Rubric To Assess The Design Process

7 6 5 4 3 2 1
SCALE Outstanding Meritorious Substantial Satisfactory Adequate Partial Inadequate
80%-100% 70%-79% 60%-69% 50%-59% 40%-49% 30%-39% 0%-29%

Formulate a Shows an Shows a Shows a Shows a Shows Shows a partial Shows poor to no
design brief. in-depth and thorough substantial satisfactory adequate Understand-ing understand-ing of
comprehensive understand-ing understand- understand-ing understand-ing of formulating a formulating a design
understanding of of formulating a ing of of formulating a of formulating a design brief.. brief.
formulating a design brief. formulating a design brief. design brief.
design brief. design brief.

Research Evidence of in- Evidence of Evidence of Evidence of Evidence of Evidence of Little to no evidence
possible depth research thorough substantial adequate adequate limited research of any research or
solutions with a wide range research with a research with research with a research with with a research is irrelevant
of possible number of a number of number of limited possible possible to the solution.
solutions, which possible possible possible solutions, which solution, which
are clearly, solutions, which solutions, solutions, which are recorded. is not fully
logically and are clearly and which are are clearly recorded
comprehen-sively comprehen- clearly and recorded.
recorded. sively recorded. comprehen-
sively
recorded.

Select, A high level of Thorough Substantial Satisfactory Adequate Limited Little to no evidence
analyse and independent / evidence of evidence of evidence of evidence of evidence of of any analysis or
synthesize creative thought analysing, analysing, analysing, analysing, analysing, synthesis in
information in analysing, synthesizing synthesiz-ing synthesiz-ing synthesiz-ing synthesiz-ing selecting a final
and select a synthesizing and and selecting a and selecting and selecting a and selecting a and selecting a solution.
final selecting a final final solution. a final final solution. final solution. final solution.
solution. solution. solution.

The final The final solution The final The final The final The final The final The final solution is
solution is outstanding/ solution is of a solution is of a solution is solution is solution is incomplete and
exceptional. very high high standard. satisfactory-ily adequate partially disjointed.
  standard. completed.   complete.  
     

Present- The presentation The The present- The present- The present- The present- The present-ation is
ation of final is extremely tidy, presentation is ation is tidy, ation is ation is ation is tidy and untidy and
the solution correct, accurate very tidy, correct, tidy and tidy and accurate in inaccurate.
and complete. It correct, accurate and accurate. generally some
complies fully with accurate and complete. It generally accurate. respects.
the design brief. complete. It complies complies with
  It complies fully fully with the the design brief.
with the design design brief.
brief.
 Rubric To Assess The Design Process
7 6 5 4 3 2 1
SCALE Outstanding Meritorious Substantial Satisfactory Adequate Partial Inadequate
80%-100% 70%-79% 60%-69% 50%-59% 40%-49% 30%-39% 0%-29%

Formulate a Shows an Shows a Shows a Shows a Shows Shows a partial Shows poor to no
design brief. in-depth and thorough substantial satisfactory adequate Understanding understand-ing of
comprehensive understand-ing understand- understanding understand-ing of formulating a formulating a design
understanding of of formulating a ing of of formulating a of formulating a design brief.. brief.
formulating a design brief. formulating a design brief. design brief.
design brief. design brief.

Research Evidence of in- Evidence of Evidence of Evidence of Evidence of Evidence of Little to no evidence
possible depth research thorough substantial adequate adequate limited research of any research or
solutions with a wide range research with a research with research with a research with with a research is irrelevant
of possible number of a number of number of limited possible possible to the solution.
solutions, which possible possible possible solutions, which solution, which
are clearly, solutions, which solutions, solutions, which are recorded. is not fully
logically and are clearly and which are are clearly recorded
comprehen-sively comprehen- clearly and recorded.
recorded. sively recorded. comprehen-
sively
recorded.

Select, A high level of Thorough Substantial Satisfactory Adequate Limited Little to no evidence
analyse and independent / evidence of evidence of evidence of evidence of evidence of of any analysis or
synthesize creative thought analysing, analysing, analysing, analysing, analysing, synthesis in
information in analysing, synthesizing synthesiz-ing synthesiz-ing synthesiz-ing synthesiz-ing selecting a final
and select a synthesizing and and selecting a and selecting and selecting a and selecting a and selecting a solution.
final selecting a final final solution. a final final solution. final solution. final solution.
solution. solution. solution.

The final The final solution The final The final The final The final The final The final solution is
solution is outstanding/ solution is of a solution is of a solution is solution is solution is incomplete and
exceptional. very high high standard. satisfactory-ily adequate partially disjointed.
  standard. completed.   complete.  
     

Present- The presentation The The present- The present- The present- The present- The present-ation is
ation of final is extremely tidy, presentation is ation is tidy, ation is ation is ation is tidy and untidy and
the solution correct, accurate very tidy, correct, tidy and tidy and accurate in inaccurate.
and complete. It correct, accurate and accurate. generally some
complies fully with accurate and complete. It generally accurate. respects.
the design brief. complete. It complies complies with
  It complies fully fully with the the design brief.
with the design design brief.
brief.

  Evidence of Evidence of Evidence of Evidence of Evidence of Evidence of Little or no evidence

Evaluation comprehensive thorough substantial satisfactory adequate limited of any evaluation.
of Product evaluation at all evaluation at all evaluation at evaluation of evaluation at evaluation at
and Process stages of the stages of the all stages of most stages of some stages of some stages of
design process. design process. the design the design the design the design
process. process. process. process.