Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 8 views

    Functionality Concept 1 Concept 2 Concept 3 Shape of Steering Wheel Round D-Shape Elongated

    Uploaded by

    Fadhlan Syahidi Shaari
    This document compares three concepts for a steering system across multiple criteria. Concept 3 performs the best overall, scoring positively in 8 criteria areas including type of material, cost, steering wheel wrapping, ergonomics, type of constant velocity joint, weight, and safety. It scores neutrally in 2 criteria and does not have any negative scores. Concept 1 scores positively in 3 criteria but negatively in 4 criteria. Concept 2 scores positively in 2 criteria, neutrally in 6 criteria, and does not have any negative scores.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content

    You might also like

    Functionality Concept 1 Concept 2 Concept 3 Shape of Steering Wheel Round D-Shape Elongated

    Uploaded by

    Fadhlan Syahidi Shaari
    8 views3 pages
    This document compares three concepts for a steering system across multiple criteria. Concept 3 performs the best overall, scoring positively in 8 criteria areas including type of material, cost, steering wheel wrapping, ergonomics, type of constant velocity joint, weight, and safety. It scores neutrally in 2 criteria and does not have any negative scores. Concept 1 scores positively in 3 criteria but negatively in 4 criteria. Concept 2 scores positively in 2 criteria, neutrally in 6 criteria, and does not have any negative scores.

    Original Description:

    hihi

    Original Title

    Pugh Selection

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    This document compares three concepts for a steering system across multiple criteria. Concept 3 performs the best overall, scoring positively in 8 criteria areas including type of material, cost, steering wheel wrapping, ergonomics, type of constant velocity joint, weight, and safety. It scores neutrally in 2 criteria and does not have any negative scores. Concept 1 scores positively in 3 criteria but negatively in 4 criteria. Concept 2 scores positively in 2 criteria, neutrally in 6 criteria, and does not have any negative scores.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    8 views3 pages

    Functionality Concept 1 Concept 2 Concept 3 Shape of Steering Wheel Round D-Shape Elongated

    Uploaded by

    Fadhlan Syahidi Shaari
    This document compares three concepts for a steering system across multiple criteria. Concept 3 performs the best overall, scoring positively in 8 criteria areas including type of material, cost, steering wheel wrapping, ergonomics, type of constant velocity joint, weight, and safety. It scores neutrally in 2 criteria and does not have any negative scores. Concept 1 scores positively in 3 criteria but negatively in 4 criteria. Concept 2 scores positively in 2 criteria, neutrally in 6 criteria, and does not have any negative scores.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 3

    Functionality

    Concept 1

    Concept 2

    Concept 3

    Shape of
    steering wheel

    Round

    D-Shape

    Elongated

    Type of end rod

    Tie Rod

    Ball joint

    Heim Joint

    Stainless steel

    Alloy steel

    - corrosion resistance

    - Less brittle

    Aluminium
    alloy

    - high strength
    - can be cut, welded,
    formed, machined
    and fabricated
    readily.

    - greater strength and


    toughness

    Mechanically

    Hydraulic

    Material

    Type of
    movement

    - light weight
    - durable metal
    - soft

    Electronic

    Cost

    Steering wheel
    wrapping

    Ergonomic

    Type of
    constant
    velocity joint

    Expensive

    Polyurethane

    Comfortable

    Average

    Leather

    Non-slip

    Cardan joint

    Pin Type

    - High strength
    transmitted
    - unable to maintain
    constant velocity
    - limited angle

    - wide angle covered


    - low torque
    transmitted

    Cheap

    Fabric

    Sweat absorb

    Rzeppa type
    CV joint

    - able to withstand
    much greater torque
    angle
    - wide angle covered

    Criteria

    Concept 1

    Concept 2

    Concept 3

    Standard
    Steering
    System

    Shape of
    steering
    wheel
    Type of end
    rod

    Material

    Type of
    movement

    Cost

    Steering
    wheel
    wrapping
    Ergonomic

    Type of
    constant
    velocity joint
    Weight

    M
    Safety

    You might also like