Professional Documents
Culture Documents
• Modern concept:
Audit means:
-Critical examination of all the books of accounts
-by independent body of qualified persons
-to verify arithmatical accuracy of books of a/c
-to report to the owners,
*whether profit/loss gives true & fair view of P/L
*whether Balance sheet gives true & fair view of state of
Affairs of business at d end of financial period.
FEATURES:
1. Systematic and scientific examination of books and financial statements
2. Inspection, checking, verification and scrutiny
3. Verification of assets and liabilities
4. Examination of books of accounts prepared by others
5. Examination of books of accounts and record by independent person
6. Examination of books by qualified person
7. Examination on the basis of documentory evidences
8. Examination of accounts throughout the year or periodically
9. Ascertainment of authenticity and accuracy of the financial information
10.Expression of opinion about the truth and fairness of the financial
statements
11.Applies to business as well as non business concerns
OBJECTIVES
1.primary objective
• To examine the books of accounts and records as to render an opinion
on the truth and fairness of the financial statements prepared by mgt.
2. Secondary objectives
• Detection and prevention of Errors
• Detection and prevention of Frauds
3. Specific objectives
• Operations audit
• Cost audit
• Management audit
• Social audit
Detection and prevention of Errors
1.Error Of Omission
2.Error Of Commission
3.Error Of Principle
4.Compensating Errors
5.Error Of Duplication
Prevention:
- Advising mgt
- creates moral check on staff & sense of fear
Detection and prevention of Frauds
1.Embezzlement Of Cash
2.Misappropriation Of Goods
3.Fraudulent Manipulation Of Accounts
Auditor is a watch dog not a blood hound
Features:
Compulsory under the law
The owner of the enterprise cannot make it optional
Conducted by qualified auditor
Serves the interest of the owner not the interest of the
management
independent and external audit
Merits:
a) It enables shareholders to know the truth and fairness of
representations made by the management in financial
statements
b) It protects the interests of beneficiaries against possible
frauds by
the trustees and also protects interests of the trustees
c) Helps in proper maintenance of books of accounts
d) It acts as a check against frauds by the managing
committee
e) Protects the members of the managing committee against
baselss criticism
Forms or types of statutory audit
• Company Audit
• Banking company audit
• Insurance company audit
• Electricity company audit
• Co-op society Audit
• Trust audit
GOVERNMENT AUDIT
• Audit of accounts of government departments and offices,
government and statutory or public corporations
Objectives:
1. To ensures that the payment has been sanctioned by the
competent authority
2. To ensure that the every payment is made as per the rules
and regulations
3. To see that the payments have been made to right persons
4. To see that payments are made to the right persons
5. To verify the existence of stocks and stores and their valuation
Difference between Govt & Commercial
Government Audit Commercial Audit
audit
1 Conducted in respect of govt Conducted in respect of concerns owned
department, offices, companies and by private individuals
public corporations
Merits:
• moral check on employees
• know the real profitability
• raising loan from banks
• Reliable basis for tax assessment
Difference between statutory audit and
private audit
Statutory Audit Private Audit
1 It is carried out as per the statute or It is carried out in private organizations
law for the concerns like joint stock like sole trading concerns and
companies, insurance companies partnership firms
etc
2 It is complusory as per the law It is voluntary or optional
3 It is carried out every year It is carried out at the instance of owners
as and when desired
4 Auditor is appointed as per statute Auditor is appointed under an agreement
5 Purpose- to comply with Purpose- to suit the needs of enterprise
requirements of law
6 The rights, duties and liabilities of The rights, duties and liabilities of an
an auditor is defined by the statute auditor is defined by the agreement
Features:
Undertaken by the concerns which are large in size
It is not compulsory
Scope of internal vary depending on size and nature of concern
Carried on continuously throughout the year
It may be an addition to external audit
Staff appointed for internal audit are responsible to management
Merits:
1. Helpful to ascertain whether accounting systems are adequate and
effective to prevent frauds and errors
2. Pre-determined plans, policies and procedures complied with
3. Reliability of accounting
4. Safeguarding the assets
5. Evaluate performance of personnel
Demerits:
1. It does not seek to safeguard the interest of the owners of the
business
2. Entirely dependent on the management
3. It is not obligatory. It is optional
4. It is conducted by the staff of the organization who may not be as
qualified as independent auditors
INDEPENDENT AUDIT/EXTERNAL AUDIT
• Audit of an organization by a professionally qualified auditor
-independent of organisation
-hiring his service for the purpose of audit
Difference between
Independent audit
Independent
Internal Audit
audit and
Internal
1
audit
It is conducted by professionally It is conducted by staff of the
qualified accountants organisation
Merits:
• Cost of audit is lesser than continuous audit
• It can be completed in one continuous sitting
• Does not cause any dislocation in the work of the clients staff
• Need not maintain large staff
• Does not become monotonous and mechanical
• Demerits
Staff will have sufficient time to manipulate accounts
Errors and frauds will remain in books for a long period
Very little time to check accounts in detail
Delay in getting auditor’s report
COMPLETE AUDIT
PARTIAL AUDIT
• The areas to be covered in audit are limited by specific
agreement to this effect.
STANDARD AUDIT
• Certain items are thoroughly checked and analyses and
appropriate test checks are applied to other items provided
there is a good effective internal check
Feature:
1. It should be drawn up by auditor himself.
2. Prepared by commencement of the audit.
3. A separate audit programme should be drawn up for
every individual audit.
4. It should be in writing.
5. It should contain the full details & procedures of the
audit work.
• Objectives:
• 1. To ensure no part of the audit work has been
omitted.
• 2. To provide clear instructions to the audit staff as to
what work they have to do.
• 3. To ensure proper distribution of work.
• 4. To facilitate the conduct of the audit work by several
audit assistants.
• 5. To enable the auditor to have proper control over the
whole audit work.
Contents of Audit Programme
• Disadvantages:
• 1. It makes audit staff specialized in respective work, and cannot assign any other
work.
• 2 Makes audit work mechanical.
• 3. It discourages the interest of audit staff because they have to act according to
programme.
• 4. They may neglect the transactions which are most important by pleading that
audit programme does not contain the instructions.
• 5. Time limit is fixed and they have to hurry up.
AUDIT NOTE BOOK: It is a book, register or diary
• Contentsby the audit staff during the course of audit for recording his
maintained
. the business
• 1. Nature of
observations
• 2. Organisation structure.
• 3. Names of principal officers.
• 4. Instruction from the management regarding the audit.
• 5. List of books of a/c’s
• 6. System of internal check & internal control
• 7. System of accounting followed in business.
• 8. Technical details & terms used in the business.
• 9. Extracts from minutes and contracts.
• 10. Provisions of the memorandum and articles of
association
• 11. Extracts from the bankers debtors and creditors.
• 12. Queries made & replies received.
• 13. Dates of commencement & completion of audit.
• 14. Complete record of nature of work done.
• 15. Progress of audit work.
• 16. Record of suggestions made by audit staff.
• 17. Particulars of errors & frauds discovered.
• 18. Particulars of all documents vouchers and invoices.
• 19. Points to be discussed with senior audit clerk.
• 20. Points which require further explanation
• 21. Points to be included in audit report.
• 22. Notes which may be used in audits of future.
• 23. Extracts from certificates
• 24. Totals & Balances of important books of a/c’s already checked.
• 25. Particulars of missing vouchers.
• 26. Verification of certificates gives by the bankers.
• AUDIT WORKING PAPERS
• Those are the papers and documents which come into the
possession of an auditor and the information recorded or
developed by the auditor in the course of an audit, about
the accounts of his clients business.
• AUDIT FILES
• Auditor often engaged in a number of audits, usually keeps
the records of each audit in a separate file.
• a) Permanent files:- Contains those working papers which
are useful for conducting the audit examination year after
year.
• b) Current files: Contains only those details which have a
bearing on the current audit
DETERMINATION OF AUDIT
PROCEDURE
• Routine checking:
• Test checking
• Surprise checks:
• Audit in Depth
• Tick Marks
AUDIT TECHNIQUES
• 1. Vouching: Examination of documentary evidences in support
of an entry.
• 2. Confirmation: A techniques through which an auditor
communicates with outside parties such as debtors, creditors,
banks, etc.
• 3. Enquiry: Technique of making enquiries with the responsible
officials of the client.
• 4. Reconciliation: Is the techniques of identification &
explanation of the items which cause the differences b/w two
related items.
• 5. Physical Examination: Technique of as curtaining the actual
existence of assets as shown in the books of a/cs.
• 6. Testing / Test checking: Technique of selecting and
examining in detect a fair representative items from a large set
of similar items.
• 7. Analysis of financial statements: Techniques of segregating accounting
figures & calculating a number of accounting ratio.
• 8. Scanning & Segregating: Making a quick & over all examination of the
books of accounts to verify whether the transactions are correctly &
completely recorded or not.
• 9. Extension verification: Is the technique of multiplying two or more
amounts to verify whether the totals has been done correctly.
• 10. Posting Verification: Tracking the items recorded in one book to another
book.
• 11. Documentary Examination: It is more or less the same as vouching. It is
the technique of examining the documents evidences.
• 12. Observation: Where the auditor observes a process or an act
performed by others.
• 13. Footing: Technique of adding the columns of different accounting figures
to test the accuracy of the total.
• 14. Flow charting: Is the technique of using flow charts to describe
graphically the causes of the transactions through different stages.
MODULE 2: INTERNAL CHECK
• Spicer and pegler
Internal check is an arrangement of staff duties whereby no one
person is allowed to carry through and record every aspect of
transaction so that, without collusion between two or more
persons, fraud is prevented and at the same time possibilities of
errors reduced to minimum
Meaning:
Arrangement of accounting duties under which work of one
person comes under the scrutiny of another person so that It is
not possible to commit fraud without collusion between two or
more persons
• FEATURES
All the duties are distributed among different staff members, and each
staff member is assigned a specific duty
Work is assigned according to their qualifications, area of
specialization, training, ability etc
No one person is allowed to do any single task from the beginning to
the end
Work of each staff member is complementary to the work of another
Each staff is held responsible for error or irregularities in the task
assigned to them
There is no duplication of work
Checking is carried out continuously as a part of routine system
OBJECTIVE
Proper division of work
Minimization of errors and frauds
Early detection of errors and frauds
Ensuring the reliability of account
Early preparation of final account
Simplification of external auditor's work
Merits of Internal Check
• To the concern
Proper division of work
Fixation of responsibility
Greater efficiency of staff
Increased earnings or profits
Early detection of errors and frauds
Prevention of errors and frauds
Early and easy preparation of final account
Merits of Internal Check
• To the Owners
The owners can rely on genuineness and accuracy of
books of account
Results in overall efficiency and economy in operation
• To the Auditor
Need not have a detailed checking of every transaction
Disadvantages
11. The customer should present the cash memo copy to receive the
goods
13. The man at delivery counter should prepare a summary of the value
of goods delivered by him
17. Daily cash sale receipts must be deposited into the bank either on
same day or on the next day
18. If cash recording machine is used in the business, the total of cash
received should be checked with amount actually banked.
Internal check for Cash Sales by Travelling Salesmen
1. Traveling salesman should be provided with pre- numbered temporary
receipt books
2. The final receipt of cash collected by salesman should be issued from
head office or from the branch office to which the travelling salesman
is attached
3. The customer asked to contact head office if final receipt is not issued.
4. The salesman is allowed to collect cash from the customers. They
should be asked to send the bank pay-in slips to the head office or the
branch office to which they are attached
5. He is not allowed to make any deductions from the cash collected by
them for the expense incurred by them or for their salaries or
commission.
6. He should be asked to submit periodical statements of sales to the
head office or to the branch to which they are attached.
Internal check for Cash Sales by Travelling Salesmen
7. The list of debtors given at the commencement of the journey should be
compared with list at the end of the journey
1. General guidelines
2. Guidelines for maintenance of wage records
3. Guidelines for the preparation of wage sheets
4. Guidelines for payment of wages
General Guidelines
1. Appointment, dismissal, fixation & alteration wage must be in writing.
It should be authorized by competent person of personnel department.
It should be communicated to wages office for preperation of wage
sheets
2. Separate personnel record should be maintained for each worker-
name, number, address, marital status, date of appointment, scale of
pay etc.
3. The wage office should be set up and placed under the control of a
responsible officer other than the cashier
4. Copies of orders relating to increase in pay, promotions, punishment
involving deductions from wages etc. should be communicated to the
wages office concerned with preperation of wage sheets
Guidelines for maintenance of wage records
• Time records must be maintained for each worker