Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Using Imagery To Enhance Performance in Powerlifting: A Review of Theory, Research, and Practice
Using Imagery To Enhance Performance in Powerlifting: A Review of Theory, Research, and Practice
net/publication/335124138
CITATIONS READS
4 3,434
4 authors, including:
Gordon A. Bloom
McGill University
127 PUBLICATIONS 4,285 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Danielle Alexander on 29 December 2019.
ABSTRACT Athletic Union in 1964. Within this shown to benefit performance in a vari-
sport, powerlifting athletes strive to ety of motor, power, and strength
Imagery is a frequently used mental
perform 3 different types of lifts: (a) tasks, demonstrated by improved tech-
performance skill that has been
the back squat, (b) the bench press, nique and lift execution (7,17,35). In
advocated as an invaluable tool by addition, the use of imagery has been
and (c) the deadlift, each with their
athletes, coaches, and sport psy- shown to have a positive impact on
own unique movement pattern and
chology professionals. As such, ath- important psychological variables
muscular execution. Given the high
letes competing in powerlifting can intensity, concentration, focus, and related to successful performance, such
benefit from the use of imagery toward maximal effort required for each lift, as enhanced self-confidence and moti-
the improvement of individualized the use of mental training techniques vation (5,17), while also helping to con-
mental and physical skills. To provide has the potential to enhance perfor- trol levels of anxiety and arousal (6,34).
coaches and athletes with a theoreti- mance in this sport (3). Imagery, Despite the physical and psychological
cal and practical understanding of the defined as mentally creating or recre- benefits of imagery use in sport, imag-
imagery–performance relationship; ating an experience in the mind using ery continues to be underused by
this article (a) provides an overview of all of the senses, is a mental skill that coaches, athletes, and trainers in
the PETTLEP model, (b) reviews the is often used in sport (33). Imagery powerlifting contexts (3,23). To pro-
benefits of imagery on both the has been advocated as an invaluable vide coaches and athletes with a theo-
physical and psychosocial outcomes tool by athletes, coaches, and sport retical and practical understanding of
for powerlifting athletes, and (c) pro- psychology professionals (18). As the imagery–performance relation-
vides recommendations for practical such, it is reasonable to conclude that ship, this article aims to (a) provide
use in strength and conditioning powerlifting athletes competing in a brief overview of the established
contexts. this high-intensity sport can benefit PETTLEP (physical, environment,
from the use of imagery training task, timing, learning, emotion, and
toward the improvement of individu- perspective) model, (b) review the
alized mental and physical skills. benefits of imagery use on both the
INTRODUCTION physical and psychosocial outcomes for
Sport psychology research has high- powerlifting athletes, and (c) provide
he sport of powerlifting has
T
lighted the positive association recommendations for practical use in
gained significant popularity between imagery and performance
since it received official desig- enhancement in a number of sports,
nation as a sport by the American including swimming (20), basketball KEY WORDS:
Address correspondence to Danielle M. (22), volleyball (1), and weightlifting powerlifting; imagery; mental
Alexander, danielle.alexander2@mail.mcgill. (35). Specific to strength and condi- toughness
ca. tioning contexts, imagery has been
102 VOLUME 41 | NUMBER 6 | DECEMBER 2019 Copyright Ó National Strength and Conditioning Association
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
a strength and conditioning sport athlete continues to refine and develop perform. Thus, being able to access
context. their motor skills, their technical exe- stimulus, response, and meaning
cution may change; therefore, an ath- propositions within imagery training
THE PETTLEP MODEL lete must subsequently refine and has been suggested to be particularly
Since its creation, the PETTLEP develop their images accordingly. important for athletes in competitive
model of imagery (10) has gained con- Sixth, athletes should use emotion sport (28). For example, powerlifters
siderable traction in sport psychology when creating and engaging in imagery who are required to have a high level
research (14,24,29,35). Holmes and to simulate what is felt when perform- of arousal before a lift execution at
Collins proposed that using imagery ing the behavior, such as psyching one- a national championship (i.e., mean-
to closely mimic the neurophysiologi- self up before a lift. Finally, it is ing) can image their competitive sur-
cal processes that occur for athletes in recommended that athletes consider roundings (i.e., stimulus) and match
practice or competition would be more the perspective of imaging, which can the appropriate feeling of high phys-
effective than simply imaging the be internal (i.e., first-person) or external iological arousal (i.e., response)
movement. With the intention of (i.e., third-person). The PETTLEP within their imagery training. In
improving the effectiveness of imagery model argues that performers should essence, the functional equivalence
techniques, Holmes and Collins sug- adopt an internal, first-person perspec- theory (12) and bioinformational the-
gested that practitioners should con- tive as it is more consistent with actual ory (15) provided a comprehensive
sider the (a) physical nature of the performance and has a greater likeli- outlook on imagery development
task, (b) environment, (c) type of task, hood of leading to a physiological through the use of varying sensory
(d) timing of the skill or movement, (e) response during imagery (10). A sum- experiences and worked to outline
learning of the movement and progres- mary of the PETTLEP model of imag-
sion of skill, (e) emotions associated effective guidelines for practitioners
ery can be found in the Table. when conducting imagery interven-
with the task, and (f ) perspective of
the image (internal or external). First, The PETTLEP model originated from tions in sport.
the physical state of the imager should research in the fields of neuroscience Research has explored the effectiveness
mimic the arousal level and body posi- (i.e., functional equivalence theory of the PETTLEP model in a variety of
tion of the behavior during perfor- (12)) and cognitive psychology (i.e., bi- sporting contexts (4,21,26,29,30,32). For
mance. For example, a powerlifter oinformational theory (15,16)). Specif- example, Smith et al. explored the use of
might position themselves in the tech- ically, the functional equivalence the PETTLEP model in the sporting
nical form of the lift to enhance the theory states that imaging a task acti- context by evaluating performance on
likelihood of successful imaging. Sec- vates similar neurological pathways a gymnastics beam task with 40 young,
ond, practitioners are encouraged to that occur when physically performing female gymnasts (29). Participants were
use the environment in which they per- that same task (12,32). As such, randomly assigned into 4 groups of
form (e.g., the gymnasium) to engage through mental practice and repetition either physical practice, imagery
in imagery. When this is not possible, of imagery rehearsal, athletes have the focused on PETTLEP, imagery read
however, practitioners can use envi- potential to strengthen those same from a script, or a control. Athletes
ronmental cues, such as visual media, neural pathways that are used when who were given an imagery script while
to ensure the imager accurately images executing and performing in a power- in their competitive attire on the beam
the setting. Third, it is important to lifting competition without the strain performed significantly better than ath-
consider the nature of the task being on their body through physical train- letes who were provided the same
imaged and its interaction with skill, as ing. Comparably, the bioinformational imagery script outside of the sporting
varying tasks and the athletes’ level of theory (15) states that to be effective, environment. In addition, Post et al. im-
ability may engender a variety of imag- images should contain vivid stimulus, plemented a 4-week imagery interven-
ing needs. For instance, a novice response, and meaning propositions. tion to determine whether physical
powerlifter may image a back squat Stimulus propositions refer to the sur- practice, imagery practice, or a combina-
differently than an experienced power- roundings of the environment, such as tion would be more effective in a stand-
lifter with respect to technique, range the squat rack or barbell. Response ing long jump task (21). The findings
of motion, and weight executed. propositions refer to the physiological demonstrated that both the physical
Fourth, imagers should ensure that senses experienced when performing practice group and the combination
the timing of imagery mimics the tim- the task, such as the feeling of the condition improved in performance
ing of behavior, such as the tempo of bar in one’s hands or enhanced heart compared with the control or imagery
the movement (e.g., 2-second eccen- rate before a lift. Finally, meaning prop- practice alone. The combination group
tric, 1-second pause, and 1-second con- ositions include the significance of the physically performed and mentally
centric pattern). Fifth, imagers are event or the nuanced aspects of the imaged 40 long jumps each (total of
encouraged to consider the trajectory competition, such as being one point 80), whereas the physical practice group
of their learning development. As an away from first place with a final lift to performed 80 long jumps in total.
103
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Imagery and Powerlifting
Table
Summary of the PETTLEP Model of Imagery
Interestingly, both groups yielded similar performance of a 3-repetition front squat provided a greater understanding of how
performance results despite the fact that task. Results revealed a significant to enhance the effectiveness of imagery
participants in the combination group increase in strength, assessed by the training for athletes in various sports.
executed only half the physical output number of pounds successfully lifted, The subsequent section will outline rel-
of the physical practice group. This find- for athletes in the experimental condition evant research conducted on imagery
ing highlights that imagery may be par- (i.e., PETTLEP model imagery and and performance enhancement in the
ticularly useful for powerlifting athletes video training). Athletes in this condition strength and conditioning context.
as this sport requires both maximal increased their weight lifted by over 8
strength performance training and high APPLICATIONS OF IMAGERY IN
pounds compared with approximately POWERLIFTING
levels of recovery time. Incorporating 3 pounds in the control group (video Through the development and imple-
imagery training may be a beneficial training only). These studies provided mentation of the PETTLEP model of
strategy to maintain performance support for the use and effectiveness of imagery, it is clear that there is a link
enhancement yet minimize strain on the PETTLEP model toward perfor- between imagery training and perfor-
the body. mance enhancement in competitive mance in sport. Notwithstanding the
Finally, Buck et al. (4) explored the use of sport requiring power and technique. various benefits of imagery training in
the PETTLEP model in combination Overall, the PETTLEP model has led strength and conditioning contexts
with video training (i.e., watching previ- to increased attention on the imagery– (4,7), there has yet to be a review of
ous successful executions) on the performance relationship in sport and the relevant literature pertaining to
105
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Imagery and Powerlifting
psychological factors, such as self- findings demonstrated that sensations for athletes dealing with injury rehabil-
confidence and motivation. of arousal and anxiety were interpreted itation. Thus, coaches and relevant
positively if accompanied by an imag- support staff (e.g., team doctors, phys-
ery script framing the upcoming event iotherapists, and trainers) should be
Anxiety and arousal control. as a challenge rather than a threat. In aware of the benefits associated with
Sport psychology research has sug- sum, the ability to interpret a high- imagery use and recovery to facilitate
gested that imagery training techni- pressure situation, such as a competi- success (8).
ques can aid in fluctuating levels of tion or an increased heart rate, as facil-
anxiety and arousal in athletes to Perhaps the most relevant study for
itative rather than debilitative would be powerlifters was the investigation as-
achieve optimum levels of perfor- beneficial for powerlifting athletes in
mance (6,13,34). Owing to its explosive sessing the effectiveness of an imagery
the competitive context. intervention to manage pain and
nature, athletes in powerlifting, unlike
many sports, often benefit from higher enhance range of motion for people
Injury rehabilitation. Specific to with stage II shoulder impingement
levels of physiological arousal to powerlifting, injuries are most com-
enhance performance. For example, syndrome (11). This syndrome is of
monly found in the shoulder, lower particular relevance to powerlifters as
achieving high levels of physiological back, and knee, occurring at a rate of
arousal was positively correlated with it can be caused by improper or exces-
approximately 1 injury per 1,000 train-
strength performance in elite athletes sive bench press training and because
ing hours (29). Some injuries can be
participating in explosive sports (e.g., the shoulder area is frequently injured
more severe and require rehabilitation,
weightlifting and track and field; in the sport of powerlifting (27). Partic-
but across sports, only 27% of athletes
(20)). As such, imagery training has ipants in the experimental condition
report using imagery during rehabilita-
the potential to influence anxiety and were provided with anti-inflammatory
tion (2). This is unfortunate when con-
arousal levels in sport. drugs, physical therapy treatment, and
sidering that imagery has the potential
imagery training for 10 sessions com-
A study by Cumming et al. (6) assessed to enhance pain management, motor
pared with a control who did not
physiological (i.e., heart rate) and psy- recovery, and adherence to rehabilita-
receive imagery training. Findings re-
chological (i.e., confidence and anxi- tion programs (8,9,11). Although
vealed that the imagery group noted
ety) states of individual university research investigating imagery and
a near-complete reduction in pain,
sport athletes who read imagery scripts sport injury rehabilitation is sparse,
whereas the control continued to
focusing on either arousal, anxiety, there are a small number of studies that
report minor pain (27). Owing to the
relaxation, confidence building, or cop- suggest imagery can enhance various
extremely low risks inherent with
ing. Results revealed that participants functional motor outcomes and aid in
imagery practice, this finding is prom-
interpreted heart rate levels differently the rehabilitation process (8,11). For
ising for powerlifting athletes as imag-
depending on the imagery script pre- example, Driediger et al. (8) inter-
ery can be easily implemented into
sented, such that increased heart rate viewed 10 injured athletes who were
a rehabilitation program to accelerate
was perceived as harmful or debilitat- receiving physiotherapy and found that
the recovery of injuries. Future
ing during the anxiety script compared athletes believed imagery served a cog-
with alternative scripts. Therefore, the nitive, motivational, and healing pur- research in powerlifting injury rehabil-
appraisal of physiological symptoms is pose toward recovery. Under the itation must be conducted to further
an important factor to consider in per- cognitive domain, athletes reported investigate the effectiveness of imagery
formance enhancement. This notion imaging rehabilitation exercises and in this context. The existing body of
was further discussed in a study by Wil- sport-specific skills and strategies, such research on imagery and rehabilitation,
liams et al. (34) who assessed the use of as performing running patterns or however, holds promise both within
imagery scripts to influence the game plays in their sport. Motivation and outside of the sporting context.
appraisal or interpretation of high- was the most frequent purpose of Overall, imagery training has the
stress situations. Twenty male and imagery use in the rehabilitation pro- potential to influence a number of
female competitive athletes were asked cess as all athletes reported using imag- physical and psychosocial variables
to listen to various imagery scripts and ery to control the stress of being that correlate with performance
told to create clear, vivid images of injured, enhance confidence, as well enhancement in powerlifting. More
what was being described. Physiologi- as maintain focus and a positive atti- specifically, the literature suggests that
cal assessments of heart rate, stroke tude in recovery. Finally, imagery was imagery training can lead to significant
volume, and cardiac output were gath- also used by some athletes to envision improvements in strength, particularly
ered as well as self-report data on per- the healing process, such as picturing when the intervention is 4 weeks in
ceived levels of anxiety, self- a torn ligament rejoining or to imagin- length (25) and 3 sessions per week
confidence, and imagery script ing oneself as strong and capable of (19). These improvements are likely
appraisal (i.e., whether the script inter- recovering. It is clear that imagery due to the impact of imagery on psy-
preted as a threat or a challenge). The serves a number of valuable functions chological variables, such as
107
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Imagery and Powerlifting
tion specializing in Fitness Sport 7: 1–5, 2018. 16. Lang PJ. A bioinformational theory of
Sport Psychology. 4. Buck D, Hutchinson J, Winter C, and emotional imagery. Psychophysiology 16:
Thompson B. The effects of mental imagery 495–512, 1979.
with video- modeling on self-efficacy and 17. Lebon F, Collet C, and Guillot A. Benefits
Eric A. Hutt is maximal front squat ability. Sports 4: 23, of motor imagery training on muscle
2016. strength. J Strength Cond Res 24: 1680–
a graduate stu-
5. Christensen L and Weibull F. Elite power 1687, 2010.
dent and recently
completed his lifters’ imagery experiences and deliberate 18. Morris T, Spittle M, and Watt AP. Imagery
practice. In: Swedish Sports Psychological in Sport (1st ed). Champaign, IL: Human
master’s degree
Association Yearbook. Stockholm, Kinetics, 2005.
from McGill
Sweden: Swedish Sports Psychological 19. Paravlic AH, Slimani M, Tod D, Marusic U,
University in the Association; 2009. pp. 97–115. Milanovic Z, and Pisot R. Effects and dose
Department of response relationships of motor imagery
6. Cumming J, Olphin T, and Law M. Self-
Kinesiology and reported psychological states and practice on strength development in
Physical Educa- physiological responses to different types healthy adult populations: A systematic
tion, specializing in Exercise Psychology. of motivational general imagery. J Sport review and meta-analysis. Sports Med 48:
Exerc Psychol 29: 629–644, 2007. 1165–1187, 2018.
7. Di Rienzo F, Blache Y, Kanthack TF, Monteil 20. Post P, Muncie S, and Simpson D. The
Jordan S. K, Collet C, and Guillot A. Short-term effects of imagery training on swimming
Lefebvre is effects of integrated motor imagery performance: An applied investigation.
a doctoral stu- practice on muscle activation and force J Appl Sport Psychol 24: 323–337,
2012.
dent at McGill performance. Neurosci 305: 146–156,
University in the 2015. 21. Post PG, Williams CD, Simpson D, and
Department of Berning JM. The effects of a PETTLEP
8. Driediger M, Hall C, and Callow N. Imagery
imagery intervention on the learning of
Kinesiology and use by injured athletes: A qualitative
a complex motor skill. J Imag Res Sport
Physical Educa- analysis. J Sports Sci 24: 261–271, 2006.
Phys Act 10: 19–30, 2015.
tion, specializing 9. Guillot A and Collet C. Construction of the
22. Post PG, Wrisberg CA, and Mullins S. A
in Sport Psychology. motor imagery integrative model in sport: A
field test of the influence of pre-game
review and theoretical investigation of
imagery on basketball free throw shooting.
motor imagery use. Int Rev Sport Exerc
J Imag Res Sport Phys Act 5: 1–15, 2010.
Gordon A. Psychol 1: 31–44, 2008.
23. Radcliffe JN, Comfort P, and Fawcett T.
Bloom is a full 10. Holmes PS and Collins DJ. The PETTLEP
The perception of psychology and the
professor and approach to motor imagery: A functional
frequency of psychological strategies used
director of the equivalence model for sport psychologists.
by strength and conditioning practitioners.
J Appl Sport Psychol 13: 60–83, 2001.
Sport Psychol- J Strength Cond Res 27: 1136–1146,
ogy Research 11. Hoyek N, Di Rienzo F, Collet C, Hoyek F, 2013.
Laboratory at and Guillot A. The therapeutic role of motor 24. Roberts R, Callow N, Hardy L, Markland D,
imagery on the functional rehabilitation of
McGill and Bringer J. Movement imagery ability:
a stage II shoulder impingement syndrome. Development and assessment of a revised
University. Disabil Rehabil 36: 1113–1119, 2014. version of the vividness of movement
12. Jeannerod M. The representing brain: imagery questionnaire. J Sport Exerc
Neural correlates of motor intention and Psychol 30: 200–221, 2008.
imagery. Behav Brain Sci 17: 187–202, 25. Scholefield SC, Cooke CP, Van Vliet PM,
1994. and Heneghan NR. The effectiveness of
REFERENCES mental imagery for improving strength in an
13. Judge LW, Urbina LJ, Hoover DL, Craig
1. Afrouzeh M, Sohrabi M, Taheri HR, Gorgin asymptomatic population. Phys Ther Rev
BW, Judge LM, Leitzelar BM, Pearson DR,
F, and Mallett C. Effect of PETTLEP 20: 86–97, 2015.
Holtzclaw KA, and Bellar DM. The impact
imagery training on learning of new skills in of competitive trait anxiety on collegiate 26. Shirazipour CH, Munroe-Chandler KJ,
novice volleyball players. Life Sci J 10: powerlifting performance. J Strength Cond Loughead TM, and Vander Laan AG. The
231–238, 2013. Res 30: 2399–2405, 2016. effect of image speed on novice golfers’
109
Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com
Copyright © National Strength and Conditioning Association. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.