3 1,000,000.00 “Trustee”), will be conducting a public sale of certain collateral that their journalism is too whether the public radio net- thought of the Free Press as a GTV growth excluding North
pledged to the Trustee. The Collateral (as defined herein) will be
51 073879YK8 BSABS 2005-AC4 M3 4,842,000.00
52 07388FAF0 BSABS 2006-2 M3 7,787,000.00 offeredandsoldbytheTrusteewithoutrecourse,representations, skeptical of Donald Trump and work was living up to its mis- home for such an important America in a range of 2% to
53 07388FAG8 BSABS 2006-2 M4 3,520,000.00 or covenants, express or implied, being made by the Trustee
with respect to the Collateral (except as to title to the Collateral)
his allies or not skeptical sion was fair game, “Question- piece.” Weiss resigned from the 6% year over year, in line with
54 07400HAG8 BSMF 2006-AR3 1B2 8,229,000.00
55 07400HAH6 BSMF 2006-AR3 1B3 3,032,000.00 or with respect to any other information then in the Trustee’s enough; too pro-Israel or too ing whether our people are Times in 2020, describing it at its previous guidance.
possession, including without limitation any offering circular or
56 16678RFD4 CCMFC 2006-1A B1 3,000,000.00
other financial information. Location of Sales. The sales will be pro-Palestinian; and gives too serving our mission with integ- the time as a place where the The company also expects
57 16678RFE2 CCMFC 2006-1A B2 2,629,000.00
58 16678WAD8 CCMFC 2006-2A B2 4,000,000.00
held at 575-B Riverside Avenue,Westport,CT 06880. Additional much or too little ink to sensi- rity, based on little more than free exchange of ideas was no free cash flow to continue to
Information. Please be advised that the sale of each security
59 17309BAF4 CMLTI 2006-WF2 M1 7,900,000.00 listed above may be made only to the best bidder who is also tive social issues. the recognition of their iden- longer welcome. She later be positive in 2024 and there-
60 225470R70 CSMC 2006-3 1M1 3,000,000.00
61 02146QAQ6 CWALT 2006-OA10 M5 10,000,000.00
a qualified bidder and may be subject to a reserve level. For
additional information, including with respect to qualified
To some extent, newsrooms tity, is profoundly disrespectful, launched the Free Press. Weiss after.
62 23245FAG8 CWALT 2006-OC10 M2 6,752,000.00 bidder status,and to obtain copies of an Investor Representation reflect a broader rise in em- hurtful, and demeaning.” previously worked at the Jour- Just Eat said that it contin-
63 23245FAH6 CWALT 2006-OC10 M3 1,500,000.00 and Confidentiality Agreement, contact David Crowle or Jeffrey
64 23245FAK9 CWALT 2006-OC10 M5 2,000,000.00 Holtman by email at dcrowle@dockstreetcap.com or jholtman@ ployee activism On Wednes- nal, where she was an op-ed ues to actively explore the
65 23245FAL7 CWALT 2006-OC10 M6 2,000,000.00
66 12666BAH8 CWL 2006-22 M3 5,000,000.00
dockstreetcap.com, respectively, by phone at (212) 457-8258, in U.S. corpora- day, Berliner and book review editor. partial or full sale of Grubhub.
by facsimile at (212) 457-8269 or by mail addressed to 575-B
67 12669VAH1 CWL 2007-7 M3 2,000,000.00 tions over the made public the Before tendering his resig-
68 12669QAH2 CWL 2007-BC2 M3 2,000,000.00
Riverside Avenue,Westport,CT 06880. Disclaimer. The Trustee
is authorized at such sale, if the Trustee deems it advisable or is
required by applicable law to do so:(i) to restrict the prospective past few years, Newsrooms resignation let- nation on Wednesday, Berliner Just Eat’s gross transaction
69 251513AF4 DBALT 2006-AB4 M6 5,594,000.00
70 251513AG2 DBALT 2006-AB4 M7 5,594,000.00 bidders on or purchasers of any of the above identified securities which was face a growing ter he had sent forwarded to dozens of col- value, change from a year
71 251510NG4 DBALT 2006-AF1 M3 2,000,000.00 (the“Collateral”) to be sold to those who will represent and agree earlier
72 25150RAP0 DBALT 2006-AR6 M6 2,058,000.00 that they are purchasing for their own account for investment partly inspired to Maher. “I re- leagues a note that he said he
73 25151RAM6 DBALT 2007-AR1 M4 1,035,000.00 and not with a view to the distribution or resale of any of such
assets, (ii) to verify that each certificate for each security to be
by the social willingness by spect the integ- had sent to NPR news leaders 4%
74 25151RAN4 DBALT 2007-AR1 M5 1,194,000.00
reckoning over rity of my col- in November 2016, shortly after
75 25151RAP9 DBALT 2007-AR1 M6 1,194,000.00
76 25157GCY6 DMSI 2006-PR1 B2 7,970,500.00
sold that has not been registered under the Securities Act of 1933
bears a legend substantially to the effect that such security has
the police killing
staff to speak leagues and Trump’s election as president.
77 25157GDA7 DMSI 2006-PR1 B3 7,970,500.00 notbeenregisteredundertheSecuritiesActof1933,asamended, 2
78 32029GAL8 FFML 2007-FF2 M6 8,000,000.00 and may not be disposed of in violation of the provisions of said
Act,(iii) to disclaim and to refuse to give any warranty (other than
of George Floyd their mind. wish for NPR to In it, he advocated for NPR re- 1Q 2024
79 35729QAH1 FHLT 2006-B M3 5,000,000.00 as to title),and (iv) to impose such other limitations or conditions in May 2020. thrive and do porters to venture beyond their –1.8%
80 35729VAK3 FHLT 2006-D M5 6,000,000.00 0
81 35729VAL1 FHLT 2006-D M6 4,000,000.00
in connection with any such sale as the Trustee deems necessary
oradvisable.
But news- important jour- comfort zone of coastal cities
rooms have cer- nalism,” he and college towns.
tain qualities that make them wrote. “But I cannot work in a McGrory, the former Boston –2
ANNOUNCEMENTS
an ideal crucible for these sorts newsroom where I am dispar- Globe editor, said about news-
THEMARKETPLACE of tensions between managers aged by a new CEO whose divi- rooms: “Leadership should be –4
Your Book
The Story of Your Life in Business,
ADVERTISE TODAY
(800) 366-3975
and employees: The staffers, or
“talent” in television parlance,
sive views confirm the very
problems that I cite in my Free
open to their staffers airing
concerns internally.” But –6
Your Strategies for Success & Your have big megaphones and often Press essay.” when staffers, like Berliner,
For more information visit:
Wisdom & Advice Should Be in a have brands that surpass those Maher, a former Wikimedia make their complaints public, –8
wsj.com/classifieds
Book. We Write/Publish Your Story. of their bosses; meanwhile, the Foundation CEO who joined “you’re actually harming the 2022 '23 '24
BizSuccessBooks.com © 2024 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.
product they are producing— NPR last month, became part organization you’re pretending
(904) 293-9893 * Since 1999 journalism—lends itself to po- of the story when critics, in- to try to save.” Source: the company
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. * * * Thursday, April 18, 2024 | B5
BUSINESS NEWS
Beat Forecasts
Continued from page B1
sion,” the company said, refer-
On Rise in Prices
ring to the National Labor Re-
lations Board. BY DOMINIC CHOPPING Volvo’s truck deliveries,
VW’s European factory quarterly
workforce is unionized, and la- Volvo posted forecast-beat- 1Q 2024
bor officials hold several seats ing first-quarter earnings af- 70 thousand 55,470 trucks
on the German automaker’s su- ter price increases imple- –9.9%*
pervisory board. mented last year continued to 60
For decades, Detroit execu- feed through, helping offset
tives complained the UAW con- normalizing truck orders and 50
tracts leave them with heavier UAW President Shawn Fain wants to add members outside the union’s Midwest stronghold. generally declining demand
labor costs than Toyota Motor, for construction equipment. 40
Honda Motor and other for- in the Great Lakes region. United Auto Workers ful organizing drives at Star- The Swedish truck maker
eign rivals with nonunion U.S. A unionization vote at VW’s annual membership bucks stores, an Amazon.com said Wednesday that truck de-
30
workforces. In 2022, foreign Chattanooga factory failed in 700 thousand warehouse and the Dartmouth liveries fell 9.9% in the quarter
automakers paid a top wage of 2014, and the UAW fell short men’s basketball team. And while order intake fell 19%.
20
about $28 an hour, compared again in a close vote in 2019. 600 unions notched several collec- Truck-market conditions
with about $32 at the three De- Workers at a Nissan Motor tive-bargaining wins—at continued to normalize both
troit companies. plant in Mississippi in 2017 also United Parcel Service, Deere in Europe and North America 10
500
The new UAW contracts se- rejected UAW representation. and other companies. as transport volumes and
cured in the fall further On Tuesday, a group of six Fain was elected UAW’s freight rates come down from 0
400
boosted the top pay for factory Southern governors, including president in March 2023 on a very high levels, the company 2021 ’22 ’23 ’24
workers at GM, Ford and Stel- Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee, issued 300 message of change, after years said. *From a year earlier Source: the company
lantis to roughly $42 an hour. a letter in opposition to the of corruption in its top ranks. Order backlogs and lead
Since then, Tesla and several UAW’s organizing drive, claim- 200 A unionization vote by about times have normalized in Eu- nor, equivalent to $1.28 bil-
foreign automakers doled out ing it would threaten their 5,000 Mercedes-Benz workers rope and the company has lion, compared with 12.91 bil-
significant wage increases to auto-industry investments and 100 at the German automaker’s gradually reduced production lion kronor a year earlier as
their U.S. workers. the health of the companies. plant near Tuscaloosa, Ala., is capacity in Europe. In North sales were virtually un-
Beyond VW, the union wants “Unionization would cer- 0 expected next month after America, Mack Trucks’ order changed at 131.18 billion kro-
to organize factories of about a tainly put our states’ jobs in 2000 ’05 ’10 ’15 ’20 enough signatures were gath- backlogs are still extended. nor. Analysts polled by Fact-
dozen other automakers, in- jeopardy,” reads the letter, also Note: UAW also represents workers ered to call for a vote under Demand for new construc- Set had expected a net profit
cluding Toyota, Honda and signed by the governors of Ala- in other industries. NLRB rules, the UAW has said. tion equipment has come of 12.9 billion kronor on sales
electric-vehicle maker Tesla, bama, Georgia, Mississippi, Source: UAW In Chattanooga, workers will down in many markets, partic- of 129.44 billion kronor.
accounting for about 150,000 South Carolina and Texas. vote up or down on the ques- ularly in Europe. Both deliver- Volvo maintained its 2024
workers. That is roughly the Fain’s team seized on a con- and a record run of carmaker tion of whether they want to be ies and order intake decreased truck-market forecasts for Eu-
same number covered under fluence of macro factors that profits—all set amid a galva- represented by the UAW in col- in Europe and North America rope, North America and
the contracts with GM, Ford aided the union’s historic con- nized U.S. labor movement. lective bargaining. The NLRB is but increased in China. China, but lifted its forecast
and Stellantis, at factories tract wins in Detroit last fall: a In the past few years, other overseeing the vote and expects Volvo reported a net profit for Brazil and lowered it for
mostly in union-friendly states tight labor market, high inflation labor unions mounted success- to have results by late Friday. of 14.08 billion Swedish kro- India.
Gifts for GRADS Celebrate your graduate with our expert-recommended gift ideas.
SHOP
wsj.com/buyside-graduation
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, April 18, 2024 | B7
From the beginning, Okta has focused on securing Identity so your company,
employees, partners, and customers can access their digital world.
Today, it’s more than just secure access. With our comprehensive Identity
solutions for enterprises and developers, we free you to build your stack
your way. So you can grow revenue, increase efficiencies, control IT costs,
and strengthen security.
From emerging startups to the largest global enterprises, we’ve got you covered.
With Okta:
That’s why nearly 19,000 of the world’s most trusted brands trust Okta.
MARKETS DIGEST
EQUITIES
Dow Jones Industrial Average S&P 500 Index Nasdaq Composite Index
Last Year ago Last Year ago Last Year ago
37753.31 t 45.66, or 0.12% Trailing P/E ratio 26.45 22.71 5022.21 t 29.20, or 0.58% Trailing P/E ratio * 24.36 18.56 15683.37 t 181.88, or 1.15% Trailing P/E ratio *† 30.78 26.72
High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 18.53 18.25 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate * 21.25 18.88 High, low, open and close for each P/E estimate *† 27.15 26.01
trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield 2.22 2.07 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield * 1.40 1.67 trading day of the past three months. Dividend yield *† 0.83 0.84
All-time high 39807.37, 03/28/24 All-time high 5254.35, 03/28/24 All-time high: 16442.20, 04/11/24
COMMODITIES | wsj.com/market-data/commodities
Metal & Petroleum Futures Natural Gas (NYM)-10,000 MMBtu.; $ per MMBtu. Aug 251.975 252.825 251.175 252.125 –.225 20,435 Three-Month SOFR (CME)-$1,000,000; 100 - daily avg.
May 1.680 1.724 1.660 1.712 –.020 137,612 Cattle-Live (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Feb 94.6550 94.6550 94.6525 94.6550 .0025 4,947
Contract Open June 1.940 1.976 1.914 1.962 –.026 230,005 April 181.175 181.625 180.075 180.900 –.600 8,184 Dec 95.0600 95.1200 95.0400 95.1050 .0150 1,202,152
Open High hi lo Low Settle Chg interest July 2.273 2.310 2.258 2.294 –.029 251,315 June 175.650 176.100 174.375 175.325 –.400 115,518
Copper-High (CMX)-25,000 lbs.; $ per lb. Sept 2.389 2.420 2.376 2.402 –.032 146,333 Hogs-Lean (CME)-40,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Currency Futures
April 4.3715 4.3715 4.3490 4.3425 0.0370 802 Oct 2.504 2.530 2.479 2.509 –.026 103,966 May 94.750 95.125 94.000 94.925 .200 6,171
July 4.3225 4.4045 4.3135 4.3635 0.0320 118,149 Jan'25 3.732 3.754 3.709 3.742 –.020 83,642 Japanese Yen (CME)-¥12,500,000; $ per 100¥
Gold (CMX)-100 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. June 102.800 103.550 102.275 102.725 –.100 102,003
May .6490 .6512 .6489 .6505 .0012 3,470
April 2384.20 2391.40 2369.30 2371.70 –19.10 398 Lumber (CME)-27,500 bd. ft., $ per 1,000 bd. ft.
Agriculture Futures May 533.00 533.00t 520.50 520.50 –6.50 5,642
June .6526 .6548 .6524 .6540 .0012 325,381
May 2387.90 2399.50 2359.70 2376.20 –19.30 1,819 Canadian Dollar (CME)-CAD 100,000; $ per CAD
June 2398.00 2412.00 2370.70 2388.40 –19.40 417,395 Corn (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. July 552.50 553.00t 545.00 545.50 –7.00 2,544 May .7238 .7270 .7230 .7264 .0020 577
Aug 2420.40 2434.20 2393.70 2410.50 –19.50 56,914 May 431.00 433.00 429.50 430.25 –.75 304,759 Milk (CME)-200,000 lbs., cents per lb. June .7239 .7275 .7234 .7268 .0020 229,537
Oct 2442.00 2456.20 2417.20 2432.80 –19.50 11,856 July 442.75 444.25 440.75 441.00 –1.75 561,942 April 15.47 15.54 15.46 15.47 … 4,958 British Pound (CME)-£62,500; $ per £
Dec 2467.70 2479.00 2439.60 2455.30 –19.60 21,537 Oats (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. May 17.25 17.30 16.80 17.22 –.09 6,143 May 1.2430 1.2483 1.2420 1.2453 .0013 882
Palladium (NYM) - 50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. May 348.50 352.25 339.25 349.25 3.25 1,806 Cocoa (ICE-US)-10 metric tons; $ per ton. June 1.2430 1.2486 1.2421 1.2456 .0013 223,924
April 995.00 999.00 990.00 1029.00 –0.40 3 July 336.75 341.50 329.50 340.00 3.25 2,031 May 10,173 10,630 10,100 10,340 97 11,616
Soybeans (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. Swiss Franc (CME)-CHF 125,000; $ per CHF
June 1024.50 1055.00 1014.50 1030.80 –0.40 20,012 July 9,750 10,297 9,713 10,066 247 55,671
May 1145.00 1155.25 1141.75 1149.50 4.50 214,649 June 1.1030 1.1073 1.1027 1.1060 .0020 92,839
Platinum (NYM)-50 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. Coffee (ICE-US)-37,500 lbs.; cents per lb.
July 1160.50 1169.50 1156.75 1164.25 4.25 343,893 Sept 1.1151 1.1187 1.1144 1.1176 .0020 401
April 966.00 966.00 958.70 942.70 –21.30 6 May 237.40 249.30 s 236.40 247.95 11.20 12,688
July 971.50 974.00 952.00 954.20 –21.00 71,632 Soybean Meal (CBT)-100 tons; $ per ton. Australian Dollar (CME)-AUD 100,000; $ per AUD
335.70 340.70 335.30 338.70 3.40 104,646 July 228.00 241.70 s 227.75 240.35 11.95 122,721 May .6413 .6451 .6405 .6441 .0023 645
Silver (CMX)-5,000 troy oz.; $ per troy oz. May
July 337.00 341.40 336.40 339.80 3.00 208,347
Sugar-World (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb. June .6414 .6458 .6412 .6448 .0023 232,702
April 28.510 28.510 28.310 28.346 0.028 91
Soybean Oil (CBT)-60,000 lbs.; cents per lb. May 19.57 19.63 t 19.17 19.32 –.31 109,648 Mexican Peso (CME)-MXN 500,000; $ per MXN
May 28.195 28.895 28.145 28.400 0.024 78,889
Crude Oil, Light Sweet (NYM)-1,000 bbls.; $ per bbl. May 44.94 45.31 44.56 45.00 .09 117,558 July 19.47 19.53 t 19.08 19.27 –.26 296,269 May .05871 .05903 .05831 .05872 .00019 12
May 85.36 85.51 82.55 82.69 –2.67 116,585 July 45.51 45.84 45.12 45.56 .08 228,520 Sugar-Domestic (ICE-US)-112,000 lbs.; cents per lb. June .05798 .05871 .05794 .05839 .00019 286,308
June 84.82 84.97 82.01 82.15 –2.68 367,895 Rough Rice (CBT)-2,000 cwt.; $ per cwt. July 38.95 –.75 1,710 Euro (CME)-€125,000; $ per €
July 84.23 84.37 81.50 81.61 –2.61 196,773 May 18.39 18.95 18.37 18.83 .47 2,982 Sept 38.95 –.25 2,051 May 1.0629 1.0690 1.0618 1.0681 .0039 3,080
Sept 82.77 82.87 80.22 80.31 –2.42 120,947 July 18.22 18.83 18.22 18.81 .59 2,691 Cotton (ICE-US)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. June 1.0645 1.0706 1.0633 1.0697 .0039 649,425
Dec 80.48 80.60 78.21 78.31 –2.09 186,422 Wheat (CBT)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. May 81.27 81.94 t 79.03 79.56 –1.73 14,315
June'25 76.80 76.93 74.96 75.09 –1.65 99,694 May 550.50 555.00 536.00 537.00 –12.75 64,974 July 83.09 83.79 t 80.91 81.33 –1.76 92,356 Index Futures
NY Harbor ULSD (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. July 565.00 570.00 551.00 552.25 –12.50 202,184 Orange Juice (ICE-US)-15,000 lbs.; cents per lb.
May 2.6549 2.6582 2.5620 2.5747 –.0766 46,111 Wheat (KC)-5,000 bu.; cents per bu. May 362.45 366.05 357.15 362.85 –1.20 3,703
Mini DJ Industrial Average (CBT)-$5 x index
June 2.6581 2.6643 2.5702 2.5809 –.0769 83,477 May 586.75 589.25 572.25 572.75 –14.75 44,450 June 38080 38257 37842 37990 –56 93,313
July 363.05 365.50 357.40 362.60 –1.10 4,043
Gasoline-NY RBOB (NYM)-42,000 gal.; $ per gal. July 582.00 584.75 568.75 569.00 –14.00 131,191 Sept 38525 38636 38232 38369 –57 294
May 2.8180 2.8229 2.7211 2.7287 –.0936 81,521 Cattle-Feeder (CME)-50,000 lbs.; cents per lb. Mini S&P 500 (CME)-$50 x index
April 240.500 241.300 240.150 240.425 .075 2,481
Interest Rate Futures June 5096.25 5120.50 5047.00 5062.25 –30.25 2,078,277
June 2.7888 2.7919 2.6938 2.6992 –.0919 103,791
Ultra Treasury Bonds (CBT) - $100,000; pts 32nds of 100% Sept 5154.25 5177.00 5104.25 5119.50 –30.25 17,680
June 120-000 121-110 119-210 121-080 1-05.0 1,608,434 Mini S&P Midcap 400 (CME)-$100 x index
Treasury Bonds (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% June 2880.50 2895.60 2848.90 2852.30 –24.20 35,844
Cash Prices | wsj.com/market-data/commodities Wednesday, April 17, 2024 June
Sept
113-270 114-310
113-240 114-310
113-200
113-230
114-270
114-280
28.0 1,545,260
28.0 996
Sept 3013.60 2910.60
Mini Nasdaq 100 (CME)-$20 x index
2883.50 2871.50 –23.90 2
These prices reflect buying and selling of a variety of actual or “physical” commodities in the marketplace—separate from Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% June 17897.00 17968.50 17615.25 17658.50 –222.75 253,457
the futures price on an exchange, which reflects what the commodity might be worth in future months. June 107-185 108-080 107-155 108-050 15.5 4,434,135 Sept 18140.00 18196.00 17842.25 17884.25 –223.00 2,072
Sept 107-265 108-160 107-240 108-135 15.5 1,562 Mini Russell 2000 (CME)-$50 x index
Wednesday Wednesday Wednesday 5 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$100,000; pts 32nds of 100% June 1983.30 2000.90 1959.20 1962.00 –20.80 480,562
Iron Ore, 62% Fe CFR China-s *110.4 Wheat - Hard - KC (USDA) $ per bu-u 6.1175 June 104-282 105-100 104-267 105-077 8.5 6,009,746 Sept 2006.40 2020.60 1980.80 1982.80 –20.90 700
Energy *825.0 Mini Russell 1000 (CME)-$50 x index
Steel, HRC USA, FOB Midwest Mill-s Wheat,No.1soft white,Portld,OR-u 5.6750 Sept 105-160 105-195 105-060 105-182 8.5 6,731
Coal,C.Aplc.,12500Btu,1.2SO2-r,w 77.350 Battery/EV metals 2 Yr. Treasury Notes (CBT)-$200,000; pts 32nds of 100% June 2800.60 2802.30 2763.60 2771.50 –17.10 6,179
Coal,PwdrRvrBsn,8800Btu,0.8SO2-r,w 13.650 BMI Lithium Carbonate, EXW China, =99.2%-v,w 15250
Food June 101-156 101-201 101-147 101-190 1.9 3,987,219 U.S. Dollar Index (ICE-US)-$1,000 x index
BMI Lithium Hydroxide, EXW China, =56.5% -v,w 13650 Sept 101-266 101-290 101-259 101-283 1.4 73 June 106.16 106.26 105.69 105.76 –.30 43,553
Metals Beef,carcass equiv. index
BMI Cobalt sulphate, EXW China, >20.5% -v,m 4485 30 Day Federal Funds (CBT)-$5,000,000; 100 - daily avg. Sept 105.70 105.71 105.36 105.40 –.29 511
choice 1-3,600-900 lbs.-u 281.07
Gold, per troy oz BMI Nickel Sulphate, EXW China, >22%-v,m 4192 select 1-3,600-900 lbs.-u 273.82 April 94.6725 94.6725 t 94.6700 94.6700 –.0025 503,358
Engelhard industrial 2387.00 BMIFlakeGraphite,FOBChina,-100Mesh,94-95%-v,m 485 May 94.6750 94.6800 94.6750 94.6800 470,433 Source: FactSet
Broilers, National comp wtd. avg.-u,w 1.3301
Handy & Harman base 2390.35 Butter,AA Chicago-d 2.9250
Handy & Harman fabricated 2653.29
Fibers and Textiles
Cheddar cheese,bbl,Chicago-d 161.00
LBMA Gold Price AM *2369.00 Burlap,10-oz,40-inch NY yd-n,w 0.8000 Cheddar cheese,blk,Chicago-d 161.00 Bonds | wsj.com/market-data/bonds/benchmarks
LBMA Gold Price PM *2369.15 Cotton,1 1/16 std lw-mdMphs-u 0.7708 Milk,Nonfat dry,Chicago lb.-d 112.00
Krugerrand,wholesale-e 2487.52 Cotlook 'A' Index-t *89.60 Coffee,Brazilian,Comp-y 2.2860
Maple Leaf-e
American Eagle-e
2511.44
2511.44
Hides,hvy native steers piece fob-u n.a. Coffee,Colombian, NY-y 2.5402 Tracking Bond Benchmarks
Wool,64s,staple,Terr del-u,w n.a. Eggs,large white,Chicago-u 2.4150
Mexican peso-e 2891.85 Return on investment and spreads over Treasurys and/or yields paid to investors compared with 52-week
Austria crown-e 2347.49 Grains and Feeds Flour,hard winter KC-p 16.65
Hams,17-20 lbs,Mid-US fob-u n.a.
highs and lows for different types of bonds
Austria phil-e 2511.44 Bran,wheat middlings, KC-u,w 75 Hogs,Iowa-So. Minnesota-u 90.36 Total Total
Silver, troy oz. Corn,No. 2 yellow,Cent IL-bp,u 4.0600 return YTD total Yield (%) return YTD total Yield (%)
Engelhard industrial 28.5500 Pork bellies,12-14 lb MidUS-u n.a.
Corn gluten feed,Midwest-u,w 87.9 close return (%) Index Latest Low High close return (%) Index Latest Low High
Handy & Harman base 28.4740 Pork loins,13-19 lb MidUS-u 1.2690
Corn gluten meal,Midwest-u,w 396.3
Handy & Harman fabricated 35.5930 Cottonseed meal-u,w n.a.
Steers,Tex.-Okla. Choice-u n.a. Broad Market Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices Mortgage-Backed Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices
LBMA spot price *£22.7000 Hominy feed,Cent IL-u,w 112 Steers,feeder,Okla. City-u,w 290.75
1998.48 -2.9 U.S. Aggregate 5.220 4.240 5.740 1963.73 -3.4 Mortgage-Backed 5.440 4.350 6.050
(U.S.$ equivalent) *28.2550 Meat-bonemeal,50% pro Mnpls-u,w 325 Fats and Oils
Coins,wholesale $1,000 face-a 22262 Oats,No.2 milling,Mnpls-u 4.1925 U.S. Corporate Indexes Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices 1943.45 -3.2 Ginnie Mae (GNMA) 5.440 4.390 6.020
Other metals Rice, Long Grain Milled, No. 2 AR-u,w 36.25 Degummed corn oil, crude wtd. avg.-u,w n.a.
LBMA Platinum Price PM *966.0 Sorghum,(Milo) No.2 Gulf-u n.a. Grease,choice white,Chicago-h 0.4100 3029.82 -2.8 U.S. Corporate 5.680 5.020 6.430 1153.27 -3.5 Fannie mae (FNMA) 5.450 4.340 6.050
Platinum,Engelhard industrial 955.0 SoybeanMeal,Cent IL,rail,ton48%-u,w 358.40 Lard,Chicago-u n.a. 1791.04 -2.7 Freddie Mac (FHLMC) 5.390 4.320 6.190
2957.71 -1.1 Intermediate 5.610 4.920 6.350
Palladium,Engelhard industrial 1035.0 Soybeans,No.1 yllw IL-bp,u 11.2800 Soybean oil,crude;Centl IL-u,w 0.4589
Aluminum, LME, $ per metric ton *2512.0 Wheat,Spring14%-pro Mnpls-u 7.9325 Tallow,bleach;Chicago-h 0.4350 3952.69 -6.2 Long term 5.840 5.160 6.600 579.78 -1.4 Muni Master 3.552 3.038 4.311
Copper,Comex spot 4.3425 Wheat,No.2 soft red,St.Louis-u 5.2800 Tallow,edible,Chicago-u 0.5000
574.84 -3.7 Double-A-rated 5.250 4.380 5.760 412.14 -1.5 7-12 year 3.213 2.709 4.097
KEY TO CODES: A=ask; B=bid; BP=country elevator bids to producers; C=corrected; D=CME; E=Manfra,Tordella & Brookes; H=American Commodities Brokerage Co; 816.41 -2.5 Triple-B-rated 5.890 5.250 6.700 468.17 -1.6 12-22 year 3.844 3.388 4.742
K=bi-weekly; M=monthly; N=nominal; n.a.=not quoted or not available; P=Sosland Publishing; R=SNL Energy; S=Platts-TSI; T=Cotlook Limited; U=USDA; V=Benchmark
Mineral Intelligence; W=weekly; Y=International Coffee Organization; Z=not quoted. *Data as of 4/16 High Yield Bonds ICE BofA 441.31 -1.7 22-plus year 4.404 4.070 5.274
Source: Dow Jones Market Data Global Government J.P. Morgan†
524.27 -0.3 High Yield Constrained 8.305 7.620 9.560
510.44 0.7 Triple-C-rated 13.556 12.616 15.455 530.76 -2.4 Global Government 3.520 2.790 3.810
Borrowing Benchmarks | wsj.com/market-data/bonds/benchmarks 3523.61 -0.5 High Yield 100 7.836 7.030 9.101 783.44 -2.4 Canada 3.720 2.940 4.260
458.80 0.5 Global High Yield Constrained 8.094 7.552 9.440 350.75 -1.6 EMU§ 3.161 2.669 3.790
Money Rates April 17, 2024
350.38 1.2 Europe High Yield Constrained 6.676 6.207 8.022 645.55 -2.2 France 3.100 2.540 3.630
Key annual interest rates paid to borrow or lend money in U.S. and international markets. Rates below are a U.S Agency Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices 456.91 -2.3 Germany 2.550 2.020 3.030
guide to general levels but don’t always represent actual transactions. 1765.43 -0.8 U.S Agency 5.100 4.150 5.390 273.67 -1.9 Japan 1.280 0.710 1.300
Week —52-WEEK— Week —52-WEEK— -0.5
Inflation Latest ago High Low Latest ago High Low
1565.64 10-20 years 5.100 4.130 5.370 496.66 -2.4 Netherlands 2.770 2.260 3.320
March index Chg From (%) 3270.74 -5.1 5.180 4.390 5.740
30-year mortgage yields 20-plus years 777.84 -4.2 U.K. 4.500 3.790 4.880
March Overnight repurchase
level Feb. '24 30 days 6.807 6.367 7.495 5.739 -2.0
'23 U.S. 5.32 5.35 5.48 4.82 2670.16 Yankee 5.510 4.720 6.110 841.90 -0.8 Emerging Markets ** 7.600 7.205 8.842
60 days 6.818 6.372 7.554 5.739
*Constrained indexes limit individual issuer concentrations to 2%; the High Yield 100 are the 100 largest bonds † In local currency § Euro-zone bonds
U.S. consumer price index U.S. government rates Other short-term rates ** EMBI Global Index Sources: ICE Data Services; Bloomberg Fixed Income Indices; J.P.Morgan
All items 312.332 0.65 3.5 Discount
Core 317.088 0.53 3.8 Week 52-Week
5.50 5.50 5.50 5.00
International rates
Latest ago high low
Global Government Bonds: Mapping Yields
Federal funds Call money
Week 52-Week Effective rate 5.3300 5.3300 5.3500 4.8400 Yields and spreads over or under U.S. Treasurys on benchmark two-year and 10-year government bonds in
7.25 7.25 7.25 6.75
Latest ago High Low High 5.6500 5.6500 5.6500 5.1500 selected other countries; arrows indicate whether the yield rose(s) or fell (t) in the latest session
Low 5.3100 5.3100 5.3300 4.8000 Commercial paper (AA financial)
Prime rates Bid 5.3100 5.3100 5.3300 4.8200 Country/ Yield (%) Spread Under/Over U.S. Treasurys, in basis points
90 days n.a. 5.34 5.54 5.02 Coupon (%) Maturity, in years Latest(l) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 Previous Month ago Year ago Latest Prev Year ago
U.S. 8.50 8.50 8.50 8.00 Offer 5.3300 5.3300 5.3700 4.8400
Canada 7.20 7.20 7.20 6.70 Secured Overnight Financing Rate 4.500 U.S. 2 4.930 t l 4.961 4.721 4.186
Japan 1.475 1.475 1.475 1.475
Treasury bill auction 4.000 10 4.584t l 4.657 4.303 3.590
5.31 5.31 5.40 4.80
4 weeks 5.270 5.265 5.840 3.190
Policy Rates 13 weeks 5.250 5.225 5.345 5.060 Value 52-Week 4.250 Australia 2 3.999 s l 3.953 3.878 3.027 -94.1 -104.5 -117.6
5.155 5.120 5.350 4.840 Latest Traded High Low 3.750 10 4.390 s l 4.340 4.143 3.382 -33.3 -22.5
Euro zone 4.50 4.50 4.50 3.50 26 weeks -19.8
Switzerland 2.00 2.00 2.25 2.00 DTCC GCF Repo Index
Secondary market 2.500 France 2 2.965 s l 2.948 2.899 3.025 -197.4 -205.0 -117.8
Britain 5.25 5.25 5.25 4.25
Treasury 5.317 31.700 5.504 4.806 3.500 10 2.988 t l 3.011 2.877 3.036 -166.2 -57.0
Australia 4.35 4.35 4.35 3.60 Fannie Mae -160.0
MBS 5.363 52.320 5.689 4.829
2.500 Germany 2 2.956 s l 2.945 2.951 2.853 -198.3 -205.3 -135.0
Notes on data: 2.200 10 2.469 t l 2.492 2.442 2.473 -211.9 -218.1 -113.3
U.S. prime rate is the base rate on corporate loans posted by at least 70% of the 10 largest U.S. banks, and is effective July 27, 2023. Other prime rates
aren’t directly comparable; lending practices vary widely by location; Discount rate is effective July 27, 2023. Secured Overnight Financing Rate is as of 3.600 Italy 2 3.501 t l 3.515 3.442 3.409 -143.9 -148.4 -79.4
April 16, 2024. DTCC GCF Repo Index is Depository Trust & Clearing Corp.'s weighted average for overnight trades in applicable CUSIPs. Value traded is in
billions of U.S. dollars. Federal-funds rates are Tullett Prebon rates as of 5:30 p.m. ET. 4.200 10 3.876 t l 3.915 3.699 4.322 -71.2 -75.8 71.6
Sources: Federal Reserve; Bureau of Labor Statistics; DTCC; FactSet; 0.200 Japan 2 0.281 t l 0.283 0.193 -0.039 -465.8 -471.6 -424.2
Tullett Prebon Information, Ltd.
0.800 10 0.887 s l 0.872 0.793 0.482 -370.1 -380.1 -312.4
2.800 Spain 2 3.147 s l 3.135 3.117 3.140 -179.2 -186.4 -106.3
Macro & Market Economics 3.250 10 3.303 t l 3.330 3.242 3.525 -128.5 -134.3 -8.1
0.125 U.K. 2 4.458 t l 4.474 4.337 3.611 -48.1 -52.4 -59.2
Watching the Gauges: U.S. Supply and Demand 4.250 10 4.264 t l 4.304 4.202 3.696 -32.4 -36.9 9.0
Inventories, imports and demand for the week ended April 12. Current figures are in thousands of barrels or Source: Tullett Prebon, Tradeweb ICE U.S. Treasury Close
thousands of gallons per day, except natural-gas figures, which are in billions of cubic feet. Natural-gas import and
demand data are available monthly only. Corporate Debt
Prices of firms' bonds reflect factors including investors' economic, sectoral and company-specific
Inventories, 000s barrels Imports, 000s barrels per day expectations
Expected Previous Year 4-week 5-year Expected Previous Year 4-week 5-year Investment-grade spreads that tightened the most…
Current change week ago avg avg Current change week ago avg avg Spread*, in basis points
Issuer Symbol Coupon (%) Yield (%) Maturity Current One-day change Last week
Crude oil and –334 68
AstraZeneca AZN 4.000 5.58 Sept. 18, ’42 75
petroleum prod 1,237,522 ... 1,227 1,234 1,224 1,258 8,314 ... 8,801 8,538 8,440 8,627 Verizon Communications VZ 4.500 5.59 Aug. 10, ’33 96 –120 87
Crude oil American Honda Finance … 5.250 5.28 July 7, ’26 33 –101 31
excluding SPR 459,993 600 457 466 454 473 6,461 ... 6,434 6,294 6,554 6,328 Sumitomo Mitsui Financial … 5.808 5.59 Sept. 14, ’33 101 –64 93
Gasoline 227,377 ... 229 224 229 235 709 ... 730 700 612 777 Athene Global Funding* ATH 1.985 5.84 Aug. 19, ’28 122 –46 120
Finished gasoline 14,487 -1,000 14 17 14 20 173 ... 221 152 144 113 Credit Agricole ACAFP 5.134 5.43 March 11, ’27 67 –35 64
Reformulated 21 ... 0 0 0 0 0 ... 0 0 0 0 Mutual of Omaha Global Funding MUTOMA 5.350 5.59 April 9, ’27 83 –14 80
Conventional 14,466 ... 14 17 14 20 173 ... 221 152 144 113 Philip Morris International PM 4.250 5.97 Nov. 10, ’44 115 –11 111
Blend. components 212,890 ... 215 207 215 214 536 ... 509 547 469 665 …And spreads that widened the most
Natural gas (bcf) 2,283 ... 2 2 2 2 ... ... ... ... ... … Apple AAPL 4.375 5.37 May 13, ’45 55 87 47
Abbvie ABBV 4.400 5.56 Nov. 6, ’42 74 74 70
Kerosene-type
Societe Generale … 7.367 7.49 Jan. 10, ’53 279 67 265
jet fuel 42,227 ... 41 40 41 39 19 ... 135 260 122 147 1.125 June 15, ’26 58 n.a.
Commonwealth Bank of Australia … 5.29 36
Distillates 114,968 -400 118 112 117 125 149 ... 163 113 145 130 9
Pfizer PFE 2.750 5.01 June 3, ’26 8 48
Heating oil 6,313 ... 7 7 7 9 2 ... 2 0 1 0 Toronto–Dominion Bank TD 5.532 5.46 July 17, ’26 53 41 43
Diesel 108,655 ... 111 105 110 58 147 ... 161 113 144 130 Oracle ORCL 6.500 5.98 April 15, ’38 139 32 126
Residual fuel oil 28,147 ... 29 32 29 32 61 ... 161 110 125 163 Banque Federative Du Credit Mutuel BFCM 5.088 5.46 Jan. 23, ’27 69 31 67
Other oils 283,035 ... 276 280 275 281 830 ... 1,070 955 775 972
High-yield issues with the biggest price increases…
Net crude, petroleum Bond Price as % of face value
Issuer Symbol Coupon (%) Yield (%) Maturity Current One-day change Last week
products, incl. SPR 1,602,406 ... 1,592 1,602 1,588 1,826 -2,785 ... -760 -2,546 -1,922 -203
Occidental Petroleum OXY 6.450 6.03 Sept. 15, ’36 103.622 0.88 104.975
Weekly Demand, 000s barrels per day Natural gas storage Transocean RIG 7.500 9.27 April 15, ’31 91.063 0.56 93.167
Telecom Italia Capital S.A. TITIM 7.721 7.96 June 4, ’38 97.950 0.53 99.631
Expected Previous Year 4-week 5-year Billions of cubic feet; weekly totals 0.50 99.000
AAdvantage Loyalty IP … 5.500 5.97 April 20, ’26 99.125
Current change week ago avg avg
Bath & Body Works BBWI 5.250 6.46 Feb. 1, ’28 96.000 0.25 96.562
Total petroleum Hughes Satellite Systems SATS 6.625 35.91 Aug. 1, ’26 56.750 0.25 59.500
Natural gas, 4250 Teva Pharmaceutical Finance TEVA 6.150 6.77 Feb. 1, ’36 95.000 0.25 96.750
product 19,220 ... 19,236 19,317 19,820 19,259 lower 48 states ZF North America Capital ZFFNGR 4.750 6.15 April 29, ’25 98.620 0.12 98.625
t
Finished 3250 …And with the biggest price decreases
57.750
t
motor gasoline 8,662 ... 8,612 8,519 8,806 8,443 Liberty Interactive LINTA 8.250 23.93 Feb. 1, ’30 52.150 –1.10
Kerosene-type Five-year average 2250 Paramount Global PARA 7.875 7.44 July 30, ’30 102.114 –0.89 101.773
for each week Hughes Satellite SATS 5.250 15.42 Aug. 1, ’26 81.007 –0.49 82.020
jet fuel 1,418 ... 1,608 1,624 1,584 1,406 Navient NAVI 6.750 7.21 June 25, ’25 99.478 –0.31 n.a.
1250
Distillates 3,666 ... 2,985 3,765 3,544 3,854 Bausch Health BHCCN 11.000 19.27 Sept. 30, ’28 76.000 –0.25 78.000
Residual fuel oil 470 ... 551 172 453 238 Dish DBS DISH 7.750 33.45 July 1, ’26 62.000 –0.25 65.177
250 Rakuten RAKUTN 11.250 9.53 Feb. 15, ’27 104.125 –0.25 105.250
Propane/propylene 675 ... 1,305 869 1,041 ... A M J J A S O N D J F M –0.20 99.185
Prime Security Services Borrower PRSESE 5.750 6.62 April 15, ’26 98.404
Other oils 4,330 ... 4,176 4,368 4,394 ... 2023 2024
*Estimated spread over 2-year, 3-year, 5-year, 10-year or 30-year hot-run Treasury; 100 basis points=one percentage pt.; change in spread shown is for Z-spread.
Note: Expected changes are provided by Dow Jones Newswires' survey of analysts. Previous and average inventory data are in millions. Note: Data are for the most active issue of bonds with maturities of two years or more
Sources: FactSet; Dow Jones Market Data; U.S. Energy Information Administration; Dow Jones Newswires Source: MarketAxess
B10 | Thursday, April 18, 2024 * ***** THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.
MARKETS
week of 2024. And for the third customers about the privacy
consecutive session, the index and security of their informa-
rose in early trading before tion in Webull’s possession,”
closing lower, the longest said the letter, which was ad-
streak of such reversals since dressed to Anthony Denier,
2022. chief executive of the com-
Stocks rallied to start the pany’s U.S. arm, New York-
year, due in part to widespread based Webull Financial.
expectations that the Federal The worst performer in the S&P 500 was J.B. Hunt Transport Services, which fell 8.1% after reporting weak results. A spokeswoman said Denier
Reserve would move to lower was traveling and not immedi-
interest rates at some point in Index performance on Wednesday have a totally different narra- Overseas, the Stoxx Europe ately able to comment.
2024. The S&P 500 had its best tive right now,” he said, refer- 600 rose 0.1%. Markets rose in Webull—like its better-
0.75%
first quarter since 2019. ring to this month’s hotter- Asia early Thursday, with known rival Robinhood Mar-
But the script has flipped in Dow Jones Industrial Average than-expected consumer-price Japan’s Nikkei 225 up 0.3%, kets—offers commission-free
0.50
April. A persistently strong S&P 500 index. Hong Kong’s Hang Seng Index trading of stocks and options
economy led Fed Chair Jerome 0.25 Nasdaq Composite The benchmark 10-year up 1.2% and South Korea’s Ko- via a phone app. In February,
Powell and other central-bank Treasury yield settled at spi up 1.7%. Webull unveiled plans to go
officials to cast doubt on that 0 4.584%, down from 4.657% public by merging with a spe-
assumption this week. Tuesday. cial-purchase acquisition com-
“We had forecast two rate U.S. crude-oil prices settled AUCTION RESULTS pany, in a deal that values We-
–0.25 Here are the results of Wednesday's Treasury
cuts this year, now we’re at just at $82.69 a barrel, down 3.1%. auctions. All bids are awarded at a single price at the bull at around $7 billion. The
market-clearing yield. Rates are determined by the
one in December, which is very –0.50 Gold futures fell 0.8% to settle difference between that price and the face value. company says it has about 20
different from what markets at $2,371.70 a troy ounce. 17-WEEK BILLS million users globally.
had expected” at the start of the –0.75 Chip stocks fell, continuing a Applications $169,098,867,700 Regulatory filings show
Accepted bids $60,235,736,100
year, said Sinead Colton Grant, recent slide for a sector that " noncompetitively $823,646,100 that Webull’s current parent is
chief investment officer at BNY has shined over the past year. " foreign noncompetitively $150,000,000 based in the Cayman Islands.
–1.00 Auction price (rate) 98.267889
Mellon Wealth Management. United Airlines stock rose (5.240%) But the company has been
Coupon equivalent 5.406%
Traders in interest-rate de- –1.25 17%, the S&P 500’s top per- Bids at clearing yield accepted 15.16%
dogged by criticism—primar-
rivatives are pricing in a 16% former, after the carrier re- Cusip number 912797KY2 ily from Republican lawmak-
Five-minute intervals
chance that the Fed will lower –1.50 ported stronger-than- expected The bills, dated April 23, 2024, mature on Aug. 20, ers in Washington—about its
2024.
its policy rate at its June meet- 10 a.m. 11 noon 1 p.m. 2 3 4 quarterly results. Rivals also ties to China.
19-YEAR, 10-MONTH BONDS
ing, according to CME Group’s enjoyed a boost: American Air- Applications $36,716,398,400
The company was founded
FedWatch tool. A month ago, Source: FactSet lines Group gained 6.6%, while Accepted bids $13,061,977,000 in 2016 by Anquan Wang, who
" noncompetitively $78,479,200
the likelihood of a cut was 55%. Southwest Airlines advanced " foreign noncompetitively $0 previously worked for Chinese
Investors have responded by so far this month. “We think the market is way 2.6%. Auction price (rate) 95.958772 e-commerce giant Alibaba. De-
(4.818%)
pushing bond yields higher and But the S&P 500 and Nasdaq overreacting,” said Tony Roth, The worst performer in the Interest rate 4.500% nier said in 2019 that Webull
prices lower, which has pres- are still solidly green for the chief investment officer at Wil- S&P 500 was J.B. Hunt Trans- Bids at clearing yield accepted 79.31% was “both a U.S. and Chinese
Cusip number 912810TZ1
sured stocks. All three major year, and investors aren’t ready mington Trust. “If we had 15 port Services, which fell 8.1% The bonds, dated April 30, 2024, mature on Feb. 15, company” with a technology
indexes are down 4% or more to give up on the bull market. basis points less in CPI, we’d after reporting weak results. 2044. team based in Hunan, China.
Get smarter
with your money.
Be ready for every step of your money
journey with knowledge and insights from
our collection of Dow Jones publications.
Curated by experts. Made for you.
Learn more at
www.dowjones.com/SmartMoney
©2024 Dow Jones & Co, Inc. All rights reserved. 6DJ9002
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL. Thursday, April 18, 2024 | B11
HEARD STREET ON
THE
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS & COMMENTARY
ASML’s Orders Show Chip Makers’ Caution ASML’s order intake, quarterly
€10 billion
Chip makers aren’t rushing to posting their lowest close since its growth plan is on track. It said chine sales in the first quarter 8
prepare for the next wave of February. it only needs orders of €4 billion a came from China, even though it
growth, based on a first-quarter ASML sells what are probably quarter for the rest of the year to is barred by Dutch export rules
update from lithography giant the world’s most complex and ex- remain on track to make €35 bil- from selling much of its most-ad- 6
ASML. pensive mass-produced machines lion in revenue in 2025—the mid- vanced equipment to the country.
Europe’s most-valuable tech to chip makers such as Intel, point of aggressive guidance it With the world’s biggest chip
company reported orders worth TSMC and Samsung. These com- gave in 2022. foundries holding back, ASML is 4
the equivalent of just €3.6 billion, panies’ equipment orders are a Chip sales fell last year after a expecting a “transition year” in
equivalent to $3.8 billion, for the bellwether for the industry’s con- bonanza in the pandemic when 2024, before a surge in sales next
three months through March. fidence. consumers bought masses of elec- year as its clients re-expand ca- 2
That was well below expectations, That said, orders of such large, tronics. That led to cautious ma- pacity.
and was the second-lowest num- pricey gear can be lumpy. The chine orders by chip makers ev- This recovery scenario remains
ber since 2020. fourth-quarter number was a re- erywhere except China, which has plausible, but after a weak first 0
ASML’s Netherlands-listed cord €9.2 billion, so taken to- been buying all the gear it can, in quarter, buying the stock on 40
2021 ’22 ’23 ’24
stock fell more than 6% on gether, the past six months have a geopolitical battle for control of times forward earnings seems
Wednesday. Its American deposi- still been strong. critical technology. riskier than before. Note: €1.00 = $1.07
tary receipts were down over 7%, The company’s message is that A record 49% of ASML’s ma- —Stephen Wilmot Source: FactSet
B12 | Thursday, April 18, 2024 THE WALL STREET JOURNAL.