Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Yukna1976 Junctional Epithelium
Yukna1976 Junctional Epithelium
701
J. Periodontol.
702 Yukna December, 1976
27
The E N A P procedure was performed in the selected
experimental areas with the following modifications:
1. The distance from the cementoenamel junction to
the reference points was measured at the standard sites
after access had been gained by removal of excised tissue.
2. An attempt was made to create a definite notch at
the apical extent of the root planing for use in histologic
evaluation.
3. Immediate postsurgical measurements of tissue
position were made.
4. No periodontal dressing was used.
Oral hygiene procedures were continued, but with
special regard for the recently surgerized sites during the
first 4 weeks of healing. Amcill-S* 250 mg i.m., b.i.d.,
was administered for 10 days postoperatively for plaque
33
suppression. The hard monkey chowf of the regular
diet was softened with water for the 3 weeks after
surgery. Sutures were removed at 1 week postopera
tively. Photographic records and clinical measurements
of free gingival margin height and mucogingival junction
tattoo position were made at monthly intervals and/or at
FIGURE 1. Line drawing showing the location of reference
points for clinical measurements. time of sacrifice. Radiographs were taken just prior to
sacrifice.
Suprabony periodontal pockets were induced utilizing No pocket depth measurements were made until 90
the technique of Caton, Crigger, and Zander. 31,32
This days postoperatively. For the 90 and 180 day segments,
involved the placement of doubled, one-eight inch, heavy, measurements with silver points were made at the usual
intraoral orthodontic elastic bands into the sulci of the locations 1 week prior to sacrifice. During all the
teeth. The bands were slipped onto the wedged teeth and postoperative documentation procedures, no attempt was
gently pushed into the sulcus with a plastic instrument. made to identify the experimental sites.
The elastic bands were changed and the pockets were The monkeys were sacrificed to yield healing periods
probed every 2 weeks until satisfactory pocket depth had of 0, 30, 90 and 180 days. The jaws were prepared for
been obtained around a given tooth, at which time histologic examination by fixing with formalin perfusion
banding of that tooth ceased. At the time of final band at sacrifice and decalcification in E D T A . The specimens
removal from the mouth, Kodachrome slides and radio were embedded in paraffin or celloidin, stained with
graphs were taken in addition to the standard measure Hematoxylin and Eosin or Masson's Trichrome, and
ments of tissue position, pocket depth, and amended serially sectioned. Sections were made in both mesiodis-
NPDI. tal and faciolingual planes in order to study both the
interproximal and facial and lingual aspects of healing.
Also at the time of final band removal, oral hygiene
procedures were instituted. These consisted of twice RESULTS
weekly cleanings with toothbrush, dental floss and
The formation of adequate periodontal pockets was
pumice. Any supragingival hard debris was removed by
monitored by clinical probing and intraoral radiographs.
hand scaling. These procedures were continued until the
The average time to achieve at least 4 mm of pocket
tissue tone of the previously banded areas resembled the
depth was about 4 months. Clinical and radiographic
remainder of the mouth.
evidence of established periodontal disease is illustrated
One week prior to each surgery (and at least 2 weeks
in Fig. 2a, b.
after final band removal), photographs were taken of the
Clinical results following the E N A P are tabulated for
gingival condition. This was followed by ultrasonic
the two 6 month animals in Table 1. Of particular
debridement and polishing of all of the teeth with rubber
interest is the amount and percentage of pocket elimina
cup and pumice.
tion due to the clinical new attachment of the tissues to
At surgery, the amended NPDI score and all measure
the root surface in the experimental group of incisors.
ments of free gingival margin height, mucogingival
Also of interest is the finding that the untreated control
junction tattoo position, and pocket depth were again
pockets demonstrated a continuing loss of attachment
made and documented with radiographs and photo
and a tendency to deepen with time.
graphs for all incisor teeth. Two experimental teeth were
randomly selected for treatment in each anterior segment
at the time of surgery, with the remaining incisors left as * Sodium ampicillin, Parke, Davis and Company, Detroit, Mich,
unoperated controls. t Ralston Purina Co., St. Louis, Mo.
Volume 47
Number 12 New Attachment Procedure in Rhesus Monkey7 0 3
Pocket depth
Initial Final Decrease
No. of New decrease
pocket pocket in pocket Recession‡
samples attachment‡ due to new
depth‡ depth‡ depth‡
attachment
The NPDI values were found to parallel the differ no rete ridges extending into the lamina propria and
ences between the treated and untreated areas, i.e., the exhibited no ulceration. There was minimal round cell
NPDI scores decreased in the treated areas, but inflammatory infiltrate evident in the corium subjacent
remained high in the nontreated regions. The distances to the junctional epithelium. The re-formed lamina
from the amalgams to the mucogingival junction re propria demonstrated abundant, dense connective tissue
mained fairly constant at all time periods. Findings for bundles or a more loosely arranged, spindly fiber
the 3 month animal were similar to those in the table. arrangement. In the latter type of healing connective
The other animals were not probed (according to the tissue the fibers were well formed, but few in number, and
protocol) and thus do not share a basis for comparison the stroma was very cellular. Both conditions generally
clinically. exhibited a fiber alignment parallel to the root surface
Microscopic evaluation of serial sections at the various (Figs. 4a, b; 5a, b; 6a). Occasionally, areas of apparent
time periods revealed the following: new connective tissue attachment were seen apical to the
A. 0 days (immediately postoperative) (Fig. 3). These junctional epithelium with evidence of new cementoid-
sections showed that the epithelial lining of the pocket acellular cementum formation (Fig. 6b), but the relation
was completely eliminated by the incision. The root ship of these areas to the surgical field could not be
surfaces were smooth, but not devoid of cementum in determined definitely because of the lack of a consistent
most instances. An intervening fibrin clot could be seen histologic marker denoting the depth of the incision and
occasionally between the cut connective tissue surface root planing. Rarely, areas of root resorption were seen,
and the root. and these were apposed with both epithelium and connec
B. 30, 90 and 180 days postsurgery. (Fig. 4a, b; tive tissue in various sections (Fig. 6b, c).
5a, b; 6a, b, c). All sections demonstrated a long, thin C. Control areas (Fig. 7a, b). Control pockets at all
junctional epithelium (usually less than eight cells thick). time frames (i.e., 0, 30, 60, 90, and 180 days) demon
An intraepithelial split was evident in a majority of strated uniform histologic appearances. The pocket epi
the sections, with a layer of epithelial cells remaining thelium was quite thick (usually greater than 10 cells in
attached to the root. The thin junctional epithelium had depth), extensively ulcerated, and had many rete ridges
FIGURE 4. A , Six month postoperative specimen from facial of maxillary lateral incisor showing the long, thin junctional epithelium
extending to point (JE) and the reparative connective tissue of lamina propria (LP). Note the suggestion of the incision line reflected
by the density differences in the corium (arrow) (H & E. Original magnification x 6.8). B. Greater magnification of inset of Figure 4
A. Small area of intraepithelial split; thinness of junctional epithelium; loose, spindly fiber arrangement in corium; and virtual
absence of inflammation are demonstrated. (H & E. Original magnification x 63.)
Volume 47
Number 12 New Attachment Procedure in Rhesus Monkey
705
FIGURE 5. A . Specimen from palatal of maxillary lateral incisor of another 6 month animal. Appearance is similar to Figure 4 A, but
exhibits increased density of lamina propria fibers and a more coronal intraepithelial split (inset) (H & E. Original magnification x
10). B. Inset of Figure 5 A. A layer of epithelial cells is seen attached to the tooth. This was a commonfindingin various areas along
the tooth surfaces (H & E. Original magnification x 160).
extending deep into the lamina propria. Moderate to strated this situation. The untreated "control" areas all
severe round cell inflammatory infiltration and edema demonstrated severely hyperplastic, ulcerated, pocket
were noted in the epithelium and corium. In addition, epithelium with a heavy inflammatory infiltrate in an
polymorphonuclear white cells were noted in the epithe edematous lamina propria.
lium. There was a decrease in the number, thickness, and Moreover, the apparent histologic health of the E N A P
regularity of the connective tissue fibers in the subjacent areas is reflected clinically by the fact that measurements
lamina propria, particularly in areas infiltrated by the and probing demonstrated a consistent new attachment
lymphocytes and plasma cells. Occasionally tooth accu of the soft tissues to the treated teeth for the experimental
mulated materials (both calcified and noncalcified) were period of 6 months. This difference between the histo
seen on the root surface extending to the depth of the logic sulcus and the clinical sulcus has been expounded on
pocket. 34
by Listgarten. He stated that the determined depth of
the clinical sulcus will depend on such factors as thick
DISCUSSION
ness of the probe, the pressure applied, degree of inflam
The consistent finding of a long, thin epithelial attach matory cell infiltrate in both junctional epithelium and
ment and a minimal amount of connective tissue attach adjacent connective tissue, degree of connective tissue fi
ment does not fulfill the histologic criteria for new ber destruction, thickness of the junctional epithelium,
27
attachment established previously. However, the strik and curvature of the root surface. In the present situa
ing absence of inflammatory cells; the thinness and tion, even the presence of a long epithelial attachment did
adherence of the epithelial cells to the tooth; and the not allow penetration of a thin silver point down to con
dense, supportive gingival collagen found in almost all nective tissue attachment.
treated areas was felt to present a picture of tissue health. The frequent appearance of intraepithelial splits in
This histologic appearance is almost identical to that experimental sections may be accounted for by problems
32
considered pathologic by Caton and Zander in animals in obtaining intact biopsies cited previously by Listgart
34 35 36
with similarly created, but untreated, pockets. In the en. Both Listgarten and Frank, et a l . , have shown
present study, however, only the surgerized areas demon the regenerated postsurgical epithelial attachment to be
J. Periodontol.
706 Yukna December, 1976
FIGURE 6. A . Facial of maxillary central incisor 6 months after surgery presents similar appearance to Figure 4A and 5A. In
addition, areas ofcementoid deposition (C), apparent root resorption (RR), and parallel gingival fiber arrangement (GF) are seen (H
& E. Original magnification x 10). B. High magnification of inset of Figure 6 A. Apical end of junctional epithelium (JE), area of
cementoid (C), apparent root resorption (RR), and parallel fiber arrangement (GF) are seen more clearly (H & E. Original magni
fication x 25). C. A different site on same tooth demonstrating an area of root resorption apposed by junctional epithelium (H & E.
Original magnification x 160).
Volume 47
Number 12 New Attachment Procedure in Rhesus Monkey707
FIGURE 7. A . Interproximal of control specimen showing characteristics of nonregressive pocket formation. Thick, ulcerated pocket
epithelium, deep rete ridges, dense inflammatory infiltrate, and sparseness of connective tissue fibers are depicted (H & E. Original
magnification x 6.3). B. Dense inflammatory cell infiltrate in area of ulceration of untreated pocket. Compare with Figure 4B. (H &
E. Original magnification x 63).
of normal structure with hemidesmosomal attachment to closely monitored, isolated teeth would suddenly become
34
dentin and cementum. In addition, Listgarten stated severely involved and exfoliate. This is a problem occa
that the junctional epithelium is readily disrupted by sionally seen clinically in patients who initiate self-
38
clinical periodontal probing and that this disruption orthodontics.
generally occurs within the epithelium rather than at the Proper plaque contol is particularly difficult by
dentoepithelial junction. Our findings seem to corrobo mechanical means in animals. Twice weekly prophylaxis
rate this because whatever stresses and manipulation does not appear to be sufficient to create the proper oral
may have caused epithelial disruption, there is still a environment for ideal healing. Chemical methods of
layer of epithelial cells remaining on the tooth, suggest plaque control may be experimentally superior, but were
ing an intact epithelial attachment prior to sacrifice. A s not used in this study as an attempt was made to
an added consideration, the perfusion technique em duplicate the prevalent clinical situation.
ployed may have forced the fixative through the tissues Surgical technique may be a limiting factor. Proper
and caused the disruption of the junctional epithelium. tissue manipulation and root surface treatment seem
The usual limitation of an adequate animal model essential to success, and this may not always have been
system appeared to be overcome by the method of pocket accomplished under these experimental conditions
formation utilized in this study. The pockets created despite the efforts of the operator. Clinician bias in data
yielded the classic clinical, radiographic and histologic gathering was somewhat minimized by measuring tissue
evidence of periodontal disease as described in the height and pocket depths at the different time periods
37
human, but may possess biochemical differences due to without prior knowledge of animal number or of which
the physical rather than microbial nature of induction. In sites were experimental.
addition, the created defects seemed to be progressive Regulation of animal habits is another chronic prob
and active as evidenced by the further loss of attachment lem. Monkeys are notoriously adept at manipulating
with time (Table 1). tissues, surgical sites, and appliances. In fact, most
There are many limitations in a study of this type. sutures were lost during the first postoperative week, and
Several teeth were lost during the pocket formation the animals could be seen fingering the surgical sites
phase due to too rapid apical progression of the elastic while in their cages. These manipulations may well have
bands. Even though the progress of pocket formation was jeopardized the minimal blood clot and tight tissue
J. Periodontol.
708 Yukna December, 1976
adaptation that is felt to be necessary for optimum 5. Shapiro, M . : Reattachment in periodontal disease. J
success of this procedure. Periodontol 24: 26, 1953.
The Excisional New Attachment Procedure, on cur 6. Linghorne, W. J., and O'Connell, D. C : Studies in the
reattachment and regeneration of supporting structures of the
sory examination, may appear to be identical with the teeth. III. Regeneration of epithelialized pockets. J Dent Res
39 40
unrepositioned flap, the Widman flap, replaced 34: 164, 1955.
41 42
graft, or mini-flap; but several important differences 7. Marfino, N . R., Orban, B., and Wentz, F. M . : Repair of
exist. The E N A P is restricted to the keratinized gingiva; the dentogingival junction following surgical intervention. J
it is not intended to be used whenever edematous pockets, Periodontol 30: 180, 1959.
8. Wilderman, M . N . , Wentz F. M . , and Orban, B. J.:
pockets extending beyond the mucogingival junction, or Histogenesis of repair after mucogingival surgery. J Periodon
osseous defects are to be treated; and vertical or relaxing tol!: 283, 1960.
incisions are not utilized since no apical positioning of the 9. Ritchey, B., and Orban, B.: The periodontal pocket. J
tissues is planned. The E N A P however, can be extended Periodontol 23: 199, 1952.
into a flap if the need arises. 10. Raust, G. T.: What is the value of gingival curettage
in periodontal therapy? Periodont Abst 17: 142, 1969.
It is interesting to note that the clinical results in Table 11. Schaffer, E. M . , and Zander, H . A.: Histologic evidence
1 parallel the findings in a 1 year clinical study in of reattachment of periodontal pockets. Paradentologie 7: 101,
27
humans. Although the human values may have been 1953.
enhanced by the consistently good plaque control pract 12. Zander, H . A.: Is root preparation important in achiev
ing reattachment? Periodont Abst 14: 53, 1966.
iced by the patients, the monkey results indicate that the
13. Morris, M . L.: Healing of naturally occurring periodon
new attachment can withstand the adverse conditions and tal pockets about vital human teeth. J Periodontol 26: 285,
limitations mentioned above. 1955.
14. Bjorn, H., Hollender, L., and Lindhe, J.: Tissue regener
SUMMARY ation in patients with periodontal disease. Odontol Revy 16:
317, 1965.
Experimental suprabony periodontal pockets were
15. Ramfjord, S. P., Nissle, R. R., and Schick, R. A.:
established around the incisors of Rhesus monkeys and Subgingival curettage vs. surgical elimination of periodontal
subsequently were treated by the Excisional New Attach pockets. J Periodontol 39: 167, 1968.
ment Procedure. Healing was evaluated clinically and 16. Bjorn, H.: Experimental studies in reattachment. Dent
histologically for up to 6 months. Clinical examinations Pract 11: 351, 1961.
17. Shapiro, M . : Reattachment operation: A conservative
demonstrated an overall mean pocket depth reduction
procedure for the elimination of periodontal pockets. J Am
from 5.02 mm to 2.82 mm, of which 0.57 mm was Dent Assoc 54: 657, 1967.
recession and 1.59 mm (73.6%) was clinical new attach 18. Stahl, S. S., Weiner, J. M . , Benjamin, S., and Yamada,
ment. Histologic evaluation of experimental sites consist L.: Soft tissue healing following curettage and root planing. J
ently revealed a long, thin junctional epithelium with a Periodontol 42: 678, 1971.
minimal amount of inflammatory infiltrate in the subja 19. Cross, W. G.: Reattachment following curettage: His
tologic study. Dent Pract 1: 38, 1956.
cent, densely fibered, lamina propria. Control areas 20. Morris, M . L.: Reattachment of human periodontal
demonstrated the classic histologic picture of periodontal tissues following surgical detachment: A clinical and histologic
disease and tended to be progressive in nature clinically. study. J Periodontol 24: 220, 1953.
21. Barkann, L.: A conservative surgical technique for the
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS eradication of the periodontal pocket.J Am Dent Assoc 26: 61,
The author wishes to extend his sincere appreciation to Drs. 1939.
G. M . Bowers, J. J. Lawrence, and J. E. Williams of the 22. Ramfjord, S. P.: Experimental periodontal reattach
Periodontics Staff of NGDS for their guidance and suggestions; ment in rhesus monkeys. J Periodontol 22: 67, 1951.
DTI D. Morgan, U S N , DT2 R. Harbaugh, U S N , DT2 P. 23. Sato, M . : Histopathological study of the healing process
Yukna, U S N R and Mr. H . Luebbing for their assistance in after surgical treatment for alveolar pyorrhea. Dent Abst 4: 22,
animal handling; Mr. G. Armstrong and DT2 T. Mikels, U S N , 1959.
for their histopathology support; the Audiovisual Departments 24. Bowen, W. H.: Dental diseases in primates. Proc R Soc
of NGDS and N M R I for illustrations; and Mrs. Nam Dayhoff, Med 62: 1295, 1969.
N M R I , and the Publications Division, NGDS, for their clerical 25. Hurt, W. C : Epithelialization of artificially induced
and editorial help with this manuscript. periodontal lesions in dogs. J Periodontol 34: 120, 1963.
26. Ramfjord, S. P.: Usefulness and limitations of animal
REFERENCES model system. J Dent Res 50: 255, 1971.
1. Ratcliff, P. A.: An analysis of repair systems in perio 27. Yukna, R. A., Bowers, G. M . , Lawrence, J. J., and
dontal therapy. Periodont Abst 14: 57, 1966. Fedi, P. F.: A clinical study of healing in humans following the
2. Stahl, S. S.: Healing of gingival tissues following various excisional new attachment procedure. J Periodontol 41: 696,
therapeutic regimens—a review of histologic studies. J Oral 1976.
Ther Pharmacology 2: 145, 1965. 28. Periodontics Syllabus, NA VMED P-5110, pp 113-115:
3. Simpson, H . E.: The reattachment of mucoperiosteal U.S. Naval Dental Corps, 1975.
flaps in surgical extraction wounds in macacus rhesus monkeys. 29. N A V M E D 6600/4 (2/71)
Aust Det J 4: 86, 1959. 30. Wingard, C. E., and Bowers, G. M . : Effects on facial
4. Persson, P. A.: The regeneration of the marginal peri bone from facial tipping of incisors in monkeys. J Periodontol
odontium after flap operation. Acta Odontol Scand 20: 43, 41: 450, 1976.
1962. 31. Caton, J. G., Crigger, M . , and Zander, H . A.: An
Volume 47
Number 12 New Attachment Procedure in Rhesus Monkey
709
animal model for evaluating periodontal procedures. IADR 36. Frank, R., Fiore-Donno, G., Cimasoni, B., and Ogilvie,
Abst No. 30, p 56, 1972. A.: Gingival reattachment after surgery in man: An electron
32 Caton, J. G., and Zander, H . A.: Primate model for microscopic study. J Periodontol 43: 597, 1972.
testing periodontal treatment procedures: I. Histologic inves 37. Glickman, I., and Smulow, J. B.: Periodontal Disease-
tigation of localized periodontal pockets produced by ortho Clinical, Radiographic and Histologic Features. Philadelphia,
dontic elastics. J Periodontol 46: 71, 1975. W. B. Saunders Company, 1974.
33. Stahl, S. S., Soberman, A., and Decesare, A.: Gingival 38. Kwapis, B. W., and Knox, J. E.: Extrustion of teeth by
healing. V. The effects of antibiotics administered during the elastics, report of two cases. J Am Dent Assoc 84: 629, 1972.
early stages of repair. J Periodontol 40: 521, 1969. 39. Morris, M . L.: The unrepositioned mucoperiosteal flap.
34. Listgarten, M . A.: Normal development, structure, Periodontics 3: 147, 1965.
physiology and repair of gingival epithelium. Melcher, A. H . , 40. Everett, F. G., Waerhaug, J., and Widman, A.: Leonard
and Zarb, B. A . (eds), Gingival Epithelium, Vol. 1. Oral Widman: Surgical treatment of pyorrhea alveolaris. J Peri
Sciences Reviews, 1972. odontol 42: 571, 1971.
35. Listgarten, M . A.: Electron microscopic study of the 41. Klavan, B.: The replaced graft. J Periodontol 41: 406,
junction between surgically denuded root surfaces and regener 1970.
ated periodontal tissues. J Periodont Res 7: 68, 1972. 42. Raust, G. T.: Mini-flaps. J Periodontol 40: 56, 1969.
Announcement
UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA SCHOOL Professor and Chairman
OF D E N T I S T R Y Department of Periodontics
The University of Michigan
The University of Southern California School of Dentistry an
nounces the following continuing education course: Sunday, January 30, 1977