Needs
Excellent Good Satisfactory
Criteria Improvement
(90-100) (85-89) (80-84)
(75-79)
Some
Content All information is Minor inaccuracies Many inaccuracies;
inaccuracies or
Accuracy (25 accurate, relevant, and or missing minor lacks research or
lack of depth in
pts) well-researched. details. relevance.
content.
Report is logically Some parts are
organized Mostly organized, disorganized or
Organization Poor structure;
(introduction, body, with clear parts missing;
(15 pts) difficult to follow.
conclusion); transitions and transitions. transitions are
are smooth. unclear.
Speaks clearly, Voice is
Generally clear and Inaudible or
Clarity & confidently, and at an sometimes
confident; minor mumbled delivery;
Delivery (20 appropriate pace; unclear; lacks
issues in pace or minimal
pts) excellent eye contact confidence or eye
posture. engagement.
and posture. contact.
Visuals are
Visuals are well-
Instructional Visuals are useful present but not No visual aids or
designed, relevant, and
Materials (10 but may lack polish clearly explained they distract from
enhance
pts) or full relevance. or poorly the presentation.
understanding.
designed.
Demonstrates deep Shows good
Critical Limited analysis; Surface-level
understanding and understanding and
Thinking (10 relies mostly on understanding;
insightful analysis of some analytical
pts) basic information. lacks analysis.
the topic. depth.
Answers questions Struggles with
Question & Answers most Unable to answer
accurately and answering or
Answer (10 questions well with questions or avoids
confidently, showing gives vague
pts) minor hesitation. them.
mastery of topic. answers.
Poor time
Time Presentation fits within Slightly over/under Too short or too
management;
Management the time limit and is time; pacing is long; pacing is
rushed or drags on
(10 pts) well-paced. mostly good. uneven.
unnecessarily.
Name of Reporter: _______________________________________________ Date:
_____________________________