This document discusses and compares the properties of human language and animal communication. It examines how different animals such as chimpanzees, gorillas, and bonobos were raised and taught sign language. While some learned individual signs and could combine them, none displayed true linguistic abilities like displacement and productivity that are characteristic of human language. The document also explores theories of language origins and debates regarding how animal communication systems differ from human language.
This document discusses and compares the properties of human language and animal communication. It examines how different animals such as chimpanzees, gorillas, and bonobos were raised and taught sign language. While some learned individual signs and could combine them, none displayed true linguistic abilities like displacement and productivity that are characteristic of human language. The document also explores theories of language origins and debates regarding how animal communication systems differ from human language.
This document discusses and compares the properties of human language and animal communication. It examines how different animals such as chimpanzees, gorillas, and bonobos were raised and taught sign language. While some learned individual signs and could combine them, none displayed true linguistic abilities like displacement and productivity that are characteristic of human language. The document also explores theories of language origins and debates regarding how animal communication systems differ from human language.
Intentional X Unintentional communication Properties: Reflexivity: We can use language to think and talk about language itself. Examples? Displacement: Here and now? (time, place, truth, imagination) Examples? What about bee communication? Arbitrariness (onomatopoeic words?) ANİMALS AND HUMAN LANGUAGE Productivity: Humans create new expressions and utterances to describe new objects and situations (creativity & open endedness) Bee experiment?
Cultural transmission (acquisition in a culture x animal
instinctive language) Duality (limited sounds x many combinations) TALKİNG TO ANİMALS Behaviourism? Conditioning? Training? Chimpanzees and language: Why? Gua: understands about a hundred words but cannot say utter any of them Viki: raised as a human child. Poor articulation of human sounds? Washoe and Koko: Raised like a human child. ASL? She could use and combine words to make sentences, questions and answers? (‘Open food drink’) Water bird referring to a swan? How do you explain? TALKİNG TO ANİMALS Sarah (caged?) (plastic shapes in building sentences? How do you explain the arbitrariness?) Lana (Yerkish symbols>computer?) (How do you explain the arbitrariness?) Kanzi: started to use Yerkish easily? Used gentle noises as words to refer to things such as bananas etc. How do you explain?(first language acquisition? Age? Exposure?) Nim (learned behaviour? Conditioning?) PROPERTİES OF LANGUAGE Vocal-auditory channel Specialisation