1. Didyouanswerthequestion? a. Didyouthinkaboutthebiggerpicture? b. Didyouthinkhardaboutthespecificcontext? c. Didyouadaptyourapproachtothespecificproblem? 2. Statmethods: a. Didyouperformathoroughexploratoryanalysis? b. Didyouwritedowntheexactmodelyouarefitting? c. Didyouinterpretthecoefficientscorrectly? d. Didyouprovidemeasuresofuncertaintyandinterpret whattheymean? e. Didyoudescribepotentialproblemswithyour approach? 3. Writeup a. Wereyouconciseandprecise? b.

Doyourfiguresconveyimportantinformation/have goodcaptions? c. Didyouincludereferencesformethodsyouused? d. Didyouexplainwhy:whythosevariables,whythat model,whytheresultsyougotmakesense/dont,why youhaveconfidence/dontintheresponse,why.... 4. Reproducibility a. Didyouincludelibrary()commandsforalllibrariesyou usedatthetopofyourscript? b. Didyouincludecommentsaboutwhateachchunkof thecodeisdoingincaseIneedtodominortweaks? c. Doestheoutputofthecodemakeiteasyformeto checkthenumbers/figures? d. Onceyoufinishedwritingthecode,didyousaveit,log out,andrunitonemoretime?Evenbetter,runitona

differentcomputer.