You are on page 1of 59

Congrats on finishing your midterm!

1
Session 11
FIN2000
Summer 2022
Professor Mark Potter, Ph.D.

2
The Agenda
Enterprise Valuation Overview
• Free Cash Flow Valuation
• Valuation by Multiples (this will look familiar!)

JetBlue and Spirit Airlines

3
Chapter 17 – Corporate Valuation
Free Cash Flow
• Free Cash Flow:
‒Amount of cash you would receive from business if you were sole owner or sole
owner and sole lender.

Operating Cash Flow

− Investment in Net Working Capital (ΔNWC)

− Net Capital Expenditures (CAPEX)

= Free Cash Flow

FCF = OCF – ΔNWC – CAPEX = EBIT × (1–T) + Depr. – ΔNWC – CAPEX


Free Cash Flow (FCF)
FCF = OCF – ΔNWC – CAPEX = EBIT × (1–T) + Depr. – ΔNWC – CAPEX

6
Free Cash Flow (FCF)
FCF = OCF – ΔNWC – CAPEX = EBIT × (1–T) + Depr. – ΔNWC – CAPEX

7
CORPORATE AND PROJECT VALUATION
• Project Valuation
‒ NPV = PV of project’s incremental free cash flows
‒ Discounted at WACC
• Corporate Valuation
‒ Treats firm as large project
‒ Value = PV of company’s free cash flow
‒ Discounted at WACC

Enterprise Value0 = [FCF1/(1+r)1] + [FCF2/(1+r)2] + …

• The value is the value of the “assets,” not the equity ownership
Enterprise Value (EV)
Market Value Balance Sheet
Non-Operating Assets
(e.g., “excess” cash) Debt

Enterprise Value Operating Assets Market Cap


(Equity)
(EV)

Enterprise value (EV) = Market Capitalization + Debt – Non-operating Assets


Market Capitalization = # of shares X share price
Enterprise value (EV) = # of shares X share price + Debt – Non-operating Assets

 Share Price
DCF VALUATION

0 1 2 3 4

FCF FCF FCF FCF

FCF
V=
𝑊𝐴𝐶𝐶
• Assuming no growth.
DCF VALUATION WITH NON-CONSTANT GROWTH

• Assume forecast period ends in n years


• Terminal period from n+1 to ∞
• Terminal Value
‒ Assume constant growth during terminal period
‒ Vn = FCFn+1 / (r - g)
or
‒ Vn = FCFn (1 + g) / (r - g)
‒ g = terminal growth rate
DCF VALUATION FORMULA

n
𝐹𝐶𝐹 𝑡 𝑉𝑛
𝑉 0=∑ t
+¿ 𝑛
¿
Where:
t =1
• n = length of forecast period
( 1+𝑟 ) ( 1+𝑟 )
• FCFt = Free Cash Flow at time t
• r = WACC = weighted average cost of capital
• Vn = Terminal Value at time n
13
WACC: 12%
4%
1 2 3 4 5
(in $ millions) $ 10 $ 12 $ 13 $ 14 14.56
$ 182
Total FCF: $ 10 $ 12 $ 13 $ 196
PV FCF: $152.31

Enterprise Value: $ 152.31


Plus cash: $ 3.00
Minus Debt: $ -
Equity Value: $ 155.31
# shares: 8
Equity Value/Share: $ 19.41
14
15
16
17
Victoria Enterprises
EBIT $1,000,000
Tax on EBIT ($400,000)
NOPAT $600,000
+Depreciation $300,000
- Δ NWC ($50,000)
- CAPEX ($300,000)
Free Cash Flow (FCF) $550,000

18
Enterprise Value to Share Price

Share Price

19
Enterprise Value to Share Price

Share Price

20
DCF Valuation

21
DCF Valuation

22
23
Spirit Stock Price Past Month

Jetblue: $3.4 billion offer, which translates into about $31.31 per share

WHERE WE ARE AT

Analyst Expectations and Ratings

Frontier: $2.9 billion offer, which translates into about $26.70 per share
24
Article Source: Bloomberg.com, 6/8/22
So, what is Spirit Airline worth???
• Use a multiples approach

• Use a free cash flow approach

25
Valuing Spirit: Multiples Approach
Steps:
1. Find Peer Set
2. Find or compute the multiples we want to use and take average
3. Apply the peer multiples to Spirit

26
Multiples We Will Use

1. Enterprise Value / Revenue


2. Enterprise Value / EBITDA
3. P/E

Averages: 0.948 7.124 17.66

0.948*$5.91 = $5.603 BILLION


(Enterprise Value of Spirit Estimate using
EV/Revenue Multiple

27
Spirit Valuation Table

Valuation Estimates Enterprise Value Equity Value Price per Share


Using EV/Revenue $5.603 billion

28
Multiples We Will Use

1. Enterprise Value / Revenue


2. Enterprise Value / EBITDA
3. P/E

Averages: 0.948 7.124 17.66

7.124*$1040.81 = $7.415 BILLION


(Enterprise Value of Spirit Estimate using EV/EBITDA
Multiple 29
Spirit Valuation Table

Valuation Estimates Enterprise Value Equity Value Price per Share


Using EV/Revenue $5.603 billion
Using EV/EBITDA $7.415 billion

30
Multiples We Will Use

1. Enterprise Value / Revenue


2. Enterprise Value / EBITDA
3. P/E

Averages: 0.948 7.124 17.66

$17.66*$0.21*4 = $14.83
(Price per Share of Spirit Estimate using P/E Multiple 31
Spirit Valuation Table

Valuation Estimates Enterprise Value Equity Value Price per Share


Using EV/Revenue $5.603 billion
Using EV/EBITDA $7.415 billion
Using P/E $14.83

AND,

JetBlue Offer = $32/share

Frontier Offer = $26/share

32
Spirit Valuation Table

Valuation Estimates Enterprise Value Equity Value Price per Share


Using EV/Revenue $5.603 billion
Using EV/EBITDA $7.415 billion
Using P/E $14.83

How do we go from Enterprise Value to Equity Value?

Enterprise Value = Equity + Debt – Cash

So Equity = Enterprise Value – Debt + Cash

So now we need to find Debt and Cash


33
CASH
1247.9

Or $1.248
billion

DEBT
293.2
165.6
2801.1
1835.9
5,095.8

Or $5.096
billion

34
Spirit Valuation Table

Valuation Estimates Enterprise Value Equity Value Price per Share


Using EV/Revenue $5.603 billion
Using EV/EBITDA $7.415 billion
Using P/E $14.83

Enterprise Value = Equity + Debt – Cash CASH DEBT


1.2480 293.2
So Equity = Enterprise Value – Debt + Cash 165.6
2801.1
Now, using Enterprise Value, Cash, and Debt, Find Equity Value! 1835.9
5.096
$5.603 - $5.096 + $1.248 = $1.755 billion Price per Share:
And, if we know that Spirit has 108.6 million shares of equity outstanding…
1.755 / 0.1086 = $16.16 35
Spirit Valuation Table

Valuation Estimates Enterprise Value Equity Value Price per Share


Using EV/Revenue $5.603 billion $1.755 $16.16
Using EV/EBITDA $7.415 billion
Using P/E $14.83

Enterprise Value = Equity + Debt – Cash CASH DEBT


1.2480 293.2
So Equity = Enterprise Value – Debt + Cash 165.6
2801.1
Now, do the same with EV/EBITDA: 1835.9
5.096
$7.415 - $5.096 + $1.248 = $3.567 billion Price per Share:
And, if we know that Spirit has 108.6 million shares of equity outstanding…
3.567 / 0.1086 = $32.85 36
Spirit Valuation Table

Valuation Estimates Enterprise Value Equity Value Price per Share


Using EV/Revenue $5.603 billion $1.755 $16.16
Using EV/EBITDA $7.415 billion $3.567 $32.85
Using P/E $14.83

AND,

JetBlue Offer = $32/share

Frontier Offer = $26/share

37
So, what is Spirit worth???
• Use a multiples approach Valuation Estimates
Using EV/Revenue
Price per Share
$16.16
Using EV/EBITDA $32.85
Using P/E $14.83

• Use a free cash flow approach

38
Spirit Valuation Table

Valuation Estimates Enterprise Value Equity Value Price per Share


Using EV/Revenue $5.603 billion $1.755 $16.16
Using EV/EBITDA $7.415 billion $3.567 $32.85
Using P/E $14.83
Dividend Discount Model? Spirit Airlines Does Not Pay A Dividend
Free Cash Flow Valuation

39
Valuing Spirit: Free Cash Flow Approach
Steps:
1. Calculate the Free Cash Flow for Spirit for 2022
(or most recent year)
2. Forecast Free Cash Flow and Terminal Value
3. Discount Free Cash Flow and Terminal Value and
determine equity price for spirit

40
Valuing Spirit: Free Cash Flow Approach
Steps:
1. Calculate the Free Cash Flow for Spirit for 2022
(or most recent year)

FREE CASH FLOW CALCULATION

41
Free Cash Flow
• Free Cash Flow:
‒Amount of cash you would receive from business if you were sole owner or sole
owner and sole lender.

Operating Cash Flow

− Investment in Net Working Capital (ΔNWC)

− Net Capital Expenditures (CAPEX)

= Free Cash Flow

FCF = OCF – ΔNWC – CAPEX = EBIT × (1–T) + Depr. – ΔNWC – CAPEX

MOST COMMON APPROACH USED


FREE CASH FLOW CALCULATION FCF

Earnings Before Interest and Taxes EBIT Operating earnings


(taxes) Abbreviated (taxes) Effective tax rate
Net Operating Profit After Taxes Version NOPAT
+ Depreciation & Amortization + Depr
+/- Net Working Capital Changes +/- NWC
+/- Changes in Property, Plant, & Equipment - CAPEX

Where do you find this stuff?


43
FREE CASH FLOW CALCULATION FCF

Earnings Before Interest and Taxes EBIT Operating earnings


(taxes) Abbreviated (taxes) Effective tax rate
Net Operating Profit After Taxes Version NOPAT
+ Depreciation & Amortization + Depr
+/- Net Working Capital Changes +/- NWC
+/- Changes in Property, Plant, & Equipment - CAPEX

INCOME STATEMENT

Where do you find this stuff?


44
FREE CASH FLOW CALCULATION FCF

Earnings Before Interest and Taxes EBIT Operating earnings


(taxes) Abbreviated (taxes) Effective tax rate
Net Operating Profit After Taxes Version NOPAT
+ Depreciation & Amortization + Depr
+/- Net Working Capital Changes +/- NWC
+/- Changes in Property, Plant, & Equipment - CAPEX

BALANCE SHEET

Where do you find this stuff?


45
FREE CASH FLOW CALCULATION FCF

Earnings Before Interest and Taxes EBIT Operating earnings


(taxes) Abbreviated (taxes) Effective tax rate
Net Operating Profit After Taxes Version NOPAT
+ Depreciation & Amortization + Depr
+/- Net Working Capital Changes NWC
+/- Changes in Property, Plant, & Equipment - CAPEX

STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS

Where do you find this stuff?


46
Last time they paid taxes: 2018
FREE CASH FLOW CALCULATION

(335.6) Earnings Before Interest and Taxes


0 (taxes)
(335.6) Tax rate: 101.2/436.4 = 23.2%
Net Operating Profit After Taxes
+ 205.9 + Depreciation & Amortization
Taxes will be 0 for this year
+/- Net Working Capital Changes
+/- Changes in Property, Plant, & Equipment

47
In Total, Cash went up by
$13+$244.3 = $267.3 due
to changes in working
FREE CASH FLOW CALCULATION capital accounts
(335.6) Earnings Before Interest and Taxes
0 (taxes) Current Assets decreased by: $13
(335.6) Net Operating Profit After Taxes
205.9 + Depreciation & Amortization Therefore Cash went UP by $13
+/- Net Working Capital Changes
+/- Changes in Property, Plant, & Equipment

Remaining Current
Liabilities increased from:

908.1 in 2021 to
1152.4 in 2022

For an increase of 244.3

Therefore Cash went UP by $244.3

48
FREE CASH FLOW CALCULATION

(335.6) Earnings Before Interest and Taxes


0 (taxes)
(335.6) Net Operating Profit After Taxes
+205.9 + Depreciation & Amortization
+267.3 +/- Net Working Capital Changes
+/- Changes in Property, Plant, & Equipment
FREE CASH FLOW CALCULATION

(335.6) Earnings Before Interest and Taxes


0 (taxes)
(335.6) Net Operating Profit After Taxes
+205.9 + Depreciation & Amortization
+267.3 +/- Net Working Capital Changes
+/- Changes in Property, Plant, & Equipment
PP&E increased from
6692 to 6834.3.

This results in a cash


decline of:

6834.3
6692.0
142.3

51
FREE CASH FLOW CALCULATION

(335.6) Earnings Before Interest and Taxes


0 (taxes)
(335.6) Net Operating Profit After Taxes
+205.9 + Depreciation & Amortization
+267.3 +/- Net Working Capital Changes
-142.3 +/- Changes in Property, Plant, & Equipment

- 4.7 Spirit Free Cash Flow for 2022


Step 2. Forecast Free Cash Flow and Terminal Value
0 1 2 3 4

- 4.7 FCF FCF FCF FCF


$41.8 million $67 million $107 million $171 million
From Analyst $7,904 million
Forecasts
$171*1.04 / (0.0625-0.04)
Forecasts range, but average is for growth to be roughly
60% per year from years 1-4.

From there, we can dial it down to a sustainable level, for


simplicity (for now) we will assume 4% per year beyond
year 4.

Also, for now, assume that investor’s require a rate of


return of 6.25%

https://www.wallstreetzen.com/stocks/us/nyse/save/stock-forecast 53
Step 3. Discount Free Cash Flow and Terminal Value
0 1 2 3 4

FCF FCF FCF FCF

$6,524 $41.8 $67 million $107 million $171 million


$7,904 million

$6,524 Enterprise Value for Spirit


(5,096) Debt
1,248 Cash
$2,676 Equity for Spirit $3,520 / 108.6 shares = $24.64

54
Spirit Valuation Table

Valuation Estimates Enterprise Value Equity Value Price per Share


Using EV/Revenue $5.603 billion $1.755 $16.16
Using EV/EBITDA $7.415 billion $3.567 $32.85
Using P/E $14.83
Dividend Discount Model? Spirit Airlines Does Not Pay A Dividend
Free Cash Flow Valuation $6,524 $2,676 $24.64

55
DCF Valuation

DO NOT DO NOW

57
DO NOT DO NOW

58
For our next session
1. Open Q&A and Discussion: JetBlue, Frontier, and Spirit

2. McDonald’s Valuation using free cash flow and multiples


approaches

3. We will be using laptops

59

You might also like