Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Challenges in Provincial Autonomy
Challenges in Provincial Autonomy
Management of
Provincial Autonomy
in the Context of 18th Amendment to
Constitution of Pakistan
PILDAT
Distribution
Balochistan: 9.09%
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa: 14.62%
Punjab: 51.74%
Sindh: 24.55%
Total: 100.00%
7th NFC Extended
Province Rank
Punjab 1
Khyber 2
Pakhtunkhwa
Balochistan 3
Sindh 3
Overall Scores
Second Year (2014-2015)
First Position:
Balochistan in 5 parameters
KP in 10 parameters
Punjab in 7 parameters
Sindh in 4 parameters
Comparative Scores
Highest Scores
KP – Environmental Sustainability
(82.3%)
Punjab – Poverty Alleviation (80.4%)
Balochistan – Devolution of Power to
Local Governments (77.7%)
Sindh – Public Transport (78.3%)
Comparative Scores
Lowest Scores
KP - Gender Gap (51%)
Punjab - Gender Gap (52.9%)
Balochistan - Public Transport
(41.3%)
Sindh - Gender Gap (38.6%)
Provincial Comparative Scores:
Education
34%
Balochistan
67%
39%
KP
61%
47%
Punjab
64%
38%
Sindh
59%
2014-15 2013-14
Provincial Comparative Scores:
Health
38%
Balochistan
60%
45%
KP
69%
48%
Punjab
65%
44%
Sindh
61%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
2014-15 2013-14
Provincial Comparative Scores: Peace,
Security & Order
53%
Balochistan
59%
34%
KP
56%
34%
Punjab
55%
41%
Sindh
60%
2014-15 2013-14
Provincial Potential
2015-2016
Balochistan
Positive improvements in
public perception
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa
Improvements in public
perception
Punjab