Stability
Stability
Basic Principles
The density of any given substance is its mass per unit volume.
Relative Density (RD) of a substance is simply a ratio of the density of the substance in question
to that of Fresh Water.
The volume of displacement is the underwater volume of a ship afloat, i.e. the volume
below the waterline.
Displacement is a mass of water displaced by the floating vessel. Therefore, displacement is
equal to the TOTAL weight of the vessel. (Displacement = Deadweight + Lightweight)
To calculate the displacement (W) of a ship, the following need to be known
The volume of displacement (V)
The density of the water in which it floats (P)
Deadweight is the actual amount of weight in tonnes that a vessel can carry when loaded to the
maximum permissible draught (includes fuel, fresh water, gear supplies, catch and crew)
Lightweight is the displacement of vessel without cargo, fuel, lube oil, consumable stores, crew
and their effects.
GRT – Total volume of the vessel including
accommodation, cargo spaces, enclosed spaces
above the deck.
Draught is the distance from the keel to the waterline as measured at the forward and
aft ends of the ship. It is expressed in metres. If the draughts forward and aft are the same,
the ship is said to be on an even keel.
Freeboard is the distance between the waterline and the top of the uppermost continuous
deck. It is expressed in millimetres and is measured amidships.
Reserve Buoyancy
This is the volume of the enclosed spaces above the waterline, which can be equal, but not less
than the volume of the biggest compartment on board the vessel. Because reserve buoyancy
is a very important factor in determining a ship’s seaworthiness, minimum freeboards
are assigned to a ship to ensure that there is adequate reserve buoyancy at all times.
WPA – The area of a hull at a particular horizontal plane, i.e. within the waterline.
[Link] Lines
Plimsoll line or the Plimsoll mark – indicates the limit until which ships can be loaded with
cargo. It generally varies from one vessel to another. Seafarers should be wary of the fact that
the water level should not rise above the line markers.
Each load line indicates the minimum freeboard that applies to the seasonal zone and/or
area, as indicated in the International Convention on Load Lines.
The ship will be loaded to the appropriate load line when the waterline is level with the
top edge of the mark concerned.
The assigned (Summer) freeboard is measured from the top edge of the Plimsoll line to
the top edge of the deck line.
The WNA load line mark is only assigned to ships that are 100 meters or less in length.
Ships over 100m will load to the 'W' mark as appropriate.
Fresh Water Allowance (FWA)
Fresh Water Allowance (FWA) of a ship is the number of millimeters by which the mean draught
changes when a ship passes from salt water to fresh water, or vice versa, when the ship is loaded
to the summer displacement.
The centre of gravity of the vessel at light displacement is fixed by the arrangement of hull,
superstructure, machinery, etc. The addition of deadweight items such as fuel, cargo, etc. causes
the centre of gravity to move in various directions. Therefore, the position of the centre of gravity is
dependent upon the size of weights added to the vessel, and the position in which they are added.
In other words, the final position of the centre of gravity depends on the practices of the vessel
operator.
The following three rules describe the movement of the centre of gravity of the vessel.
(3) The centre of gravity moves parallel to the movement of a weight, which is already on
board.
The size of the movement of the centre of gravity is directly dependent upon:
¿V a vertical component
¿ H a horizontal component.
w Xd
The vertical component of the shift of G is calculated by the formula: ¿V =
W ±w
Where:
d is the vertical distance between G of the ship and g of the loaded/discharged weight.
wXd
If the weight is just shifted within the vessel, we are using only W. (¿V = )
W
w Xd
The horizontal component of the shift of G is calculated by the formula: ¿ H =
W ±w
Where:
d is the horizontal distance between G of the ship and g of the loaded/discharged weight.
wXd
If the weight is just shifted within the vessel, we are using only W. (¿ H = )
W
It would be very tedious to carry out a calculation for every single weight that was either
shifted, loaded or discharged from the ship. In practice, moments about the keel are taken
to determine the final KG of the ship, where: Moments (t-m) = Weight(t) x Distance(m)
If the ship is considered: Moments (t-m) = Displacement (t) x KG (m).
Moments(t−m)
Therefore: KG =
Displacement (t)
When a number of weights are shifted, loaded or discharged, the moments for each weight
are calculated. This are added and divided by the final displacement of the ship to give the
final KG.
Metacentre – a point on the centre line of a vessel through which all the forces of buoyancy pass
when the vessel is heeled
Metacentric height – the distance from the Centre of Gravity to the Metacentre (G.M.)
GM = KM – KG = BM + KB – KG
Metacentric Radius – the distance from the Centre of Gravity of the forces of buoyancy to the
Metacentre (B.M.)
Height to the Metacentre – the distance from the Keel to the Metacentre (K.M.)
Suspended Weights
When a weight is suspended from a boom, the effect is as though the weight were situated at the
point of suspension, that is, the head of the boom. Usually, this is a long way from the centre of
gravity of a vessel and therefore, a suspended weight may cause a large movement of the centre
of gravity.
Heel
Previous diagrams showed a transverse view of a vessel in an upright position, with the centre of
gravity and the centre of buoyancy on the centre line. It was said that all of the weight of the
vessel, and any associated deadweight items, can be assumed to act vertically downwards
through the centre of gravity. It was also said that all of the
buoyancy effect can be assumed to act vertically upwards
through the centre of buoyancy; and, of course, when a vessel
is floating the weight is exactly equal to the buoyancy.
The centre of buoyancy (B) is the centre of the underwater volume of the vessel. Because the
underwater shape has changed, the centre of buoyancy moves to the centre of the new
underwater shape, which is at B1.
Buoyancy acts vertically upwards through the centre of buoyancy as shown and cuts the centre
line of the vessel at a point called the metacentre (M). The initial position of the metacentre is
determined by the shape of the underwater portion of the hull (displacement and weight added)
Position of G has not changed, because no weights have been moved, but weight still acts
vertically downwards, through G as shown.
The distance from G to M is called the metacentric height. It is aim of the officer in charge of
loading of the ship to ensure that the initial metacentric height is not less than 0.15m. It is essential
that the ship has suitable GM. As a guide the GM should be in the region of 4 to 8 % of the ship’s
breadth. For a ship with a breadth of 16m this would mean a GM of between approximately 0.6 to
1.3m.
The lines of action of weight and buoyancy are separated by a distance GZ,
which is called the righting lever
Righting lever (GZ) is the horizontal distance, measured in metres, between the
centre of gravity (G) and the vertical line of action of the buoyancy force (Bf)
acting through the centre of buoyancy (B) when the ship is heeled. Generally, the
lower the center of gravity the larger the GZ will be.
Equilibrium
STABLE EQUILIBRIUM – This is when the vessel has a positive righting lever (G below M)
NEUTRAL EQUILIBRIUM – This is when the vessel has no righting lever (G and M coincide) –
Danger of capsize
UNSTABLE EQUILIBRIUM – This is when the vessel has a negative righting lever (G above M) –
Capsizing Lever
STABILITY – This is an act of keeping the vessel stable. This word means, if the vessel is heeled
by an external force it has the ability to right herself whether its statical, transverse or longitudinal
stability.
DYNAMIC STABILITY – the amount of work taken to bring the vessel back to its upright position
Equilibrium is the term used to describe a vessel that is afloat. It is a word made up of two words
namely equal and balance. A vessel will float when the forces of weight and buoyancy are equal,
and they balance - that is both B and G are in the same vertical line, and the vessel is not being
acted on by an external force (a force other than buoyancy or weight)
Stable Equilibrium
A vessel which will tend to return to the upright after being heeled by an external force, is said to
be in stable equilibrium. When G is below M (GM is positive value) the vessel is in stable
equilibrium (so that the ship will have positive stability) e.g. the situation shown in Fig 3.7.
Unstable Equilibrium
If G is above M as shown in Fig 3.9 the ship is said to be in unstable
equilibrium. It will not remain upright. It will heel to an angle called an
angle of loll. At that angle of loll it will have ‘picked up’ stability and will
return to the angle of loll if disturbed by an external force. If G is sufficiently far above M, then the
angle of loll may be very large and the vessel may capsize.
Angle of loll (угол крена при качке) is a large angle of heel, since the line of action of the
buoyancy force is no longer passing through the initial transverse metacentre.
Figure 3.9
Neutral Equilibrium
If G and M coincide, as shown in Fig 3.10 then, theoretically the vessel
will have no reason to remain upright. Also, if it is heeled, it will have no
tendency either to heel further or to return to the upright.
Figure 3.10
MEAN DRAFT – This is the forward and aft draft added together and divided by the number 2
RESERVE BUOYANCY – This is the volume of air trapped in a watertight space above the waterline.
(This is the volume of the enclosed spaces above the waterline.)
CENTRE OF FLOTATION – This is the centre of the water-plane area of a vessel at any draught
MOMENT OF STATICAL STABILITY – The total weight (displacement) X the righting lever (GZ).
The righting moment at any angle of heel represents the instantaneous value of the ship’s ability
to return to the upright expressed in tonnes-metres, when the ship is in still water conditions.
List
If weights are loaded or discharged or moved within the vessel G may move off the centre line.
Figure 3.15
GZ is determined by position of G
ROLL PERIOD
All vessels have a natural roll period. When heeled by a wave, they will begin rolling. It is like a
pendulum set in motion - the period of roll remains the same, even if the angle to which the vessel
rolls changes. The period of the roll is governed by two factors.
the GM
the beam of the vessel
If the GM is large, the roll period is short. If the GM is small, the roll period is long.
A vessel’s roll period is a good indicator of stability. The roll period may be measured at sea, or in
port by rolling the vessel artificially. On a small vessel you can conduct your own rolling test to
obtain GM. To conduct such a test, the boat should be alongside, in smooth water, with no wind or
tide, with slack moorings and adequate side and bottom clearance. All loose weights should be
secured and all slack tanks pressed up. A roll is initiated, perhaps by pulling on a masthead line
from the wharf, and when the vessel is rolling freely, several rolls are timed, and averaged.
An approximate value for the GM in metres may then be found from the formula:
2
0.88B
GM
T
where:
Thus, roll period is a sensitive indicator of stability. You should always be aware of it. If the roll
period seems longer, or the roll sluggish (очень замедленный), investigate the stability
immediately.
WEIGHT DISTRIBUTION
The distribution of deadweight items within a vessel is the responsibility of the operator. It is
normal for vessels to be stable and upright in their lightship condition. Therefore, if a vessel is
unstable or listed, after the addition of deadweight items, it can be corrected by the action of the
operator.
Remember
Also
Stability is worsened if
The amount that the centre of gravity of a vessel is shifted by the loading of a weight can be
calculated by the formula:
The amount that the centre of gravity of a vessel is shifted by the unloading of a weight can be
calculated by the formula:
If the position of LCG and LCB are as shown in Fig 3.16 then the actions of buoyancy and weight
will cause the vessel to rotate as shown by the arrow. The stern will sink deeper, the bow will rise
higher. LCB is the longitudinal centre of all underwater volume. As the vessel rotates, the shape of
the underwater volume will change and LCB will move to the new centre.
The amount that the centre of gravity of a vessel is shifted by the loading of a weight can be
calculated by the formula:
The amount that the centre of gravity of a vessel is shifted by the unloading of a weight can be
calculated by the formula:
The rudder may not be fully immersed, making the ship difficult to steer
reduced propeller immersion will lessen propulsion efficiency
if the ship is pitching, particularly in a lightship condition, the propeller will tend to race. This,
along with increased vibration, may cause tail shaft damage
rudder efficiency will be intermittent as the ship pitches
ballast suctions are sited at the after end of tanks and so a head trim will
make these impossible to empty completely.
The large wind area forward and too deep immersion of the aft end will
make the ship difficult to steer
pitching may be excessive in heavy weather, causing excessive panting and pounding (this
will be evident regardless of trim if the forward draught is too small)
a large blind area will exist forward, particularly with an aft bridge, hindering pilotage and
reducing lookout effectiveness.
COT (Change of Trim) – the difference in the draft of a ship's bow and stern before and after a
weight shift. In other words, when cargo is loaded or unloaded from a ship, or fuel is consumed,
the weight distribution of the ship changes, and the angle that the ship sits in the water can also
change. This change in angle is called the change of trim.
w Xd Trimming moments a
COT = MCTC = MCTC
COT = T a +T f Ta =
LBP
x COT
MCTC (Moment to Change Trim by One Centimeter) – This is the trimming moment re9uired to
change the ships trim by exactly 1 cm. It is tabulated in the ship's hydrostatic particulars and is
used to determine the change of trim that takes place when weights are shifted, loaded or
discharged.
W X GM L
MCTC = where:
100 LBP
When loading or discharging weights, the effect of bodily sinkage or rise must be taken into
account.
w
Sinkage/Rise (cm) = TPC
[Link] stresses
Ships experience stresses from a variety of forces and their structure needs to be built strongly
and supported properly to handle different loads at any given time. The cost and weight in the
construction of a ship must be balanced against strength, rigidity, sea worthiness and cargo
capacity.
The structure of a ship is subject to two basic types of force, namely Static and Dynamic forces.
A. Static forces: Two forces that act on the vessel when they are in still water as well as when
in motion. They are the force of gravity acting downwards (due to weight of ship and its
cargo) and the force of buoyancy acting upwards (due to upward thrust of water). When
they are in equilibirium, vessel is said to be at rest.
B. Dynamic forces: These forces act on the ship while ship is in motion. While underway,
Vessel is also subjected to six degree of motion namely: Rolling, pitching, Heaving, Surging,
Swaying and yawing. When these motions are large then very large forces may be
generated. Though, they are local in nature e.g. pounding forward, but they cause structure
to vibrate and transmit the stresses to other parts of the structure.
Longitudinal stresses.
There are four main types of longitudinal stresses:
1. Sagging. Sagging stresses are caused by the uneven distribution of weight and buoyancy
along the length of the ship, causing the middle part to bend downwards. This can happen
when the ship is supported on both ends by waves, which can lift the ends and reduce the
buoyancy of the center,
causing it to sag. This type
of stress is called sagging
and can be harmful to the
ship if not monitored and
managed properly.
2. Hogging. It is the opposite of sagging. It occurs when a wave passes under a ship and the
middle of the vessel is supported by the crest of the wave while the two ends hang over the
crest on either side. This uneven distribution of weight and buoyancy creates stress that can
cause the ship's
structure to bend
upwards in the middle.
This type of stress is
known as hogging and
can also be harmful to
the ship if not properly
managed.
3. Vertical shear forces. It is the forces that act parallel to a ship's surface and perpendicular
to its length in opposite directions on any part of a structure to break it apart or shear it.
These forces are caused by waves, winds, and the ship's own motion through the water.
Shear forces can cause stress on a
ship's structure, particularly at the joints
between different sections of the hull or
deck. If the stress becomes too great, it
can cause the ship to twist or deform,
which can be dangerous or even cause
the ship to break apart.
4. Torsional forces. When a ship is hit by waves on either side, it can be subjected to two
types of motion: rolling (side-to-side movement) and pitching (up-and-down movement).
When a ship experiences both rolling and pitching at the same time, it can cause the ship's
hull to twist along its longitudinal axis,
generating what is called torsional stresses or
forces. In other words, the hull of the ship twists
as it responds to the combined motion of rolling
and pitching, and this twisting can cause
additional stresses on the ship's structure.
Transverse stresses.
There are three main types of transverse stresses:
1. Racking. When a vessel is rolling in a seaway the transverse section will try to bend or twist
at the corners due to racking stresses. This can
happen when a vessel is rolling back in rough seas,
causing different parts of the vessel to move in
opposite directions. This stress can be particularly
strong at the corners or joints of the vessel, which
may be more vulnerable to bending or warping.
1. Panting. When the ship is under way in a seaway, she is subjected to changes in pressure
caused by the waves and the pitching if the ship. The variation of pressure at the ends
causes the ship to vibrate due to panting stresses.
2. Pounding. It occurs at the bottom plating of the ship near the bow during excessive pitching
when the ship's bow repeatedly slams into waves.
Rolling: This is the side-to-side motion of a ship around its longitudinal axis. It occurs due to the
movement of the waves or any other external forces acting on the ship.
Pitching: This is the up-and-down motion of a ship around its transverse axis. It occurs when
the bow of the ship rises and falls with the waves.
Heaving: This is the vertical motion of a ship along its vertical axis. It is the movement of the
ship in the water as the waves pass beneath it.
Surging: This is the forward and backward movement of a ship along its longitudinal axis. It is
caused by the alternating rise and fall of the bow and stern with the waves.
Swaying: This is the movement of a ship from side to side along its transverse axis. It occurs
due to external forces such as wind, waves or currents pushing against the side of the ship. It
can also happen when weight shifts from one side of the ship to the other.
Yawing: This is the rotating motion which spins the ship around it’s vertical axis. It is caused by
external forces acting on the ship, such as wind or waves, and can affect the heading and
direction of the ship.
[Link] STABILITY CRITERIA
According to the International Code on Intact stability, 2008, the following criteria are mandatory
for passenger and cargo ships:
1. The area under the righting lever curve (GZ curve) should not be less than 0.055 metre-
radians up to 30° angle of heel.
2. The area under the righting lever curve (GZ curve) should not be less than 0.09 metre-
radians up to 40° angle of heel or the angle of downflooding if this is less than 40°.
3. The area under the righting curve between the angles of heel of 30° and 40° or between 30°
and the angle of downflooding if this angle is less than 40°, should not be less than 0.03
metre-radians.
4. The righting lever GZ should be at least 0.20 m at an angle of heel equal to or greater than
30°.
5. The maximum righting arm should occur at an angle of heel preferably exceeding 30° but
not less than 25°.
Downflooding: The entry of seawater through any opening into the hull or superstructure of an
undamaged vessel [or portion of a vessel] due to heel, trim, or submergence of the vessel.
Downflooding angle means the static angle from the intersection of the vessel's centerline and
the waterline in calm water to the first opening that cannot be closed weathertight and through
which downflooding can occur. It is an angle at which deck immersion takes place with subsequent
water ingress.
[Link] stability
DAMAGE STABILITY - The ship should be able to survive the breach (flooding) of any one or
more compartment. A damage stability criterion varies from ship to ship and the requirement for
the same is given in SOLAS chapter II-1. It may be single compartment flooding, multi
compartment flooding, engine room flooding etc. Under all the criteria as applicable, vessel margin
line should not be submerged after the damage. Margin line is an imaginary line drawn 75mm
below the free board deck.
Oil tankers shall comply with the following requirements for damage stability criteria:
1. The final waterline, taking into account sinkage, heel and trim, shall be below the
lower edge of any opening through which progressive flooding may take place. Such
openings shall include air-pipes and those which are closed by means of weathertight
doors or hatch covers
2. In the final stage of flooding, the angle of heel due to unsymmetrical flooding shall not
exceed 25°, provided that this angle may be increased up to 30° if no deck edge
immersion occurs.
3. The stability in the final stage of flooding shall be investigated and may be regarded
as sufficient if the righting lever curve has at least a range of 20° beyond the position
of equilibrium in association with a maximum residual righting lever of at least 0.1 m
within the 20° range; the area under the curve within this range shall not be less than
0.0175 m·rad.
4. For oil tankers of 20,000 tonnes deadweight and above delivered on or after 6 July
1996, the damage assumptions shall be:
i. longitudinal extent: