Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Graphic Thinking For Architects Amp Designers
Graphic Thinking For Architects Amp Designers
for Architects
& Designers
TH RD E ITION
Graphc Thinking
for Architects
& Designers
PAUL ASEAU
New Yor k
Chich ester
Weinheim
Brisb ane
Singapor e
Toron to
il'
1. Architectural dr awing .
2. Com m u nication in ar chi
tectural design . 3. Architecture-Sketch-book s.
I. Ti tle.
4. Graphic arts.
NA2705 .L38
2000
720 '.28 '4-dc21
Pr inted in th e United Stat es of America .
10 98 7
99- 086809
Contents
vi
Discovery
141
vii
Verification
163
viii
Foreword
Acknowled gments
1
Int roduction
ix
BASICSKILLS
CO MMUNICATION
10 Process
179
11 Individual Design
189
12 Team Design
203
Drawi ng
17
13 Public Design
217
Conventions
39
14 Conclusion
231
Abst raction
55
Notes
237
Expression
67
Bibliography
239
Illustration Credits
242
Index
244
APPLIED SKILLS
6
Analysis
Exploration
81
115
Foreword
vi
1980
vii
v iii
AcknowLedgments
ix
.~~
"'_ .:;
\ - :
--
.1
)I
. .
\
H ..
'
'
i _ ..
q ,. .
-~
,r
, .... .
10,
c ,
-: \.
.... .;..
1 Introduction
rap hic thin king is a te rm I ha ve ad opted to
describe thin kin g assisted by ske tch ing. In
ar chitecture , t his type of thin king is usually
associate d w ith the concep tua l design stages
of a projec t in wh ich th inkin g and s ke tch ing w ork
closel y toge th er as st im ula n ts for develop ing ideas.
In terest in th is form of th inki ng is prom ot ed by a
reexam ination of the histor y of ar ch itectura l des ign ,
th e impact of visu al com mun ication in society, and
new concepts of th e role of design and design ers.
;,~
j' ~
.t
.oli\
,.
' 0
' L
,
. .-l
', .
.......-.
. ~ '.
'
..L
! --...._---'
"T'" , .
\
)
-~
- ,- '
~ _.
..r ~.r
'
~-~
"I
.""';'
' .,
j '
U
. i'J.' ., :
'\ ~_
. ' '"
. '
,.,
,; .
t.~!
1.-'\
11'
";
./
. '. >....
_ ...... ..,
".
"
r ">
~ -I:':" -
,-
. .. : '
--
<,
t,.. ..- ..
, ~~ --~~ ~. -;
( "
_.. . . .
~i
WI' ;p,
, Ii )
,~\ ej JIJ:i
I' I '
/J.
'f
-t
~~~
~7 - .s ~ "
~-T"~
'" ~.
-"
,/),. ,)I" V:'
-.-~
~. ' ~~ . ~
[I),.
.-
- -r
"'
.,
~'-_
i.o--r---:::>
'
C-7~
t" '~
.~
,.
6r>o" 1
\
;
.
.
<
~
I
~~.!l-:""
~- . -~
. ..
Intr oduction
~. \fJ!lJiK~-:'1.
I
. Tt1~~""'~
.
,"
-c. ~
-- .-
ILJI
\.
~~~~
Ir=
I
I
~~~
Figure 1-12
Figure 1-13
Figure 1-14
Figure 1-15
Figure 1-16
Figure 1-17
VISUALTHINKING
The study of visual thin king has developed in maj or
pa rt fr om the st udy of cr ea tivity wi thin the field of
p sycho logy. Th e w ork of Rudolp h Arn h eim in th e
psychology of art has been particularly signi fica nt . In
his book , Visual Think ing, he laid a basic fram ew ork
fo r r esearch by dis solv ing the artificial barrier
bet w een th in king an d the ac tion of the se nses. "By
cogn itive , I mean all m enta l op erations invo lve d in
Introduction
~.-
;//
f ,;:;:,
Ii,,"
/"'''":k
'~ 'f '<
, ,, L, .
-. /k,:~,
./
'.
;;." f '"
~-
'-"0
t'n~","
"lY.<r:;;c
:11< '
'
_ \
;'
'
-......
"
.'
l' oIO" j
.100;: r~.r
~~'~ ~f. iF_~.
i'J . ".
.,,
1/,
i. . ,
'if';
' '.,,
-- - -' l.
.:J., ~ ..
'\'I
..<
'1
rt'
,.:,....
( "...
i . .~ .-.. . ,
-,' ''''';-- .
._ .
\
J
oIl.: '\ {
! \;
';
Jt,~~I'
y .]
'-
." .,
-I.
,, ~ , .
'
"
":
~.
!'t
.i
\I t\ ,,.
. ~. f
:'l'...".f' \'
c..~t".
~. t~
Visual Thinking
I~
\
Figure 1-21 Graphic thin king process.
Introduction
'\ ','-1
.\ }
' -Y
I
.!'--,
~ :;..~
.,.
,.
i\
J~
Figure 1-24 By David Stiegletz. Development sketches on back of a placemat, Siegler Residence.
10
In troduction
EFFECTIVE COMMUNICATION
A st a nd ard story th at m any archit ects del ight in
tell in g de scribes h ow the m ost ba sic co nc ept fo r a
multim illion -doll ar project was first scribbled on the
ba ck of a restauran t na p kin . I have wo nd er ed w hy
both th e telle r and th e listener alw ays se em to derive
a m use me nt from s uc h a sto ry. Perhaps the story
restores confidence in the strength of the ind ividual
de signe r, or m ay be it is the incongruity that de cision s
on suc h im por ta nt matters ar e being made in suc h a
re laxed , cas ua l m ann er. Viewing th is story in the con
text of gr aphic thinking, it is not at all sur prising th at
in spired , inven tiv e thi n kin g sho ul d ta ke place at a
resta ura nt tabl e. Not on ly are th e eyes, m inds, and
han ds of at leas t tw o person s interacting with th e
im ages on th e napk in , but als o they ar e further stim
ulated by con versat ion . Besi des , these pe rso ns a re
separa ted fr om th eir day-to-day wo rk prob lems ; th ey
are rel axing in a pleasant at m osphere, and with th e
co nsu mptio n of good food , th eir level of anxiety is
significan tly recfuced. They ar e op en , ready, prepared
for d iscovery ; ind eed , it would be surprising onl y if
the most cr eative ideas w ere n ot born in this setting.
To be effective commun ica tors, arc hitec ts m ust:
1. Un d ers ta nd the bas ic elem e nt s of co mmun ica
S ~N 17E:e.
~e lvR
ArGhrtt.e..t
c /il'nt
A ~ d l e Y\c.e
Ol'$ I ~"'(.Y'
CONl E-XT
ObJe-d'lV e?1 Lo CCtt IOl'\, flo'V lI'DI)/Io' t n0 11Ml
/ Clrcuyy,.<;{o.I1 C1'S
11
0:.;::,.()
i:
~o
,.:;.
~ ~ st- >
..'. ~
1.'1 1 ..
j ;~
jii!11
12
Introduction
I NDlVl DUAL
IEAM
Figure 1-29
13
BASIC SKILLS
2 Drawing
17
2 Drawing
17
,
1.11~~ \;:J,,~~
' t \?
I
~ ~:;~~
', " i4"-~
tl )
;Y J f"
"
~If":/ ' ,e ~ II
' ~ ':) :,. ;f1 \-.L.~ "~~~ ~~
~
L:f,~s
~ .~
-r
=:
c '
<,
.@J
~'
D rawing
:>\"
t
,,~ ,
/ '0
-:\: '
,)
,
",,--- ~1:t
;>
r'~.::. c';
/ h'? _ r rN N (
1k~}Ir~
~/".u
.1
6 - ,(,"',)
~~~
P'1-~
~ ~'i l
,I
1:
Figure 2-4 By Karl Brown.
18
~G
.E(f
"
: -_.- -----.-__.-y
/
Figure 2-7 By Patrick D. Nall.
Th e Sketch N otebook
19
OBSE RVATION
The thousands of students who pass through archi
tectu ral schoo ls are us ua lly to ld th at they shou ld
learn to sk et ch fr eeha nd and , to a cer tain degr ee,
how . Rarely are they told w hat they sh ou ld ske tch or
w hy. Draw ing cu bes and othe r still-life exercises ar e
an att em p t to teach ske tching d ivorced from th in k
ing. Mo st st uden ts fin d it bori ng, and it drive s some
away from sketchi ng for the rest of th ei r lives. I pre
fer to sta rt students with th e sket ching of exis tin g
buildi ngs beca use :
1. The y ar e drawing subjects in wh ich th ey have a
20
D rawing
Observation
21
I(YM~
?trl-{4 lJY~
{!
IJ
Figure 2-12a House drawing structure.
BUILDING A SKETCH
22
D rawing
Building a Sk etch
23
IZJ D
L7k1
\
1
Figure 2-17
Structure Sketch
Figure 2-14
Fi gure 2-16
24
Dra wing
Fi gure 2- 18
Figure 2-1 9
Figure 2- 20
Tones
Tones can be represen ted with differe nt den sities of
hatching or com binations of cross-ha tching . The lines
s ho u ld be p arallel and have eq ual spa ces between
them . Always re m em ber that th e ma in purpose of the
cross- ha tching is to ob tai n different levels of gray or
dar kne ss . Use straight strokes as if you were pa inting
the sur faces w ith a brush . Errati c or irreg ular lin es
d raw att ention to th em and di stract th e e ye fr om
m ore im po rtant thing s. There is no st r ict r ule for
ap ply ing tones on a sket ch, bu t I ha ve some prefer
enc es tha t se em to work well. Horizontal ha tch ing is
used on horizontal surfaces, di ago na l hatch ing on
vertical surfaces . Wh en two ve rti cal surfaces meet,
the h at ching on on e is at a slig htly di ff eren t an gle
from the hatching on the other surfac e.
Bu ilding a Sketch
25
==
-
ififf
~I ~I
r
~ ')!! .~~
../
~u[1fj
0000
L..J
l--J
L.....-..>
'--.J
1=
~
~
,.j71iii~~~~;)
~11i/W WJ&il. ~
Figure 2-21
Fi gure 2-22
Details
Detai ls a re ofte n the most in terestin g or compe lling
as pe ct of buildings. T he window is an exce lle n t exam
p le. T her e, the de ta ils ca n be th e result of a tr an siti on
be tw een tw o m a ter ial s-brick and glass- or b etween
two b u ild ing elements-wall and op e ning. The w ood
w indow frame , brick arch , key stone, and w indowsi ll
ma ke t hese transi tio ns po ss ib le , an d each of th ese
de tai ls tells us more abou t th e b ui lding . O n a regular
basis, I have students sk etch window s, doors, or
other bu ild ing elemen ts so they ga in an unde rstand
ing a nd appre ciat ion of the con tribution of detai ls to
th e q uali ti es and func tions of the bui lding . Details
tell us so m e thi ng of need s a nd ma ter ia ls as w ell as
our in ge n uit y in re lating th em . Th e ske tc h of the
me ta l grating around th e b ase of t h e tree exp la ins
bot h the need s of the tr ee and the use of th e su rfa ce
under the tree where people w alk .
Figure 2-23
26
Drawing
Combining Observations
Building a Sketch
27
TRACING
Trac ing ex isting graph ic mat erial is anoth er w ay to
bu ild sketching skills. Ma king an overlay of you r ow n
drawing s w ith tr acing paper is an ob vious but und er
used dev ice. Rath er th an overwork a d raw ing th at is
h ead ed in t he w rong directi on, make an ov er lay
sh owing th e ele men ts that need to be corrected and
then, in anothe r overlay, ma ke a w hol e new ske tc h
incorpor ating th e ch an ges. You w ill learn more from
yo ur mi stak es, and th e fina l sketc h w ill be better an d
fresher. Tracing can also be do ne by lay ing a tran s
pare n t s hee t with a grid ov er a draw ing or p ho to,
draw ing a larger gr id, and th en transferring the draw
in g square by sq uar e. A thi rd tec hniq ue uses a slide
projector a nd a sm a ll m irr or to p roject images of a
conveni ent size for tracing on your d rawi ng ta ble.
The large sketc h on page 3 1 w as don e in this w ay.
IJ
o
01 1'0 0
Figure 2-26a Orig inal sketc h.
DOD
Figure 2-26b Overlay sketch.
MWJrt4~~11-
M \t?RD1<... IA~LE
~ -611~ ~?etf~
I~ I'1j kt-~td.-l - up
~~~:
~J"'T r
"Z061'V-.
~w;
""'T'
ii
i i
" 'm
li\ol
4~~~lA-!PtUltw$
~kj?ru .
~~LWt>r-
'>\<
:tl~
'f~~)
Ml~D1< 130)(
28
Dra wing
Tracing
29
(a)
30
Drawing
Figure 2-34 a (opposite), b (above) Plan, section, and perspective of garden-court restaurant, Salzburg, Austria.
PERCEPTION
Many a rchitects have b ecome m et hodica l abo ut
sketch and note taki ng. Gordon Cullen , the British
illus trator and urban d es ign consult an t, had a m ajo r
influe nce on the use of ana lyti ca l sket ches. His book
Townscape' is a wond erful collec tion of visua l percep
t ions of th e urba n e n v iro n me n t. Th e sketc he s a re
clear and com p rehe nsive , im p ress ive ev ide nce of
w ha t can be dis covered wi th gra p hic thinking. Using
pl ans , sect io ns , and perspectives, th e sketches go
beyond th e obvio us to uncover n ew percep tio ns .
Tones ar e used to iden tify m ajor orga ni zers of sp ace.
(In the book , many of th ese tones are achieved
m ec hani cally, b u t th ey are easily rendered in
sket ches by hatch ing wi th grease pe nci l or large felt
tip markers.] The verba l ca tego ri zation of urban ph e
nom ena th rough shor t titles helps to fix the visual
p ercep t ions in our memori es; verbal and gra phic
communications are working together. And these are
Perception
31
rt~
;~t~~
11
~ k ~
~ /~~
c h~ k-.tk
~~
I
~.JIIiF
Figure 2-36 Salzburg, Austria.
~?
32
Drawing
~.
---~I c.,K
. . , . - --
_ .., M.A.~1-
=._~~~'S.
Figure 2-38 By Todd Calson. West minster Cat hedral.
Percep tion
33
oL
::=I:>::J
()~
Figure 2-41 After Saul Steinberg.
DISCRIMINATION
Cartoons ar e a n im portan t source of sk et ch ing id eas.
My favo r ite sourc es are T he N ew Yor k er a nd Pu nch
m aga zin es, but th e re a re many oth e r sou rces.
Cartooni st s co nvey a co nv inc ing sense of reality w ith
an in c red ib le economy of m ean s. Simp le con tou r
lin es suggest d et ail inform ati on w h ile con cen tra ting
on ove ra ll shape s. Michael Folke s desc ribes some of
the d iscip line of cartoon drawings :
.. .simplicity refers to the need to ma k e the clearest
possible sta teme nt.... Avoid all unnecessary de tail.
34
Drawing
IMAGINATION
Imagination
35
Visual-Mental Games
An en te rtaining way to im p rove ha nd - eye - mind
coord ination and promote an ability to visualize is to
play some simple games.
1. Show a few people four or five cuto uts of sim
ple shapes arranged on a pi ece of paper (above , left ).
Ou t of view of the ot hers, one p ers on m oves th e
cut outs while verbally desc ribing the move. The oth
ers attempt to d raw th e new ar ra nge me nt from the
description . Th is is repeated a few tim es to see w ho
can ke ep track of the pos ition of th e shape s. Aft er
m aster ing th is exercise, have the persons draw ing try
to form a men ta l picture of each new arrangem ent
and then try to draw only th e final arran gemen t. In a
sec ond version of this gam e, an object is su bstitu ted
for the cut outs, an d it is ma n ip u late d , op ened , or
taken apart.
2 . Form a circl e wi th a small gr ou p. Each pers on
m akes a sim pl e sket ch a nd pa sses it to hi s righ t.
36
D raw ing
Imagination
37
\
"
,\ '
t
\
"-,
"
..
'\
.....
'~
....
...
':,
" '~\~'f,
,'", I'
.,\~.
~~~.~--
~_
"
.----1
nventions
Figure 3- 2
Figure 3-3
39
',"/
Figure 3-4 Site plan.
40
Conventions
Rdure
9 1ane
l1 otrzon L U1l
PERSPECTIVE
Pers pect ive sket ches ha ve a n eq ual stand ing w ith
plan d raw ings, the starting poi n t of m ost d esign edu
cation. O ne-poin t persp ec tive is the easiest and there
fore , I fee l, th e mo st usefu l of pe rsp ect ive
co nvent ions. I have fou nd th e follow ing th re e-step
m ethod to be mo st succe ssful :
1 . Indicate th e pictur e plane in bot h elevation a nd
pl a n ; it is usuall y a w a ll or a not he r fea ture th a t
d efines the far li m its of th e immed ia te space to be
view ed . Loca te the p oin t from w h ich the space is to
be viewed, or view point (V P.). Vertically, th is po in t is
usu ally abo u t 5.5 feet from th e bottom of the pi ctur e
plan e. Horizon tally, it can be p laced just a bout any
w her e in the sp ace w ith the un der standin g that pa rts
of the sp ace outsi d e a 50 -d egree con e of v ision in
fr on t of the view er tend to be di s torted in the per
sp ect ive. T he horizon ta l line d raw n th rou gh th e V P.
is called th e horizon line.
Persp ec tive
41
42
Conventions
Perspective
43
-- - - )7f'- '
<,
'
q (
"
Cl
- ~2 /
<,
:s: /
::
----
> ./
>
1------
-4'l\
~/ /
C\ (",
..... ,
/
/
----
--
l) i?
1"
I)b
./
/'
/
/
\
\
QUALITATIVE REPRESENTATION
spec t ive , p ara llel wit h the horizon lin e , are now
sligh tly slan ted in the di rect ion of th e imaginary sec
ond poi n t. To m ake th e transition fro m one -poin t per
spec tive , the top and bottom lin es of the pi cture pla ne
can be given a sligh t slan t an d a new plane is estab
lished ; by d rawing a new d iagona l, the new diagonal
va n ishin g poin t can be set. A grid ca n also be app lied
to this type of perspective to help in plac ing objects in
the spa ce.
44
Conventions
45
ii
PARALLEL PROJECTIONS
Cur re ntly in comm on use, the axono me tric sketch is
an importa nt alte rnative to th e persp ect ive, plan, and
section . The axonometri c is simp ly a projection fr om
a p lan or sect ion in wh ich all p a rallel lines in the
space are show n as para llel; t his is in con tra st to a
persp ective wh ere parallel lines are show n as exte nd
ing fr om a single point. The axonom etric techniq ue is
traditio nal in Chi ne se d raw ings. Instead of p lacin g
the viewer at a single poin t from w hich to view the
scene, it gives the view er th e feel ing of being every
w here in fr ont of the sc ene. The axonom etr ic has the
46
Conventions
1
r
VERTICAL SECTION
A vertical cut through a space is ca lled a sec tion.
What was said abou t the plan sketc h also ap plies to
the section sketch, excep t for the cas ting of shadow s.
With sec tions, we can show depth of space by apply
ing the one -poin t perspective co nventions explai ned
earlier. Imagine you are looking at a cut m odel of the
space; the point at which you loo k d irectly into the
mode l is where the viewpoi n t (V. P.) wi ll be p laced .
T he viewp oint is used to projec t th e pe rspect ive
be hind the section.
Vertical Section
47
~
~
~..
PLAN SECTION
Abs tract pl an d iagr ams suc h as th e one ab ove have
m an y uses in the ea rly concep tu a l s tages of design .
Th is is covered in d epth in Ch apt er 4 . However,
m any architecture s t ud~nt s make th e m istake of try
ing to use th ese plan d iagram s to rep resent th e m ore
concrete decisions a bout th e format ion of space. Plan
sketc hes of d esign ed sp aces mus t sho w w ha t is
enclosed and wh at is no t, including scale, height, pat
tern , and d etai l. A p lan is basicall y a horizontal cut or
section th ro ugh th e spa ce. Thin gs th at are cut , su ch
as w alls or columns , are ou tl ined in a heavy lin e
wei gh t. T hings that can be see n bel ow th e pl ace
w here the p lan w as cut are ind icated in a lighter line
weight. Things such as a skyligh t th at ca n not be see n
becau se they are abo ve the lev el of the cut ca n be
show n w ith a heavy dashed lin e if d esired.
The first stage of a r ep resent a tiv e pla n is the
heavy ou tlini ng of wa lls clearl y show ing ope n ings. In
th e secon d s tage, d oo rs, win d ow s, fu rn iture, an d
other d eta ils a re ad d ed . Th e thi rd- sta ge ske tc h
48
Conventions
OTHER REPRESENTATIONS
A variety of sk etche s ba sed on th e con ven tions of
persp ective , pl a n , section , and axono me tric are
shown on the next page. By m ean s of ske tches, we
can cu t open, peel ba ck, p u ll apart, re constr uct, or
m a ke co ncre te objects transpa ren t to see how th ey
are arra nged or con structed . Th es e are jus t a few of
th e poss ibl e ex tens ions of repr esen tation . As we use
ske tches to v isu alize design s, w e sho uld al w ays be
ready to inven t new too ls as need ed .
- -- + - -
I
I
-- --
Figure 3-22 Cut-away view, the Simon House, Barbara and J ulian
Neski, architects.
49
/I
,>I'
- --1tr--
- -
-,~
,~
/ .1
.:%
.f
~
-~
f1~ :
.:
1,
_l"E;'-~--,
: I_ "" '__~:_~..: _ ~<'~~
__ ~_'_:~ --f
---
- <=.:.
...
,t .i""
.. .
t~~
- :I( _ . ~
:-~-
or
, 'jd .~ ~
'
r'-:i?J~
- i::'"-~.
t~
~
,,:.L..-<;.
t:.t<
\ l~~ ..., r , ' /, ~ ~ t6 ~ _ .
SKETCH TECHNIQUE
---1
11
50
Conventions
Figure 3-26 By Brian Lee. Auto matic drawing done wit hout
looking at the paper. It encourages fluidity of line and
nat uralness of expression.
51
,A
,v~/'
",L.-...-i
__\.
/~l=0
-c
':
I'-l-LA.~
.. c::I " v,
I ~-= \~ r
l~
c~(~.
. \..I;/
1/
-:
"\
1"--'
-\. ~ '-"'1 ~
<: l_ . _
52
Conventions
53
4 Abstraction
Yl1lZlA
]V1Wff//A
:1
'Ii ?l12tZ~
waw~
Figure 4-2
55
rY1 0 dl + , e ~
, -,(
-:
./
.--- ---
-- ~
---- ---
(d)
",
5VI;\J.
1\
no.",e )
,
(c)
I
/
I
/- - -
,el"h01\ Sfl/p
\
/
,/ -----B
- I- ... ,
(e)
GRAMMAR
56
Abstraction
Building a diagram.
,--------,
,,
,... -------,
I
I
I
I
:, - - - - - - - -- -- --':
I
I
'_'\
.
-r-"
I
i
'L ._
. -j
...
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
....
l ..
- ,
Grammar
57
-$
?>
t:::I
--
-=s
c:::
z;:=.
c:::s
t:::3
t=:I
~-
CJ
c::r
- -
--=
e:::t
ALternate Grammars
Th e basic grap h ic grammar disc ussed so far is mo st
commonly exp resse d in what ar e known as b ubble
diagram s. It is p roba bly the most broad-based , ver sa
til e gramm a r. Ot h er conven tions may qua lify as
grammars, or r ul es for relating graph ic elemen ts so as
58
Abstra ction
..
..
VOCABULARY
The m eani ng of w ord s or sy mbols in any for m of lan
guage m ust be con sist en t and shared in order to su p
por t h u m an com m uni ca tion. This co nsistent set is
ca lled a voca bulary . Basic verb al vocabul ary wit hin
our na tive la nguage is norm a lly acq uired in chi ld
hood th rough associ ation , w h ile gram m ar is learn ed
formall y. Lite racy is achieve d ove r se ve ra l years of
edu cation . Th e acq uisit ion of grap hic language is not
a com m on comp one nt o f a general edu cation. In a
for m a l sense it is m ore often a part of ed uc at ion in
d es ign and a rt curr icul a . How ev e r, the re are som e
grap hic "la ng uages " to wh ic h the ge neral pub lic is
ex posed. Among th ose are in terna tional road sig ns ,
roa d map legend s, mu sic notat io n , and mathe matical
symbols.
Th e acc essib ility of gr ap hic la nguages is heav ily
d epe nde nt on associat ions with fa mi lia r obj ec ts or
expe riences . T he se ass oc ia tions can be ma de th rough
nam in g gra ph ic item s or by using symbo ls th at are
read ily re cogni zed as abstr action s of fa m iliar obje cts.
Identities
There a re a grea t n um ber of w ays to sy mbolize a n
ide nti ty. The more common symbols are repres en ted
here in ho rizontal rows. The iden tity of th ese d iffer
ent possible groups is achieved by contrast. Us ua lly
a ll varia bles are held con st ant exce p t for on e. Th e
n um ber in ea ch group is limi ted becau se m ost of us
are un ab le to de al with m or e th an five or six vari a
tions in on e grap hic di agram . Th e el ementary sy m
bols can be supplemented o r replac ed by numbers,
letters, or othe r sy m bols. By jud ici ou sly com bi n in g
differen t gro ups of sy m bols, it is po ssible to have sev
era l levels of infor mation in a grap hic d iagram w ith
out sacri ficing clarity. Someti me s ide n tities are best
show n w ith a more te n tative q uali ty using d ott ed and
irr egular lines. Later chap ter s further explain this less
d efinite need .
0 .6 <)
x*
t::::l
t{}~~
0 (De $ 0
EJ ill a ill 12I ~
0 () .. S f4i8
a (J~~ t1i8
t:::::::I
II
aD
D liD
c::::l t:::::J
t::::1 c::J
t:::::1
co
t1
-
- =-
a 00
,- - -.
000
(
\
v .; ,/
.
.
. .
'
000
000
Figure 4-7 Graphic grammar conventions.
Vocabulary
59
- - - - -- - - - -- - - ---0'
-j ~-) ~~
-t>-.++
D)D}D_
LI>r>D={>
t::::lc::lt==1r:=:Jt::::Jt==1t:=l ~
..
J:::Ic::::It=lc::lllI=Is::::IJ:::Iw=I
---~--
~~
...
00000000000000000000
IUlllllllllllll1 l1 llllll11IlIl\lllllllllllllllIIlIIlIlIHlllllIllllllIlIl
e@~
II11III1IIIII11111111111111
Figure 4-8
Relationshi ps
As w ith ide ntities, di ffe ren t rel ation sh ip s a re best
represent ed by se ts of lin e types. The se line typ es can
also be used as borders for gr oup in g id entities as a
m ean s of seg me nting a diagra m or of sh ow ing special
re lat ionship s.
The arr ow is a very sp ecial device for ind icating
re lation sh ip s. As a sy m bo l of m ovem en t, Arn heim
hold s th at it has co m pellin g qu alities: //...any mo ve
me nt in the env ironment autom ati call y att rac ts at ten
tion because mov em en t m eans cha nge of cond itions,
wh ich may call for a rea ct ion. :" Arrows com bin ed
wi th lines ca n in di ca te a one-way rela tio ns h ip , a
sequence of even ts, or a process. Separate ar rows can
be used to mark im po rta nt par ts of a d iagram or to
show dependenci es and th e fee d-in of suppleme n tar y
informa tion .
Modifiers
Identi ties and rel ationsh ips ar e mod ified according to
a hi erar chical sy ste m . In th is man ner, th e signifi
cance of part s and the d ifferent levels of intensity in
the relati on ship between parts ar e exp ressed .
Hi erarc hy ca n be s how n by d iffe ren t line w id th s,
mu lti pl e lines , or the re lat ive size of das hes a nd
sp ace s in dash ed lin es (Figure 4-9a) . G rad ed tone s
an d the acc umulation of parts are also usefu l de vices
(Figur e 4-9b).
Mo d ifier s ca n also crea te em p hasis, pr inci pa lly
through contras t in term s of size, ton e, con to u r, or
detail. Em phasis is used to signa l a spe cia l ide n tity or
relationship , segreg ate interw oven diagrams, or indi
cate sp ecial point s or steps in a p roc ess (Figur e 4-9c).
60
A bstraction
@)
.0
......
:....i
"
\..j
.....0., .. Q: ....._..0'9
..
'. ~ ' ,
'
.
-,
....
D~
-
-
-
eq()~ I -to
Ident lcall.!:)
e.qualto
~ equcl! 10
~
proporfl oM I
to
>
<
-
lG1 rg er-+h~ n
lar.0er t h ~n
.?h'\a lIer
e:.
A..
or etjLJal f o
thaYl
orE:ijual f o
corre6f'ond0
to
plus-or-mlY1US
or
}ouaooHIE
-3IE
~
-r'
-r'"
""'
~~
06)
theretor-e
I- \- r I- f-
""
pluG
'--/
/'"'0..
L-I
+
c1Y1 d so 0 1'1
H- H- t- H -1- H - H - H-+
Xl
,
[
I I I
I I I
I 1 i
ti/41
WI
///////////////
-D- --c:J- -1
f-0- -CJ- -{
l-0- -C)---c=J-
___ -0
>- -c
-CJ-D DD O 0
Figu re 4-12b Process symbols.
Vocabulary
61
-I
-q-0=0=9
/11
,W
>
>
>
-I
\
II
III
J
II
-- \ \1
=1
\ I
J
\
0---H-- ~Tt-
,Sf
,~I
,
,W
G-
-f- ---41r.-
'). .
~cJCP
>
t-
11-
\\1
\\\lll~lll~
- - - - - - - - - -
---0
---0
0
0
-0
0"'-'"
It
-,0
)))))))))))))))))))))))J))))J)))))))))~
)(
A-
>~~
.iY"ff./"ff.L1.J5ffL1ffSL7fft'~
62
Abstraction
11II1l\1I\I(I"
111111\1"'''1\
II 11111111111\
':I/.YlLYI!..
)f'L ~ YL
~~~
:il.3L~
~
~
~
./\A.A,.A.AIv
[!J
~
00
a
a
xx )(J<X
XXXM
xxx;xx
xxxxx
I\I\I\M
IV\I\IV\
J\IVV'V\
@
@
o6co~'
rzIlZI@6 ~
;zfJ=(JA:
(@<DCDO
T ,< ~ ~
@~0.
~~e
tI~~, 1/~
-- - ---
00<DE9@(f)
ill ~ D {gJ
fZl~ E8 ~
B[;] m~
. ~
f'VtPit
AhlJ.~A
0
A
A 0
....
o,
8: 0
00
- .. -0
+
lIno~~
.......
c c
+++...+:tt :t'
+.t.T+ + + +'+
/\I\I\AI\
~
11\~111l=
:>1Jll~
Figure 4-14
lVIa lill=
=\11\::00
++
++
tIt.
V
&
~
~~lt
\>
*~
....
Vocabulary
63
QO DCJ O
.... OftO
OQCltl
"_ OQ
C'::J
QQO
00
t=
00
o C1 a Q
rJO
~
o
~ ~Ld, ? ~<:
~~~ Ia~t~
4i1ra.?-tN0, ~t ~
~ '-:b 6~~ .
3. Glamorizing an idea .
64
Abstraction
~~~
Figure 4-19 Circulation choices, Place des Vosges, Paris.
~~~
~~J~
~~~~
Vocabulary
65
1~4 T;}(;4 ~- ,
~ '-l,
I' r -= _ 'I
~ r _~_
~~-T(JlW, 1~~"-
~!f~,~
-J I
~,
l'
~>
'
,~
'\:.
1. -l'
--,.;' ~-.;;
'
:'1:,:' -,.~~ . - .
~ - , . ~ -.
,.
".. _.
-"
~ (
",,'
'
Figure 5-1 (top) By Lo uis Kahn. Concept sketch for central Philadelphia.
Figure 5-2 (bottom) By David Stieglitz . Buffalo Waterfront Redevelopment Proje ct.
Expression
IDENTITY
The draw ings on these firs t two pages are sig nifi can t
for the ir stro n g se nse of ident ity, a presence that says
they are importa n t a nd we ought to take time to look
a t the m mor e closely. How does the way th e ske tc hes
w e re drawn account for th is qual ity? Both th e sty le
and th e hig h contr as t ar e impor ta n t , bu t the flui dity
of th e sket ch es tell s us abou t the int ensi ty a nd confi
d en ce of th e a rc h itec t. We can alm ost see or feel the
a rc h itect 's hand mov ing over th e pap er.
CONSISTENCY
Disc ip line in draw ing is some times ass oc ia te d w it h
stiff or Spa rta n-looking drawings. Bu t , as you ca n see ,
qua li ty need n ot limit expressi on . T hese drawings
hav e their in te rn al co nsiste nc y in common . It mi ght
be com pa re d to th e diffe re nc es in ca r d esigns. Th e
Porsch e an d the Roll s Royce a re im med ia tely recog
n ized as two ve ry d iffer e nt ca rs, but bot h have a n
exp ression of high qua lity an d cra fts ma nsh ip. G ive n
th e bas ic co nc ep t of eac h ca r, th e d esi gner s ha ve
give n every pa r t of the car a feeling tha t it belong s to
th a t, a nd only that , ca r.
67
?'k
~~~
~'
-r ,~
~
,
\..- ' -
17"-1
l
'
~"
tIt
all!:~
~/r::!C)
.)
~ '-
, 1
~~
1
\
,I
),---i
\; ~
<,
f,
-Q
r'~ld
~.
.,
, ;.,.
,.
', .
STYLE AN D SELECTIVITY
68
Expression
.. ,.
69
..
. . ,
.
..... . . .
.,
-'
..
70
Expression
Wff4i
a~'4"
JM:fli,
71
UO .lSSeJ.l d x g
'lL
c:;=--..
' ,lJ u a p ~s a ~
s"[-s al n5lj
I
I
,I,
,,
. ..
, -
'-~
.
. , - ,
--:-'h*.' ,
.
";/
--
73
-----.
~-,
_-=:/
ECONOMY
As in verba l co m m u n ica tion, w e apprec ia te so meone
wh o can find j us t th e r ig h t m ea n s to conv ey th e
esse nce of a n ex perie n ce . T he sk e tch es on th ese
p ages a re by a rc h itec tura l stu de n ts wh o we re so
in sp ired by w ha t they e n co un te re d on their field tr ip s
th at th ey sp e n t m u ch tim e d rawi ng a n d develop in g
a n edu ca ted eye .
- .i
/ :' 1~/
Ll
~ ~/7 ~
Figure 5-21 By Lisa Ko lber. Byzantine church, Myst ra,
Greece.Fi gure 5-21 By Patrick D. Na ll. Ahmed Ibn To ulon Mosque,
Cairo.
74
Exp ression
,.
ra .. "
tr l ,
t ,
s;:
..
;,re.
Economy
75
"
76
Expression
AESTHETIC ORDER
Both in build ing d esign a nd in draw ings, most of us
ar e se nsit ive to th e role of compositio n in ach iev ing a
se nse of u n ity or sy n thesis. U n ity in e nv iro nmen ts is
also ach ieve d th ro ugh aesthe tic or d er , ch a rac te risti c
s ha pes, p a tt erns, or d et ai ls sh ared by th e e lem e n ts
tha t cons ti tu te th ese e nv iron me n ts. Th rou gh ske tch
ing we can deve lop an awaren ess o f aesth e tic order
tha t ca r ri es ove r to o ur draw ings, e ndowing t he m
w ith a sim ila r se nse of orde r.
77
APPLIED SKILLS
--. .. -_...
I:
I:
:1
:I
I:
I:
I - ~
:1 )1
:..::..: :.=:..:
:I
fIi~~
II
/f\.
'\.
./
-;7
<,
'-----._
.: :. ~
- -
V
--
6 Analysis
cco rd in g to Go rd on Best , th e an al ys is of
design p rob lems is fu n d a m e n ta l to d esign
p rocess. "Practica l d esign probl ems are va r i
ab le and idiosyncrat ic. Th ey ge ne ra te a vari
e ty so great t hat it is n early im p ossibl e to describe
suc h prob lems le t alone und e rstand th em . Despi te
th is, practicing design er s must in terpret th ese prob
lems if they ar e going to d eal with th em. ": Ar chitects
must simplify problems, reduce th em to th ei r esse n
tial elements. This is the process of abstraction , th e
exposure of the underly ing structure or pattern of a
whole system. As w e w ill see, gr ap h ic co m m u n ica
tion is w ell su ited to th e ta s k of abs tracti on . T h e
simu ltaneous view of th e ab stract ske tc hes keep s the
whole structure of a syst em up fro n t.
81
f V1 .:') W\ e
~I
82
Analysis
Figure 6-4 Perspective of ent ry to Sunyats alo City Cente r, Alvar Aalt o, architect.
83
[ ve4J
.N\
;':c
f'.
~
~~
~'\
8
~
80 @8
B
~eV\ 16ev'Vld"\J
-I
!- IVw.::l
~h
84
A nalysis
- -_. - -
85
86
Analysis
V'Sfahb
A. J
b~ rr tJ"l%i'1
~~ -PoY~
Figure 6-7c Misfit between need and form.
87
{3r~ k dowV1
o-fA Y1.a ~ ~
[lifE} Elr:t
III
o iii o
I
(a)
6k'MW1tWy
o-f Av t"-s ~
(b)
eJElElffi
OWVl ev-
I
I
{/ea0
~+- ~u5l
NEED
The build ing progra m or brief usu ally contains m ost
of the in formation ab out th e clie nt's needs . Pro grams
for the aver age-size proje ct , suc h as an educational or
in stitu tional building , can be quite co m p lex.
Alt hough th e program for our exampl e, a four-bed
room recreat ional re sid ence , is not ve ry comp lex , it
should ser ve to illustrate the basic typ es of d iagra m s
th at could be us ed to descri be fun ction al n eeds.
The fir st step is to get a good grasp of th e qu an tifi
able as pe cts of the p rogram . Using sq ua re s to show
th e area requ ir ement s fo r d iff er en t fu nction s, th e
88
Analysis
~1-r~
~ rt-~eV1
-------'1--4
~__1------4
~Y17D (tV\ 8
redt
Gv~ ~
~~ ~
~13t{,~
Relationships
Th e b u bb le di agr am has be com e a fami liar tool to
architec tur al designers. It ca n a bs trac t th e b uildi ng
prog ra m to convenie n tly summarize the ac tivi ties to
be housed and their required relation sh ips. As w e
saw in Chap te r 5, bubble dia gr ams are also eas y to
manipulate as th e designer m oves from build in g pro
gram to building design . As lon g as th e basic rules of
th e gr aph ic language are foll ow ed , th ese d iag ra ms
pe rm it wide flexibility of thinkin g.
An other type of relationship di agr am is th e
m atrix. All th e functions are listed alon g tw o perpen
d icu lar axes a nd then th e relat ion sh ip of eac h fun c
j on to the other functions is cate gorized . The advan
89
10
~
r%
{2~
KrrcH~N
11
II
l-tVING~M
VEc{(
B~f<OOM
-.
f;A1H
~
~
~~
ourDoor<s
cP
~ W2
~~
~
~
J:;
~~
~~
/f'
I
)flJJ-L-('-L9 --t~ ~
---I
l
rt>:
/
.-L -<"""'--/,-/,;;,-./--7 ~dUl
\
v'~<.
,
'
C
...-""
~__
,J
~ttwtJ(l)
'-~
(
'J/VleW?
-:">
i:>
<----..wI
l ~ M-
Physical Behavior
Alt h oug h w e mi ght assu m e that mo st p eopl e use
hous es in p ret ty m uc h the same way (judgi n g from
new h ous ing de velop m en t d esign ), there a re di ffer
en ces. Th ese di fferen ces ca n have a lot to d o with th e
co m fort of a family in a pa r ticu la r house. One w ay to
illustrat e the use of a h ouse is to m ake a log of spa ces
occup ied by d iffer e n t fa m ily m embers d uri ng a typ i
cal d ay. T he res ult s may be su rp r ising a n d may
en courage the clien t to look a t h ousin g in a n ew way.
T here may al so be imp licat ions for de sign pr ior ities,
orie nta tion of spaces , a nd e nergy m anagement.
90
Analysis
-.\\
~
~
s:::
\.U.
s;
ii
~
Y
;::.
-=:1
C)
.:J
.s
\0
~ ~ ~
C3
WW1.q,rt
0Ld~ t+
C~cAu
Maltl1m~
f lJ\ er~~
f rex(btl t1:J
Figure 6-15a Matrix diagram of relationships betwee n design issues and spaces.
Design Priorities
To ma ke a successful hou se, an arch itect m us t help
th e cl ien t choose h is p riori ties , as h is de sires ofte n
exc eed w ha t is fin a nci all y p ossible. Bu t p riorities
remain a va gue notio n for mo st pe opl e un til they see
a spe cific bu ild ing d esi gn with a price tag. The n
come s th e prun ing and p ush ing and p ulling , end ing
wi th a des ign that loo ks as if it has been th rou gh a
str eet fight. A m atri x diagr am clarifies p ri orit ies so
the client can better un d ersta nd them before pro
ceeding to buildi n g-for m altern a tives. T he ma trix
starts w ith a list of d esig n issu es an d a list of fu nc
tions. At ea ch p oin t of relationship in the m atrix, w e
as k th e importance of thi s issue to this function . The
d egree of impor tance is ind icated by the size of th e
d ot. W hen th is process ha s been comple ted for each
issu e, the m ost imp ortant issues and functions (those
with the highes t cu m ulat ive deg rees of impor ta nce)
can be identified and a hier archical list of iss ues and
fu nctions for med. W he n th e mat rix is rec on stru cted
with issues a nd sp aces a r ra nge d in t hei r ord er of
impor tan ce, it is possible to ma ke so m e ob servat ions
ab out cr itica l areas of the d esign p rob lem .
N eed
91
Design Objectives
Analysis of a design problem requires the explorat ion
of th e broad se t of issues, con tex ts, an d con cerns. To
initiate thin king abo ut the pro blem , we can ada pt a
te chn ique used in cr eati ve writing that builds a net
work of ve r bal as socia tion s. To brin g th e subcon
scious m ind in to action , the stan dard tabulated lists
are replaced by a loose, open-ended method of nota
ti on that le ts ideas develop in an organ ic p at tern
mu ch like the roots of a tr ee. As a comp lex netw ork
of ass ociations develops, we can begin to iden ti fy th e
mo st imp ort ant issues and re lationsh ips.
92
A nalys is
00
0
dlr. Darn,G
o
0000
~O 0 0
OUe
N eed
93
CONTEXT
Site Selection
94
Analysis
Wtrtfer
Fall
OD
RtM
V'ttjS
5~
t7~7 -----"""'"'~--
95
?:01J6S
PA-1110/
BNTR, 5
. ..
NOD ~ ~/
LANDM M-~ S
Activity Patterns
W h en inserting a new s tr uc ture within an exi sting
en viron m en tal con text, s uch as a college campus,
curr ent patte rns of pedestrian ac tivity sho uld be an
im p ort an t con sid era tion . T he upperm ost diagram
above tr aces the dom ina nt patterns of pedestrian
mo vement and reflects to so m e exten t their relative
96
Analysis
f1tEL.IMINARY DE5tG-N
PeSlG-}o{
~El.Of1>\ff1T
WO(~"'G
DFAWINtSS
11_~I D
I[
n 'STEE L]I~
tar ";+ttl
L--_ Il_
ISTee.L
I'"-
-J.
kTh1(~utd J
l~ l lt;~l l~ I
~~l ~~Il~r~
Construction Processes
Arc hitects may overl ook at tim es th e im pac t of th e
cons truc tion p ro cess as a co n text for the de sign solu
tion . Construction m etho d is recogni zed as a strong
determinan t of for m in vern acula r arc hitect ur e, a nd
it is s till in fl ue nt ia l in con te mp ora ry architectura l
des ign . With the pr essur es of fin a nc ing and the varia
tions in th e cost of bor row ing fu nd s, in novations in
con str uct ion processes a re co n tinua lly e mergi ng.
When th ese p roce sses a re includ ed in th e set of
deter m in an ts of fo rm, th e d esigne r enhances th e
p ro ba bi lity o f d eve lopin g a s ucc ess fu l d es ign .
Abstra ct rep resent a tion of the a ltern a tive constr uc
tio n processes, a s wi th ot her d es ign d e te r m in an ts,
promotes the d esign er 's intuitive acce ss to these con
siderations .
_~d~ ~~ __ J
AreA
J f.0~II?(e
MJuitMt4"
Context
97
\~
.~
\
.6
lit::
-ro?oGRAf~Y
Fi gure 6-27b
98
Analysis
Figure 6- 27c
Figure 6-28 a
Figure 6- 28b
Figure 6- 27d
Figure 6- 28c
Contex t
99
L[ ~ ked f'oxetS
GYOVvea 13oxe?
Bv-f+ev Wo.l(
--
0fft/~ lI/t.g
EJeVldtJ
'B6Xt'&
W~1I 6
FORM
The third set of variables, form, is under the control
of the designe r. In th is area h e can help the clien t
m ake decisions after the need and context variables
hav e been ide ntified . But rem ember tha t th e soluti on
to th e d esign p rob lem ' is bas ically an ag reem en t
betw een need, context, and form . In a sense, all th ree
se ts of variab les are flexib le un til a fit is ac h iev ed .
Some designers expe ct th e client's progra m and the
context alone to d ict a te the so lu ti on , but for m is
eq ua lly im porta n t be ca use th ere a re a n umber of
viable forms th at m eet specific needs. The arc hitect
m ust be as fam iliar w ith form variables as w ith th ose
of need or context. The abstract sketches that follow
are used to bui ld a visua l memory of form variables.
.....
On~- W())j
&IC!
Space/Order
Variations of the spa tial or ga niza tion of a hou se ar e
n um erous. A few examp les ar e sh ow n here in plan
diagrams using a sim ilar d rawing style to facilitate an
easy comparison . The w all s ar e d raw n w ith h eavy
lines so the d iagrams can em phas ize space by clearly
defining solid and void . Furth ermore, titles are give n
to each organ izational ty pe as an importan t aid for
eas y recall.
100
A nalysis
Two--Wa3
Q r~d
lrfj~~== J
Q O'Gt4
Box
Form
101
Scale/Proportion
tf~ ~le
~ ' t va rch:l
ot ~Ut le~
?t'lfOr1LoV1 ~G6
102
Analysis
I
Figure 6-34 Traditional brick const ruction.
I,
Mass/BaLance
Anyone w ho has taken up joggin g is w ell aware of th e
im po r tan ce of mass a nd balan ce in hu m an experi
en ce. We all have a built-in se nse of thes e q uali ties,
cau sing us to r espond to t hem in bu ild ings.
Furtherm ore, m ass and balanc e are associa ted w ith
m any ot her feelings, such as sec ur ity and flexibili ty.
In a bu ild ing, a sense of ma ss can convey sec uri ty or
perman ence; a sen se of air iness can convey flexib ility
or fr eedom . Th roughout arc hitec tural history, many
met hods have been di scovered for varying the appar
en t m ass of build ings. By anal yzi ng b uild ings th at
hav e clear sensations of m ass, the use of su ch formal
devices as hor izonta lity, verticality, and em phasis ca n
be uncov ered .
Walking is a tremendous feat of ba la nce . M uch of
the enjoyment of w alking, rid ing a bike , skiing, and
th e like is derived fr om the ten sion betw een stability
and instability. We have a fin ely tuned sense of bal
ance that carries over into our visual pe rcep tion. The
d iffe ren t w ays of ar ticu latin g balan ce in b uild in g
design ca n be also h ighlighted t hrough abstract
ske tches. The sketc hes shown he re deal w it h sy m
m etrica l and asym me tr ica l ba lance in com po sit ion
and three-dim ensiona l ba lance, an im por tant part of
ar chite cture.
Form
103
mmillm
Repetition/ Rhythm
One way of ac hieving unity in a build ing is throu gh
re pe tit ion of parts that are alike, suc h as w indow s or
column s. Simi larity of objects, even if on ly pa rtially
sim ilar, is a w ay of emp h a siz in g associa ti on .
Me m be rs of th e h um an race are recogn ized by a
numb er of sim ilar featu res in spite of th e gre at d iver
sity in their ind ividual appearance .
The importanc e of rhy th m in architecture is ba se d
upon its relationship to the h u man rhyth ms, w a lking
or bre athing, and the natur al rhythm s, the tide or the
sea so ns. Just as music pres en ts au d io rhyth m s, archi
tectur e displays visua l rhy thms In ar chitecture, th e
pr in cipa l m ean s of ach iev in g r hy th m is spacin g of
p ar ts; this is co m p arable to the in tervals bet w ee n
beats or notes. The chara cter of visu al rh ythms in a
bui lding dep ends on th e size of both the interv als and
th e parts. Two basic typ es of rh ythm can be identi
fied . Staccato rhythm is form ed by clear d istinction
between in terva ls and parts , such as mu llions on a
curtain wa ll. Legato rh ythm is softer, formed by mo re
su btle tra nsition s betw een inter val s and parts, as in
th e curvilinea r ar ch itec ture of Gaudi . There ar e also
rhyt hms d isting uishab le by p attern s of in te rva l or
part sizes, as in a facad e by Pallad ia . And ther e are
accelerat ing or decel era tin g rh yt hm s, as in the
Wolfsbe rg Ce nter by Aalto.
104
A nalysis
l[~ ~ti ~~
! ~fJ ~ l~~
~ ~ -- -----------------\(
~I
r; II
__
/'' ,l-'11
--i
.
. 1'; L~ igg~ UU L
-HJ.:..j ~ ' " ;' '\ a
1 Ir --~
r-------I m-1 ~ H rTTTr."n; r:f ,:, "I II fI
LC --fj
-
Figure 6-41 Boston City Hall.
_ .III
Unity/Diversity
The d egree of unity or d iversi ty exp ressed in a b u ild
ing con st itutes ano ther class of form variables. The
"other varia bles (scale, p ropor tion , m ass, ba lance, rep
et iti on , or rhy thm ) can be used to ach ieve unity or
diversity. Som e of the w ay s of increasi n g u n ity
incl ud e fr am ing or em p has izin g a bo rd er; using a
contin uous pattern , mod ula r grid , or a sing le shape,
w hich is at the sa m e scale as the bu ilding; and mai n
tain ing ind ep en de nce be tw ee n th e parts and t he
whole.
Div ersity can be ac hieved by p la nned violat ion of
the rules of unity: avoid ing fram ing or cons iste n t pat
tern ; va ry ing r h y th m s or mo d u les ; u sin g mult iple
grids ; and breaking up the domina ti ng geom etry.
Figure 6-43 Ohio Town Hall project , Vent uri and Ra uch.
Form
105
~ ~S)~
!) P
1-
c:Jt::::J
I~
[G
~ [1Jl ~ [1J]
2J
-$
"t:::I
=J
..
c==J
Fig ure 6-47 Mt. Angel Library, Alva Aalto, archite ct.
Hierarchy
Con cep tual strength and clarity often play a n impor
tan t ro le in the experie nce and use of a b uild ing. A
sens e of hierarchy can co n tr ib ute m uch to th e con
cept ua l presence of ar chit ecture. W hether as analysis
o f ex is ting b uildi ngs or as sp ecula tio n a bou t an
eme rgin g design , int ent ions can be highligh ted by the
106
A nalysis
Fi gure 6-50
SOURCES OF SOLUTIONS
As w as poin ted out before, th e origin of a d esign solu
tion may be foun d in a nyone of the three typ es of
var ia bles : n eed , co n te xt , or fo rm. O n the following
page s are ca se studies based on th e recreat ional
house examp le. In ea ch study, an a bs trac t diagr am of
one of the va ria bles is used as the source of a basic
organ izing id ea for th e hou se ; th en con strain ts or
con siderat ion s from the other types of varia bles are
107
I S-g
8 0 1
aJnfi ~j
~~f7Y
No. 12.
e~~s()Y"( V6 ~re
Figure 6-52
So urces of Solutions
109
S.ISr\[ rJUV
0 11
Figure 6-54
11 1
.(
)...
S ISr\ID U V
Z II
C; C; - g aj n 5 ~:J
J...
113
l:-L aJnfi~.:l
7 Exploration
r:;LABoRNnON
Figure 7- 2
115
r-
WfJ
&~ It
Ivt\!(k- f""~
,r '/ '
f , -,
, '; ,.:>'"
/,1 .
~~
:</
~--
~ .. .
~) <
r ','
. \ ".;' .
< .
. ........
Cjj
"
-rrttN1~a veV\ C3
\\
~1<Ll.
\VlftyfYCIlfllOh
Figu re 7-4b
( 1 7~""" \fiT -( r
I i ,
- l);
';:, ;
.;,.,
~ i l ''''''~
J:~~"-~~~YllT:l
.
l-~'~~~~
I'
,....
I:
,\
,'.
~I
,j
)'
I ,(
,r':
,J!" '
I
-Cb
ClJ
..
,,,
~V0je~+" lN\
Figure 7-4c
OPEN-ENDED IMAGES
Terms like amb iguous, collage, and m ulti va lent have
be en used to descr ibe wo rk s of art and archite ct ur e
that can be "read," in terpreted , or appreciated simul
tan eo usly on sev eral lev els. These works a re ofte n
sai d to have severa l meani ngs. Design sketches ofte n
ha ve sim ilar q ua lit ies of a m big u ity, allow ing the
design er to thin k flexibly and in gene ral terms. I refer
to thi s as op en -ended . Open -ended ness can be
ac hi eved wit h transparen cy. Thi s ap proach is based
on the trad ition of show in g dept h location by over
lapping. Mod ern ar t introduced m ut ua l overlapping:
prod ucing a tran sparent effec t tha t a llow s tw o or
m or e figures to occupy th e sam e p lace. In co nce pt,
developing a tr ansparency allow s the designer to sus
pend decision s abo ut th e exac t loca tion of spaces or
th e boundaries betw een spaces .
116
Exploration
.~
.'
~}
t--==--==- . . . ~ -----
Open-Ended Images
117
~Q r;] ~
uliJGl ~
C\-vIiA Wl ed~(
lC'~[03 I~r
II
1<'evev6al
o
t7 t~t'r-+tOtl
TRANSFORMATIONS
The p urpose of ope n -ended images is to invite
ch anges in the images. Transfor mations , however, are
specific ch an ges made in t he grap h ic im ages . Th e
possib ilities for change in graph ic im ages are practi
cally un lim ited , bu t we w ill look at a few basic types
of tran sform ation . They are topologi ca l con tinuity,
orname n tal gramma1; revers als, and distortion.
Graphic transforma tions ca n be very hel p fu l to
creativity in desig n . The stages of crea tiv ity have
bee n described by Hele n Rowan as "Prep a ration ,
In cu ba tio n , Ill u m ina tion , and Veri fica tion .... th e
period of in cubation fr ees the ind ivid ual fr om previ
ous fixations, he is then able to see the problem with
new eye s whe n he re turn s to it. " 3 Tra ns formations are
aim ed at changing perspective or p erceptions, m ak
ing the fa miliar se em strange. It is im po rta n t to
remember that a peri od of p re para tion m us t p recede
in cuba tion . The de signer prep ares by be comin g
im m ersed in th e p roblem , tr yin g to u nd erst a nd a ll
the var iables of need , contex t, and for m . O nce the
problem becom es imbedded in his m in d , he attempts
to overcom e preconceptions about the p oss ible solu
tions by changi ng the existing grap hic im ages.
Topological Continuity
In m at hem atics, the term topology is defined as "th e
stu dy of th ose p r ope rtie s of geom etr ic figures th a t
11 8
Explora tion
Figure 7-10 Topological analysis of t hree houses designed by Frank Lloyd Wright.
Transformations
119
~uDDQDD~uuuuQ
II [
DDDDDDDDDDDD[Du~uuQu~QuD
J . T /U NS/.AT/ON
2 . ROTATION
Gourna The"' .
Owenjones, PI. VII. o. 4.
non
tern a t Pompeii.
Ou-'enjo n(J, PI. x xv
4. IN VERSION
5OD~OuDDDDDUDDOd
,-'m
I
d-f~
5 . String course
Ollt ,.
Po na tb ena i c
rht
Fri ez e,
Partbenon , A /Mm .
OU'V1 j 01U1,
PI. xx u, no. /8
DeP[J~DDDDDDDD9=J
6 . SliPI'd R,j/t et;on,
bTIITDooo o
'~
QWW\J\A
~ Ou..m j
kiY
ono . PI.
Ahrmat ion
[3
I laJt .
7. A ccderanon
Egyp" an
VI II ,
0'
no. 17.
o o
8 . Dtet/frorion
DDOCiill1
Ii
n
iliE
I
S,.",.dwjeh islands
Ornamental Grammar
Thomas Bee by, in h is art icle "Th e Gr amm ar of
Ornamen t/O rnam ent as Gram ma r," clearly illustrates
th e app licatio n of ornamental grammar to building
m as sing and design at many sca les by the m aster
a rch itec ts of the m odern m ovement. Spe cifically in
th e w ork of LeCor busi er, he show s th e impact of th e
trad itional tra ining in orna m entation principles. A
d irect me ans of achievin g a rich comp lexity in bu ild
ing forms is revealed. "LeCorbusiers early tr ain ing in
orn am en t pla ced a valuable method of working
with in his grasp. The principles found in Owen Jones
120
Explora tion
.----
r--------
fly
--
I" "9
====
=So
p
f:.
rI
I
l-
, 1
'
f.=. ~
v.-=
- , 11\
~ ~'
<,
~ ,
...
:~
:I
' :;;:;;;0;
T "
TT
SisI=
1\
\I
l ~~ 1
d 1 <,
_ '
'"""'=
<,
~l
r 1-
......
ff
.=-.
":L.
I~
\I \ I
.:
the unit merely slides along the surface of the pla ne,
in a straight line or a circle, but in both reflect ion
an d inve rsion the unit is flipped over in spac e to
presen t its under side. W ith refle ction (illustra tio n 3),
the unit is flipp ed over on one of its edges, producing
bilateral, or m irror, symmetry. W ith inve rsion (illus
trat ion 4), the un it is flipp ed over its centra l horizon
tal axis . More complex configuratio ns are derived
from a combination of these fou r basic operations.
Translation accompanied by reflection is probably
the most famili ar. Transla tion acc ompanied by reflec
tive invers ion is another typ ical opera tion (illustra
tion 5). Th e complexity increases through devices
suc h as shifts along the horizontal axis, or glid e line,
leav ing gaps between uni ts, to produce slipped reflec
tion or alterna tion (illustra tion 6}.. . . A lso, by accel
erating (illus tration 7) or decele rating (illustratio n 8),
the rhythm through decrea sing or increasing eith er
the size of the units or the distance between them,
one can tra nsform sca le,'
0 0 cJ
I
R1iu t;(}If
RtJ*aiw
1m-mUm
S"fJ'J RljI",;",
%
\3
.
'
RoI4IiMI
I mm it'J"
Um t
X
1'"'"';0"
Rt~etir~ lrnrrsifm
Rotarioff
Transformations
121
UOljvJ.o/dxg
ZZ I
~_-===t=-_
~ Dd lIT o
Tran sformations
123
r~W ld lJ tl l
[)r-~es
Wall
f ..IUI iJ
o~~s
,~'I.DlL
,~
fV\ crvtet'ttt I
JOLVI+S
Figure 7- 15
Reversals
Reve rsals are cha nges in an ima ge fr om its fir st char
act eristics to op posite cha ract eristics [ligh t to dark ,
object to space, open to closed , etc.). Th eir us efuln ess
derives fr om th e qualities of the contra sting comple
m ent. Th e Chi nese philosophe r Lao-Tzu held tha t th e
essen ce of everything we could see lies in what we
can not see; the esse nce of m an is not in his physical
appearance, and th e ess enc e of arch itecture is not in
the visible str ucture. The Taoist sym bol yin and ya ng
re p rese nts th e absenc e of ord er, chaos, as a bl ack
backgrou nd ; the tw o r evo lv ing for ms are yin and
yang, th e con trast in g com plemen ts th at m a ke up
or d er, n igh t a nd day, a m u si cal n ot e and a pau se,
active and passive. Th e ide al condition , pe rfec tion , is
symbolized as a dynami c balance between op posites:
gro ups of people are defined by ind ivid uals and indi
vid uals are defined by groups; th e color of an orange
change s in intensity w ith the changing background .
124
Exp lorati on
-_
._ _.....y)
n -ans(ormat ions
125
<:
?~tdDW\~~-t c>r-le;~~
of ~~ th u~e
Op~ V t lM.;
C6 Kt-~ ll ed
Vi ew
2;!]
~V\UkPul"e
Bj [
A1t-~0" .], h v~~
Co IlMV\ 'W'
h f osed C6(UW\Y\
tva[[
126
Exploration
Transformations
127
1
~
,
--
,...
r--
.
J
"
_ oJ
(b)
Not'"rvYlt\ GYtd
(c)
tlkror--hoh
Distortion
The Du tch ar tis t M . C. Escher create d a wonderful
wo rld of fa n ta sy throu gh op tic al illusions based on
th e rep resen tational syste ms of th e Renaissance. He
ach iev ed di st ort ions th at dramat ica lly alter our view
of re ality through simple man ip ulat ion of these rep
resent ationa l systems, as in th e lit hograph Ba lcon y.
By w ay of an exaggeration of the projection m ethod
used for maps of the w orld , he imposes a simple grid
over th e co nventional drawin g and th en doubles the
size of the cen tral sec tion; th us the di storted gri d is
used as a referen ce sys te m to comp lete the dr aw ing .
The gr id-man ipu la tion m ethod can be used as a
simp le way of di storting oth er typ es of im ages. For
our p urpose , the gr ids should be kept quite simple to
rem ain in a sketc h sty le. Th e exa m ples of th e bubble
dia gra m on this page and the building pl an on th e fac
ing pag e sh ow just a few of th e possibilities for gr id
d istor tion. Simple magnificati on or red uction of the
scale of an image can produce a distorte d effect. In
addition , a n umber of special projec tion tech niq ues ,
su ch as 360 -degree view s, ar e poten tia l tools for d is
to rtion ske tches.
(a)
(b)
NOV'Yv\a1 Gv1d
DI~+Oy-ho \i)
12 8
Exploration
DO
DO
DO
0 0
DO
cJO
Figure 7-22 Variations on distortion.
I
_-r--;,._~~",;,-",;,-'
\-- --I
1- _
Transformations
129
f-
~u
'lIl
I I I I I I I II
V\{l~ crt
G-rfh age
t?oqut
flam') ~ Gr~
II
130
Ex plora tion
Bl-noda/
- -JO Dt-J
r=uC?
DUIXI Axes
DO
000 ODD
"6 f li'l I S "
Figure 7-29 Basic ordering devices.
13 1
(I
z;
[><vr-,
\'i.
[X
~
II
I
I
\ 1/
1/
)~
All
-.
UO.1J DIOZdxg
Z I
,..,.
~
c:9
DO
Matrix
B ~
~EJ
-+
--+ --+
-+-
-t
D~
D~
8 -+-
~-
-+. 8
[j-: [l:
-+- ".
fJ
8--1
" b:.
0-+
00
DO
u:
~ [t:
G"
--- B
Of},.
-+~
--+
++ -tEJ GO
~ _G.
0 --
+-+
=
=
133
~~ ..
#'
1 ~~<
~
-
'.
.~-~. -
..
~
~~
u(/
,
I
....
1. \..
I I ' :,
'L
"
"1 r
'\ ~ ~
'
-.
~ ~-
_~
Ir~._.
. ~
.
_
"..
~ .. ..
,"r "'
U " ..
- .~ .
-.oe. ...
Or
A Pyramid of Possibilities
It is my hope that , as you begin to exp er iment w ith
134
Exploration
?'"h~ '
.I rf~'f
l !~11\l
,
t
Mu ltiply
Subdue
Transpose
Delay
Flatten
Su bm erge
Weigh
Flu ff-up
Subtract
Th icken
Relate
Protect
Symbolize
Divi de
Invert
Un ify
Distor t
Sq ueeze
Freeze
Destroy
Bypa ss
Lighten
Str etch
Extr ude
Segr egate
Abs tract
Eliminate
Separa te
Search
Rot ate
Compleme nt
Soften
Concentrate
Add
Repeat
Adap t
Repel
Integra te
Dissec t
135
~.
T7lM.P6
1I0.1JV.LO/dx:g
9 I
@[jJ a ~
~
[J .
0 0 ~
DD ~
D~
0
~~~==>ik---,
'-:11-=
--
Figure 7- 36
137
llOIJD.i.ZdXH
8 I
. .ct Q
/ e,~Jr1(V}..-I
Figure 7- 38
139
Discovery
Fi gure 8- 2
141
/'
,/
II.
(~
rnU(ffimfUaW
'WIT
+t-t\ Vl'U'v1 {(
/
~(LI ;;I(CI
Crlcr
c l
I t
fl
{1){.(
!
I
/
J~
R~d(-
\1TfITriiffiiJi
~
Invention
David Pye w rote tha t invention "can only be done
deliberatel y, if the inven tor can di scern simi larities
be tween the par ticu lar result which he is en visaging
an d some other actual result wh ich he has seen and
stored in his m emory.... An in ven tor 's power to
in vent de pends on his abi lity to see ana lo gie s
between resu lts and, secondarily, on h is abi lity to see
th em betwe en devices. " 3 The ana logies ar e easily rec
\ognized in our everyday inv ent ions. If we lack a ham
'fIler to drive te nt stakes in to the ground , we gain an
Insight
to th e solution by seeing a tent pole se ction or
\
a ro ck at arm 's length an alogous to a hammer. Burrs
caught in she ep wo ol were the inspiration for Velcro
fasten ers, and the cooling effect of th e evap oration of
perspiration from our skin is the basis of the idea of
using semiporous containers to keep water cool.
14 2
Disc overy
1
- 0
Figure 8-6 Analogy bet ween a house and a pit cher of water.
14 3
0j W\ ~() [J C- A \'\6\ ~j I 0
<Sfv~
--1
0 00
0
0 60
()
~o-+ f nvrl"<;;
Analogies
In hi s bo ok Sy nectics: Th e Developm en t of Crea tive
Capacity, W illiam G ordo n described fo ur typ es of
analogy: sym bolic, dir ec t, personal, and fantasy.
The examp le of th e p itcher and the hou se as con
ta iners is a sym bolic analogy, a com parison between
general q ualit ies of the two objects. O ther sy m bo lic
an a logies m igh t be m ad e be tw een the sp read of a
han d and the extensions of a house or betwe en foot
prints and ca nopied pavi lions, w h ich loosely cons ti
tut e th e house. O ne of th e m ost pr om in ent examples
is the ana logy between the Latin cross an d the p lan s
of ma ny Got hic ch ur ches.
D ire ct analogy com pa res pa rallel facts or opera
tions . In the examples opp osite, the house is des igned
to have th e sam e co o ling chara cte ri stics as a tre e:
shade, eva pora tion , and air mo vem ent. And the roof
suppo rts for Nervi's ex hibition hall em ulate a hand
balan cing a tray.
C.V07 -:;'
144
D iscovery
(a)
(b)
(b)
145
(a)
reV\
CLoSed
~rA
~
I
/
/
.;'
;'
.........
<,
-,
\
'\
\
/"
(b)
14 6
D iscovery
61Yvdura.\
ORG-AN\C
ANALOGIES
C ULTURAL
ANAlO G-IE6
Figure 8-11 Eight different types of analogy based on a hierarchy of syste ms.
Sources of Analogy
Th e possibl e mode ls fro m wh ic h to d raw ana log ies
can be classified by categories as p hysical, org an ic, or
cu ltu ral, and th e su bc a tegories include:
1. Structural- Referring to shape or rela tionship .
5. A nimal- Behavior.
6. Ma n- Imagination and choice .
7 . Society-Inter action , comp etition , organization .
8 . Symbolic-Conventions, references , suggesti on .
Increasing Effectiveness
We have a ll exp er ie nced times w he n our m ind s
ap p eare d fr oze n with a single thou ght that doe sn't
seem goo d eno ug h or is una ble to solve a cr itica l
problem . A few spe cific app roach es that might help
thinking get moving again ar e shown on th e follow
ing pages.
147
D~~
4 o(M" heat
];
" L
?TO~.e
Ir-U
Doov/ Tabl e
N'0kt
148
Discovery
'01100
WI .:1:
box
~(} nJ
Avvtf lttiWttlOYl
Concept Formation
Th e basic concept, some t im~s referred to as the patti,
is an enduri ng mechanism used by architectural
design ers to es tablish th e fundamenta l organization
of a building and guide the enti re p rocess of design
d ev elopment. T h e parti, at its best, p rovid es:
1. T h e first synthesis of the designer 's re sponse to
th e determinant s of for m (p rogram, obj ectives,
context, site, economy, e tc.).
The Ideagram
T h e sket ches t ha t have alread y b ee n described as
flowing from an alogies, kn own as ideogram s, ar e the
starting p oin t for concept forma tion. Ideagrams are
extensions of an alysis d iagrams that can be used as:
Th e Discovery Process
149
"
/.
~I.J
,tn:t =
Ii.. r
....
......~....l~;;;;a:
_ i
,,\
OfiM -6ttt
Prototypes
As with oth er des ign ski lls, concept formation need
not be a mysteriou s process developed solely thro ugh
trial and erro r. There is a lot to be learn ed from archi
tects who are hig hly skilled at molding conc epts, and
here again ske tches can be an im porta nt aid . On the
next pages ar e exa m p les of a nalytica l sk etches and
ab stract con cept-getti ng tec hniqu es fro m the w ork of
several architects.
The first exam p le s are fro m th e wor k of Fran k
Lloyd Wrigh t. In the hou ses know n as the Prairi e
Style, h e us ed a bas ic p lan of in terl ock ing spa ces
domi nated by a cent ra l hear th with an elab orate,
indirect ro ute of entry. Alth ough the basic organ iza
ti on al pa rti rem ai n ed constan t , Wrigh t 's carefu l
response to th e un iqu e constraints of each site pro
duced a w ide variety of building form s. As designers
of houses, w e can try to us e Wright' s basic parti or
de velop our ow n prototyp e p lan and m anipu late it in
res ponse to specific sit e con ditions.
~?ad ?\"+l
Figure 8-17b Che ney Ho use 1904, Wright architect .
I.
I"
I"
I
'-
."
..
"
. . .. "" '[1
It . . , . . ' . ' .
~all/Slof~& 61te
Figure 8-l7c Hardy House 1905, Wright archite ct.
150
D iscovery
Ca+~r"f It( ar
IlJ\ t\ ~b)(.
'[Jr-----4
~u-ttertb ~ 170x
Figure 8-18a Prototype concepts developed by Alvar Aalto.
151
Box
A-ddrhve
1. Ma ''?o~ 6
WttV\tle
1.. . Vd [~ ~ G~t ~
7v0-tYztc;t ~\) e
5,
v//~//// /,/ // ~ .
Vdk\ ~&t-hoge
4. Vd l~ <Sa vo-::J e
I.
: II
r.
\1
fJ
~
. 11
'I
:3:
.
- - - - - - --'
~\ \ - C4!r Th<Jt,,"$h F
L,h--tWYj
o
(v'l lJ0(! UW\
152
D iscovery
:
I
I
1-siJ
153
~pe.~
of=
rv'-ACH INE..p
~W'6
AY'ov~
O~PEROr
Rt'OM~
ITIJ
~d1 td
t=a1
AY'o()VI~ Coy!
?\
l~ X+ltl o r:
~
~
Gre~R.oo~
W
CiJ
4.2
I
--------
:1
QJ
5.1
Co .l
G,.'2
4 .~
@
63
8J1
EkE Ej
Gi'ta r~
0Cl
14
z.4
rQr ~
'7.::
lV'l
R06L'Y\6
~4
Eill ~f!1 ~
6.1
6>e{-W(lh
r\D ooe
'2.'3;;
3,'2.
Q
\.-?
'2.'2..
'l .\
2D
f?o6vY16
1. 1
/1
Llnkta
Otr+~ l d e
wrth~\I\
1(ooywb
G, 3
[0 OJ 1-oJ []J []
4 .4
I
~
J;.4
<;.4
154
D iscovery
155
1< ~ -
\~e' ~~\(~
"5DC{p.-\ I z~
"
. \-)~v::'3 f \~~ ~ ~ l~
~
v'S
_~
C\
f:~ --~
' ~~~ W lf ~~
VleM.>$ ~ ~ ( ~ b~
1i4L----7
---7
.>
~ (}" ,:~
t4, ~~""'CJ
~ ~ 4; DHt~ ~VV'-
T
I
<.~
i.,
~/5Iv'"j
~ iiJ l . P~
~
Fi gure 8- 22
Pattern Language
For several years, a group at th e University of
Califo rn ia/Berkeley, headed by Christopher Alexander,
has been wo rking w ith a m et hod of generating build
ing des igns, called patte rn lan guage. Basically, it is an
approach that const r ucts con cep ts for a building by
com bining pr ototypes for sm aller pa rts of th e bu ilding.
The work ing tool is a hierarchy of prototypes: areas
th at com bine to make roo ms, that combine to make
build ing s, that com bine. to m a ke co mm u ni ties, th at
combine to mak e urban complexes, an d so on. Pattern
language appears to be less a prescription for the per
fectly designed environment th an a convenient format
for form ulating design conc epts. Any designer is free
to supply his own prototyp es, alth ough there is cer
tainly m erit in sharing wo rkab le prototypes.
Application of the pattern lan gu age approach, on
th e simp lest leve l, to our ho use proje ct mi ght take the
follow ing form :
1. Based on past experience, we wou ld start w ith an
1 56
D iscovery
, -- - - - -
Plnl"3 ~
u?ua. l~
C\AA
Ilfl W~ <t
Fi gure 8- 23
---~ -------
H'\
Icrf; ~ Cl""h-fbd
Whe n the desig ner is formu lat ing concepts for the
bu ildi ng design , he sp reads the collec tion of releva nt
cards or sh eet s on a table or wa ll. Patterns or mini
concep ts are then grouped as possible combina tions
an d observed, but the designer m ust go beyond a sim
pl y add itive pr ocess, In describing "pa ttern lan
guag e, " Ch ris top her Alexa nder exp lain ed that "It is
possi ble to put pattern s togeth er in such a w ay that
man y, many pa tte rn s ov erlap in the sam e physical
space : the buildi ng is ve ry dense ; it has many me an
ings captured in a small space; an d through this den
sity, it becomes pr ofo und . "7 To ac hi eve this sort of
synthesis, or "compression ," of pa tt erns, the graphic
think ing process can be applied, using cards or a clip
boa rd to turn ove r ideas as one scans th e disp lay of
patterns.
157
Figure 8-2 6
CASESTUDIES
Examples of id eagram s develo ped in to conc ept s for
the rec reationa l house ca se s tud y ar e shown her e.
Th e ideagrams, as you w ill re cognize, are taken from
th e ana lyses of need , context, and for m in Cha pter 6
(a na lysis), fr om Ch ap te r 7 (expl ora tio n ), and fr om
Case Studies
15 9
sc-s
a -g
091
aJn 5~:J
aJn5 ~ :J
,
)
r,
V'l~
~ '
;.\~
~~~. ~
~
Fi gure 8-29 By Leonardo da Vinci . Studies of a tempo raty structure for festivals.
Case Studies
161
9 Verification
16 3
far+tO
Figure 9-3a Three alternative expressions of the perspective.
4;-- Vltl.{}?
ll~ ~rt
--fLX1Ut"f
Pe(~eoh v e
I~ t1DD"
1.:
~nd
:t=rool'"
{J(dw
~ iJrud-urf
VYlcdtJ.e
"Z.o VllMf1
r1aV\
/ - -f>C1XI<
~ ~po~oh
I~Vv+
7ed LOVi
Fig ure 9-2 A parti and three different forms of its articulation.
164
2M 1100\'"
Verification
ARTICU LATION
To get a feel for the range of im ages that a re used to
a r ti culat e a con ce p t , the three sket ches sh ow n in
Figure 9-2 ad d ress some fea ture of the design co n
cept. Th e qualiti es or ch a rac teristics illus tra ted a re
noted for eac h ske tc h . In Figur es 9-3a, b, and c, th ree
alt ern ative exp re ss ion s a re develope d for ea ch
ske tc h .
Articulation
165
-"
III_
Need
CoVlt l)(f
ro\'1'Y\
t:qlJttl!j t0e~~~
Cnh~Ytt\
Figure 9-5a
Figure 9-5c
Figure 9-5b
-.J
-,
Figure 9-5d
Figure 9-5e
EVALUATION
Evalua tion
167
>
~ ~
"~ ~
~~
<:::
~
....
(jJ
o-@
"
st
~Ji
";:5
~~
@
(!)
--->.
G-
fnva Oj
O nelrtt4LOI1
C wcvlat 1011
(!)
'\J
VIews
~ ~
tUldlVtg
On evrf-ctflDI1
H-1er avchtj
6 C41t:
tn
ro
A CUf6 -Iz, s ~e
(a)
mvaCAj
()
Q
(b)
-\
m
x
-1
V ~1: 1-o
O~";>L de
~ -5v(r\ ~
~ W~
(c)
7'ij
16 8
Verification
i~S
~""",---'-+"-~; ~f
:',r\\
~.,....,.......,.,-,""......,,..,. ' \
Evaluation
169
Cost Benefit
O the r exa mp les of grap h ic im a ge s us ed to as sis t
eval uation appear on these two pages. The dia gra m
sh own to the r ight is a n ex tension of analysis te ch
n iq ue s de ve lope d by the a r ch ite ctu ra l firm of
Ca udi ll Row lett Scott ." T he relati ve size of building
areas and their approxim a te co sts are shown s ide by
sid e , p rov id in g a n ov e rv iew of th e rel ati on ship
be tw e en p rogram n eed s and co s ts useful to bo th
cli ent and design er.
C~
. 11
Aof(17o,
ill ~
f V\d~q
Oecb
I
I
A(m
C0t
t;]
@]I ID
I
I
I
III *
""
ElEi rn
I
I
III
~~.
_____
t3......
~t: ?
W~ !
')
r - --7 -r
I
U I I " I I \ ~~~
~i ~ ;t-
~J
~ 5~
Figure 9-9 The perspective as an evaluation
tool.
./
Drawing Evaluation
Persp ect ives are so co m mo nly used as sellin g to ols
th at an exam ination of the p ersp ective ab ove might
help to emphasize its pote n tial as an evaluation tool.
Here, the perspect ive is fir st rend ered w itho u t co n
scious att en tion to the design of spa ce. The d raw ing is
now exa m in ed for cl u es to s hor tcom ings. Th is
1 70
Verificati on
CONSOLIDATION
As the evalu ation of alte rn atives helps us decide on
the be st rou te, a range of good ideas an: un cover ed ,
w hich the d es ign er t hen a tt em p ts to in corporate in
his final scheme. Ma n y com bina tions ar e s ketched as
the design is pull ed together, and even at the stage of
the comp let ed d es ign , so m e refin em en ts a re st ill
in corporated . The d es ign er se eks consist enc y in a ll
par ts of th e d esi gn . The end re sul t is sketches that ar e
m ore spec ific as to d im ensio n , sha pe , an d position .
r-----II)!
Consolidation
171
~~? rMill
I
v~
ElABORATION
W ith the basic d esign d ecisions made an d cla rified,
pr eparation is under way for the next cycles of ver ifi
cat ion . Dec isions at one level of des ign op en up ma ny
p r oblems at ot her level s. For exam p le , fix ing th e
de sign of a room ma kes it pos sible to study w indows,
floo ri ng , m ech ani cal sys te m s, sto rage un it s, and a
num ber of sp ecial it ems such as fir ep lace or so la r
iu m . Conce p ts fo r each of the parts are devel op ed
wi th in the context of th e design of the w ho le ro om .
Bu t ea ch concep t in tu rn can be verified by repe at ing
th e me thods de scribed earl ier in thi s chapter.
Elaboration
17 3
~~l f~tM~
~=----- Pbhlb\
-;:/~
11 1 1
a!
'/
~ tD~
I~
I h~
11
- 0-
Details
At som e p oint in designing, the archite ct m us t ass ur e
h imself that the design concepts are realist ic by as k
ing wheth er the pa rts can be constru cted . W ill they
fit togeth er? Detail sketches p lace the design under a
sort of mi crosco p e. The sample sketches on th ese two
pages show, through th e different vi ews, the im por
ta nce of h ow som e thi ng is put toget her a nd how it
sh oul d look. Addi tionally, the up -close d raw ings or
sketches m ust show the context for th e deta il.
~J
[ffi
i--
--
~t'Vt<JV 1n\'V1
;;
~ ?<;S
17 4
Verification
I I II
UlJ.
/
Figure 9-16
<;)
IT rrn ~ 1f1I n BE
"
t--
MA-f>-Tl tJ-SoN
>--
ce.
11.
~ ~~
\ ~ .r,
"
fl/llj)
! !( ~
175
COMMUNICATION
BUILD
CLIENT
--~~
CONTRACTOR
-~
- - -- ----,
c---
-~~----
--
USERS
PLANNER
MANUFACTURERS
MANAGEMENT
LANDSCAPE
ARCHITECT
SUPPLIERS
FINANCE
LEGALAFFAIRS
PUBLIC AFFAIRS
SALES
CONTRACTOR
INDUSTRIAL
DESIGNER
SUBCONTRACTORS
COST SURVEYOR
CONSTRUCTION
MANAGER
ARCHITECT
CONSTRUCTION
SUPERVISOR
MECHANICAL
ENGINEER
ELECTRICAL
ENGINEER
STRUCTURAL
ENGINEER
CONSULTANT
l-..
~~
__ .
,_
_~
-~ ~ - ~ ~~~ ~ ~
LAND DEVELOPER
REALTOR
BUILDING MANAGER
BUILDING SYSTEM
DEVELOPER
CONSTRUCTION
FINANCE
CODE ENFORCEMENT
ANTHROPOLOGIST
SOCIOLOGIST
10 Process
179
fY~jVaM
f-
XhtMaTlG
Ve~3Y\
?mblem
VeflV\ rt lot')
f-
I--
17eve(~g
Alternafl\}R6
~~V'
!7eve of~~
c,vrtr~
{7oev~tV\t?
~-?Lled ID\'I
~p
I-1A--t{v)I~
UM&frvchOh
u".", u.,ar/lon]
A DESIGN PROCESS
Regardless of wh at is being d esi gn ed or w ho is
involved in d esign ing it, th ere is a co m m on objective:
translat ing the clien t's p rog ram in to a spec ific bu ild
ing or ano ther resp onse to his needs. In architec tura l
pr act ice thi s nor m a lly invo lves the follow ing st eps :
b uild ing p ro gr am , sche m a tic d esign , p relimin ar y
d esign , d esign de velop men t, con tract d ocume nt s,
shop d raw ings , co nstructio n . At each of these st eps,
the probl em s tha t mu st be solved requ ire of th e
designer an effect ive pro blem -solving p rocess. Th ere
ar e m any good m od els for p roble m-so lving p ro cesse s.
I pr efer the follow in g five-s te p m od el:
1. Problem defini tion- Identifyi ng the specific lim its
180
Process
processes.
Figure 10-4 An application of the pro blern -solvinq
A De sign Process
181
INCcMING
0Uffi0 1~ G
~C1<'rvn ()N
~lvn oN
I ~rlY>\~
8G5Cvv~ ,
1~er, rv.e~l
~D~u~ u
I D p~VL I
I ObS-e-rve. ]
! Ol:>~e I
18 2
Process
!<fi
'"
.c,
"
~
~
...<:>
-r
~
~
s:
'S
:::::
s:
'"
FJ -+
'"
>
~
c:s
~
-5
~
.Pr-(7~ (O \'Y1
De0l.6V\ P.ev'elopi'Ylt'nt
183
P ~ IVATE
C ONCE PTu A L
PeRCf: P flJAI-
AB sT f<.AGT ("
pI A GRAM AT IC
~EF'l<E.SENTAT10 N A 1
PUB LIC
P RIVATE
Cof.,JC P(7TU A L
A\3 'ST~ACT
t7IAG f?AMA Tl C.
Pe.\<C E..'f'TUM..
CDJ.,lct<t;rg
'R{;'Pf<l::SE.NTA11DNAL
D~[]IlI!.
0!]OEJDCI
QlZlrn~D~
~1SI8~DIiiI
[3l81EE1mD~
'PUBLIC
184
Process
,/
r1J
(IJQ
~
~
~
/'
-----
~
~
~
~
(IJ
185
SSC)JO.ld
981
187
'
. r.
- .,( (
" f)
I\,..j.,"
~'
~I.
.1 '~
.,.). ~
'"
~J
. ". ~~~
Lo
)
':'
'!
./,"
11""- \
--~t
"
N"~~'
"
, "", IA
'"
....... 0 "'('I
A/_ "7
t'
'
/~."
. ~_ . ~"" . ,, '1,
J
A '
,' r. ~ ~
._
~_
y
< s- ,
~
.
"
r
-..'
. / /;j
. ; _J,.J" : 'iii.. .:. \\' ,,\
.J:-,;:--'.
,/
,"ii "
\. J ,
- $ ,,'
l ' ~j~
",~",,-
. ...
~.
'.
,.,
'.
:"
J, '
f'
"l+-/::~ )
"'i
:, l' _.
-'tf' 1 L
'. H
'0 '
:Il
. )
~,
~ -. -
....'
..,~ :~
;
;
,,, . . ., .. I"
-I"
I!:-~\
t-\
tX"'~''Y~''/'~
~. ~
- -":
_~ .., -T
~~
~
~-
r' - '
J ,,,
"'l
~~
';r-
,..
... .. ,'
-------
Figure 11-2 (bottom) By David Stieglitz. Buffalo Wate rfront Redevelopment Proje ct.
11 Individual Design
....-...,
.J
........
Figure 11-4 Ordering devices.
189
~
Figure 11-5 Drawing instruments.
190
Individual D esign
ENVIRONM ENT
It is cur ious th at ar ch itects, whose p rofession is con
cern ed with suiting environments to needs, spend lit
tle tim e stud y ing the environm ent in w h ich they
------
MENTAL/PHYSICAL CONDITION
Th e right materials and environme nt m ust be accom
panied by a good m ental and p hysical state for th e
indi v id ua l to th ink or solve problem s effecti ve ly.
Eve ryone is su bje ct to tension and stress in th eir
work, and this is esp ecially tru e of p racticing arch i
tects. Experienced architects try to pace th emselves
because th ey know that m istakes are m ade under
excessiv e pressu re. Freq ue nt exe rcise and re creation
are a bas is for a good m ental state , bu t designers can
also take specific m ea sures to improve th eir prepara
tion fo r w or k . Relax eyes by closing, the n ro ta ting
the m ; ease neck tension by sitting up right w ith bac k
suppo rted and slow ly bend t he head forw ard , ba ck
wa rd, and to ea ch side in a cir cular mo tion; relax the
w hole bod y by stretching and deep breath in g.
19 1
ABSTRACTTO CONCRETETHINKING
...
,
ba
I'd
c~
.,..
192
, - - -I -- - - -
I
I
I
III
Individual D esign
II ~
__
..J
19 3
!, ,rr'J
-,
1'\.- "
......
, '>:
r - -'
\
,
;.l--' '-,
J
- __ ___.,
--::,
195
OVERCOMING OBSTACLES
Eve n the best preparation does not assur e success in
d esi gn . Arch itec ture st ude nts and some tim es even
practit ione rs ru n in to think ing an d p roblem-solving
obs tac les . The fo llowin g lis t describes some of the
m ore com m on obsta cles an d so me possib le
responses.
O~fA6Lt
1.
Figure ll-l1a
I'/ \/ E::::
m
.. Ol]]
!J]
.,
~f,AC l
Figure ll-l1 b
196
ggf 00
B
G
...
..
~IACL
S,
Figure ll -ll e
-=-- - -
=c= =
..,
=:.
- - --
~TA CL t-
4.
Figure ll-ll d
Overcoming Obstacles
197
?f<OC~w
11<DJf.C/f
? 1
0'6
Q Q Q Q
~~.:S~~4
--4~~1
1
>~J-.4
19 8
Individual De sign
- - I
'Ul :
, ~ il/'11I1'1
/1 1
L. - -~!.'-'~I
" I 1
I I
1' 1
- - ' ,I II !
L-r-; -~
- bUD
__--l ]
DJ
Figure 11-14 Combination of the previous elements using new materials in a new context .
19 9
~
~
"'--- v
v..
Figure 11-15 Elevati on sket ch. Guggenheim Museum.
200
Individual D esign
)
/
/
I
20 1
12 Team Design
TEAMCOMMUNICATION
Gr ap h ic co m m u n ica tio n can playa very im po rta n t
part in the success of tea mwork . To be effe ctive, team
Figure 12-2 Dia gram of double helix model of the DNA molecule.
203
PfRF EC T
E'XCFUEN T
F AI R
Miele
TH E:
0F A
Poor< T(ZIA IJ(, lE IS:
10-/0 ,,(0
THE ARf A OF A
-':';$Z:'
l'AIWi<E
5-5-5
T R IANGLE I S :
130
'?TR E N &Tt+ IS
;/
/0
T IlIAIJGVL),TIOl,/ OF T~ E
2-e-3
II
AReA
TR IA~GLE
A IID
2~e
WE
OF
10
.ASO
I~ :
perrFS'T/ON.
20
~2
Jr0~~~j('
\,::;'
.,,
to
Q"'AU1'Y QVDT,e~~
0- 0
0_
204
Team Design
Team Communication
205
APPLYING GRAPHICS
Grap hic no tati on can contrib u te to team d esign by
ill us tr ating tw o im por tan t needs : informa ti on an d
processes of w orkin g tow ard a so lution of th e de sign
pro blem . T he de sign br ief (d isting uishable fro m th e
build ing program , w hich normally refer s to the pro
gram of bu ild ing fun ction s) contains most of t he
inform ati on ne eded to comple te a b ui ld ing design .
The design brief incl udes:
-=r==r ,
Ob~u.et t~ \'o~~
Vlt W.s
~ ~~
6'e+buts
s
~
----4 -'
206
:- . . (
'
,
1bt:'"
1. br.".
-~l l~ ~~W3S
il
WJ1:r ft
fr~ (J~1lr 1J
0 00 0 1 0 0 0 0
000 00
00000
OO O O DI[)O OOD
0 0000 D OOOO
, ~- - ~--
m \Thb:l~
I '
'.
I
\
';
\
\
..
'\
..._d
Q ')
____I
...
__- . . . 1.9---
A pplying Graphics
207
.z.
314
5 G 7
8\q
10
II
12 13 14 15
1
Ii
V
c,
t?A~CHA~'-
'PRBCJ7f;:Na
NETWoRK
208
Team Design
/ {P
17
clleV\{
f?nef
209
TEAM CREATIVITY
Becau se grap hic thi n kin g increa ses the o u tp ut of
ideas for the ind ivid ual, the possibilities for a grou p
are geometrically in creased, assuming that the w ay is
op ene d for everyone to co m m unicate. Alex Osb orn '
deve loped a method calle d br ain storm ing that helps
to kee p th e chann els of thi nkin g ope n . He identified
four rul es th a t m ust be follow ed to gen era te id eas
w ith in a group during bra insto rm in g:
1 . Susp end j udgment on anyone's idea.
2. Freew heel; let yo ur im agination roam.
210
Team Design
------- --
--
211
'f\p n~ s
~-----'>
~-----7
~ -----7
~---- -'>
~ -----7
~-- - --7
~----~
lV\()\j e M1?NT
o~
tIJ ~ ]J
~CC5
8?D
f~1
Figure 12-13 Urban core st udies.
213
eninportant part 01
higheredlro8lion
( CIRCULATION )
( IMAGINATION)
e
\\: ~ :
:. ~ "
( COMMUNICATION )
SAFETY )
( STlWLATION )
( INf ORMATION )
~~~GU~
CRI TERIA
1NTR000000 ON
DESIGN
EXPLORAT ION
ALT ERNATIVES
PROPOSAL
214
Team De sign
( RELAXATION)
( ENTERTAINMENT )
CONTEXT
OBJECT IVES
PROCESS
RESULT S
~ENmY
ANAL YSIS
PROGRAMMATIC
CONTEXT
FORM
FEASIBIUT Y
ANALYSI S
COMPARISONS
CONCLUSIONS
RECOMMENDATIONS
215
13 PubLic Design
Figure 13-2
2 17
OV\e -(V~
Gn'H\t1Mtatht>n
(a)
vs
-r
(po -
W~ G,rn W) V~HUfhcM
(b)
-,1,1;:-r \
r10
\ ! r. -.'
". I
1-
'I
1_ -_i ' ::
\: I
lr: >
(.: iI
I :
:.
I-
-~ ! , ':
,
-I
r:.-
\'V
,
,I
,I
,I
I
f i \
2 18
Public D esign
COMMUNITY DESIGN
Jim Burns cla imed that archi tects must w ork more
di rec tly w ith the p ubli c to avo id the mista kes of th e
past.
"Some of the envi ronmenta l changes... have had neg
ative imp acts that were not easily discern ible at first.
They seemed to be good things to do-to relocate a
museu m or provide new housing or put a spo rts
are na in a pa rk . What happen ed eventually was that
the m useum lost part icipants, the housing was dis
lik ed, the park patrons shu nned the spo rts facilities.
Th e reason for these kin ds of failures is usually that
the change s broke con nections between people and
the opp ortunities their com munity offered. "3
219
~ L S T,.!.[E 7
I~
;;s ~~~/ b
~~ vu-
if4}>
---,
P""
@
6 ACN /
TAKE-PART WORKSHOPS
Seve ral arch ite cts and plan ners have worked vigor
ously to develop gr ap hic comm uni cation m e tho ds,
making it possible for the pu blic to understand and
enter in to the design process. O ne of the innov ators
in th is tr end w as Law rence H alpri n:
I am concentrating on the issue of people's int erac
tions with their environment both as individua ls an d
in grou pe.: both aspects are important. We hav e
been searching for archetypal relationships... in
wor kshops which tak e place primarily out in the
field T hese taki ng par t work sh ops allow people the
opp ortunity to disco ver and articulate their own
needs and desires for themselves and for their com
m unities... . They discover ways of com munica ting
with each oth er an d arri ving at crea tive decisions
based on mu ltipl e input.'
220
Publi c D esign
TH E
T (}
f ile HOLIN-/)
tr. { '
ro
/~!ALL- .
17IE IV
l IfE 6GACH .
221
:-P)..~~
V" e-,
........ .......
-,.....
":;:-~~ ,,;
,.~,-
~~
7
<i.
~.
,"
."
-,
-I
~
it'1~~ ~
.......'~~~(_
. i!'~
' : ~ ',1:1)1.,'
- ~ .- It r~
;.+..-
f,.,..... . "
_~ ll-J~ ! ~~~
: -- ~ --~~:~
Fi gure 13-13 By Peter Hasselman. Atlanti c City st udy.
222
Public Design
223
l__J
(~
" \
'I
( ::;
./
Ir- )
\I
ill
t-- '1
\
I,
I
~,,.
) I
{Ii
-~
I '
~I f--'L/ \ -~-~--~:J
~ - - Jl1.
I:
{\
/1 -
.l ~ l ~~ 1\r
I
uOL- _~~~{p
..'
224
"J
<.
~-
-\ vir
Public Design
-,
"
- ,-'
- ( - ~ '--..",r - ...
'>-'to
""
,i )
<..~
- "?\
'\
1\
-,-'.
J/./\
~;-
\\
-~
--
-,
WORKING SKETCHES
Working Sketches
225
~~
-"
:>
:-..\ \1//..
<:;"
'1-
.,, \/J/
~ -o -'
d~ ::-II \ \
Re gional Se Uing
226
Public D esign
Figure 13-23
227
229
14 Conclusion
231
UOIs n[:JlIO:J
zz
THE CHALLENGES
In ar chitect ur al ed ucation th e temp ta tio n to focus on
the con tr asts betw een trad itiona l an d d igital m edia
see m s irresis tible. On the one ha nd is the belief that
dig ital m ed ia will no t only prov ide new opport u nities
b ut re nde r other media obso lete. On th e othe r sid e is
an equally strong commi tm en t to th e impo rtan ce of
th e q ua li tat ive impacts of trad itional media . The res o
lu tion of these con tras ting po sitions lies in tw o cr iti
ca l persp ec ti ves- the q ues tio n of app ropriat ene ss of
media and the concep t of m edia int egrati on .
Fig ure 14-5 Devel opment sket ches, Hammonds Resid ence, House
233
Fi gure 14- 6 Comput er-rendered view, Hammond s Resi dence, House + House, architect s.
Appropriateness
Int egration
234
Conclusion
The Challenges
235
Notes
Chapter 3
Chapter 1
Chapter 4
2 . Ha m ilton , Edward A. Graph ic Design for the Com puter Age.
Ne w Yor k: Van Nostra nd Reinho ld Company, 1970 , p . 16.
3. M c Kim , Rob e r t H . Experi en ces in Visual
Monterey, CA: Brooks/C ole, 1972 , p . 22.
T hink ing.
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
1. Bes t, G ord o n. "Me t hod and Intention in Arc hit e ct ura l
Chapter 2
Yo rk :
237
Chapter 7
3.
Chapter 12
"T h e Gra mm a r
G r am mar," p p . 11 -1 2 .
of
Orn am ent/Orn am en t
as
Chapter 8
1. Row an , "T he Creat ive Peo p le: How to Spo t T hem, " p. 11.
2 . Rowan, "T he Cr eati ve People : H ow to Sp o t Them ," p . 13.
3. Pye , D avid. Th e N a ture of Design. New Yor k : Re in ho ld
Publish in g Cor po r at ion, 1964 , pp . 65- 66.
4 . M cKim , Experiences in Visu al Th in k ing, p. 4 7.
5. Bro ad be nt , De sign in Architectu re, p. 34 1.
6 . Broad bent, D esign in Archit ecture, p. 34 3.
7. Alexa n d e r, C h ri sto p h er, Is h ikawa , Sa ra, an d Silve rste in ,
Mu rray. A Pal/em Language. New Yor k : Ox fo rd U n ivers ity
Pr ess , 1977, pp . xliii-xliv.
Chapter 9
1. Lockard, D esign D rawing. p . 119.
2 . Pena , Problem See k ing.' An Architect ura l Progra mming
Pri mer, p. 165.
Chapter 13
1. Dr u c ke r, Pe te r F. Th e Age of D isco nt inuity. New Yor k :
H a r p e r & Row , 1968. Toffl er, Alv in . Fut u re Shock . New
York : Ra nd om Ho u se, 1970 . Ben n is, Wa r ren G ., a nd Sla ter ,
Philip F. T he Temporary Society. Ne w Yo r k: Ha rp e r & Row ,
1968.
2 . T h es e tw o renova tio n p roj ec ts ad ap ted large old er struc
Chapter 14
Chapter 11
1. M c Kim , Experiences in Visu al Think ing, p . 31.
2 . Kub ie , Law r enc e. Ne u rotic D ist orti on of the Creat ive Process.
G ar d en C ity, NY. Fa rr a r, Strau s & G iro ux , In c. (Noo nday
Press), 1961.
238
Not es
Bibliography
I. DRAWINGS AND GRAPHICS
Atk in, Willia m Wilso n. A rchitectural Presentat ion Techni qu es.
New York: Van Nostra nd Reinhold Co., 197 6 .
Beittel, K. M ind and Context in th e A rt of Drawing. New Yo rk :
Holt, 1972 .
Bellis, He rbe rt F. A rchitectu ral D ra fting. New York: McGraw
Hill Boo k Co ., 1971.
Bow ma n, Wi lliam 1. Gra phic Comm unication. New Yor k: Jo hn
Wiley & Son s, Inc., 1968.
Chi ng, Fran k. A rch itectura l Graphics. New York: John Wiley &
Sons, Inc., 1975 .
Collie r, G . Form , Sp ace, a nd Vision. Englewo od Cliffs , NJ :
Pren tice-Ha ll In c., 1972 .
Czaja , Mic hae l. Freehand Drawing, Language of Design. Wal nu t
Creek , CA: Ga m bol Press, 1975 .
DaVinc i, Leo nar do. N otebooks. New York : Dove r Publica tions,
lnc ., 1970 .
De Vries, Ja n Vred e ma n . Perspec tive. New York : Dove r
Pub lications, Inc., 1968 .
Klim e nt , Ste phen A. Creative Com m unicat ions for a S uccess ful
D esig n Practice. New Yor k: Wat so n-G up ti ll Publication s,
In c., 1977 .
Lockard , William Kir by. D ra wing as a M eans to Architecture.
Ne w York: Reinhold, 1968.
Locka rd , Willia m Kir by. D esign D rawing. Rev. Ed. New York:
Van Nostrand Rein hold , 1982.
Lockar d , Willi am Kirby. Design D rawing Exp erien ces. Tucson ,
AZ: Pep pe r Publicati on s, 1974 .
Lockw ood , Arthur. D iagra m s. Ne w Yor k: Wa tso nG upt ill
Pub lica tions, Inc., 1969.
McGi n ty, Tim . D raw ing S k ills in Architectur e. D ub uq u e, IA:
Ken da ll/Hunt Pu blis hing Co. , 1976 .
Me ndeIow itz, Dav id M . A Guide to D raw ing. New Yor k: Holt ,
Rein hart a nd Winston , 197 6.
Murgin, Ma thew. Co mm unicatio;z Graphics. New York : Van
Nos tra nd Reinhold Co ., 1969 .
Nicolaides, K. T he N atu ral Way to D ra w. Boston : Hough to n
Mifflin , 1941 ; Paperback ed. , 1975.
Go lds te in, Na tha n . The Art of Respon sive Dra wing. Englewoo d
Cliffs, NJ: Pre ntice -Hall Inc. , 1973.
Gup till, Ar th ur Leigh ton . Dra wing with Pen and Ink . New York:
Reinhold Pub lishing Co. , 1961.
Stegman , George K. A rchi tectu ral Drafting Chica go: Amer ican
Tech nical Society, 1966 .
Stein berg, Saul. T he Labyrinth. New York : Ha rp er & Bro the rs,
1960 .
Han ks, Kur t, Bellis ton , Lar ry , an d Edwa rds, Dave. D esign
Yourself Los Altos, CA: W illiam Ka ufma nn , Inc., 1977.
Hayes, Co hn . G ramma r of Dra w ing for A rtist s and D esigners.
New York : Van No stra nd Rein hold Co ., 1969 .
Hill, Ed ward . The La nguage of Dra wing. New York: Pre ntice
Hall Inc., 1966 .
Hogarth , Pau l. Drawing A rch itec ture: A Crea tive Approac h. New
York: Walson -G up till Publicat ions, Inc., 1973.
Ja coby, He lmu t. New Archi tectural Dra w ings. New York :
Praege r, 1969 .
Jacob y, H elm u t. N ew Tec hniques o f Architectural Ren dering.
New York : Praege r, 197 1.
Kemper, Alfre d. Prese nta tion D rawings by America n A rchitec ts.
New York: John Wiley & Sons , Inc., 1977.
Sou rcebook.
Tucson ,
AZ:
239
Lu c ki esh , Ma tt hew.
Visual
Ill usions,
Th eir Causes,
Characteristics and A pplicati ons. New Yor k : Dover, 1965.
240
Bi bliography
The N otebook of Paul Klee. Vol. 1 Th e Thi nk ing Eye. New Yor k:
W itt en b orn , 1978 .
Pa ra m e n te r, Ross . The Awa hened Eye. M id d le tow n , CT
Wesleya n Un ive rsity Press, 1968.
Pitch e r, G . A Theory of Perceptio ns. Pr in ceton , NJ : Prin ce ton
Un iver sity, 197 1
Rob e rt so n , T In novative Beha vior an d Com m uni cat ion . New
York : Holt, 1971
Sam uels , M ., an d Sam u els, N . Seei ng wi th the Mi nd 's Eye. N ew
Yor k: Ra n d om H ou se. 1975 .
Summer, Robe rt. The Mi nd's Eye. New York: Dell Pu bli shing,
1978.
Gombrich , F. H.
A rt an d
Ph ardon/Pantheon , 1960 .
Whi teh ead , Alfred North . Sy m bolism , Its Mea ning and Effe ct.
New York: Ma cm illan Co. , 1959.
Illu sion.
N ew
Yo rk:
IV. CREATIVITY
Ban ker, W. Brain Storms, New York: Grove, 196 8.
Korner, S. Concept ual Thin ki ng: A Logical Inqu iry. New Yor k:
Dover, 1959 .
Pikas, A. A bst ract ion and Concept' Forma tion . Ca mbridge , MA:
Harvard University, 196 6.
Burton , W, Kim ball, R., a nd W ing, R. Edu cat ion for Effective
Think ing. New York: Apple ton , 1960.
Prince, George M. The Pra ctice of Crea tivity. New York: Harper
& Row (paperbac k, Collier Boo ks, 1972 ).
Reed , F. D eveloping Creative Talen t. New York: Vantage, 1962.
Rieser , Dolf . Art a nd Science. N ew Yor k: Van Nos trand
Reinhold , 1972 .
Row an, H elen. "Th e Creative Peopl e: Ho w to Spot Them. "
THINK. New Yor k: IBM Cor p . Nov.-Dec., 196 2, pp . 7-1 5 .
Sam p les, Robe rt. I ntrodu ction to the Metaphoric Mi nd. Reading,
MA: Addi son-Wesley Publishing Co., 197 6.
Wat son, James D. Th e D oubl e Helix. Pasadena, CA: Athe ne um
Press, 1969.
B ibliography
24 1
Illustration Credits
1-4 ,7-3, 7-33 , 11-1: Repr odu ced fro m A lvar Aa lto : Sy nopsis,
ed ited by Be rn ha rd Hoesli , p ublished by Bir kh a use r Verl ag,
Basel, 1970 .
1-5, 5- 11, 5-15: Co ur te sy of T homas N . Lar son , FAAR, Th e
Arc hitec ts Collaborative .
1-6, 7-34 , 11-10: Court esy of Th om as H . Bee by, Hamm ond ,
Beeby, Babka , Arc hitects, Chicago.
1-7, 2-6, 5-4: Fro m Atkin , Will iam W. A rchitect ural Presenta tion
Techn iqu es. e 1976 by Litt o n Ed ucational Publis hin g, Inc .
Rep rinted by pe rm ission of Van Nos tra nd Reinhold Com pany.
1-8: Fr om Er ma n , Adolph . Life in Ancient Egyp t. N ew York :
reprint ed by Benjam in Blom , In c., 1969. Distributed by Arno
Press, Inc.
5-7, 5-19: Cour tes y of Ja mes W. Anderson and Lan dplus West ,
lnc., Lan d Pla nne rs/Landscape Arc hitects.
2-3, 7-18: Reprin ted w ith the perm ission of Pr oces s Arc hitects
Pub lish ing Com pa ny Ltd ., Tokyo , and Law r en ce Ha lpr in.
Copyr ight 1978. From Process: A rchit ect ur e N o. 4 Lawre nce
Halprin.
2-5: Reprinte d w ith th e perm ission of Des ign Pub lica tion s, In c.
From the Ma rc h 1975 issue of Indu strial Design M agaz ine.
2-7, 5-2 1, 5-26, 5-27: Repr odu ced by pe rmi ssion of Patrick P.
Na Il.
7-32: Cour tesy of Th omas P. Tru ax. From m aster 's thesis proj
ec t, O hio Un ive rsity, 1975.
242
Illustration Credits
243
Index
Aalto, Alva r, 3, 15 1
Abstraction :
ap plied, 86
Des ign :
br eif. 212-2 13
Activity pa tte rn s, 96
Aestheti c orde r, 77
objectives, 80
p roble m s, 87
process, 180-18 1
De ta ils, 174
Directio n , 7 1
D iscove ry, 14 1
Balance, 103
Beh av ior, 78
Distortion, 128-129
Building program , 87
Doodles, 36
Cartoons, 34
Dr awing, 17
Cha rac te r, 73
Climate, 95
Ene rgy, 70
Comparison, 82
Co mp rehensive views, 40
Escape, 147
Concrete :
im ages, 40 , 171
Extraction , 82
Focus , 71
For m , 100
244
G rap hic:
gra m ma r,
~ 6 - 5 8
Pa r ti, 149
lan gu age : 56
G ra phic Th inking:
Perspective , 41 -43
Phy si ca l be ha vio r, 90
op tion s, 184
tra d ition , 1
Pr iorities, d esign , 9 1
Process, 179
Progra m , b uilding, 76
Ideagra m , 149
Ide ntities , 59
Ide nt ity, 67
Pu blic de sign , 2 17
Im agin ati on , 35
In viti ng co m munication, 2 19
Red uctio n , 70
Linew ork , 24
Refres hme n t, 70
Repetition , 104
Ma ss, 103
Matrix, 154
e le me n ta ry fo rms, 40
qualit a tive, 44
Mood ,73
Reversals, 124-127
Ne ed,88
Ne tw or k diagra m s, 20 8-209
Note books, 1
Se lec tivit y, 68
O bserva tion , 20
Site se lection, 94
Index
245
Sketch:
Ton es, 25
building a , 22
Tracing, 28
details, 26
structu re , 24
tech nique, 50
tones, 25
U ni ty, 105
Style, 68
Vision , 5-6
Visual:
Synectics, 148
com mu nication , 4
percep tion, 13
Team :
th inki ng, 6
design , 203
Vitality, 70
Thinking:
abstract , 192-193
public , 194-195
24 6
Index