Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INVITED
PAPER
ABSTRACT | Electric propulsion has emerged as one of the technology was rapidly developing and soon the dc drives were
most efficient propulsion arrangements for several vessel types replaced with ac drives. In the same period electric propulsion
over the last decades. Even though examples can be found in emerged as basic standard for large cruise liners, and DP ope-
the history at the end of 19th century, and further into the 20th rated drilling vessels, but also found its way into other seg-
century, the modern use of electric propulsion started in the ments as shuttle tankers, ferries, and other special vessels. At
1980s along with the development of semiconductor switching the same time podded propulsion were introduced, where the
devices to be used in high power drives (dc drives and later ac- electric motor was mounted directly on the propeller shaft in a
to-ac drives). This development opened up for full rpm control submerged 360 steerable pod, adding better efficiency, im-
of propellers and thrusters, and thereby enabling a simplifica- proved maneuvering, and reduced installation space/cost to
tion of the mechanical structure. However, the main reason for the benefits of electric propulsion. The future trends are now
using electric propulsion in commercial ship applications is the focusing on further optimization of efficiency by allowing mul-
potential for fuel savings compared to equivalent mechanical tiple energy sources, independent operation of individual
alternatives, except for icebreakers where the performance of power producers, and energy storage for various applications,
an electric powered propeller is superior to a combustion en- such as power back up, peak shaving, or emission free opera-
gine powered propeller. The fuel saving potential lies within tion (short voyages).
the fact that the applicable vessels have a highly varying ope-
ration profile and are seldom run at full power. This favors the KEYWORDS | Commercial ships; cruise vessels; drilling vessels;
power plant principle in which electric power can be produced frequency converter applications; icebreakers; LNG carriers;
at any time with optimum running of prime movers, e.g., diesel marine technology; podded propulsion; ship electric propulsion
engines, by turning on and off units depending on the power
demand for propulsion and other vessel loads. Icebreakers
were among the first vessels to take advantage of this technol- I. INTRODUCTION
ogy later followed by cruise vessel, and the offshore drilling Electric ship propulsion has a long history going back more
vessels operating with dynamic positioning (DP). The converter than 100 years (see [1] and [2]), however, in quite limited
numbers. The main stream of propulsion machinery was
steam turbine propulsion and later on followed by diesel
engines. There are examples of early diesel-electric pro-
pulsion system as for the river tanker Vandal (see Fig. 1)
Manuscript received April 10, 2015; revised June 23, 2015; accepted July 12, 2015.
The authors are with the Marine Department, ABB AS, Billingstad 0575, Norway launched in 1903, with a ship’s power plant of 3
(e-mail: jan-fredrik.hansen@no.abb.com; frank.wendt@no.abb.com). 120 horsepower, with electric transmission to the propel-
Digital Object Identifier: 10.1109/JPROC.2015.2458990 lers. The power plant was built in Sweden by Swedish
0018-9219 Ó 2015 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
| Proceedings of the IEEE 1
This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
Many of these variants are discussed and highlighted later protection relays in the switchboard makes sure that elec-
on in this article. trical faults are identified and isolated via a selective pro-
Besides icebreakers who clearly benefit from electric tective scheme. Further for protection purpose the PMS
propulsion on the icebreaking performance itself, it was the also have functionality to avoid total blackouts by moni-
cruise vessels that embraced the variable speed electric toring the power plant on a higher level and take protective
motor drives as their main propulsion. Besides the power actions as heavy consumer start prevention, load reduction,
plant principle, also the flexibility in location of equipment and load shedding in case of major failures in the power
gave benefits. Such that combustion engines could be lo- plant. All these control and protection technologies were in
cated in their optimum position without the need for long the early day’s stand-alone units and based on available
shaft-lines to the propellers. Among the first modern use of technology at the time of use. This has today developed into
ac drives was the retrofit of ‘‘Queen Elisabeth 2’’ in the early more integrated systems, by use of modern digital com-
1980s [1]. However even for that installation, the RPM puter based units, being able to communicate with each
control was limited to start-up, and variable pitch propellers other for optimized performance.
did power control. However later on in the 1980s the Despite the fact that the power plant technology itself
Fantasy Class [1], [12] and Princess Class [1] cruise vessels with respect to components and needed competence for
were constructed with fully variable speed electric propul- operation, etc., in practice would be the same for land
sion system with fixed pitch propellers. More cruise vessels based applications and ship based applications there are
and a series of shuttle tankers followed the same way in the certain factors that must be accounted for both with respect
1990s, and later on also DP drilling vessels were constructed to design, operation and equipment production. IEC 721-3-6
with same principle technology, however the choice of ‘‘Classification of environmental conditionsVship envi-
converter type could be quite different yielding various re- ronment’’ defines guidelines for climatic conditions,
quirements and challenges to the power plant design. After mechanical conditions, and chemical substances to be con-
year 2000, and until today, this market has grown steadily sidered in design of marine equipment. Requirements and
and the converter development has evolved to a more stan- specification by all the marine classification societies (as
dard type for any range of propulsion load and vessel size. DNV GL, ABS, LRS, BV, and others) includes this. Ship
movements and high vibrations require more rigid mecha-
A. Power Generation and Distribution nical design and construction. For example, lubrication and
On the power plant side the development from the cooling circuits must be able to operate under a certain
1980s until today, has been on optimizing design and inclination angle in several directions, either in normal
manufacturing of components as generators, transformers operation where the ship movements are results of wind
and switchboards (including circuit breakers and protec- and waves, or in emergency operation where other incidents
tion relays) (see Fig. 4). However most noticeable develop- (like collision) may lead to larger inclinations. Vibration
ment has been on control systems and implementing new levels must also be coped with and for the most sensitive
IT technology. Several layers build up the power plant equipment, vibration dampers in some kind of format is
control. Engine governors for controlling the network fre- often used. The environmental conditions like temperatures
quency (by RPM control of diesel engine) and active power and humidity is usually also more demanding for ship
(kW) load sharing. Automatic voltage regulator (AVR) for applications, which means that equipment must withstand
controlling the network voltage and reactive power (kVAr) some more stringent conditions, which typically may lead to
sharing. On the top, a power management system (PMS) derating compared to standardized industrial use.
monitors the power plant and optimize the number of on- Today, one of the most noticeable development of ma-
line engines, and possibly adjust the load sharing between rine power plant is the trend to move away from standard
the generators. In addition to control, the power plant must power plant design with a fixed voltage and frequency
be protected in case of failure, and for this purpose the switchboard, into dc distribution systems, where each
prime mover can operate more independent of each other.
More details of this trend is presented in a later section.
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
Fig. 5. Frequency converter topologies: (a) VSI; (b) CSI; and (c) cycloconverter.
between stator and rotor with brushes created certain higher performance with respect to speed/torque accuracy
maintenance challenges. The ‘‘dc’’ drives for propulsion and response. DTC was developed in the mid-1980s and later
were soon replaced by ac drives in the 1980s. Several on commercialized by ABB in mid-1990s [13], and used for
technologies for variable speed control of ac motors were marine applications from about year 2000.
developed in parallel. Some of the variants were due to type For synchronous motors the converter types used were
of ac motor, asynchronous (induction), or synchronous, current source inverters (CSIs) and cycloconverters. Both
other related to application as slow speed direct propulsion were build up by thyristors, similar as for dc drives, where
or medium speed geared propulsion. Synchronous and the first one has as the name states a constant current dc
asynchronous motors dominated the propulsion and link, and a load commutated inverter (LCI), getting the
thruster applications for electric ships from the 1980s commutation energy from the synchronous motor field
and to today, and are still a preferred solution for most winding. This type of converter is often named LCI, how-
applications, however use of permanent magnet motors has ever belonging to the CSI family. Cycloconverter is a direct
entered the business the last decade. In the 1980s and conversion and can be looked upon as a rectifier where the
1990s, the clear split between asynchronous motors and dc link voltage is slowly varying between maximum and
synchronous motors was on the physical size. As this size is minimum. This fact limits the possible output frequency to
dependent on both rated power and rated speed, the se- about one third of the input frequency, limiting the cyclo-
lection typically ended up by using asynchronous motors converter applications to direct slow speed gear less pro-
for application below 5 W, and synchronous motors for pulsion applications. All these converter types have pros
application above 10 MW. For power rating between 5 and and cons, however one issue that favor the VSI type, is the
10 MW the rated RPM was then a decisive factor, indicating use of diode bridge rectifiers, which gives you a constant
synchronous motors for direct slow speed propulsion down high power factor (> 0.95) towards the main switchboard.
to 5 MW and asynchronous motors for medium speed Thyristor-based converters have a varying power factor
geared propulsion/thruster applications up to 10 MW. based on the thyristor firing angle which again is depen-
A frequency converter (see Fig. 5) does speed control dent on required speed of propeller. Low power factor
of ac motors, as their RPM is depending on the applied affects the efficiency of the power plant and may require
input frequency. Different converter technologies evolved more generators online than what is really needed from
from the 1980s, and for almost 20 years, it became a active power [kW] point of view.
couple of standardized ways of designing electric propul- Inevitably, when the semiconductor switching devices
sion applications. Voltage Source Inverters (VSI) con- like gate turn-off thyristor (GTO), integrated gate con-
trolled asynchronous motors. VSI consist of a rectifier, trolled thyristor (IGCT), insulated gate bipolar transistor
dc-link and inverter. The rectifier (usually a diode bride) (IGBT), and other variants became commercially available
converting (rectifying) the fixed frequency into dc voltage. for larger power ratings, and higher voltages, and with
The dc-link capacitor bank smoothens the rectifier dc out- acceptable reliability, the VSI type converter became the
put voltage and supplies a stable dc voltage to the inverter dominating technology for propulsion and thruster drives
(giving the name Voltage Source). The inverter, by using in year 2000. Today, the VSI type of converter is the stan-
the active switching semiconductors (IGBTs or IGCTs), dard solution for all electric propelled marine vessels.
converts the constant dc voltage into a variable frequency More details and explanation of the different converter
and voltage. The first and still most common used switch- technologies used for marine applications are found in [2].
ing algorithm (control method) in VSIs is called pulsewidth In the 1990s, podded propulsion was introduced, add-
modulation (PWM), which is also widely ‘‘incorrectly’’ ing further dimensions to electric propulsion, and initially
used as synonym for the VSI topology. Today, VSI convert- penetrating the icebreaking vessels and cruise vessels. To-
ers are fitted with more advanced control algorithms as day, podded propulsion is more widely used, and explained
direct torque control (DTC) and vector control leading to in more detail in a later section. Shortly after, the podded
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
propulsion, in addition to superior icebreaking effects, also operating at different speeds are essential. The power plant
adds to improved efficiency and increased maneuverability. is then designed to supply the propulsion, and other loads
In the following sections, the electric propulsion sys- (which could be quite substantial) in an optimum way.
tem is explained in more details for each application and Usually, the power plant consist of four to six generator
vessel type, however focused on today’s solutions. The last engines and very often of the same rating in order for the
section gives some overview of the latest trends as dc grid owner/operator to have same type of spare parts and
systems, use of energy storage, and other trends seen for maintenance routines for the engines. However, from an
the further electrification of the marine market. efficiency point of view it could be beneficial to have va-
rious sizes of engine ratings in order to match more pre-
cisely the expected operational profile. Shaftline or podded
II I. ELECTRIC PROPULSION S OLUTIONS propulsion is standard, and propulsion motors for this
Electric Propulsion solutions today have many variants category has usually been large synchronous motors
depending on vessel type, operational profiles, and availa- (unless smaller vessels with propulsion ratings less than
ble technology at the time of construction, a large flexi- 5–10 MW). Recently, also asynchronous motors are intro-
bility of the design and many parameters that influence the duced for the larger frame sizes and ratings. The selection
optimal solution. Over the last ten years, the electrical of motor type today in this category is mostly vendor de-
propulsion fleet grew three times faster than the world pendent (different preferences). Frequency converters are
fleet [5]. Cruise vessels, Icebreakers, DP offshore vessels, today standardized around the VSI family, and all main
and LNG carriers still accounts for the majority of vessels, electric equipment are medium voltage 3.3, 6.6, or 11 kV
but the technology is increasingly also used in other vessel (unless smaller vessel with less onboard power).
types. LNG carriers as mentioned, was the last large group
of vessels changing from mechanical steam propulsion to B. Station Keeping
electric propulsion with the first vessels ordered in 2003 The main purpose of station keeping vessels is to keep
[6]. Further, other vessel types as dredgers, special con- position, and safely perform an operation. Thereby the
struction vessel, pipe layers, cable layers, shuttle tankers, thruster units are designed and optimized for giving maxi-
ferries, etc., are vessel types that increasingly use electric mum thrust at zero knot, which is quite different than
propulsion, or partly electric propulsion. Some of this is optimizing the design for a specific vessel speed. Further,
due to special requirements as operation in ice, as we see the focus for vessels in this category is safety and redun-
more and more that the vessels themselves are constructed dancy, more than efficiency. According to the International
for icebreaking for travelling in the northern routes with- Maritime Organization (IMO) guideline for vessels with
out additional icebreaking support. Another driver is DP dynamic positioning systems, vessels with assigned DP
operation, which means that you need several propulsion equipment Class 2 and Class 3 have to be built with re-
and thruster units and by that benefit of centralized power dundancy in the DP system, and related subsystems and
production and distributed electric drive systems. components. The subsystems of a DP system are the power
Except for these drivers, there are also now increas- system, thruster system and DP control system. The design
ingly interests in looking into alternative propulsion sys- intend is that in occurrence of a single fault within the DP
tems also for vessel types that have traditionally been system the loss of the affected subsystem or component will
propelled by one or two main engines, due to the opera- not compromise the station capability of the vessel.
tional profile. One of the main benefits of electric propul- Redundant components and system have to be immediately
sion is the ability to keep a high propulsion efficiency for available with sufficient capacity to maintain the DP ope-
the whole operation range, while many of the vessels ration. In order to increase safety in the power distribution
equipped with mechanical propulsion are designed and system and achieve up to 100% blackout free operation the
optimized for just one single operational point, but in power plant is operated with open transfer breaker be-
practice after delivery operates at larger variations than the tween the main switchboards. The operational conse-
design point. quences of the instant availability of redundant equipment
In the following subsections, we will look more in is that the number of running power producing engines is
details of three different application areas of electric higher than necessary, and thereby run at lower load and
propulsion systems; a) ocean going; b) station keeping; efficiency than the optimal point of operation. This is
c) icebreaking. somehow about to change as the efficiency measurable is
lifted up to also influence the design, but without affecting
A. Ocean Going the safety. Drilling vessels and offshore support vessels
Cruise vessels and LNG carriers are typically example (OSVs) are example of vessels of this category. In order for
of ocean going vessels, where the propulsion is designed a vessel to keep position by use of DP control system, sev-
for supplying one or two (sometimes three) main propel- eral thruster and propulsion units are equipped on the
lers ranging up to 20–25 MW each. The propulsion design vessels both stern and bow. Usually, five to eight units are
criteria is then a certain vessel speed, but the flexibility of installed ranging typically from ab 1 to 6 MW. Some con-
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
medium voltage rated equipment, and main electrical known as bollard pull. DP Drilling vessels have two basic
power distribution is done on 11 kV system. 11 kV diesel designs, either as a ship or as a rig. However, the power and
generators (4 to 6) are feeding the main switchboard, and propulsion system is quite similar in design with six to eight
from there the propulsion drive system of 3.3 kV (typical, thrusters, and six to eight generators. Because of the re-
variants exists) are fed via propulsion transformers. Most of quired availability and redundancy defined by DP classifi-
the cruise ships are configured for two (or three) propel- cation rules the power plant is split in 3 to 8, depending on
lers, mostly because of redundancy and feasible power vessel type and design. Usually, a drillship has six diesel
limits of electric drives. Dual-stator motors supplied by generators with either one or two at each split, and a drill-
parallel frequency converters are commonly utilized at the rig has eight diesel generators in either 4 or 8 split. The
highest power ratings, because the maximum current rat- total installed power is typically in the range of 40 to
ings of frequency converters are typically much lower than 50 MW, and the voltage level is therefore usually 11 kV on
those of electric motors. In addition, such solutions provide the main switchboard. The thruster drives could in this
redundancy and reduce harmonics in the electric system. case either be at 690 V (low voltage) or 3.3 kV (medium
Podded propulsion gained entrance to this market about voltage), depending on the thruster sizes ranging from
1995, and is today one of the most used propulsion variants about 3 MW (for rigs) up to 5.5 MW (for ships). The
on new cruise vessels. Rated power of each propulsion line thruster units are always of azimuthing type, being able to
is typically around 20 MW, and total installed generator give thrust in any direction as controlled by the DP system.
power can reach 80 MW or more. For example, the largest The thruster itself could be of mechanical design, either
cruise ship today ‘‘Allure of the Seas’’ has an installed power with an inboard electric motor or of podded design.
capacity of 97 MW divided on six engines, and 60 MW of Besides the propulsion/thruster plant the biggest elec-
propulsion divided on three propulsion lines [11]. Propul- trical consumer on these vessels are the drilling system,
sion converters are of VSI type, and most of these vessels comprising of about 10 MW variable speed drilling motors.
are using synchronous motors as these are directly coupled In addition, this fact favors the use of a centralized power
to the propeller either in a pod or through a shaft-line. plant for electricity production.
Some cruise vessels have lately also been equipped with
large slow speed induction motors. ABB is using synchro- C. OSV/OCV
nous motors due to overall efficiency considerations. Offshore support/construction vessels (OSV/OCV) are
a class of vessels with many variations in operational
B. DP Class Drilling Vessels characteristics, sizes, and designs (see Fig. 9). This section
While cruise vessels are mostly about sailing, maneu- will therefore only give some very general characteristics.
vering, and powering a small city, drilling vessels are de- These vessels are smaller than the other vessel types
signed to keep position and do required drilling operations discussed, and with less installed power, typically around
(see Fig. 8). This gives different requirements to power and 10 MW, but with examples of up to 20 MW. The complex-
propulsion plant, and for these vessels, the safe and reliable ity varies from more standardized supply vessels, to more
operation is the key focus. These vessels are operated with a advance vessels like anchor handlers, pipe-layers, con-
DP control system, in order to keep the vessel in correct
position. This control system delegates required propeller
speed and power to all the units in order to counteract the
environmental forces from wind, waves and currents. The
propulsion plant is therefore optimized for this application,
giving maximum thrust force. Each thruster is then de-
signed and constructed with a nozzle around the propeller
in order to direct the water flow straight astern as much as
possible. A nozzle creates additional resistance in sailing/
transit operation, and is therefore only used on vessels
optimized for performance at vessel speeds around 0 knots, Fig. 9. OSV with power and propulsion overview.
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
struction vessels etc. The majority of these vessels with a term chartered vessels on fixed routes to more short term
certain complexity are today diesel-electric, however still a and even spot trading of LNG. This again favors electric
certain amount of mechanical propulsion is used for the propulsion with the flexibility and the capability to keep
more standardized versions. Required DP operation and also a high propulsion efficiency at lower vessel speeds. In
flexibility favors the electric designs, and for this design, this respect the LNG carriers of the future will be seen
most vessels use 690 V (low voltage) power generation and with several types of propulsion system, where electric will
distribution systems. The thruster drives are usually also on be one of them.
690 V giving possibilities for a variety of design with and What characterize the electric propulsion system for
without transformers, and possibly also today with DC dis- LNG is that most vessels have a single propeller, and a
tribution as will be described in following sections. The reduction gear between the propeller and the propulsion
largest vessels with up to 20 MW-installed power may switch motors. Reduction gears are even used for those vessels
to medium voltage (6.6 kV) design. These vessels typically built with twin propellers. The reduction gear enables use
consists of two main propulsion units, either as shaft-line or of medium speed electric motors of less physical size than
azimuth construction. Further, several bow-thrusters (and corresponding slow speed motors. Beside this fact, the
possibly stern thrusters in combination with shaft-line pro- electric propulsion plant of an LNG is quite similar to what
pulsion) complete the DP operational requirements. Usually, is used on cruise vessels, with two independent converter
these vessels must be designed with tradeoffs between good lines supplied by a two split switchboard. Normal operating
transit performance and good DP performance. voltage on these vessels are 6.6 kV. Besides the propulsion
plant, there is also an approximately 10 MW cargo plant. This
D. LNG Carriers is not used in combination with propulsion, hence another
LNG Carriers (see Fig. 10) were one of the latest vessel benefit is that the installed power capacity can be dimen-
types to make a distinct shift from mechanical propulsion to sioned on the propulsion demand, and more than cover for
electrical propulsion [6]. The operation profile of a classic the cargo demand when the vessel is at its terminal.
LNG carrier with a long-term charter does not intuitively
favor electric propulsion as they most of the time operates on
design speed. However, these vessels used steam turbines as VI. FUTURE TRENDS
main propulsion as one of the last major vessel types because AND T ECHNOLOGIES
of the available boil-off gas from the cargo. LNG Carriers, as
the name indicate, carries Liquid Natural Gas at a tempera- A. New SolutionsVDC Grid
ture of minus 163 C. The gas is kept liquid by insulated DC grid is a novel, new electric power distribution
tanks, but is allowed to boil in order to avoid too big pressure concept that, while utilizing the well proven ac generators
built up. The simplest way to deal with this boil-off gas was to and motors, opens new opportunities for efficiency im-
burn it and produce steam for propulsion demand. This is not provements and space savings. The efficiency improve-
as efficient power production as from combustion engines, ment is mainly accomplished by the fact that the system is
meaning that when the technology made combustion en- no longer locked at a specific frequency (usually 60 Hz on
gines available for operating with gas as fuel, this opened the ships), even though any 60 Hz power source also would be
way for electric power production from the boil-off gas, and connectable to the grid. The new freedom of controlling
thereby utilizing electric propulsion. Until now, mainly four- each power consumer totally independently opens up nu-
stroke generator engines have been available for these sizes merous ways of optimizing the fuel consumption. Since
of vessels, but now also two-stroke gas or dual fuel engines the main switchboard is omitted, including its generator
are available and used for direct mechanical propulsion. and feeder circuit breakers, a new design of the protection
Another factor playing a role is that the LNG Carrier system is proposed. Proper protection of the onboard dc
business has also changed the last years from only long- grid is achieved by a combination of fuses, isolator
switches and controlled turn-off of semiconductor power
devices. Fig. 11 show the layout of the machinery and
electric distribution and propulsion system for a typical
platform supply vessel (PSV) with traditional ac distribu-
tion and the new onboard dc grid, respectively.
There are several ways of configuring the onboard dc
grid from a multidrive approach [see Fig. 11(a)] to a fully
distributed system [see Fig. 11(b)]. In the multidrive ap-
proach all converter modules are located in one or multiple
lineups and occupies the same space as today’s main ac
switchboard. For the distributed system, each converter
component may be placed more freely around the vessel,
Fig. 10. LNG Carrier with power & propulsion overview. normally close to the respective power source or load, and
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
Fig. 12. Various dc grid configurations: (a) multidrive approach and (b) distributed approach.
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
Fig. 13. Different converter types in the ACS800/ACS880 industrial LV converter family reusing the same power-electronic building block.
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
D. DP Closed Bus
This section is partly based on [9]. In the last couple of
Fig. 14. Hybrid propulsion single-line configurations: (a) separate years, there has been a growing market demand for ope-
mechanical and electrical propulsion units and (b) combined
rating DP class drilling vessels with closed bus power sys-
mechanical and electrical on same propulsion unit.
tem, even under the strictest DP requirements. The main
motivation for going in this direction is to utilize the full
potential of an electric power and propulsion system with
propeller. Both system have its advantage and disadvantage respect to fuel efficiency, emissions and flexibility. For
and use depends on vessel type and operation. For certain other ship types (e.g., cruise vessels and LNG carriers),
vessel types both propulsion types can be merged to im- this operation mode has been a standard ever since the
prove the overall power efficiency and safety as redundant electric propulsion principle was introduced, for fuel
alternative propulsion for emergency operation. Merging saving reasons.
of both system is referred to as hybrid propulsion. Hybrid Today the fuel efficiency is getting higher priority also
vessel propulsion can be achieved in it simples way by for drilling vessels, and thereby pushing the requirements
combining direct engine driven and electric motor driven for closing the transfer breakers under operation. How-
propellers [see Fig. 14(a)]. More advanced systems com- ever, the safety requirements are still of equal or even
bining directly engine and electric motor driven on a single higher importance than before, such that provisions must
propeller [see Fig. 14(b)]. For most cases, this would mean be made to existing power plant designs in order to prove
a two-stroke engine propulsion line with a PTO/PTI func- an equal integrity towards any imaginable fault condition.
tion of an installed shaft generator. This kind of systems This has led to added requirements from operators and
has existed in smaller scales for many years, however with classification societies for the design of the power and
some limitations in the use of the electric system and propulsion plant.
usually only then for Power Take Out (function). The technology development of products and system de-
Today, the converter technology has opened up for sign is constantly moving forward. New generation of pro-
advanced use of an electric motor/generator in combina- tection relays, new communication standards like IEC 61850
tion with a combustion engine, in such a way that the same and automation systems supporting this standard is enabling
electric machine could run in both generator mode and a design being able to fulfill the new requirements for closed
motor mode. A number of operation modes can be ima- bus operation. This new technology opens new ways for
gined and following are just a few examples. integrating the power and automation system in one uni-
/ Pure electric. This mode can be used in certain form design built around the same IEC standard.
maneuvering situations and for zero-emission ope- In addition, the possibility for all systems to com-
ration if there is energy storage device installed, municate at the same level implies that a huge amount of
and as ‘‘take me home’’ function if there is failure data is available for diagnostic and monitoring and conse-
on the main engine. quently enables for more efficient and qualified support of
/ Combined propulsion, boost mode. If for a short time the operator in service and maintenance tasks.
the vessel need a higher speed or bollard pull than
normal, both the engine and electric motor power 1) Closed Bus Operation: Operating electric ship power
the propeller. systems with closed transfer breakers or bustie breakers is
/ Combined propulsion, mixed mode. Some propeller not a technical challenge as such, but a question of safety
ran by engine, other electric. Example could be in philosophy. The designs have basically always been done
maneuvering or in DP operation where main pro- with two or more separated switchboard systems. Opera-
pulsion is part of DP system. tional wise they were designed to operate as one unit by
Another use of the term Hybrid in this respect is on the use of transfer or bus-tie breakers. The protection system
power plant side where the use of energy storage, batteries was designed with traditional time/current selectivity such
in particular, in combination with diesel engines form a that electrical faults anywhere in the system would be
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
cause total blackout. Fig. 16 shows the basic zone and VoltageVReactive Power Output, FrequencyVActive
redundancy configuration for a four-split power plant Power Output, Fuel-RackVActive Power, or VoltageV
typically applicable for semisubmersible drilling rigs. Excitation Current.
With the latest generation of protection relays, zone
protection can be simplified by utilizing high-speed
generic object oriented substation event (GOOSE) com- VI I. CONCLUDING REMARKS
munication capability, and applying what is called block- Electric propulsion in commercial shipping has a history
based protection scheme principle. Basic principle of the going back more than 100 years; however, the break-
protection scheme is that the protection relays within one through and ‘‘mass’’ production started in the 1980s with
zone exchanging fault-current status information and the rapid development of high power semiconductor
conclude if the failure place causing the fault current is switching devices. This was an enabler to build efficient
located within the zone or outside the zone. If the zone controllable speed propulsion and thruster drive systems.
protection function locates the failure place within the For certain vessel types, the electric way was quite obvious,
zone, the adjacent transfer circuit breaker will isolate the as for cruise, icebreakers, and offshore DP vessels, where
zone instantly. With the faulty zone isolated the remaining the electrification gained efficiency, performance, and
healthy system continuous operation within the perfor- reliability advantages over the more traditional mechanical
mance of its power plant configuration. Within the faulty propulsion systems. More vessel types were introduced to
zone, standard protection functions will clear the failure this concept, and in the last decade, electric propelled
and set the subsystem into to a safe state. vessels grew three times faster than the world fleet. Along
the way, new products have been introduced (as podded
4) Enhanced Generator Protection System: The early ver- propulsion), new and efficient converter designs have been
sions of enhanced generator protection were made based implemented (VSI converters), and more IT intelligence
on the acknowledgement of certain failures that were dif- have been incorporated (as implementation of IEC 61850
ficult to catch by normal protection relays, apparently led and GOOSE communication protocol). All this are leading
to trip of healthy generators in first stage, and then led to
partial or full blackouts. Examples of such failures could be
a fuel rack stuck in a fixed position leading to over or under
fueling of one engine. This could lead to other connected
engines taking all load variations and thereby trip on over-
load or reverse power, leaving only the faulty generator on
the network. Examples of handling such faults by using
various types of algorithms is illustrated in Fig. 17. Voting
between three or more generators or looking at the ex-
pected correlation between certain parameters that should
follow each other in normal situations, but not necessarily
in faulty situations. Examples of such correlation are the Fig. 17. DGMS voting and correlation algorithm illustration.
Hansen and Wendt: Electric Ship Propulsion, Integrated Power Systems, and Future Trends
to increased advantages for the electric propulsion concept most of the vessels energy storage is considered in hybrid
and possibilities to grow further in existing and new vessel solutions in combination with combustion engines (gener-
segments. ator engines), and by this responding to increasingly
The latest technologies of dc distribution and use of stricter environmental emission requirements in coastal
energy storage is further opening possibilities also for ves- waters. It is also worth to mention that vessels equipped
sel types that have not seen any reason to look in the elec- with electric or hybrid propulsion have the necessary
tric direction before. A good example of this is the recent onboard infrastructure to accommodate future electrical
delivery of the fjord crossing battery ferry ‘‘Ampere’’ in energy sources as fuel cells, solar panels in combination
Norway. It is a pure zero–emission ferry. However, for with energy storage media. h
REFERENCES [5] H. Pestana, ‘‘Future trends of electrical performance of DP class drilling vessels,’’ in
propulsion and implications to ship Proc. DP Conf., Houston, TX, USA, 2013
[1] ‘‘ICMES TC B; Electric design,’’ in Proc. Martech, 2014. [CD-ROM].
propulsionVState-of-the-art and trends
in electric power generation, distribution, [6] J. F. Hansen and R. Lysebo, ‘‘Electric [10] S. Kanerva and J. F. Hansen, ‘‘State-of-the-art
propulsion, their associated control systems,’’ propulsion for LNG Carriers,’’ LNG J., in electric propulsionVViewpoint on
in Proc. ICMES Rep. Techn. Committee B: Elec. 2004. redundancy.’’
Propulsion. 8th ICMES/SNAME New York [7] J. O. Lindtjørn, ‘‘Demonstrating the benefits [11] [Online]. Available: http://en.wikipedia.org/
Metropolitan Section Symp., New York, NY, of advanced power systems and energy wiki/MS_Allure_of_the_Seas
USA, May 22–23, 2000. storage for DP vessels,’’ in Proc. DP Conf., [12] [Online]. Available: http://en.wikipedia.org/
[2] A. K. Ådnanes, ‘‘Maritime electrical Houston, TX, USA, 2014, [CD-ROM]. wiki/Fantasy-class_cruise_ship
installations and diesel electric propulsion,’’ [8] J. F. Hansen, J. O. Lindtjørn, and K. Vanska, [13] P. Tiitinen, P. Pohjalainen, and J. Lalu,
ABB report/Lecture note NTNU, 2003. ‘‘Onboard DC grid for enhanced DP operation ‘‘The next generation motor control method:
[3] [Online]. Available: http://en.wikipedia.org/ in ships,’’ in DP Conf., Houston, TX, USA, Direct torque control (DTC),’’ EPE J., vol. 5,
wiki/Vandal_(tanker) 2011, [CD-ROM]. no. 1, pp. 14–18, May 1995, doi:10.1109/
[4] [Online]. Available: http://en.wikipedia.org/ [9] J. F. Hansen, F. Wendt, J. Nowak, K. Hansen, pedes.1996.537279.
wiki/SS_Normandie and K. Stenersen, ‘‘Integrated power
and automations system for enhanced