Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
The aim of the study was to elucidate on the basis of physical, floristic and edaphic features of habitat, the
distribution in natural montane forests of the two endemic Carpathian clausiliid species, Macrogastra
tumida and Vestia turgida. Sites sampled were in the Bieszczady National Park, East Carpathians, Poland.
Snails were sampled quantitatively at 11 sites located along an elevation gradient in various floristic
communities. The estimated population densities varied from 0 to 49 /m2 of forest floor. In a multivariate
analysis, the first four axes accounted for 82.7% of variation in recorded environmental variation. The
first axis, representing habitat fertility, correlated most strongly with the density of M. tumida. Density of
V. turgida showed a weaker correlation with this axis, as it was relatively less abundant in the wettest sites,
which were also the most fertile. Multiple regression models were used to determine the effects of single
variables: plant species number, herb cover, slope aspect and habitat humidity were the best predictors of
the snails’ abundance at the sites. The interactions and intercorrelations of these factors are discussed in
relation to land snail abundance.
Figure 1. The localities described in this paper. A. The Carpathians, showing the location of study area in the Bieszczady National Park.
B. The Bieszczady Mountains, arrows showing the sampling stations (numbered 1 –11); contours in map B are given in metres a.s.l.
In lower parts of the area the average annual temperature are subalpine shrubs of Alnus viridis and alpine meadows above
exceeds þ 6 8C and the vegetation season lasts 200– 214 days. On the timberline. Alder woods (plant association Alnetum incanae)
the highest ridges the average annual temperature is lower than grow along rivers and streams up to 900 m a.s.l. Alder swamps
þ3 8C and the vegetation season lasts 181– 192 days. Minimal (plant association Caltho-Alnetum) occur in isolated patches on
values of temperature occur in January (mean temperature from low-permeability soil. About 14% of the forested area is occupied
2 3.4 8C in valleys to 26.7 8C on the highest ridges), while by secondary forest communities. Some of them (with grey alder,
maximal in July (þ16.6 8C in valleys and þ 11.5 8C in the highest ash, goat willow and hazel) have spontaneously overgrown
ridges). Mean annual precipitation is ca 900 mm in low parts of unused farmland and some spruce and mixed stands have been
the region and probably exceeds 1200 –1300 mm on the highest created by tree planting.
ridges. The highest monthly rainfall is in July, the lowest in
January, February and October. Snow cover is present on ridges
from the second half of October and from the second part of
METHODS
November in valleys. The mean number of days with snow cover
varies from 94 to 180. The upper timberline goes along the
Sampling procedure
isotherm þ 2 8C (ca 1000– 1200 m a.s.l.). Snails were collected at the 11 stations (each an area of
The Bieszczady Mountains are covered mostly by deciduous 10 £ 10 m) located along a transect crossing two main mountain
forests; the fertile Carpathian beech wood (Dentario glandulosae- crests, in different forest associations, at elevations from 650 to
Fagetum) predominates (80% of forested area). More locally, 1250 m a.s.l. (Fig. 1). At each station snails were collected twice:
acidophilous mountain beech wood, sycamore forests (with Acer in spring (May– June) and in late summer (end of August,
pseudoplatanus) and alder woods (with Alnus incana) occur. There September). Quantitative samples of soil and leaf litter were
106
HABITAT CHOICE IN CARPATHIAN CLAUSILIIDAE
107
A. SULIKOWSKA-DROZDA. SULIKOWSKA-DROZD
Table 2. Principal component analysis. Table 3. Pearson correlation coefficients (r) between principal
components and DENSITY of clausiliids.
Environmental PC PC PC PC
factor I II III IV Principal components DENSITY of
habitat fertility habitat humidity
Macrogastra tumida Vestia turgida
ALT 2 0.17 0.21 2 0.13 2 0.17
I 0.79* 0.61*
SLO 2 0.21 0.11 0.21 2 0.87
II 0.04 2 0.22
ASP 2 0.19 2 0.08 0.14 0.02
III 2 0.23 2 0.22
PLANT 0.92 2 0.05 2 0.14 0.15
IV 0.38 2 0.38
CANOP 2 0.33 2 0.81 0.20 0.09
SHRU 0.15 0.07 2 0.94 0.18 *P , 0.01.
HERB 0.82 0.02 0.01 0.08
C/N 2 0.54 2 0.31 0.59 2 0.09 range of site humidities studied, V. turgida appeared to be a less
Ca 0.71 0.28 0.08 0.27 hydrophilous species than M. tumida.
pH 0.82 0.11 2 0.05 0.45
POR 0.08 0.84 0.15 0.02
DISCUSSION
HUM 0.37 0.06 0.01 0.76
MORG 0.16 0.21 0.01 0.10 Data on the density of clausiliid populations are sparse. In
general, recorded densities do not exceed 50 ind./m2, but the
Coordinates of environmental factors on the first four principal components. highest densities are about 400 ind./m2 (Agócsy, 1968; Piechocki,
Factor loadings . 0.7 are in bold. 1982). The density of Macrogastra tumida population in beech
woods of the Tatra Mountains was as low as 1 – 6 ind./m2
Habitat fertility (PC I) was positively correlated with the (Dyduch-Falniowska & Tobis, 1989; Dzieczkowski, 1972), and
number of land snail species recorded at the stations (r 2 ¼ 0.56) was higher only near a stream bank where Dyduch-Falniowska &
and with the total snail abundance (r 2 ¼ 0.44). Habitat fertility Tobis (1989) recorded 40 ind./m2 for M. tumida. Density of Vestia
turgida populations in the Carpathian beech forests was usually ca
of the habitats (PC I) also significantly favoured high abundance
10 ind./m2 (Dyduch-Falniowska & Tobis, 1989; Dzieczkowski,
of both studied species but density of M. tumida was more strongly
1972) and was rarely higher: 30 ind./m2 near stream banks
associated with PC I (r 2 ¼ 0.62) than the density of V. turgida
(Dyduch-Falniowska & Tobis, 1989). These data correspond
(r 2 ¼ 0.37) (Table 3). Other PCs showed no significant well with the results of this study.
associations, but PC IV showed quite substantial, but opposite, Because of the habitat complexity it is difficult to single out
trends in the two species. Macrogastra tumida was not found at the which factors play a crucial role in controlling molluscs
least humid station (Stn 7), and was most abundant at stations 8 distribution and abundance. Many parameters involved are in
and 9, where PC IV reached higher values. a functional relation and are correlated at sampling stations: e.g.
In the multiple regression analyses the number of plant species soil pH and calcium content (positively); herb cover, soil pH
and moisture related best to density of M. tumida (Table 4). The (positively); and all the above and C/N ratio (negatively); herb
highest density of M. tumida populations were at the sites with cover and plant species richness (positively); hydrophilous plant
very diverse flora (more than 40 plant species/100 m2 of richness and steepness of slope (negatively).
mountain forests), which also contain a significant number of Relations between abundance of land snails and environmen-
hydrophilous plants (Fig. 4). tal factors have been investigated with the help of multi-
For V. turgida, high density of populations could be expected at dimensional statistical analysis (Barker & Mayhill, 1999; Cowie
sites with dense herb cover, cool microclimate but not very damp et al., 1995; Dillon, 1980; Tattersfield et al., 2001), but they have
(Table 5). It was less abundant at temporary submerged alder not proceeded to multiple regression using real environmental
swamp (Stn 9) than at sites of moderate moisture. Within the factors. This study is the first to do so. Since the number of
Figure 3. Principal component analysis: ordering of sampling stations (1–11) based on environmental factors.
108
HABITAT CHOICE IN CARPATHIAN CLAUSILIIDAE
The regression of Macrogastra tumida densities on the environmental factors. PLANT, HUM, environmental factors (see explanation in text); B, regression
coefficient; SE B, standard error of B; beta, standardized regression coefficient; T, F, test values; P, significance level; R2, coefficient of multiple determination;
df, degrees of freedom.
The regression of Vestia turgida densities on the environmental factors. HERB, ASP, HUM, environmental factors (see explanation in text); B, regression
coefficient; SE B, standard error of B; beta, standardized regression coefficient; T, F, test values; P, significance level; R 2, coefficient of multiple determination;
df, degrees of freedom.
sampling sites was not very high, the results of the analysis should least two causes for this relationship can be considered. First,
be interpreted with much care. Nevertheless, they are concordant natural forests are a mosaic of microhabitats, which differ in
with many data on ecology of land snails collected throughout the terms of moisture, shade and soil properties, providing suitable
world. conditions for many species of plants. The diversity of flora may
Some differences were found in moisture preferences of both control fauna diversity or both are similarly influenced by
species, with M. tumida being more hydrophilous. Contrary to climatic and edaphic factors. Plant diversity (which is easier to
its ecological description published by Kerney et al. (1983), assess than animal diversity) can be applied as a user-friendly
V. turgida had a quite wide moisture tolerance. This result is indicator of overall habitat diversity. Secondly, the importance of
in concordance with the remarks of Urbański (1939). He dead plants (especially palatable herbs) as the food source for
claimed that V. turgida did not inhabit very damp places, most snails can be stressed. The correlation between plant
where it was usually replaced by Vestia gulo (E.A. Bielz, 1859). diversity and mollusc richness is seldom discussed in malaco-
Densities of both species studied were best correlated with logical papers (Barker & Mayhill, 1999). More often, the view is
number of plant species (PLANT) at the sampling stations. At that the physical nature of the habitat, rather than floristic
Figure 4. Relationship between DENSITY of Macrogastra tumida on sampling stations (1–11) and environmental factors.
109
A. SULIKOWSKA-DROZDA. SULIKOWSKA-DROZD
composition, is most important (e.g. Bishop, 1977). Peake (1978) BARKER, G.M. & MAYHILL, P.C. 1999. Pattern of diversity and
claimed that there was no conclusive evidence that the habitat relationships in terrestrial mollusk communities of the
proportion of palatable vegetation is a limiting factor for snails. Pukeamaru Ecological District, northeastern New Zealand. Journal
Later Proschwitz (1993) criticized this attitude, suggesting that of Biogeography, 26: 215–238.
the composition of vegetation, which took part in litter formation, BISHOP, M.J. 1977. Approaches to the quatitative description of
was highly significant. He noticed that the number of coexisting terrestrial mollusc populations and habitats. Malacologia, 16: 61 –66.
vertiginid species was the highest where several species of BURCH, J.B. 1955. Some ecological factors of the soil affecting the
deciduous trees contributed to the litter content. Since leaves of distribution and abundance of land snails in eastern Virginia. Nautilus,
different tree species are processed at different rates, higher tree 69: 62–69.
species diversity provided more stable food supply over time for CAMERON, R.A.D. 1973. Some woodland mollusc faunas from
snails (Getz & Uetz, 1994). According to Barker & Mayhill southern England. Malacologia, 14: 355 –370.
(1999), mollusc abundance may also be regulated by niche CONEY, C.C., TARPLEY, W.A., WARDEN, J.C. & NAGEL, J.W.
availability, and this with increasing floral richness via site 1982. Ecological studies of land snails in the Hiwassee River basin of
successional development and higher microhabitat Tennessee USA. Malacological Review, 15: 69–106.
differentiation. COWIE, R.H., NISHIDA, G.M., BASSET, Y. & GON, S.H. 1995.
However, at the sampling sites, ecological factors such as Patterns of land snail distribution in a montane habitat on the Island
calcium content in leaf litter and soil pH were positively of Hawaii. Malacologia, 36: 155– 169.
correlated with number of plant species. The highest population DILLON, R.T. 1980. Multivariate analysis of desert snail distribution in
densities were recorded at the sites with the highest pH and an Arizona Canyon. Malacologia, 19: 201–207.
calcium content. Thus, it is possible that these factors (and not DYDUCH-FALNIOWSKA, A. 1991. The gastropods of the Polish Tatra
directly plant diversity) favour high abundance of clausiliids. In Mountains. Nature Protection Research Centre of the Polish Academy
the Bieszczady Mountains soils are mostly decalcified with the of Sciences, Kraków.
exception of places of groundwater discharge, which have a pH DYDUCH-FALNIOWSKA, A. & TOBIS, H. 1989. Spatial structure of
higher than 5.5 (Skiba et al., 1998). Consequently, advantageous a gastropod community in the litter of a beech forest of Dentario-
glandulosae Fagetum in the Tatra Mountains. Folia Malacologica, 3:
factors (humidity and low acidity) operate in the same places. It
51 –72.
is clear that a separation of these various factors requires detailed
studies in areas in which one or more of the variables remains DZIECZKOWSKI, A. 1972. Badania ilościowe ślimaków buczyn
poludniowo-zachodniej Polski. Studium ekologiczno-faunistyczne.
relatively constant, while others vary.
Prace Komisji Biologicznej, PTPN, 35: 243–332.
It is supposed that the litter and bacteria decomposing dead
FOG, K. 1979. Studies on decomposing wooden stumps III. Different
wood are the main component of the diet of clausiliids (Fog, 1979).
relations among some gastropod species and species groups to the
Thus, decomposition rate may affect the abundance of snails. stump microflora, weather changes and pH. Pedobiologia, 19: 200– 212.
Differences in consumption of different kinds of litter are related to
GETZ, L.L. & UETZ, G.W. 1994. Species diversity of terrestrial snails in
the C/N ratio in fallen leaves (Ghilarov, 1971). Leaves of Alnus, the southern Appalachian Mountains, U.S.A. Malacological Review,
which contain a lot of nitrogen, are mineralized very rapidly and 27: 61–74.
are a rich food source for saprophagous soil animals (Zimka &
GHILAROV, M.S. 1971. Invertebrates which destroy the forest litter
Stachurski, 1976). High abundance of clausiliids, and of snails and ways to increase their activity. Ecology and Conservation, 4:
generally, in alder woods is probably a joint effect of favourable 433 –442.
moisture, low acidity and high decomposition rate. Alder woods, GOSTELI, M. 1996. Diversities of snail faunas and ecological
therefore, stand out in an otherwise oligotrophic area, but in relationships between snail community and vegetation in dry habitats
calcareous areas, e.g. the Pieniny Mountains further west in the of the northern Swiss Jura (Gastropoda: Prosobranchia et Pulmo-
Carpathian chain, mixed woods on well-drained soils have very nata). Malakologische Abhandlungen Staatliches Museum für Tierkunde
rich clausiliid faunas (Urbański, 1939; Dzieczkowski, 1972). On Dresden, 18: 107 –120.
the contrary, beech leaves have a high C/N ratio and decompose KERNEY, M.P., CAMERON, R.A.D. & JUNGBLUTH, J.H. 1983. Die
very slowly, especially in places with a short vegetation season (e.g. Landschnecken Nord- und Mitteleuropas. Verlag Paul Parey, Hamburg-
at higher altitude). The paucity of snail populations in these sites Berlin.
can be attributed to the low value of beech litter as a food source MASON, C.F. 1970. Food, feeding rates and assimilation in woodland
(see Mason, 1970). Conversely, Cameron (1973) found highest snails. Oecologia, 4: 358–373.
diversities in beech woods with least field layer vegetation, but this OUTEIRO, A., AGÜERA, D. & PAREJO, C. 1993. Use of ecological
related to highly calcareous sites, in which the relative unpalat- profiles and canonical correspondence analysis in a study of the
ability of beech litter was mitigated. The properties of sycamore relationship of terrestrial gastropods and environmental factors.
litter as a food lay between these two extremes. The chemical form Journal of Conchology, 34: 365–375.
of calcium in leaf litter may also be of importance (Wäreborn, PEAKE, J. 1978. Distribution and ecology of the Stylommatophora. In:
1970). Pulmonates (V. Fretter & J.F. Peake, eds), 429–526. Academic Press,
London.
PIECHOCKI, A. 1982. Life cycle and breeding biology of Vestia elata
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS (Rossm.) (Gastropoda, Clausiliidae). Malacologia, 22: 219 –223.
I thank Professor A. Piechocki, the supervisor of my PhD project, PROSCHWITZ, T. VON, 1993. Habitat selection and distribution of
for helpful comments and support and Dr Z. Wojciechowski ten vertiginid species in the province of Dasland (SW Sweden).
(University of Lodz) for advice on statistical analyses. I am also Malakologische Abhandlungen Staatliches Museum für Tierkunde Dresden, 16:
indebted to referees for comments on the manuscript. The project 177 –212.
has been supported by grant from Polish State Committee for RIEDEL, A. 1988. S´limaki ladowe Gastropoda terrestria. Katalog Fauny
Scientific Research. Polski 46. PWN, Warszawa.
SKIBA, S., DREWNIK, M., PREDKI, R. & SZMUC, R. 1998.
Gleby Bieszczadzkiego Parku Narodowego. Monografie Bieszczadzkie 2.
REFERENCES Bieszczadzki Park Narodowy, Ustrzyki Dolne.
AGÓCSY, P. 1968. Data to quantitative conditions in the mollusk faunas SOKAL, R. & ROHLF, F.J. 1995. Biometry. W.H. Freeman, New York.
of two different substrates in central Hungary. Acta Zoologica Academiae TATTERSFIELD, P., WARUI, C.M., SEDDON, M.B. & KIRINGE,
Scientiarum Hungaricae, 14: 1 –6. J.W. 2001. Land-snail faunas of afromontane forests of Mount Kenya,
110
HABITAT CHOICE IN CARPATHIAN CLAUSILIIDAE
Kenya: ecology, diversity and distribution patterns. Journal of WÄREBORN, I. 1969. Land molluscs and their environments in an
Biogeography, 28: 843–861. oligotrophic area in southern Sweden. Oikos, 20: 461–479.
URBAŃSKI, J. 1939. Mieczaki Pienin ze szczególnym uwzglednieniem WÄREBORN, I. 1970. Environmental factors influencing the distri-
terenu polskiej cześci Parku Narodowego. Prace Komisji Matematyczno- bution of land molluscs of an oligotrophic area in southern Sweden.
Przyrodniczej PTPN B, 9: 263 –505. Oikos, 21: 285 –291.
VALOVIRTA, I. 1968. Land molluscs in relation to acidity on WIKTOR, A. & RIEDEL, A. 1992. Ślimaki ladowe Gastropoda
hyperite hills in Central Finland. Annales Zoologici Fennici, 5: 245 – Terrestria. In: Czerwona lista zwierzat ginacych i zagrozonych w Polsce
253. (Z. Glowaciński, ed.), 31 –38. Nature Protection Research Centre of
WALDÉN, H.W. 1981. Communities and diversity of land molluscs in the Polish Academy of Sciences, Kraków.
Scandinavian woodlands. I. High diversity communities in ZIMKA, J.R. & STACHURSKI, A. 1976. Vegetation as a modifier of
taluses and boulder slopes in SW Sweden. Journal of Conchology, 30: carbon and nitrogen transfer to soil in various types of forest
351 –372. ecosystems. Ekologia Polska, 24: 493 –514.
111
APPENDIX
Station number 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
Locality Wielka Suche Połonina Wielka Wielka Czoło Połonina Dolina Dolina Bereżki Wielka Rawka
Rawka Rzeki Caryńska Rawka Rawka Caryńska Rzeczycy Rzeczycy
Altitude above sea level (m) 800 725 1060 730 1175 1120 930 665 670 650 1250
Slope aspect SE N S SSE NE N ENE SE E NE NE
Slope angle 58 58 158 108 258 108 408 18 28 108 158
Relief form convex concave convex convex convex convex convex concave concave convex concave
Average annual temp. ( 8C) 5.3 4.7 4.0 5.6 3.2 3.4 4.3 5.1 5.1 5.6 2.8
A. SULIKOWSKA-DROZDA. SULIKOWSKA-DROZD
Adenostyletea
Canopy cover 80% 90% 80% 95% 75% 80% 65% 70% 70% 85% –
112
Shrub cover 40% 30% 15% 15% 5% 50% 20% 20% 25% 15% 40%
Herb cover 60% 60% 65% 80% 65% 90% 80% 100% 100% 95% 97%
No. of plant species 28 28 20 16 27 42 29 50 41 41 39
Soil moisture index 3.44 3.53 3.48 3.52 3.55 3.70 3.22 3.58 3.86 3.62 3.64
Organic matter content (%) 14.1 8.15 14.77 11.19 15.13 16.68 13.13 9.67 36.6 19.57 17.2
Soil Ph H2O 3.6 5.0 3.6 4.0 4.0 5.0 3.7 6.2 5.4 4.5 5.2
Soil porosity (%) 68.85 69.7 69.24 68.53 74.3 65.2 73.17 64.9 82.83 77.17 86.3
C/N in leaf litter 35.32 33.37 33.65 30.68 21.9 32.43 28.92 23.62 17.54 18.14 24.65
Calcium in leaf litter (mg/dm3) 295 500 235 285 310 400 400 690 935 605 550
No. of species
Terrestrial Gastropoda 22 18 6 15 11 23 24 31 19 28 14
(spring)
Terrestrial Gastropoda 20 21 7 13 11 24 21 32 18 27 18
(late summer)
Density (ind./m2)
Terrestrial Gastropoda 130 119 18 118 28 304 283 546 1069 296 265
(spring)
Terrestrial Gastropoda 184 242 24 108 35 670 233 800 871 340 275
(late summer)
M. tumida (spring) 4 0 0 0 1 16 0 34 40 4 9
M. tumida (late summer) 3 2 0 0 0 27 0 49 36 6 1
V. turgida (spring) 0 6 0 0 1 11 0 7 3 9 4
V. turgida (late summer) 0 1 1 0 3 49 10 24 10 6 9