You are on page 1of 23

               



     /


   

"# $%& '# :

/&1  ."/0 ("# )#$%& '#  *'# '+# ,-   *)#
 !'/ 2% &1  )#3  . , 1 ' 4  !' !& 2%
:4  2+#&& 5'#%&# ' 6(  ' 7)& ,- 218# 0&1 *9 4
/ )#'  5'#  2. 5  # 7)&  2#3 79&   ,-
'/"#  ;&/  " 2' # 0&1 <9 2#   - 7)& '+# 2'
 ?/ @/#3   6'/%3 : , 1 6#  5'# . 2 '=&
: 5/
/// /
///&#  /
///'. 2/
///  /
///  #/
///
.( 6'&.13   6''#   6'#3 6')' #   6'3)

  ! : 

!/+ / 5/ )&' 5 '   1  "2"  6 :".1
/  2F/ G&4 : &# 2+' 3# 2#' 2 5 '#E ( "'
 , 1   ::'

2/ G&# ,& &&' 2 &#   G4(  G4( H#4 : ' H## 
2" 2/# # #   4 ( 2 ,& (1) 4(  4(
!/& 5'/ ' I 2 2+' J3K) # J3K) # 3# H  )&' 4
:,# H  J  (2)")0 (

87 2009! ! 


' 1 H' /   
'/ 1 /# M8  5$ 'N 5 ( (3)(!& 5' )& ' : # )
' 5'&K  5' ' 0& 5    5# # 5'O J1 5'
(4)"/ 5 :4  &     6& 5- # J1 ' 1 2'& " 2+'
5K/ )& I "'  G4( 5 :4   5 " H+  )8 4( 
/8 " /' /8 " G4) ' !& 5' ' I 2'  8  
.  4 2# &# )& =8  G4( 5 Q9  (5)"P

5/ ( 2# 28 5 2# 2 5'' 5  Q "0 6'#
/ ,- '%# # "6'" +. &N % ,& 2# # 218# '0
) ' ' G4( 5 '&  (= 20#'  1 '#    )&
Q "0 ) +' '#   5 ,- 0 '%# 4- ' H'  5 'O'  1
4& 5&' 8. )# '   @ &# # '&&' (pragmaticus)
./% /+'  '&#. ,- 2 4( 2+#& (6) '  , 1 3  , )
   M."03 :4 # ( '&'#. (pragmaticus) =8  &&' Q "0
P 2+ )+ 2# " =& :4 =8  ' ,- '# Q "0  #
'8& '0#3 '# :)& '  6 # 5 'N ) 5R )  
<#   6+ *= <   218# NS 5 #( + (7)"' 4
/+ # 2 5' 218# ' ' 1# 3 =& 2 )# 6'8'
T/&# /"# &1 2#3 &1   ) ?+## # '8' " &## 54- )
:/ ;0#3 2( &1 ,# 6'=& 6 5 '# "-  )  '9+ G4(
5/1 # ) )N# #  8 :4 6" '# *'# 6#.(8)"'#
   # 0+ #)# ( (9)) 0 ' 8 '   8 #)# '=&
2. 5 2 ('' # @O *%#   # . & O
/  / 1 5 U" ) ## ,& ,-  ,& 3 P## + H#
/&" 2/ + 2/+  # ,&    # 0+ < *%# '8' 
H/&$ H/ /- 5' 5 . 5 !' J 5   9" :&# 5%"1
/1 V !'O $%& .(10)"H#  H+#  N &'  'N  # 5%"1

             82


   '/#
?/8#3 /+ /N'( "# ' 1  5'% 5'" 0+ !K#
,/- ,/' (. "# ' 1  5'% W" X" 5' &9
V G4( &&# "# =#& '   0#   20#3 % 2
(11)
:( '  < , 1

' 4( *( H'9#+' 4 + '- '  :#( 2 # :F  
. " (  N '- )  # 3 5

5 H'1# 5 :&' 3 J% ) # 3 '  '+'+ ( +# 5 :*' 
.* 2'

.'  ,& )  ( +# 5 : . 

.=#& 2%  :#  +# 5 )Y & #' M9  #' 5 :.  

'  '#& 5# ,#  V G4( # .  5'% 2 21  
64

/ .1 J& Q# '"  64 5# Z' # '   8& 64 0+
&'#

/&1   ) 2## # '8' &# '# H'- 2 2 5' 20# 
/ 2 )N' ? " 5' # ,&# *  . ?' #)# '
/  #)' 2  )&$  '- )' ' 9 20#3 ' 1 '' 5 H&$% 5
:( . 2# ' 1 H # 6'" N.N

(2)
.  ' 63#3 /& ?' /% 5 # /

 #/ #/)# /N.N /0& 2. 5    2#3 '# ,&# 


2/ + . *= #)#  0#  . 2  % <

83 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬


' 1 H' /   
G/&#   2/ 5/ 2 &#  '  21 5 .  0 H  2
/ /#  /  <   5' #  '  6 ' #)# .  
.(12)"2#3     " ) " 0+ 7#&##"'" '8'

/)8 2/+ /'#' 5 5' G'# '#  )  G ?' 
2/ , 1 8 # 2  G4( 2 ?' 2  '  ?'  + :4 5'
2/+ T/#&- "% U " ( ?' )&1   2 5' # 0
5/ G  #' 5' 0 ' ( 2+ H#4 2+ 51 '  "% (
(5) =  (5) "  :4 20' H'#  H#  # '0%
' (13)
 #/ ?'/ /  5'/ $%&# # 6 . !# ")' 20' 5'4 
/'8' H/=  # 0+ :4 1# '& '& *= <
#/)# 54- /) 2# 2 )&- ) "' )= 5' ,- . 20
(14)"5'[  '#3 4( 'N$#   ;% '#  NK# # 2 "
/('O 5 3 ) & P 5 =8 2#& &' 0 3 =8 2 5
+'" 5'  '#3 &'# ,- ('& # &0+ 20'- , 1  )&  &
=8 #& 5 5 (& # )#'0    G4) =8 #  &#  :&( 5 '"#1
:(15)/(   7# 600# N.N 5' ' !' % )1('O   
!/' :(  @ )9 ' % 6 .  ,&' :% 
 .1  #)# :)'- 2'#  )' 1 2# # J'% 6.  .1
5/ " 2% ,&' 5 J    .1 H  2 !# )'8 6.
6/.  '  6' J'% )# .1 3  ) 3  J'-  
,/ 1 Z/' # ' 1 ## ' 5 &9 )8  . 6 #&# 6%Y
"/ &' !    [ '  4# 2#  ' H  5
5 (16)/' /   " '# " Q "0 2# 5 2 '  
/)& , 1 '# *F1  29 M.0 5R 2% 1 U 1 ) Z' # ' 1
H/  2/0# 6J - 2. )0 0 '    1  5   U8"
 0# 28 ) #&- !& ) '8' !' 6'&  5'' 5 5' )&- (17)"1

             84


   '/#
/'# :'/& *F/1   . !  . *  "-  . 2 
"2+' ' 20#1# 3 218#  2 2% (# )&$  1 )&$ )80
 )# '  6 "&8 = '  2 2' #  1 )80 '#
/ )/Y ,- *)# '  6 "& 5 5  ."& 1 H  20#3 ' 1
' (18)
/ /' 4/   :4 '# ' :'&8 "1# 3 218# 20#3
#/'8' "  2  51 ' 1#  218#  - ,- ) 6 "&
Q#/ ." : ) 68% 2  3F .1 (  =8  5 2 #
'#  'N 68'# 5'N 5 '  + 5'+ #  5' 20# 
2  5 1  5#  *& 5 ) <'"#& # !  ( '#" )&
44% M9'- 5 5 O , 12 .  #  '# anomalons 4%
'# )' 1 +# # ! 5 U& ,- 20  ' .' 5'  2  G4( 
(19)
3 4/ ./ ,/ 1 '# &# + ")#3  2 .% 8'# ' 3 )
/ ! ). 5 !& # ( '   '' 63#3 ,%#'
/  2# "& 2 !# ) )'1 (4% <#  2   2# '8'
/'& 5/ )/9 )' % 'O % '&9 '0 )#33
,/- /Y   '# & Q9' 5 2' *'# 5 U& (" '8'=
/1   63  1 5' " & &  ' *'# 4( 5 (20)" ' 'O 
; /& 0 *'# 4) 8&    1   U# 3   P ' 1 U
< *'# '#   + 0 G4( 2 '# ? + 2 ' 3 ' 3
/ /3  1 < <"+## :%##    63  2+  )%#  5' <&
/) )# /# ,& & 2 " 5'N @ )1  ) ,&  )#
"/% )' 1 ?"&# # 2   , 1 3  1 0#  4R '3 6'=&
'# (21)" "% G4( H' 1 ?"&# 3  :4 J  ,&# '# 5R ?0
H'&'  2 6%Y 2 '  'O '  6. 2 ,- 3  1  ##
J / ,- '0 3  ## G  H 0 H ' 5 5'  2 2+
/ /) "#  # < 218# <  ## 2 ,& ,- 20  2+
# ?' &  " )& , 1 )9 )F1 + :4 M & 2 20#3 ' 1

85 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬


' 1 H' /   
# '# (22)2# + 5 J 4 &1 (   '#  ' % 8%#
?'  # ) <  # 5' 20# )8 +' 5 H&$% 5  2 
1# 5 5' # '& '& ''# '+N '1# 3 *= 2 
H. @O G0+  # & ,- 20  H#+ H#J8 :# <#
,/- 5   (  # 5(4    ,& 8%  ,- ,' <
 #/ 5'/ 3/# 5/' ,& 1&0 ,- ,# '# +   ,&
6 ' 2 2. 5  .  5 ,& Y 9#' 5#' 2 <
P/& &&R 63  5''  '# "#3 =& '  '1# 3 '
, 1 H' , .## G # )& P' '1# 3 K 2   2# #)' 5'#
?/"& /O. ;/    1 )( 8 #  5 5'' 5' H 
5#/   '#'(23)   5 ('O U# 3  1 :4   8 
,/& 2/0# * G4( 2 =## *   5 1  2% 2+
'/0#3 /'  Q &/#  '/ 3- 2+ : # 2  Z' # 20#3 ( ))
M./0 / H'- % 4 )8 ,- && +&# )8 4) '# 2 ' 0#
/+# " :2/+' ' ?"& , 1 # !' )8 5 # *'% 5'
,/- */) (!') U%  G4 H 1 =& 2 )8'&0# , 1 '#O
5 ? "&' ))8 (24)"1 '+"& '=& 5# (+'"'') ' 3 '.1 <9
'  20#3 " 2 6. 6%Y ,& 51 # '8#  +'" )&
/) 2/ 2 " 2+ 21- ?"& , 1 :4  &# '  'O
28  1 1 J- ,- *)# ( 20#3 2  5  ' 5# <  2+&#
5' 5 2 Z' # 20#3 20# *) 8 H" <  "' H# .1
6'=& JN-  ( 4 '#  H N$# G&# *'# 4( 7)#& 5
\./Y /0+ ,/ 1 # '' '#  H)8 2. 5  J+
;& '(&# 3 633 2' 4 ;& M#8 ;& 5K' H& ' 20#3
5/ 5/ 2  ' 0# &  ?+' 4 ;& ( '# &1 
2./ 5 3- :4 2 ' 5 & 2 0 1 J+ P  # '
*/  '#3 V+ 5 ;&  +# )8 2)# '#  #
             86
   '/#
(!/') /' 3 5'/ '+'# H# 5 <& H8 " # 6J+ 2'$# 5
H/  /+ (25)"" 2' # 6'=& ' 20 64 ' '' '=&
' /0# '0#3 '  5# ,# ;& < H# # V+  H#( ' #
, 1 #1 + ' &  ( 6' 2' # & 5 &   2   &
5/1 /  # & 2. 5 2 & V+ ?'   51   
 2  '' )#4 2  )#4    + :4  # )#4  
'  ' 5 H&$% 5  2  

:4 5' 2'$#  . J% 2 G&1 Q0' '.1 ' 3  6& ' ' 0#
, + '# )8 U8# %# 4) =& &  2 , 1 #8& "
!/' /) 2/0# /0+ "# ) )8   )' H+ '% 
/)& , 1 )1 + ' 0# '  M &Y '98   2#3 # 6'8'
/'# ) (26)"    (  ' )& )8& +'"   '#  '"
20# 63 *  2. 5 =8  2+   #& 6'8' 2  # G&1
.?'

20' ,# '. H 2. 5  # 0+ : ,- ,' 4 ( "
.N 51 #' G& &&R !' %# ,- & +#& 4-   # 20# ,- <#
/'3 /''# / /( '# 6'&  5F#  5 6'#
/'# 6'&/  @#8# " 2+' ' '% .#  #  ( '#
/ 6/ . ' 8'0 % & 5'3 ''#  5 . +
2'' # J'%   .1 4@ )9  6 .1   ## )'K
/1  /  / 5/ ? "&' '#  !' 0# (27)"58K )' 1
6/'8' 5'K ,- 2+#&' <  6  ( 63 , 1 '  '#
1938 &  '=& ! H#  (!') ' +" # " < )
/' 5 .1 ( ' 5  ' '#  2# N.N 0&1 5'
/ ,- & +#& 4- (28) ..<# 4 5 2'$#  2 ( ' 5  3 (
6'&  ,-   6'&  5  2+&' 5 2' G & &&R  ( 2 

87 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬


' 1 H' /   
"%& 6'& 5 '& 'O ''&' 6'& 2  5 54- Q'  ( 5-" ''
(29)"2'/  ; % 2#3  ,- &  ) *0&# '   
'# '0 M#  20# Z' # P# ,- 6'&  2+&' 5 2'  (
,#  ] )# 6'8' 2. 5 5' # @O 51 *%' 5 $
H1#   "%& 5## * = <  ( <9   H'- 2 , 1 NK'
(30)
:/( * = G4( 'O.Y '  ?+# H'- 2 2 20'- 2#
G4( 2 J& '# :  8'= J& 8'= '# 8'= 2'N# 8'=
H/'- 2/ -  G/0  2 R 'O.Y '  Q &# ## * =
"/%& ,/- /  28 5 2+#&' )   # 0+ ) ,- 20 H#
 ' 0# J8 2. 5 '#  8'# +' H&R  (   +'+
/&' 6  =8 #' H  # # '0#3 J8 G4( : ' H&R ' J8  2 5
2/0#' < H)8' ''  !1 =8 #' + ' 0# 3 K# 5' ?' 
J/8 2+&  N && && ' 0# H#J8 2. 5 ( # & ,-
*/0# 4- '&  J8  &  (  :4 '1 G& ) " G&1 ' 0#
5 #5 18 )  ' # 1+   =& " 28   '=&
,/- T/#' 2 (31)"2  ; 2#3 "% J8'# ) Q# #
/+ # 2/ ( 5' 18 5' K"# :&( '. H ?+' Z' # "%
5'N/ ) 6# + M & 20# Z' # ' 1 ## ,# '0#3 "%
 1 )  4 0  4# ) 5' 5' 5 5 '# 2  
2#/3 2   ) ' '  (= 2 !' ? %# &  2#
/'  ,& '8# *0 8#'  1 9 '  1 6' " :H+ )^1 '
'  (= !' &&Y 20#  '  1 ( 2 )% ( &1 *+'
5/# /&( 5   20#  '&&Y 6+ , 1 *## 2#3 2  
'(32)
1/ /&  2 !'  1 )  "   2#3  1 ,# 5$ '
2 6%Y 6. 3   2%  &1 *+# 3 )   20# , 1
/ 1 G/&1 '# &&Y 20# ,- 20 *) G ## :4 2 N##

             88


   '/#
5'N @  + '#  0# *'# 1    " '0+
(33)
:(    63  5 ('O 51 (# '#  0 6'

2#/3 /   ,& *=# )&    2#3  , 1 +# )&


.,& ' 4 :  5  '0 ' 5  8

.//"# 61//9 3 //) //0 2//' # 6// //'#  !'//


.(...'+N '1#  ') 1 '8'=    '# !#

/ 1 /3      0#   5 '1 63  H' 0'  '#
2/0# Z'0 '#  1 " 2' # 8&    1 1# 3  
.?'

: *    ! .II

,-  U& Y ,- *)' .N (&1 ?"& 3 '9+ '+ 4& 8.8 #( +
Q/#  G4) @ )9 )"#  J'% 6N# # 5'(  7  '+#
#&'3 )'- 1 #  '=&  *%#&" 5 &&' .N )    "
5/1 /# 5 &&# * '8 4(  . 2' 0# ' V
(34)
,- "9 ) 5&Y  "%  U&   6'N' #1 )&' ' J'%
/=& :4  H "'# # J'%  <  2'N#   6. 5 =& #
5/ ( 6  H#  51 ' )# ,-    ,- T# )  '+#
' H+ 6 #   "# 4 (35) % 8  E

:. .!  / !  :+ , *- 1

 "# N 5'4 2  5 !' !& %#  ''  * '8 #'
(36)
" "+'"'/ N ?"& '# G&1 6"#" '. 8 8  &  2 
</ , '# Q. 6)= +   7)&   5' :4 6"#

89 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬


' 1 H' /   
8  5' ,# !' 2J#  1878 1" 9 & 2 & *'" + )=
"/%&  64 5' ' 4 218# " H- 2 1  2' !  ,&
< / /)"  / 2./ 5 '&&Y  # '"# 2    ''
2  (  , 1 3 '& '&&-  # @#8' H' 1 2 <  5-" 1# 3
(37)
4- G/ 2/ "# '#  !' )8 * #   1#  (  , 1
5 ,/- ,/)#&  /9 N & 2 '8' 51   2K# 3 ? "&
20# 7)& )& ' 5 !' &1 ## '  7 #& !+'  U9 &0#
#/' )#" # ?" 51    #( %Y !' #(  7)&
 6' ' 5 1 '# :4 2. 5 #''=& )    5' 20#3
@#8# # 6'&  5:4   ("Y H0' #  H&1 1 H# ' :4
.(38) '3 ''#  5 .

 .2/0#3  / 2  5  '  <   2+& ( =& 4) '#


/. /## /# '# 5 !' P :4   5'' <'  7)&
(39)
&' 1  *" 5 P 6.1 < ?'&#  )#  '& 
5/ :. 0   ! % )"'  )# *=  .1 '&  . 
5/ J/ '# #1 4  !' %#  '# =&  K
 /3  1   '#  1 (   ' G4) U N.N G''# &1 ' '
(40)
/(N  )8'=# +'"  ) # .  .1 ,- !' H& +  '#
"# )9 "# U8 G4( 2  )'K   .1 ,- H&  5'+ # 
2/ 51 2 #' 3 '8# 4(  .  + # '8# '8' !# '# +'N
 J'/% ,/ 1 /#'   =& 5 #   '&  ''# ,&
,/- /Y  #' ))      )'- 2'# <  :4 6.
)#  3  '#  1 , 1 ## '#  3  4(  ) 
,/ 1 /('N$# 6'8'    ,- !' =& +   # 0+ 51 *% 
# (  *  , 1 'O" ( )&$ 2 . '  =& )'- =&  H'- 2
 Y !8& ,- K' 5' <9  2 2 5' 2  4# ,- " _')#

             90


   '/#
4/( 5/ J/ + # P *  4#  2'  #'  2  28  
.  +    '%    J- '   ' ' * 

/ /' 5/ 3- !' 0# 51 'N #' 3 !' 5 7#&#& ?  
6&/9# 6/ 5 1  @)&    8 !' )8 5  
2/  1 2% 6. =& 2   '1# 3 '8& (= 
60#   ; 2%  

 )Y 2   ?"&  8 8 N$# 5'#%& &'  5- :2  !!3 ! 1&
  2+

,/- H/ #  :4 51 21  51 H& 8 8 8  ?"## 'N   '- 
/3:/( ' '(8 N.N , 1 8 8 G4( ##  (41)"'   
.(42)    1+

.2+ 5 1# 2     2  2+    5' ?   :3 .

# 5' # 2 5 '  0 2N 1  ( :1+ .
.2#3 '##  '0 '& 1+ (   "%& <'&# Q#

/ /( 3 1+ )8 51 208&' 3 )8 H&- :'   .T
#/ / ?/ " 6#   "%& U&# + ' 2% 5 .% G=&
=8 2 2 '+"&  6'   5'#%& &'  '# %    
5/ /(& #       ?'  ,&   2 5' ,& )
(/ + (43)"(Meaning is use) 2#3 ( G&1 ,&" )## 2.
' ' 4 ( 2#3 2 ' '# 2    ( * '8 4(
/  2   '8 8 )  5 O  ( 20# 2     
/ /' ' # )#J -  Q9##  )'  5 3- ;0 H  , 1 '# 
.5'# 5 * '8 J  3- '19  '  ,- ?#

91 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬


' 1 H' /   
:45!  / (   12

*0# ##&-  #1 4 5'#%& & * '8 H+ 5 N$# :2 ! 1
5'# P0#   '  <    <  ,- '%# '  3- (   
/& /+ "/ (   ' 8'= 5# 5 &  (+&   G4)
/- 80 <   2 *0 ( 'Y 6  ' 8'= 5# 5 5'#
6 5 5'1& 5' '' (44) "'80 "" H' 1 ? "  4   0 5'
/)' 1 / 5'     <   51 # ,  & 2 5# #
/ 2./ 5 4   0 2## 3 ) 2 )  &# '&N  4  ?0
/ G/ ;' # 5'   '. 2 '=& <9 5'# 5- 2+ 5' ?
/'&N "+&4  ?0 ' &N H9  2N## , "+&.(45) 5'#&N 5'#"+&
2/ 5 ,/ 1 K# . 2 '=& 21 51 1 2 2 5$ G -  2N##
 #&  5& 64 .   H %# 4 28  '.  8' =8 
/'   28 +& &(   0# 2   59##    #& 3 .N
.'  2 5 5'1& 5' H#'=&  5'#

 ?/0 ' )' 1 ' # '  <      2N## :  6 / 3 .1
 4 5# 5 5' ''+#  H'#N- '80     5'# ; ' " 4
(46)
H 0 $#' '- . 2N' 4) )8& 2 # @ 5 .N &+ "  0
* H& 4 - 2 ) !&# :  # &+  <   H#+" 2. 5
"/& 64 2) "   ,- :4 %  . !'  ) 2 ) :  3 # !&# < 
 (47)
" ' 4( )' 1  ' 5 5' 3 ;

 &/N ' )' 1 '  <  *0# 3 2 (  :(7 !6) 7 / 3 .2
,/ 1 ' /%&Y 2 2  G4( 5'# '  ?8Y  ?'#  M & (
(48)
. ,  !1

             92


   '/#
 ?8#   Q &#  2  G4( 5 , 1   4  ?0 )80 ,8&  
(49)
/&' "% ?+# 3- ?+## 5 ?'# 80 3 2 ,9#+ ' ## )&
(50)
:51& ( 

:  2N##    28 ?'+# '9 (  : !   1

. ?."  T 2+ 1 N  2+ 1 J -   11

&' *=  5'' !& *" 5  6  ?"& J Y 59#' 5 1 2
/#& :#   :#& &  2 2N 5 6  =8 # "#%' T  .N
) 5 &&' 5  , 1

5'   (#   "% 2N J Y 4( 4'8&# 5' (K !& 5' 513
\ 

/ 3-  ?."   ?"& 3- <+' 3 .N ?." 8 '0 4'8&# 5' 5 1 4
.9 6  2# 51 #3  ' '0 J K'  H& ?." 5

#/%  <  5 2 '$# 2. 5 3- #' 3 <' + . 4'8&# 5' 5 .5
& '  63#3 4 $ , 1

/ 5-  #' 28 5  . "% 2N '9 6' (  :   
G4/(  H/1  ?'# 28 , 1   3 "% G4( 9 5 2+ '
 G/   0 J Y  :% 5 9 .1:  ' ' ; ## "%
:8&   6&  "' & G4) : &(" :0% 6 4R G'&  G1%
28 J 6$ + H9'+& 2 :4 %# 3

/'O  / 6  N :  ;% 6 4R: . 2+'  2 + # ' 5 .2.
/+# /'Y 28 5 'N 5 5'# Q9#  28 J 6$ + 
/'  2/ 5' ''#  ) 5 5'# H4  O '  2 8'=

93 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬


' 1 H' /   
5'  5 ')&  H 5'## ,# '+# 4(  =& < ' 2= + 'Y 
3  && *' 2K ,- 1 <  9 'O 2# 3 2 5 5'1& 5'4(
H/&  /- 2 +'+  ) " 5%"1 & " & .N (51)`3  ?"&& 5'
/  J   9   " ,& K# )& '  2 8'= K'
# 2 N.N 5  . 28 5 P M" 2K# 51  a H#
&' 2%# 2 N.N , 1   28 #'"  . 2  8 # &
3 2/ /) (52) "/  6   )N <+' N.N 2 G4( 5$  1 
:(53) (    3- [ 51 )& 5 & 208&'

& N.N H :89: /:1

 (  (BRUIT) U  60 T#&-  =8 #  2N#' : 8, /:1 %


. ,& H Q'0 &- '#  )8 ' 60 5 *$#'

/1+ </9#  /  ,- #&#  '#0 0 )   : 8" 1 &
.'&

&' 633 6  : # 2 ' 4 (  : 8  /: 12

Q "/0'  9- ,& 5 =8  28 H'K'  (:85" ;0 !- /: 13


(54)
 H 0+'    '% &+ ?+#' 4 (   %&Y 28 b3 .'  H' 1
(55)c... Q0&  '4# 1 2#3  8'= 5 =8  28 H'K'
4 28   N (  :;< /:. 4. # 0 ?'+# 54-  ? #' 
/ / &Y 2/8 H/N' 4/ N H 0+'  <  + # 5 0'
H/1 / 4) '%  '  ' '#$N 5 J "  (56)"<
2/8 /( 4/( " 6'# 2 , 1 'N$# <  '  # 5 ' 5'#
/ ' . 'N$# 28  . +&3 '9 =8  28 #'  (57)" 'N$#
< , 1 H 'N$# 3  )& H& 2 2

             94


   '/#
2/ ./ 2/ (/ ' 4  &Y 28 ,- H#( 5'# H  :4 
28 5 H  :4  (58) ' &Y '=&  ' &Y 2 '=& ,1# 60
/) H/)8 ,- 20  G) 24 + # , 1   # 0+ "#'  &Y
 28   ,- +   (  2+' 2#3 2 . 8% : 2'
(59)
"*&0 ! ,- '. 2 *'&0# 5'#  ' &Y 2 , 1 J&
/0'  51 # # (  :  = / 3    >  " / 3= . .
 ''+# 5#   4& 'O  4& 5#   '   ' )& 5'    5
..., 1 F 2N '&=

 4# 51 # #  :+ / 3    >  " / 3= .%
...4  Q0& 5'1:2N ;% 9  Q0

2/ /)' )#' # (  :? / 3  : >  " / 3= .&
...  , 1  # 1:2N H H8&  ' J% 28

:  2  2# # (  :@ / 3  : >  " / 3= .


... J    &)#  %  4#13 5'[

2#/# 2/ /(  :B 5- / 3  :A >  " / 3= .*
 /&Y  6NY :2N 5'(  7  #$#   5'#  =& )  Q'9#
 '/ 2/ /&  5 "9 2 +#  )8#3 *#13  +"
(60)


:/ ! /%

2/ /' 2 '=& !'$# U. - "+&  ?."&  5'# ) 6& +
)8 O 4  &Y 28 )8  &' 5'#   1 2' 
2/98 5/ )' 1 +# # ' )& !  . 2 '=&  '
 # '=& <9 5 H'- ,  ?+' 5 <"#' " H& 5 O 5'# < '

95 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬


' 1 H' /   
(61)
5 /' / &Y 28 2 21 5 H  5   "...'. 2]
" 2'  + )  ' '# 2 :&( 5# '9 G4( 5 2' ? "&'
'  2 '=& "  6.'# @ M#  5'# G4# ! 5 H#8#
(63) (62)
, 1 2' ;& :(  :'#[ "+&  2' ) ; & 5 5'  "...
.'/ /' &Y +  5    20#. P0  (  &Y 28 5
/   H/+"&  # H'K' 4  &Y 28 5 5'' ' &Y + 2'" ,'
. '&#  )&   &' 3 , 1 2# &' '0 H# 5' &'

5 5/ </ /(  1# 3    * "# G&1 . 28 : ! <
, 1 (   )    . "% 2' F" : < < . #  , 1 0#+'
:#

5/ / "' 2+#/ / 2 9#+' 4 (  :;5 C   .1
. 1 28 "

/ &- ,/ 1  " 5 4- "% ?+#' :;?   .2


.+ 5'+' , 1  # 28

'O 2+' . 2 J  0   # 5' ' ?+#'  :D-  .3


.<'"#' 3  2 , 1  H& 1' 3  0+' 

 28 '+  <  'N$#  #  2. 5 ?+#'  :8 =   .4
.+ G &-

.(64) % 'O  % 2: ,- '. 2 2'  : 

/( 2/+ 5$ 2 + '   8.  5 2' ? "& :   / 3=11
(65)
/ / &- &' 4(  1# 3 :  5 .% G#1 2+ 5 " 2
/$  'N$# 2 J%&Y 2 &Y 2 2+ 2 (  H8& 6   2
             96
   '/#
'&  '0  ''# ,& 64 2  6  =8 #  2N#' 4 ) 2+ 2
J%&Y 2  H'- 2  2 5'  0 " +' 4 ) &Y 2 
'1  1  ')#  '4# 5'  4 2+  H&1  0+ ( 
5 5 5  < , 1 'N$#  #   5' 'N$# 28   
/0& <' , 1 G#1  # 0+ ,- 20 '' 4 <#  ,&#
5' # ?"# , 1 ##" # 2  (: 2' &1 % 2820#  '98
(66)
0+  ,& ?"# "2+ ,&    ,&

2/ /(    ,& ,- +'+ ,& 2+#&' )' :  E / 3= .2
5/ <#/ ' # 4-" '&  #3  &Y (0 )=Y 2'$# ,- T##
2' 21  .(67)"H ,-  # G&' 4 ,& ,- +'+ ,& 5 2+#&3
/'  (  5'# H J  ,- *9  '. 2 '=& '"# , 1
.(68) (  ' )& ! , 1 +' .'  ' 8'&0# )   

. ;.Y "% .& .+" G # .% .  &Y @ .

5'  5'# )  *&0  ,- + '. 2 '=& 2' 2
.(69) ' ( & 5

 '/9 2. 5 &'    # *0 )'  &Y @ :+  - .1


4( 2

. ,- 6  5 5'  + G #  4  ?0 2## *&0

,/- " H' #  #   )'  &Y @ 2N##  :+ ?.2
J% 2

2N#' ;.Y "%  6  ,-  5 2+#&3  5' &N !  5'
... *"#3    Q0&: H# N 5  '+'+ Y   0 O 

97 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬


' 1 H' /   
/ J/% 2/8  #/ # 51 '# (  &Y )9O :+ 0( .3
6  ,-  5 :4 ,- 2+#&3 ) )' +" G #   2+#

H' #' '# 8& *  51 '#" (  &Y )9O : +  .4


 /%   &)# H' 2' .(70)" +" G # *&0 4) !'  ;.Y "%
"/+ / "      +" H#  2 ' 3 2  4#13
. ;.Y

/  /9+ (# +"  2N#' Q & (J 5 ('  (:+ !D-.5
G/ #  ./ /&    & J  5.1- 2 .N &' 4R  
,/- T## 3   ,- 6  5  6  ,-  5 . 5' +"
 /& 5 '  5' '# "# $%& , 1 =& G4(  ;.Y "%
?/ @/#3 6'/%3 : / ' ' # 2' #  & 4
/( .+/ (&/91 /# '. 2 '=& ,- 9-   #
1  5'    J  5' " 6 2. 5 ' J  ) #(: +  -
J/ 1 N'/ ) #)' '3 '& '0 &  @ )#( 2 
5/ % )&' ' '+# 0& 5  1 5 *$#' ;& " 5 #1 '#
/0& :/ # 5' :#  &3 5 U&  '- , 1 2# # '  6 .
/( (71)"/)+'+# / 'Y " '& " ''# " )#
(72)
U&  (  6 <'   ## ' 6

6& J "  # , 1   9 2N# ( :,  +  -1
. 08&   0#

5/ */'  4R  1 0 5 *= ) N# :!0 +  - /%


. & & 5 , 1 '%Y 0& 2#   5'+ # , 1  !#

             98


   '/#
('8# )# #' 5 *= 1 0 ) N# :!  +  - /&
/"   "  * E 5 , 1   # 6   # 5  , 1
&( :5 *= .:4 4( :( 9 '& 6'%Y N 2 <
6# :&(

?/
/ "&' /
/'  63/
/- /
/ /
/1  /
/  5- :F  A
3(.2 
(73)
5/ # /) M/0' 3 ) *# ' 6'" 5 (5"#)
:/#  2/ *' :&+ '' # '  M & '9 Z' # '8  2%# &-
/ .1 H/ 2  5   J& H&1 2K 5' 5 + @#8' ` :3
.2K < '

'" )+0 H& # 2' #  & ( 5 H&- :;  0( .3
/ ' 6& + (74) 3 ! 63  !#3 51 (  H' 
(75)1968&/ (   ) +- ,- !' 1 # 69 < H'
 6'=& ( 5  H 1 ,9 + # 5#  G 5 5 O , 1
  5+'  . 50+'  )#  !& 5 !' *%# # 
:4/ 6$%& 50+'  9'+& H&+'  5'   5+'  N (0  #'
2/ 2 5' 5#  G  <9   (76)   #3 
(77)
:( '1 V  H## 9' 1  ( H'

:  1 : !  1& :  1% :  1

99 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬


' 1 H' /   
: +(  - G?

 /E'8 "2" / 253 252; 11T / 5 =& 5 1
<'# %& 1"  8  1+  c'% *' "9 "' !+
."2"  .900; 20035& 6' 1"
1T '# 2&"2" 1989 1  "'   '     2
.304;
.140 '[ 51 2E  3
.542; 3T '= 5E+ '8# 4
.150; 5& . '8#  5 ' ''# 5
<'/&'  '#O  !K !' &1 #O ?"&2'   6
.196; 1996 0
 +N    & 2' O   ' 5 ' 7
.102; 2000 J9'  2"
/   1" /%&  0+  6'&   V '(Y "  8
.158; 2000
/0 (/+ 1" [ # 0 '&  !   5& 9
.165; 2004
'    0     ' ?E  &   10
.13; 2002 0 1"
5/' 5#/'' / / # '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  11
.33; 1986    '  61"
.185; 6'&   V '(Y "  12
.14; 0     ' ?E  &   13
.41;  '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  14
.185;  6'&   V'(Y "  15
.9;  0     ' ?E &   4

     100


        
   '/#
.11; 5. 16
.5 ; 5. 17
5 ; 5. 18
  + ) 6%& '&  ! ( 5E ') + 1 19
.95; 1990 !&# 2" '#
.99 5. 20
.118; 1990  1" %&  2+#  5' 2)  M#8  21
/+ J&Y  b 1 '  # '# + &' & 22
.49; 6'
.11; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  23
' ''/ 6/   ?"& 6'&  * 2# :5 1 H" 24
.120; (87،88) &N  '
.15 14;'# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  25
. 14; 5. 26
.80; '# +&' & 27
<  " J  &1 '#" 0  # J  "  51 28
www.chab.net : 6'&#&3
.14; 0     ' ?E  &   29
. 06 '# 6'&  , 2 b3 .'  30
5 ;5  31
/' /   6'&    N' 6'&   '#: *'8 '9 32
 243 ;2U 2006    &1 #    2006
; '#O !K !' %# &1 #O ?"& 2'   =&  33
.198
.10; '# 6'&  ,- 2b3 .'  34
.11 ; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  35
. 198 ;  0 '&  !    5& 36

101 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬


' 1 H' /   
.5 ; 5  37
.09 ; 0     ' ?E  &   38
.41; 0     ' ?E  &   =& 39
.18،19; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  =& 40
42;  0     ' ?E  &   41
.43; 0     ' ?E &   42
.22; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  43
22;'# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  44
.5; 5. 45
.5; 5. 46
.5; 5. 47
.5; 5 48
44،45 ; 0     ' ?E &   49
.45 ; H8& <  0     ' ?E &   50
.24 ; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  51
.45 ; 0     ' ?E  &   52
.22; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  53
. 45 ; 0     ' ?E   &   54
.46;5. 55
.25 ; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  56
.46 ; 0     ' ?E &   57
.25 ; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  58
.5.; 5. 59
.47 ; 0     ' ?E  &   60
.25 ; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  61
47 ; 0     ' ?E  &   62
.(   25 ; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  63
     102
        
   '/#
.29;5. 64
.49;0     ' ?E &   65
.49،50 ; 5. 66
.29 ; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  67
.49 ; 0     ' ?E  &   68
50 ; 5. 69
.5 ; 5. 70
/# /3 '& 5'  .  '+'"# ' 6  ' 5 ' 71
.94; 2005  (+ [
.(  17 ; 0     ' ?E  &   72
.34 ; '# 6'&  ,- 2 b3 .'  73
.35 ; 5. 74
.32 ; 0     ' ?E  &   75
.33; 5. 76
/8  /' /   '#O ''# 3  1 5 (% 77
.(  169;  20010 1" <'# %& 1" 

103 2009‫ا د ا  رس‬

You might also like