Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Project Presentation - Measure Phase
Project Presentation - Measure Phase
MEASURE
Project Charter
This resulted in complaint from our business partner, lost business Secondary metric is to document the products request and discuss customer
opportunity and impacted our competitive position in the market. focused concept in the trading team and then generate completion of Blue Desk
Form within 4 weeks.
Estimated Financial Impact : RM 52.395 Million Estimated Completion Date: 30 June 2010
Run Chart – Conception Phase
(New Products Development in 2009)
Auto withdrawal
features -Due to
21 system capability
(needs 3 years for
Run Chart: Conception
16 development)
11
Mean: 4.50
6
month
18 Count = 38
Mean = 4.500
16
Stdev = 4.360
14 Range = 23.00
12
10 Minimum = 1
The average time
8 25th Percentile (Q1) = 1
taken from Conception
50th Percentile (Median) = 4 Phase is between
6
75th Percentile (Q3) = 7 3.07 month to 5.93
4
Maximum = 24 month, with 95%
2 confidence level
0 95% CI Mean = 3.07 to 5.93
95% CI Sigma = 3.55 to 5.64
1.0
6.1
8.7
3.6
11.2
13.8
16.3
18.9
21.5
24.0
Enter LSL:
Resources problem No Gatekeeper (Planner) Blue Desk not completed fully but Different requirement/process Competitors Analysis
register at PSC between channel
Slow in response time to new ideas Sales perspective on product No proper registration of new Product request is not monitor Research inputs/ Reference
Ideas and Sales don’t ideas missing Not register in Not able to share
resources understand Blue Desk info of competitors
No Ownership and responsibilty of sub processes No Awareness of product Skip process (short cut) Work job scope not clear at the No proper filling
Development Process beginning stage
No assess effort done by related Don't care to ask Tigh timeline Request is differ Documents
department (short cut) No from nature and missing
concept form features
Dependency of 3rd Party Lack of discussion with Bank Always change in priority or Not clear in policy
decision making
System Flexibility & Capability Not prepare for Build, Launch & New Regulatory Requirement
Delay in Completion of
Replicate
Conception Phase
IT is not familiar Not in own control
with new feature in
the system
Long time to Must DO!
analysis
Computer slow, No colour printer Income to Distributor New Players in the market (Takaful)
People
100% in new
product
development, not
focus
PEOPLE
Conception Phase – Cause & Effect Diagram
Process
Skip process (short cut) Work job scope not clear at the
beginning stage
PROCESS busy
hard to get
response from
email
Conception Phase – Cause & Effect Diagram
ENVIRONMENT factor:
New Regulatory Requirement Not in own control
Must DO!
Competition
Divert attention
Economic conditions
Not suistable to
launch
Economic turn
down
Environment
Conception Phase – Failure Mode & Effect Analysis (FMEA)
Potential Failure Mode & Effects Analysis
Process/Product:
FMEA Team:
To improve TAT of response to product request
Nizam, Kam Liang, Nana, Nik & Shah
Highest RPN –
Responsibility:
Prepared By:
Nizam, Kam Liang, Nana, Nik & Shah
Low Kam Liang Risk Priority
No Process Steps or Product Functions Potential Failure
Mode
Process
Potential Effects of Failure Severity
(1-10)
Potential Cause(s) of
Failure
Occurrence
(1-10)
Current Controls Detection
(1-10)
Risk Priority
Number (RPN)
Number base
on severity,
Work job scope not clear at the beginning stage
Delay in project Delay in project Under estimate of resources
estimates
Product Development Weekly Meeting
occurrence &
detection link
1 10 8 7 560
Work not done Delay in project Under estimate of effort Trading Team members
No Ownership and responsibilty of sub processes completely required & lack of
2 10 commitment 8 6 480
3
New Regulatory Requirement
Delay in project
No awareness
Affect new product
development timeline
No awareness
8
Product in queue
No communication between
6
No control available
Development
5 7 8 8 448
Missing ideas info on Not able to track product ideas No database to store the Trading Team members
No proper registration of new product ideas
6 product ideas 7 product ideas 8 8 448
7 Product request is not monitored Product request delay product request delay 7 Nobody care and ask 8 Trading Team members 8 448
8
9
Slow in response time to new ideas
Resources problem
slow response time
Delay in project
complaint for sales channel
Delay in project
7
8
Long TAT to new ideas
Product in queue
8
8
No control available
No control available
8
7
448
448
Processes
Delay in project Affect new product Unclear request PSC
Always change in priority or decision making development timeline
10 8 7 8 448
Work not done Affect new product Compliance issues Product Development Weekly Meeting
Skip process (short cut) completely development timeline
11 9 7 7 441
Delay in project Affect new product Analysis not complete PSC
Blue Desk not completed fully but register at PSC development timeline
12 9 7 7 441
Missing files Missing files Not able to access No control available
No proper filling documents for futures
13 9 references 8 6 432
No awareness No awareness No communication between No control available
No Awareness of Product Development Process
14 10 department 6 7 420
Sales not picking up Company sales target goes Regulatory No control available
Income to Distributor
15 down 7 5 9 315
No control on the Process unclear No communication between No Control available
Difference requirement/process between channel process and department
16 requirement 7 6 7 294
not familiar with new Delay in response to product Long time for analysis No control available
System Flexibility & Capability
17 feature in the system ideas 7 6 7 294
High competition in the effect on the market Strong competition No control available
New Players in the market (Takaful)
18 market positioning 8 7 5 280
High competition in the Divert attention No competitive advantage No control available
New Products launch in the market
19 market 8 7 5 280
Time consuming for No awareness on the No dedicated resources Market Watch
Competitors Analysis competitive analysis competitor's movement in the
20 market 6 7 6 252
No up todate info No up todate info Not able to access Market Watch
Research inputs/ Reference Materials/Regulation not updated documents for futures
21 6 references 7 6 252
Delay in sign off Affect new product Waiting time to get PIC, Product Development Weekly Meeting
Time consuming for sign off development timeline everybody busy
22 8 6 5 240
23 Economic conditions Not suitable to launch Lose competition 8 Economic turn down 3 No control available 10 240
24 Lack of discussion with Bank Unclear request Delay in project 7 Resources problem 6 Insurance & Takaful Task Force (ITTF) 5 210
No innovative products Different requirement by the Pricing assumption different Wealth Management Task Force
Dependency of 3rd Party
25 distributor 8 5 4 160
No clear understanding Lack of communication Always agreed to the Trading Team members
resource planning and customer to offer products
Sales perspective on product development
28
High Capital Requirement (Risk)
Product design not
attractive
Never ready for it
No innovative products
Slow to market
8
Expenses of the company
increase
will have direct competition
3
No control available
No control available
5 120
Detail FMEA
Not prepare for Build, Launch & Replicate with CIMB Bank (others
29 5 version for similar products) 5 4 100
Marketing material not Marketing material not Slows of works No control available
Computer slow, No colour printer presented well to bank presented well to bank
30 partners partners 3 8 1 24
Conception Phase – Failure Mode & Effect Analysis (FMEA)
Process
No Process Steps or Product Functions Potential Failure Potential Effects of Failure Severity Potential Cause(s) of Occurrence Current Controls Detection Risk Priority
Mode (1-10) Failure (1-10) (1-10) Number (RPN)
Delay in project Delay in project Under estimate of resources Product Development Weekly Meeting
Work job scope not clear at the beginning stage estimates
1 10 8 7 560
Work not done Delay in project Under estimate of effort Trading Team members
No Ownership and responsibilty of sub processes completely required & lack of
2 10 commitment 8 6 480
Delay in project Affect new product Product in queue No control available
New Regulatory Requirement
3 development timeline 8 6 10 480
No awareness No awareness No communication between Product Development Weekly Meeting
Policy not clear
4 10 department 6 8 480
Product not able to No proper product planning No monitoring on the Product Development Weekly Meeting
No Gatekeeper (Planner) prioritize accordingly product request status
5 7 8 8 448
Missing ideas info on Not able to track product ideas No database to store the Trading Team members
No proper registration of new product ideas
6 product ideas 7 product ideas 8 8 448
7 Product request is not monitored Product request delay product request delay 7 Nobody care and ask 8 Trading Team members 8 448
Conception Phase – Failure Mode & Effect Analysis (FMEA)
Process
No Process Steps or Product Functions Potential Failure Potential Effects of Failure Severity Potential Cause(s) of Occurrence Current Controls Detection Risk Priority
Mode (1-10) Failure (1-10) (1-10) Number (RPN)
slow response time complaint for sales channel Long TAT to new ideas No control available
8 Slow in response time to new ideas 7 8 8 448
Delay in project Delay in project Product in queue No control available
9 Resources problem 8 8 7 448
Delay in project Affect new product Unclear request PSC
Always change in priority or decision making development timeline
10 8 7 8 448
Work not done Affect new product Compliance issues Product Development Weekly Meeting
Skip process (short cut) completely development timeline
11 9 7 7 441
Delay in project Affect new product Analysis not complete PSC
Blue Desk not completed fully but register at PSC development timeline
12 9 7 7 441
Missing files Missing files Not able to access No control available
No proper filling documents for futures
13 9 references 8 6 432
No awareness No awareness No communication between No control available
No Awareness of Product Development Process
14 10 department 6 7 420
Conception Phase – Failure Mode & Effect Analysis (FMEA)
Process
No Process Steps or Product Functions Potential Failure Potential Effects of Failure Severity Potential Cause(s) of Occurrence Current Controls Detection Risk Priority
Mode (1-10) Failure (1-10) (1-10) Number (RPN)
Sales not picking up Company sales target goes Regulatory No control available
Income to Distributor
15 down 7 5 9 315
No control on the Process unclear No communication between No Control available
Difference requirement/process between channel process and department
16 requirement 7 6 7 294
not familiar with new Delay in response to product Long time for analysis No control available
System Flexibility & Capability
17 feature in the system ideas 7 6 7 294
High competition in the effect on the market Strong competition No control available
New Players in the market (Takaful)
18 market positioning 8 7 5 280
High competition in the Divert attention No competitive advantage No control available
New Products launch in the market
19 market 8 7 5 280
Time consuming for No awareness on the No dedicated resources Market Watch
Competitors Analysis competitive analysis competitor's movement in the
20 market 6 7 6 252
No up todate info No up todate info Not able to access Market Watch
Research inputs/ Reference Materials/Regulation not updated documents for futures
21 6 references 7 6 252
Delay in sign off Affect new product Waiting time to get PIC, Product Development Weekly Meeting
Time consuming for sign off development timeline everybody busy
22 8 6 5 240
23 Economic conditions Not suitable to launch Lose competition 8 Economic turn down 3 No control available 10 240
24 Lack of discussion with Bank Unclear request Delay in project 7 Resources problem 6 Insurance & Takaful Task Force (ITTF) 5 210
No innovative products Different requirement by the Pricing assumption different Wealth Management Task Force
Dependency of 3rd Party
25 distributor 8 5 4 160
No clear understanding Lack of communication Always agreed to the Trading Team members
resource planning and customer to offer products
Sales perspective on product development
task involved that is not do-able
26 10 5 3 150
Product design not No innovative products Withdrawal of the products Pricing Report
Profit to CIMB Aviva
27 attractive 8 (loss making) 3 5 120
Product design not No innovative products Expenses of the company No control available
High Capital Requirement (Risk)
28 attractive 8 increase 3 5 120
Never ready for it Slow to market will have direct competition No control available
Not prepare for Build, Launch & Replicate with CIMB Bank (others
29 5 version for similar products) 5 4 100
Marketing material not Marketing material not Slows of works No control available
Computer slow, No colour printer presented well to bank presented well to bank
30 partners partners 3 8 1 24
Data Collection Plan
Type of Data Data Source Who Will Collect the When Will Data How Will Data
No Measurement/Metric X or Y Operational Definition (Discrete/Continuous) and Location Sample Size Data? be Collected? be Collected?
Work job scope not clear at the beginning stage Product Development Weekly
1 X Clear job scope in the job description Discrete Meeting's minutes Whole population Nizam & Kam Liang Measure & Analyse Phase Manual
2 No Ownership and responsibilty of sub processes X Clear job scope define in processes Discrete Sales Team Whole population Nana & Kam Liang Measure & Analyse Phase Manual
3 New Regulatory Requirement X BNM Guideline, Risk Management Discrete Risk Management Dept Whole population Nana & Kam Liang Measure & Analyse Phase Manual
Samples
BNM Guideline
Data Collection Sheet
Samples
Samples
Samples
Samples
Start
VA B
8.0 (a) Prepare Blue Desk Form 8.0 (b) Do Product Comparison
Obtain Sign
Off? VA
Yes
Concept Form is not Any further
Yes PSC
consistently circulated and issues to
resolve?
No
Approved?
VA
without Pricing
No
NO ACTIVITY / STAGE START DATE END DATE WORKING AVERAGE NO. OF DAYS REQUIRED SOURCE OF RESOURCES
DAYS FROM GB / YB PER WEEK
1 DEFINE 22/2/2010 14/3/2010 15 1.5 days / week Marketing Proposition Development, S&D, PSC, TT,
Project Chartering Actuarial, Risk Management, Change Management,
Process Map verification Corporate & Quality Assurance, Operations & Bank
SIPOC, VOC & CTQ
Just do it
Barriers & Challenges
Financial Benefits
2 MEASURE 15/3/2010 14/4/2010 23 2.0 days / week Marketing Proposition Development, S&D, PSC, TT,
Baseline measurement Actuarial, Risk Management, Change Management,
Cause & Effect Corporate & Quality Assurance, Operations & Bank
FMEA & Data Collection Plan
Potential Xs
3 ANALYSE 15/4/2010 3/5/2010 13 2.0 days / week Marketing Proposition Development, S&D, PSC, TT,
Actuarial, Risk Management, Change Management,
Corporate Quality & Assurance, Operations & Bank
4 IMPROVE 4/5/2010 24/5/2010 15 TBC Marketing Proposition Development, S&D, PSC, TT,
Actuarial, Risk Management, Change Management,
Just Do It implementation plan
Corporate Quality & Assurance, Operations & Bank
Initiative Implementation plan
TOTAL 66
5 CONTROL 25/5/2010 31/12/2010 32 weeks TBC Marketing Proposition Development, S&D, PSC, TT,
Actuarial, Risk Management, Change Management,
Corporate Quality & Assurance, Operations & Bank
Project Milestones
EST. Feb-10 Mar-10 Apr-10 May-10 Jun-10 Dec-10
MILESTONE PROJECT ACTIVITIES
TIME W4 W1 W2 W3 W4 W1 W2 W3 W4 W1 W2 W3 W4 W1 W2 W3 W4 W1 W2 W3 W4
DEFINE Define charter & definition 3
Understand overview of the project scope and background 2
Define problem & goal statement 2
Draw out SIPOC 1.5
Understand VOC & categorise 3
Translate VOC into CTQ 1.5
Process Mapping 3
Estimated Financial Benefit 3
Resources Planning (Tean roles & responsibility) 1
Project Milestone 1
Issues & Challenges 1
Quick Wins / Just Do It 1
MEASURE Refine Problem Statement & Defect definition and Timeline 1
Cause & Effect - Fishbone session for brainstorming 5
Translate into Cause & Effect matrix 2
Detail out Failure Mode & Effect Analysis (FMEA) 3
Develop Data Collection Plan 3
Sample Data Collection Sheet 2
Value Stream Mapping 2
Calculate Sigma or Z capability for baseline 2
Develop Project Execution Plan 1
Issues & Challenges 1
Quick Wins / Just Do It 1
ANALYSE List down key input variables / funnelling
Analysis strategy checklist
Graphical & Statistical Analysis
List of validated Xs
Action plan for improve phase
Quick Wins / Just Do It
Refine Charter
Issues & Challenges
IMPROVE Brainstorm improvement ideas
Pilot & Validate Improvement
Create 'Should Be' process
Look at possible DFSS
Perform cost & benefit analysis
Summary of Improvement phase
CONTROL Monitor trend (6 months)
Conduct training
Updates any SOP
Develop audit plan
Develop sign off and transfer of new process
Develop and validate real financial benefit
Reporting
Sign off & closure
“Just-Do-It” Opportunities
Person In
No Problem Quick Wins Charge Timeline
• No data available
• Difficulties of accessibility to sales people and
business partner process