This document provides exercises and answers related to evaluating academic sources. It discusses evaluating different types of sources for credibility and relevance for academic use, including popular media sources, commercial websites, online encyclopedias, and educational sites. It also covers analyzing the style of writing to determine if a source is appropriate and evaluating abstracts to determine relevance for a research topic.
This document provides exercises and answers related to evaluating academic sources. It discusses evaluating different types of sources for credibility and relevance for academic use, including popular media sources, commercial websites, online encyclopedias, and educational sites. It also covers analyzing the style of writing to determine if a source is appropriate and evaluating abstracts to determine relevance for a research topic.
This document provides exercises and answers related to evaluating academic sources. It discusses evaluating different types of sources for credibility and relevance for academic use, including popular media sources, commercial websites, online encyclopedias, and educational sites. It also covers analyzing the style of writing to determine if a source is appropriate and evaluating abstracts to determine relevance for a research topic.
ALLPPT.com _ Free PowerPoint Templates, Diagrams and Charts
Exercise 1 1. D 2. E 3. A 4. F 5. C 6. B Exercise 2 Although the author writes for popu- lar media, she does have academic credentials. She holds a PhD from a respected university and is a visiting lecturer at another well-known uni- versity. She is also a member of two widely recognized scientific associa- tions and an associate editor of an academic journal. Exercise 3 1. The .com suffix indicates this is a commercial publication. Scientific American is a good quality magazine. However, as it is not written specifically for an academic audience, you should verify with your lecturers that it is alright to use this source.
2. The .co.uk suffix indicates that this is a com-
mercial news site. It is widely respected but not generally considered suitable for academic citation. Exercise 3 (cont.) 3. This is an online encyclopedia. The infor- mation is not ‘peer-reviewed’, so it is not considered suitable for academic citation.
4. The .edu suffix indicates that this is an ed-
ucational site, so the material is likely to be academically credible.
5. This is a commercial site which sells essays
online. Information from this type of site should not be cited in an essay. Exercise 4 No, it has not been written for an aca- demic audience because it is too informal in style. Although it mentions the names of scientists, the style and the use of contractions such as ‘don’t’ show the informality of the article. It is possibly an article in a newspaper or magazine. Exercise 5 1. we 2. He uses their full names: Felix Warneken and Michel Tomasello 3. the dash 4. We’ve, don’t 5. chimpanzee has been abbreviated to chimp 6. something, science 7. fascinating; give … a hand 8. all Exercise 6 1. Although the title looks potentially rele- vant (e.g. ‘cures’), the date (2000) indicates the item is too old. 2. The title doesn’t specifically mention the 2008 crisis but the word ‘aftermath’ suggests it may be relevant. 3. Probably not relevant as the focus is on causes. 4. Appears to be relevant. 5. Probably not relevant as the focus is on developing countries not on the European Union. Exercise 7 The abstract describes a study of the impact of Facebook use on undergraduate students, and would therefore not be directly relevant to young people be- tween the ages of 12 and 16. However, the study could be useful for background informa- tion and as a point of compari- son.