Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1.0 PT LTD Check Calcs - Verification
1.0 PT LTD Check Calcs - Verification
CALCULATIONS
MU000749
PROJECT TITLE
OFFICE
Manila Office
KAFD_Hotel_Plot_1.08
SHEET No
SUBJECT
ISSUE
TOTAL
SHEETS
AUTHOR
DATE
CHECKED BY
DATE
APPROVED
BY
DATE
RJB/GB
03/30/00
IF
04/17/15
RB
04/17/15
COMMENTS
2
3
4
5
SUPERSEDES DOC No
DATE
DESIGN BASIS STATEMENT (Inc. sources of info/data, assumptions made, standards, etc.)
DOCUMENT No
SHEET
MU000749
SUBJECT
SUBJECT
CALCULATIONS
OUTPUT
Summary
METHOD
CODE
Manual Check
89.53
0.62fr(ACI-318)
BS 8110-1997
Manual Check
89.77
Prokon W 2.4.13
84.62
ACI-318
Prokon W 2.4.13
89.84
BS 8110-1997
RAPT 6.2.2
81
RAPT 6.2.2
89.1
BS 8110-1997 - fr (N/A)
SAFE 12.2.0
54.13
0.62fr(ACI-318)
SAFE 12.2.0
85.89
0.33fr(ACI-435)
SAFE 12.2.0
82.94
0.62fr(BS 8110-1997)
SAFE 12.2.0
82.94
0.33fr(BS 8110-1997)
Conclusion:
SAFE 12.2.0, underestimate the long term deflection to the fact that it is using a
modulus rupture of concrete based from ACI-318 which is 0.62 fc' and this parameter
can not be controlled by the user as it is internally calculated by the program.
ACI-435 stated that using fr = 0.62 fc' underestimate the calculated long term
deflection, in that case it is advised to used fr=0.33 fc', which produced good
correlation between the calculated deflection and the reported field deflection.
See appendix B and C for detail verification.
1.0 When using British Standard please note that we are using
fcu, and the modulus of rupture the program uses fc'. The relation
between the cube strength is, fc' = 0.8 fcu
2.0 To resolved the scenario of the problem above, instead of
DOCUMENT No
SHEET
MU000749
SUBJECT
SUBJECT
CALCULATIONS
Appendix A
- Load Case Sequencing when checking longterm deflection
Dead , Nonlinear(Long Term Cracked) with creep and shinkage, start from unstressed condition
SDL, Nonlinear(Long Term Cracked) with creep and shinkage, start from stressed state Dead
LL, Nonlinear (Cracked) , start from stressed state SDL
NOTE:
For
OUTPUT
DOCUMENT No
SHEET
MU000749
SUBJECT
SUBJECT
CALCULATIONS
ACI 318
fr = 0.62(fc')^0.5
fr = 0.33(fc')^0.5
OF
OUTPUT
gerry
DOCUMENT No
SHEET
MU000749
SUBJECT
OF
SUBJECT
CALCULATIONS
OUTPUT
APPENDIX C
gerry
DOCUMENT No
SHEET
MU000749
SUBJECT
OF
DOCUMENT No
CALCULATIONS
PROJECT TITLE
OFFICE
Manila Office
SHEET No
SUBJECT
ISSUE
TOTAL
SHEETS
AUTHOR
DATE
CHECKED BY
DATE
RJB
11/24/11
SL
11/24/11
APPROVED
BY
DATE
COMMENTS
2
3
4
5
SUPERSEDES DOC No
DATE
DESIGN BASIS STATEMENT (Inc. sources of info/data, assumptions made, standards, etc.)
The study of deflection between two softwares have been conducted in one way
spanning member. All parameters shown below were used in both software however
some values that are not mentioned here the default values on each software has
been adopted.
Prestressed Property
DOCUMENT NO.
SUBJECT
RAPT MODEL
DOCUMENT NO.
SUBJECT
DOCUMENT NO.
SUBJECT
DOCUMENT NO.
SUBJECT
DOCUMENT NO.
SUBJECT
RESULTS
METHOD
RAM CONCEPT
16.28
23.6
RAPT
20.4
25.4