Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By Barkat Ali,
Advocate District Courts & High Court
CONTENTS:
1. Performance of Contract
4. Remedy
5. Types of Remedy
1. Promisee
2. Legal representative
3. Third Party
Performance of Contracts
1. Promisee:
It is only the promisee who can demand performance of the contract. There is a rule
that a person cannot acquire rights under a contract to which he is not a party. A third
party cannot demand performance of the contract even though it was made for his
benefit.
Example:
Asif promises with Raina to pay Rs.500/- to Kamal. If Asif does not pay the amount to
Kamal, It is only Raina who can demand performance , Kamal cannot demand
performance from Asif.
Performance of Contracts
2. Legal Representative:
In case of death of the promisee, his legal representatives can demand performance of
a contract unless a contract intention appears from the contract or the contract is of a
personal nature.
Example:
1. Akmal bought wheat from Babar, Babar died before recovery of price. In this case
legal representatives can demand performance.
Example:
Anil transfers some property to Anita under trust for the benefit of Mishal.
Mishal can demand the performance of contract from Anita
Performance of Contracts
Who Must Perform?
2. The Agent
Example:
Bisma promises to paint a picture for Adnan, Bisma must perform the promise herself
Performance of Contracts
2. The Agent:
In a contract where no personal skills is involved, the promisor may employ a
competent person to perform it. In case of a contract to sell goods the promisor can
appoint an agent to perform the contract. (Section 40)
Example:
Anusha promises to sell goods to Basit. Anusha can ask her agent for performance.
Performance of Contracts
3. The Legal Representatives:
In case of death of the promisor before performance, the liability of performance falls
on his legal representatives. In a contract involving personal skills, the legal
representatives of a deceased promisor are not bound to perform the contract. But in a
contract of impersonal nature, the legal representatives are bound to perform the
contract. They are liable to the extent of the estate of the deceased received by them.
They are not personally liable. (Section 37)
Example:
Danish promises to deliver mobile to Muskan on a day of Valentine of Rs. 10,000/-
Danish dies before that day. Danish’s representatives are bound to deliver mobile to
Muskan, and Muskan is bound to pay Rs.10,000/- to Danish’s representatives.
Performance of Contracts
4. The Third Person:
A Contract can be performed by a third party, if the promise accepts the arrangement.
When a promisee accepts performance of the promise from a third person, he cannot
afterwards enforce it against the promisor. (Section 41)
Example:
Aneela borrows Rs. 5 Lac from Amish & promises to repay within a month. After few
days Kashif, the friend of Aneela pays Rs. 5 Lac to Amish. Aneela is discharge from
her liabilities
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES
Two or more persons may enter into a joint agreement with one or more persons.
In such cases the question arises who can demand performance & who is liable to pay.
Example:
Amar, Akber & Anthony jointly promises to pay Rs.3,000/- to Tom, Dick & Harry
jointly. Following are the rules regarding performance in this case.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES
1. Promises
2. Legal Representatives
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES
1. Promises:
When a promise is made with several persons jointly, them, in the absence of any
agreement to the contrary, all the promises jointly can demand performance & a
single promisee cannot demand performance. (Section 45)
Example:
Danish borrows Rs. 5 Lac from Akber & Anthony. Only Akber & Anthony can
demand the performance jointly
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES
2. Legal Representatives:
In case of death of any promisee, the legal representatives of deceased person jointly
with surviving promises can demand performance. When all promises are dead, the
legal representatives of all jointly can demand performance. (Section 45)
Example:
Danish borrows Rs. 5 Lac from Akber & Anthony. Akber dies. Akber’s legal
representative with Anthony jointly can demand the performance. On the death of
Anthony the representatives of Akber & Anthony can jointly demand performance..
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES
Who Must Perform:
The rules to perform the contact are as follows:
Example:
Tom Dick and Harry jointly promise to pay rupees 3000 to Danish. Tom Dick and
Harry must contribute rupees 1000 each and pay rupees 3000 to Danish. If Tom dies
then the representative of Tom are liable to pay rupees 1000 along with Dick and
Harry.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES
Who Must Perform:
Example:
Tom, Dick and Harry jointly promise to pay Danish rupees 3000. Danish may compel
either Tom or Dick or Harry or all or any two of them to pay.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES
Who Must Perform:
Example:
If Tom is compelled to pay the entire amount of rupees 3000, he can recover from
Dick and Harry, rupees 1000 each.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES
Who Must Perform:
Example:
Tom Dick and Harry are under a joint promise to pay Danish, rupees 3000. Harry is
unable to pay anything and Tom is compelled to pay the whole. Tom is entitled to
receive Rupees 1500 from Dick
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES
Who Must Perform:
Example:
Tom, Dick and Harry are under a joint promise to pay rupees 3000 to Arshad. Arshad
releases Harry from liability. Tom and Dick remain liable to pay to Arshad. Harry is
not released from the liability to Tom and Dick. If Arshad recovers from Tom and
Dick, they can recover from Harry.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
Assignment Of Contracts:
1. Act Of Parties
2. Operation Of Law
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
Assignment Of Contracts:
1. Act Of Parties:
It is subject to following rules.
i. Contractual Liabilities:
This is subject to the following rules;
b. A promisor cannot assign his liabilities under a contract. In other words a promisee
cannot be compelled to accept a third person to perform the promise,
Example:
Aysha owes rupees hundred to Bushra and Bushra owes the same amount to Kamran.
Bushra cannot ask Kamran to recover from Aysha
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
ii. Contractual Rights:
This is subject to the following rules;
i. The right and benefits cannot be assigned, if they are of personal nature.
Example:
Alina owes Beena rupees 100. The creditor can transfer the rights to recover to
Sharukh from Alina.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
ii. Contractual Rights:
This is subject to the following rules;
ii. An actionable claim can be assigned only be an instrument in writing. Notice of such
assignment must also be given to the debtor.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
2. Operation of Law:
This may take place in any of the following circumstances.
i. Death:
Upon the death of a party to the contract his rights and liabilities are assigned to his
heirs and representatives. But when the personal skills is involved the contractual
relations come to an end on the death of promiser.
ii. Insolvency:
In case of a party to the contract been declared insolvent, his rights and liabilities
under the contract are assigned to the official receiver or assignee as the case may be.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
Reciprocal Promises:
Section 2 (f) provides that, “Promises which form the consideration for each other are
called reciprocal promises.”
In other words,
A contract consists of reciprocal promises when one party makes a promise in
consideration of a similar promise made by the other party.
Rules of Performance:
The rules of performance of reciprocal promises are as under:
(Section 51 to 54)
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
Rules of Performance:
The rules of performance of reciprocal promises are as under:
(Section 51 to 54)
Example:
Atif and Basheer contract that, Atif shall deliver goods to Basheer at a price to be
paid by Basheer on delivery. Atif needs not deliver the goods unless Basheer is ready
to pay on delivery and Basheer need not to pay unless Atif is ready to deliver them on
payment
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
Rules of Performance:
Example:
Tufail and Rana contract that Tufail shall build a house for Rana at a fixed price.
Tufail’s promise to build the house must be performed before Rana’s promise to pay
for it.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
Rules of Performance:
3. Prevention Of Performance:
When a contract contains reciprocal promises and one party to the contract prevents
the other from performing his promise, the contract becomes voidable at the option of
the party so prevented; and he is entitled to compensation from the other party for any
loss which he may sustain in consequence of the non performance of the contracts
(Section 53)
Example:
Asifa and Bilawal contract that Bilawal shall execute certain work for Asifa for Rs.
1,000 Bilawal is ready to do the work, but Asifa prevent him from doing so. The
contract becomes voidable at the option of Bilawal.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
Rules of Performance:
4. Conditional and Dependent:
Where the performance of the promise by one party depends on the prior performance of
the promise by the other party, the promises are conditional and dependent. If the
promiser, who is required to perform his promise in the first place, fails to perform it,
such promisor cannot claim the performance of the reciprocal promise, and must make
compensation to the other party to the contract for any loss with such other party may
sustain by the non-performance of the contract (Section 54)
Example:
Amit promises Bano to sell him 100 bags of wheat, to be delivered next day and Bano
promises Amit to pay within a month. Amit does not deliver. Bano’s promise to pay need
not to performed, & Amit must make compensation
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
Rules of Performance:
Example:
Asif and Bindu agree that, Asif shall sell Bindu a house for rupees 10,000, but that if
Bindu uses it as an gambling house, he shall pay Asif rupees 50,000 for it. The first set of
promises is a contract and the second set of promises is a void agreement.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
Rules of Performance:
Example:
Aslam and Bisma agree that, Aslam shall Bisma Rs.100,000/- for which Bisma shall
delivers to Aslam either rice or opium. It it is a valid contract to deliver rice and illegal
agreement as to opium.
Performance of Contracts
PERFORMANCE OF JOINT PROMISES:
Time & Place of Performance:
Following are the rules about the times & place of performance of a contract:
Example:
Zahid promises to deliver goods at Nazia’s house on 14th-February at 12:00 am.
Zahid delivers good at specified place for time.
Zahid has performed the contract.
Performance of Contracts
Time & Place Of Performance:
Example:
Akber promises to deliver goods at Bilal’s warehouse on 1st January. On that day Akbar
bring the goods to Bilal’s warehouse but after the usual hours for closing it, and they are
not received. Akbar has not perform his promise.
Performance of Contracts
Time & Place Of Performance:
Example:
Asif undertakes to deliver a thousand bags of wheat to Akhtar on a fixed day. Asif must
apply to Akhtar to appoint a reasonable place for the purpose of receiving it and must
deliver to him at such place.
Performance of Contracts
Time & Place Of Performance:
Example:
Ashok agree to supply wheat of certain day, but no place was fixed for the delivery.
Ashok must ask Shams for the place of the delivery and supply at the place.
Performance of Contracts
Time & Place Of Performance:
Example:
Ali describe Basit, who owes him rupees 1,000 to send him a note for rupees 1,000 by
post. The debt is discharged as soon as Basit puts into the post a letter containing the note
duly address to Ali.
Performance of Contracts
Time As Essence Of Contract:
The time as the essence of contract means that the time is an essential element and the
concerned parties must perform their promise within specified time.
Example:
Bilal agreed to deliver 20 bikes to Usman on 12th March 2020, But Bilal fail to deliver
by that time. The contract was voidable at the option of Usman.
Performance of Contracts
Time As Essence Of Contract:
Example:
Asif promises to supply 100 bags of sugar to Basit on 1st May, Asif supplies cement
on 9th May. Basit will have to accept the delivery. Basit can claim damages only.
Performance of Contracts
Time As Essence Of Contract:
Example:
Mirza promises to sell and supply bricks to Naveed on 5 February. Mirza delivers on
10 February. Naveed accepts the delayed delivery. He cannot afterwards claim
damages.
REMEDY
Kinds Of Damages:
The damages may be of following five kinds:
i. Ordinary Damages. ii. Special Damages.
iii. Exemplary Damages. iv. Liquidated Damages.
v. Nominal Damages.
REMEDIES FOR THE BREACH OF CONTRACT
i. Ordinary Damages:
These are also called general damages. When a contract is breached by any party, the
aggrieved party can recover from the guilty party the ordinary damages suffered by
him. Ordinary damages are those which naturally arises as the result of breach of
contract.
In other words, the aggrieved party can claim damages for loss which is the direct
result of such breach. In a contract of sale of goods, the damages payable are the
difference between the contract price and the market price at the date of breach. The
subsequent increase or decrease in the market price will not be considered. (Section
73)
Examples:
Anil contract to pay 1 Lac to Basit on 1st of March 2020. Anil does not pay on that
day. Basit as a result is totally ruined. Anil is liable to pay Basit only principal some
and interest on that.
REMEDIES FOR THE BREACH OF CONTRACT
v. Nominal Damages:
These are neither awarded to compensate the aggrieved party nor to
punish the guilty party. When the aggrieved party suffers no loss, the court
may award him nominal damages in recognition of his right. But the court
has discretion in this case. The court may refuse to award damages.
Examples:
Asif promises to sell cement to Ashraf for rupees 200 per bag. Asif does
not supply. At the time of breach, the market rate of cement is the same.
Ashraf is entitled to nominal damages.
REMEDIES FOR THE BREACH OF CONTRACT
Example:
Bina contracts to build a 03 storey house for Ashok. When 01 storey is
constructed Ashok prevents Bina from working more. Bina can get
compensation for work done.
REMEDIES FOR THE BREACH OF CONTRACT
Example:
Ayesha agrees to sell her plot of land to Kamran, who agrees to purchase it for
erecting his mill there. Due to certain inconveniences, Ayesha commits breach.
At the suit of Kamran, Ayesha is asked by the court to carry out the contract.
REMEDIES FOR THE BREACH OF CONTRACT