0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 3K views16 pagesVolume 66, Issue 1
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
volume sixty-six, issue 1
september 21, 2020
Masthead Editor's Address
managing editor-in-chief Greetings from the new beginning ofthe same end,
‘aya morgan
‘This is our very first quar made paper and we are bringing it to
content editor-in-chief you smoking hot ikea late night plz (contactless delivery
Tucas huntsman merkur Spl). The Garg i eurrently operating from te basement of
‘every library on the UofT campus, aswell as several
‘production manager ‘disclosed octions throughout the GTA. We are wrapped in
snnika eller blankets and tear soaked foe masks wondering, alongwith
‘you, i this is indeed the en.
copy editor
tava tar But inspite ofall ofthat, we are trumpeting ou triumphant
ett from the baren wastes of lockaown! And boy, have we
arts & culture {got content for you. The new editorial team brought thee all
ash man & uvinapersaud With Chicago stl citations, ruminations on the tials of online
‘school, and some new U of Fmascotst
opinions
cole sandblo Tey stark Were so proud of or team of editors and brave contibutors
who gave their energy towards this greasy li publication.
avant-garg ‘Times are tough and ining ime to ereate is hard. We really
‘iam p. bryant & joshua bienstock appreciate everyone in our Gargoyle fail editors,
eontrbutors, and readers alike. You make this paper what its
polities ‘Thank you for sticking with ws
alex heyman
sree kovaes
Stay sexy and remember you're not lone — we're eying to,
Lucas Huntsman Merkur & Maya Morgan
distributor Editors-in-Griet
this could be you!
staff emeritus
‘anTitsang
Sront cover
as huntsman meri & ma
morgan
back cover
Jas huntsman meri maya morgan
‘contributors
Sstin patrick
bear shit,
esther smerek
‘ews
About us
‘The Gargoyles University College's easiest student newspaper and publishes every two weeks.
‘Weare a paper that believes that sometimes youshould be angry, and that sometimes you should
be loud, andi you have not hada voice before you deserve a voice. We donot give print space to
‘igo and we do not feign neutrality on ses of social justice. At this moment everything in our
‘office is being hosted by UC admin,
Production bi-weekly in the aether.
ucgargslea gmaicom/ submissions uegaryoyle.ca
woagargovlecaShould We
Abolish the
Police?
How can we live with
them? Can we live without
them?
‘alex heyman
(CW: police wolence
In May 2020, Minneapolis plie killed a Black
American man named George Floyd, Witnesses’ cll
phone videos eaprured Floyd repeating "I eant
breathe” as officer Derek Chauvin knelt on his nec
"until he asphyxiated. Floyds ast moments echoed
those of Eric Garner, choked to death by NYPD.
offers in 2014, whose pleas of "ean breathe
tured the phrase int a rallying ery fora wave of
racial justice activism inthe mid-2010s. Floyd's death
contributed ta sina resurgence of protest,
especialy inthe U.S. and Canada, against police
brutality toward racalized people. Inthe following
‘weeks and months, poice attempted to eruh even
Peaoefl protests with ruthless tacts, inching
rubber bullets, tear gas (a chemical weapon that's
ben banned in wear singe the 1928 Geneva
conference), and trapping groups of protesters in
ase arrest, even i their only offense
‘was violating a mid-evening curfew that was also pi
in place to quell the protests. These ations, ecard
on video (even when police retaliated violently fori),
only strengthened ant-poice sentiment.
the post-George Floyd era are cls to
nePolice~ usually meaning that cities
Should reduce ther police fores' proportionally very
high operating budgets and invest the extra funds in
non-violent emergency response services, public
Schools, anti-poverty and ant-homelessness
programs, ete These changes, the thinking goes,
Wwould make the marginalized communities that police
Aisproportionately brtalize safer and more
Dresperons, as well as les likely to engage in behavior
Aleered criminal inthe fist pace
A minority of activists take things one step further
however, and seek to # AbolishThePolice entire
(Sometimes, they phrase it as above; other times, they
to "defund the police" by which they mean “take
away al police fads" The word “func is
Ambiguots like that.) Among those in earshot who
aren of the ani-plice-activist persuasion, police
abolitionisn nay trigger a particular knee-jerk
Fesponse: "Without police, no one will bey the law,
tnd society wil descend into ehaon” Ihave to admit
this intuition has tation in my evn mind, thoagh as
good skeptic I need to examine it areilly to make
Sure my imagination isn just shackled by copaganda,
Inthis arti, IM give my best shot at explaining the
reasoning behind both the pro-abolition and
anti-aboliton postions, and then eritically assess
both
For anarchists, police abolition isa natural part of
the overall project of abolishing the state ~ though
T doubt that everyone who's eaed for police
abolition recently is explicitly an anarchist-1
Suspect that in many eases, their abolitonism
‘originates less in high-minded poiial theory than
indirect, grounded observation oftheir own social
realities, Police in xr society do lite ta help
marginalized communities. They rarely bother
themselves with marginalized people's concerns
and grievances, denying marginalized people ste
And legal routes of expressing them. Their main
interaction with marginalized communities i
patrolling them for shat the sate deems
Criminality ~ harassing, inearcerating, and even
Jing their members ~ just to ensure they're nota
threat tohigher-status people, seemingly the aly
‘people thatthe police really “serve and protec"
‘An! comminities of those higherstatus people ~
‘what do they need the police for, other than
‘maintaining thie relative position on the social
ladder? Police barely even visit their communities,
letalone arrest anyone there. In the end, any good
the police do is absolutely dwarfed by the harm
‘they if, bath directly and by reinforcing
systemic inequality. The solution is obvious: just
get rid ofthe.
{suspect that, in contrast, those opposed to police
abolition tend to base their view (explicitly or
Implietly) on abstract theories of how society
finetions. To them the term “police” does not refer
‘only tothe specific institution of policing in our
Society i's a synonym fr the general concept ofa
State la enforcement organization. This is hove
‘youl typically see “police” defined in detonavies
(oot that they're infalible authorities on what 2
‘word means or should" mean to be clea).
1 likely thatthe politica theories of our society's
Anti-aboltioniss are rooted in our society's
‘dominant political tradition of liberalism,
Stretching back to Thomas Hobbes in rth-century
England. (It's worth noting that despite Hobbes
strong influence on liberalism, he stands out in
favoring monarchy over representative democracy.)
Hobbes believed that violence beyets violence (and
poverty) by destroying people's ability to trust each
tether and cooperate. The only way for people to
escape this eel of violence so, va collective
agreement, creat a state and give it the authority
tw enforce cortain rules goveraing peoples behavior
iolently, if necessary. As sociologist Max Weber
athave putt, Hobbes thinks that if people
‘ont want to fear violence from each other, they
‘must give an entity a monopoly on the estimate
tse of violence. (For Weber, thisis the very
Sefton ofa state.) Hobles was eoncerningly
‘unconcerned about the state abusing ts power
later iberal theorists would attempt to avoid this
problem by recommending systems, suchas elected
representatives, for keeping the state accountable
to the people. These theorists intended for some
aspects ofthe state's behavior to be more malleable
by public opinion than others the hardest 0
change were constititional rights designed to
proteet minorities from majorities and the electoral
power they wield in their numbers.
In this view, police are simply the division ofthe
state responsible for enforcing the law in evi
contexts Ifyou break the la, then isthe job of
the courts to decide your punishment ~totell you
to paya fine oF goto prison or what-have-you ~ but
it the police who will make you do what the courts
say ifyou don't do it voluntarily Ifyou don pay
your taxes, the police wil make you you reise
{oeven paticipate in the judicial process, the
police wll make you. Ideally, the police won't even
Ihave to use tele power that often the mere fact
that they could acts as a deterrent for disobedience
‘Studies might shov that police only solve X percent
‘of erimes, Dut even if the fail more often than not,
‘X might sil be high enough that many potential
ritinals aren’ willing to take the risk The value
‘of policing sin al ofthe crime ~and especially inthe violence ~ that does? happen, not justin the
police response to the rime that does happen
People obey the lw out of fear of panishment. If
there are no plie, there sno punishment, and
thus no incentive to obey the a If there's no in
‘centive to obey the law, then there's effectively no
Taw, and no state, and we all return to Hobbesian
violent anarchy
As pto-abolitonists are eager to point out,
however, liberal democratic societies have long
suffered from design fas that prevent them from
ing up evento thei own ideals. For instance,
bert theorists likeJohin Locke envisioned aright
tomateral property almost as unconditional as
those to ie and Hert, and this has permitted the
‘evelopment of vast economic inequality on|
‘account of how, ita free market, geting money is
tesier the more money yon already have. (Locke
justified this by claiming that his preferred
fconomy, even the poor are better off than they
be without state, Whether or aot this is true,
Locke's design is still very far from optimal given
teverythinga state can do) This economic
‘nequality often translates nto equally severe
social and political inequality, due to insufficient
legal safeguards against the rich buying elections
and dominating eltute via mass media, Making
tnatters worse is the limited distribution of
constitutional rights at the outset of iberal
‘democracies such asthe U.S: ifony white men can
‘ot, then the stat sony accountable to white
‘nen (and everyone else can only make themselves
heard by disrupting the functioning of society and
‘making the alread-powerfl afraid ofthe
‘consequences of not listening). Meanwhile, to
preserve their own poser, the already poserfl
Fight to farther disenfranchise the aleeady-weak
and they sueceed to a dangerous dagre because of
the existing power gap. This vious yee of n=
fealty tends toward an ottcome in which the
State ~ including, of course the police ~ heed only
the will ofthe powerful, and the west re left with
‘only enough if, liberty ad propery to be eal
tools for their superiors,
Furthermore, Hobbes’ dichotomy’ betwoen a
society with state and violent chaos is false one.
There exist, and have always existed tatcless
societies tha enforce rule of conduct ina
‘decentralized fashion, Punishments may be violent
(eg beating, killing exile) or non-violent Ce
‘ostracization)~ andl while the frequency of
‘olence varies from one scietyto the next, we
{know of no instance in whichis totaly absent.
Stateles societies also tnd tobe small ~ small
‘enough to feasibly maintain a consensus on wha
‘constitutes unacceptable behavior, so they don't
form ireeonelabl conflicting factions and break
apart
This articles still about police abolitionism, 1
‘swear ~ bit {think ts informative that that
subject has led me into so rich diseussion of
broader issues Police violence against
‘marginalized people in our society is rooted in
Structural problems that keep the law and the state
beholden tothe interests of some people much
‘more than others, To eliminate this form of
‘opptesson once and forall, those who are
‘rrently marginalized must be given the voice in
‘ur sciey’s governance that they have deserved
al along, and tat the philesophy behind our
politics has promised them. But are wet achieve
Sich a thing through evoltion or revoltion, and
Felatdly, what magnitude of change is necessary?
T won't ty to resolve this longstanding debate here
and now, but close by commenting oni
To the evoltionaries, I say this: t's okay to
estroy something tht performs an important
fimetion a lng a8 you have something else lined
‘upto replace it with It night turn out, fr
instance, thatthe culture of existing police
‘departments sso messed up that it remains a
Ihuge obstacle to ending police brutality regardless
of broader changes in society (Foran illustration,
See the Medi article "Confessions of a Former
Bastard Cop”) In this situation, even ifyon think
society needs something lke police, we might need
to disband our existing police organizations and
scemble new ones ith few ono members rom
the old ones.
To the revolutionaries: [won't try to quash your
ambition, but keepin mind that ifyour plan
involves everyone behaving pro-socaly in the
coimpete absence of violent coercion, centralized oF
fat = of fit involves stateless cooperation on the
Seale of, sa, the industrial supply ehains that make
‘modern technology possible~ thea what you're
planning is anthropotogically precedente. And
Above all, make ste you have a plans again, i's
okay to destroy something that performs an
Timportant fnetion as long as you have something
‘lene upto replace seth, Perhaps yo think
‘jetory over oppression Is historially inevitable,
bu if tha’ tre, its because people work to
‘understand how a world better than their own ean
test as well a 10 make that world realityA Publication
Too Far
Justin patrick
academia inthe ats century difficult to
navigate nite, but is toghet doing eas a
sudent In my experience in graduate tds, it
oten fc ike fs more ofa networking ame than
ssthing. Networking cars ference eters and
reference etter earn admission to competitive
programs funding and event tenure-track job
opportunites I ved to look at Northrop Frye asa
Kopefl example that ould perhaps be replete
He made sgnfeant poisons and evenly
came profesor sethout a PhD other ord,
Fthoght that pblcations could bea way to
transcend the networking nightmare of worrying
a en toa profesor could be misinterpreted and
esd to abridge birme,aeter short on
spplicton, and an ery en to an sade earer
Tse abeays denpsed this imterdependent aspet of
academia since fee Hike al of ty grades and
ting ar not enough; ike need to be
chaperoned as fmy stent status makes me les
person. Now, however ann nse writing
one's way to an exo of independence spose
During my master's, {ied a numberof
way to game te sytem of academia
Smite to conferences without
expicly statng that wa a stent and
not correcting the response enals
resing me as-Prfeso" which once
reaifed ina funded conference toa
sll erica Pla Science
Associaton spinoff conference where only
one other student presented. became
tdieted to writing cadre book reviews
forany journal or platform that would
take high onthe cheap th fee
Books and the que traaround of
publications Seven book reviews fom
HNetand a rapagassortnent of todent
journals wer enh of bis to
Eoin oumal with an impact factor to
send mea book to reve
Trspedupan over 60-000.ont amc
during iy masters and submited ittoa
high-end publisher fo one their shorter book
Publications, Imad it tothe review pace, For
ot the nes five months, responded othe
Comments of editors and three reviewers By some
nial, the manag survived. However, ight
Tnforethe editorial board was to delve their
vend they asad me to send my CV's second
te. Then, nother ena came nad al
te crashing down, They esentily
onplinented me on the writing bt old me that
Tease Teas sent hey dd nt wart to
Dbl canes got a proesor to jonas
‘over, eventhough the Dook was already
‘writen. There was no eseape No matter how hard
work, ial eame back to newerking, sent
ermal on to ew anders versed inthe opie,
Tntnone woud go for
rea, thene was Researcher
cade social media site where frum
omments cout toward your profiles
pat factor. Aer year of emnening
on arson thread, ny Researchate
score rose higher than some professors
ny departments, While many graduate
stunts are inte interme of publishing
Spportintis often not publishing nt
their PD dsertation or only as
ewes with hee superssars
ought hada ehanee to defy the odds
and move to bigger publetions to cement
an ealy status asa expert in my esearch
opie not veto wom ae ch aboot job
pplication, a above al propose
l-neted poly recomendations
sooner ater than ater
Toad another dimension to this ny research
topi fs stidentgoverament In ser words was
‘eting about polite sytem in which Iam. a
iret participant, and even so, was stil shut out
Furthermore there ea sick ey ih eich scholars
on this topic oie the writings of student leaders
‘who dled young, obsessing aver the even the mast,
‘ninasol esp of wing ef bein fra
"vents taken too soon Irene that my writing
‘oul be worth more to thse scholars were
ded than fer aie Maybe this jst a ba
txperience Maybe another pbsher wil ake the
Took or other shorter publeatons could make i
throng. Upon starting s PhD. program, 1 dead
the eating being second las tien before
the ints ofthe ory tower
Lie Cea aeGap Years for
“Grown Ups”
why this is the perfect year to take a
semester off
SN ee
ssc,
a Sezer cs ahem
[2 imerecrttentn ceiaugane
og) Soe rece nt aoe
:
-
—
—
~~ =
-
-
-
-
| —_tnany stents have registered and paid for
| Signifeant portion of thet yearly tition, Td take to
-thesteets every night~naked lee witha
\, _seeapionerating oral oso ditch this yar
Te
— ~~
However, sine this is not a easonble proposal or
‘ny conades without liniess tine, sggest i
ead that you it your course oad so that yo ean
ese oer things. What are the grounds on which
____Viake this argument? Wel
2. You need a bre
nese es Te igh on the pce
Proc on Concentrating on
« ital object foros fhe day can et
Were a week note semester and ale ital
Siders despot and wringing theta fg mbosble combine tht with he at hat
Fens one reply sear hat schoo en one of your works geting an tangible or
| tow of eamingand ops signe’, ch nteretonal edb and you may fel ke
Sounds sol eshing at ts worst and aenatingat ff M2" zetingabsclatey nothing done. For
statin one sumnerscholandthagh any dens his eases them top een
ret hres of pages week apes ost or pressre on themselves og something
pees weck an pope cove, ich exes ven noe dates ad
begat eee that wrecks the hel ofthe beain
sd he quality of work
paper after pape would not be ale ol on
“ne thing ered Consider that yx it
F thermmber of asses you tke onlin, you wl get
“todo more of your degree in-person and may
— therefore retain more knoe, You probably need a beak even yo fe ike
vou dont need one {took Break fom schoo in
Tul and withina moth Iwas able to wake up
ees thou pangs of terror and my nausea abated
. The tine that ay fee wasted from not taking
more classes isesreely salable Sou use to
help ourselfevena ite
Nowa great tne odo yon do part oft
Athome: ny two ont fsa ve Fr you si yoredoing what yon want tobe
Picked up fm photog started ating ion
together pore snd han eter coe time off and away om your area
‘endoratsomeleiinate fetal Taking my MM stay Ean be more wef in understanding what
My series ssomehing have alsa wanted ME Soue learning anti contmuation When!
664 os and a gration draws nearer the Tooke of tom Pica! Scene and
BESS: possity orcas tang tine to workon my ME Ptosopty treated how warped rain had
Big ert scesfrher and ferther sway With Tome = procesing al phenomenon ssl
Everthingin fv and legitimate employment. MW constructed or as an edge sie
Pipedream foros of now's the time totale Mla fastened ides ofan joy on me and
that one in-aiion shot before yu have © qt thinking about te meaning of human existence
Som eft me pure to anthingyeth
‘Wort entescnai, dons work ot and svn ny ie ie.
Schoo ht theo jmp Bak it, To
B isstrdin temas quote: hing that ne ‘Your majors may note ding this toon bit
f were doingare worth sing ir good tosep bck even alte tse what
ae Sour area of sty iturin onto. You iy
{Sacver tha ou ae dng xsl what yo
rat tobe doing and tra with «nena
{Speciation ory ay be faced wah heat
tha you ned gu Ether way, Be
Sevingyounel lt of tie dow the toad and
lncovering things about yourself in he proses
TENT ber ended up dropping
«ally summer courses after the mterns
Bcase Iwas doingso pory: Obviously, now
that my experience not universal but i's
harder todo well when your'e not engaged, and
ros students that Ie spoken to are checked the
Ill out. Confer honestly with yourself ae you
sping ove any motivation in wo weeks? &
‘oath? Si? ot, consider iting the dainage
ices tv beerto jut est oes :
v ay ae
Aad etn
feebHow Are We All
Going to Survive
This Year?
online school’s problem is that it’s online
lucy stark
‘Thanks for asking. but no, Lhave not attended any
ofthe CLNS workshops for being an effective
‘alne lamer or ting time ecient
Why? Because jst ike the classes they are
supposed tel wth thse workshops are also
online
‘One week nto the fall semester and my brains
being destroyed by the endless oop of aria
sere and lokig tthe asiterented faces fm
pees on BB Collaborate, Just ding! You eat
‘ven fol yourself int thinking there are other
people gong through the same thing beease no
‘ne want tenon theireameras. And why
‘wo they ett? With he eames fy can
istract ore ro the pointless online Tete
by coking stretching or dng ting else
lrg it love stretching o siting outside during
hy leeture whenever is possible because, forthe
eof me, Leannot itil and stare ata compte
srmen for more than go mites. And tha’ nak
te trsngto subtly Nex how disconnected oo)
Tram Gs not like when Lott stdents are ke
ea gt 2 hours fle lst night” and they
| want you to be impressed). im genuinely envious
| ofthe people who ar abl foes completely
‘uring online lected meetings ye ont
there pleat help me ost.
|
"think the most concerning partis thatthe most
‘cent way to spend yor school day =a i, the
‘ay you'e going to got the most dane and have
the most ime isto stayin one roo al dT
{id that yesterday. woke up at 9 (sleeping
Inter than sual sone ofthe oly tings ke
aout onlin learning) and frm 9am to 1 pm,
‘id ot eve my room except to ge od. This
1s Ineredibly. Unhealthy. Most ether days,
‘would take # break to go fora walk orn or
Something ouside, bt beeause of my seed
‘only had time odo my breaks inside. And what
‘avy when you have break? You wateh TV
‘or Vote, To do my workoat yesterday 1
Watched a YouTube exercise torial So, even
‘uring my healthy tine as staring a9
Seren 'm reli o sound as nooner
2 posable, burg, think the boomers were
Fight about his one: we're aay ooking a ou
«damn phones (or eomputes).
Not changing my setting, not having eh i, not
fecing people face to-fae—also why does the dea
lofrbrenknt rooms" eae me toners set,
Bat meeting up wth strangers in real ife sounds
so apprting?those things areal adding ip and
making me worried el about the esto tis
Sear This only weck Whats going to happen
‘ven the mater gts harder oF we get exas?
(Or when i gets way to cold os ontsid and do
‘work? What happens when the second COVID
‘nae isa we ea even meet ip wth ove
‘ses frends olive outside of ur homes?
Pessimism tothe MAX, eae But, thought by
geting out al ofthese ears andeoncers, abe
ble read ver and know exactly wht | shonld
ddothin year give myself breaks fom the
‘compute. It's gong to be har to bid those
‘reas ino ny Schedule an eomtinue to gh for
‘hem agalast the immense pressure to always be
‘working of be productive. Reminder to sap
Today willy ie long with my ptf
don't prioritize tines o walt Qoees Park or
‘he grocery store or erally walk to Missing 1
{hi online lacing might be amazing forms
tales (calveson our bodies are spelled the sme
{sthe word for a baby ow? Cite,
a
ant to escape to “The Lakes" hat Tylor Swi
sigs about on her boas trek of Folkore~
natre wil be ny savior this year: Whether hat ay
means esting fey baked bead fom nature's =
‘eat or sol training myself to on far enough
twenjoy varias green parades devoid of ig
sgaces (Queen's Parks geting ait repetitive at
this olny wanna run so ofr, bu resting a
{he caléTovontoalris eal
“TL:DR: fy want to print ot pages of your
line textbook and met pat» part sy
Snthotsereens, pease HMU! Once I ets 00 cold
(nz eks), eat dot do though?A™\is ©
Odin Who?
CULta Be
Looking for Queer Rep in Norse Mythology
neiltiams
‘The people want tospeak to—mosty white middleclass
‘queers probably find the image I present fara:
‘Ament o something from the interme, about gender.
‘Specifically, itis about the gender ofthe Old Norse deity
(or the Marvel Franchise character?) Lok. This
untrustworthy; shapeshifing, adopted child is regularly
regaded as an excelent example of queer representation
inmth orn poplar media, fu in gender and sexily.
‘Tobe quite bunt, hate this notion, Queer people, being
se rootless are always seronging around for role models
land exemplars to identity with and celebrate To be
represented isto be sen: tbe seen isto know you exist. 1
ow the weird loneliness of existing without a mold of
‘who you are, an ideal of who you could be, but take
‘offense because the discourse surrounding Lak tips her
‘ofthe contest of her queemess. Very specially, LOI
(anal coded) takes on the form ofa mare to lure agian
horse away from his construction project, thus becoming
pregnant with ol. Lak transgresses the limits of her
‘assigned gender, but the version of Loki people identify
With is non-transgressive. Theres ver tle tha’ tly
untoward inthe raver-haired pretty Doy/gel who
represents Lot inthe popular imagination and the
‘question “Ist gay to fek a horse ifyou are also a horse
And defending the interests af the gods?” Is nt even in
play. Lok is id sure but tame, simpler fr the sake of
Saying ves, that’s me!” and for selling comics. Engaging
withthe original mater reveasa more complicated
Image. Engagement should not only rediacover queerness
‘bu suggest different Kind of identification aswel. "Yes,
that’s ie” not the representation Pm ater—and think
yat shonld want something diferent too. We might find
‘what I'm looking for in another character from Nordic
poetry Ooimn.
‘rm not referring to Odin, whose names crude angiciza-
ton ofthe word which appears in the vigil sourees and
‘sho seems litle more than alight ystial patie
Headey in the poplar consciousness I want ote.
shou Odin The Iike oan expression of surprise
$Thevo ike thet in moter father and oer) «queer
icon ther eve was one. But Before we de into the gy
{etal yon should know more about Odin sat
“Though we know the most about Gi fom Ola Norse
tests haling from medieval eda, Odin was wor.
hipped rom the Roman acpation of Germania t the
‘ike age, from Seandnava fo ental rope to -
‘and: Xe discovered the rune alphabet, ges favor in
{ntl Knows almost everthing butte universe rom a
ints corpse, rules hat ever, sad to have founded
Tan royal ieages, and eats numerous asolatons
sr pty and fervor, death and mage. The base reasons
for Oainsqueernoss are prety simple: xe performed
gender and sewalty ina non-normative ay Though very
thucha patriarchal hea dey, muipe sources repr
that Odi spent some tine ing on an land to practice
feminne-coled magi, which st sey ving aa woman,
“Additonal Ob’ wie, rag atone with
‘Srbrothers(peraps during OO shame gender
‘ile. Gains reters maybe hypestases-Uit It say
Ssernate entities ofthe eal dey ell So Odin ie
tian wh hel folvelikea worn (Wont gain.
ces feminine sree) and has sx wth women er
tap wile exile for beng worn and perhaps under
the guise of being two other men? This sal chamef,
Strange and eve the wrsreness ofthe sian sinks of
quernes.
‘But what makes Odian especialy interesting tome, and es
pecially valuableas a queer role model, isi strange class
‘character and how they osilate between a normative po-
‘ition anda non- normative one. In adition to stepping
the boundaries of wr assigned gender, Odinn alo violates
‘rupper-class position. In many adventures, inn takes
‘on the persona of an old wanderer who is delassé or
maybe even outside lass. At one time, dinn-the-wanderer
‘is welcome in the halls ofthe high, a another, xe is
Smprisoned on sight (eta some magical interference, but
nonetheless). And ually, Onn comes to trek and defeat
those xe wists: stealing the mead of poetry from
landowning giants or orchestrating the death ofa king xe
‘once favored. But Otani welcome among slaves too, who
‘xeisjustas happy to deceive, kil, and replace forthe sake
fof some scheme Odinn is dangerous to everyone. Odin
always looks ater xi own interest, the interests of
Asgard, the home of the ruling elites. Sot comes as no
‘surprise that when Lok (never an insider among the gos,
4 foreigner) comes to inslt her adopted fais O8inn
‘who shames Loki for having indulged a pervert’ way of
living’ Gi JeeKson Crawford's translation) or wonanish
sways (in Lee M- Hollander’). None ofthese translators are
brave enogh to render the line ina way with any
contemporary resonance, but the real sense ofthe phrase s
Something likes" see that u're a fucking faggot" OF
‘otee, Lak urs the same accusation right back at Odinn,
‘but soon finds herself thrown out nthe cod, For all the
shame that follows O8inn and Lak it is xe who keeps it
et at the table and no wonder, Odinn can wear adres or
ft wanderer’ lak but was always in charge. And Odinn
fan sleep with any woman x kes, almost without consent
‘And Odinn can decide who vil survive and wo wil die on
the bated, whichever serves xem best And Gdinn will
Allston a throne, with birds and wolves who pick st
corpses by xirside, whether or not they were judged the
‘worthiest to live. think I've heard of contemporary Odinns
fut there, who begile the vulnerable with thelr bain
intelligence, whe hurt people and disguise their deeds with
the language of theraps als known as ‘rune magic), and
‘who want fo look poterless wile holding many more cards
than they show. As we have see, thisisa tremendously
‘dangerous postion to occupy but where giants are fooked
bby Oainn, their small servants end up dead
‘There may be just one oF two possibly redeeming features
n Gdinn's character. ea thik of notrats person with as
‘many names ad identities (sin has dozens f tiles and
nieknames). And Lean think oo person more eam mitted
toself-transformation, whether by becoming a hawk or
‘woman-soreeres, whether by cutting ont xi eye for
Knowledge oF ding ad coming hack oie 0 Tera the
nes. Odin is alway switching skins and identifiers
ways making journeys int the anknown, going a far as
{omotlate srs iit Teas to Tearing, Odinn not on a
‘quest to find some true, genine, o ‘essential self. Xe
‘ses self lke a tool, turning it over and inside out,
‘becoming what suits xem best forte ime being. What
could be queere than that?
Don't let me take your representation away from you but
Jet me suagest a more complicated relationship the
figtes yo identify with, Heng Odin fa terse thi
(itera, xeis named Ygg—the terrible one), but after
reading this hope you ean see something of yourselfin
‘vip (the changeable one) and something you might be
agree that tobe seen isto exist, but Taso believe that the
best recognition comes not from meeting your tin but
sour shadow, We meet ourselves every day andl probably
‘ont notice bt itis a rare and valuable thing to meet an
other who reminds you of yourself as much as they dont 1
Fhope you dont want tobe someone else completely not jst
because you'd be giving up your chaie over wo you are,
‘but because to accept seh a simple arrangement I oten to
Jose consciousness ofthe dif of yur positon. By
sing not just wto you ae it who you are not, you hone
sour sense of
sou may find
toadopt but always to exist near, comfortably ad
‘uneontortably, for better and wore. You are not one ting,
franother; yu arein Mux, just as Odinn wasOn-Screen
Academics
ashman
1. Ryan Reynolds in Van Wilder
If acategory of hotness could apply to Ryan Reynoks even bya
slaring stretch of said eategorys definition he wl be squarely
place a the top ofthis group's rankings.’ Seine. Although
an Wilde is nto fri iatenion to Academia and
focuson the unsanttoned and raucous elements of eam Is be
spends Seven years in univers. You kw who ese dos that?
(Gad student I's Math TM, Despite the overwhelming appeal of ts
lee, this movi is ot what yon wold conser watchable. Do
sourela favor and wath iterally any ther Ryan Rel
rove except Waiting)
2. Viol Davis in How to Get Away with Munder
{still haven’ decided ike this show, but knew rom the fst
times er om seen that Eloved Viola Dis din etch
tnt deen of his seees to ind ot they ata ha ge way
th murder buf they ida, woulda’ consider tis show
instructive, Maybe try the'For Dummies’ guides instead,
{3 ily Blunt in The Five-Year Engagement
This one's Halpert approve.
4. Denzel Washington in The Great Debaters
felin love when my debate coach made ws watch this movie. We
was nme in st place it that wast Dena fa
5:Julla Roberts in Mona Lisa Smile
{once spent five days writing an essay outline contrasting the
Aepction of New England traitonliem a the proresive
‘hinking of West Cost Academia Min his ove never wrote
‘ha essay but Ti writing this ht now, supe was al
fornaught
6.Tom Hanks n The Da Vine Cae
"gerne thought twas hil prodigy for reading this book in
‘heft grade It contbated mor ome than it adaptation
‘id tothe word of ema, bt the ln stillserves up some Ron
Howard-brand vanil-yogur mediocrity. The eal sues that his
rovisries getaway with formally ving its protagonist 2
new brillant blackhaired bet for alove interes sidekick three
times ina rom Tom Hank seat nside and oat and we al
Jew he deserves better than ths preditbii
17-RenedctCumberbate n-The Imitation Game
‘The man tat inspired leagues of women to cll themselves
Caer in his et role to date
8, Pal Bettany in A Resi Mind
His character wasnt rel but my felings for him were
69. Harrson Ford in Raiders ofthe Last Ark
This ones only s0fardown the Ist because fe deep
paternal connection otis character and 'm not about hat. Ps,
this point nhs ie, Academia TM was ost Indiana’ ame side
hustle that eld his passion ~ ransacking sated sites ad iting
Ne
The Zodiacs
When They’re
High AF
uvina persaud
Capricorn
December 2-Jansary 19
can you say paranoia?
Aquarius
Santary 20 - February 8
“Tolerances high you outdo snoop doggy dges 81 bunts aay. Kudos to
‘yout frend, Blaze uppppo
Pisces
Febriary19- March 20,
Gets the manehies at 2am ane cannot for he feof them decide what to
fas they js end up staring into the de for 30 minutes wating foe
Soniething to magia appear
Aries
‘March 21 Api 39
inalyyy ils the ack oat
Taurus
‘Apr 20- May 20,
Literally cannot stp as
Gemini
May-June 20
Congratulations on reaching nina oh great ones
Cancer
Tune 2 -July
‘oes nt eave the couch for several horse theyre to high they cant
et
Tul 25 - August 22
“Thinks thew a comedian and wont tp telling jokes bt ays
somehow so high they forget the pinching
Virgo
Augis 25 September 22
‘Conspiracy theorist,
Libre
September 29 -October 22
Cano eontro their emotions gong from fs of lughter to baling their
foro ino. seconde at
Scorpio
(ctobr2g-November 21
{sgt it onnnnn ala Mavn Gaye
Sagittarius
November 22 December 21
Socrates who? Sagitaris isthe el pilosopher her. Thinking about
thir exstetil ers tl thei head explodesPlan a Date to Find
Out Which
Academia™ Hottie
You Are
ashman
1. What you wil eat:
2) Chareutere board
1) Carnitas tacos
€) Pork enderoin
{Beet hourguignon
©) Dali sandwiches
2. For dessert
8) Cream puts
Pudding
«© Pecan pie
creme bebe
©) Sale doughnuts
13. Acockal to help ital go down:
2) Sauvignon bane
b) Whiskey
©) Bourbon on the rocks
4) Merlot
©) Cotton candy vodka
4: deal ven
8) Pienie
b)acwe
«) Candle-it table at home
Bistro
©) The couch
5 Ifthis date could occur anywhere inthe word, you would choose:
Italy
b)Per
€) New York
‘Pars
©) Michigan
6. Most likely topic ofdiseussion to flex that you're in Academia
An
b) Archaeology
©) Contemporary legal issues
History
©) Psychology
7-What you wil wear
2) Plaid blouse and slacks
1) Khaki. Bversthing
©) Blazer and dress pants
@Asuit
} Sweats
8.TV viewing forthe post date cil
8) ILove Lucy
Gunsmoke
«True Detective
{History Channel
) Sorubs
Ifyou got mostly 4's
You're Julia Roberts (AKA Katherine Ann Watson) from Mona
List Smile,
You're tee-thinking and stick to your principles witen push
comes to shove. Your tenacity wins over even the most
"Stubborn of people but sometimes you misplace yo faith in
fathers. When someone breaks your trust, you bounce Baek
‘uickly and easily adap to every change life rings.
Ifyou got mostly B's.
You're Harrison Ford (AKA Indiana Jones) from Raiders ofthe
Lost ark
You're adventurous bt old-school. You know what you want
and tend to gett Love eludes you though you have other
pisstons in your life that keep you busy:
Ifyou got mostly Cs
You're Viola Davis (AKA Annalise Keating) fom How to Get
Away with Murder
You're headstrong and cutthroat. Some fear you, some loathe
ya, but no one underestimates you. You're passionate and
food at what you do with awit sharp enough folet everyone
Kw it However they never see the whole pete; you're a
‘aster at hiding your secrets and keeping the skeletons in your
‘lost Forked aay
Ityou got mostly D's
You're Tom Hanks (AKA Robert Langdon) from The Da Vinet
Code
You're a disciplined and knowledgeable person, which has
brought yo fr, Despite your sucess, yon ind yoteelf alvays
chasing something. Even when you find what you're looking
for, you feel drawn to another searh, always om the nt for
the worlds wonders.
Ifyou got mostly E's
You're Emily Blunt (AKA Violet Barnes) from The Five-Year
Engagement
You don’t take yourself 10 seriously and peopl lve you fort
You ean be gullible at times, but you tend to end up where
you're supposed tobe even if you falloff rack, even iit takes a
wile. You lni-back personality and eense of amour make
Sua keeper well worth the waltProse, Poetry, Allusions of the
Existential Mind:
A Twenty-First Century Quarantine
Collection
Shit, Bear, Bienstock, Joshua
Bryant, Liam P., Smerek, Esther
OR.NPIW,.7H0D NS
GRG469H1F: Avant Garg
21 September 2020Perspectives
after Teletherapy
it is impossible to tell how many chameleons are
inaroom.
a transparent audience to my confusion.
head fog clouds my vision.
it is important to care for and feed the Goldfish in
your mind.
i must care for and feed the Goldfish.
they are relying on me to save them from the
chameleons.
Counsellor
With clammy palms I say grace,
mottled pieces of faith trudging past my nose and
resting on my good favour.
Because I'm lovely and plump, and
imperfect and kind and my heart bleeds without
my permission
and my hair falls in curls around my face.
Yes — Iam a wicked thing, for Love without you
telling me.
Because my hands are calloused and my heart
sings of promise.
And when I see art my eyes sparkle and Iam
raptured
Day ones
Last night, I sat
Cross-legged in the park
Weightless and falling into rapt attention
Ofa boy,
‘Nodding along encouragingly?
As he explained philosophy badly.
Man, I feel like a woman
With clammy palms I say grace,
‘wiping them on my jeans,
muttering my faith:
T'm nota godly man, nor shall I ever be.
I don’t deserve God, and he doesn’t deserve
me
* Bathera Smerek, “Perspectives after Teletherapy”, UC Gargole: Avant Garg, vo.66 (Toronto: Six Months A.C- After Covid, 2020)
2 Bear Shit, “Day Ones”, UC Gargoyle: Avant Gar, voL66 (Toroato: Five ¥¢ Months A.C- After Covid, 2020)
9 Liam P. Bryan, "Counsellor", UC Gargoyle: Avant Garg, vl.66 (Toronto: Five % Months A.C- After Covi, 2020) 2not okay
not okay.
what even is okay?
have i ever been okay?
will i ever be okay?
is there something i can do to ever be okay?
do i even want to be okay?
i want to feel normal, or like i have some grasp
over the life i live.
i want to feel like the main character, the pilot,
the captain, the creator, the owner... the one who
takes up space.
the one who crafts the narrative, the vision of
what is to come, and executes it... deftly dodging
the obstacles that come up along the way.
i want to feel powerful.
i want this life to feel like my own.
but instead, i am not okay, *
not even just “okay”,
i am less than okay,
i am nothing.
i ama ball of confused emotions, a shell without
a pearl, a creature without sentience, a bullet
without a gun, a person without a mind, a mind
without a body.
iam only parts,
only visions of what would have been if,
only a figment of others’ perceptions held
together by little to no effort nor energy nor
will nor ability nor time.
1am but a random association of atoms that
feel some attraction to one another but have
no way of truly connecting.
iam here but also not here at all
am i in transit or did i just never begin the
joumey?
are you okay?
what do you see?
do i feel like something of substance to you?
can you see me differently than i see myself?
can you define me, for me?
can i leam how to be okay through you?
{just tell me what to do, how to think, where
to look, and what to be.
i'll be you so i don’t have to be me.
i'll take that over what i am without you.
i'd rather be okay with you than not okay
with me.
so i'll just be with you,
and then maybe, i'll be okay.
‘Joshua Bienstock, "not okay”, UC Gargoyle: Avant Garg, vol.66 (Toronto: Five's Months A.C- After Covid, 2020)Lebuitwy Gens”
ave whels ths over 2 winlion Files?
‘Senedn in
Oscinvaific cihides © manga.
obooiks odrenms:
Seontrowisrel witter threads
lonce haaa
Stress dream
I Wasenrened
M1 4 class abevt
frogs and Never | fa. 4: but you feo! nothing
Went fe the lectures
“n accident...
the final exam
W45 to stack
them
KIND SMILE
PREFERENCE FOR
COUNTRY-ROCKcomi
ming soon:
swords & sorcery