Professional Documents
Culture Documents
• Synergy
• Increase in revenue and/or decrease in expense and/or
decrease in capital expenditure that occurs because two
companies operate as one.
• Premium
• Increase in target share price from before the merger to after
the merger
• Dilution/Accretion
• Effect of merger or acquisition on earnings per share or
some other measure – accretion is increase from merger
and decrease is dilution.
• .
• .
Net Synergies
$720 – 1,440 million
• .
• Purchase Accounting
• Purchase accounting is normally used in M&A. Assets and
liabilities are measured at fair value rather than original cost
and the common equity of the company is eliminated.
Alternative method is pooling of interests.
• Goodwill
• Asset arising from purchase accounting that arises from the
difference between equity that was on the balance sheet and
equity that is paid for the company.
• Minority Interest
• The share of the company (assets and income) that is not
owned by shareholders of the corporation.
• Consideration:
• How the payment is made for the equity value of the target
company. This can be share exchange, cash, preferred stock,
option or other creative forms of financing.
• The number of shares received for the new merged firm that will
be received for existing shares of the target. The starting point for
evaluation should be the relative share prices before the merger.
• Transaction Multiples
• Transaction Value
• Enterprise value (equity value plus net debt (market value) plus the
transaction fees
• Accounting
• Economics
• Finance
• Compute the Equity IRR with Exit Multiples over Holding Period
• Acquisition Model
•Compute Equity Cash Flow with Actual Financing Structure
• .
• .
Premium received by
target company and
added benefits if
continue interest in
the new company
EPS Accretion from
the perspective of
acquiring company
• Purchase Accounting
• Assets of acquired firm must be reported at fair market value
• Goodwill is created – difference between purchase price and
estimated fair market value of net assets
• Goodwill no longer has to be amortized – assets are
essentially marked-to-market annually and goodwill is
adjusted and treated as an expense if the market value of
the assets has decreased
• Pooling of interests
• Pooling accounting is meant to reflect situations in which
there is no ownership change, but the uniting of business
interests
• Consolidation
•When the investor controls more than 50% of the voting shares
•Line by line consolidation of financial statements
•Eliminate inter-company transactions
•Minority interest
• Equity Method
•Investor holds between 20% and 50% of a company
•Investment stated at net asset value
•Dividends received treated as adjustment to investment
•Earnings recorded as percent of companies earnings
• Fair Value Method
•Investor holds less than 20%
•Dividends treated as income
• Goodwill -- The intangible assets of the acquired firm arising from the
acquiring firm paying more for them than their book value.
• Formerly, goodwill could not be amortized for more than 40 years for
“financial accounting purposes.” and goodwill charges are generally
deductible for “tax purposes” over 15 years.
• Now Goodwill is amortized only when determined that there has been a
permanent “impairment”
• Impairment of goodwill is not tax deductible (for tax purposes, can still
amortize goodwill)
• Step 1:
• Purchase Price of Equity less Book Value of Target
• Step 2:
• Add Transaction Cost (Like increase in the purchase price
that is capitalized)
• Step 3:
• Deduct asset write-ups (Like increase in the book value of
equity of the target)
• Step 4:
• Add liability write-ups (Like reduction in the book value of
equity of the target)
• Over the last three years, Tyco has spent about $30 billion
on acquisitions and created the same amount of goodwill.
• This example shows how the balance sheet is reconciled with valuation of
assets at market values and use of goodwill.
Restructuring charges
combined company–
• They are not recognized as a liability on the transaction date.
• Alternative synergies
• Calculations are simple: Revenues – Expenses – Working Capital Movement, net of tax
• Inputs to Derive Net Cash Flow
• Debt to Capital
• Interest Rates
• Debt Repayment
• Dividends
• Net cash flow is: Operating Cash – Interest – Debt Repayment – Dividends
• The basic structure of corporate models are easy to understand without being a modelling
expert
• The balance sheet must balance – by far the most effective check on calculations
• Purpose: establish the initial balance sheet for modeling. Existing book equity of
the target company should be eliminated. All of the other adjustments including
goodwill, debt and equity issues and retirements and asset write-ups are from
the sources and uses and the goodwill analysis.
•Surveys
•Return on Investment
• Increased diversification
• Diversification
• Investors can diversify for themselves at lower cost and
more efficiently through capital markets
• Stockholder wealth may actually decrease after the merger
because the reduction in risk in effect transfers wealth from
the stockholders to the bondholders
• Securing access to inputs or sales of outputs
• This may be valid, but presumes there are inefficient or
uncompetitive markets
• Creating the appearance of growth
• Increased EPS
Increased Integration
market power difficulties
Overcome Inadequate
entry barriers evaluation of target
Lower risk
compared to developing Too much
new products diversification
Avoid excessive
competition Too large
• Business brokers
• Accountants
• Lawyers
• Consultants
• Commercial banks
• Investment banks
• Exxon Mobil
• Chevron Texaco
Each objective
should be
quantified with
a financial
model
• An investor can invest in risk free securities and earn the risk free
rate of interest. If a strategy is to be effective, you must make
profit over and above opportunity cost -- you must make economic
profit and be able to grow the profit. If you are in a very
competitive industry and a price taker, you can earn economic
profit through cost efficiency. In a less competitive industry, you
can try to differentiate your product, and keep up barriers to entry.
• The P/E and other valuation ratios are driven by the rate of
return earned above the cost of capital and the ability to grow
real profits (valuation from ROIC and growth);
• Net present value is computed as the value of cash flow
relative to the opportunity cost of capital;
• The return on invested capital should be gauged against the
weighted average cost of capital.
• Valuation may be the most important skill for a business professional and
there are a number of different techniques that can be used to measure
value ranging from discounted free cash flow to earnings multiples to
discounted earnings. However:
• None of the valuation methods gives you a precise value number
from a practical perspective and none of the approaches is perfect
from a theoretical perspective.
• You can come up with vastly different valuations if you apply
different discount rates or different terminal value methods.
• You should acknowledge that there is a range in values and
evaluate the downside risk and upside potential in value with
different assumptions.
• If you use DCF, measure risk directly through scenario, sensitivity and
break-even analysis rather than focusing on the discount rate in the base
case.
• Merger
• Definition: A transaction where the purchasing company
buys all of the assets and assumes all the liabilities of the
target company. Both prior companies cease to exist and the
new company combines both.
• Modeling: Model mergers with exchange ratios and/or with
integrated model.
• Approval: 50% or more of the shareholders of each firm.
• Tax: No write-up of assets; no taxable gain for target
shareholders, surviving firm can use net operating loss. In
the old days, the accounting would use pooling of interests.
• Other: Assume contracts, no minority shareholders remain
• Tax: Avoids tax for the target on a corporate basis (it is as if targets
company just changed shareholders).
•Cannot write-up or step-up assets for tax purposes.
• Taxes paid by the target company and personal taxes on capital gains
result in double taxation
• Actual Example of
Goodwill and Fair
Value adjustments –
note the asset and
liability categories that
had the largest impact
• Pre-emptive Bid
• Bear Hug
• Target makes bid for Offereor before Offeror makes bid for
target
• Pac Man
• Target makes bid for Offeror after Offeror makes bid for
target
• Horizontal
• Conglomerate/Diversification
• Financial
• .