Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Niveen Lutfi
THINGS TO BE COVERED
General Comparison
Analysis methods to evaluate earthquake forces
Simplified Design Base Shear
Equivalent Static Method
Response Spectrum Method
Time History Method
Directional Effect
Diaphragm Design Forces
P-∆ Effect
Drift Limitations
GENERAL COMPARISION
UBC-97
Ca = Acceleration coefficient as per UBC Table 16-Q.
Cv = Velocity coefficient as per UBC Table 16-R.
Z = Zone factor as per UBC Table 16-I.
GENERAL COMPARISION
UBC-97
TABLE 16.I-SEISMIC ZONE FACTOR Z
Zone 1 2A 2B 3 4
SOIL CLASSIFICATION
Soil
Profile Z = 0.075 Z = 0.15 Z = 0.2 Z = 0.3 Z = 0.4
Soil
Profile Z = 0.075 Z = 0.15 Z = 0.2 Z = 0.3 Z = 0.4
S M 1 Fv S1
SMS = Maximum considered earthquake spectral acceleration
at short period.
S Ms Fa S s
SD1 = Design spectral acceleration at one second period.
S D1 2 S M 1
3
SDS = Design spectral acceleration for short period.
S DS 2 S MS
3
IBC-2000
TABLE 1615.2(1)
III Essential facilities either important for security, provide major 1.5
services such as rescue operations, health services,
transportation and communications.
S1 ≥ 0.75 E E F
Design Requirements of Seismic Design Categories
UBC-97 IBC-2000
UBC-97 IBC-2000
1.2 S DS
Total Base V W
3.0C a R
Shear V W
R S DS 2 / 3S MS
S MS Fa S S
Vertical
Distribution
3.0C a 1.2 S DS
of Base Fx wi Fx wx
Shear R R
Simplified Design Base Shear (UBC-97)
Simplified Analysis Procedure (IBC-2000)
UBC-97 IBC-2000
5. Permanent 5. Permanent
equipment. equipment.
Simplified Design Base Shear (UBC-97)
Simplified Analysis Procedure (IBC-2000)
Example 1
Solution
UBC-97
- Seismic Coefficient, Ca
The seismic coefficient Ca is obtained from UBC table 16-Q. For zone
3 and soil type Sd, Ca = 0.36.
- Response Modification Factor, R
The response modification factor, R, is obtained from UBC table 16-N.
For building frame system and concrete shear walls, R=5.5.
- Base Shear V
3.0C a 3.0(0.36)
V W W 0.196W
R 5 .5
Simplified Design Base Shear (UBC-97)
Simplified Analysis Procedure (IBC-2000)
IBC-2000
- Spectral Acceleration SS
The spectral acceleration SS can be obtained from IBC-2000 map
section 1615.1, figure 1615(1). For Longitude 121 o and Latitude 38o,
Ss (0.2 sec. spectral response acceleration, 5% of critical damping,
site class B) ≈ 0.58g.
-Base Shear V
1.2 S DS 1.2(0.52)
V W W 0.125W
R 5 .0
Static Force Procedure (UBC-97)
Equivalent Lateral Force Procedure (IBC-2000)
UBC-97 IBC-2000
UBC-97 IBC-2000
V Cs W
Total Base
Shear Where,
2.5Ca I S DS I E
W S D1 I E
R C
S R
RT
C I 0.11 Ca I W 0.044 S DS I E
V v W
RT 0.8 Z N v I W C shall not also be taken
R S
UBC-97 IBC-2000
UBC-97 IBC-2000
where
N = Number of stories.
Simplified Design Base Shear (UBC-97)
Simplified Analysis Procedure (IBC-2000)
UBC-97 IBC-2000
n 2 n
T 2 wi i g f i i
i 1 i 1
Simplified Design Base Shear (UBC-97)
Simplified Analysis Procedure (IBC-2000)
UBC-97 IBC-2000
where Note:
Structure The calculated fundamental
Period f i The applied lateral forces. period,
i The elastic deflections. T, shall not exceed the product
of the coefficient for upper limit
on calculated period, Cu, which
Note: obtained from table 1617.4.2
The value of T from Method B and the approximate
shall not exceed a value 30 fundamental period Ta.
percent greater than the value
of T obtained from method A
in Seismic Zone 4, and 40 SD1 Cu
percent in Seismic Zones 1, 2 ≥ 0.4 1.2
and 3. 0.3 1.3
0.2 1.4
0.15 1.5
≤ 0.1 1.7
Simplified Design Base Shear (UBC-97)
Simplified Analysis Procedure (IBC-2000)
UBC-97 IBC-2000
wx hx
Fx (V Ft )
wi hi
Simplified Design Base Shear (UBC-97)
Simplified Analysis Procedure (IBC-2000)
UBC-97 IBC-2000
Vertical
Distribution
of Base
Shear
Simplified Design Base Shear (UBC-97)
Simplified Analysis Procedure (IBC-2000)
Example 2
Solution
UBC-97
- Seismic coefficients Ca and Cv
The seismic coefficients Ca and Cv are obtained from UBC table 16-Q
and 16-R, respectively. For zone 3 and soil type S d, Ca = 0.36 and Cv =
0.54.
- Response modification factor, R
The response modification factor, R, is obtained from UBC table 16-N.
For building frame system and concrete shear walls, R=5.5.
-Period (T)
T C t ( hn ) 3 / 4
-Base Shear V
2.5C a I
Cv I W
V W R
RT 0.11 C I W
a
2.5(0.36)(1)
0.54(1) W 0.164W
V W 0.205W 5.5
5.5(0.48) 0.11(0.36)(1) W .0396W
Therefore, V = 0.164W
Simplified Design Base Shear (UBC-97)
Simplified Analysis Procedure (IBC-2000)
IBC-2000
-Period (T)
T C t ( hn ) 3 / 4
0.52(1)
0.254(1) 0.104
CS .106 5
5.0(.48) 0.044 (0.52)(1) 0.0229
Therefore, Cs = 0.104, then V = 0.104W.
Response Spectrum Analysis
For each mode, the spectral forces and displacement are found
and then combined by SABS (Absolute method), SRSS (Square
Root of the Sum of the Squares), CQC (Complete Quadratic
Combination).
Response Spectrum Analysis
Time History Analysis
This is the general method used for large and complex structures.
Ground motion records are needed for this type of analysis, the
code requires that at least three pairs of records be used.
These records shall reflect site characteristics and seismic hazard
and They can either be scaled from actual records, or, artificially
generated (synthetic records).
Directional Effect
UBC-97 IBC-2000
Vertical
Earthquake E v 0.5C a ID E v 0.2 S DS D
Component
Directional Effect
UBC-97 IBC-2000
E Eh Ev E QE E v
Em o Eh E m o QE E v
where, where,
Design E = effect of combined E = effect of combined
Earthquake Force horizontal and vertical horizontal and vertical
components of the components of the
earthquake. earthquake.
Em = estimated Em = estimated maximum
maximum force that can force that can develop in
develop in the structure the structure due to
due to overstrength overstrength effect.
effect. Ωo = overstrength factor
Ωo = overstrength factor as defined per IBC Table
as defined per UBC 1617.6.
Table 16-N. ρ = reliability /
ρ = reliability / redundancy factor.
redundancy factor.
UBC-97 IBC-2000
-For seismic design
6 .1 category A, B and C, ρ
2 shall be taken 1.0
rmax AB
- For seismic design
Reliability / category D, E and F, ρ
Redundancy Factor AB = ground floor shall be taken as:
rmax = the maximum element-
6 .1
story shear ratio of floor 2
rmax AB
number (i) where (i) is any
floor that lies within the first Ai = ground floor area
two thirds of the building rmax = the maximum
from the ground . ri is given element-story shear ratio
according to the structural of floor number (i) where
system as follows: (i) is any floor that lies
within the first two thirds of
the building from the
ground . ri is given
according to the structural
system as follows:
UBC-97 IBC-2000
Zones
1
1&2
Drift
Calculations 1
Note 1 : If moment resisting frames are not used as part of a dual system, the frame bays must be arranged
(increased) to produce a value of less or equals to 1.25.
Note 2: = length of the wall in the horizontal direction in meters.
Table 1 Definitions and values of parameter ρ as defined in IBC-2000
SDC
1
A, B & C
Drift
Calculations 1
Note 1 : If moment resisting frames are not used as part of a dual system, the frames bays must be arranged
(increased) to produce a value of less or equals to 1.25for Seismic Design Category D, and to less than 1.1
For Seismic Design Category E and F.
Note 2: = length of the wall in the horizontal direction in meters.
Diaphragm Design Forces
UBC-97 IBC-2000
Ft Fi 1.0C a Iw px F 0.3S DS I E w px
i
F px w px F px w px
0.15S I w
w i
0.5C Iw
a px w
i DS E px
Note:
The summation is carried out from the diaphragm under
consideration to the top of the building.
P-∆ Effect
UBC-97 IBC-2000
- zones 1 & 2 0 .1
M S .O / M F .O 0.1 θ is a stability coefficient
and calculated as follows :
where,
Px
Condition at which MS.O. is the second order
P-Δ should be V x hsx C d
moment.
taken MF.O. is the first order where,
moment. Px = total unfactored loads
above level x.
In terms of forces, this Δ = design story drift.
moment ratio may be Vx = story shear at level x.
given for each story as: Cd = deflection
P G M
0.1
amplification factor.
VE hx
P-δ Effect
UBC-97 IBC-2000
where, Note:-
∑PG = summation of The structure must be re-
gravity loads above story designed if :
under consideration. max
Condition at which ΔM = inelastic
P-Δ should be displacement where,
taken VE = story shear at level 0 .5
max 0.25
x. Cd
hx = story height.
where β is the ratio of
- zones 3 & 4 shear demand to shear
S 0.02
capacity. β may be
hx R
conservatively taken equal
where, to 1.0
ΔS = elastic displacement
R = Response
modification factor.
Drift Limitations
UBC-97 IBC-2000
TABLE 1617.3
ALLOWABLE STORY DRIFT
Other than shear walls, four stories or less, that .025 .020 .015
have been designed to accommodate drifts