Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Estimating Machinery Cost
Estimating Machinery Cost
The straight-line method is not very accurate in giving the true value of
a machine at some age short of the end of its assumed life.
In actual practice, machines depreciate much faster in the first few
years of their useful life than in the later years.
Estimating Machinery Costs
Sum-Of-The Digits Depreciation
The sum-of-the-digits depreciation method means the
sum-of-the-years digits method.
It is a much more accurate method of estimating the true
value of a machine at any age because the annual
depreciation rate decreases as the machine gets older.
The amount of the depreciation by the sum-of-the-digits
method is determined in three (3) steps, viz:
Add up the numbers representing the years covered by the
depreciation period
Divide the total depreciation by the sum of the digits of the
years for the depreciation period
Proportion the depreciation in reverse of the years over
which the depreciation occurs:
Estimating Machinery Costs
Sum-of-the Digits Depreciation (10 years life, 10 % Salvage Value)
Estimating Machinery Costs
Apply the sum-of-the-digits method to the US$40,000 swather, assuming
10% Salvage Value:
The total amount to be depreciated is:
(Total value) – (10% of total value) US$40,000 – US$4,000 =
US$36,000
The sum-of-the-digits for ten years is:
10 + 9 + 8 +7 + 6 + 5 + 4 + 3 + 2 + 1 = 55 depreciation units
Depreciation per unit = US$36,000 = US$654.545 per unit
55 units
Each year`s depreciation is calculated as follows for the first three years:
Year 1: 10 x US$654.545 = US$6,545.45
Year 2: 9 x US$654.545 = US$5,890.91
Year 3: 8 x US$654.545 = US$5,236.36
The final (tenth) year is calculated as: 1 x US$654.545 = US$654.55
Estimating Machinery Costs
Declining-Balance Depreciation
Declining-Balance Depreciation better reflects the actual
value of a machine at any age than either of the two methods
discussed above.
The value of a machine on the farm is, sometimes, referred to
as the “as is” value.
The “as is” value assumes that the machine must be sold on
the open market without a trade-in or at the farm auction.
The formulae for declining-balance depreciation are listed for
the more-mathematically inclined.
For a more practical and quicker approach, tables are used.
First, we look at the principle of declining-balance formula for
the US$40,000 swather, assuming a life span of 10 years as
above.
Estimating Machinery Costs
The formula is: With reference to the swather
RV = C x (1 - r/L)y example above and with the
where: following assumptions:
RV = Remaining Value C = US$40,000
C = Cost (initial) r = 2*(10/100) = 2*0.1 = 0.2 (20%)
r = rate of depreciation compared Therefore, r = 2
to the straight-line method L = 10 years
L = Life span in years
Y = age at which depreciation is At y = 1, the end of the first year
of ownership, the remaining value
being determined (RV) of the swather is:
And r is determined as: RV = US$40,000 x (1 - 2/10)1
r = 2*(L/100) = US$40,000 x (1 - 0.2)
When the percentage is 10%, r=1 = US$40,000 x 0.8
When it is 20%, r=2 and so on = US$32,000
Estimating Machinery Costs
Declining Balance Depreciation
Estimating Machinery Costs
At y = 2, the end of the Simply, the declining
second year of ownership, the balance method works
remaining value (RV) of the on the basis that
swather is: whatever value a
RV = US$40,000 x (1 - 2/10)2 machine has at the
= US$40,000 x (1 - 0.2)2 beginning of the year, it
will be worth a fixed
= US$40,000 x (0.8)2 percentage of that value
= US$40,000 x (0.64) one year later.
= US$25,600 In the case of the new
US$40,000 swather, its
value one year later is
80% of cost. With this
method, the value of the
machine never reaches
zero.
Estimating Machinery Costs
In the past few Average Remaining Value
years, a careful
study of the “as
is” values of
agricultural
machinery has
indicated that, on
the farm,
remaining values
more nearly fit
the declining-
balance method
than either of the
other two
methods.
Estimating Machinery Costs
In actual practice, the first year depreciation is considerably
higher, percentagewise, than the later years (see figure 6.4).
To provide a more accurate method for estimating the value
of a machine, a first year correction factor is added to the
declining-balance formula.
For all combines and tractors, including 4WD tractors and
crawlers, the remaining value (RV) formula is:
RV = List price x 0.68 x 0.94y
In this formula, the correction factor for the first year
depreciation is 0.68.
The annual depreciation factor is 0.94. The “y” exponent
indicates how many times 0.94, or the annual depreciation
factor, is multiplied by itself.
Estimating Machinery Costs
For example, a US$50,000 tractor is worth US$28,240
after three years:
RV = list price x 0.68 x 0.943 = US$50,000 x 0.68 x
0.943 = US$28,240 (verify in table 6.1, row 3 years)
For all farm machines, other than tractors, the formulae
are:
• Combines: the same formula as tractors.
• Cotton harvesters and balers: = list price x 0.64 x
0.921
• All others, RV = 0.6 x 0.9y
Remaining values are listed in table 6.1 as percentages of
list prices for all tractors and farm machinery.
Estimating Machinery Costs
Remaining Value as a Percentage of List Price
Estimating Machinery Costs
Other Fixed Costs
The other four fixed costs are:
Tax: The annual charge for taxes would be from 1% to 2% of
the value of the machine at the beginning of the year.
Shelter
Typical annual costs for providing shelter including a service or
repair shop will average 1% to 2% of the remaining value of
the machine.
Insurance
The annual charge for insurance or risk is assumed to be from
0.25 to 0.5 percent of the remaining value of the machine
Interest
Interest rates vary but will, usually, be in the range of 8% to
12% of the remaining value of the machine
Estimating Machinery Costs
Estimating Fixed Costs
Taxes, Shelter, Insurance and Interest (TSII) can be
combined in order to estimate costs.
If the interest rate is set at 9% and the others
combined at 4%, then an annual charge of 13%
of the remaining value at the beginning of the
year would be reasonable to cover fixed costs
For such a case, the first three (3) years
depreciation and TSII costs for a US$50,000
tractor are shown in table 6.2 below
Estimating Machinery Costs
Example of Total Fixed Costs
Year Remaining Depreciation TSII Costs TSII Costs +
Value at Start (US$) (US$) Depreciation
of Year (US$) (US$)
1 50,000 18,040 05,850 23,890
6 24,953
Estimating Machinery Costs
Table shows that TSII Age Tractors, Balers, Cotton All Others
costs are 13% of (Yrs) Combines (%) Harvesters (%) (%)
US$45,000 at the
beginning of the first 1 37.78 42.82 47.70
year. 2 24.96 27.59 30.06
By looking at the total 3 20.45 22.19 23,77
fixed costs (DTSII) it is 4 18.02 19.26 20.34
clear why frequent 5 16.43 17.33 18.08
trading without high 6 15.27 15.92 16.43
annual use results in 7 14.36 14.81 15.13
high per-hectare
machinery costs. 8 13.62 13.89 14.06
9 12.98 13.12 13.16
For purposes of 10 12.42 12.44 12.38
estimates, table 6.3
combines all fixed 11 11.92 11.84 11.69
costs. An interest rate 12 11.48 11.30 11.08
of 9% is used.
Table 6.3: Average annual depreciation and other
fixed costs as a percentage of original/list price
Estimating Machinery Costs
How to Reduce Fixed Costs
Have the proper Amount of Equipment
Properly matching one`s tractors and equipment is very important as
part of saving costs.
A farmer who is efficient with, say, two 125 hp tractors with an initial
cost of US$60,000 each, decides to buy an extra 75 hp tractor that
costs US$36,000 to pull some of their lighter draft equipment.
If they plan to own the tractors for eight (8) years, then, their average
annual fixed costs for eight years is 13.62% according to table 6.3.
13.62% x US$60,000 x 2 = US$16,344 per year
Adding the 75 hp tractor to the fleet would have the effect of
increasing the fixed costs as follows:
13.62 x US$36,000 = US$4,903 per year.
US$4,903 x 100% = ~30% increase
US$16,344
Estimating Machinery Costs
Certainly the added tractor would make some
of the farming operations more convenient,
but the farmer needs to be very careful about
having equipment that add to the cost of
production without a proportional increase in
production.
It is much less expensive for the farmer to use
the larger tractors for lighter loads, than for
them to purchase an extra tractor
Estimating Machinery Costs
Longer Ownership of machinery Remember, to own equipment longer,
one needs a good maintenance and
Table 6.4 below, illustrates how trading repair program.
too frequently will increase fixed costs. A saving of US$9,675 per year would
The equipment listed is a basic set for more than meet the maintenance and
producing 800 acres (328 ha) of row repair needs.
crops... (ref: table 6.3)
Machine Cost (US$) Ave.Annual Ave.Annual
The ten-year trading interval lowered the Fixed Costs Fixed Costs
annual fixed costs by (US$48,149 – Every 6 years Every 10 years
(US$) (US$)
US$38,474) = US$9,675 per year.
Tractor1 060,000 09,162 07,452
Regarding that the farm size 800 acres,
the added costs for trading every six Tractor2 060,000 09,162 07,452
years is:
Combine 120,000 18,324 14,904
US$9,675 = US$12.09 per acre
800 acres Tillage Tools 050,000 08,215 06,190
OR
Seeding 020,000 03,286 02,476
US$9,675 = US$29.50 per hectare Equipment
328 ha 48,149 38,474
Totals
Blah
Machine Hours Cost Hours Cost Hours Cost Hours Cost RF1 RF2
All Wheel 3,000 6.3% 6,000 25% 9,000 56.2% 12,000 100% 0.006944 2.0
Tractors
Self- 750 2.2% 1,500 9.3% 2,250 21.9% 3,000 40% 0.039820 2.1
Propelled
Combines
Planters, 375 4.1% 750 17.5% 1,125 41% 1,500 75% 0.320000 2.1
Drills
Moulboard 500 8.3% 1,000 28.3% 1,500 59.6% 2,000 100% 0.287300 1.8
Plows
Chisel Plows, 500 10.1% 1,000 26.2% 1,500 46.8% 2,000 70% 0.265240 1.4
Cultivators,
Disc Harrows,
Mulch Tiller
Mowers 500 14.2% 1,000 46.2% 1,500 92% 2,000 150% 0.461700 1.7
Sq. Balers, 625 6.2% 1,250 21.5% 1.875 44.7% 2,500 75% 0.144100 1.8
Large & Small
Round 375 7.4% 750 25.9% 1,125 53.6% 1,500 90% 0.434000 1.8
Balers,
Large
Self 1,000 3.1% 2,000 12.5% 3,000 28.1% 4,000 50% 0.031250 2.0
Propelled
Forage
Harvester
Self 750 3.4% 1,500 13.7% 2,250 30.9% 3,000 55% 0.061100 2.0
Propelled
Windrower
Estimating Machinery Costs
Table 6.10: Accumulated repair costs as percent
of purchase price
Example:
Determine the predicted accumulated repair
costs for a US$90,000 tractor after 4,000 hours
of use.
TAR = US$90,000 x 0.006944 x (4,000/1,000)2
TAR = US$10,000
Estimating Machinery Costs
Total Cost for Machines and Operations
This unit will provide information on how to
estimate total costs for the use of an individual
machine, and for operations involving a
combination of two or more machines. Costs for
entire machine systems can be estimated once
the procedure for estimating costs for specific
machines is mastered.
Estimating Machinery Costs
Using Machine Cost Tables
With reference to Appendix Table 1, costs are calculated for a 150 hp diesel
tractor with a list price of US$90,000. The tractor is used for 500 hours per year
for five (5) years. The engine`s fuel cost is rated as US$0.26 per litre.
In Appendix Table 1 (the table of accumulated average fixed and repair costs for
2 and 4-wheel drive tractors), check the cost figure shown opposite 500 hrs/year
under the 5-years-of-use column. This figure is US$0.346. At the top, the table
indicates that cost figures are per US$1,000 of list price (cost of new machine).
The costs included in the table are:
●Depreciation ●Taxes ●Shelter ●Insurance ●Interest & ●Repairs
Because the tractor had a new list price of US$90,000, it would have 90 cost
units of US$1.000 each.
US$90,000/US$1,000 = 90 cost units
Therefore, multiply the cost figure from the table by 90, we get:
0.346 x 90 cost units = US$31.14 per hour of use
With 5 years of use at 500 hours per year, the accumulated use of the US$90,000
tractor would be 2,500 hours.
Total expenditures for repairs, plus all fixed costs would be:
2,500 hrs x US$31.14/h = US$77,850.
Estimating Machinery Costs
Estimating Fuel/Lubricant Cost Component
For diesel engines, the average fuel consumption is 0.223 times the maximum
kW rating.
The 150 hp (i.e.111.9 kW) diesel engine tractor would use, 111.9 kw x 0.223 =
25.0 ltrs per hour.
Now, let us calculate the fuel and lubricant costs:
For fuel: 25.0 ltrs/h x US$0.264/ltr = US$6.60 per hour
Lubricants: 10% of fuel cost = 10/100 x US$6.60 = US$0.66
Therefore, the total fuel and lubricant costs amount to: US$(6.60 + 0.66) =
US$7.26 per hour.
For 2,500 hours of use, total fuel and lubricant costs come to: 2,500 hrs x
US$7.26 = US$18,150
Including fixed costs, repair costs and operating costs, the average costs for
the US$90,000, 111.9 kW tractor over a 5-year period of use would be:
Fixed costs plus repairs = US$31.14/h
Fuel plus lubricants = US$07.26/h
Total costs = US$38.40/h
Estimating Machinery Costs
Without including labour, average annual costs at 500 hours
of work per year would be:
500 hours/year x US$38.40/hour = US$19,200 per year
Remember that in subsequent years, the fixed costs dwindle
and, therefore, one expects that total running costs also go
down successively.
Also, if the machine is used longer hours annually, say 800
hrs, the per hour cost of use reduces
Going back to table 1 for this particular case, we get, 90 cost
units x US$0.233 = US$20.97/h of fixed costs plus repairs
Fuel plus lubricants rate at US$7.26/hour remains the same.
Therefore, total per hour costs become: US$(20.97 + 7.26)
= US$28.23/h
Estimating Machinery Costs
From Appendix Table 7, the average cost of
operating a US$12,000 mulch tiller after 10 years
with 100 hours of use per annum and a capacity of
2.8 ha/h is:
From the table, US$1.503 (roughly, US$1.50) per
hour per US$1,000 of cost of the tiller.
The number of US$1,000 units is:
US$12,000/US$1,000 = 12.0 units
12 units x US$1.50 = US$18.04 per hour...No
fuel plus lubricant costs
Estimating Machinery Costs
Estimating Tractor- Machine Costs
If the average capacity for a mulch tiller operation is 2.8 ha/h,
then the per ha.
Cost of mulch tilling would be:
US$56.44/h = US$20.16 per ha
2.8ha/h
Now that the cost examples for the US$90,000 tractor and the
US$12,000 mulch tiller have been computed, we can combine
the two estimations to estimate the total cost of an operation
such as mulch tilling:
Tractor costs: US$38.40 per hour
Mulch tiller costs: US$18.04 per hour
Average mulch tillage cost: US$56.44 per hour
Estimating Machinery Costs