Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Public Relations and Political Power - A Case Study of The Caterpi
Public Relations and Political Power - A Case Study of The Caterpi
1966
Public Relations and Political Power: A Case Study of the Caterpillar Tractor Co.
Frank Simpson
Illinois Wesleyan University
Recommended Citation
Simpson, Frank, "Public Relations and Political Power: A Case Study of the Caterpillar Tractor Co." (1966). Honors Projects. Paper 41. http://digitalcommons.iwu.edu/polisci_honproj/41
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Political Science Department at Digital Commons @ IWU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Honors Projects by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ IWU. For more information, please contact sdaviska@iwu.edu. Copyright is owned by the author of this document.
A Case Study
of
the
059. II! 10 13
ARCHIVES
Submitted
for
Honors Work
1966
by
Frank Simpson
\\
Aoe:ep1ted by the'Department
of Political
h6nors _J1
fulfillment
of
the require-
Science of
>vq.rU/
Project. Advisor
PREFACE
case
in the
state of Illino i s
Cater p il l ar is the l arg e s t private and the largest single It has plants,
n ine
employer in the
city
of
Peoria
-
off i ces ,
twenty
two pla.ces in
t e en
different
congressional districts;
and the
Company also
ha s many
Finally,
Caterpillar is a maj o r
Such an
organization would
sensitive to--the
ttempt s
are made
to
p ro vi de
moralistic
judg
Consequently,
the
s i nc e
the paper
dl:escriptiolli of
corporate
initiated as
-!funors Program at Illin6is Wesl eyan thanks is due: t'G Dr .. 1>., P. lB'r6WJJl,
Special
Project Advisor at
linois
1h:-actr '&'i..:(ill'
Wesleyan
]?oria,
President,
William Bla.crkie.
would like. to
Vice-President;
to Roger T. FUblic
Kelley,
DeNaan, Manager o
and
Ken
mQ;.
Gerber,
Don merman of
Affairs; P't1iQ1. ic
Carl
Winterrose, Department;
the
Affairs
tv
ABLE OF CONlfEN"TS
PAGE PREFACE
e . . ' .
iii
.1
Chapter
II ..
I.
Ilt'fR6ll')1(1;T!ON.
THE
'III.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . .
COMMUNITY! RELATIONS.,
:';4
APPENDIX IIr
APPENDIX II
APPENfi3L I
e" . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . " . . ..
44 47 51
e . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .......
BIBlJIOGRAPHY .
I.
INTRODUCTION no single
There are many definitions and descrip tions of corporate public relations-";so many that there is
the attempt,
persuasion,
More
simply put:
"Public relations
have
is
called public relations activities the ohief means of eduoating the publio; that much of and many businessmen frankly admit
selling of their company' s attitudes towards commun ity and governmental matters . Regardless of the many defini tions of public rela tions, most people in the field will at least agree tht the primary function of public relations, the modern oorporation , is to presen t the as practiced by "truth" on civic
of the public as
The working defini tion of public relations used at the Caterpillar Traotor Company is that public relatio ns-is the means whereby the story o f free enterprise in general and the tractor industry in particular is told to 1. the publio .
2
The objective is to contribute to the company's profit making 8.b11i ty by developing
an
'I
of doing
business in a particular
are.
The method of the Public Affairs Department is :'to tell the story of the free enterprise system te public and to goernment officials at
the
all
levels.
It
The department
st'anda,rdizing public
,
in building
opllaiio!ls
,
!s:, IJhvin
. 'Itlat.l? is 'trY1Ilgto" "'sfenSe" are ":the merits ,Elf,a :oorpora.tion a.nd<tll. merits
eapi talist system. ' .
In
things should be left pretty much alone except for "improvements" in tax
possible
ar'eas
of public
relations advocacy,
ap athies,
3
and
taken into
consider
_ if a COlD,t> any, over a period of time, is sWathed in layers,iOf good will, it wil,not bedamae by an o c c asi o nal
is
The purpo se
In shor t,
fuslade of abuse.
"
the
publicity_
by Irwin Ross:
th provision of scholarships to de serving studentrill, the production ot' educational aids for use in "the SChools , ta-e assiduous cultivation of oo<,lrelations with sto ck , B:14'&ra.. The" stoe1tho ; Iders,. when Er:ffe gti Y""" ' J;7b"at'ea, are nt!hemselves a FU.b1.i
tcgovernmen;t.',
Relations: ,lBUsiness
,: WOlf,or1is, againt an un -
Caterpillar,
.-
Through
,
1,940'19
discussion of
"
business ,
relationship
4
between the two has not always been a close one.
But
it has now
turned into a deep and permanent love affair. Until around 1900, the predominant attitude of the
posi tion
however,
atpts by the national government in conjunction with $t11te and national regulation of certain aspects of business activities.
As a consequence,
the business
commu
nity found it necessary to make at least token gestures in the realm of public relations in an att empt to pla cate some of its more outspoken critics and to adjust itself to a new p ol i tical situation. The additional rude shock of public indignation and additional governmental regulations in the post depression era lent further impetus to the development of corporate public relatione.
to
rebuild its "image" by pr o j ecting a new picture of, Irwin Ross summed up the situa
The wholesale disesteem. which befell American business, in the depths of the depression, pro-
favor. at nIt' youlookbaok at 1936" that time the so .... called political rev>lution was in effe-o-t. lVIuch of the suspi ci o n about ?p-g business arose from the fact that nobody knew what went on inside. There were high fences around the plants--no one went ins ide exc ep t the workmen. Newer m anagem en t realized that it had to o p er ate in a goldfish bowl. It One of U.ll. Steel's first mo v es, after this revelationbr0ke over it, was to provide o wls conGlucted tours of the plant gold ish . , , for ,any CJ. tizens who mJ.ght be curJ.0us
vided the mo tive force for the establishment of PR departm.entsin a number of large corpo rations. Charles Huse, se c on d in command of the public re l at ions department at U. S. Steel, vividly r e o a lls the atmosphere when our largest st$elproducer began concerted efforts to win
pUblic
In the 1940's,
therefore,
In 1944,
as such.
Commun i ty Relations,
company,
ac co rding to ROlbert
blished
1944.9
the Community
The purpose of the
A. Newman of
was to develop understanding of the company among In addi tion , the division significance
and the
lO
6
Mr. Newman stated: Lack of pub lic understanding of the Am eric an IIway of business" could threaten the business existence of all comp anies, including Oaterpillar. Understanding the free enterprise system is like buying. good illsuran.ce it may ke p the company 11 in busness som, day'. '
' ,
to public
,"
'
relations as
"good insurance"
1937 c oncerning
System: Though widely denounced as immoral, the attempt on the part of bus ine ss management to insure itself against changes in the political framework--a framework which it must, to a large degree, be able to take for granted if it is to concentrae on its more orthodox economic tasks--seems'as 12 : logie as insuringag4l.inst fire or flood.
'
They were: Plant tours Mailings to important community l e a ders Assistance to chairmen of various c ivi c groups in the community
(1)
(2)
( 3) (4) (5)
(6)
Urging ac!tti ve
part
0f
(7)
however,
expansion of the
1959.
led to the
The c ir-
cumstan ces behind this development are taken up in the next se ction of the chapter. Public Relations
1957
Departmen t at Ca terpillar was President Eis enhower's urging . of businessmen to take a more ac tive Ilart in politics--at
least this was one reason given by Oarl Winterrose of the .Puplic Affairs
,amination o f conditions
needed to give
a correct picture.
of an intensive
renewal af activities
in
As
a curative,
stopgap measure.
corporate public relations wi th the ac cent on., prevention -developed slowly until aro und own as a politi c al tool. reasons for the new accent B. J .
on
to depend, year af ter year , upon the usual political expedients for stopping hostile legislation is short sightedness. In the long run isn't it be tter and surer to lay a ground work with the peo ple back home who have the
8
votes, so that proposals of this chacter ( proposals that are not Ubeneficial" tobu.sines s) are not populwar with thm, rather than depen4 Upon. s:topping sucl.! propoS)8.ls whenl ey ge;t into the legislature or coission?
lhphasis was still being placed olf. cormnUJ;lity and/or pubiLc relat::J.ons. :But th pUbli? relaions function was n o w being
qorrupt
contributionSJby no1;
and
it did iss ue s ;
from. taking
on
activ part
in
political affairs.
Hence
on tnEil
cqrporation
article after
executives to get
i,nto poitics.
Mr.
if business is to improve its effectiv;ene$$ ilf the l e gisla tive process and with gQvel't generally, it must beQomm.ore actiI and . effectiva in, the . poli ti'cal proce'Els.
of
inte8
by
en lierprJ.se system: .
continued.
:p
Sheldon "s discussion o poli iiical power. ' ificance the free aYinghomage to the si
of
.. merl'P :e{;rUiEt',tha1f:ijlf[J:.tl(aSS., pqple 'articulate their points, :of' V'1}eW:>'Wh:re : ' oQl.lll ts ,mc1.i/!3t. The t'f ;;spendillg; taritt :Qr()olp:e!lt,. 'an1Ji
..
The free busills-s vstem.is a Qorllertoe of .o,ur tli'ee.1?I00iety. l!itd.its defaIlse and adviillce-
trust, e
and
of government,
,
te
driye td get
! ,
I,
, .
'.
',
"..
Reord numbers of executives are studying the mechanioa of practictal. :pol,i tics: examining issues and thebaokgrq'Unds of" avowed;or:P9tentialli:id.a;B.eSf,wei ing whichio:f':f'iceseker to siU.pp()rt. with money or persolla ef l orl.i; or both; "urg;,ng ,mheir 3.. "-em;plQYEts . regar'<jiless Qf party a:t'fi:ihiation to ip.form th.ms'elvs d to partlcipate in . the electJ.vp:r:'0cesllit.
gh
..
The av.erage businessman. was now becoming aware of the faot governmen t al units at all levels.
,
as what our
Bu.sinessIna:Ii.
The Chamber
'of Commerce
of
NIl:t.. Busin e ssman , i te your country, too. The nation belongs to um all, in cluding you. And we should all have our say in d e ci d ing what way its: going. This brings up a subject tha t is anathema to many business leaders--politics. But it shouldn't be. Politics the art of dealing with peop19, of convincing them that it you in is to their advan tage to join getting your 1',o1'os&.1s aocepted.
10
wiit]
is
po si ti on is public relations.
they are now t akin g stands and becoming inv ol ved in civic
and political. affairs.
As a result,
;ttl.
sh or t ,
viously held.
adjustment will be taken up in the next chapteF' along with a detailed description of its publ ic affairs activities.
11
ote$ on Ohapter I
lEdward L. Bernays, "!rhe Theory and Practice of Public Relations," The EngineJ!'ring of Oonsent, ed. Edward L. Bernays (University of'Oklah0ma Press, 1952), pp. 3-4.
2Wena: llarlan and lian Scott, contem orarl Public Relations) (New York: Prentice-Hall Inc., 1755), p. 4.
York:
4Irwin Ross, The Image Merchants (Garden City, New Doublemy and, Oomp&nY;, 1959) p. 21.
JThe
7 I bl. G.i.e .
'
81bid., p. 162.
9Fred R. Jjolly, "Public Relations 4mr!I.r"iJ.{}iI1riBadr4:y'ard, e:: Publie Rel a tion s J;ournal, Vol. 3 i'b. 8, (AUgust, 1947) .. i"'
....!
It
1!!!
lORobert A. Newman, "Public Relations on MamJlu:,S'treeif," Manager's Kel, ( Fe bruary, 1957), p. 11.
llIbicli., p . 12.
12S'tanle Kell ey Jr., Professional Public Relat i o ns and PoliticalPowe;: (Belitimore: The Johns Hopkins Press, 1956), p. 19_. The quote is:; talma;t'rom the ar ti cl e , "bilic Relation&: of the BellL S.yst.em," Publ;Lc Opinion {luarterll I . (October, 1937), p. 7.
. 'N
lNewman,
p.
12.
personeli interviews with personnel of the PubliC Affair. Department 'Oarl Winterrose), June 15, 1965.;.
Relations
12
l6Horace, E. Sheldon, lBUsinessmen.Must Get Into Po1i tics ,. " Harvard Bus i n ess Review,, (March-April, 1959), p. 37.
l7rfmci\., p.
38.
For
;NovemberJ.1963},
20WaShington
Report,
II..
Briar to
1959, the
of C aterpillar were'. handl e d by different s egments of the Oompany. Publi c ati ons was under ploye e rela tions and
legislative ac tivi ti e s were par t of the admini s tr ation . Oommuni ty rg,lations were handled by the Communi ty Relations Departmen t--f or.merly a d ivi s i on as de s cribe d in Chapter
I.
It was d e c i ded tha t a riew admini strative se tup was ne eded to handle the s e opera tions, condu c te d
an
at o ther companie s and re commended that Oaterpi llar create su ch a department in At the start,
1959.
thus merging the public affairs function of Caterpillar into i ts publ ic a ffai r s ac tivi tie s . l
The Publi c Aff airs Department attemp ts to ful fil l i ts goal of a b e t ter bus ine s s c l ima te an d a be t ter under s tanding of the free enterpri s e sys tem in two ways:
13
(1) By
14
speaking out on some of the important issues of the times; and, (2) by encouraging e mplo yee s as individuals to better 2
The employee best
In
summary,
(lobbying)
CDf Caterpillar
center around the legislative committees at the various plants and the Public Afairs Bulletins.
The Public Affairs
Bulletins--which are stateme nts of the Company's Viewpoints on current issues--are contained in the Public Affairs
Notebo ok held by ninety management people in the corporation. e purpose of the notebook is to make part-time lobbyists out of some of the Company's best pe ople . fU]fills three objectives:
1. It informs reCipients of existing or pro posed legislation, or of the need for legislation, either on a state or national Any given bulletin
basis;
2.
15
terms of letters, phone calls; personal contacts, or:whatever method of contact seems most appropriate, considering the' issue and the time fao tor. '.
The' processing of a typical bulletin d.oes elude administrative clearance with the President to avoid policy conflicts. Administrative clearance is in
-ri stead made wi th the. manager of' the department an,d the appropriate administrative Y:ice-president whose area is concerned with the issues covered by the bulletin.
The
idea is that the vice-president is supposed to know the thinking of the President on the matter--theory, at least.
The legislative committee at each plant is made up of legislative advisors which are individuals i:n regular departments assigned related legislative areas for conr
sultation.
course of action is to be taken regarding any given policy bulletin. Letters may be written to legislat.ors or to Editorials
congressmen.
sonal contact is made by Company officials; fessional lobbyists as such are used.
President of Personnel and Public Affairs at Caterpillar, states the purpose of this method of lobbying:
the views expressed by local managers--or by managers whose functional responsibility qualifies them to assess various legislative
propoeals--carries considerably more weight with legislators than the views of the public ffairs staff man.' The latter, after all, can look pretty much like industry's full-time lobbyist, unless he assumes his proper role as back-up man, idea feeder, and- coordinator for the front-line managerl who contact legislators on key issues.
I
16
The advantage of the current program of legislative activities according to Kelley is in the fact that Ca:terpillar does not utilize professionsl lObbyists. Over the years, the Company's position on legis lative matters has b'ecome more sophisticated that they do not flatly oppose everything.
in Mr.
the sense
The bulletins
usually recommend alternative proposals as substitutes . many.measureEl.receive . the support of the Oqmpany.aa ex.
. , ' ,
that
they oppose
In add,ition,
pressed.
in,
the bulletins.
But,.
the
improvement
of
cOmm'@ ty
For exple,
sr4es tax..
en
increase in a sales
of
,
implementation
a state
tax"
policy guidelines of
Company. In
employees
and t,
17
legislative
eight
Analyze and take public positions on many ,of/the, important: issues of the times, wh!eth,e:r thei;r relationship to Caterpill,ar bu;s,1ness is direct,:or'ind:4rect, "an9-with out f'ear of c0ntroversy tht may lie 'ahead.
Engage in such nonp ar ti s an activity without, 11'eference to the positi0ns tkenbyariypoli tical party. '
I '
2.
I,
4 . Promulgate the Company's beliEd's thr0ugh 1s ,publiqa tions and se,ek un.derstandingof these beliefs ,through the issuapce,ofre
'I
'
Whenver possible , appear independently ofpendihg legislation thatthe Company's viewpoints are so 'wid.eYk:rio.l{.l1 findcearly understood in advart,oe Q,;f,new legislative proposals that may r'eiaie tohm:. ,
' , '
la:t:ed statements,. In accordance wi th past practi,ce, U:Ch statem9J+ts 'require approp:r iate 'adininistr'ative a.provals.
ecohomic andpoli,tical, on public issueSl and a.qhieve ,broa.clr understanding among managers as tq their rights and, limita,tions un,der'the statutes that gevern political ,participation by individuals and corporations.
7. Follow
officials in order to secure better Gom pt-ehenSion ;of each other', s viewpoints ; and of the" effect of propose.dleg'islation on the Company..
and report on the performance of legislatoors and appointed officials. This !-:
may take
l. Workcloselywt,h
"
the form. of comment relating to their s,ta,nds on specific issues, butshould not tke tli form. 6fbroad general 'support , or oppoSlitiGn.. '
associatio,nS :LlL the
trade and
In addi t;i.cin
, 'COeIly'beli,::ts.1?aXticipe.tfng in re lated committee w9:rk,anq"helpingkeep "th,e public a.t'fa:rs:t:grts ,of such' : association$,' ,cqnchj{";ratea. and effec,tive. :,' to "legislative activities,
" ' " "
advancement
business
of,,'
"l,"i
the
Department
that
.i"
program
or
"pblitical
activities.
A goo d
J:u.s"tt.
acc'eptance
s.sthe'J':'individual ci ti z en desirous!
political activity
fn
of
aChieving the
an;x; company.
WhCh
it
conducts'it"":9pera.tj.ans befere
cor:portion
\\ .:
have the'respect
se c ti o n
of
the
pol! tical
views.
The next
with
the
IIre".ett'en'ga:,aeerJ.n:gll
m.munit:i
\ '
Relations
of
theEbard at
those 'whom
19
"re spe c t "' for i t a s
a
t spe ak o ut on
publi c i s sue s .
that
mue
Failure
'
b :t t s i s de aori be d by Mr .
.
onee a ce>mpany ge t s 1ihe reputation o f duCking i:tl!;! ' c'ommu;ni ty . rel;3p6ns1bili tie s , hen they pound 'G:h.e ne: one ' will} If s "tell w J
'
Randall :
tabl e b e s ave d
ay 'that
.'.
am ,
o f the c o rporati on i n relation t o " and o ther lo c al indus tri e s . the app e arance o f
,
thE!! communi ty o f Pe o r i a
a domine ering
giant ;
and ,
in a
t small task .
thi s preve s
f ar as
the pro gram prevents p e o pl e froIn r e s n ting the Oompany ; plac e s them on a plateau o f neutral i ty .
In o ther words ,
To
it
communi ty relaions ke eps l atent ho s tili ti e s l aten t . thi s par ti cul ar gentl eman ,
It i s the fe eling
o f the wri ter that bo th d e s crip ti ons ..:: eo.lhlil, d : cbe different time s ,
u.s ed"':btit,a. t.
20
of i ts communi ty rel a tions work through the hands of O . Ken Gerber .
D.
Maddox
some th ing invol ving CaterpillaD comes up in civic a ffair s , he i s the man sought out for a s s i s tan,c e ..
Maddox
is also
bo arel!
'
members
turned
di re c t e d
to o the r
sour c e s o f manpower be caus e i t i s fel ; that there i s a c ertain saturation p o int be yo nd whi ch no additio nal
should
be us e d .
c orp o r a t e
is
that they wish to avoid cre ating the image o f ruling; the c ommuni ty f S affairs.
The to no t Lc
pant
Jus u as they
much,
to
the
communi ty .
p& 1m
uours is
s e t o ff be cause
the wri ter feels that the nature o f this topi C meri ts clo se at tenti on.
conduc te d tours : to ur s are At Caterpillar there are two regul ar , typ e s
of
Regular
and
sp e c i al gro up to urs .
the general publi c ,
conducted
daily for
visiting
21
caterpillar DealenfI,
and
ous tomers .
The:
purpose of the'
i s des cribed as being made po ssible; by the free enterpris e system. More bluntly put , the core o f the message s tates
product are
that quality
various' communi ty groups Eluch a s the clergy , barbers , county offiCials , lawyerSl, OPA l s , <itl c tors , dentists , women ' s civi c l e ader s . Th e w.ogram is s e t up s o that each The the
and
meal , product
"
o f the
i t .is delivered to the mo s t important people in the commun i ty : the .. talkers " or opinion mol ders .
of
their duti e s , members of the se groups usually oonverse a deal wi th their cus tomers .
up of If
gre at
the subj e c t
of
Caterpillar
comes
of
poli cy
example , suppose
thle. t;tr, e
22
taking
ano ther s to ry .
will no t now be
to the
cOUIltry
or
ap t
to
More
wr i t e
23
Dro te s on Chap ter II lSupra p.
7.
2Bfron DeHaan , Manager o f the Publi c Affairs gave an explanati on o f Caterpill ar ' s interest in the:: busine sr-8 climate o f the; Peoria are a . In a July 30 , 196 5 in tervi ew , Mr . DeHaan s ai d : ItWe have a ri ght and an o bligation to talk about things that affe c t us . We have pee:r;l. here for fifty-SI:''ix ye ar s , an& we have an inter.es,t in . the are a . u ,
partme:nt,
' Affairs
3P:ersonal iD.tervi ews wi tiL personnel o f the Publi c Jiune 1 5 , 1954 and
oger 1'. Kelle y , I re So l d on the .An Addre s s by Hoger T. Kelley , Vi ce Publi c Affairs , "; Pre sident , Caterpill ar Tractor Co . at Public Affairs Conferenoe of the .Ameri c an Irmu and StellL Ins ti tute ,
"W
Impartance
of
, 5Caterpill an , however , do e s maintain membership in busin e s s iand trade as s o c i ati ons and reli e s on their dire c t lo bbying ac tivi ti e s . , Membership in such organi zations affo rds oppo rtuni ti e s for e s tabli shing contac ts wi th the community and tho s e who mo l d public s entiment . Oompany men can thlis act as spo kesmen for Caterpillar f D-.al so perform the: equally important ' rol e o f intelligence gents, gathring information re garding the fe el ings of a parti cular group towards the 6ompany . 6E1is expl anation o f the po s sibl e re as on for Caterpill ar ' s backing o f the incre ase d s al e s tax i s s tri c tly the wri ter ' s own .
(JUly 2"
8 Cl arenee B . Randall , A Cre e for Enterpri s e ( Bo s ton Li ttle Brown an d Oomp any , l) , p . 10 .
9]bid. ,
p ..
67 .
de s cription i ar, o f c ours e , an ac count o f an ideal cOlI1lIl.un i ca tiona ere tup . In re ality , things do no it; op erate as smo o thly as the passage may l e ad one to bel i eve .
l)iThis
I I I . COMMUNI TY RELATIONS A de s crip tion o f the publi c affairs pro gram would
be inc omple te if
the
fun c tion ,
o ther s e gme n ts
Pre si dent
find
and
,c.
themselife.s;
Oater12illazr
.1
magazine .
of'
the Caterpillar
pro gre s s ,
s everal items o f
o f some
of (1)
reve aling :
the re bui l ding
As the fir s t and mo s t impr e s s ive bi t o f " eVidenc e , " o f the downtown are a was mentione d . The
maj or imp e tus to thi s re deve l o pmen t was the d e c i si on by Caterpillar to l o c ate its new W o rld He adquarters building
in
wha t i s
now
the c en ter o f
the
( 2 ) In
to P e ori a ,
Pre si den"tr
the re developmen t
25
are a .
publi c s tand .
to
Blackie ,
a l e t ter
the P e o r i a
tl priva te
put a
the
in
the are a . l I t
once
'
to
c on c e de d by
c an wri te a le tt e r to
"private c i t i z en ,
"
the l o c al p aper ; j us t
le tters
o f some
happen to
c arry
a l i t tl e
howeve r ,
in que s tion
of
the
pr e s i d en t
of
inently
in
thi s
Asso ci ation of
Comme r c e ' s
matter
through hi s
COmInittee on .AIplex:t;on. .
the
re tention o f
manage r mitte e
( 3 ) In
councilcom-
chairmane d the
Public Affai r s Dep ar tment c0n tributed space publ i c ati ons showin g the ac co mp l i s hmen t s
in Company
the
the
of
council-
manager form
o f government in Peori a .
The
"
(4)
to
(5 )
po r ting the
The Fire
Company to o k an
'; ,
o ff i c i al
po s i tion sup/,'
Bond
26 endum in
i ts (6)
publi cations .
Chairman o f the Bo ard at Caterpi llar Franc i s Ho spi tal Fund drive .
Al though the Company did no t o ffi c i ally spons o r Pe o ri a ' s entry in to the
mus t be no te d that a Caterpillar employe e o f the Public Affairs Depar tment was ins trumen t al in bringing about Peo ri a ' s entry into o ther personnel , the c ompe ti tion . The the s ame employe e ,
and
Chairman of the
evidence
in the
that were
a s tring o f intenti onal and purpo s e ful c ommUni ty devel o p men ts brought about by Caterpill ar wi th a go al in mind . The ac t that i t was Carl inently i s immater i al .
Winterrose
'- '
likely
ano ther Oompany man wo ul d have c arr i e d out the s e duti e s . No formal dire c tive or o rder i s n e c e s s ary ,exoep t the
c i ti zenship
27
s e l e c t e d as suc a Peoria
an
All Ameri c an Ci ty .
The bene fi ts
of
deve lopment to a worldwide corporation wi th as the lo c ation o f i ts World He adquarters are to s e e--gr an t e d such benefi ts are intangi
no t hard ble
pro fi t .
is any one point to be made in con publi c relati()Jns and :,:L,ts Although the
that corporate
Many
,[).e ;'!Qllowed to go .
to di8'. <
In the firs t
points .
over
e ffe c tivene s s o f any publi c relati ons pro gram should be is no t all-pervasive . j udge d in the T.e.aJ.d zation that
.
any
of indus try i s ,,'dnlne d outf1 ON" the selec tive pro ce ss e s o f the people that i t i s dire c te d to . mo s t fai thful
supporters
"
Much o f
attenti oni.<to the in publi c rel ations output., place , al though there exi s ts
an
element of s elf-intere s t
II
inally ,
intere s t and parti Cipation in publi o and poli ti c al affairs be wel comed and no t eri ti c i s e d .
co
For it
is onl
through involvement in
n- temporary
29
o te a
Ipe r sonal intervi ew wi th Willi am Blackie , Pre sident of the Caterpillar Tractor Co . January 26 , 196Q.
from
2peoria was one of twent- two finalists in competition which eleven All Ameri can Ci ti e s will be lIel.e c ted and
_ the Publi c
VICE
PRESIDENT
Roger Kelley
C IVIC AFFAIRS
CO MMUNICAT IONS
." -#t. ,
LEGISLATIVE LIASON
D. W . Hyle r
0. 0 .
II
.
S PE C IAL ASSIGNMENTS
..
,
INT ERNAL NEWS MEDIA '"
j<.
-
'
,,,
'
Maddox
K. Gerber ,
w Alberti
MEDIA
. '
l.!,J, ....,.
F. R. J.
3-5-62
32
Like all parts of the " relations " group , Community Relations is the implementation of a philosophy of management . lightened management . In the field of good human re lations , Caterpillar is a leader, having decided a great many years ago that it would put cons iderat ion of the right treatment of people at the top of the list . And it is the implementation of an . en-
It did this from the start with customers , deciding that it would build only
the best and pricing its products accordingly , yet trying always to keep prices low . The Company s policy of permitting no product to become obsolete is
In another area of high concern for people , Caterpillar management has determined that owners shall be rewarded fully for their confidence . missed paying dividends since its formation . Our Company has not
for their support has resulted in still further confidence and this is reflected in the public ' s estimate of the Company ' s worth . It haa now been JD8.llY years since a formal program was establi shed to implement our philosophy with regard to Caterpillar people ... employees . Believing that
the Company ' s best interests were served by a work force of people who were well paid in every sense of the word, a fa.rs ighted management here has provided employees with a s core of "plus values " to their jobs - in addition to good wages and salaries ... to make a life-time of work for Caterpillar an interesting, challenging opportunity to contribute both to self and to a constructive force in society .
- 2 1944 33
first and then again a couple of years ago -
More re cently - in
administrative management further deve loped it s philosophy that a company is ,a corporate citizen in its community 'by establishing the Community Relations Department and, later , the Public Affairs Department .
Company and the things it does of interest to community neighbors - and thus to create good will for Cate rpillar .
Like every activity, ours must benefit the Company, directly or indire ctly . There are several s , it seems to me , that our program does benefit the Company . First , and here we go back to one of the reasons for Employee Relations functiOns , employee s who like their company and the community where they live are almost certain to be better employees . It is our thinking that whatever we do to make
Thus , when we find Caterpillar people who will serve on committee s of the Association of Commerce , or on Boys ' Club and Junior Achievement Boards , or in
other community spot s , we believe we have demonstrated that we and our people want this to be the best possible place to live and raise our familie s . Now this might seem like a slow to go about our j ob we started in
1944
that Caterpillar was a good neighbor ; that you could borrow wheelbarrows and tarps from us for church j obs ; that you could drop in and see how we live and how well we keep house - and on occasion you could share a meal with us .
We knew that we weren ' t going to announce a Community Relations program one day
- 3 -
34
and have an informed public the next . As a matter of fact , it was our thinking that we were going to make our friends slowly - just a few at a time - and that the best friends we ' d make - the ones who would give us a recommendation when we needed it - would be those we got to know pretty well - and who got to know us as well . What I ' m saying is , we have always believed that our staunchest support will came from people who have the kind of confidence in us that comes from firsthand acquaintance with us . These are the friends we make
at time .
Therefore , the activities in which we ' ve engaged have been those which take time and personal contact . They are such things as the patient listening to thousands , For example , we are We
asked to help local police associations in the ir work with junior police . listen to and support nearly every youth program we know about .
There is a
special reason for our enthusiasm here - this Company and this country will be
run by these young people in a few years .
We are also asked for support for all the usual things .
over a million and a half dollars from us in the past several years
Privately United
Fund' agencie s , the Red Cross and other charitable and we lfare programs have had our support . But our gifts aren' t all s ix-figure gift s . Many are for
$100,
$1, 000
or
$2, 000 .
$25
and
It has been our philosophy that we will support those programs which our community ne ighbors believe in and support . For example , it was demonstrated that
this community would underwrite new facilities at Carver Center - and we gave
. $30, 000
to that
$250, 000
proje ct .
- 4 35
But there are many othe r ways we can give things to people . and the Human Relations Commiss ion Office and others have small budgets . of little value as trade -ins
-
Country s chools
When we have surplus wooden desks and chairs we give them to the se worthy organizations .
We give away old typewriters and research inst rume nts that are out-of-date even air cleaners to the C ivil Defense people for breather tubes for bomb shelters .
even better j ob of charitable giving if they felt one great obje ction could be overcome . We had already jumped one hurdle when we said we ' d solicit them o
once a year .
The b ig problem was that they were be ing asked to give both in their home community and at Peoria where they worked . After a good deal of study , we hit on the
Caterpillar Employees United Communitie s Appeal, whi ch works with home-town Chests - to their great satisfaction - in the arithmetical allocation of employee gifts to all
t:, p.
S R. 6) s-<'J
24
It is almost a full-time j ob from August through November for Bill Watson to handle all the details of this complicated program, but it has made employee s much more contented - and i t has certai tied our neighbor communi ties close r t o u s - to have CEUCA . We think we have made many fine and close friends .
If you want real proof of employee satisfaction - let us remind you that employee gifts have , every year s ince CEUCA started, subs cribed more than fifty per cent more dollars than they did before UCA .
- ) -
ne ce ssity, personal visits - and neighbors outnumber customers about three or four to one in a year ' s time . the individual ' s interest . Our plant visits have always been tailored to
Our
escorts are truly hosts - they act and dress like management men and they talk with authority be cause they are trained for at least three months before theY' are given important customers as , their guests . It is the close , personal touch -
the last ten per cent - that makes the difference between friendship and ac quaintanceship .
We are not now doing it - but I am hopeful that we will again someday set up to take every man' s family to his department - and have them here with him for . a meal . ' These are the kind of " one-at-a-time ll activities that we think are After our last family vi s it program, we had the feeling that
most effective .
wives would be hard to convince that this was such a ' hell-hole t to work
in .
There are , of course , a s core of other things we can do to develop understanding . We can find Caterpillar people who will man s cience fairs and judge exhibits we
and do invite newcomers like clergymen to have lunch with us - each of us in Community Relations belongs to a service club - for the contacts it brings us . and the opportunities it gives us to schedule Company speakers at appropriate t1mes .
If same fine community group - a nonprofit organization - wants us to provide a speaker .. or just wants to borrow a proj e ctor and s creen .. or a slide proje ctor .. or a film - or a public address system .. we have the se right at hand . In the
- 6 37f
well over a million people have sat in audience s whe re our speakers or equipment were in evidence . high, They ' ve seen, in letters a little les s than a foot They know we ' ve
been of he lp to them .
we do to keep our neighbors informed is to le t them look over On spe cial i s sues of
FOLKS and NEWS AND VIEWS we mail to the eight thousand opinion molders of the area, teachers , ministers , busine ssmen and others . sele cted Sometimes we mail to a This is an effective way of
600 ,
100 .
Almost everything we do, then, is aimed at face-to-face contact with our fellow employee s and neighbors .
to make folks know that this is a company of people who believe in and support this community - just as any other good citizen would .
There i s one thing certain about our j obs . have done more than get a good start . better j ob . We welcome ideas .
We welcome help .
there are twenty thousand needed for good will ambas sadors program on that fact .
I'l JI lT , T C
S o on a.ft e r
th c Pub li c
Aft'.']. i r :;
l oc at i ons
s ome m i n o r chang e s ,
p:wt ,
1.
"mat a r e th e g oa l s
/1"
of :pub H c affa i r s at
lictL t' I' , \. 1',1 \ 1 ' 1' -pub ! i ( " i llq'1r( ' : : : : i (>11 " of Cn L c: rp i l 'l ar \ h \ \ . \'J , ) \ ' 1 1 1 I t i , IV 1 ir 1. 1 , IV ( : 1 1 1 1 i I ) II , :
1,ihn.t
vm n,Y'f.' ,
b.
Bc t t m' l md c rntn.nd i ng
marl\:et s .
0 ['
l;h c 1'lI.ct,
in worlil
c,
Bett er und e rs t anding of the b,us i ne s s v i ewpoint , on important nat i onal and s t at e l eg i sla t i on .
d.
e.
e c onomi c
pr inC i pl e s .
c ommun Lty att Ltu(1 e t owarcl fa c t ors 'wh -L c h m8.ke s ct t l f;ment and
a
g i v e n c ountry ,
1'.
Inc rea s ed c ommun ity c on f i d en c e j n and g o od w i l l t owa.rd the Company, i t s o perat i on s and :i t s pe opl e .
g.
2.
What
the ' " ext ernal " f(tet on: that. i n thA t. arC':'l .
are
c l imat e c an , b e (1 e f J. n e c1 a s t h e net
affect anel c a r; c
t:hc c o n !:.
re sult of al l
of (l o i ng b\w :Ln e :1 r
3.
lJhat
Th e y are LL s t c:d
The ma in point
be found on any
are important d o l l a r - and - c en t s ' c ons i d erat :i ons when B . new plant s it e b e ing s ought , e s tabli shed , a. b. c. th ey ought t o b e equally important aft er the plant and th roughout t h e c our s e o f it s e x i s t en c e .
Commun ity progre s s iv e n e s s . IIone s t , eff:i c :ient gov ernment and fa i r tax e s . relat:L on s . employe e s .
d.
e.
C-
f.
Good s c rV i C C [3 [lnd
J'u,c :i LL t L e[: :
L'irc ,
poLi c e ,
39
g. h.
4.
Bas,i cal l y ,
b e c ome L d ent i r .L ed w ith any pol i t i c al P.'l.Tty . Nonpart i s an pol it t c s , on the other hand ,
RLrt i nnn pol i t i c [ ha s to do w :Lth pol iti cal part:L es , cand :Ldat e r3 . and campai gns . it j e; Dem o c ra t 'IS . Republ i c an . rrh e Company yho ul d not ancl largely cannot , cmd cr the law, take part in part i san matt ers . The Company should not
w ith9ut f ear of c ontroversy and w ithout referenc e to the . pos it i ons taken
i s the f i e l d of i s sues as
oppo s ed
5.
, a s al ready ment I o n ed , the Compnny enc ourages all empl oyeei:l t o take rart :i.n part i s an . affa i rs in a c c Onl an e G with t h e i r own pers onal rarty preferen c es . ,
'
6.
part i c ipat e a;
What are s ome of the ways through wh:Lch empl oyee s can be enc ouraged to in part i san po l it i c s ? . . .
enc ouragement
a c t i v i t i e s such as
urge key peopl e t o s et a good example' Empl oyee . Relat i ons Lett er
Uni t ed Fund ,
j ust as
B oy S c out s ,
b.
o n l o c al ,
t i on on cand idat es .
2 : 19 .
. . .
' allow r ea s on
ment i on ed , c .
"thumbna i l sket ches " of, all cand idat es for a part i c ular off i c e . the Company- ' d o e s not want it o' end ors e cand idat e s .
( Not e :
Thi s c ould ,
provid e informa
whe r e
'
Enc ourage pol it i c al c ont ribut ions by ind ividual empl oye es of th e i r choi c e .
el e c t i on of good peopl e ;, the el ect i on of good e f f e c t iv e ' campaigns requ i re money . whe re pos s ibl e ;
. . .
to the
t o 8, c amprl.ign,
c1 el i c R t e propos i t l on , n.3 you know . ) rfuere :i s no s :ingle b e s t answer . Any plan l nt en(1 nc1 for b road expOfmre nhould be fa :i r , b i put L san and
In any event ,
effective
( Not e :
S o promot e the
1) . 2) .
An empl oyee should not b e s ol i c it e d by h i s b o s s . He should und erstand that the sub j ec t of whether or how much
3) .
d.
']'h e C orrrpr.H(y c}D.iJ orr ', cr: thc; J r J ca of g e n e ral , but not any u pc e :L f .i. c c am pa i gn
.
40
Ave:: r agc U , 8 . vot e r - part i c i pat i on :in fed eral el ect i ons
Urge people to regist er and e s pec ially i n the primar i e s .
"
are putt ing forth the b est pos s ibl e c and i d at e s . e. Support " prac t i c al pol it i c s " t raining programs und erstand ing of and . . .
d e s i gned t o in
mental proc es s es .
r ease
7.
Of the many "pract ical pol it i c s " c ours es ava ilab l e , ov er-al l , Aft er a s e ems to be the b e st one ? the U. S .
Pract i c al
s t ill appears
eas i e s t :
'
c :int :L on of Commer,c c haL; g i v en :Lmprtun aml ci :i. rcc: t L on t o pl omoli J on of the c ourro e . I0::pt)rL cnc e hD,,: nhown , . howevC!r' , tl1nt wh JJ . c r C fl ponn l i n g()o(l at the out s ct, j t becomeG inc r Gl, n l nc;ly more d -L fl' l eulL to cnC OllrD{';C , onrollrrwnt in nuch c ommun:lty c ours oro . A no,,, approach wh 1ch hn,:: uh own out utand:tng rc sult c i.n c overal plant locat i ons i s the i n - plant off - uh.U't c ourn c . .'0 (I n,t e , n,Pllrox'Jinat cly 1200 Cat erpil lar people ( inc lud :Lng 111 2 w e el{.ly sal ary and hourly employee s ) have'
.
t o admin i s t e r
workshops .
c ours e c o s t s o n a 50 - 50 bas i s with any empl o ,ye e enroll ing .in one of thes e
. 8.
to a s t at e l e g i s lature or the U . S .
Suppo s ing a Cat e rpillar empl oyee runs for and s uc c eeds in b e c oming el e ct ed Congre s s . 'What then?
He should apply for and be grant ed a formal l eave of abs en c e s d ef inea in Elnpl oyee Relat i'ons Lett er 2 : 1 9 , At the C l os e o f hi. s t e rm o f o f f i c e ,
h e should return t o worl<: . , , ' or, i f suc c e s s ful i n be ing re - el ec t e d , for an ext ens ion of the l eave .
apply
i s to be g rant ed a Formal leave t o hold such el ect ivc ' offic e , b e c ons i d ered . the campaign pe ri od i s d i ffi cult t o d ef i n e , However,
t ime reui rement s for n e c e s s ary campai gning ' for the s ame off i ce must al s o unl ike the per i qd , ' o f s ervi c e o f el e c t iv e offi c e , ' and i s often mad e up of widely and t o avo id
s i rabl e effect 0 :[' such variat i ons on ComIK '1ny work schedul e s , s 1tuat :L onD ,.;h ere an empl oyc9 :['rcquently l eaves A.c e or\l ingly,
not ic e .
. . .
An exampl e and events that may b e d i f f icult t o ant i c i pat e i n advanc e . i onal d ignitary of the cand. idat e 1 s party . , might be a l oc al v i s it by a nat Info rmal l eaves o f l imited durat i on may al s o b e appropr i at e i n c ertain But onc e agai n i t should be emphas i z ed that the Company d e s i re s cases . pos s ible , in fact o r i e s and offic es .
and then t o apply for a Forn.al . l e ave for the ext ent of such peri od . Beyond thi s po int , r eas onab l e t ime off c an be given for s pe c i al oc cas i ons
fully c ons:L l1 e r h1s c ampR ign needD well :in advan c e 6f the c,ampaign per i od
i n order t o
9.
:::l2:(;omp:tn::L, I l u
Po1 1 c y Let LL;r N o . a.
;].:3
a l '[', t L J';
( ; cc
qlw r : t i on No , ) 1
fur
(1 cf LnLt:LC.iY2.h
, 41
In bri e f :
Analyz e and take pos it i ons on i s sues whi ch have an important relat i onsh i p t o Company operat i ons , . . approaching i s sues, with c ons i d e rat i on o f the i r effect o n t h e nat i on , , a s well as the i r effect o n t h e Company .
b.
Promot e the Company ' s , pos it ion through empl oyee publicat i ons and other fOTIns of c ommunj. c at ion , . . with appropriat e admini s t rat ive approval as . requi red . ,
c.
Communi cat e ,-lith lec;i slators and appointed ' of f i c ial s t o c reat e b etter mutual und erstand ing of vi ewpo ints and to l eg i s l at i on on Company operat i ons . Fol l ow and report ori 'pos i t i ons and
Clar i fy
e f f e c t of pro o s ed
Advan c e Compsmy b eLL efs 'wl th t rad e nnCl bus :i n c fJ s a s n oc i. a.t t onB the pnbLL c nffn L rs
can n,
10 .
'l,mnt
0['1.'01' [;[1
of [ HICh
A f i r s t s t e p i s build ing and ma intaining good pers onal relat i onships with l bcal , ways , includ ing period i c luncheons at the plant w ith key plant people . , " It' . . . s o that the Company ' s b e s t i nt erest will be a part ' stat e and nati onal repres eptat ives . \ . : th i s c an be d one in s everal
i s d es i rabl e that repres entat ives b e reas onably fam i l i a r w ith Cat erpilla
11 .
W e want to promot e b ett er mutual und erstand ing o f each other ' s problems . . . . but i s probab ly b e s t ac c ompl i shed b etween Cand idat es should not be all ow ed to d i s t ribut e pol it i cal c ard s pr'omot e individual c ampaigns on - Caterpillar property during
Thi s c an be d one at any t ime campai gns . and , work hours . in g eneral ,
12 .
13 .
What about us ing a plant aud it orium or s ome othe r Company- owned meet ing pla c e a s a forum for pol it i c al cand idat es ' during campaigns ? Can b e a good i d ea or local , . . . prov id ed that all part i san groups , whethe r nat i onal
To db otherwi s e would
,.)
14 .
. . .
s ome s'ort o
for exampl e ?
42
be all r i ht
15 .
to que st i on No .
If Ccrt erpillar has tCl.len a p08 Lt :i on with r e s pect t o Quch an :i s sue , :Lt YT01).ld g 1n most ra;3 en to uc c, n. Compnny me e t i ng plnc e to h( l p promot e ou r s id e of the i s s ue . II' the ComIlany har; noi; takr::n a pall tt t on, both 8i (1 88 should be g iven an o pportun:ity to part i c i pat e :.. - as s et :forth in the answer
'
13 .
l?
what i s fi rst
Nat i onal and stat e i s cues should b e referred t o the Publ ic : Affa i rs Department for study and res earch . proposal , etc .
16 .
may already haVe ac cumulat ed s ome thinking or expe ri enc e in th e s ame f i el d What about tho plant l eg i s lat ive c ommitt e e s ? The s e c o:it t e e s have proven to be effe c t iv e : s c reen ing f}, ' vari ety . of propos ed l e g i s lat i on . . . f i rp t "
mal be
Local is sues
( c i ty
manag e
referendum,
s chool board
thi rd ,
s ec ond ,
for generating l et t e r s and other c ommun i c at i ons on such i s sues : or the i r repres entat ive s ,
17 .
.. '
'''' I
whi ch is
"' i
and others
in the
18 .
but rathe r
will "mi s s t.h e mark " wit,hout t h e pa rt l c i pat t on ahd guidanc e of th e i r member firms . ' 19 .
As far as the law or s el f - impo s ed restri c t i ons " c annot s " and are c onc e rned , what a!re
o rgani zat i on s
the
basic a.
The Company c annot make a c ont ribut i on or expend iture in c onne c t i on with the e l e c t i on of a cand idat e .
b.
The Company can d o all of th e things l is t ed und e r quest i on N o , , 'The Company can d i st ribut e promot e
6.
c.
( or
oppo s e nncl c ri t :i c J z e )
i nf ormat i o n
a part i c ular
on . an :i s s ue ,
s L d e of tb at. i S 8 ue .
- 6 -
Prohib i t s any c orporat i on what ever , at whi c h Pr e s id ent ial and Vi c e l\epr e s entat ive i n , are t o b e vot ed for ,
from
making a c ont ribut i on or expend iture in c onnect i on with any e l e c t i on or 'a Del egat e or Re s id ent
poLit i c al c onvent i on or caucus held to s e l e c t c and idat es for any o f or i n c onn ec t i on w ith any primary e l e c t :i on or or for any cand i d at e, pol i t i c al c ommit t e e ,
b.
any c ont ribut ion of money ' or any oth e r thing of value t o c OYnmitt,ee o r cand idate for pub l i c off i c e or: t o or an y d epartment or agency or flxrn i. r:l hln g
any pers on for any pol it i c al purpos e o r u s e b y tho s e who have ent ered int o " Ctny c ontn'1.ct w Lth the Un t t e d Rtat cs tho r e o f , 0 1 thor for trw rcmll. L U. on o f pcrn onal n crv L c c)f,:
:\ny mat e d :!} , GU}Jpl L c D , or cqu i T1l1lCnt to the United n Lat e n or fj,ny
the Uni t e d )tat e s o r any d epartment .Or ag ency thereof, suppl i e s , equi pment , land , l't op.1.rtmont or agency thereof , ' or s el 1 :Lng any lanel or buHd ing t o
i f payment
for the performanc e of such c ontract or payment for such mat erial , or build i ng i s to be mad e . in whole or in Congr'e s s , during the period of part from fund s . appropriated by the ,
suppl i e s , . equipment ,
or buil d i ngs .
if
,M>PENDIX II
P U B LI C
A F FAI RS
C AT E R P I L L A R
T R A C T O R.
45
CO.
MEDICARE The following l etter from Vi c e Pre s id ent R. T . Kell ey has b een mailed t o memb ers Bulletin of the Hous e Ways and Means Committee and t o all Ill ino i s congres smen . recipi ents out s i d e Ill ino i s are urg ed t o c ontact their congres smen, a s s oon as practicabl e , al ong the same general l ines . January 26, 1965 Dear May I point up a s ign ificant feature of the Med icare is sue whi ch appears t o have largely escaped the att ent ion of the pres s ? I refer t o the im pres s ive numb er of firms who already have c omprehens ive hos pital and m ed ic al ins uranc e plans for their own ret irees . Caterpillar , 39, 000 U. S . benefit s are t o vi rtually for exampl e , provides such b enef its without cost to it s These c o st - free employees and their qual ified d ependents . available to 90% of our currently ret ired employe es , ana:- all employees who ret ire in the future .
Under Med icare, each of our active employees would b e required t o pay taxes during hi s working l ifet ime for aft er-65 med i c al benefits that he is now ent itl ed to without c ost . Hi s individual tax of $2 5 . 20 a year would very l ikely increa s e with l ib eral i zat i on of this program over the years . We b el i eve the Caterpi llar example i s quite pert inent . When the effect is mult i pl i ed by the many bus ines s es and indust ries that have such pro grams , more than 50 mi llion U. S . workers would b e affect ed . In add ition to our own m ed i c al insuranc e, we have g iven c ons i s t ent support t o c ommunity, stat e , and nati onal programs provid ing health care for the needy aged . It s eems to us that a publ i c program pro vid ing l imited b enefits to all aged ( regardless of financ ial need and the ex istenc e of other coverage ) reduc es th e government ' s ab il ity to pay ad equat e benef it s to thos e who really need such prot ection . Thes e argument s are not mot ivat ed by Company cost fact ors . loc at i ons , Caterpillar ' s l iab il ity for health insuranc e for would b e automat ically reduc ed at the pas sage of Med icare . Soc ial S ecurity c o s t s would then be roughly balanc ed out by reduct i on in our insuranc e cost s . At most ret irees Inc reas ed thi s
- 2 -
46
We b e l i eve that a program, needy aged , c ompl et ely d etached from Soc ial Security, from provid ing low- c os t o r free c omprehens ive health insuranc e to the wow_d be a far b etter s olut i on to the probl em . . . the long - t e rm s t andpoint of b oth employe es and employers . S inc erely,
/s/
Not e : The following c ongre s smen, Ways and Means
R. T . Kelley
l is t ed by home stat e ,
Committee who have alr eady b e en addres s ed d i rectly on the Med i c ar e Dupl icate correspond enc e should therefore not b e Rep . Cecil R. King , Rep . James B . Land rum ; utt ; Jr. ; Georgia : Rep. Phil M. Cal ifornia :
i s sue i n t h e l etter abov e . d i rect ed t o the s e men . Florida : B. LOUi s iana : Rep. Rep . A.
Curt is ;
Sydney Herlong ,
Rep . Hale Boggs ; Mi s s ouri : Rep . Frank M . Kar s t en , Rep . Thomas New York : Rep. Eugene J . Keogh ; Pennsylvani a : Rep . George M . Rhod e s , Schneeb el i ; Wi s c ons in : Rep . John W . Byrn e s .
Herman T .
--
DPgVIX In
!the ma.terial. in thi s appendix cons i s ts o f newspaper
articl e s . The arti cle from the; Wall Stre et Jio urnaJ. i s in
Cludecili as an example o f the kind o f 8.i tuation that an e ffe c tive publ i c rel ations and publ i c affairs pro gram shoul d avo i d .
48
'- , T1l GM.ChfYi11er,: :Sh!?wlng i 5 ; do!fu!,'lln., J ortllneJe f9X' them pca,lls, it W!),Iil $q" un.f , ' n ec ess a ry. The Ame rican Motors perf(lt'm; 1<"" / , , ', , ', ..:..;J J " Vt;-, ' ' lll1 ce ah()wed that the lawmakers c:01}ld be f,', ,; " " ." ', mollifi d. Indeed, " l the ,weel{Cl' d , ' l i t U. 't4 & O i U e : ' : t en :S Y a n: e ' ___ " ." , " ::-,-= " " " " , . ,',"" ," , ,,,' ' Sen, Ribicoff ,a concillatory leUer accom{ " '" , '" ',, _ , When Sen: J{ennedy asked for GM's 1964 " _ , ___ "" , " , , " [ profits, a preViously published figlil re i presi' P.ftni .a d ': by ' a lo ng-de t.ail ed accounting ' ' :By' DAN CORDTZ safety'related spending. 'rhe grand total, c " . , WASHlNGTON-So dismal is the auto in' i .dent James RGche tried to. argue that it was . t 'dustry's performance at the Senate's safety 0t ' g:ermae. , The enator , p<1l'si'ited and uI- Donner, wrQte, came to $193 million lai ; l1: ear. A of yest erd ay afternoon nothing' hadl hea,rings that the chan ces of Federal legisla; ' Mr. Donner snapp e d, "I wil l have' y hroately , to ask one aL my. ' asso ciates :," ' '\'Vh en , 1\1r. bee n heard from Chry slc l', . ' ., t1on .in the field have markedly increased. . , . GM's " cri tic s ' , on t he subcommittee e Of the thrM m anufacturers that have tes' : Roche then gave the information , S n Ken el be more imp ressed by the company 's: n edy drew the imfavorable comparlsori'be- llk y ' tiffed so , far; '()nly little , American MotorS i l'etreat than by figures themselves, Yet. ' tween profits and safety spendIng that the , Corp, emerge;; with cre(ltt. Of General Mo: ' within the l\mihj, here'!\I. no queshon ,tors , Corp. and, hrysler Cql'p. one Senator exe cutives knew was . coming, . , Impo s ed ! by competitIVe pressures and the; , ',. l.'efleets : ''1' rCfl.lly wouldn't have belie ved After Mf'. Donner sought to ' evade ' com. tesultu: \g Obse8in . with styling, Detroit: menting o n It Cornell University study ab6tlt , they could be so bad , " AmI Ford Motor Co. , ' noes have a S(:liClt.ude for safety. It'a their;' '' ' , " appearing. tomorrow, may find its 'hat cal the fallure of GM door hinges, Sen. Kennedy faUure , to ntal11 es hH concern l cut in tartly to insist, "I think . YOl1 can an- . ;approach to' advertil';ing the most attractive ly t at maltcs mfIl11b ly, more probab e : ;trget of' aU to the Senate Gov-ernment Op- i s,,:et my question. Isn't the Cornell study . thm.. . t/'le a,uo mN WI" h 1 cntical of. GM ? " Clearly irritated, Mr. Jj)on ' erati olls Subcommittee on ExecutiVe Reor. , e structlOna , ?n hQ\';' 'b:i ,lff . ne repUed, ,. " Oh,J I. suppose. so . " Sen. Keh: : 1',a.l i gap.zation. The , subcommittee is studying the i . ' . neely coldly commented : "That is not.,the ' :, 9v: ernment's role . in highway . safety and < hopes ()r'better coordination of the fforts. of. , right attitude, ' it you ask me," ,. '. . . ...'; Mr. D<;mner's few attempts to spar back.' " vs.rious' Fedel'a agencies in this field. l ,. , > Clearly o,M and Chrysler underestimated . fired. Iri ,one exchange , Sen. Kennedy asked .. :-:,the : opY'oitioll and failed to prepare ade_ , about : expenditres( on sfety. resarch and : . Mr. Donner. saId, ' We don't know, Senator,. , . q\lately Moreover, their executives antag. [ ; how to add thes things up.'" onized bot.h subcommittee ch a.irman Ribi. .. Feign ing . astonishment, ' Sen; Kennedy ! .cotf (D;, COrin,) and the even more formida.'tked, Genel'ltl Motors 'doesn' t know how to " aola Sen. Rohel't Kennedy of New York. Yet " ' ' .. : the hbstilQ ,.Cong:re'lsiQnal reaction evidently;, . add' these matters up ? ! ! < "It isn't adding, " retbrted' Mr; ' Donner . : c:am a1! a llhockin g s1Jrprise ' .to the auto ) I ::\ . " "It is dividing!', ; . " .. . . . " . .. ' , .. ' :" . . . ' , . quickly ' remnded Mr. Don . ' . . Sen Kennedy i: ) ,At the: .outset, both c.ompanies atternpted " ' n'er that the .'word " add" w as. hiS own. . ' . V'to :seize the offensive 'by rmeans that were . '. . . . , . .. tr;\nsparently obvious. . . Finally, for men who guide the destlnl.es ; GM ' board chairman , Fredric Donner, of (:orpoi'a,te giants, the GM antl Chrys!er ex r .w,hose owIt salary and bonus last year to, ecutives were astonishingly ill,prepared , 'sug-, taled $833,298, grandly announced the' dona" ges ting to Sens; Ribicbff and Kennedy a less- '. i . :" tlon of $1 mi1lion over the next four years to than compelling ihteJ:est .in the " subject . . of < !: the Mass\tchusetts Institute of . !iechnoiogy ,safety. gaJn and again Sen, Kennedy sought' , ! !, for a study of traffic accident statiRtics. Yet " ,. the .daci:'11ort to malte even that moriest !loi1' . fi gures on. s8,fety expenditures, but their im Donner conceded under ques, ' :' pr essive ;lineup of off!Clals , and public reI a- , ' tdhUtlorl, ttons nide s couldn't. provide any. :Hlxplana-: . il, g ' W!l.Brt't g,rrived at until 8.ftcr the' sub tiona of why It's so difficult to calculate such . . c;Ccol1.l,mittee. had, asked ,GM nfficia.ls to. appear. . . .. . .. . outh\'y s were unconvincing, especially in vi ew Ignored MoekUp ,. " ' 0; ' . >, ' " , ' of Detroit's penchant for' cranking out fig " Chrysler " vice president Harry Chese . , ' , ures when :tne 'r more self-serving-the a I y e' ' I egedly astronomical cost ot switchlin g to the' ( prough proudly annotll1ced that his , 1 91\& c ars , , , <, Will have ,'!i new concept of door latch reo " ' metria, system o , measurement , ' for eXarih, ' ,Iea,sa' !J'Iech,anism"' whereupon a press agent, ' pIe, or the daimed investment in" bringing , ' , , " UnilWited and with no further ,exnlan ation " " out , e ach hew car ' modeL ;'11'om Mr; Qhesebrough. laid an imp essively ' r , Even the technical experts Vl'rere " weak, " ' " m ounted mock-up of arm re st and door ' Hal'ry Barr, GM ,vice president In 'charge''of : ,' nandJe" on',the desk beside Sen. Ribicoff. The , the engineering staff, appeared entirely un;i : chairman, with, barely a glance, ' had it refamiliar with a Cornell University stUdY " " ':tnoved Whel1 Sen/Curtis (R , Neb. ) , the in which the company ,had helped finan,ce , . and .qustry's champion' in the hearings, walked fumbled .answers to a number of Jther, ques- i ', ' over to inspect the gadget he ,couldn;t figure tions , on safety development. Chrysler' s Mr. ! , how it worked,. , '. ' Chesebr:Jugh, chief pC ,product , planning, ;! didn't know ho"" }orig tlle firm has \Vbrked The t""o auto titans. stubbornly refused to on, a collaplSible steering wheel ' or why it ,admit even the jJ:Jssibi1ity that car design . is'n't ready y et. . . '. , " may play a significant role in the traffic .. . ; toll. Thus,. when Alnerican Motors presiden t , " By ttui time they were . fhrough/ ' Tee . marks ..one ',lJubcommittee member, "I had. Roy' Abernethy conceded that the product ,\ 101'e doulirt'll al'out the Rafty of their cars' } 1l , isn't perfect 1)e . won Mr, Ribicoff's sympa, ,tliY : "You're . the . first witness to a.droit that ; 1:at:l:!{gtf;they .fJtrtl(l,i' ;j,' . t . .. .. ; l!.sh. Yi9 hrightn !ls.. 'J rtafrW.h ii, :, " " , ,. ',,'ci,.: ,. : . " . ; .i. .;
"
"' ' "
E" Xecu t-ier V:J(,> ' ' j Uu' 1";'t' "OWn ,,.--va'u'se' '; ' " -' ' : , . V,.,j",!;_,_ I =: c:;: '_,:" ": _',." ,'." " , ,.
r ,A :..,'ff tO ' (.t:L
t " ' ; ,.' " " ,
f ; III
...
" .
"
;..
'rhe' earl'i.er \Jithe;;sa; espiiCilIy Mr.. l)Qn: nl', a4l0 l1dUlged in the,: n9tly luxury ot displaying annoyance<when questionll too k , an unwelcome turn. But eVl;tding -a, query i\l vasV. ly easier at a GM press conference, as .the earne d than ' at Congre l s:' a t
'
1 b:
G:rvr>g'
Mt,' '
'I
he
hat,
'. I I'
. june.' 2() ,
Ii'age . 14 '
1965
ri}ites; '; \ )
!:;.' tlon.
'Mt',.
,' The
, ?ut
/ carscl1lPmetHn
:i01
!;I". , , ' ,l
'1 . / '
49
..
they: cam e :, c e' o el"",::: :1to :nationallyknowii . firms . of great leaders maklng prodllcts usec:j'by Ct pillar Tractor Co. this . week. i :whicl(: stature in so many instances, d at , they ,were given a . tremendous.: intro.;, they did n.ot. send " representatIves. a \ ductQn . to " thi rea a lts advl!tage . .. . S $o .often tbe ",se bu,t; th.e , oll l1'1ii . for industrial . sites" was unprecedented , .... . came" THEMSELVES. '; ., '" .... '::1':;: . :' " :so }ar as we know here or anywhe e r ' ; That didn't'just happen. '; ); ) . : else , ,. . : , That came bet8use of tb, 'kmfui ' , .' ' ' " " . . ; It was ' an imaginativ handling of the arrangements and llla i ,. treP1endou ,pls fo th, e!l\ ' \ . : "; '<:'; 1 perSortal interest and participation o ! ,; . . . ."" No company could ave, pedoi'tne \ ': ;' President William BlacJd beyon'aj ; more significant 'service, ' n o r' ex , doubt. It couldn't be done ,any. oth''J ' , pressed more realisticallYJts . ties, its" , way' , ". .. , :: , . 'Concern, ' and its. faith fn the w Ii () 1 e ' ' )' e pr6grm wasl clearly artd pow; : ,h ,. community ill which iHuntiollsC ' ' : r ny designed to hammet h ome in ' e fu ; , A eat deal more than a . day off . the strongest way possible Caterpmat$'i and a few speeches was:involved .iri 'this;:'::" recommendatlon ' that theY, locate new1t " p odtiction 'It had to take tnonths of facilities in ' this area and .that theY i planning, close flttention, and deveIop . would find it a good place to do 50.1:"., f " mente . '" , . ' This was someone: of povt :: . , ,It was one ofthose things i'l c,enow'; rfuHnfluehee with a 'brotherhoo" an' . ',company can ". do hat no : Uindust ial . custonier relationship, a n d some<Jej , cmmittee" or other promotional civi<:;T\Who ':talks the samE,t languag; ',' ,/ <\;;,',) t ". . agency ca.,:" , posSiblY,, 111atC;!t.,; becus"';;t; How'cal1,yu t()P hat?' " , ., 'only the . ma}o :idustrjal " 'cocer,n; ' H":" %;;" /'And . the. ivote?tial ,cqsq1J.:nce ilf ,; , ,, ' self, bas the pgsltlqrHrom hlCh to' act terms of everythmg fro:q1 hOUSIng, :em,< ' so effectively ': ': \ i ' \. \ ployment, s cb o o l s , opportunitY. and.,:\:# Sorp.ethmg C?f te nature of the prep. ; prosperity are greater than could fi9" J -, " " ,\ aration , is revealed by the ,'single fact.., from any other single act or ,1'
. .
. .
"
'
'j
'
'
'
a9tion ,: a
' ,
"
"
', .
,"
'
'
'
....
'
gr
done .by
. '
'
".' : :j:
. ,
. . _-,_: , ' ,
'-""
'
,,<
E O RIA
-
A S S O C I AT I O N O F C O M M E R C E
Agu s t 1 8,
PH O N E 676.0755
1 9 65 50
TU ESDAY, JU LY 2 7 ,
.
. .
1 96 5
Caterpillar T ra ctor C o. has again demonstrated, by additi onal taQ.gible evi dence,
in a p o s itive, c onstru ctive manner, their de s i r e to be g o od cotpo rate and individual citizens in our c ommunity.
On Tu e s day, July 27 ,
"
"
1 965,
.
of s ele cted maj o r suppli e r s who s pent the day in P e o ria a s their gue s t s .
I ,
l' I
The event wa s fashioned to demons trate to their gue sts the man
, . ,
y advantag e s
. :., , '
'of
. the Pe oria Area a s a pla c e to work, live and ope r ate a bus in s s
and to .
.
mutual
. b enefits t o b e gained in having . supplie r s m o r e advantag e ou s ly r e,pre s ented near '. . ' their
p rincipal bas e
of operations .
C OJ.l gratulations , and a s in c e r e thank you, to Cate rpillar T ra ctor C o. ! Progr e s s Day will p r ovide for b r oade r indu strial development an d e c onomi c div e r s ifi cation for the Pe oria Ar ea.
IvHght we suggest that other Pe oria Area manufa ctu rer's c on s i de r a s imilar p r og ram. One hundr ed new indus trial employe e s develop s int
359
more
:nw
BIBLIO GRAPHY
52
JBt> oks
Be may s ,
374
p. ,
Universi ty
Be mays ,
:J4WlU'd L . ( e d . ) . The !ngine ering 0 f Cons en t. vii i , 2446 p . " tlrb.iversi ty-o? . Oklahoma Pre s s , 19 5 5 . Bernays has oollected s everal good arti cle s on the sub j e c t and pre sente d them in this boo k .
Mills , c . Wri ght.. .!!!!. Power Elite . 423p . , ()OCford;. 1lJInivers:ii.ty Pres s\, 1 9 5 9 .. ".' Al though no t dire c tly related to thi s paper , i t dG e s provide an interesting antilysi s o f the so ciety that the pro c e s s de s cribe d in the p ap er take s plac e . Randall , marence B . ... Oreed for Free . Enterpri s e .. 171'];> . , lBbst0ll1: :: ill.. t tle :Brown and Company, 1952 . . J:lrQvide s the . views of an indus try ' epoke sman .
.
Eel'!ey , Stanley , Jr., Profe s s ion al Publi c Relations and Poli ti cal Power . 247tj.; , BlJ.; timor4lu: The: John S Fopkins Press, 19 56 . " An excellent enalysis o f the 'po litic al us e s o ft publi c relations).
.
Griswold , Glenn. an d Denny . (ed . ) . Your Publ i c Rel ations . xix , 6 341' . , Ne:w. York :: FunlC'-aild Wagnalls , 1948. ffihi s coll e c ti on of wri tings i s similar to the Eernays ' book.
Werner , . WiJlli am. Lloydl. !he e-orpora tion in . :&nergen t (:; j Am.fJdtlfan 8:0 ci e ti:;:-b41R. , . mew: 'JeJl''"andJ EVens ton :: EFarpel!"' Elll d .R0W!, 196 2 ' . Jlx eElll analys i s o f the mo dern corporation " and 1 ts problems " in contemporary life . kti cl e s and Ferio.di e;als : cravens, Ken ton R . ":A; Wew Fo r c e; in. 1'0 Ii ti cs , Hi in :JBa.nke.]!" " s IlGnthl..z , 'lhXXWI ., Ai>rilL 1 5 , 1965l. l! spe akS, o f the ri eing influence o f busin e s s . in p oli ti c s .
""
t':
l'enn ,
Ban m ,
. .
lBUsine s s an d Fo li t i c s , uPro..a in Revi ew: Jr . in Ifarvard . RUsine s s Revi ew, 1"01 .. 37/ No. .. J" 'Iay/Une . .. ' . 19-5 9 1., b-14,, 131 42 . . ' . . .... .'. :rt1;tdy, . o f the ' relationship be twe en the S e two' . spheres,. ,
. ' ' " 1 ,
JIO:l.ly,
Fred R ." nbli c_ ReJl.ati0ns in Our Own Backyard , " im The PUbli a: Rati one Journal , "lau . 3 N[Q . Sl, . tAUgus t , 1194 , 'Reprin t . W} '. llIue:niption 6 f the e arly communi ty rel ations work at Caterpill ar .
SIS
ETation '
ilp,1. 51 Nb . .
ut(loming :; Bli.gge s t Role A ver for :Busine s s , 11, November , :E96 3 . Predi c tion of :ffu.r ther growth o f busine s s influence i n Washington .'\ ' EUsd.ne s e . S tre e t , Itl in Reprint; .
It
Shel don;, lli> race , B e ".sine s smen Mus t Ge t Into Po li t i c s Uf t in , Ifarvardi; lBUsin e s e Revi ew, (Maroh:"'A'pril , 1959 }, .' '. ' " " " 37-4#. ' Sheldo:n eli:1ilJbusl s s parti oipation in communi ty. and ' poli ti cal affairs--as a me ans o f self-preservation .
PUbl i she d by the Chamber o f Commerce o f Washington Report . the Unite d State s , Vol ., 4 No . 37 , Aug . 2:7 , 196 5 . Ro ger " ''We ' re S.o l d on the Impo rtance o f PUbl i c Mfains, .tt . An address by Roger T . Kelley', Vi ce Pre si cllen t, Jlaterpillar e tl'r eo . , at Publi c Affairs Gonferen c e o f the Ameri can Iron and S t e el Ins ;j. tute , ' J anuary: 1 3-14, 196 5 . 'Nnpubli shed Materi al
Kelley ,
Po l i cy Le tter.,
Co .
No .
ather Sources Caterpill ar Tractor Co .. " Personal interviews wi th personnel of the Publi c Mfairs Department .. J) une 1 5 , 196 5 , . an d J anuary 14 , 19;66 . .
____
Personal' interview wi th :myron DeHaan , Manager o f S:5 .. the Publi c Affairs Department .. JJuly 30 , l:9
__ __ __
.'
Personal in tervi ew wi th William l ackie , Fre sident of the Caterpillar Trac to r Co . January 2 5, 1 9 6 6 . Kelley , Vi ce J anuary 26 ,
____
1966 .