Professional Documents
Culture Documents
تميز ابن تيمية في نقد المنطق
تميز ابن تيمية في نقد المنطق
)
(
=
=
:
) _ ( 001
1427 2006 -
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
*
(' &
#"
+-( +*#
..- : '#
'@ +AB?=>* '4 5 ;
89
'
52
34
G3 F C'5 CD '54
*
C'
#
J#
HI
G
M4
P ?
O
MN @
+
F
8
9
'
5 G
B S
TB
B 234*'
'
2
34 C'
5 GB 89
P
* +
VB
P (\ GB [4P ? O :+B X?Y + S 855 +] H N
+ 855 @' =V9 P (\
(;
:
(\ :=@ X4
234 8* =3:+B
. '>9 -1
-2=@ X`'
.
-3=@ X#
.
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
="5 P = O 9
2
34 C'
5 G
B 8
9"
= 8
*b
8
V?
G
? 2
34 C'
5
> S
F=
"5
'=H S
(9 G
B
M9
A
B 2
34 C'
5 S
P =
3 *
' @
' ?
+
B d
?'
#
M?B SP9 N '54 #9 N@' dP (\:
)
(
& g @ +B 4Hb ?=..2B
iM4 +@ i +.. h
Ali Fattani
)
(
:78
=#
? S# 234 j# ? S5= = M =G
( 855 =@
M
5AB lP J#;
` GB
M2
34
1427/12/23
=' G
' ) (165P h= 8 ? 8M M).(39
) (3# j#~O G).(329
) (4 Sn
O 25(9 ).(98/4
Ali Fattani
)
(
'
5?
'
5B 8
"(4 G
B
=@
M=@
X`
' =@
X
# M9 S P j GB G>B 234
B N 234
) _ ( 001
4/ :::
@' ' GB =3* +534 ?'
# G
B +
4 '
# +
4
@?
4
(
>
' C 8M
M=
?4
b
= ?
i
1427/12/23
3 + ?5 8n m
:
Ali Fattani
)
(
" in4? S#? 9 G VM +3 2=' ?"( p
?+((
"9 F
'4 4 M.(1)D '4 +(("9 F? B
:
?B +AB 234 =3? @ :+
B
:
+ AB "
#
?2
34
"#
=3? 8* +
#
G
B 2
34?
* S
+
#
#
N +
#
' N>
P 2
34>
P =
>B5
X
g =
oB
j
j =V +@ # b =
V9
@
' G
B +
?98
B#
.(3) 234
45" 01$ *%./' ,* )
( '
$% $%
&$
O
S#* >4 234'5 SV 8=#) (4 N ?m @=
+
~OAB G
g
9 j
C
V N '
#~O
G
jN
V
O g
9
P G
B?
m
.234
=
"5 :
4=5
i4~O
'
@ G
=
G
B 2
34
= :
) _ ( 001
~O G?3 (
= 234 +P 8Mno G49
*
C'
#
#
+
S
#B
I
'
G
59
'
GV
9 +
4
'
b]
G
(*
h?
?MG
D j;
S
V ]
i
'
#~O
G
49
G2
34
) (1" =# M G).(69
1427/12/23
) (2b ?>4
.(161/1) 4
)9 (3 z GB 8M Mb = ).(387
) (4 Sn
O ) (102/4 ?" M~O.(45/1) G
Ali Fattani
)
(
.:.
* S# `M
@ :=# =# @ SnP d=
# =
#
*=
@ S
#
P
"4 G] GB 8
& ) (1 DP
; 8;V ?
G
>B
D
O .
="5
O '' P GB +?m
P GB + j#bG P h# G
B
l
O
?
m
) _ ( 001
P j
:G?
g
i G
B 8
n
3Y
* +#B F4(\ +
8* +M"9
8n] M
1427/12/23
) (1[
'
G
B
O
:=@
X
O
'
.85m
Ali Fattani
)
(
=#
4 = = * >9? i 59>
=
=
G
B +
4V9 +
4
=3?
h
5z
m
.(4)Fn
~O
G?
'
?
G
B +
2
34 +
P
'
+?=2
B
V
? # j#? h
4.8534
S
5~O
G
G
B 4 2
34 8M
M
P C
5
~O G
`N
' +AB h#~O G?
S
5 C@
=
o
=3 2
(5)4 lP
N 89 ? ~O G
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
H. :N
O
~O
j
2
34 G
V
O N
; (b + N
*> 8'5 ?'@ G > =5 P j# N
1427/12/23
) (1 P54
T ~O G).(26
) (25' 8MM~O G).(10
) dB>9 (3 8MM~O G).(85
Ali Fattani
)
(
10
= +9?m i
?
G? d
M>
.
i
P j
B]
i
4 @= = +
9
S
d#
2
34 8
44
P @8
n
=@>.
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
11
4;&
:"&:
'
5B
G
B =3
* +
534 ?'
# ;
[ j
X 8O?# D.(2)j
@' =H " M MV9 8O?#
( 2
34
X]
Gn
? " C?" (3)"pM +B 234.=3
2
34
=
# G
4) (4
lP
@ G
.(5)+
8MY`N 234 =3t 8MY ? XM G? GB
o
234 8
5?
V
'
>
~
2
34
(6)=3
* +P ? GB
V'o
V9 j > j 85.(7) =3
J
B 2
34
G3
j +
5
>
#
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
) (5
534
.(82/2) 89
)9 (6 z GB 8M Mb = ).(198
) 2#9 (7
* + 234M G).(84
Ali Fattani
)
(
12
) _ ( 001
) (1
'
#
#) (62 57 36 8
V
N
>
`+
9M
).(20/2
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
13
01$;&
:
4&
'
4/ : 4: :=8
@ `N : [ j
JB 234 =3> O
+
G
B N?
h 2
34>
P '
5B
A
B 8
9 2
34 C'
5
=3
' =
(9
* G +# Gm4 =
(9 8
35
9 G
B '
5 z j
5B 2
34
'
5 S
234 @ S
89 '#
8
9 G
B
P =
5 :
\ '
5
2
34
G3 +
*=9*>
8
H
'
VM
X?
G
59 Hg
'
jB 89 '#>]= ?; S 234 GB G3=
?B
59 (9 +' ~?N + S' >]= ? SV PY '54 G
]>4=
5
F.(1) 8534
GBP 4#=5 ' X3 : '# '
5
2
34 8
9
+B#9 '5( 85# '5 GB 8 b'5 234 .(2) ]>4
'54B
S5 89(\
'
54]
S
'
54 S
"M
'
54
jn# '54~ GB n P j#>P '5B]
h
+
8
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
C'5;
# ;
.
:".' ,1S
R9@ '5B
'5
:234 89
= ' 8534 '> P4
894] GB + '54'
)
(
14
).(1
"$V
:
./ +
AB ?
8
9
O
'
52
34
.(2)=3
$' "X HY
%' :
$
9
2>
P @
?
"
: "
534[
j?
G
B?
b
G
+B i?9 >4`9 +M z 234 G 33>]=
+
j
i
= - GB CP GB 234 8 5PB 8 ).(3
m4 =5 P
'5
234 89 i GB +
=
o
H
'
3'
GM
+
?
+
P
8
9
'' "
+M +
g? Y9
Y
? ]Y h5 j + j
@ +' ? "( 8?
# 8nPh
#).(4
iP B +# N ?# ? O
'
5 G
B 8
9 2
34'
?#
GB +? + "4 (\ '4VM b".
$# "X 01$% $#
=Z* :
<
&V
"
G
B
P =
5 :
'
5B 8
9=
i
B ;
=
2
348M
M
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
15
$' "
X H
Y
0
1$%
$< \"
' ]
/@
*
^ :
'". +AB $G?
89 534]' F 534
+
G
B =3;
= +*?>
' G
B
i'* 2
34
'
9[4
*'' 2(? 9=@= '4 ;).(2
<
SX$
*
8
#
;
@
' ?
8
9
?O 234 C'5 GB F +~ C
'5 2
34
G3
; j j>4
4]=
h?
O
9 G>
8
9
P
; CO9 dP (\ ] GA & * +? O9 G>
89
]
2
34 C'5 GB
=
5 `
'
@
+
`N
#
;
G
B
O9
.89
4;&
: 4"& :=8
@
' J
#?
Hg
'
5
2
34 8
9
= =
5
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
16
)
(
3 S?
;
@
T C
@ @
G
B
X :2
34
" '"
' ,
% ?
V
5 <
X :
8
9 ?
V
j S = = G GBP =5 : j#m' ( "(p
@
>
8#
T *
=
l
S
V =
>B;
+
) _ ( 001
8MMD j @= C
j( p=5# i= +=m 5B P
=
jV9 89 j 8MM >3Y> S >4
) (2]= ?M
.(261/9) 89
) (3
534
.(29/1) 89
) (4 .(17/2) 2
Ali Fattani
)
(
17
*' = GB';
+ 2
34 8M
M(
@
4 8
m@4
Y
" j ?...
V
i4b ~O G;
P P +#4b
8
9
i
B ' :=
j(
4
+
M4 +
;
'
5B G
9 i'n 8M M?4 >4(;= >@og ( h" G
B p
S
1427/12/23
= +3
j'n ).(2
) (1 ?#
.(276/9 248-247/6) 89
) (2 8M 8 84 N 8P h G(' '#= Go).(162
Ali Fattani
)
(
18
Go=B5
j
i4
8
9 2
34
'
B j
+
* 25(9
O# >P + i4 +4 iP
B
8
9
?#
>P j# ?= GB + S# +?# j# +@ + 8m@4
Y
T
T5 C
=5
' C
=
(B +
8
9 J@
4 +
T# #
XVB( 2
34
j
= +
M?
#9 +
#
#?
p?+
B
4V
P
Hg
T5 C= G
B
>53
+! P
Hg S
>B=
5
(9 G
B 8
9j
j
2
34
2
34( +
j
V
M P
Hg +
#M
P
'
( On* p#?N.
P XVB ' ?#V
GB 89 234 +T@49 iP!
P V P C= GB Go(? +? S5
g '
5
8
9
D 234( p' ' (?' + = :>4
J : +
5 ' 8 N So ' =V
85
j
+
X
b
G ]>
+
P
C~O
- G
8"Ym? G] h> =@ +AB -Go GB'5" 85' : "8M
M
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
19
)
(
+3~ +
(N P ?=* h
#3@ S GB? &
#9 ' +* h GnM; += @= & :#9
4 |mr& } L9$$/ 9y_u ( u|pt:$# sy9$#u y3t:$$/ y7n/u 6y
4n<) $#
] [125:S
'5
?]@ 8 ~O- G
4VB C d=* CM
SnN~
+(] 8 C 8?... +
S>B MV ~O +#B GP D N
4
+ @M
pTB~O.(2) .. + G
P>B V
= Go N +"549 +
GB 89=@ +M
234
S#B
j 89 S#B XY~O XVB GM
? .
@=@ :K = Go
D 89 GB?# S i@ 8=
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
?#
P = Go '
89 ;V ? 5
)"Y (1 ?=@ G4?M(' '#= Go).(104
) (2 2).(105
Ali Fattani
)
(
20
234 89 CD
8n* i 234 4#PHgB
5 X
89(= S5# ?# '4 S5#j
` 8@'O >=@ j :
'O9 '5B 2349 2344
4#?# S5# (1) 53P GB( 855* i ]> S
'4 234 j +AB j
V="5 '4 234 j N 234="Y
P = 234AB =3 @"' = Go
89 ;V
?#
234 4# P>B ( p +B h N '"5 +=GB SD
.2 S=
234 4#="Y CP>B= jP >
) _ ( 001
GB( 855
XY= j +4
89 234
# XY
= =>m
GB 89 XVB 234 +?T@4 +=@ S5P
S!!.
J@
K<
J G ` ? `V "/
e%X "X
:01$% $
j 89 G9g]'' N C'54B C'5 GB '# =V
=@ #]9
+5
'5 234g G ~'B
89
1427/12/23
) (1 GB 8M M=
o# G# O=' # 8).(51
Ali Fattani
)
(
21
GB ?#(P9 855
9 '5 GB CP 234 (1)8M Mg G
> =?5 '54B
89="5 * i@= `N
DgB j GB O9; SP !
5 _ bVS N N" p = GB( '5 jV
89
?O l
:
J : ( jV? O
234 C'5 GB 89 N =3O +4 S
'5 + 234 9 +
+ M '4 N=
= ( jV? O
l ( jV? O? STM* i ]= "M ; N >9
B B AB >4 =TM @' =M M GB S J#"M iP N
> M4
=V B *= '4 85nB 8M=TM B +#]9 N
? M H .>#
= pP V J#? '@
#=M ' "( GB 8J#
i N l( jV +=V STB
l"( G
#oA
P V =( + ;.G
@ : 5 : ? F O* # "?HN g S? O+
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
"M ]=>
; 8 l X j9 Gn3 +g
) 8@ (1 234~ 8
m p).(66
) (2 #
=[4 ).(231/13
Ali Fattani
)
(
22
# N +AB O +4 CD
# j
V ="5
B 9 GB CD CP".8M
lPVB( '5 jV
89? '@ O=V * # M CgS
J#VB @' =V * # GB +B"9 J#VB >VG
=*= GB CD '4> P> G9g V O' &.
i
= ? G > (> =5
@' '5
4' S S C'5
:234 89
j 234 C'5 GB 89 g
' ] P @' +& #
234 C'5 GB 89GB
P =5 : S +5M(- G4 '"5
-89 iT5 S5
G3P H- 3 C'54
M + M jD
.(1) j
P GB( 855
j5
534 j5
?Hg
? G d] h4 '4 Gnmb
89 G9gO'
>P ].h
) _ ( 001
/@& 8 >$2
8
':
j 234 89
V N
*
+
d
P
MN
@
'
#
?g '5 GB S
234 89*
' CO
9*
i
*?
8*
+
1427/12/23
+B:G
) (1=>M ' S5#& # ).(111
Ali Fattani
)
(
23
:
3M9 +
= 2
34 8M
M?
GA
B
> G
4
S2
34
9 8M M 84# 4=> >P dM?H= ?HN #9 234
= M
M ?
G
V g
9 +
B G
B
P =
5
:h
] G
=
=
=
= 2
34 N X
?Y9
[4
+
?H
Ph
GM M GP ?] + +\ )B (1
CP>
3M9 89
4B 8T5
C'5 234 G3 G4= m 8MY S5#G
B 8
o
> M GBP =5 G
9 : ;
G
B C
=> G
B j
>b
G
B 2
34
=
=
M G
B
>b ;
S
C
9
h
"
M ?
=
G
9 ) (2@
'
#
J
#
@=' 234 >#9
G
B
D
>b :
P
MV? J@
4;
+
= h ?>
234] 8@'O@
' G
B
#3
P
)(4
& . [10:
] 9$# =ptr& $. $t )t r& yn $. s9 (#9$s%u :j>B
= 8M
M?
G
> G
4 2
34=
5 =*
=
V G
B
2
5(9*
=
V G
B
YA
B
=3 G
B +
=@
4(
'
;
) (1 234= G# h] G).(1
) (2 N
534
(29/1) 89]= ?M ).(82/9
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
24
8
9
@
=
G
B =3(
' @
8
G
4
G
B G
V
Y 8M B =3* 8# N? >
P
G
V
S
5
=
@ 8
9
G
B =3?M
2
"
M S
#]B >
T# G
9G
B S
H
8
55G
m N?"
= G
m N
+ >
T#
H G
8
55
Gm @= +P * i GM
B S
= ?M
2
*
= G
m
?
+ G
B
P =
5 :
P
V - G
4#?M
2
"
M
G
9
-GP C G4
'B
:
M
8*=
N@?M
= : T' 8 :+?55 SV
B h
1427/12/23
) (1
534
.(84/1) 89
d> 8o S >T#(( 8
CP= "(( 8
' P8
9
:+?55 Gm = = ~?9 N 855= +4 # ] G [
CP
= "
(( 8 :
T
'
' ? J@
4 :+
?55 N
T54]?
#
)
(
25
V*= =V CP>B (1)h += D
=
? G > G4 234 G= (( 8 ? 85>P j?=* +> '5
.89
:
+
?= h
=
o G
B S
Y 2
34 '
54 +
B i
=9i
?9
M9 +P ?=
N i=*
' C
D '
4
A
B +5
C'
5
j>4G
M?V
*b ?M GB S J
#
Sn
j
?= h G
B 2
34 '
54
P
Y
i?9 +AB 89M9 GB 234 '54B + 234:+
@ GB G3
?"
= ?"
' 2 G
B C'
5
'NN
M9 G
B
V o G
B8
5
(
' G
B~
(
' G
B
T5 9 G
B
h
5 o G
B8
5
5
G
B +o
= C
S
j
V9?*
8
=3
> j? GB 855 234 j"#9 8- + +9P
g
3Y
i
P
B
j
8
9 '
54
S 2
34 F
2
34
+
o
P
V
=( + G9g.C'#
=49 : ]> ? G '54
89 >42
34 C'5 GB +AB 234
?= h]> ? G '5
V 2
34
9 =
>B
>4 +
3 C'
54
) _ ( 001
9 '# C'54 +9'nB9 =3 C'54 '5 +9
9 C?
N C'
54(
+
B 2
So9 '# C'54 = 8~ +?5B# 9 '# C'54 =~ +?5B
8
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
26
)
(
?.(1) #
> $ \5`Y Z "X "' 01$ $> f.
:
J +?#* :
' 4 =>B 234 C'5 GB '
54 S
* N 2
34
+
234 * S j + SH * Y S
h
(B =3
S
#B
h
)(2
)(4
) _ ( 001
) (15
' >4V ).(73
) (2
=
N
(1572-1515) G
S 2
34
G
B =38M
M
(';
8?
+
P=
8*
? "
S
'?= C
? G
B" +
3H
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
27
h~
+
B
=o S X
n
4 ?
G
B*
=
#9
jP j; G
B S
H 2
34
G
B g
3Y>
G
B j
V
]nO C
M
P9 =
8
=C
9 h=
P9 ?m 8O ? G
=> ]
F4S
"M
8
9
CP"
M *
O
8
= j
CP"
M ?
G
=>
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
28
l
j>3D?=59 G
>#9 GB g3Y>b ).(1
:
'
C
S G
B 2
34(
' G
B
5
=
] h '4 Gnmb
AB 89
j
89'
5 2
34 C'
5
V ]
S '5 4 FM GB=@ '5B d?3
89 G
B ;4?
" +
"
534 CD
?
=@ +
'
= =
V9 ]=>
[
8
8
GB 234
(' @ 8N'?N +
@o@
+@=
' 8
#o G
B
8B#m 8=3
8
CP]>
G
B 8?
O
>
G G
m4
+AB ?#
> +49>P @ '5 j
234 89
*
h
'G
)(2
* h Gnm
>
P ]
'
4 h
'
+
o 8
9
@ +
AB
:8
9
9
[4 G
B 2(?
9 2
34 '
4 X
5
>3# >5
?( S 3 G
B C 2
34;
']9
'
3 S
85o4P
'59=.(3) C
@
'
G
B 8
9[4 +
n4?
G
B +=
2
34 G
B(
'
@ ' 8 =:
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
29
?
VD j S =@ + >= "4 ]=).(1
@
j 89P '
S5 .G3
:
C
D 2
8
9
*
=
C'
# '
#59 G
BJ
#
VB >nm S#M9 GB >T#=39
CPVB:
"@ :?#
X
=
Y
CP
VM
j?
M >
1427/12/23
) (1 ?#
.(320/3) 89
)gm (2 VM GB GM Mbm4 ) (239/14 (\ + T).(75
) (34 (\m4 ).(270
Ali Fattani
)
(
30
M N N? 2# +b = ="9 S Cj
V
=V
(= == >P =?VB" 2 =" '? +
85o4
*=VP
?=Mm V 84V> =V9 GB
?"=).(1
VB :8# O G
B
' SA
B
> +
#M9 ( 8
55
?# G
B
S
'4 S
89 GO SVB
?O
=
>B
+
S
S
:
'
O
9
8
9
+
C'
5 G
B O
="H 8 234 G3 +H >4 N" p =V ]>4j
#
S4 P
VB S
3
=3?
G
+
534
o N +
2
'4 j#
S
4 o N +
5@
'
="H 8
9
8 2
34
=3
;o 8:
: 234P * + =3= GB +?553
H
+
4( 2n5T?5.
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
31
9N 8#3>=@MB j
( 2n5 8#Y* 8" j>9(3Y8
> j 855P S#M= ( 2n
5=
V9 8
# 9(3
" 8
#
4
N
3 9=
"? 8
#
#B
P =
V9 ( 2n
5Y*
9 88
#
?"
=
>4 49
=
# '
8 ( 2n
5Y*
8
?~N
4 84
=V9 9="? 8# 49="9 S9 49 > 8#>P
89
3
M9 j>5
P G9#
G
G
B +(
B N 8
55 G
B N]
N
3
@ :
P
i
" X
Y p S
5#
=
S
84
(' ('
4 8
55=
V?B j
848
o
M
( N 2n
5=
V
] G# S
+
G( >
M 2n
5
P
V
C
G
B 8
9
=
o
5B C'
5 ... :
= ( 8
55X
?Y9 N 8
#
?H N3 8B#"M j#
B
>5n5
g Gm G j @ ' ?(
D
F=
"4 =AB ... 8# =# j#9 85#
3B&
+- G4
b X59 N O
Y
m G#
#
1427/12/23
) (1
534
.(52/1) 89
) (2 .(92/1) 2
Ali Fattani
)
(
32
h5# j#=@=.(1) + B
o
(? +5# N
J@
P
'
="H
8 2
34
G3
+?
h
T?5~ 8= :8 N=5 ' n5# (?*=
CP
~ (2) 8 N
G
@=
' H
8
'
@ +?
M G
* +? G
V ?' >
="H
8 2
34
G3
= =3 4 +534= H 8M
B
8
+
P =*
+
2
+
'4V =* +
* +?.O
) (1 .(181/2) 2
) FM (23# .85
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
33
" '
?<S ,
% 0
1$J
1
j
P C
8
9
="H? +
*>
8 '
"5
= G
iA
B 2
34 G
B 2
34
i
8
Mno
+="Y
'
B 8
>93B
>=5
j
= XVB 8n3 B j# S4 3B ' M9 j j j.j>=5
:
O
2
34 C'
5 G
B 8
9
+
?~ J@
49 S
85o4 i j>534? j>B"=#? + '
5B C
O
P G
B
] j
#
# "
( p
o + 8
5?
VM
' g 234 =V >4
>P
B
8
9
V ?
j>B"
=# 8(
'
3 8
5?
G
=M
lPP ? j>B"=# 8?M 2
P G9#
G G
B
P =
5:
PV =5 P@>'(9 GB j
'
= ;
@
'
'
D j=
=5 N
V
.(2) >4
CP>B SnTM? G*? '5 GB d#
234 89* + dP ?
O
MN
CD F="5
O
9
2
34 C'
5 G
B 8
9
?(
5
g
C'
5
HI
J e
k e
jA
%
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani
)
(
34
) _ ( 001
1427/12/23
Ali Fattani