This document provides feedback from markers on a Year 10 yearly exam. It discusses student responses to four questions: 1) How does a magazine cover comment on political power, 2) How an image conveys the power of technology, 3) How a poem represents unwillingness to surrender through poetic techniques, and 4) How two texts comment on power with reference to techniques. The feedback indicates that most students did well on question 2 but struggled with questions 1, 3 and 4, failing to sufficiently analyze techniques and compare texts. Students are advised to pay close attention to question requirements and support responses with specific examples and textual evidence.
This document provides feedback from markers on a Year 10 yearly exam. It discusses student responses to four questions: 1) How does a magazine cover comment on political power, 2) How an image conveys the power of technology, 3) How a poem represents unwillingness to surrender through poetic techniques, and 4) How two texts comment on power with reference to techniques. The feedback indicates that most students did well on question 2 but struggled with questions 1, 3 and 4, failing to sufficiently analyze techniques and compare texts. Students are advised to pay close attention to question requirements and support responses with specific examples and textual evidence.
This document provides feedback from markers on a Year 10 yearly exam. It discusses student responses to four questions: 1) How does a magazine cover comment on political power, 2) How an image conveys the power of technology, 3) How a poem represents unwillingness to surrender through poetic techniques, and 4) How two texts comment on power with reference to techniques. The feedback indicates that most students did well on question 2 but struggled with questions 1, 3 and 4, failing to sufficiently analyze techniques and compare texts. Students are advised to pay close attention to question requirements and support responses with specific examples and textual evidence.
Section I Reading Task Markers’ feedback Mr Tzantzaris, Mr Penn and Mr Ticehurst Question 1
How does the magazine cover comment on political power? 4 marks
• To gain full marks, students needed to identify one comment on political power made and support their discussion with at least THREE visual techniques. • Students who failed to gain full marks tended to generalise about the image without linking to specific visual language. • Be sure to pay attention to the mark allocation when determining the required depth and detail. • Students will need to refine their knowledge of visual language and how meaning is conveyed • See exemplar response below Question 2 How does the image convey the power of technology in the modern world? 4 marks • This question was done quite well by the majority of students. • To gain full marks students need to correctly identify and explain THREE visual techniques and explain how they conveyed the power of technology. • Most students explained that the image suggested that technology was controlling humanity. • Students did well to identify the symbolism of the saddle and reins, suggesting the Pikachu character was controlling the human subject. • The contrast in colour, vectors, gaze and the exaggerated neck of the male subject were also explained effectively. Question 3 To gain full marks, students need to correctly identify and explain •Analyse how the poem represents the persona’s unwillingness to how FOUR poetic techniques were used to convey ideas to do with not surrender. 5 marks surrendering. • Quite a few students failed to go into enough depth and detail with their response. There was also a failure to correctly identify specific poetic techniques. • There was some confusion over the technique of zoomorphism, particularly as it related to the line ”If we must die, let it not be like hogs”. This is a simile in which the persona emphasises a desire to not die like a hog i.e. to not die without honour or nobility. • Zoomorphism as technique involves attributing the characteristics of animals to human beings, which is not the case in this instance. The effect is achieved through the simile. Question 4: texts 1, 2, 3 and 4 With reference to Text Four and ONE other text, compare the ways the texts comment on power. 7 marks • This response was a significant discriminator for the cohort. • There were numerous strong responses achieving full marks, however, many students failed to go into enough depth and detail. • The prose extract was also a challenging text in terms of form and content. • Time management also appeared to be a factor in determining success in this question. • To achieve full marks you needed to present an argument as to what each text’s comment on power was and then support your discussion of this idea with at least THREE examples/techniques from the text. Question 4 cont’d
• The better responses were able to COMPARE the comments on power.
• You may use evidence from earlier responses, provided you shape your explanations to the focus of the particular question. • There was some confusion over what was meant by the character Atticus loosening his tie and unbuttoning his waistcoat. To the children he seemed naked. This was because it was so unusual for him to be dressed informally. He was not naked literally. • The extract itself was quite tough and required close reading. Be sure to make good use of reading time.