Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Stereophile 2017 07
Stereophile 2017 07
TOTALLY PIAN
GEORIGST
TUBULAR!
WINSTOE
REINVEN N
CAREETRS HIS
LAMM’S
REFERENCE
PREAMPLIFIER
COMBINES TUBES &
TRANSISTORS
MULTICHANNEL MUSIC SERVERS
FROM FIDELIZER & BAETIS
MEGA-POWERFUL MONOBLOCK AMPLIFIERS
k JULY 2017
FROM AUDIONET & MARK LEVINSON
AFFORDABLE DIGITAL EXCELLENCE kARCAM’S IRDAC-II
THERE ARE AS MANY OPINIONS
AS THERE ARE EXPERTS
AS WE BY STEVE GUTTENBERG
T
here are no ifs, ands, or buts about it: Headphones it’s going to really shake things up. The sound quality of
sound different from speakers. For different rea- these ’phones wasn’t available at any price even a few years
sons, I like both, but all speakers come with one ago, and I haven’t seen this level of innovation and new
undeniable disadvantage: the room you play them ideas with loudspeakers in ages. Headphones are where the
in. I don’t care if you’re running pint-size Falcon Acoustics action is.
LS3/5a’s or giant Wilson Audio Alexandria XLFs—they’re So I find it more than a little strange that when it comes
at the mercy of your room’s acoustics. Losses are inevitable. to headphones, my boomer pals who are so heavily invested
Sure, some rooms are better than others, but their size, in all types of audiophilia seem oddly content with a pair
shape, and furnishings alter your speakers’ sound in ways of Sennheisers they bought when Reagan was in the White
their designers can never fully anticipate, leaving it up to House. It’s hard not to bust out laughing when these guys
you to dial in the best sound you can. With headphones, lose it over the prices of the Abyss AB-1266 ($5495) and
those variables and uncertainties are much smaller—just Focal Utopia ($4000) headphones. Do they read the same
pop on the ’phones and you’re good to go. With them magazines I do, in which reviews of $7000 phono cartridges
you’ll hear more—a lot more—of what’s really going on in are nothing special? Or reviews of the dCS Vivaldi SACD/
your music. CD transport ($41,999), or Bang & Olufsen’s BeoLab 90
One other thing: most over-ear headphones are full- speakers ($84,990/pair)? Now those are what I call crazy
range, single-driver designs that don’t suffer from the losses expensive. Add up the prices of the top headphones from
associated with speakers’ crossover networks. Take, for Abyss, AKG, Audeze, Beyerdynamic, Focal, Fostex, Grado,
example, Sony’s MDR-Z1R over-ear ’phones ($2299.99), HifiMan, Oppo, Sennheiser, Sony, and Stax, and you’ll see
whose frequency range is 4Hz–120kHz. Do you know of that all of them together sell for a fraction of the cost of
any single-driver loudspeaker that can do that? You may, Magico’s Q7 Mk.II speakers ($229,000/pair).
of course, still prefer the sound of speakers, but the best Less exalted high-end headphones and headphone amps
headphones are more truthful messengers than the best are still downright affordable by high-end standards. For
speakers. There are fewer ways for the sound to go wrong. around $2000, you can live large with a pair of Beyerdy-
Before you dash off a snarky letter to the editor, I’m not namic T1 headphones ($1099) and a fully balanced head-
suggesting that you put your speakers on the curb, just that phone amp from Schiit Audio, the Mjolnir 2 ($849).
today’s headphones are good enough that you should at One by one, audiophiles are coming around. After my
least consider including a pair in your system. It’s not an friend Bruce tried a few ’phones—Audeze’s iSines and
either/or choice—you can have both—and one thing’s for EL-8s, and AudioQuest’s NightOwls—he said, “The EL-8s
sure: you can buy any of the world’s best headphones for a are sort of like a headphone cousin of my Avalon Eidolon
tiny fraction of the cost of any speaker listed in Class A of speakers in terms of their emphasis on resolution, speed,
Stereophile’s “Recommended Components”! and transparency.” Bingo. He bought the Audeze EL-8s and
I’m not completely sure why, but it’s been a long time couldn’t be happier.
since audiophiles gave headphones a fair shake. Sure, Are you worried that, with headphones, the sound will
headphones are useful when speakers aren’t available, or be stuck inside your skull? Granted, headphones can come
when traveling, and they’re essential tools for recording and off that way, but the better open-backed headphones let
broadcast professionals—but headphones are the Rodney the soundstage bloom—it’s not inside but around your head.
Dangerfields of high-end audio: they don’t get no respect. With closed-back ’phones, you can seal out the noise of the
That wasn’t always true: Stax electrostatics were popular outside world, or play music as loud as you want at 2am
in the 1980s, the Sennheiser Orpheus HE 90 ’stats from without disturbing your family.
the mid-1990s were praised in the February 1994 issue It’s worth the effort to search out the best of these head-
of Stereophile,1 and I was a big fan of the first-generation phones and hear them for yourself. There’s more music in
’phones from Grado Labs in the late ’80s, each hand-crafted your recordings than you’ve ever heard through speakers.
by Uncle Joe Grado and his nephew John. But all of that is If I’ve made you even a little curious about the latest,
ancient history. greatest headphones, check to see what your local dealer
And the pace of change is accelerating. The new surge carries. Or get over to Axpona, CanJam, T.H.E. Show New-
in headphone tech is visible in the recent introduction of port, High End (in Munich), or the Rocky Mountain Audio
Audeze’s iSine series of planar-magnetic in-ear headphones, Fest—any show that has a tasty selection of headphones to
with prices starting at a mere $399. Their sound is more dy- audition. Try ’em—you might like ’em!
namic and spacious than most in-ears I’ve heard, including Steve Guttenberg writes The Audiophiliac blog for CNET.com.
ones that sell for upward of $2500. Then there are Shure’s
1 See www.stereophile.com/headphones/sennheiser_orpheus_he_90_head-
KSE1500 electrostatic in-ears ($2999), which John Atkin- phones/index.html.
son swooned over in the November 2016 issue2 —and from 2 See www.stereophile.com/content/shure-kse1500-electrostatic-ear-headphone-
what I know about AudioQuest’s upcoming in-ear model, system.
p.106
p.67
FEATURES p.79
47 George Winston
What do The Doors, Vince Guaraldi, and Professor
Longhair all have in common? They are all pianist George
Winston’s idols! The former New Age star talks to Robert
97 Arcam irDAC-II D/A processor
by John Atkinson
Baird about his recent health scare, the way he makes
FOLLOW-UP
music, and, of course, cats!
p.37
p.21
p.31 p.37
p.111
Good is better than best the sellers of high-end audio just sit back of how hi-fi played a role in people’s lives.
Editor: and watch the money roll in. Invariably, I am asked: What happened
As prices of audio gear soar, so do expec- Music is the aim—not possessing a to all the dealers? Why don’t today’s
tations. It is helpful to remember that room full of overpriced gear that merely audio advertisements in magazines and
the soul-stifling search for the Best is the inflates someone’s ego and makes that publications speak directly to the public
enemy of the Good. The music recorded person feel part of an exclusive club. anymore? —David Blumenstein
is burned like banknotes on such a fool’s —Cliff Millward david.blumenstein@gmail.com
quest. Good beats elusive best. Music is United Kingdom
the point. —Bruce Moss zaccypoo18@gmail.com Long live two-channel audio
Santa Fe, NM Editor:
brucemoss@earthlink.net Audiophiles are killing audiophilia As stated by Robert Schryer in the May
Editor: 2017 “As We See It,” “Audiophilia is
Music is better than piffle If video killed the radio star (see Robert dead.” But two-channel audio is alive and
Editor: Schryer’s “As We See It” in May, p.3), well. Yes, times have changed and prices
In response to those who defend spend- then audiophiles are killing audiophilia, have skyrocketed, but it’s still possible
ing vast sums on hi-fi equipment, one and have no one to blame but them- to get a system superior to anything I
wonders how music lovers enjoyed selves. The audiophile, as commonly thought possible 50 years ago, when I
recorded music back in the era of 78rpm thought of, is a dying breed. The herd got into this hobby—and for a price I can
records. Wind-up gramophones provided thins before our eyes. There are no new afford on my Social Security income.
a sound best described as “midrange,” and audiophiles, but rather new generations —Rick Zolla
yet people danced and sang along to such of recorded-music enthusiasts who want n8nkn@aol.com
records. Children learned about musical to hear the music reproduced to a higher
instruments from 78s, and in later years I quality. This relationship is not necessar- Most people are multichannelphiles
enjoyed music on a portable record player ily linear. If the solution is a great pair Editor:
equipped with an autochanger and crystal of headphones connected to a superb Instead of audiophiles, wrote Robert
pickup. I have moved on since then, but digital audio player, does that constitute Schryer in May (p.3), “Maybe it’s time
my current hi-fi is not some object of audiophilia? we began calling ourselves . . . stereophiles.”
adoration, as so many are. Its total cost Audiophilia is ever evolving—perhaps Actually, most people these days are
would not buy one of those super amps, stereophilia is the correct term, and today’s multi—5.1-, or 10.1—channelphiles.
nor a speaker which looks like a gramo- audio enthusiasts are indeed “stereo- —Kim Eccles
phone horn. But it gives me, and all who philes.” Audiophilia is, for the most part, kimeccles@comcast.net
sit and listen, great satisfaction. no more, crumbling under the weight of
I realized the obsession of continual its historic trappings. Congratulations!
upgrading years ago: the minute changes The philosophy of audio, its level of re- Editor:
heard (or imagined) by changing cables; spect, its place in the world and in homes, I’ve followed/subscribed to Stereophile
the silliness of presuming that sound has changed. The manner in which since 1994, and have probably missed no
quality could be improved by a short audio, in its heyday, was marketed and more than two issues in the ensuing 23
length of fancy mains cable after the advertised is a thing of the past. When I years. Although I also read The Abso!ute
power had traveled many miles along share digital scans of hi-fi magazines of Sound, I’ve always enjoyed the reviews, ar-
bog-standard cables; and the fallacy of the 1950s and ’60s with people, nine out ticles, etc. more at Stereophile. I remember
resting cables on little blocks of wood! of ten of them want to flip through the fondly JGH, Corey Greenberg, the Muse
There is no science behind such piffle. advertisements. They are mesmerized not 18 subwoofer, Larry Greenhill, Larry
But the world of hi-fi was taken over just by the historic prices and photo- Archibald, etc., and I hope to continue
by the asylum inmates years ago. They graphs, but by the actual language: the the journey with you as I enjoy my third
turned a healthy hobby into an obses- text and words used to describe the gear, decade as an audio enthusiast. (I would
sion where money is squandered on which painted a picture in the mind’s eye still not call myself an audiophile.)
ever-fancier gear merely to play, in many And congratulations on John Atkin-
cases, distorted pop music. LETTERS TO THE EDITOR should be sent son’s 31st anniversary as Stereophile’s editor
I cannot help but feel that high-end as faxes or e-mails only. Fax: (212) 915- in chief, on May 1. —Daniel Long
audio is immoral in a world full of 4167. E-mail: STletters@enthusiastnet- Singapore
poverty and suffering, and that people work.com. Please note: We are unable to lcheetec@yahoo.com
answer requests for information about
who buy into the High End may lack
specific products or systems. If you have
something in compassion and concern. problems with your subscription, call (800) Thank you, Daniel. What a long, strange trip
It’s not a case of envying those who spend 666-3746, or e-mail Stereophile@palm- it’s been—and continues to be. Readers can find
big sums of money to satisfy their egos. I coastd.com, or write to Stereophile, P.O. the very first “As We See It” I contributed to
fancy that many folks spend such money Box 420235, Palm Coast, FL 32142-0235. Stereophile at www.stereophile.com/
to be different; to say, “Look at me.” And asweseeit/352/index.html. —John Atkinson
Acoustic INC.
Mastered by
Ryan K. Smith
SME LIMITED
MO D EL 1 5 Precision Turntable
QUESTYLE AUDIO
QP1 & QP1 R Portable DAC
The Model 15 could be described as "the ultimate in recovery
vehicles," allowing the cartridge to retrieve the last nth of
recorded material, whether digital or analog, from the vinyl
disc, approaching the ultimate in perfection.
MUSICAL SURROUNDINGS
P HON O MENA II Phono Preamp
Available in Gold or Silver finish
SENNHEISER
HD8 0 0 S IE -8 0 0
Reference Headphones Reference In-Ear
Headphones
UPDATE
seminars, shows, and meetings should e-mail
the when, where, and who to JAtkinson@
enthusiastnetwork.com at least eight weeks
before the month of the event. The deadline for
the September 2017 issue is June 20, 2017.
PonoPlayer1 and were purchasing high- little expectation of getting the money or moderate resolution, Xstream plays
resolution music from the PonoWorld back. Record companies believe they at the highest quality your network
site were aware, the company that should charge a premium for high res condition allows at that moment and
operated the store, Omnifone, was recordings and conversely, I believe all adapts as the network conditions
acquired in 2016 by Apple, who then music should cost the same, regardless change. It’s a single high resolution
shut it down. of the technology used. As you might bit-perfect file that essentially com-
Since then, Pono had been working imagine, I found it difficult to raise presses as needed to never stop playing.
with another company to build the more money for this model: delivering Xstream is one file, streaming for all
same download store, but, in Young’s with 15,000 seamlessly changing levels
words, “the more we worked on it, “Good-sounding music of playback quality.”2
the more we realized how difficult it Young emphasized that one of his
would be to recreate what we had and is not a premium.” conditions in his negotiations with
how costly it was to run it: to deliver —Neil Young record companies was that Xstream
the Pono promise, meaning you’d nev- should not have a premium price. “I’ve
er have to buy the same album again quality music at a premium price to told the labels it’s not a good model for
if was released at a higher quality; the a limited audience that felt they were them to charge a premium for music
ability to access just high res music, and being taken advantage of with the high the way it was meant to be heard. I
not the same performances at lower costs.” firmly believe that music is in trouble
quality, and the ability to do special Young explained that Pono’s goal because you can’t hear it the way it is
sales. . . . I also realized that just bring- was to find “a way to deliver the qual- created unless you pay a premium... .
ing back the store was not enough. ity music without the expense and to Good-sounding music is not a pre-
While there was a dedicated audience, bring it to a larger audience,” and that mium. All songs should cost the same,
I could not in good conscience con- that effort led to a technology devel- regardless of digital resolution. Let
tinue to justify the higher costs. oped by Orastream, a small company the people decide what they want to
“When it comes to high res, the in Singapore. “Together we created listen to without charging them more
record industry is still broken. The Xstream,” he explained, “an adaptive for true quality. . . . If high resolution
industry was such that even when I streaming service that changes with costs more, listeners will just choose
wanted to remaster some of the great available bandwidth [that is] capable the cheaper option and never hear
performances from my artist friends of complete high-resolution playback. the quality. Record companies will
at high res, Pono had to pay thousands Unlike all other streaming services that ultimately lose more money by not
of dollars for each recording, with are limited to playing at a single low exposing the true beauty of their music
INDUSTRY UPDATE
to the masses. . . . Let listeners decide find, and the house looked like all the
on the quality they want to purchase rest on its street. But when we walked
without pricing constraints.” inside and upstairs, we found a floor
Amen to Neil’s sentiment, but as I devoted to serious hi-fi, with at least
understand the USB port on the Pono- three systems properly set up, each in
Player can’t act as an input to allow it its own room. European Sales Repre-
to play streamed audio, its owners are sentativ Frank Vermeylen had bought
left with a superb-sounding portable the house a year earlier, and took his
player that will not be able to benefit time turning it into a place suitable for
from Pono’s new initiative. demonstrating and selling components
from MSB and other high-end brands.
BELGIUM: ANTWERP The main room featured an MSB
Paul Messenger DAC and the latest version of the
Was I interested in a day trip to company’s power amp—which didn’t
Antwerp, in the north of Belgium, to run nearly as hot as its predecessor
celebrate the opening of a European while sounding even better—driving
showroom for MSB Technology, the a large pair of floorstanding Contriva
California manufacturer of digital speakers from Tidal Audio, a German
audio gear? The sheer idea of traveling brand unfamiliar to UK ears but other-
to and from Antwerp in a single day MSB’s European sales rep, Frank Vermeylen, with wise well respected throughout (West-
a Tidal Contriva speaker.
seemed so outrageous that I agreed to ern) Europe and the US,3 the entire
join MSB’s UK representative, Paul system fed by an Aurender server. The
Benge, on the trip. I’d encountered company founder Larry Gullman.) results were impressive across a wide
MSB previously, through its excellent MSB Antwerp doesn’t follow the
and costly DACs and its splendid- usual showroom pattern, but then, 1 See our review in April 2015: www.stereophile.
com/content/pono-ponoplayer-portable-music-
sounding, cylindrical class-A power high-end hi-fi is not your typical con- player.
amplifiers. Since then the company is sumer market. Rather than the usual
PHOTOS: PAUL MESSENGER
CORNER
THIS ISSUE :
Zesto’s Andros Téssera phono
preamp and Acoustic Signature’s revised
Ascona turntable and TA-9000 tonearm.
M
aybe you’ve seen the widely circulated New Yorker cartoon: Two ohms, the resistor value is closer to 15k
guys stand in front of a nicely drawn, tubed audio system, under ohms, with the cartridge “seeing” the
which are shelves full of LPs. One guy says, “The two things that transformer’s primary coil. The RIAA
really drew me to vinyl were the expense and the inconvenience.” curve, applied passively, is claimed to
If you can’t laugh at that, you’ve lost your sense of humor—even acknowledg- be accurate within ±0.5dB.
ing that, oddly, convenience is the raison d’être of some recent phono preampli- On the Andros Téssera’s neatly
fiers—including Dan D’Agostino Audio’s Momentum and the CH Precision P1, laid-out rear panel are, for the A and
both of which offer multiple, switchable, configurable inputs saved in memory. B channels, three sets each of gener-
Today’s well-heeled vinyl enthusiast might have two or more tonearms mounted ously spaced, chassis-mounted inputs:
on a single turntable—or even two turntables, each with two arms. Zesto Audio’s for MM, a stereo pair of RCA jacks;
new Andros Téssera tubed phono preamplifier takes aim at that market segment. for MC, single-ended (RCA) and
contacts. There are no solid-state thing. These relays, specified to survive as long as you don’t insert the 12AX7s
devices in the signal path, which uses “millions of throws,” should last longer in the 12AU7s’ sockets, or vice versa.
only polypropylene capacitors and 1% than you—unless you’re seriously into While it’s always good practice to
metal-film resistors throughout. throwing switches. lower the volume before throwing any
The outboard power supply, at 17" The Andros Téssera is handmade switches on a phono preamp, I never
wide by 5" high by 8" deep and 17 lbs, in the US, is burned in for 50 hours heard so much as a faint tick when
is almost as big as the Andros Téssera before shipping, and comes with a adjusting gain, loading, or even switch-
itself, and is as visually homely as the two-year limited warranty (six months ing between preamps A and B. I ran
phono preamp is appealing. According on the tubes). Counnas told me that in the Andros Téssera balanced out and
to George Counnas, designer of the the six years since he launched the PS1 single-ended in.
Andros Téssera and Zesto’s president, phono stage ($4300 when I reviewed After listening to the Zesto for a
this supply is “where all the noise it in my March 2013 column), which week as it sat on its supplied rubber
is,” and so should be placed as far as was later upgraded to the Andros 1.2 feet, I tried a set of Stillpoints’ Ultra SS
possible from the main unit, to which ($4700), he’s been thinking about ways footers. The sound definitely benefited
it’s connected with a 3m umbilical in- to improve on the basic circuit topol- from that. And while every Andros
corporating “special RFI suppression.” ogy. The result is the Andros Téssera. Téssera is broken in for 50 hours
This cord conducts only direct current, I noted that while the Andros 1.2’s at the factory, the sound definitely
and is terminated with the neatest- noise spec is –75dBu below maximum improved after another 30 or so hours
operating spring-loaded connector I’ve output, the Téssera’s is –90dBu. The of playing time.
ever used. Andros has gone from very quiet to While the usual way to start listen-
KEEPING IT PURE: The switches on extremely quiet. ing to a new audio component is to
the Andros Téssera’s front panel, all So the question is, do you need two play familiar recordings, I thought
mounted on a single circuit board, Andros 1.2s—which is essentially what it might be more interesting to start
don’t carry the audio signals. Instead, you get in the Téssera? And consider with an unfamiliar record. Les liaisons
they’re connected to another circuit this—can it be all that long before we dangereuses 1960, Thelonious Monk’s
board at the rear of the case, where all see an Andros 1.3, incorporating the previously unreleased music for Roger
signal routing and signal processing is Téssera’s circuit upgrades? On the Vadim’s film Les liaisons dangereuses (2
done by seventy 12V, reed-type electro- other hand, if you like the Téssera’s 180gm LPs, Sam 5 051083 116923),
magnetic relays. Why so many relays? flexibility and sound, and can afford had just arrived, and I was anxious to
Consider that switching from the A to $12,000 . . . why not? hear this newly discovered Monk!
the B inputs requires switching every- SETUP, USE, SOUND: Setup is simple, Would I be judging the record’s
elusivedisc.com
A Trusted Name Since 1989! For all your Analog needs!
What you can expect from us:
• Expert Cartridge Installation & Set Up.
• Excellent Customer Service.
• Speedy & Safe Delivery.
• Expert Help & Advice.
G o o o s NEW VPI “Curvy” Scout Turntable & JMW-9 Tonearm NEW Shinola Runwell Turntable & Ortofon Blue
Latest Evolution of the Multi-Award Winning Arm! The Multi-Award Winning Table Just Got Even Better! Shinola partnering with VPI for this beautiful table!
MMF 2.3, 5.3 & 7.3 Series Turntables NEW VPI Prime Walnut & JMW-10 3D Tonearm G hamNEWPh Sutherland
Eli KC
& Vibe
Ph Phono III Stage
T a s
All Music Hall Tables, Arms & Accessories Available! ALL VPI tables & combos available! All
Latest
Sutherland
Evolution
Award-Winning
of the Multi-Award
Products
Winning
Available!
Arm!
22 July 2017 Q stereophile.com
ANALOG CORNER
sound or the Téssera’s? No way of recording’s actual sound—which, while presence region (as are most Smith
knowing until I played the same very good, isn’t quite up to the quality remasterings).
album through a reference phono of the best from the Nola Penthouse, Despite the cackling and goofy stuff,
preamp. But Tom Nola had recorded at least those I’ve heard that were mas- my favorite BS&T album is still their
the session on July 27, 1959, at Nola tered when the tapes were fresher. first, Child Is Father to the Man, with Al
Penthouse Sound Studios, where many Out of the box, the Andros Téssera Kooper. I’d thought my 1A original
familiar jazz records of that era were produced luscious mids that immedi- pressing was unbeatable, but this
recorded, and I know the house sound. ately dominated the music, producing reissue kills it in every way, revealing
Had I reviewed the album’s sound in that region a glorious, golden, airy heretofore hidden musical details, and
quality based on that first hearing sound reminiscent of my old Dynaco delivering, with far greater precision
through the Andros Téssera, I’d have PAS-3X preamp (which I stupidly sold and dynamic thrust, what was always
written that Sam Jones’s bass was to buy a PAT-4), while the top was out front in the mix. At first, the still
somewhat soft and loose but well tex- simultaneously a bit soft and glassy, relatively un-broken-in Téssera’s
tured; that Charlie Rouse’s and Barney even with my Lyra Atlas SL cartridge rendering added unwanted glare to the
Wilen’s saxes sounded wet, pleasingly loaded at 50 ohms. The bottom was horns while slobbering over the bass
reedy, and luscious, but softer than somewhat flabby—bigger and longer- lines—the same colorations I’d heard
expected; that Art Taylor’s cymbals lasting than it should have been. with the Monk album.
were somewhat soft but beautifully I’d played test pressings of Bloodlines, But by the time a finished copy of
textured, and his snare also somewhat a boxed set comprising the first four the BS&T set had arrived, the Téssera
soft but harmonically expressive; and albums by Blood, Sweat & Tears (8 was fully broken in and sitting on the
that Monk’s piano had soft attacks, 45rpm LPs, Columbia/Legacy/Ana- Stillpoints. I gave Child Is Father to the
too-generous sustain, and uncharacter- logue Productions APP BSTBOX-45), Man another spin. The glare was gone,
istically long decays. The piano didn’t through both the Ypsilon VPS-100/ the bottom end had tightened consid-
sound underwater, but it was murky. MC-16L and CH Precision P1/X1 erably, and, thankfully, the addictive
After again playing side 1 through that I wrote about in the April and midrange remained.
another tubed phono stage, the far June issues, and had gotten a good han- Which was what I’d expected to
more expensive Ypsilon VPS-100 dle on the sound of Ryan K. Smith’s hear. Once the Téssera had settled in,
Silver Edition ($65,000) with MC- remastering, at Sterling Sound, from everything I played sounded “right”
16L step-up transformer ($2800), I the original tapes: ultra-transparent, within the context of how a properly
concluded that what I’ve just described superdetailed, forceful, fully extended designed and tricked-out, 12AX7-
was an exaggerated version of this on bottom, and a bit forward in the based phono preamp should sound:
NEW Audioquest Carbon NEW AudioShield NEW 93,0DJLF%ULFN UHGLUHFWVPDJQHWLFÀHOGV Hana SL Shibata Soundsmith Zephyr MIMC
Fiber Record Brush Turntable Dust Covers NEW VPI Dual Pivot Asssembly Tweak! MC Cartridge 0.5mV Star MI Cartridge 0.4mV
NEW Grado GH2 NEW NEW V S a og e Sys em Air Tight PC-7 Lyra Delos
Ltd. Ed. Headphones On-Ear Headphones Extremely accurate speed control for your VPI Turntable! MC Cartridge 0.6mV MC Cartridge 0.5mV
fully extended on top, with precise, an original (LP, RCA Living Stereo shares with tubed phono preamps
finely focused transients and an abun- LSC-2313) and a reissue (200gm LP, in general, though whether or not it
dance of air; rich, even voluptuous Analogue Productions AAPC 2313). will be a problem for you will depend
mids; and a generous, fully expressed Instead of obscuring the differences on the extension and quality of your
bottom end that fit well with the between them under a blanket of tube speakers’ bass, and the kind of music
mids, but was hardly the last word in warmth, the Téssera made them clear. you listen to. Acoustic music, particu-
terms of grip, authority, and punch— On the RCA, engineered by Ken- larly jazz and classical, thrived in the
although, overall, dynamics were very neth Wilkinson at Kingsway Hall and Andros Téssera’s hands; hard rock did
good, helped by the low noise floor. originally recorded for UK Decca, the somewhat less well. As with any audio
In short, the Andros Téssera traded strings are to melt from; on the reis- component, your reaction to it will
bottom-end authority and grippy bass sue, they’re somewhat drier and less depend on what you’re willing to give
for the fully developed textures and effusive, though more detailed. The up. There are always tradeoffs.
sonorous midrange that even the best Téssera let me hear those differences, That said, I stand by what I wrote
solid-state designs somewhat lose but compared to the Ypsilon or the about Zesto Audio’s Andros PS1—and,
track of. CH Precision, it also exacerbated the for its overall finesse and host of attrac-
I then compared two pressings of recording’s problematic bass. tive sonic qualities, what I can now say
Venice, with Georg Solti conducting The Andros Téssera’s less than fully about the Andros Téssera: it’s “among
the Orchestra of the Royal Opera controlled, somewhat larger-than-life the more enjoyable and satisfying
House Convent Garden in instrumen- bottom end was its only less-than- phono preamplifiers I’ve auditioned at
tal music from various Italian operas: stellar attribute. This is something it any price.”
ACOUSTIC SIGNATURE’S REVISED tonearm, I felt that one costing $17,995 able, and significant. The original
ASCONA MK.2 TURNTABLE AND should provide something better. The Ascona Mk.2 sounded overdamped—
TA-9000 TONEARM new TA-9000 features an ingenious while pleasing in the midrange, it
Recently, on AnalogPlanet, I wrote gear system that raises and lowers the lacked drive, and music sounded
about Shinola’s Runwell turntable.1 pillar, which, once properly set, can trapped inside the turntable. Bass, even
The review was mostly positive, but I then be securely clamped in place. with the Swedish Analog Technologies
thought the Runwell had some seri- With a low-compliance cartridge tonearm, was less than fully expressed.
ous problems that needed addressing. mounted in the original arm, I couldn’t The Ray Brown Trio’s Soular Energy (2
Instead of being angry at getting a less- measure its horizontal and vertical 45rpm LPs, Concord Jazz/Analogue
than-glowing review, Shinola thanked resonant frequencies, which suggested Productions APJ-268-45) exposed
me for pointing out the problems, so that those resonances occurred at the original Ascona Mk.2’s stifling
that they could be fixed. frequencies outside the test-band range of instrumental decays, which were
Likewise, rather than getting hot of the Hi-Fi News & Record Review Test unnaturally short. This made Gene
under the collar, Acoustic Signature’s Record (LP, Hi-Fi News HFN 001)— Harris’s piano sound tinkly; on leaving
Gunther Frohnhöfer noted what I’d surprising, given the arm’s stated ef- the instrument, bass notes seemed to
written in my December 2016 column fective mass. This time, the resonances immediately dry up.
about his Ascona Mk.2 turntable were visibly and audibly within the Frohnhöfer redesigned the interface
and TA-9000 tonearm, and set about ideal window of 8–12Hz. between the upper and lower chassis,
improving both. He then asked me to Frohnhöfer has made the biggest replacing the top’s three domed brass
give them another listen, and I happily improvements in the Ascona Mk.2 1 See www.analogplanet.com/content/
accepted. turntable, and they’re audible, measur- shinolas-plugplay-runwell-turntable.
The original TA-9000 tonearm was
surprisingly lively. A light tap on its ar-
mtube with the volume at a moderate
level produced a loud, seemingly un-
damped sound through the speakers.
In the update, the tonearm’s internal
structure has been redesigned. Tapping
on it with the volume up now pro-
duced a barely audible, well-damped
tink. The bearing housing now includes
a binding bolt that greatly increases
the housing’s mechanical rigidity, and
a new titanium headshell replaces the
original one of aluminum.
The original TA-9000 lacked conve-
nient and easily repeatable settings of
vertical tracking angle (VTA) and stylus
rake angle (SRA). If you loosened the
grub screw holding the pillar in place,
the arm would simply drop. While
that might be okay in a budget-priced
greater drive,
and now seems
unshackled from
the turntable it-
self. Image three-
dimensionality is
greatly improved.
Most critically, I
feet with a new magnetic-repulsion think, the improved Ascona Mk.2 pro-
system he claims fully isolates the duces far longer decays and “blacker”
upper and lower chassis from each backgrounds. The result is a far more
other. “Floating” the upper chassis, natural, more believable reproduction
Frohnhöfer says, produces greater of the music.
dynamics and “speed.” Although these upgrades represent
He also replaced the single belt that considerable costs in parts and labor,
looped around all three motor pulleys owners of the original Ascona Mk.2
with a three-belt configuration that in- turntable and TA-9000 tonearm are
creases the area of each belt that comes being offered them for free. That’s
in contact with the subplatter. The commendable on Acoustic Signature’s
belts are of differing Shore hardnesses part, but it’s only the right thing to do.
(something I first saw in the Döhmann I’m told that some customers—includ-
Helix 1 turntable), which Frohnhöfer ing one who owns two Ascona Mk.2s—
says minimizes, or better distrib- have already had their ’tables and
utes among the belts, the “beating” arms upgraded, and that so far, all are
produced by friction and belt tension. thrilled with the improved sound.
The new arrangement loops one belt As am I. Q
completely around the subplatter and Michael Fremer (fremer@analogplan-
around one pulley, in the standard belt- et.com) is the editor of AnalogPlanet.com,
pulley arrangement; the other two belts a Stereophile website devoted to all things
loop around all three pulleys, as before. analogical.
The result of that change was
greater consistency of speed, as
CONTACTS
I measured using Dr. Feickert
Analogue’s PlatterSpeed app. The Zesto Audio
relative maximum deviation of the 3138 Calle Estepa
raw frequency (fig.1) went from Thousand Oaks, CA 91360
–0.37%/+0.61% to –0.36%/+0.27%. Tel: (610) 853-9171
The absolute maximum deviation Web: www.zestoaudio.com
went from –11.6Hz/+19.1Hz to
–11.3Hz/+8.5Hz. The lowpass-filtered Acoustic Signature, AS-Distribution
results (fig.2) were equally good: the GmbH
relative max deviation went from Ulmer Strasse 123
–0.03%/+0.03% to – 0.02%/+0.01%, D-73037 Göppingen
the absolute max deviation from Germany
–1.1Hz/+0.9Hz to –0.06Hz/+0.4Hz. Tel: (49) (0)7161-3898135
A major improvement! Fax: (49) (0)7161-3898137
Most important, the sound of the Web: www.acoustic-signature.com
upgraded Ascona Mk.2 was far better US distributor: Fidelis Music Systems
than the one I reviewed last December. 460 Amherst Street (Route 101A)
I have my original 24/96 needle drops Nashua, NH 03063
and my new ones demonstrate the Tel: (603) 880-4434
improved sound. The bass is now far Fax: (603) 880-4433
more substantial and viscerally satisfy- Web: www.fidelisav.com
ing, yet well controlled. The sound has
Optimized Dual-Chamber
Upper Bass/Midrange Enclosure
with Angled Rear and Side Walls
Open-Cell Polyurethane
Foam Damping Pads
Linear-Phase Balanced
Crossover Network w/ Film
Capacitors and Bridging Cap
Four Inertially-Balanced
10-1/4˝ x 9-1/2˝ Quadratic
Planar Infrasonic Radiators
Two on Each Side of Cabinet
Triton Reference
$4249 ea.
“ oldenEar’s New Triton Reference Redefines
Ultra High-End Performance and Value! ”
“The Triton Reference presents a serious challenge to speakers in the
multi- $10,000 range. Sandy has done it again!” - Robert Deutsch, Stereophile
“ Hearing my reference tracks on those ( $85,000) bass/midrange drivers, a unique proprietary mix of long-fiber lamb’s
wool and Dacron for more effective internal damping, intensive work
über-expensive speakers, I was surprised at how with a high-resolution accelerometer to determine the most effective
well the Reference compared.” – Al Griffin, Sound & Vision implementation of complex internal bracing, a 3/32˝-thick steel plate
built into the medite base to further stiffen it for increased stability,
GoldenEar’s Triton One is one of the best selling high-end new stainless steel floor spikes and cups, all of which results in higher
loudspeakers ever, consistently thrilling listeners and reviewers alike resolution of subtle details … and the list goes on and on.
and winning an enviable and unmatched collection of the industry’s
most prestigious awards, including “Loudspeaker-of-the-Year” and “ Undeniably stellar … Yes, it does deliver the
“Product-of-the-Year” from key publications all around the world.
sort of performance previously delivered only by
Clearly, we knew that the One would be a very hard act to follow. cost-no-object speakers.” – Dennis Burger, Home Theater Review
There was a spirited discussion within our product development
group about an all-out assault on the ultimate, cost-no-object, Visually, the Reference offers a strikingly beautiful upgrade to the
state-of-the-art, to produce a six-figure loudspeaker to do battle classic Triton styling, with a gorgeous hand-rubbed piano gloss-black
with the most esoteric and expensive loudspeakers on the planet. lacquer finished one-piece monocoque cabinet. Sleek, statuesque
However, after much soul-searching, rational minds won out, and the and refined, the Reference is simply an elegantly gorgeous statement
decision was made to create a new GoldenEar flagship, positioned piece that will excite listeners with its dynamic visual presence, as
above the Triton One (of course still current and available), that well as its extraordinary sonic performance.
would joust with the best, but still stick to our trademarked slogan,
“We Make High-End Affordable.” We are pleased and proud to Sonically, the Reference has been engineered to perform with a
introduce the new Triton Reference. The Reference has begun dramatic and authoritative voice, comparable to speakers that sell
gathering its own collection of honors, winning the prestigious and for ten and more times its surprisingly affordable price. T Refs
coveted CES Innovations Design and Engineering Award, Digital completely disappear, with superb three-dimensional imaging that
Trends Best Home Audio Tech at CES, HD GURU Best High will open up your room, stretching from wall to wall and beyond,
Fidelity Loudspeaker at CES and What HiFi Stars of CES! and depth that makes the wall behind them seem to vanish. The
astonishing bass is rock-solid, with low-frequency performance
A grand slam … all 4 Absolute Sound writers that is tight, quick, highly impactful and musical with extension
flat to 20Hz and below. Another GoldenEar signature is a silky
at CES 2017 honored Triton Reference as their smooth high end that extends to 35 kHz with a lifelike sheen but
“Best Sound (for the money)”! no trace of fatiguing hardness, sibilance or stridency so common
with lesser tweeters. Tremendous time and energy has been put
The Triton Reference is an evolution of everything that we have into the voicing of the speaker and the seamless blending of the
achieved with the Triton One, but taken to a stunning new level of drivers, for unmatched musicality with all types of music, and home
sonic performance and sophisticated visual design. All the com- theater perfection. Rarely do speakers excel at both, but with their
ponents in the T Ref: including larger, more powerful, active sub- world-class neutrality, the Reference absolutely does. A special
bass drivers with huge “Focused Field” magnet structures, upper- bonus is the Reference’s extremely high 93.25 dB sensitivity, which
bass/midrange drivers with “Focused Field” magnet structures, gives them tremendous dynamic range and allows use with almost
and High-Velocity Folded Ribbon tweeter with 50% more rare any high-quality amplifier. You must experience T Ref for yourself !
earth neodymium magnet material, are brand new, and have been
specifically developed for use in the Reference. The powerful 1800
watt subwoofer amplifier, with level control to fine tune the bass to
your room, and 56-bit DSP control unit are a significant evolution
of those in the Triton One and our SuperSubs.
S
ometimes I feign interest in liv-
ing in the Soviet Union of the
1950s and ’60s. This happens
mostly when I’m shopping for
toothpaste at my local supermarket,
where the toothpaste aisle is as long as
a football field. “I don’t want so many
choices,” I say in my Abe Simpson
voice, “because all these choices are
stupid. I wish I lived in the USSR:
Shopping for toothpaste wouldn’t take
so long.” But I’m only kidding.
Now I see dozens of high-end
audio manufacturers popping up every
year, with new turntable companies
leading the charge. Virtually all of
them offer at least a half-dozen dif-
ferent turntables, and sometimes the
various models in a given company’s
line represent a variety of different
design philosophies: You want high-
mass, we got high-mass. You want low-mass,
we got low-mass. Whatever you want, we
Above: The Soulines Kubrick DCX, seen
got it. Those companies act as if they’re without its platter (but with its extra
in the toothpaste business: They offer armboards). Left: The same turntable,
a bazillion different choices, just so with platter and dustcover.
they can occupy more shelf space or
catalog pages than their competitors— Soulines’ US distributor—offset
and their competitors will always be whatever doubts I might have
more than happy to up the game and had owing to the Soulines’ lacks
demand even more space on those of those design elements I’ve
shelves and pages. come to favor: heavy platters,
So I was cheered when, at the 2015 idler-wheel drive, and, above all,
New York Audio Show, in suburban high-torque motors. I wondered:
Rye Brook, New York, I first encountered the Serbian might one of these turntables nonetheless shine in my
turntable manufacturer Soulines. All five of their mod- system? Is there life beyond my own hi-fi hobbyhorses? I
els featured acrylic platters, belt-driven by DC motors of decided to find out—and, a year and a half later, I borrowed
moderately low torque. (I define moderately low torque as just a review sample of Soulines’ top-of-the-line turntable, the
enough to start the platter spinning without assistance, but Kubrick DCX ($4000 without tonearm).
low enough that the platter or motor can be easily stopped Its name a nod to the space station in the Stanley Kubrick
by hand.) Each model was no larger than necessary to ac- film 2001: A Space Odyssey, the Kubrick DCX lacks a plinth
commodate a 12" platter and a 9" tonearm. The plinths or in the usual sense, and is supported instead by a skeletal
chassis of all were on the low-mass side of average—though aluminum chassis in which three elongated pods of unequal
apparently not as low as, say, the plinth of a Rega Planar 3. length extend from a central point that also serves as a base
There appeared to be a point of view at work here, and you for the platter bearing. Given the pods’ unusual shape, ac-
know how I love those. curately measuring each from the chassis center out to the
The icing on the cake was that all five Soulines models center of its supporting foot wasn’t possible, but I estimated
came with a cleverly designed, minimalist dustcover, and 150mm for the rearmost pod, 200mm for the left-front
each turntable was fancifully named for a famous individual: pod, and 250mm for the right-front pod; interestingly, the
two composers, one novelist, one film director, and one supporting feet at the ends of those pods, also machined
Greek god—respectively, Elgar, Satie, Dostoyevsky, Kubrick, from aluminum, are also differently sized, with diameters of
and Hermes. These elements, and the fine sound produced 40mm for the rear foot, 70mm for the left-front foot, and
at NYAS 2015 by Soulines-fronted systems—this was in 60mm for the right-front foot. (On their website, Soulines
the suite sponsored by retailer Adirondack Audio & Video, claims for the Kubrick’s design an adherence to the Golden
Ratio/Fibonacci sequence, but without pleasantly louder and more forward Expectations confounded
going into detail; while noting my lack with the white belt, but I may have The first thing that impressed me
of mathematics training or any intui- imagined that. about the Soulines Kubrick DCX was
tive sense of spatial relationships, I just Another aluminum pod of sorts is its very well-designed and well-made
don’t see it.) The height of each foot is fastened to the underside of the main packing. The sturdy white carton with
adjustable, and all have rounded, soft- chassis with 32 stainless-steel bolts; this its multilayer, compartmentalized foam
polymer tips. extends into a vaguely kidney-shaped inserts reminded me of the packing for
The platter bearing is an inverted substructure built up of multiple layers the Linn LP12, Roksan Xerxes, and
type: a stainless-steel axle is held of machined aluminum, in which are other products from long-established
stationary within a round brass plate mounted the Kubrick’s DC motor and companies—and while many good
that’s rigidly affixed to the center of drive circuitry. On the kidneypod’s up- products have reached me, intact, in
the chassis; a steel ball sits in a recess per surface are an on/off toggle switch, far less sophisticated boxes, I’m always
atop that axle, on which rides a very another toggle for selecting between impressed when a manufacturer invests
hefty and obviously well-machined 331⁄3 and 45rpm, and two tiny, recessed greater-than-average amounts of mon-
brass outer hub with a diameter of trim pots for fine-tuning those speeds ey and effort in getting their designs to
45mm and a bore just large enough with the aid of a similarly tiny screw- their dealers and customers.
to accept the whole of the bearing driver (not included). Setup was a breeze: The main
shaft, with freedom of rotation but A separate aluminum tonearm- chassis, support feet, motor pod, and
zero apparent play. A small amount support structure, also kidney shaped, tonearm pod are preassembled, and
of 30-weight synthetic oil is used attaches to the main chassis from the Rega armboard—which can be
between the shaft and the hub. The above but is compliantly mounted, said used with either old-style single-nut
40mm-thick acrylic platter is ma- compliance provided by cork washers RB250s and RB300s or newer three-
chined with a bore that snugly fits atop and grommets of various diameter. To bolt Rega arms—was already in place.
the brass bearing hub, which is also fit- its outer end is bolted a round tonearm My chores were limited to fitting the
ted with a record spindle. The platter, board, machined with an opening platter atop the pre-assembled, pre-
whose edge is ungrooved, is driven by for the arm of choice. Three boards oiled bearing, fitting the drive belt, in-
a polymer belt of round cross-section; are supplied with the Kubrick: one stalling the tonearm on the armboard,
supplied with the Kubrick are two for Linn/Jelco-style mounts, one for and installing and aligning my Denon
belts, one black, one white, appar- SME-style mounts, and one for Rega DL-103 cartridge. For that last chore,
ently made of two different materi- tonearms—which is the one I used, the Soulines Kubrick DCX comes
als. I thought the turntable sounded with my own Rega RB300. with a laminated alignment tem-
800-449-8333 | MUSICDIRECT.COM
LISTENING
plate with calibrations for the three in size down to that of dust-mite feces Kubrick-based record player also
most popular geometries: Baerwald, is always a good thing. focused more on the sound of the
Stevenson, and Löfgren. Normally, That brought me, in short order, recording space than did my Garrard
my preference is for the Baerwald to the third thing that impressed me rig: reverb, like scale, was far more
variation devised by Keith Howard,1 about the Soulines Kubrick DCX: generous. Yet this did not come at the
but for the sake of ease I sometimes When I lowered the stylus of my expense of any of the performance
opt for traditional Baerwald with my Denon DL-103 to the lead-in groove characteristics nearest and dearest to
Rega arm, whatever the turntable. of the first record I tried—Mendels- me. Musical momentum and flow
When the Kubrick arrived, I removed sohn’s Octet for Strings, performed were superb—and, especially in the
the RB300 from my LP12, cartridge by the Academy of St Martin-in-the- final movement of Boccherini’s Cello
intact—and was happily surprised to Fields Chamber Ensemble (LP, Argo Quintet in C, Op.37 No.7, also in-
see that the cartridge alignment was ZRG 569)—I was shocked by how cluded on this LP, the sense of bounce
still correct after I’d installed the arm big the ensemble sounded. I’d been in bowed note attacks was delight-
on the Soulines. I took this as confir- listening to that record a lot in the fully real. Overall tonal balance was
mation that its armboard was correctly days leading up to this review, and the very slightly dark, yet with no lack of
machined. difference I heard compared to my sparkle—and surface noise was never
The very last chore was to fit the Garrard 301–based player—which itself brought to the fore.
platter with the supplied cork platter has a typically large sense of scale—was As I said: I was impressed!
mat, which brings me to the second unmistakable. In previous columns and I moved on to a new LP acquisition:
thing that impressed me about the reviews I’ve wondered about which the Incredible String Band’s wonder-
Kubrick: Its platter bearing and plat- design aspects of playback gear might ful Liquid Acrobat as Regards the Air
ter are so beautifully machined that, contribute to generous scale—and (LP, Island ILPS 9172). The first time
looking at the platter from the side, I I’ve mused that, in loudspeakers in I heard this record was in March, at
couldn’t tell when it was spinning. I particular, one might consider that the Montreal Audio Fest, in the room
could detect no platter wobble—zero. quality an additive distortion, owing sponsored by Toronto dealer Sonic
To put into proper context this often to unintended sound reflections from Artistry. It was also the first time I’d
underemphasized aspect of turntable physically large cabinets. I still haven’t heard the Döhmann Helix 1 turntable
construction: Lack of unwanted move- got the slightest idea what’s responsible
ment in a device whose sole job is to for this effect, but I like it. 1 See Keith Howard’s “Arc Angles: Optimizing
Tonearm Geometry,” in the March 2010 issue: www.
measure, at correct and steady speed, Listening closely to that Mendels- stereophile.com/reference/arc_angles_optimiz-
bumps in the record groove that range sohn recording, I heard that the ing_tonearm_geometry/index.html.
D9 45 YEARS IN
THE MAKING
D9 D7
Forty-five years ago, Spendor developed the first As a result, the D7 became the most critically acclaimed
loudspeaker with real transparency, articulation and Spendor ever, earning Stereophile’s coveted Class A
natural sound specifically for BBC engineers who were recommendation - a remarkable accomplishment for a
mixing orchestras for live radio playback and needed $6,000 loudspeaker.
to hear exactly what each musician was playing.
Today, the new D9 takes the D7’s brilliance a step
Over time and through their exhaustive R&D efforts, further. An elegant, modern, 3-way loudspeaker, the
Spendor engineers achieved a series of technical D9 delivers music with exceptional resolution and a
breakthroughs and the company went on to become vibrant realism with any genre. Easy to drive and highly
one of England’s leading loudspeaker manufacturers. efficient, the D9 is also remarkably flexible and can be
Spendor continually developed landmark loudspeakers, placed in any living environment. This is a speaker
always remaining true to the Spendor sound but also 45 years in the making. This is the Spendor D9.
consistently improving transparency and thus creating
“better” loudspeakers. Visit www.bluebirdmusic.com to learn more
about Spendor or find a dealer near you.
Three years ago, Spendor introduced the D7
which delivered an articulate, coherent and natural
presentation, with a level of transparency never
before heard in a conventional dynamic loudspeaker.
DISTRI BUTED I N NORTH AM E RIC A BY BLUEB I RD MUSIC LIM ITED • WWW.BLUEB I RDMUSIC.COM • TE L: 416.638.8207
LISTENING
THE ROUND
THIS ISSUE : Computer-based multichannel music
playback becomes easier with new hardware and
software from Fidelizer, Baetis, exaSound, and Roon.
I
t’s been going on for a while now: Despite support for multichannel in exaSound e28/e38 ($3849; see p.39),
audio/video receivers and A/V processors priced from as little as $200 to and the miniDSP uDAC-8 ($275). My
$30,000, there are still very few offerings that cater to the music listener. preference was to use the exaSound, as
They may offer stereo-only streaming features through their USB or it supports DSD as well as PCM, but
Ethernet inputs, but these inputs don’t see your multichannel files. To handle there was an incompatibility between
such files, they would require you to add a music server with HDMI output. exaSound’s ASIO driver and JPlay that
However, I know of no turnkey music servers that will output multichannel I couldn’t resolve during this review
audio via HDMI. Sure, servers based on PCs and Macs will output lossless, period. Keetakawee Punpeng sug-
high-resolution multichannel via HDMI, and for years I’ve been running a Mac gested a workaround using VB-Audio’s
mini/Windows/JRiver Media Center server into my Marantz AV8802a A/V ASIO-Bridge Virtual Cable software,
processor. The playback of multichannel, music-only recordings could be so but that wasn’t compatible with DSD,
much more popular if compatible HDMI output were as common as USB or and was a little fragile with hi-rez
Ethernet, and all were included in a reasonably priced package. multichannel, at least in my hands.
Then, on the Web, I stumbled
on the Nimitra computer-audio
server from Fidelizer, a Thailand-based
company whose eponymous software
package aims to optimize Windows
as a music-playback platform. My
first, immediate e-mail to Fidelizer
included my standard query: Will this
thing do hi-rez multichannel? To my
surprise, the lightning-fast response of
proprietor Keetakawee Punpeng was
a definite “Yes.” Still, I was doubtful.
Similarly constructed servers—the
Nimitra is a fanless implementation
with an Intel Celeron J1900 2GHz
Celeron processor, 4G RAM, and
an mPCIe SSD for OS and stor-
age—usually get indigestion when less,” controlled Smaller than you’d The combination of
fed a rich diet of multichannel files. by an app on think: A Fidelizer
Punpeng assured me that by remov- a Windows or Nimitra sits atop a Nimitra and uDAC-8 was
very red platform.
ing all non-audio functions from the Mac computer absolutely delightful.
Windows 10 installation and by using or an iOS or
a special version of Fidelizer software Android mobile device. It’s meant to Knowing that the Nimitra could
with optimizations beyond that of the get input via LAN or WiFi, but it also handle DSD—it did so with the Mytek,
popular Fidelizer Pro version, he has has multiple USB inputs and outputs albeit in stereo—I opted for miniDSP’s
greatly reduced the processing time as well as VGA and HDMI outputs. PCM-only uDAC-8.
and improved audio performance. The Setup was almost trivial. Connect the The combination of Nimitra and
Nimitra also includes dBPoweramp’s source (via USB, LAN, or WiFi), then uDAC-8 was absolutely delightful.
Asset UPnP file access and the JPlay the output (same options), and boot up Old standbys such as Willie Nelson’s
app for streaming output. the Nimitra. In about 30 seconds, using Night and Day sprang from the speakers
The Nimitra ($1395) is packaged in Linn’s Kazoo UPnP control app on my with all the detail and zest expected
a conservatively distinctive black case iPad, the Nimitra-based system located from the six-channel, 24-bit/96kHz
measuring 8.9" wide by 1.7" high by the music files on my NAS. I took the files I’d ripped from the DVD-A
7.9" deep and weighing 4 lbs, with only quick route of two-channel output, us- (Surrounded-By Entertainment SBE-
a single blue LED on its front panel ing a stereo Mytek Brooklyn DAC via 1001-9), and Beethoven’s Symphony
to tell you it’s awake. The standard its ASIO USB driver, and was playing 5, in a triumphant recording from
power supply is a 12V, 5A brick, but tunes in minutes. Manfred Honeck and the Pittsburgh
my review sample came with a large, But stereo is easy. Multichannel is Symphony (SACD/CD, Reference
low-noise, regulated supply called the what we’re here for. There are only Fresh! FR-718), was as dynamic and
Fidelizer Nikola (a $495 option). The three multichannel DACs on the mar- colorful as ever. However, I had fewer
Nimitra is designed to operate “head- ket today, and I have two of them: the than 20 multichannel PCM recordings
on my Connecticut server at the time, Dirac Live room equalization. the Nimitra via the Oppo consistently
and this delightfully easy-peasy setup In terms of sound quality through brought me the best sound, though I
has no way to transcode DSD to PCM. the DAC, the Nimitra was easily the can’t fathom why that should be.
The answer, and my musical libera- equal of the Mac mini–based server it Did the Fidelizer Nimitra have any
tion, was to switch to music software replaced, and I felt no urge to switch limitations? Although it will support
that is not only DSD-capable but back—but I also wanted to use the playback and transcoding of multi-
more powerful. Foobar is built into the Nimitra’s HDMI and Ethernet outputs. channel DSD256 and DXD files, it
Nimitra, and while it did the job just The Marantz AV8802a’s Ethernet coughed when I installed Dirac Live
fine, I also preferred my two other op- input is limited to stereo—a common in the signal path. Two solutions are
tions. I installed JRiver Media Center bottleneck—and unfortunately, in the to use Dirac Live’s plug-in version,
on the Nimitra, and it ran as well as on effort to slim-down all the non-audio Studio VST (now in beta testing), or
my other Windows 10 PCs. Consider- functions, the Nimitra is shipped with to use Roon’s DSP engine to drive the
ing the Nimitra’s limited RAM and its HDMI audio output defeated. I Nimitra as an output device.
storage, I was surprised to find that it complained to Punpeng and he sent I tried the Nimitra with its stock
handled JRiver with aplomb, loading simple instructions to activate the power supply and its higher-quality
my library quickly and connecting to Nimitra’s HDMI audio output. After optional supply, but heard no differ-
the uDAC-8. just one change in the BIOS setup, the ences. It was dead quiet with the stock
I also installed the new multichan- Nimitra played multichannel signals of PS, so I’d consider the optional PS only
nel-ready Roon 1.3 on my desktop resolutions up to 24/192 PCM through if my AC were suspect.
PC; it found the Nimitra on the LAN, the Marantz via HDMI, just as it Clearly, the Fidelizer Nimitra can
confirmed that it was connected to the should with any multichannel AVR or do the job of playing high-resolution,
uDAC-8, and played through. JRiver, processor. I strongly urge Punpeng to multichannel music-only signals won-
foobar, and Roon can all be controlled activate HDMI audio by default so that derfully, and it comes with all the apps
with an iPad, but I’m an incorrigible all AVR users can enjoy high-resolution you’ll need for the job. Finally, a great-
mouse-and-keyboard guy. In addition, multichannel streaming with the equip- sounding and affordable multichannel
all three give you the option of trans- ment they already own. server that works with USB or with
coding DSD to 24/176.4 PCM on the In addition, DSD output via Ether- HDMI. Hooray!
fly—using the uDAC-8, I could enjoy net to my Oppo BDP-103 universal
my entire library. Even when using a Blu-ray player, the Oppo feeding the EXASOUND E38 EIGHT-CHANNEL DAC
DSD-capable DAC, I usually convert Marantz either via HDMI or as analog, The e38 ($3849) is the third generation
DSD to PCM—it allows me to use was a revelation. Extended listening to of exaSound Audio Design’s multi-
MUSIC IN THE ROUND
Reflections (BD, 2L 2L-125-SABD). Because the e38’s competitors DSD512 or higher, but as yet there is
Furthermore, when I compared the in the consumer market for multi- no source material for those resolu-
sound of this track played through the channel DACs are more limited in tions, and in my opinion, upsampling
e38 with Dirac Live EQ to the MQA- their capabilities (miniDSP), more to them isn’t worth the effort. The
decoded version via the Mac-Mytek expensive (NADAC+), or more exaSound e38 is not so much revolu-
stack, I found little to choose between cumbersome (eg, a stack of three tionary—it doesn’t need to be—as it is
them. Both were outstanding at re- Mytek DACs), for me, the exaSound an expression of the applicable state-
creating the experience of being at the really has no competition. Sure, some of-the-art and a valid and valuable
performance. will cavil at the lack of support for enhancement of my favorite DAC.
PURE TRIPLE X
ADRENALIN
Delivers a wide soundstage
and information. No loss of fine
details. Perfect!
Stereoplay, Germany
WOW XL
“my current in-house referen-
ces for quality phono playback:
Acoustic Signature‘s WOW XL ”
WOW XXL Stereophile 2015
The new RH-5 balanced tube headphone amplifier from Rogue Audio
3.5 WPC • 3 and 4 pin XLR • (2) 1/4” jacks • remote • optional phono • Pure Rogue …only $ 2,495
NEW AGE.
huge talent, called his music “Heavy
Mental.” In its heyday, New Age sold
a lot of records, some of them well
recorded and aimed at the audiophile
market. The Wikipedia entry for New
Age may have caught the essence of
HAVING SURVIVED Most of it was acoustic. While there
New Age. the music best: “intended to promote
CANCER AND were vocals here and there, much of it serenity.”
featured instrumentalists playing solo For a couple of years in the
NEW AGE, THE or in groups. Some of it was meant to early 1980s, no one was bigger in
SOLO PIANIST alleviate stress. Some of it was margin- the touchy-feely, sometimes sleepy,
CLIMBS ABOARD ally connected to a similarly named sometimes downright boring musical
HIS CAROUSEL movement in spirituality. Environmen- world of New Age than pianist George
talism and respect for nature were con- Winston. The eastern Montana
by ROBERT BAIRD stant themes. Some New Age artists native’s string of hit albums in that de-
created moody, ambient sounds that cade—Autumn (1980), Winter into Spring
were intended as background music, to (1982), and December (1982)—all ranked
promote healing and relaxation. high on the New Age charts, and even
As the genre grew, some might say climbed into the top 20 of the Bill-
by attracting marginally talented musi- board U.S. Jazz charts. Depending on
cians who were searching for musical who’s doing the judging, each is filled
direction, record labels specializing with pleasantly meandering solo-piano
©2010 JOE DEL TUFO, WWW.JOEDELTUFO.COM
in New Age, such as Windham Hill, explorations that Winston has always
Narada, and Private Music, appeared referred to as “folk piano.”
on the scene and made stars of such “First, they called it classical, but I’ve
diverse musical talents as harpist An- never played any classical, I can’t be clas-
dreas Vollenweider, native American sical,” Winston told me over the phone
flutist R. Carlos Nakai, saxophonist from California. “Then they called it
Paul Winter, keyboardist Kitaro, and New Age. I kept saying, ‘folk piano
guitarist Michael Hedges. Hedges, a with a lot of New Orleans influence
From those he chose 15 for his new Of the 20 carousels Winston com- software for editing and storage.
album, Spring Carousel: A Cancer Research posed at City of Hope, half made it “Recording is very important to
Benefit. He plans to donate the pro- onto the record. Of the six Ms. Myster- George,” Johnston explained in a
ceeds from sales of the album to the ies, he selected three for the album; of recent interview. “He lives with and
hospital campus that saved his life. ten bouquets, two. “At first I thought develops the songs and concepts over
“I was just practicing, and a bunch about a double CD, one called Carousel time. This occurs before he comes
of songs just kind of happened. And and one called Spring. But I realized it into the studio to record. Some songs
I realized that these 15 kind of came was only 15 that hung together, and so happen with little or no editing. Some
Audionet Max
MONOBLOCK POWER AMPLIFIER
T
hree years ago, when I first heard Audionet’s Max monoblock power for medical applications. The company
amplifiers, I described their pairing with YG Acoustics Hailey loud- claims that the technology “delivers
speakers “an absolute winner” and “definitely one of the finer systems results that nudge the boundaries of
at T.H.E. Show Newport Beach.”1 At subsequent audio shows, no fewer what is feasible with current measuring
than four other Stereophile Contributing Editors enthused about different pairings technologies. Even under conditions of
of YG loudspeakers with Audionet amplification. Herb Reichert, at the 2014 maximum strain or in other border-
Rocky Mountain Audio Fest: “Everything had a kind of just right quality. Totally line situations, any incidence of signal
impressive!”2 Sasha Matson, at RMAF 2015: “Marvelous” on vocals, “rockin’ and impurity remains almost undetect-
tight” on bass and drums.3 John Atkinson, at T.H.E. Show 2016: “Duke Elling- able, while the outstanding feedback
ton’s classic Jazz Party in Stereo . . . was reproduced with terrific dynamics.”4 damping ensures that the loudspeakers
Larry Greenhill at the 2017 Consumer Electronics Show on the sound in the YG crisply perform to the limits of their
Acoustics room, which included Audionet’s Max monoblocks: “the sound on capacity.” I wonder what JA’s measure-
playback of Jake Shimabukuro’s ukulele wizardry came closer to matching his live ments will have to say about that.
performance than in most rooms.”5 The Max has four separate power
I visited the same room later during supplies—one each for the control-
CES 2017, and wrote that it produced ler and input/driver stages, and one
a huge soundstage, “with the low each for the output section’s positive
frequencies remarkably fleshed out and negative half-cycles. The sup-
and layered. Everything was perfectly ply for the input/driver stage has its
controlled, with the speed, power, and own 80VA toroidal transformer, with
weight of bass response astounding. separate secondary windings for posi-
Highs, however, were a bit recessed, 1 See www.stereophile.com/content/
and lacking in brilliance, and strings show-2014-day-3-morning.
briefly turned wiry on the track’s loud- 2 See www.stereophile.com/content/
est passage.”6 What we didn’t know rmaf-2014-reichert-ongoing.
3 See www.stereophile.com/content/
from these auditions was how the more-first-day-adventures-sasha.
Maxes might sound with other gear. A 4 See www.stereophile.com/content/
review would answer that question. jas-day-show-2016.
5 See www.stereophile.com/content/
ces2017-live-vs-recorded-audionet-and-yg.
Description
6 The music was by Mason Bates, from his
The Audionet Max ($30,500/pair), ($29,900/pair), which I reviewed in Works for Orchestra, with Michael Tilson Thomas
which were designed and are manu- the April 2017 issue.7 conducting the San Francisco Symphony (SACD/
CD, SFS Media 65). See www.stereophile.com/
factured in Germany, cost almost The Max is based on what Audio- content/sonja-xv-loudspeakers-yg-acoustics.
the same as that of another German net calls an Ultra-Linear-Amplifier 7 See www.stereophile.com/content/
monoblock, AVM’s Ovation MA8.2 (ULA) topology, originally developed avm-ovation-ma82-monoblock-power-amplifier.
SPECIFICATIONS
Description Solid-state, ohms, 100pF (balanced); 37k 19.7" (500mm) D. Weights Price $30,500/pair. Approxi-
MOSFET monoblock power ohms, 100pF (unbalanced). (each): 83.8 lbs (38kg) net, mate number of dealers: 9.
amplifier. Inputs: 1 balanced Damping factor: >1800 at 100 lbs (45.4kg) shipping. Manufacturer Idektron
(XLR), 1 unbalanced (RCA). 10kHz, >10,000 at 100Hz. Finishes Front panel: Brushed GmbH & Co. KG,
Outputs: 2 pairs binding Intermodulation distortion aluminum, black/light gray Alboinstrasse 36-42, 12103
posts. Power outputs: 400W (SMPTE 100Hz and 20kHz, or silver/black printing. Top Berlin, Germany.
into 8 ohms (26dBW), 4:1): <–110dB at 50W into plate and side panels: Black- Tel: (49) (0)30-2332421-0.
700W into 4 ohms 4 ohms. THD+N: <–106dB, anodized brushed aluminum. Fax: (49) (0)30-2332421-99.
(25.4dBW), 1100W into 2 1kHz at 25–700W into 4 Chassis: black-varnished Web: www.audionet.de.
ohms (24.4dBW). Frequency ohms. Signal/noise: >125dB. sheet steel. US distributor: GTT Audio &
response: 0Hz–500kHz, Dimensions 11.2" (285mm) Serial numbers of units Video. Tel: (908) 850-3092.
–3dB. Input impedance: 3k H by 8.5" (215mm) W by reviewed 9.16.19, 9.16.20. Web: www.gttaudio.com.
tive and negative voltages, while each based input stage is configured as a gold-plated XLRs of unnamed prov-
of the two output-section supplies has cascaded and bootstrapped differential enance, the latter are gold-plated, Tef-
its own very hefty 1000VA toroidal amplifier. The output stage is equipped lon-insulated Furutechs—and two pairs
transformer—one for positive voltages, with eight hand-selected MOSFETs, of Furutech rhodium-plated speaker
the other for negative. The control- with actively controlled bias current. terminals (for biwiring). Also on the
ler stage—which is powered by its For all that, the Maxes didn’t run hot— rear panel are a 15-amp power-cord in-
own toroidal transformer—monitors the pair of them didn’t heat up my put and, right above that, a small rocker
temperature, DC offset, and other well-insulated, 20' by 16' by 9' listening power switch. The power receptacle,
parameters, and controls all amplifier room, as do the Pass XA200.8 monob- power switch, and speaker outputs are
functions. Should a fault occur, it is locks ($42,000/pair) that usually drive all so close together that, if both your
announced on the front-panel display, my Wilson Alexia speakers. power cord’s input termination and
after which the Max disconnects from On the rear panel are balanced and speaker-cable spades are wide and your
the mains supply. The Max’s FET- unbalanced inputs—the former are fingers are thick, you may have trouble
Q &XVWRPFRQŵJXUDEOHIRUDQ\V\VWHP
Q ([SDQGV\VWHPYHUWLFDOO\RUKRUL]RQWDOO\
without limitations
Q 7HFKQRORJ\RSWLPL]HGDWHDFKFRPSRQHQW
for maximum performance
$ORZQRLVHŶRRULVIXQGDPHQWDOWRJUHDWV\VWHPSHUIRUPDQFH2YHUWKH
SDVW7:2GHFDGHV+56KDVEXLOWDFRPSOHWHOLQHRIKLJKSHUIRUPDQFH
QRLVH UHGXFWLRQ SURGXFWV UHSUHVHQWHG E\ WKH ŵQHVW GHDOHUV DQG
GLVWULEXWRUVLQWKHZRUOG(DFK+56SURGXFWLVEDVHGRQ7+,57<),9(\HDUV
RIWHFKQLFDOH[SHULHQFHLQSXWIURPRXUOLVWHQLQJSDQHORIHQJLQHHUVDQG
PXVLFLDQVWKHQEXLOWE\DWHDPRIH[SHUWFUDIWVPHQ2YHU7+,57<LQGXVWU\
OHDGLQJDXGLRFRPSDQLHVXVH+56DXGLRVWDQGVWRGHYHORSQHZSURGXFWV
DQGXVHDWPDMRUHYHQWVZLQQLQJQXPHURXV%HVWRI6KRZDZDUGV+56
KDVFUHDWHG21(+81'5('6,;7<GHWDLOHGSURFHVVDQGTXDOLW\FRQWURO
SURFHGXUHVWRHQVXUHSURGXFWTXDOLW\:LWKWKLVKLVWRU\DVRXUIRXQGDWLRQ
ZHLQWURGXFH21(QHZ+565HIHUHQFH/HYHO9;5$XGLR6WDQG
Visit AVisolation.com to learn more about HRS high performance noise reduction products.
716.873.1437
AUDIONET MAX
accessing the power switch. I’m sure there’s a reason for such nal is detected; and a warm-up countdown that enables the
cramped ergonomics, but it’s not user friendly. user to enter an amount of time, between 15 minutes and
Equally disturbing, the positive and negative speaker 99.45 hours, after which they intend to begin their listening.
terminals are close together. Bill Parish of distributor GTT Also adjustable are the display’s brightness and various other
Audio & Video advised me to insert a piece of Styrofoam control functions. All of this is easily done by holding down
between my Nordost Odin 2 speaker cables’ spade termina- the Power button longer than two seconds, then navigating
tions to ensure that they would never touch. I made sure the the menu and making selections from it with short presses
lugs were tight, and checked them often. of Power.
The Max’s Spartan front panel is far better designed. On If you leave the display on, you can choose to have it
it are an LED display, and a Power button that also controls announce the input selected or the Max’s temperature.
a number of other functions. Once all inputs and outputs Since the display text changes locations randomly every 12
are connected and the mains power switch is turned on, the seconds, I found it utterly distracting and switched off the
Max is in Standby mode. When you press the front-panel display. That meant that, once the “Waking up . . .,” etc.,
Power button, the message “Waking up . . .” is displayed. sequence was completed, the display went dark. Thank God.
Should the polarity of the amp’s AC cord be reversed—
perish the thought—you’re informed of that, too. Assuming “I have the time!”
all is in order, once the Max flashes which of its inputs is in When I first installed the Max monoblocks, Bill Parish
use, you’re ready to go. urged me to replace the balanced (XLR) interconnects that
Switching back to Standby triggers a sequence of messages: I usually use with unbalanced (RCA). “For the balanced
“Going to sleep . . . ,” followed by “DISCHARGING NOW input Audionet uses an op-amp, which is just another piece
please wait . . .” When that message disappears, the Max is of circuitry,” he explained by e-mail. “While it is the best
in Standby. If you change your mind and press Power once op-amp out there, you can still hear it. I don’t want to make
more, “RE-STARTING” is displayed. Parish recommended this a big thing, but I assure you that you will greatly prefer
that I leave the Maxes on 24/7. Since they use very little the RCA (or at least I do). BTW, I’ll bet most of the equip-
electricity when no music is playing, and took quite a while ment made today falls into this camp; they just don’t know
to sound their best from turn-on, I followed his advice. or tell you.”
The Max offers several options each of operation and dis- Given such strong advice, I switched to unbalanced inter-
play: AutoStart, which permits timed operation; Auto On/ connects, and stuck with them when I reinstalled my Pass
Off, which turns the amp on from Standby whenever a sig- amps for comparisons. While the Audionet Maxes don’t re-
MEASUREMENTS
I
measured one of the Audionet front panel displaying the message reduce the input level, the amplifier
Max monoblocks (serial no. “SEVERE ERROR OVERHEATING.” The turned itself off several seconds after
9.16.20) with my Audio Precision Audionet’s top panel at that point was the increase in THD. I let the amplifier
SYS2722 system (see the January fairly hot, at 117.3°F (47.4°C). cool down for a couple of hours, then
2008 “As We See It,” www.stereophile. What I found interesting about resumed testing. The Max’s protection
com/content/measurements-maps- the amplifier’s behavior was that its circuits kicked in several times during
precision). Before doing any testing THD+noise, which was extraordi- the measuring when I was operating
of a power amplifier, I precondition it narily low with the amplifier cold, at it at high powers, particularly at high
by running it at one-third its specified 0.0008%, stayed close to that level for frequencies, giving me the message
power into 8 ohms for 60 minutes with almost the entire 42 minutes, but then “SEVERE ERROR HIGH FREQUENCY.”
a 1kHz tone: This power level results rose to around 0.03% (not shown). If I Each time, I let the amplifier cool down
in the highest thermal stress on the then reduced the level of the input sig- before continuing the testing.
output devices of an amplifier having a nal so that the output power was lower The voltage gain into 8 ohms for
class-B or -AB output stage. The Max than one-third power, the THD+N the balanced input was a low 23.4dB.
turned itself off after 42 minutes, its remained around 0.03%. If I didn’t Unusually, the gain via the unbalanced
d d
B B
r r
A A
Hz Hz
Fig.1 Audionet Max, frequency response at 2.83V Fig.2 Audionet Max, small-signal, 10kHz square- Fig.3 Audionet Max, spectrum of 1kHz sinewave,
into: simulated loudspeaker load (gray), 8 ohms wave into 8 ohms. DC–1kHz, at 1W into 8 ohms (linear frequency
(blue), 4 ohms (magenta), 2 ohms (red) (0.5dB/ scale).
vertical div.).
65V-1
quire that shorting pins be installed in their balanced inputs that was dumping obscene levels of noise into the line, but
when using their unbalanced inputs, the Passes do. that I’d gummed up the sound by spraying much too much
The first time I listened to the Maxes in my system, they DeOxit contact cleaner on my connectors.
sounded disappointing. I suspected there was some sort of Regardless, I ended up with a tub full of Kubala-Sosna
incompatibility between them and all of my Nordost Odin cables in the middle of my music room. Weeks went by
cables—even though I’ve used Nordost Odin 2s with a wide before I could summon up sufficient fortitude to carefully
variety of amps and speakers, and the sound has always replace my entire system’s worth of Nordost cables and
been excellent. power treatment products with their Kubala-Sosna equiva-
I immediately contacted JA, and asked if it would be lents: Elation!s and the Xpander. I used not a single squirt of
kosher if I borrowed a full set of Kubala-Sosna Elation! wires DeOxit. And, as I finally sat down to listen, and realized that
for this review. With his assent came a warning: I would I would also need to hear the Audionets with the Nordosts
need to establish, as a benchmark, the sound of the Pass/ before I could write the review, the Almighty Atkinson’s
Kubala-Sosna combo before moving on to the Audionet/ wise words came back to haunt me . . .
Kubala-Sosna, and “That will take a lot of time.”
“I have the time!” Famous last words of Serinus the Idiot. Listening
Joe Kubala agreed to send what amounted to an 80-lb As excellent as the Kubala-Sosna Elation!s were with bass,
tub filled with Elation! cables and a Kubala-Sosna Xpander and as admirably smooth as the system sounded overall, I
power distributor. Although in price the Elation!s are far found it darker, less open on top, less rich in the midrange,
more comparable to Nordost’s Valhalla 2s than their Odin and not as focused as with the Nordost Odin 2s. So here, I
2s, Kubala felt I wouldn’t be disappointed. confine my observations to those made after my reference
While awaiting that shipment, I reinstalled my Pass Labs wires were returned to the system.
XA200.8s so that I could review recordings without pain. As I listened to Mahler’s Symphony 9, with Iván Fischer
But when the Passes now sounded bad as well, I went into conducting the Budapest Festival Orchestra (SACD/CD,
a full panic. Check the connections, check the ground . . . Channel Classics CCS SA 36115), I noted how tightly the
everything checked out except my composure. Audionet Maxes depicted bass-drum thwacks. Rapid tim-
Many days later, but before I’d settled down, my refer- pani rolls were correspondingly clearer than with my Pass
ence amps began to sound themselves again. In retrospect, amps. But I had little sense of hall acoustic and boundaries.
I believe the problem was not that one of my neighbors Although the violins sounded fairly silky and sweet, they
had started a power-sucking marijuana-growing operation were a little edgier than I’m accustomed to. Overall, the
measurements, continued
inputs was 6dB higher. Both inputs pre- a wide small-signal bandwidth, with odd-order harmonics, but these are all
served absolute polarity, the XLR jack the response into 8 ohms (blue trace) at very low levels.
being wired with pin 2 hot. The input down by just over 1dB at 200kHz. The The Audionet Max exceeded its
impedances were close to the specified Audionet’s reproduction of a 10kHz specified output power of 400W into
values, at 35k ohms unbalanced and squarewave into 8 ohms (fig.2) thus 8 ohms (26dBW), clipping at 450W
3k ohms balanced. The latter is very featured very short risetimes, and no into that load (26.5dBW, fig.4). Note
low; if this amplifier is used with tubed overshoot or ringing was visible. that in this graph, the actual distortion
preamps, which typically have a high Not only does the Audionet Max lies beneath the noise at powers below
output impedance at low frequencies, have very low distortion—it is also very 30W, indicated by the upward slope
the bass will sound rolled off. quiet. Its unweighted, wideband signal/ of the trace as the power decreases.
The output impedance was very noise ratio, ref. 1W into 8 ohms and Fig.5 reveals that the amplifier also
low, at 0.045 ohm (including the taken with the input shorted to ground, exceeded its specified power of 700W
speaker cable) at 20Hz and 1kHz, ris- was a superb 85.4dB, which increased into 4 ohms (25.4dBW), clipping at
ing slightly to 0.07 ohm at 20kHz. The to 98.5dB when the measurement was 750W (25.75dBW). The Max clipped
response with our standard simulated A-weighted. Fig.3 reveals that the only at the specified 1100W into 2 ohms
loudspeaker1 varied by just ±0.05dB spuriae present in the output were 1 See www.stereophile.com/content/
(fig.1, gray trace). The Max offered at the 60Hz supply frequency and its real-life-measurements-page-2.
% % %
W W Hz
Fig.4 Audionet Max, distortion (%) vs 1kHz con- Fig.5 Audionet Max, distortion (%) vs 1kHz con- Fig.6 Audionet Max, THD+N (%) vs frequency at
tinuous output power into 8 ohms. tinuous output power into 4 ohms. 20V into: 8 ohms (blue), 4 ohms (magenta).
sound was darker and less colorful than with my reference was extremely fast, with lots of layering. Ditto with “Electri-
monoblocks. fied II,” whose very wide, studio-enhanced soundstage,
Even more deep percussion is to be savored in Revueltas’s sizzling top, and fast, hard-hitting bass made me want to
Sensemayá, with Werner Herbers conducting the Ebony get up and dance. Both tracks sounded so much tighter and
Band (SACD/CD, Channel Classics CCS SA 21104). Here, more impactful through the Maxes than through the Passes
the Maxes excelled more in bass impact than in richness. that I don’t hesitate to say it: If your preferences lean toward
Ditto with soprano Carolyn Sampson’s recital disc Fleurs hard rock, driving jazz, or propulsive/explosive music of any
(SACD/CD, BIS 2102)—Joseph Middleton’s piano sounded genre, Audionet’s Max monoblocks are must-hears.
flatter than usual, Sampson’s voice more toned down, less Those sentiments were reaffirmed when I revisited Four
engaging, a bit edgier. Four Three: The Music of Terry Riley (DSD128 download,
Back to percussion and speed. I find the 24-bit/96kHz Channel Classics 37816) that I reviewed for Stereophile.
download of Ludovic Morlot and the Seattle Symphony’s re- com. This collaboration of the Ragazze String Quartet with
cording of Stravinsky’s The Rite of Spring (Seattle Symphony the percussion quartet Slagwerk Den Haag and Kapok—a
Media 1005) extremely demanding in both departments, as genre-redefining trio of horn, guitar, and drum kit—has slam
well as extremely colorful. Once again, the Audionets were for days, and sounded fabulous: again, darker than I’m used
superb on the low end. to, but fabulous nonetheless.
Mezzo-soprano Jamie Barton may have sounded a bit “This Seeming Dream,” from Zen Widow’s Screaming in
darker and less brilliant through the Maxes than I’m ac- Daytime (Makes Men Forget) (CD, pfMentum PFMCD 069),
customed to, but I absolutely loved listening to her huge, was ideal for illustrating the Maxes’ many strengths. From
resplendent voice in the 24/96 download of her All Who bright and eerie sounds to piercing trumpet and knock-down
Wander, with pianist Brian Zeger (Delos 3494). Ditto for violent percussion, this unhinged jazz from trumpeter Leo
a very different singer, lyric soprano Elly Ameling, whose Wadada Smith, percussionist Garth Powell, and crew was so
gifts, on her rendition of Schubert’s “Die Sterne” with compelling that I quickly turned out the lights to better sur-
Dalton Baldwin (The Artistry of Elly Ameling, CD, Philips render to its grip. Ditto for “Black on White Paper,” which
473-4512), the Maxes reproduced without that last iota of sounded even more stark and violent than through the AVM
radiance that the Pass XA200.8s can provide. MA8.2 monoblocks. If the Audionet Maxes didn’t trans-
A tip of the hat to Jon Iverson for turning me on to mit the most well-lit images on the planet, their darker yet
Yello—I indulged in two 24/48 download tracks from their detailed top, combined with their excellence down below,
album Toy (Polydor). The driving beat of “Lost in Motion” made them ideal for recordings with ear-bleed potential.
measurements, continued
(24.4dBW), though the AC wall voltage protection circuit cut in and displayed pensive German amplifiers, Audionet’s
had dropped from 123V to 118.5V at the the “SEVERE ERROR HIGH FREQUENCY” Max performed very well on the test
clip point. message. At low frequencies and bench, offering high powers with very
Fig.6 plots the THD+noise percent- high powers into low impedances, the low levels of distortion and noise. It
age against frequency at a level, 20V, highest-level distortion harmonic was doesn’t quite have enough heatsink
that is equivalent to 50W into 8 ohms the third (fig.7), though with a 1kHz capacity for its power-output capabil-
and 100W into 4 ohms, and where I tone at the same output voltage into ity, but I suspect that that shortcom-
could be sure I was looking at actual 8 ohms, the second harmonic was the ing will not be a problem in normal
distortion rather than noise. Even so, highest in level (fig.8). Intermodula- use, especially given its very effective
the THD+N percentage remains very tion distortion was also extremely low protection circuitry. (Despite the abuse
low, with only slight rises in the top (fig.9), even at a level close to visual I gave it during testing, the Max didn’t
octave and into the lower impedance. waveform clipping on an oscilloscope, break.) My only reservation concerned
I haven’t shown the THD+N plotted where the 1kHz difference product its very low balanced input impedance,
against frequency into 2 ohms at this rose from –120dB (0.0001%) to –96dB but this won’t be an issue with modern
level (equivalent to 200W), as despite (0.0015%, not shown). solid-state preamps and digital source
repeated attempts, the amplifier’s As I am coming to expect from ex- components. —John Atkinson
d d d
B B B
r r r
A A A
Hz Hz Hz
Fig.7 Audionet Max, spectrum of 50Hz sinewave, Fig.8 Audionet Max, spectrum of 1kHz sinewave, Fig.9 Audionet Max, HF intermodulation spectrum,
DC–1kHz, at 200W into 4 ohms (linear frequency DC–10kHz, at 100W into 8 ohms (linear frequency DC–30kHz, 19+20kHz at 100W peak into 8 ohms
scale). scale). (linear frequency scale).
Theater for
PC-USB with support of up to 24 bit/192kHz decoding
and Bluetooth streaming with aptX. And there is also
a phono stage, and an analog bypass mode. Both
single ended and XLR outputs are provided.
A S S O C I AT E D E Q U I P M E N T
Get Better Sound: Reference Set-up Manual, DVD, StraightTalk, RoomPlay Reference, and
RoomPlay™ Custom Voicing. Get better sound from any home audio system!
Internet: www.getbettersound.com • Phone: 770-777-2095 • E-mail: jim@getbettersound.com
EQ U IPMENT R EPORT
LARRY GREENHILL
D
inesh Paliwal, CEO of
Harman International
Industries, was addressing
engineers and the audio
press in a crowded conference room
at the opening of Harman Luxury
Audio’s new Engineering Center
of Excellence (ECOE), in Shelton,
Connecticut. Paliwal singled out
as the ECOE’s first beneficiary the
Mark Levinson brand, with the
goal of revitalizing it as Harman’s
flagship marque. (Other brands
in the HII stable include Harman
Kardon, Infinity, JBL, Crown, AKG,
Lexicon, and Revel.) To achieve this,
he gave the ECOE team access to The design fits into a gardless of load, delivering high amounts
Harman’s R&D budget of $400 mil-
lion; brought on Todd Eichenbaum,
solid tradition of Mark of current—and expensive. After Madrigal
bought Mark Levinson, in 1984, ML
formerly of Krell, to be its Director; Levinson monoblocks. produced bigger, more powerful, more
and hired 11 more engineers. costly monoblocks, including the 100W
Paliwal spoke with pride of the facility’s output of six new No.20.61 and the 150W No.33H.2 In 2008, the Harman
Mark Levinson models in the past 24 months, and pointed Specialty Group, which had purchased Mark Levinson from
with pleasure at the new No.536 monoblock amplifier. I Madrigal, upped the ante with the No.53, a 500W mono-
smiled: I was already scheduled to review it. block3 with a pulse-width-modulated output stage. Paliwal
1 See John Atkinson’s review of the No.20.6 in the April 1992 issue:
The Monoblock Legacy www.stereophile.com/content/mark-levinson-no26-preamplifier-no20-monob-
The No.536’s design fits into a solid tradition of Mark lock-power-amplifier-ja-april-1992.
Levinson monoblocks that began in about 1977 with the 2 See Wes Phillips’s review of the No.33H in the January 1998 issue:
www.stereophile.com/solidpoweramps/115/index.html.
ML-2, a 25W, class-A amplifier weighing 80 lbs and cost-
3 See Michael Fremer’s review of the No.53 in the December 2012 issue:
ing $6490/pair, and that established the design pattern for www.stereophile.com/content/mark-levinson-no53-reference-monoblock-
subsequent ML monoblocks: big, heavy, voltage stable re- power-amplifier.
SPECIFICATIONS
Description Solid-state Input sensitivity: 2.83V RMS output (full power on). AC D. Weights: 100 lbs (45.4kg)
monoblock power ampli- output for 150mV input. voltage: 100V, 120V, 230V at net, 114 lbs (51.7kg) shipping.
fier. Inputs: 1 unbalanced Input impedance: 60k ohms 60Hz (set at factory). Con- Finishes Black and silver.
(RCA), 1 balanced (XLR). (balanced), 30k ohms (un- trol connectors: 1 Ethernet Serial numbers of units
Outputs: 2 pairs Hurricane balanced). Output imped- (RJ-45) 10/100; USB-A (for reviewed 1250, 1255.
spade connectors with ance: 0.054 ohm, 20Hz– updates); USB micro (access Price $30,000/pair. Approxi-
banana-plug sockets (not 1kHz; 0.055 ohm at 5Hz; internal webpage); 1 mini mate number of dealers: 97.
available on 230V models). 0.056 ohm at 10Hz; 0.059 (tip/sleeve) 3.5mm plug Warranty: 5 years.
Power output (20Hz–20kHz, ohm at 20kHz. Signal/noise: trigger input, 12V DC; 1 (tip/ Manufacturer
0.25% THD+N): 400W into >85dB, ref. level 2.83V RMS. sleeve) 3.5mm plug trigger Mark Levinson, Harman
8 ohms (26dBW), 800W Voltage gain: 25.5dB. Power output, 12V DC. Luxury Audio Group,
into 4 ohms (26dBW), consumption: <0.5W (Green Dimensions 17.25” (438mm) 8500 Balboa Boulevard,
stable into 2 ohms. Fre- Standby), 5W (Power Save W by 7” (178mm) H (w/o Northridge, CA 91329.
quency response at 400W: Standby), 65W (Normal feet) by 7.65” (194mm) H Tel: (888) 691-4171. Web:
10Hz–20kHz, ±0.05dB. Standby), 1500W at rated (with feet) by 21” (533mm) www.marklevinson.com.
“The Sigma SSP can be regarded as a superb “Oh my, what a wonderful system Classé has
stereo analog pre-amp, and all the rest of its provided with the Sigma range. It shows that
bells and whistles as a gift.” audiophile sound is not the sole preserve of
Kal Rubinson, Stereophile, USA stereo and equally that it is not incompatible
with reliable and convenient operation.”
“It combines the flexibility of a Swiss Army Stephen Dawson, Audio Esoterica, Australia
knife with the precision of a surgeon’s tool
in an easy-to-use package. There’s simply “This Sigma system is a huge achievement
not enough room here to even pretend to which everyone must absolutely discover.”
detail what you can do with this processor. Adrien Rouah, Québec Audio & Video, Canada
It’s just awesome.”
Theo Nicolakis, Audioholics.com, USA
Artwork by Marian Bijlenga and Scott Rothstein. Available at www.browngrotta.com
classeaudio.com
MARK LEVINSON NO.536
had asked the ECOE to design a “middle-tier” monoblock internal cooling fans unnecessary. The output-stage circuits
at half the No.53’s list price of $50,000/pair. The result is are mounted on the inner surfaces of the heatsinks. The
the class-AB No.536, at $30,000/pair. component quality is tops, and the bulletproof build quality
should last a century. Like all Mark Levinson gear, the 100lb
Circuit Design No.536 is made in the US.
According to Todd Eichenbaum, the No.536’s design is new Eichenbaum removed the No.536’s top plate and pointed
from the ground up. Its signal paths are fully discrete and out that the rectifiers and filter capacitors are directly attached
fully differential, and it has a mirror-imaged circuit topol- to the output-stage subassemblies, to make the electrical
ogy with high bias current. The No.536’s voltage and driver connections short and direct. Second, each of the two output
stages are based on the gain stage of the No.585 integrated stages handles both inverting and non-inverting signals, which
amplifier.4 The No.536’s output stage is biased to operate in allows each stage to draw current evenly and simultaneously
class-A up to 3W. from both the positive and negative supply rails, to maximize
The No.536’s overall gain structure was designed to have the amount of power available to the amplifier.
linear open-loop performance before negative feedback is Although each No.536 drives only one channel, it uses
applied. This was accomplished by meticulously setting the two fully differential, class-AB, 400W output stages in a
open-loop gain and bandwidth of the output circuit using bridged configuration to bolster its current output. This
precision resistors and capacitors. Once that was achieved, helps the amplifier remain stable into loads of 2 ohms.
additional resistors were used to add the feedback network. Each output stage has 12 discrete TO-264 bipolar power
Eichenbaum tuned this design to exhibit no latching, ring- transistors (each rated at 15A, 260V, 200W), and 12 discrete
ing, or oscillating when the No.536 is driven into hard TO-220 bipolar driver transistors.
clipping, nor does it round off the waveform. The waveform Each of the No.536’s two high-current power supplies
does exhibit the usual flat top when clipped, but is otherwise contains eight discrete, high-speed TO-220 Schottky recti-
clean. Harman specifies the No.536 as outputting 400W fiers and 18 paralleled filter capacitors. Including both power
into 8 ohms or 800W into 4 ohms, and remaining stable supplies, the total storage capacitance of the No.536’s 36
into 2 ohms. filter capacitors is 169,200μF. Just behind the front panel is a
Harman calls the No.536’s design Pure Path, an umbrella single, low-noise, 1800VA toroidal power transformer with
term used across the Mark Levinson product line—includ- separate secondary windings for each output stage.
ing in the No.526 preamplifier5 —indicating a direct-coupled The No.536 includes the protection design described in
signal path, voltage gain and drive stages that use folded cas- my review of the Mark Levinson No.585 integrated ampli-
code circuits and operate in class-A, and the use of minimal fier in December 2015, scaled up for the No.536’s greater
feedback and high bias-current settings in the output stage. voltages and current handling. It uses redundant pathways—
The folded cascode circuits—built with junction field-effect ie, direct connections to the amplifier circuitry itself, as well
transistors (JFETs) and bipolar junction transistors (BJTs)— as to the microprocessor, which monitors the amplifier’s
are included to achieve high gain, low noise, wide band- operation for ultimate reliability under all conditions. To
width, and excellent linearity. protect the amplifier and loudspeaker attached to it, the
No.536 continuously monitors the heatsink temperature (as
Construction a fail-safe, there’s also a second temperature sensor on each
Todd Eichenbaum had walked me through the No.536’s heatsink), internal operating temperature, power-supply rail
layout at the 2017 Consumer Electronics Show. Its case
4 See my review of the No.585 in the December 2015 issue:
of extruded 6063-T5 (aircraft-grade) aluminum measures www.stereophile.com/content/mark-levinson-no585-integrated-amplifier.
17.25" wide by 7.65" high (with feet attached) by 21" deep; 5 See my review of the No.526 in the May 2017 issue: www.stereophile.com/
openings in the bottom and top plates vent heat and make content/mark-levinson-no526-preamplifier.
MEASUREMENTS
I
measured one of the Mark Levin- was warm, at 101.3°F (38.5°C).
son No.536 monoblocks (serial The voltage gain into 8 ohms for
no.1250) with my Audio Precision both the balanced and unbalanced
SYS2722 system (see the January inputs was 25.6dB, and both inputs d
2008 “As We See It,” www.stereophile. preserved absolute polarity, the XLR B
r
com/content/measurements-maps- jack being wired with pin 2 hot. The A
precision). Before doing any testing input impedance at low and middle fre-
of a power amplifier, I precondition it quencies was extremely high, at 240k
by running it at one-third its specified ohms 360k ohms balanced, and though
power into 8 ohms for 60 minutes. at the top of the audioband this imped-
Hz
(This power level results in the highest ance dropped to 250k ohms balanced,
thermal stress on the output devices these are still very high. Fig.1 Mark Levinson No.536, frequency response
of an amplifier having a class-B or -AB The output impedance was low, at 2.83V into: simulated loudspeaker load (gray),
8 ohms (blue), 4 ohms (magenta), 2 ohms (red)
output stage.) After an hour driving at 0.1 ohm at 20Hz and 1kHz, rising (0.5dB/vertical div.).
133W into 8 ohms, the temperature of slightly to 0.13 ohm at 20kHz. The
the No.536’s heatsinks was fairly hot, response with our standard simulated 1 See www.stereophile.com/content/
at 114.8°F (46°C), and its top panel loudspeaker1 varied by just ±0.1dB real-life-measurements-page-2.
axios.kimber.com
*Try it in your system for 30 days from date of purchase. If you are not satisfied with our product
simply return the undamaged product in original packaging for a full refund. USA only.
“SONY” & “WALKMAN” are trademarks for SONY, www.sony.com — “FOCAL” is a trademark for FOCAL, www.focal.com
MARK LEVINSON NO.536
voltage, the output current relative the output (but not at the input);
to the output-transistor operating the No.536 will not restart until
voltage, the output voltage, and it is serviced by a Mark Levinson
the output DC level. The No.536 technician.
is prevented from overheating by On the rear panel is the main
thermal switches inside the power- power switch. Just above sits a
transformer housing. Recoverable row of control and connectivity
faults—ie, faults that do not indicate inputs, including: USB-A, for
amplifier damage—include over- upgrading the firmware; USB-
heating, incorrect AC input, DC micro, for accessing the internal
detected at the input, and short cir- webpage; RS-232, for connection
cuits across the speaker terminals. to a computer with a serial port;
jacks for trigger inputs and out-
External Features and Controls puts; and an RJ-45 connector for
The No.536 has Mark Levinson’s an Ethernet link. Single RCA and
usual black case with multiple heat- XLR input connectors are next,
sink fins running along each side, flanking a small toggle switch that
and its silver-and-black faceplate selects between them. At the top
trim is reminiscent of my ca-1999 is a row of four speaker terminals
No.334 stereo amplifier.6 The front with Hurricane binding posts.
panel has only a single button; this The amplifier has three operat-
toggles the amplifier between On Just behind the front panel ing states: Off, via the rear-panel power switch; On, by
and Standby when the rear-panel of the No.536 is a low- pressing the front-panel button, which turns on all audio
Power switch is turned on. Above noise, 1800VA toroidal circuits and activates all outputs; and Standby, an energy-
power transformer.
this is an LED that indicates the saving mode. Within Standby are three more options,
operating status: steady red when selectable via the amplifier’s internal webpage or RS-232
the amplifier is fully turned on, flashing red while the connector: Green, the factory default, is the lowest-power
amplifier is in Standby, steady blue as the amplifier starts standby mode; it disables the Ethernet and RS-232 inputs,
up from a reset, and flashing blue while an update is being but permits wake-up via the trigger inputs. Power Save, a
installed. This same LED also indicates fault conditions: moderate energy-saving standby mode, permits wake-up via
When it continuously flashes white, the No.536 has entered RS-232 or Ethernet. Normal mutes all outputs, but keeps
into Safe Protection Mode because of a recoverable fault the audio and control circuits powered. Except when the
that can either correct itself (amplifier temperature over safe amplifier is set in Normal mode, the No.536 automatically
limit) or be fixed by the owner (speaker terminals shorted goes into standby when it hasn’t sensed an audio signal for
together). If it glows a steady white, the fault is nonrecover- 6 See my review of the Mark Levinson No.334 in the September 1999 issue:
able: an output transistor is damaged, or DC is detected at www.stereophile.com/solidpoweramps/142/index.html.
measurements, continued
(fig.1, gray trace). The amplifier offered ground, the Mark Levinson amplifier tone at 1W into 8 ohms (fig.3) revealed
a wide small-signal bandwidth, the offered a wideband, unweighted signal/ some supply-related spuriae, these
output into 8 ohms (blue trace) not noise ratio of 71dB, ref. 1W into 8 ohms. were all at a very low level.
reaching –3dB until 195kHz. Conse- This improved to 96dB when the mea- The Mark Levinson is also an ex-
quently, the No.536’s reproduction of a surement bandwidth was restricted to tremely powerful amplifier. With clip-
10kHz squarewave (fig.2) featured very 22Hz–22kHz, and to 99.3dB when the ping defined as when the THD+noise
short risetimes and, commendably, no reading was A-weighted. This is a quiet reaches 1%, the No.536 clipped at
overshoot or ringing was apparent. amplifier, and while spectral analysis of 510W into 8 ohms (27.1dBW, fig.4),
Measured with the input shorted to its noise floor as it reproduced a 1kHz compared with the specified maxi-
d
B
r %
Hz W
Fig.2 Mark Levinson No.536, small-signal, 10kHz Fig.3 Mark Levinson No.536, spectrum of 1kHz Fig.4 Mark Levinson No.536, distortion (%) vs 1kHz
squarewave into 8 ohms. sinewave, DC–1kHz, at 1W into 8 ohms (linear continuous output power into 8 ohms.
frequency scale).
´%HWWHUWKDQVRPHVSHDNHUV,·YHKHDUGWKDWFRVWWLPHVDVPXFKμ
²-HII'RUJD\721($XGLR
´«RQHRIWKHELJJHVWKLJKHQGVSHDNHUEDUJDLQVRXWWKHUH«μ
²5R\*UHJRU\7KH$XGLR%HDW
´0\QHZUHIHUHQFHVSHDNHUVμ²$QWKRQ\&RUGHVPDQ7KH$EVROXWH6RXQG
The Model 5A Carbon at $29,900/pr. features an advanced carbon tweeter and the patented
Perfect-Piston™ carbon midrange from the Model Seven Mk II, plus %,*SRZHUHGEDVV
ZLWKDZDWWSRZHUHGVXEZRRIHUZLWKEDQGURRP(4
´8QEHDWDEOHSRZHUHGEDVVμ²0LFKDHO)UHPHU6WHUHRSKLOH
Buy Vandersteen, Leave “Upgrade-Itis” Behind. When all of the information from
the amplifier is faithfully retrieved, especially in the crucial time domain, you hear
that something is missing. That something is the
Dual 8,” 300-Watt Powered Subwoofers
distortion of the original signal that leads to the
w/11-Band Room EQ In Each Speaker
For Perfect Bass in Virtually Any Room inevitable feeling audiophiles experience called
“upgrade-itis.” Yes, moving up the Vandersteen
line always offers more performance and ever greater musical pleasure, as will
any other true upgrade to your system. But owning Vandersteens and upgrading
EHFDXVH\RXORYHWKHZD\\RXUPXVLFVRXQGV is so much better than swapping
out your gear because you FDQ·WVWDQG the way your music sounds.
20 minutes. This is a requirement for all products shipping webpage. The No.536’s webpage showed the temperatures
into Europe, and it is enabled in the factory default settings. of the output stages and main circuit board, and confirmed
that the standby mode was “2”: Green, the factory default.
Setup
Todd Eichenbaum drove down from ECOE to help me sch- Listening
lep the two 114-lb shipping cartons containing the No.536es The No.536es’ sound quality was immediately evident.
up the short flight of stairs into my listening room. We then They woke up my Revel Ultima Salon2 speakers, delivering
donned white knit Mark Levinson gloves, complete with an aural palette startling in its transparency and clarity, with
special gripping surfaces for lifting amplifiers. (Two pairs of an expanded ability to reproduce dynamic contrasts, com-
these gloves are included with each mono amp.) We each pared with Mark Levinson’s ML-2, No.27, and No.334 am-
grabbed one end of a heavy vinyl strap that plifiers. My first listening
ran under the No.536 and up through its session produced the same
heatsinks, to form loops at the amp’s front epiphany I experienced
and back. This allowed the two of us to easily on first hearing Theta
lift the amplifiers out of their cartons and Digital’s Prometheus class-
place them behind my Revel Ultima Salon2 D monoblocks:7 Both
speakers. Eichenbaum ran through each sounded open, slightly
No.536’s simple setup routine: rear-panel bright, and whole from
Power switch on; rear-panel input toggle set top to bottom. Needless
for balanced connection to my Bryston BP-26 to say, both pairs of ampli-
or Mark Levinson No.526 preamplifiers; fiers brought out the best
Green standby mode and front-panel Standby from my Revels, which
button pressed. sounded incredibly dy-
For most of the listening period, the namic and pleasingly fast,
No.536es were plugged into my Torus Power RM20 power with greater punch and precision in their deep-bass response
conditioner. I also briefly plugged them directly into the than I’d heard before.
wall outlets, and then into a voltage-regulated Torus Power First impressions count. I soon adopted the No.536es
AVR TOT, but could hear no differences. as my go-to amplifiers for the next nine months’ worth of
After playing the No.536es at top volume for 15 minutes, reviewing. During the listening for my review of the Torus
I checked their output-stage temperatures via their internal Power AVR TOT power conditioner,8 the Mark Levinsons
webpages. To do that, I connected each amp to my network
7 See my review in the March 2015 issue: www.stereophile.com/content/
router using an Ethernet CAT5 cable, and to my laptop theta-digital-prometheus-monoblock-power-amplifier.
with a micro-USB link. The router assigned the amplifier an 8 See my review in the March 2017 issue: www.stereophile.com/content/
ISP address, and my laptop’s browser displayed the internal torus-power-tot-avr-power-conditioner.
measurements, continued
mum output into 8 ohms of 400W 119.5V with the No.536 clipping into 4 to become more linear at moderately
(26dBW). It clipped at 800W into 4 ohms, and to 117V with it clipping into high powers before it starts to clip. I
ohms (26dBW, fig.5), and at 1050W 2 ohms. With the wall voltage held suspect that this behavior is due to
into 2 ohms (24.2dBW). I don’t hold constant, the amplifier would deliver there being only a moderate degree of
the wall voltage constant in these even more power into very low imped- negative feedback.
clipping tests, as I feel that is more ances! The shape of the traces in these The THD+N percentage at 28.3V—
representative of how an ampli- two graphs puzzled me: Although the which is equivalent to 100W into 8
fier behaves in normal use. The wall level of THD+N is extremely low at low ohms, 200W into 4 ohms, and 400W
voltage at the 20A circuit that feeds powers, it starts to rise earlier than I into 2 ohms—was very low at low and
my test lab dropped from 122.8V to expected, and the amplifier appears middle frequencies (fig.6). Though the
% % V
W Hz sec
Fig.5 Mark Levinson No.536, distortion (%) vs 1kHz Fig.6 Mark Levinson No.536, THD+N (%) vs Fig.7 Mark Levinson No.536, 1kHz waveform at
continuous output power into 4 ohms. frequency at 28.3V into: 8 ohms (blue), 4 ohms 200W into 8 ohms, 0.013% THD+N (top); distor-
(magenta), 2 ohms (red). tion and noise waveform with fundamental notched
out (bottom, not to scale).
played with surprising fullness and unexpectedly wide into a driving rock anthem (CD, MCA MCAD-1498); the
dynamic range, limited only by the Torus’s 10-amp slow- dense, solid bass-drum notes that erupt from silence in Eiji
blow fuse, which died when the No.536es drew a steady Oue and the Minnesota Orchestra’s recording of Stravin-
16 amps. Driven by the No.536es, both my Quad ESL-63 sky’s The Rite of Spring (24/176.4k PCM file, Reference
and ESL-989 electrostatic speakers sounded more open RR-70); and the struck chimes and thunderous bass drum
and more dynamic, and developed unusually well-defined that tighten the suspense in “Assault on Ryan’s House,” from
upper bass and sweeter, more open highs. The No.536es James Horner’s score for Patriot Games (CD, RCA 66051-2).
remained unperturbed when the Quads’ protection circuits The midrange response blossomed when my speakers
kicked in and short-circuited the terminals, producing were driven by the No.536es. Whether the volume was low
none of the scratchy, staticky sounds or overheating warn- or high, it was easy to hear differences in tone and timbre in
ings I’ve experienced with other amplifiers. When the male voices, piano, and percussion. The No.536 made the
Quads’ protection circuits relaxed, the amps immediately timbres and harmonics of different solo male voices easy to
turned back on. distinguish, without added midbass emphasis. José Carreras’s
The No.536 exerted a superior grip on the Salon2s’ effortless, lyrical tenor floated before the arc of choristers
woofers, creating a powerfully deep, yet well-controlled and in the Kyrie of Ariel Ramirez’s Misa Criolla, in the record-
well-damped deep bass response. In the Toccata of Widor’s ing conducted by José Luis Ocejo (CD, Philips 420 955-2).
Organ Symphony 5, as performed by Jonas Nordwall and Large choral works benefited greatly from the No.536es’
recorded by John Atkinson (24-bit/88.2kHz AIFF file), clarity, illumination, and power. John Rutter’s Lord, Make Me
deep pedal notes were reproduced with unflinching control an Instrument of Thy Peace and the Piè Jesu from his Requiem,
and solidity, and pressurized my room. Similarly, the pedal both with Timothy Seelig conducting the Turtle Creek
note that ends James Busby’s performance of Herbert How- Chorale (CD, Reference RR-57CD), revealed subtle tonal
ells’s Master Tallis’s Testament, from Pipes Rhode Island (CD, differences among the members of this male chorus, distinc-
Riago 101), was muscular and throbbing yet well controlled. tions made possible by the No.536’s precision. A Gaelic
The conga drum that opens “Hotel California,” from the Blessing, on the same disc, revealed superb pitch definition of
Eagles’ Hell Freezes Over (CD, Geffen GEFD-24725), had the pipe organ’s pedal notes.
a leaden, rock-like solidity, with no sustain. The No.536es The No.536’s midrange performance was highlighted by
were able to define and contain the massive bass chord that its ability to throw a wide, deep soundstage. “Breathe (in the
cuts in just after the beginning of “Deeper Well,” from Air),” from Pink Floyd’s Dark Side of the Moon (SACD/CD,
Emmylou Harris’s Spyboy (CD, Eminent EM-25001-2), EMI 82136-2), engulfed me in sounds of throbbing helicop-
allowing her voice and the drums to be heard farther back ter rotors, jackhammers, footsteps, dive bombers, and PA
on the soundstage. announcements spread across a wide stage. In Rutter’s Piè
One of the most striking things about the No.536 was Jesu, the soprano, chorus, harp, and organ were each separate
its huge dynamic range and bass impact, as demonstrated and precisely positioned, and the No.536es’ excellent pitch
by: the kickdrum that catapults the sleepy opening of David definition allowed each descending pedal note to be heard.
Bowie’s “Putting Out Fire,” from the Cat People soundtrack, The No.536es’ reproduction of cymbals was exemplary.
measurements, continued
THD rises at frequencies above 2kHz, However, it is fair to note that all the (fig.10), while some higher-order
it still lies below 0.08% at 20kHz. distortion components lie at or below intermodulation products are visible,
With a 1kHz signal, the distortion –86dB (0.005%). And while the mix almost all lie below –90dB (0.003%),
signature is odd-order in nature (fig.7), of harmonics varies with frequency, it and the second-order difference prod-
with the second harmonic around remains constant with output power, uct is at –100dB (0.001%).
12dB lower in level than the third which some commentators feel cor- Overall, the Mark Levinson No.536
(fig.8). At low frequencies, however, relates with good sound quality. When measured very well, its performance
the higher-order harmonics reach I tested the No.536 with an equal uncompromised by its ability to deliver
the same level as the third, and the mix of 19 and 20kHz tones, the peak very high powers into low-impedance
even-order products disappear (fig.9). level equivalent to 200W into 4 ohms loads. —John Atkinson
d d d
B B B
r r r
A A A
Hz Hz Hz
Fig.8 Mark Levinson No.536, spectrum of 1kHz Fig.9 Mark Levinson No.536, spectrum of 50Hz Fig.10 Mark Levinson No.536, HF intermodulation
sinewave, DC–10kHz, at 100W into 8 ohms (linear sinewave, DC–1kHz, at 100W into 8 ohms (linear spectrum, DC–24kHz, 19+20kHz at 200W peak
frequency scale). frequency scale). into 4 ohms (linear frequency scale).
;OL?LVPZ[OLWLYMLJ[JVTIPUH[PVUVMLVY[SLZZLUQV`TLU[
and high-quality sound. It is Dynaudio’s smallest wireless
speaker system yet – without any compromise of the completely
high-end audio sound. It is small, smart and unbelievably versatile.
It is all you need.
Xeo 2 Footstand optional.
New AQ
MARK LEVINSON NO.536
ART DUDLEY
SPECIFICATIONS
Description Solid-state ance: 50k ohms. Output Dimensions Preamp and Serial number of unit
line-level preamplifier with impedance: typically 130 power supply (each): reviewed F10186.
separate tubed power sup- ohms. Frequency response: 19" (483mm) W by 4.5" Price $22,790. Approximate
ply. Tube complement: one 20Hz–20kHz, ±0.2dB; (114mm) H by 13.875" number of dealers: 12.
12AX7/ECC83, one 6C19P, 5Hz–120kHz, ±3dB. Slew (350mm) D. Preamplifier Manufacturer
one 5651A, two 12AX3. In- rate: 30V/μs. Risetime: weights: 15.4 lbs (7kg) net, Lamm Industries, Inc.,
puts: 4 single-ended (RCA). 1μs. THD: )0.03% at 2V 34.6 lbs (15.7kg) shipping. 2513 E. 21st. Street,
Outputs: 2 single-ended RMS. Signal/noise: typically Power supply weights: 19 lbs Brooklyn, NY 11235.
(RCA), 1 balanced (XLR). 94dB, 22Hz–22kHz, below (8.6kg) net, 39 lbs (17.7kg) Tel: (718) 368-0181.
Input sensitivity: 0.135V 2V RMS output. Power shipping. Fax: (718) 368-0140. Web:
RMS, ±2%. Input imped- consumption: 80W. Finish Black www.lammindustries.com.
impedance of the original current-source transistors wasn’t that select between Line 1 and Line 2, and routes the signal
as high as he wanted, Lamm said; “the new transistors gave directly to the dual-mono, detented volume potentiometers.
me the chance to optimize the performance of the circuit’s I love the two-volume-pot arrangement, which provides a
first differential amplifier, and increase its signal-to-noise means of controlling the left/right balance without burden-
ratio. For me, this is a very serious achievement.” ing the signal with an additional pot for Balance. And it’s
Also new in the 2.1 Reference is a shift from electrolytic to Lamm’s opinion that a potentiometer always sounds better
high-voltage polypropylene capacitors for some of the posi- than any of its newer, more high-tech counterparts, includ-
tions in its power supply. The power-supply circuit topol- ing but not limited to resistive ladders and digital volume
ogy remains, in Lamm’s words, “very similar, except for the controls of every sort.
absence of those electrolytics: polypropylene caps are much All of the above-described inputs are single-ended only
better than electrolytics.” While noting the much higher cost (RCA jacks). Of the L2.1 Reference’s three outputs, two—
of these new caps, Lamm told me, “People are always asking the pair labeled Rec, grouped with their corresponding Tape
why I would spend so much on these very expensive capaci- inputs, and the pair labeled Single Ended (RCA jacks, all)—
tors, and my answer is always the same: If I could show you are themselves single-ended. The third pair of output jacks
the calculations, and if you could hear the improvement they (XLR sockets) are balanced, as marked, although Vladimir
make, you would see they are worth the price.” Lamm’s experience is that balanced operation confers no
Key elements of the original L2 Reference endure in the sonic advantage.
L2.1, especially the use of high-voltage MOSFETs in the In addition to the user controls described above, the L2.1
latter’s all-single-ended, class-A gain stages. According to Reference also offers a Mute/Operate switch, and a switch
Lamm, “because of high voltage, we have a gigantic linear labeled Phase 180/Phase 0, for inverting absolute phase
range, [so] we don’t need feedback: this is the natural way (signal polarity)—the latter, I came to realize, accomplished
to design electronics.” This element of the preamp’s design without delays or audible clacks. One more design element
is itself made possible by the use of a high-voltage (350V) deserving of mention has to do with not an added feature
power supply that uses two 12AX3 single-diode rectifier but one that is, happily, missing: a remote-control handset
tubes and a Russian 6C19P voltage-regulator tube; Lamm is not supplied with the L2.1 Reference, or with any Lamm
describes the latter as having “very good parameters, and product. The new preamp’s single concession to the seden-
[its] voltage drop is insignificant.” Two other tubes are used tary life is the ability to connect Lamm power amplifiers to
in the L2.1 Reference’s power supply: a 5651 voltage refer- the L2.1 in such a way that they can be turned on and off by
ence tube—“very stable, very low noise, with a much better a pair of Remote switches on the L2.1’s power supply. (The
temperature coefficient than zener diodes,” according to special cables required for this are not included.)
Lamm—in concert with a 12AX7 dual-triode, the latter used The construction quality evident in the L2.1 preamp and
to amplify errors before notching them out. its power supply is superb. The outwardly somber enclo-
Of the L2.1’s four line-level inputs, three—Line 1, Line 2, sures—solidly made aluminum-alloy boxes finished in satin
and Tape—are sonically identical. The fourth input, Direct, black, with white lettering and rack-mount handles—conceal
bypasses the Tape/Source toggle switches and the toggles hefty circuit boards with neat traces, cleanly precise solder-
MEASUREMENTS
I
measured the Lamm L2.1 Refer- The unbalanced output impedance, controls set to their maximum. There
ence preamplifier with my Audio specified as typically being 130 ohms, was no significant difference at lower
Precision SYS2722 system (see was 131 ohms at 1kHz and 139 ohms settings, and the balanced response
the January 2008 “As We See at 20kHz, but rose to 3.3k ohms at into 100k ohms was identical to the
It,” http://tinyurl.com/4ffpve4). All 20Hz, presumably due to the pres- unbalanced. Also note in this graph the
measurements were taken at the pre- ence of an output coupling capacitor. excellent channel matching, which was
amplifier’s Direct inputs, which bypass The balanced impedances were twice preserved at lower volume settings.
the input switching. The gain with the the unbalanced, again as expected. The Lamm’s channel separation was
volume control set to its maximum was With this very high output imped-
8.8dB, unbalanced input to unbalanced ance at low frequencies, it came as
output; and, as expected, 6dB higher no surprise that, when I tested the
from unbalanced input to balanced unbalanced frequency response into
output. The twin volume controls the very low 600 ohms load, the bass d
B
operated in accurate 1dB steps, and rolled off, reaching –3dB at 180Hz (fig.1, r
the unity-gain setting at the unbal- cyan and magenta traces). But into A
anced outputs was with the controls a much higher impedance (blue and
set to 3:30. Both sets of outputs red traces) the response was flat from
preserved absolute polarity (ie, were 50Hz to 50kHz, with the output down
non-inverting). The unbalanced inputs, by just 0.9dB at 10Hz and by 0.7dB at
Hz
specified as offering a usefully high 200kHz. As long as the L2.1 is used
input impedance of 50k ohms, met that with power amplifiers having an input Fig.1 Lamm L2.1 Reference, unbalanced frequency
figure at 20Hz and 1kHz. Though the impedance of 20k ohms or higher, the response at 1V into 100k ohms with volume control
set to maximum (left channel blue, right red) and
input impedance dropped to 44k ohms low frequencies will not sound lean. into 600 ohms (left cyan, right magenta) (1dB/
at 20kHz, this is inconsequential. This graph was taken with the volume vertical div.).
www.yg-acoustics.com +1-970-367-6077
LAMM INDUSTRIES L2.1 REFERENCE
measurements, continued
superb, at >120dB below 1kHz and still that the low-frequency noise floor was test set can’t deliver a voltage high
110dB at 20kHz. Noise levels were low: smooth, other than some very low-level enough to drive the L2.1 into clipping.
the wideband, unweighted signal/noise spuriae at the AC supply frequency Fig.3 shows that at the signal genera-
ratio, taken with the inputs shorted of 60Hz and its odd-order harmon- tor’s maximum output the L2.1 delivers
to ground but the volume controls ics (fig.2). These stem from magnetic 36V into 100k ohms, but the distor-
set to the maximum—the worst-case interference, perhaps from a supply tion is still only just above 0.1%. At
situation—measured 76.8dB ref. transformer—though for these tests lower output voltages the percentage
1V. Restricting the bandwidth to the I did have the separate power-supply of THD+noise is very low, reach-
audioband improved the ratio to an chassis on the floor, well away from the ing just 0.005% at 1.4V. Below that
excellent 87.8dB, with an A-weighting preamplifier chassis. level, the trace in fig.3 is dominated
filter giving further improvement to As I found with the original L2 Refer-
90.5dB. Spectral analysis revealed ence preamplifier,1 my Audio Precision 1 See http://tinyurl.com/m3cfaop.
d
B
r % %
Hz V V
Fig.2 Lamm L2.1 Reference, unbalanced spectrum Fig.3 Lamm L2.1 Reference, unbalanced distortion Fig.4 Lamm L2.1 Reference, unbalanced distortion
of 1kHz sinewave, DC–1kHz, at 1V into 100k ohms (%) vs 1kHz output voltage into 100k ohms. (%) vs 1kHz output voltage into 10k ohms.
(left channel blue, right red; linear frequency scale).
QRXQYHUõLõW\?âYHUWÖ?
1 : the quality or state of being true or real
2 : something (as a statement) that is true; especially : a fundamental and inevitably true value
3 : the quality or state of being truthful or honest
Listening
I know it’s gauche to quote oneself. I’m going to do it anyway.
In the October 2004 issue I wrote, in my review of
Lamm’s ML2.1 monoblock power amplifier: “To listen to
the ML2.1s was to imagine . . . that I was hearing music’s
original complex wave stripped of more garbage than ever
before: Notes were more distinct, as were the relationships
between them.”3 As I think I also made clear, the Lamm
monoblocks did this while preserving the natural timbral
richness and roundness of every one of those notes, from ev-
ery instrument and voice. The musical cleanness and clarity
of the Lamm amp gave lie to the notion that sonic richness
and color in an audio component are always additives—in
a word, distortions. Each distinct note, every reproduced
sound, was clean and rich.
So it was with the L2.1 preamplifier, which nailed the tone
and texture of the bassoon’s sustained note that bridges the
first and second movements of Mendels-
sohn’s Violin Concerto in e, with soloist Inside the L2.1
Jascha Heifetz and Charles Munch Reference preamp
(top) and power
3 See www.stereophile.com/ supply (bottom).
tubepoweramps/1004lamm/index.html.
measurements, continued
by noise. Reducing the load imped- at a level, 2V, where I could be sure graph was taken at 1V into 100k ohms;
ance to 10k ohms—which is about the that I was looking at THD rather than increasing the level to 2V did not in-
lowest impedance the preamplifier will N. Commendably, the measured figure crease the level of the distortion to any
encounter in a real-world system—the remains low across the audioband, and significant extent—this is extraordinary
picture was very similar (fig.4). Only the distortion signature is almost pure linearity for a circuit that is said not to
into the punishing load of 600 ohms second harmonic, this lying at –90dB use loop negative feedback.
did the Lamm actually clip (defined as (0.003%, fig.6). This graph was taken Like the other preamplifiers de-
1% THD+N), but even then, not until into 100k ohms; the second harmonic signed by Vladimir Lamm that have
3.3V (not shown). rose slightly into 10k ohms, to –87dB passed through my test lab, the L2.1
Fig.5 shows how the THD+N per- (0.0045%). Intermodulation distortion Reference is well engineered.
centage changes with frequency, taken was also extraordinarily low (fig.7). This —John Atkinson
d d
B B
% r r
A A
Hz Hz Hz
Fig.5 Lamm L2.1 Reference, unbalanced THD+N Fig.6 Lamm L2.1 Reference, unbalanced spectrum Fig.7 Lamm L2.1 Reference, unbalanced HF inter-
(%) vs frequency at 2V into 100k ohms (left chan- of 50Hz sinewave, DC–1kHz, at 1V into 100k ohms modulation spectrum, DC–30kHz, 19+20kHz at 1V
nel blue, right red) and 10k ohms (left gray) (linear (left channel red; linear frequency scale). into 100k ohms (left channel blue, right red; linear
frequency scale). frequency scale).
UDP-205
HERB REICHERT
AnalogueWorks Zero
TURNTABLE
M
y main task is to describe an au- The Zero turntable looks the realm of high-quality
dio component’s basic character. and feels like a classic record players.
How was it made? How did If accuracy of speed,
it fit into my system? How ef- 1958 MGA motorcar. wow and flutter, etc. were
fectively did it deliver musical performances? the only record-spinning
My goal is to create stories that generate sounds and images realities, every audiophile would own a Japanese direct-drive
in your mind—stories that will allow you to imagine how and that would be it. But, fortunately, scores of sophisticated
the component might perform in your system. turntables are being manufactured all over the globe, each
I can hear the moans from all you objectivist guys: Please, a representation of the unique engineering and aesthetic
Herb, spare us your purple prose. viewpoints of its designer, and each presenting recordings of
But guys! Our full appreciation of music, art, and perfec- music in its own distinctive manner.
tionist audio depends entirely on our ability to imagine. The Don’t believe me? Then watch the extraordinary video
most practical measure of any hi-fi component’s usefulness, by Michael Fremer in which he compares his Continuum
hence its value, is to listen to diverse recordings and notice Audio Labs Caliburn turntable and Swedish Analog Tech-
how they grip (or don’t) our attention, how they stir our nologies tonearm with Technics’ new SL-1200G.1 It clearly
moods and provoke our imagination. demonstrates how differently two high-quality turntables,
My purple prose, John Atkinson’s measurements, the best with different types of drive system but the same cartridge
recordings—all are completely useless if we can’t imagine
what they describe. And nowhere is this more true than in 1 See www.youtube.com/watch?v=qY9YYkqW8ng.
SPECIFICATIONS
Description Belt-drive turn- (13kg) shipping. ber of dealers: 8. Tel: (44) (0)1536-762211.
table. Motor: AC synchro- Finish Birch ply (plinth). Manufacturer Web:
nous. Speeds: 33 1⁄3, 45rpm. Serial number of unit AnalogueWorks, www.analogueworks.co.uk.
Platter: aluminum, 4.9kg. reviewed 000018. Divine Audio Ltd., Harbor- US distributor: High Fidelity
Dimensions (without Prices $1595 with blank ough Innovation Centre, Services, 2 Keith Way, Suite
tonearm): 18.4" (468mm) armboard; $1995 with Jelco Airfield Business Park, 4, Hingham, MA 02043.
W by 4.25" (108mm) H by SA-250 tonearm; $2095, as Leicester Road, Market Tel: (781) 987-3434.
14.5" (369mm) D. Weights: reviewed, with Jelco SA-750 Harborough LE16 7WB, Fax: (781) 949-2998.
24.25 lbs (11kg) net, 28.7 lbs tonearm. Approximate num- England, UK. Web: www.hifiservices.com.
vitusaudio.com
ANALOGUEWORKS ZERO
and phono stage, can play the Left to right: The Zero’s platter bearing,
same LP. disassembled; the same bearing,
That said, I will now attempt assembled; one of the Zero’s
supporting feet, disassembled.
the impossible: to keep my purple
prose to a minimum while de-
scribing the unique sound charac-
ter and essential value of a brand-
new, moderately priced turntable:
the AnalogueWorks Zero ($1595
with blank armboard).
Motor axioms
I’d been using the Palmer Audio 2.5 turntable2 for a while double pulley: one wheel each for 331⁄3 and 45rpm. The
when, in October 2016, I encountered the AnalogueWorks motor pod is connected, via a captive cable, to an outboard
Zero at the Rocky Mountain Audio Fest. I said to Paul supply called the Black Eye, designed by British power-sup-
Manos of High Fidelity Services, AnalogueWorks’ US dis- ply specialist Martin Bastin. I was disappointed to see that
tributor, “Look! A baby Palmer!” He did not smile. I asked, this supply doesn’t have a speed-adjustment pot.
“Do you have to spin the platter with your hand to get it The Zero’s AC synchronous motor drives a substantial
going?” Then he smiled, and answered in the affirmative. I (10.8 lbs) aluminum platter via a silicone belt. Wrapped
told Manos that I was a slow learner, and that the Palmer 2.5 around the top edge of the platter is a second, thicker belt, the
was only now, belatedly, teaching me the lessons of the old purpose of which, I assume, is to mechanically reduce platter
Nottingham Analogue worldview. ringing. The plinth and platter, but not the motor, sit on three
When I first read about Nottingham Analogue Studio, I height-adjustable compound-polymer isolation feet.
learned that its founder, the late Tom Fletcher, believed that, My review sample came with a 9", gimbal-bearinged SA-
to reduce noise, it’s best to use a heavy platter driven, via a 750 tonearm (available with the Zero for a package price of
soft belt, by a motor so low in torque that when you switch $2095), made in Japan by Jelco Ichikawa Jewels. It features a
it on, the platter’s weight stalls the motor. You give the removable, SME-mount headshell with adjustable azimuth.
platter a push with your hand, and its mass and momentum Using one of its two provided counterweights (one heavy,
take over. All the motor does is feed a little speed-stabilizing one light), the arm can accommodate cartridges weighing
energy into the rotating mass. 5 to 24gm. On the top of the SA-750’s horizontal bearing
I laughed at this ridiculous concept. I believed that Fletch- is an adjustable, oil-fillable damping pot that can be used to
er’s idea was flat-Earth fiction fed to gullible audiophiles, tune the arm’s motional response when used with higher-
and that my much-less-expensive, high-torque, direct- and compliance cartridges. The antiskating bias is set with a
rim-drive turntables were far superior pieces of modern rotary spring control.
engineering. I thought belt drives were rinky-dink, and that
any basement DIY guy could build one. Setup
Years later, when I finally listened to a Nottingham Setting up the Zero is easy—I’ve done it now at least five
Spacedeck and the Fletcher-designed Ace-Space tonearm, times. Start by putting the plinth-tonearm assembly exactly
the fictions I’d both created and accepted dominated my where you want it and, on that surface, mark the position of
perceptions. I remember shrugging my shoulders and think- the motor cutout. Place the motor pod on that spot and low-
ing, No slam, too precious sounding, and definitely overpriced! (In er the plinth over it, making sure that pod and plinth never
2005, for example, the Spacedeck retailed for $1800 without come into contact with each other. Connect the captive mo-
a tonearm.) tor lead to the power supply. At this point I recommend that
But now, direct daily experience of implementations of you switch on the motor, and feel the top of the plinth with
Fletcher’s ideas has opened my mind about how the motor’s your hand—or listen to it through a stethoscope—for motor
torque, the drive system, and the platter’s mass affect the vibrations. Adjust the pod’s position until the plinth is com-
character of a turntable’s sound. After listening at length to pletely still and silent. If that never quite happens, it means
Fletcher-inspired turntables manufactured by Palmer Audio, that vibrations are being transmitted through the surface that
Pear Audio—and now the AnalogueWorks Zero, designed both plinth and pod are sitting on. You may need some sort
by Tim Chorlton—I’m finally appreciating the unique of isolation platform.
“black” quietude, subtly described midrange, and pure, Put two drops of the supplied lubricant on the platter-
grainless highs that can be heard when a low-torque motor bearing spindle—one on the tip, the other on the shaft—and
is harnessed to a high-mass platter. lower the shaft into the bearing well. Loop the longer,
thinner belt around the lower motor pulley and the lower
Description platter groove, then the shorter, fatter belt in the platter’s
The British-made AnalogueWorks Zero turntable looks topmost groove.
and feels no-frills basic, like a classic 1958 MGA motorcar: I’ve always believed that the four mechanical and eight
its plinth is a slice of birch-ply laminate 18.4" wide by 0.94" soldered connections associated with detachable headshells
thick by 14.5" deep and pierced by three holes. The platter’s must represent a sonic compromise—but my years spent
bearing well of leaded bronze goes through the center hole, with Abis, Fidelity Research, and SME tonearms suggest
the tonearm pillar through another, and the diameter of that this may be difficult to prove or even hear. But I’ve since
the freestanding, cylindrical motor pod is only 0.157" less discovered that the cartridge/headshell interface is a much
than that of the third hole, which the pod must fill without 2 See Michael Fremer’s review of the Palmer 2.5 in “Analog Corner” in the
touching the plinth. The motor is crowned by a stepped November 2014 issue.
YPSILON ELECTRONICS
!!!"#$%&'()*'*+,-()&+%"+(.
ANALOGUEWORKS ZERO
The new Stellar line brings the DNA of Class A+ DirectStream DAC and BHK Signature separates to a
remarkably-low price point. They don’t just sound “great for the money”: They sound great. Period.
Stellar Gain Cell DAC with built-in analog preamp $1699
Stellar S300 Stereo Power Amplifier, 300 w/channel, $1499
Stellar M700 Mono Power Amplifier, 700w/channel, $1499/each, $2998/pair
888.850.4366 | HighPerformanceStereo.com
ANALOGUEWORKS ZERO
JOHN ATKINSON
Arcam
irDAC-II
D/A PROCESSOR
F
or digital playback, in recent Karen Carpenter’s Description
months I’ve been breathing The irDAC-II is a small box about the
some rarefied air, pricewise. In husky tones sounded size of a thick paperback book, finished
December 2016, I reviewed appropriately intimate in black. Inset on the front panel is a
dCS’s Rossini Player and Clock,1 via the Arcam. small plate with a 3.5mm headphone
followed in May 2017 by Meridian’s jack and the sensor for the infrared
Ultra DAC,2 and in June by Chord’s remote control. Along the top of the
DAVE DAC. The Rossini Player costs reach of the cash-strapped middle class. front panel’s radiused top edge are six
$28,499 without the Clock, the Merid- Arcam’s irDAC-II was released a year LEDs, each of which glows green to
ian $23,000, and though the DAVE is ago to celebrate the British company’s indicate which input has been selected:
less expensive than either at $10,588, 40th anniversary. It’s an updated ver- USB, Optical 1 and 2, Coaxial 1 and
that’s still a fair chunk of change. Even sion of the irDAC (2013), and adds 2, and Bluetooth. (The USB and Blue-
PS Audio’s PerfectWave DirectStream Bluetooth connectivity, a headphone tooth LEDs glow red when no data
DAC, which I bought following Art amplifier stage taken from Arcam’s
Dudley’s review in September 2014,3 flagship A49 amplifier, support for 1 See www.stereophile.com/content/
costs $6899 with the Network Bridge DSD128 files, and a high-performance dcs-rossini-player-rossini-clock.
2 See www.stereophile.com/content/
II, which hardly counts as “affordable.” ESS ES9016K2M DAC chip, but meridian-audio-ultra-dac-da-processor.
High time, therefore, that I lived eliminates the USB Type A jack and 3 See www.stereophile.com/content/
with a D/A processor priced more in the coaxial digital output. It costs $749. ps-audio-perfectwave-directstream-da-processor.
SPECIFICATIONS
Description D/A processor USB; 16–24/32–96, TosLink; Bluetooth antenna, remote number of dealers: 175.
& headphone amplifier with 16–24/32–192, coax; SBC, control, stereo phono–phono Manufacturer Arcam, The
volume control. Digital aptX, aptX-Ll, AAC cable, optical & coaxial West Wing, Stirling House,
inputs: 2 coaxial (RCA), 2 Bluetooth. Frequency digital cables, USB A–B cable. Waterbeach, Cambridge
TosLink, 1 USB (Type B), 1 response: 20Hz–20kHz, Dimensions 7.6" (194mm) CB25 9PB, England, UK.
Bluetooth. Analog outputs: ±0.1dB. THD+N: 0.0007% W by 1.75" (44mm) H by Tel: (44) (0)1223-203200.
1 pair unbalanced, fixed ref. 0dBFS. Signal/noise 4.9" (124mm) D. Weight: Web: www.arcam.co.uk.
output (RCA); 1 pair (A-weighted): 115dB. 2.4 lbs (1.1kg). US distributor:
unbalanced, variable output Maximum output level: Finish Black. The Sound Organisation,
(RCA); 1 headphone 2.15V RMS, line; 4V RMS, Serial number of unit 159 Leslie Street, Dallas, TX
(3.5mm). Digital formats headphone. Output reviewed EDIC801291 75207.
supported: 16–24-bit/32– impedance (headphones): 1 (“Made in PRC”). Tel: (972) 234-0182.
384kHz, PCM; DSD64/128, ohm. Supplied accessories: Price $749. Approximate Web: https://soundorg.com.
are being received.) On the top panel are four pushbuttons: Gabriel’s Secret World Live (16/44.1 ALAC file ripped from
two to choose an input, two to raise and lower the output CD, Geffen), Tony Levin’s double-stopped bass line punc-
level. The rear panel has two pairs of outputs on RCA jacks, tuated by an underdamped kickdrum remained clean and
one pair fixed in level and one pair variable; two S/PDIF clear. Billy Drummond’s kick drum in “Followthrough,”
inputs on RCA jacks handling streams with sample rates up from the Jerome Harris Quintet’s Rendezvous, which I
to 192kHz; two S/PDIF on TosLink jacks that are limited recorded in 1998 (16/44.1 ALAC file from CD, Stereophile
to 96kHz data; a Bluetooth antenna; a USB Type B input STPH013-2, no longer available), was well defined, despite
jack; the Power switch; and the input jack for the wall-wart its resonant tuning.
power supply. I wondered if the fact that the irDAC-II is powered by a
Operation simply involves choosing an input by scroll- wall-wart supply would limit its dynamics, but it reproduced
ing with the top-panel buttons. If Bluetooth is selected, the the solitary conga drum that begins “Hotel California,” from
relevant LED flashes purple while the user simultaneously the Eagles’ Hell Freezes Over (24/44.1 ALAC file ripped from
presses the two input buttons to pair a smartphone, tablet, DVD, DTS Entertainment 71021-51006-2-3), with superb
or PC. When the connection has been established, the LED slam. The individual tone color of Drummond’s drums and
glows a steady blue when music is playing. Simultaneously cymbals in his solo on “Followthrough” were well differ-
pressing both volume buttons mutes the irDAC-II’s output, entiated, as were the various tuned percussion instruments
and the LED for the input in use turns orange. A second providing the minimalist accompaniment to Peter Gabriel’s
push of both volume buttons together lifts the mute. The hoarse vocal in “San Jacinto,” from Security (16/44.1 ALAC
remote control duplicates the top-panel functions, and adds file ripped from UK CD, Charisma).
transport control of a PC or Mac USB source via the Hu- Though the acoustic of Blue Heaven Studios, in Salina,
man Interface Device (HID) protocol. Kansas, was readily apparent in “Followthrough,” the
soundstage was a little shallower than I’m used to with
Listening in the Big Rig the PS Audio DAC. Playing Patricia Kopatchinskaja’s fiery
As the irDAC-II has a volume control and I currently don’t performance of the Tchaikovsky Violin Concerto, with Mu-
have a preamplifier, I plugged it straight into my power sicAeterna conducted by Teodor Currentzis (16/44.1 FLAC
amplifiers with unbalanced AudioQuest Cheetah intercon- file ripped from CD, Sony Classical 88875165122—a tip of
nects. The sound was good from the outset. The balance the hat to Jon Iverson for recommending this recording), the
was overall a tad lightweight, though with good definition soundstage was again a little shallower than I expected, but
in the low frequencies. In “Don’t Give Up,” from Peter the highs were more delicately rendered than the PS Audio
MEASUREMENTS
I
measured the Arcam irDAC-II chronous asynchronous mode. Apple’s all three outputs preserved absolute
with my Audio Precision SYS2722 AudioMIDI utility revealed that, via polarity (ie, were non-inverting). The
system (see the January 2008 USB, the Arcam accepted 32-bit float output impedance from the fixed
“As We See It,” http://tinyurl. and 24-bit integer data sampled at all and variable outputs was a low 47
com/4ffpve4), using the Audio Preci- rates from 44.1 to 384kHz. The opti- ohms from 20Hz to 20kHz, and the
sion’s optical and electrical digital cal input locked to datastreams with impedance from the headphone jack
outputs, USB data sourced from my sample rates up to 96kHz, the coaxial was a constant 1 ohm across the same
MacBook Pro running on battery power S/PDIF inputs locked to streams of up range. The irDAC-II’s impulse response
with Pure Music 3.0 playing WAV to 192kHz-sampled data. Via Blue- with data sampled at 44.1kHz (fig.1)
and AIFF test-tone files, and with the tooth, the Arcam was identified as revealed the reconstruction filter to be
same files played on an iPhone 6S, an “irDAC2 f93a.” a conventional FIR type, with time-
iPad2, and an HTC Android phone via The Arcam’s maximum output symmetrical ringing.
Bluetooth. Apple’s USB Prober utility level at 1kHz was 2.15V from both its The magenta and red traces in fig.2
identified the irDAC-II as “irDAC-II” variable and fixed line-level RCA jacks, show that this filter rolls off rapidly
from “ARCAM,” and revealed that its 4.01V from its headphone jack, and
USB port operated in the optimal iso-
d
d B
B r
r
A
V
Hz
Hz
Fig.3 Arcam irDAC-II, frequency response at
sec Fig.2 Arcam irDAC-II, wideband spectrum of white –12dBFS into 100k ohms with data sampled at:
noise at –4dBFS (left channel red, right magenta) 44.1kHz (left channel green, right gray), 96kHz (left
Fig.1 Arcam irDAC-II, impulse response (one sample and 19.1kHz tone at 0dBFS (left blue, right cyan), cyan, right magenta), 192kHz (left blue, right red),
at 0dBFS, 44.1kHz sampling, 4ms time window). with data sampled at 44.1kHz (20dB/vertical div.). 384kHz (left blue, right green) (1dB/vertical div.).
and there was an appealing tactile quality to the sound of DAC, as they did when I substituted a short AudioQuest
the admittedly large solo instrument. Perhaps Kopatchin- Forest USB link for the Belkin with the Antipodes.
skaja is a fan of the late Jascha Heifetz—the orchestra (The engineer who recorded Kopatchinskaja’s Tchai-
peeks around her shoulders just as it did around Heifetz kovsky could learn from Ondine how a violin should be
on his recordings! recorded.) So either the Arcam or the Antipodes is fussy
I had no problem playing when it comes to
single-rate DSD files with the handling high data
irDAC-II, using either the rates via USB.
Aurender N10 or Antipodes DX
servers. I have a secret love of Listening with
Karen Carpenter’s singing—her Headphones
breath control rivaled Sinatra’s in As it did in the
his prime—and in “We’ve Only big rig, the Ar-
Just Begun,” from the Carpen- cam irDAC-II’s
ters’ Singles 1969–1981 (DSD64 headphone output
file, A&M/Analogue Produc- offered, in absolute
tions), her husky tones sounded terms, a some-
appropriately intimate via the what light balance
Arcam. And the complicated combined with
kick-drum pattern in this track didn’t interfere with the clean highs and an excellent presentation of recorded detail.
subtly balanced bass guitar. It worked well with both the Audeze LCD-X and Audio-
However, when I tried to play double-speed DSD files Quest NightHawk headphones, less so with the Think-
with the Antipodes, such as my recent purchase of Chris- sound On2s, where the highs sounded a little aggressive.
tian Tetzlaff and Lars Vogt’s superbly idiomatic recording However, it could readily swing enough volts to drive the
of the complete Brahms Violin Sonatas (DSD128 file, On- high-impedance Sennheiser HD650s to satisfying levels. But
dine/HDtracks ODE1284-2D), the irDAC-II’s USB input I needed to hear how it compared with other D/A head-
light turned red and there was no output. Sourcing the phone amplifiers.
same DSD128 files from the Aurender via the same long The perfect comparison would have set the irDAC-II
Belkin Gold USB link, they played fine with the Arcam against Chord’s Mojo D/A headphone amplifier ($599),
measurements, continued
above the audioband, with the aliased and 3 were taken from the fixed out- bit depth from 16 to 24 with a dithered
product at 25kHz of a full-scale tone puts; the responses were identical from 1kHz tone at –90dBFS dropped the
at 19.1kHz (cyan and blue traces) the variable and headphone outputs. noise floor by around 21dB (fig.4),
suppressed by >110dB. Fig.3 is a more Channel separation (not shown) was suggesting that this inexpensive DAC
conventional way of showing frequency superb, at 125dB in both directions at offers close to 20-bit resolution, which
response, in this instance taken with 1kHz, and decreasing to a still-excellent is excellent. However, with 24-bit data
data sampled at 44.1, 96, 192, and 110dB at the top and bottom of the (blue and red traces), the reduction in
384kHz. In each case, the response audioband, the former due to capaci- analog noise unmasks some distor-
falls sharply just below half the sample tive coupling somewhere in the circuit, tion, the highest-level harmonic being
rate, and other than with 384kHz the latter to the wall-wart supply’s the second. With an undithered 16-bit
data, the channels are superbly well increasing impedance at low frequen- tone at –90.31dBFS (fig.5), the three
matched. At 384kHz, the right channel cies. The level of random background DC voltage levels described by the data
(green trace) rolls off a little earlier noise was very low, but some low-level are very well defined, and other than
than the left (blue), reaching –3dB at spuriae were present at 60Hz and its 25μV DC offset in the right channel
80kHz compared with 100kHz. Figs. 2 odd-order harmonics. Increasing the (red trace), the two channels match
d d
B B
r V r
A A
Hz sec Hz
Fig.4 Arcam irDAC-II, spectrum with noise and Fig.5 Arcam irDAC-II, waveform of undithered 1kHz Fig.6 Arcam irDAC-II, spectrum of 50Hz sinewave,
spuriae of dithered 1kHz tone at –90dBFS with: 16- sinewave at –90.31dBFS, 16-bit TosLink data (left DC–1kHz, at 0dBFS into 600 ohms (left channel
bit data (left channel cyan, right magenta), 24-bit channel blue, right red). blue, right red; linear frequency scale).
data (left blue, right red) (20dB/vertical div.).
800-449-8333 | MUSICDIRECT.COM
AURENDER N10 Music Server NAIM DAC-V1 Asynchronous USB McINTOSH D150 DSD DAC/
$7,999 DSD DAC/Digital Preamplifier $2,595 Headphone Amplifier $3,000
iFi Pro iDSD DAC PS AUDIO PerfectWave Memory Player MERIDIAN Explorer2
$1,999 CD/SACD Transport $5,999 MQA USB DAC NOW $199
NightOwl
ARCAM IRDAC-II
Around-the-Ear
Closed-Back
Headphone
measurements, continued
well. With 24-bit undithered data (not harmonic was the highest in level, at
shown), the Arcam output a well- the same –111dB. All the previous tests
formed sinewave despite the very low were taken with S/PDIF or USB data;
level of the tone. as with Bluetooth-sourced data, the
Harmonic distortion at high signal performance will greatly depend on
levels was very low, even into 600 the code used, whether aptX (Android
ohms (fig.6), with the third harmonic phones and my MacBook Pro) or
the highest in level from the line out- SBC (iPhones and iPads). I examined
puts at just –111dB (0.0003%). From the behavior of these codecs in the
the headphone outputs, the second measurements that accompanied our
review of Arcam’s rBlink.1 Basically, the
superior-sounding aptX trades off low-
level resolution in favor of preserving
a random noise floor, whereas AAC
seems to try to preserve resolution at
Extreme Comfort
d
B
r
the expense of noise-floor modulation +
and the introduction of enharmonic
A
spuriae. However, even aptX introduc- Superb Isolation
es noise modulation, as can be seen in
fig.7, which plots the spectrum of the =
Hz
Arcam’s output as it decodes aptX-
encoded Bluetooth data representing
Musical inspiration
Fig.7 Arcam irDAC-II, spectrum of 1kHz sinewave,
DC–10kHz, at 0dBFS (left channel blue, right
a 1kHz tone at 0dBFS (blue and red
traces) and at –20dBFS (green and
all day long
red) and at –20dBFS (left green, right gray), both
sourced from MacBook Pro via Bluetooth (linear 1 See www.stereophile.com/content/arcam-rblink-
frequency scale). bluetooth-da-processor-measurements.
High
Fidelity
H i g h E n d • 2 0 1 6
US dealers: The Audio Salon, Santa Monica CA | Audio Salon, Miami FL | David Lewis Audio, Philadelphia PA | EarsNova, New York NY
David Michael Audio, Detroit MI | Don Better Audio, Cleveland OH | Goodwin’s High End, Boston MA | JS Audio, Washington DC
Musical Artisans, Chicago IL | Music Lovers, San Francisco CA | Ne Plus Ultra, Austin TX | Arizona Hi-Fi, Phoenix AZ
Canada dealers: Audio Eden, Toronto ON | Element Acoustics, Vancouver BC | Filtronique, Montreal QC
ARCAM IRDAC-II
output. Once I’d adjusted the Arcam’s The Arcam opened up "extraordinarily
output level to match the Meridian’s,
therefore, I could adjust the volume
a somewhat cleaner,
clearer view into the
powerful...
with Pure Music without worrying
that I would interfere with the level recorded acoustic. uncolored...
matching between the two DACs. All
comparisons were performed with Au- natural"
dioQuest’s NightHawk headphones. file, Hear Music/HDtracks), the low- - John Atkinson, Stereophile .
Art Dudley had written of the pitched drums were better defined
Explorer’s headphone output that the and had more impact with the Arcam
sound was “a little more opaque” than driving the AQs. With my unreleased
he expected, and while I’ve enjoyed recording of organist Jonas Nordwall
using the Meridian on and off since playing the Toccata from Widor’s
his review, compared with the Arcam’s Organ Symphony 5 (24/88.2 AIFF
headphone output, yes—it was a little file), both DACs did surprisingly well
opaque. The individual singers in Eriks with this recording’s high levels of very
Esenvalds’s “A Drop in the Ocean,” low frequencies. At climaxes, however,
from the Portland State Chamber the Arcam better preserved the sense
Choir’s 2013 album of that title (16/44.1 of space in the First United Methodist
AIFF master file), were less distin- Church of Portland, Oregon.
guishable than with the irDAC-II, the The Meridian is excellent value
sound a slight touch more midrange- for money—or it was until it was
dominant. The Arcam opened up a replaced, at the same price, by the
somewhat cleaner, clearer view into MQA-capable Explorer 2, reviewed
the recorded acoustic, which surprised by Jim Austin in June 20166 —but the
me—I’d expected the Meridian’s use of Arcam adds S/PDIF inputs and edges
a minimum-phase reconstruction filter it out in sound quality.
to give it an edge in that respect.
The irDAC-II’s low frequencies also Listening with Blue Teeth
sounded a bit cleaner than the Explor- I had last listened extensively to
er’s, with more subjective extension. CONTINUED ON PAGE 115
In “The Afterlife,” from Paul Simon’s 6 See www.stereophile.com/content/
So Beautiful or So What (24/96 ALAC meridian-explorer2-da-headphone-amplifier.
Hz JosephAudio
Hz Fig.9 Arcam irDAC-II, high-resolution jitter spec-
trum of analog output signal, 11.025kHz at –6dBFS,
Fig.8 Arcam irDAC-II, HF intermodulation spec- sampled at 44.1kHz with LSB toggled at 229Hz: EFFORTLESS MUSICALITY
trum, DC–30kHz, 19+20kHz at 0dBFS into 600 16-bit TosLink data (left channel blue, right red). EXCLUSIVE TECHNOLOGY
ohms, 44.1kHz data (left channel blue, right red; Center frequency of trace, 11.025kHz; frequency
linear frequency scale). range, ±3.5kHz. (800) 474- HIFI (4434)
T
he words right and wrong and good and
bad make me uncomfortable. As-
signing virtue or value is against my
religion. And thinking that I know
the best way to design a loudspeaker, amplifier,
or record player would only prove that I’m a
conceited old fool. Therefore . . .
When I feel the urge to upgrade my analog
pleasures, I keep an open mind and endeavor
to shop outside my comfort zone. And,
because I can, I consult with me ol’ runnin’
buddy Michael Trei, contributing editor to
Sound & Vision, and collector and setter-up of
turntables. I also study the wisdom of Stereo-
phile senior editor Michael Fremer.
Last year, after I’d reviewed the Technics SL-
1200GAE1 and Roksan Radius 7 2 turntables,
the two Michaels spoke in unison: “Herb, you
need to move up the analog food chain.” Meaning I needed photo on my Facebook page. He said it was a great ’table.
to experience some 21st-century perfectionist analog. Trei “Did you buy it? You could learn from it.”
suggested I try auditioning turntables from the likes of The first and most obvious thing I learned was how
Brinkmann Audio, Dr. Feickert Analogue, and Döhmann. raucous and unquiet all my previous turntables had been.
“But they’re not British!” I protested. He laughed. “Okay, Fremer always writes about “black” backgrounds, and I’d
maybe you’re not ready for Nietzsche or Kant. What about always assumed I knew what he meant. But moments after
Palmer Audio?” I’d first started the Palmer’s 22-lb platter spinning by giving
That night, I read Fremer’s November 2014 review of it a push with my hand, I sat down and smiled. There it is, I
the Palmer 2.5 turntable ($8990)3 with Audio Origami thought: a genuine “black” background. My next thought: What
PU7 tonearm ($3000), and the quotes from that review’s a fool I’ve been. I used to make fun of Tom Fletcher and low-torque
summary in “Recommended Components”: “attractive, turntable motors, and now I’m marveling at this one’s silence and
velvety midband,” “black backgrounds,” “serenity and understated authority.
smooth musical flow.” I liked the sounds of all those words, Then I remembered: True audio connoisseurship requires a
especially “velvety midband” and “serenity and smooth long life of mindful listening and open-mindedness.
musical flow.” They made me call Palmer importer Walter Now, suddenly, I am stunned, drunk, stoned as I revel in
Swanbon, of Fidelis Music Systems, and ask to borrow that the Palmer 2.5’s “black” backgrounds. This dark quietness
same setup so that I could write a Follow-Up on the 2.5. frames singers and instruments in a way that directs my
He told me that borrowing a 2.5 “was possible—but not attention toward the musical content. Obviously, we have to
probable. Jon Palmer makes them one at a time and they all pay extra for such luxurious framing—but that silent “black-
go to customers.” ness” and the deep musical spaces it makes possible added
A month later, Swanbon was standing, unannounced, visual, sonic, and emotional impact to every record played.
outside my bunker, holding a big, heavy box. Then I remembered how, once upon a time, my hero
Since buying my very first turntable, a Dual 1019, I’ve Art Dudley marveled at his serendipitous discovery of
owned dozens of exotic record-playing systems. None of high-torque turntable motors: “The turntables that have
them prepared me for the experience of the British-made impressed me most . . . the ones that are the most musically
Palmer 2.5 with Audio Origami PU7 tonearm. compelling, and that tease from my records the greatest
I listened to the Palmer-Origami deck with a variety degree of musical flow, momentum, drama, and sheer
of as-yet-unreviewed cartridges, but I have restricted this force—all have high-torque motors.”5 Until recently, me and
Follow-Up to what I heard using EMT’s luminous and my 1957 Thorens TD 124 turntable felt that way too. But
real-sounding TSD 75 moving-coil ($2095), which is an buying a Linn LP12 reopened my mind to suspended sub-
anniversary edition of the popular TSD 15, fitted with a chassis turntables and the low-torque motors they virtually
super-fineline stylus ($1950).4 Also, I describe the Not- always use. To take this a step further: Using the Roksan
tingham Audio Tom Fletcher-ness of the Palmer and Pear Radius 7 with its Nima tonearm showed me how unipivot
Audio turntables in my review of the Analogueworks Zero tonearms can deliver extra-textured midranges. Reviewing
turntable, elsewhere in this issue. Here I’ll describe only Rega Research’s Planar 36 started me thinking philosophi-
how the Palmer 2.5 worked, slowly and subtly, to teach me cally about the natures of music, noise, and silence. Now,
an important lesson in the sound characters of turntable the Palmer 2.5 and Analogueworks Zero are showing me
drive systems. the deeper pleasures of almost no torque.
Fremer was surprised when he saw the Palmer 2.5 in a Of course, a lower-powered motor generates less power-
ful noise. But does it hamper musical displayed a unique form of momen- In my modest system, the Palmer-
flow or momentum? I have tediously tum that reminded me of gravity and Origami combo sounded best with
investigated that question, and I would planetary motions. There was an eerie cartridges that were fast, beautiful,
now say that in the Palmer 2.5 it does cosmic strength and silent power and resolving—like the EMT TSD 75.
not. But clearly, the force and feel behind the Palmer’s transcriptions that But surely, the Palmer’s outer-space
of that momentum differed greatly was more powerful than my Thorens silence, coupled to the PU7’s preci-
between a low-torque motor turn- TD 124, Linn LP12, and Technics SL- sion, just begs for a nice Lyra, Fuuga,
ing a high-mass platter of copper and 1200GAE combined. But the Palmer’s or Koetsu cartridge.
aluminum (like the Palmer’s), and lots power was completely invisible—like “Herb, you should buy that Palmer—
of torque twisting a relatively low- the hand of God. it’ll be good for you!” Ultimately, the
mass Lexan platter (like the Voyd TT3 Something tells me that the source Palmer Audio 2.5 played the zydeco,
Super turntable Art was discussing). of this uncanny, invisible force was the bluegrass, choral, piano, and early
Long ago, I owned and loved a rotating mass of the Palmer’s thick cop- music I cherish so damned evocatively
three-motor Voyd turntable. I was per-clad aluminum platter. Whatever that I feel I must now do as the two
friendly with its designer, Guy Adams, the cause, this natural power imparted Michaels suggested. —Herb Reichert
and thought highly of his engineering a unique form of transparency to the
1 See “Gramophone Dreams” in the August 2016
intelligence. I felt uncomfortable sell- Palmer’s bass and treble. This constant issue: www.stereophile.com/content/
ing my trusty Denon direct-drive ’table sense of a silent, invisible force was the gramophone-dreams-11.
and replacing it with a British belt- Palmer 2.5’s core virtue. Fremer called 2 See “Gramophone Dreams” in the October 2016
issue: www.stereophile.com/content/
drive design—but the Voyd was simply it “serenity and smooth musical flow.” gramophone-dreams-12.
more together, in terms of rhythm and A chunk of this serenity must be 3 Palmer Audio Ltd., 12 High Street, Lamport,
momentum. Most important, the Voyd attributed to the Audio Origami PU7 Northamptonshire NN6 9HB, England, UK. US
distributor: Fidelis Music Systems, 460 Amherst
played solo-piano LPs with beguiling tonearm, which steers and wrangles Street (Route 101A), Nashua, NH 03063.
authority. However, today I’m experi- every cartridge with extraordinary Tel: (603) 880-4434. Fax: (603) 880-4433.
encing a more focused force behind the precision. Our Recommended Com- Web: www.fidelisav.com.
4 See Art Dudley’s review of the EMT TSD 15 in
Palmer’s musical flow than I remember ponents blurb noted the midrange the May 2011 “Listening”: www.stereophile.com/
hearing from my high-torque Voyd—or richness of the Palmer-Origami duo, content/listening-101.
from any other turntable I’ve owned. but urged prospective owners to “con- 5 See the March 2009 “Listening”: www.stereophile.
com/artdudleylistening/listening_75/.
I hear more subtlety, more realistic sider cartridges that, in other settings,
6 See my “Gramophone Dreams” in the February
piano corpus from the Palmer. might be considered on the lean side 2017 issue: www.stereophile.com/content/
Recordings played on the Palmer of neutral.” gramophone-dreams-14-rega-planar-3.
NO O C
Instantly achieve better sound from any USB DAC by utilizing iFi iUSB3.0
technology to separate your music signal from the noisy power signal.
800-449-8333 | MUSICDIRECT.COM
Find all your hot music & gear at
elusivedisc.com
A Trusted Name Since 1989!
Roger Waters | New Solo Album Flying Burrito Brothers UHQCD Reference Sampler %HDWOHV_6JW3HSSHU·VWK
Columbia 2LP Intervention 180g LP & SACD Sony Jpn Import UHQCD Capitol 180g 2LP
James Horner | Avatar Diana Krall | Turn Up Ellington | Masterpieces McLaughlin, De Meola & De Lucia The Nat King Cole Story U2 | Joshua Tree 30th
MOV Blue Vinyl 180g 2LP Verve 2LP AP 200g 45rpm 2LP Audio Fidelity 180g LP AP 200g 45rpm 5LP Island 7LP Box Set
Buddy Holly | Buddy Holly Beethoven | 5 Sonatas Derek & The Dominos Rimsky-Korsakov | Scheherazade Joe Cocker | Mad Dogs Alison Krauss | Windy City
AP 200g LP & SACD Analogphonic 180g 3LP MoFi SACD & 180g 2LP Hi-Q Records 180g LP A&M 180g 2LP Capitol 180g LP
RECORD REVIEWS
T
he blues, that wonder- It’s the classy, grown-up hit this
ful basis of so much EDITOR’S PICK album was clearly seeking.
American popular
music, has for many RECORDING For another flavor, “Soul” has
a world-music vibe of the kind
listeners grown a bit stale and OF THE MONTH that Taj has occasionally made a
old-fashioned. It’s not much of part of his act. The tune is pow-
a draw outside bar bands, and ered by the largest band on the
other than Alligator Records record—including a brass section,
and APO Records, most of the a B3, and a Fender Rhodes—and
biggest blues labels have folded the return of Shelia E. “Soul”
or gone dormant. Losing many is one of two tracks co-written
of the music’s first- and second- by Mahal and Mo’. The other,
generation practitioners hasn’t “Don’t Leave Me Here,” opens
helped. the album. With Billy Branch’s
So when you combine the harmonica licks and Keb’ Mo’s
wide-ranging talents of Taj always tasty electric-guitar work,
Mahal and Keb’ Mo’, two players this mid-tempo electric blues is
whose singing and playing are gritty and right.
rooted in the blues but who, Although they appear together
for artistic and financial reasons, on the album’s cover, these two
have built wider-ranging careers fantastic singers and players have
(particularly Mahal), what kind busy schedules; making TajMo
of music should they record? happen took a good two years
Does the world really need TAJ MAHAL & KEB’ MO’ of recording whenever possible.
another middling blues-rock Most of the guests contributed
session, even from talents this
TajMo their parts from afar, yet the
considerable? Concord CRE00432 (LP). 2017. Taj Mahal, Keb’ Mo’, album’s sound is fairly consistent
The answer is a tasteful and prods.; Zach Allen, John Caldwell, Alex Jarvis, throughout. Some details are
beautifully balanced album, TajMo, Jesse Nichols, Casey Wasner, engs.; Ross Hogarth, fumbled; for example, it would
now also the name of a tour, a mix; Richard Dodd, mastering; Bernie Grundman, have been nice to hear Bonnie
website, and perhaps a profitable vinyl mastering. AAA? TT: 45:20 Raitt’s voice louder in the mix in
side project for both men. PERFORMANCE the cover of John Mayer’s “Wait-
First, to keep the faithful on SONICS ing on the World to Change.”
board, Mahal and Mo’ had to re- And speaking of sound, TajMo’s
cord something traditional. Their impending summer tour may
version on side two of the great Ten- both men seem to be having a ball be the catalyst for another recording.
nessee bluesman Sleepy John Estes’s singing this outta-left-field choice. The quotes in the press kit confirm
“Diving Duck Blues,” which Mahal The stylistic range is stretched even that the making of TajMo has been a
recorded on his 1968 self-titled debut further when a spirited guitars-drums- life-changing experience for both men,
with Ry Cooder and Jesse Ed Davis, and-bass cover of Piano Red’s “She a fact that happily is also audible on the
is masterful. With both men singing, Knows How to Rock Me,” a jumpy final product.
Mahal on acoustic guitar, and Keb’ Mo’ rock’n’roll number made famous by “Taj is a stellar human being, just a
on resonator guitar, this is very quiet, Carl Perkins, is followed by Keb’ Mo’s brilliant man, and I learned a lot work-
traditional acoustic blues played by “All Around the World,” an attempt to ing with him,” said Keb’ Mo’. “It’s an
two of the very best, and Mahal clearly lure adult ears from another angle. The honor to have that kind of person in
relishes singing it again. album’s biggest production number, your life, and there was a lot of trust
But lest anyone get too settled, the it makes beautiful use of eight female that developed between us.”
musical horizon immediately expands background singers. While it treads “It was a lot of fun,” added Taj.
with the next track: a snappy, very perilously close to being too produced “We’d been thinking about collaborat-
successful version of Pete Townshend’s for its own good, it stays on the right ing for a little while, but once we actu-
“Squeeze Box.” With Shelia E. adding side of good taste and gets in a memo- ally got in there, I was really impressed.
a variety of percussion, from Vibraslap rable groove, and happily, the sound is Keb’s really good at keeping the ball
to guiro, and Joe Walsh guesting on neither too loud nor too compressed. up in the air. He’s a hell of a guitar
guitar, this is a very intelligent attempt After a few listens it sticks with you, player, and I’m just amazed at some of
at attracting adult listeners to a tune especially the girls singing the title the stuff that he put out there.”
that was a big hit 40 years ago. Again, refrain over and over in the choruses. —Robert Baird Q
C L A S S IC AL
GLASS MAHLER
Piano Works Das Lied von der Erde
Etudes; Glassworks: Opening Jonas Kaufmann, tenor; Vienna Philharmonic,
Víkingur Ólafsson, piano; Siggi String Quartet Jonathan Nott
Deutsche Grammophon 4796918 (CD). 2017. Sony Classical 88985398932 (CD). 2017.
Christopher Tarnow, prod., eng. DDD. TT: 79:39 Christopher Adler, prod.; Philip Krause, eng. DDD.
TT: 61:06
PERFORMANCE
SONICS PERFORMANCE
SONICS
We are now, happily, familiar enough
with the music of Philip Glass that it Had Gustav Mahler wanted all six of
need not be explained or apologized the songs that comprise Das Lied von
for; the endless arpeggios and repetitive der Erde sung by the same voice, he
“cells”—which are, most often, not ac- probably would have made that clear.
tually repetitive but subtly varied—are But he asked for a tenor in three of
expected and welcome. Glass is now them, and a baritone or female voice
80, and his music is among the most in the rest. The contrast works better
played of any composer now living. when it’s tenor and mezzo, though
Even the vaguely trained ear hears some baritones have left their mark on
the skill and the beauty in his music, the work, notably Dietrich Fischer-
and it’s nowhere more starkly lovely Dieskau (under Leonard Bernstein
than in his solo-piano works. The and Paul Kletzki). But the go-to CD
Etudes, not facile “studies” but often is under Otto Klemperer, with Fritz
finger-twisting tests, were composed Wunderlich and Christa Ludwig.
over 20 years (1994–2013) and differ Jonas Kaufmann, arguably today’s
wildly from one another: the faraway most famous and alluring operatic
quality of No.2, with a dreamlike tenor, has a dark, baritonal sound that
melody that reminds listeners of nonetheless brightens with brilliance
something they can’t quite put a and light above the staff—one can
finger on (it’s played here straight, as understand his presumption that he
well as with the Siggi String Quartet, might be able to sing all six. In short,
in what seems an unnecessary addi- it’s a mistake: The tenor songs are
tion); the fabulous mania of No.13, notoriously difficult—relentlessly
which, aside from its tonality, would high-lying, often requiring singing of
have made Prokofiev proud; the great power over a huge orchestra.
gentle calm of No.5, sustained over Indeed, Wunderlich is the only tenor
nine minutes; the final, almost tragic I’ve heard sing them with comfort, and
No.20, sounding and feeling less like while Kaufmann claims that Wun-
the Glass we know than like dark derlich was his model, he comes no-
Schubert. It all adds up to a great body where near him. Kaufmann hits every
of work. The opening and closing note, but hits is the operative word: he
tracks are the Opening of Glassworks attacks them with something akin to
(1981); the Siggis assist on the latter, vengeance or desperation. Kaufmann
deconstructing and reconstructing it, shines in the pianissimo upper reaches
this time to fine effect. Young Icelan- of the alto/baritone songs, but they of-
dic pianist Víkingur Ólafsson plays ten sit too low, and his sound becomes
10 of Glass’s 20 Etudes here, out of toneless—his voice may be dark, but its
order; his touch takes in every mood center can’t find the mahogany color
and every dynamic level Glass asks for. easily marshaled by a true baritone.
Beautiful engineering as well. This recording is a failed stunt.
—Robert Levine Jonathan Nott leads the Vienna Phil-
harmonic in a beautiful but character-
less performance. —Robert Levine
ROC K / P O P JA ZZ
Beauty lies in
the ear of JASON RIGBY &
DETROIT-CLEVELAND TRIO
One
RALPH TOWNER
My Foolish Heart
Ralph Towner, classical & 12-string guitars
now provide multichannel output via don’t believe a DAC going direct with a in fig.3 have nothing to do with the 1kHz
HDMI, though some PC/Mac-based digital volume control that trims bits is signal. These are 60Hz components from
servers do. At Baetis, we spend a lot of ever superior to a proper preamplifier. the mains. The procedure by which the
time and money on making our servers Further, if a system is filled with tweaks Max turned itself off after 42 minutes
as “turnkey” as possible. One does not and you are going to evaluate a compo- will have no practical effects on a speaker,
need Kal’s background to run a Baetis nent, we strongly encourage detweak- but this was stated later on. All shut-
server—only a 90-minute training session. ing the system and then reoptimizing downs by the safety circuit are correct.
Indeed, “turnkey” servers not based on a the system. Only then can you really Bill Parish
PC often have more difficulties with their tell what a particular component really GTT Audio & Video
proprietary operating systems and playing sounds like. Also note that when using a
software than our clients do with JRiver, digital volume control and playing DSD Lamm Industries L2.1 Reference
Roon, or good old Windows. files, the DSD is converted to PCM for Editor:
As for the alternatives, most audio- the volume adjustment. We at Lamm are quite pleased with the
philes now use either a factory com- Any system’s sound is the sum of its review of the L2.1 Reference preamplifier
puter’s USB port or the HDMI port of parts. The system in which the Max amps by Art Dudley, accompanied by superb
a less-than-most-advanced multicore were placed might have been the Audio- measurements and their interpretation by
computer (eg, Kal’s Mac mini). Some net showing off other parts of the system John Atkinson.
DIY types also use a factory computer’s rather than the actual sound of the Max. As was indicated in Art Dudley’s
free PCI slot to install an SOtM (or other In April, Jason Victor Serinus reported, quotes from the L2.1’s manual at the on-
brand) of USB port on a PCI card with from the 2017 Audio Expo North Amer- set of this review, the original version of
better-than-factory USB quality. ica, that a system at Axpona that included the preamp, the L2 Reference, was “vir-
So what we would really like are com- the Max monoblocks “proved once again tually flawless,” from both the theoretical
parisons of the following sort: that this was a perfect, synchronistic and sound-reproduction perspectives.
A) For the non-DIY person: How does match of components. Nevertheless, as the designer of this prod-
the Prodigy X’s SOtM USBhubIN “Perfect match? How about highs that uct, I knew of some inherent limitations
USB port compare to that of a factory were brilliant without being piercing, in the topology because certain desired
computer? How does the Prodigy X’s impressive bass (albeit nowhere near as components were not available at that
HDMI port (connected to Kal’s Marantz overwhelmingly powerful as from the far time. However, even without those com-
8088a pre-pro) compare with that of his more expensive [YG] Sonja XV system), ponents, the L2’s level of performance
Mac mini, or with the HDMI port of and excellent timbres? The bottom end was superb, and no one could’ve guessed
the Fidelizer Nimitra he also reviewed in may not have been as focused and clear as that there was room for improvement
this issue? it could have been—this was a hotel room waiting to be explored once those parts
B) The DIY person will want to know set-up, after all—but the excellence of were at hand. Therefore, I considered the
how the Prodigy X’s SOtM USBhubIN timbres made for a winning presentation. L2 Reference a completed product, and it
port compares to an SOtM PCI-bus– Reservations aside, I loved it.”1 remained our top-of-the-line preamp for
based USB port. SOtM says that their It is this type of experience of our set- more than a decade.
USBhubIN card is better than their PCI ups that piqued Jason’s interest enough to In recent years, technological advances
cards; and I even think that Kal may give the Max a try in his system. We just made it possible for those components
have said something like this in an article wish the recommendation of a preamp to become a reality. That was a sign that
last year. was used, and a bit more care in setup the time for the preamp’s modification
We’re pleased to be the maker of Kal’s addressed. A true apples-to-apples com- had come.
current reference music computer. But parison would have been appreciated. In listening to both versions of the pre-
we think that a lot of readers would like We are not quite sure why Audionet amp, it is now possible to hear the differ-
some more cross-platform comparisons was chosen for the experiment of ampli- ence that the new parts made. Art Dudley
before they plunk down $1400 or $5000 fier comparisons for a Pacific Northwest captured the nuances in sound of both,
or a lot more. We are biased—we think Audiophile Society meeting when, even though he hadn’t formally reviewed
Kal simply knows more about multichan- according to Jason, “The Maxes were at a the original L2 Reference (though he had
nel audio than almost anybody, and his distinct disadvantage” in a system clearly listened to it at various shows).
writing is always clear and concise. That optimized for his reference amplifiers. One of my goals, while designing the
is why his views on such comparisons are Not only did the end results end in differ- L1, L2 Reference, and L2.1 Reference
so useful. ing conclusions; they amounted to a se- preamps, was to put to rest the issue of
John Mingo, CEO verely flawed experiment. A true A/B test “tubes vs transistors.” Our own experi-
Baetis Audio should be on a basis of comparing apples ence in this regard, backed by that of our
with apples, which this clearly was not. customers and various reviewers, has
Audionet Max We appreciate John Atkinson’s been summed up aptly by Art Dudley:
Editor: measurements, and his conclusion that “During its time in my system, the Lamm
The review of the Audionet Max mono- the “Max performed very well on the L2.1 Reference was the rare product that
block is perplexing. We have had 16 test bench, offering high powers with swept the questions of tubes vs solid-state
reviews of Audionet systems in the US very low levels of distortion and noise.” into insignificance, focusing my attention
since becoming the distributor, and all of We would like to highlight and clarify on the music. . . .” And that—coupled
those reviewers come up with a different a couple of things in the Measurements with what I believe to be an impeccable
conclusion from Jason’s. section. The measurement spikes shown design—was exactly my goal.
We strongly recommend using power 1 See www.stereophile.com/content/axpona-more- Vladimir Lamm
amplifiers with a companion preamp, We thats-new-jasons-day-two. Lamm Industries
STEREOPHILE
Dynaudio 76 Music Direct 32-33, 102, 107 Titans Audio Lab 18
ADVERTISER INDEX Elusive Disc 22-23, 108 Nagra 104 Totem Acoustics 26
AudioQuest 8, 77, 103 Harmonic Resolution Systems 58 Ortofon 111, 114 VooDoo Cable 119
Cable Company 16-17, 119 Lewis Audio Video 115 Rogue Audio 46
THE AD INDEX IS PROVIDED AS
CH Precision 25 Magico C2 Rotel 64 A COURTESY. THE PUBLISHER
IS NOT LIABLE FOR INCORRECT
INFORMATION OR EXCLUDED
Chord Electronics 36 Margules Group 65 Siltech C3 LISTINGS. ADVERTISERS SHOULD
CONTACT THEIR SALES
Classé Audio 68 Mark Levinson 62 Spendor Audio 34 REPRESENTATIVE TO CORRECT
OR UPDATE A LISTING.
Crystal Cable C3 Morrow Audio 43 T.H.E. Show 96
Iso.Pod
Set of 3 - $299
Set of 4 - $399
In Silver or Black
MANUFACTURERS’ SHOWCASE
ADVERTISING
120 stereophile audio mart
AUDIOPHILE
ESSENTIALS
EDITOR CD
PACKAGE
includes
10 YEARS OF
RECORDS
TO DIE FOR
COLLECTOR’S
EDITION
EDITOR’S
CHOICE CD
shop.stereophile.com
YOUR ONLY
AUDIO
AUTHORITY $15
To advertise, contact Mark Aling • 289.828.6894 • emailing.mark@gmail.com 121
THERE’S ONLY TWO KINDS OF MUSIC: THE BLUES AND ZIPPETY DOO-DAH.
—TOWNES VAN ZANDT
S
he started out as a tape trader, that fanatical breed most interested in buying catalogs of recorded music from
of music fan who secretly revel in the back-alley, defunct labels—although this, she admits, can present
semilegal aura of their passion, and are driven by unique challenges. While she says she prefers to work
the belief that somewhere out there is the ultimate with “stone-cold flat transfers from analog 1⁄4" or 1⁄2" tape,”
show—one that, as she now says, “was recorded from the Omnivore’s recent purchase of Ru-Jac, a Baltimore label
back corner of a downstairs ladies’ bathroom but was the that released soul and R&B singles from the mid-1960s to
only recording where the band ever played with this guest or the early ’70s, bought them three small boxes of 7" reels, a
performed that song.” couple four-track tapes, and two 1⁄4" tapes. To begin reissu-
Cheryl Pawelski, who is now one of the four principals of ing this material, Pawelski eventually had to appeal to the
seven-year-old Omnivore Recordings, says that being that world of Ru-Jac 45 collectors.
“voracious” music collector has everything to do with where “Once we knew what singles were actually issued, we had
she is today. “Suddenly, I was hearing outtakes and alter- to A/B the single versions to the tape, but oftentimes the
nates, and I was like, ‘Wow, this is fascinating!’ I started to only thing that we had were alternate takes or backing tracks.
understand how you build a track, a song, a record.” What’s interesting is that in some cases we didn’t have the
The fact that Pawelski and her partners in Omnivore single version on tape, because they made a two-cut tape and
spent years working for major labels has given the label a sent it to the pressing plant, and it never came back.”
fighting chance for survival. After spending 1990–2002 in For much of Omnivore’s audio-restoration work Pawelski
the catalog department of Capitol Records/EMI, Pawelski uses Mike Graves, an Atlanta-based audio engineer who
worked at Rhino Handmade, Concord Records, and, finally, won a Grammy in 2008 for Art of Field Recording Volume
as head of A&R at Rhino Entertainment. I: 50 Years of Traditional American Music Documented by Art
“Working at Rhino as the head of A&R looked like play- Rosenbaum, a four-CD set released on the Dust-to-Digital
ing centerfield for the Yankees, right? It was probably the label. A Stereophile reader, Graves is among a growing group
worst gig of my career.” of audio engineers who think that transferring music at
In 2010, Pawelski and a trio of record-biz vets—Brad 24-bit/192kHz is overkill that few can really hear (he works
Rosenberger (music publishing), Greg Allen (photography in 24/96). Like all restoration and reissue engineers today,
and design), and Dutch Cramblitt (sales)—joined forces to he says that the digital files he receives from Omnivore have
form Omnivore. In addition to Omnivore Recordings itself, often been transferred by someone, somewhere, at varying
the Omnivore Entertainment Group includes a music-pub- resolutions while the actual source is long gone.
lishing company, a film division, and consultants who help “For the Hank Williams, there were no master tapes,
artists preserve their creative legacies. but somebody had found these 16" transcription discs.
Though Omnivore releases CDs and MP3 downloads, Whoever transferred them did the best they could, but
it’s best known for its high-quality vinyl reissues of rock and they didn’t have the right kind of turntable or the right
country. Like all new music ventures it needed a few imme- kind of needle.”
diate lightning bolts to distinguish itself from the ever-grow- While working on the Big Star Complete Third project
ing pack of vinyl-focused reissue labels. Those hits came in for Omnivore, Graves came to a crossroads at which many
the form of colored vinyl reissues of Bellybutton (1990) and audio engineers and everyday audiophiles often find them-
Spilt Milk (1993), the only full-length studio albums released selves. “There were dropouts on the both the left and right
by the San Francisco power-pop band Jellyfish; a boxed set sides. I did the best I could. It was an improvement. But
containing everything recorded for Big Star’s controversial yet it’s a historical thing—there’s a fly-on-the-wall feeling with
much-beloved album 3rd; and The Garden Spot Programs—24 some of these recordings. If you want a ringside seat, this is
previously unreleased radio performances by Hank Williams what you’re going to have to listen to.”
that in 2015 won a Grammy for Best Historical Album. A devoted member of those caught up in the Big Star
“A lot of the records that we do didn’t exist in nature mystique, Cheryl Pawelski is rightfully proud of what her
before, so we’re not just a reissue label,” Pawelski says over years of patience and sleuthing produced in the six LPs and
breakfast at the Hilton Austin during the 2017 South by three CDs of Complete Third. It also gave her a great war story.
Southwest Festival. “Think about the Townes Van Zandt “You never know what you’re going to find when you
record [Sunshine Boy: The Unheard Studio Sessions & Demos open up a tape box,” she says with a laugh. “Sometimes you
1971–1972], the Big Star stuff, the Hank Williams. I’m not find absolutely nothing. But when we were researching the
really interested in ‘Wow, this was never on CD, let’s put it Big Star, a guy at Ardent [Studios, in Memphis where Third
out.’ There are other companies that do that, and that’s cool. was recorded] called me and said, ‘You won’t believe what
What we’re really interested in is adding a chapter—or at we found.’ Somebody had put out a cigarette in the tape
least a page—to an artist’s bio, discography, and story.” box, and it was still there.” Q
Like all reissue labels, Omnivore rises or falls on the Music Editor Robert Baird (RBaird@enthusiastnetwork.com)
quality of its sources. According to Pawelski, the label is finds all this talk of having too many records patently absurd.
New
triple crown
POWER
www.siltechcables.com www.crystalcable.com
WALNUT VEINEER
CARRARA WHITE
BLACK LACQUER
IMPERIAL RED