<ZkbeI_gq_\

IHGYLB?LHA:BGNHJF:PBY

DeZkbq_kdZlZ bgnhjfZpbhggZ l_hjby k_ p_gljbjZ \tjom

R_gtgh\ZlZ _gljhiby KemqZcgZlZ ijhf_geb\Z ; jZaij_^_e_gZ
kihj_^  jZaij_^_e_gb_ gZ \_jhylghkllZ SL k_ oZjZdl_jbabjZ k
R_gtgh\Z_gljhiby
H(X)≡ –∑pilog2pi
R_gtgh\ZlZ_gljhiby+;baf_j\Zg_hij_^_e_ghkllZgZ;ly
baq_a\ZZdhjZaij_^_e_gb_lh_kZfh_^bgibdl_ZdhklhcghkllZgZO
_ ba\_klgh gZitegh lhqgh Dh]Zlh jZa]e_`^Zf_ ^\_ kemqZcgb
ijhf_geb\b ; b M hibkZgb qj_a jZaij_^_e_gb_lh gZ kt\f_klgZlZ
\_jhylghkl Si,j lh fh]Zl ^Z k_ ^_nbgbjZl gydhedh _gljhibb Itj\h
bfZ kt\f_klgZ _gljhiby +;< hkgh\Z\ZsZ k_ gZ Si,j ih ZgZeh]by k
]hjghlhjZ\_gkl\hdhylhhljZay\Zg_hij_^_e_ghkllZgZ;bgZM
H(X/Y)≡ –∑pi,jlog2pi/j=H(XY) – H(Y)
<lhjhbfZmkeh\gZ_gljhibybeb_gljhibygZOijbmkeh\b_M
dhylh__gljhibylZgZOdh]ZlhM_ba\_klghKe_^h\Zl_egh
H(X/Y)≡ –∑pi,jlog2pi/j=H(XY) – H(Y),
dt^_lhSi/j = pipj/pi,jmkeh\gZlZ\_jhylghklgZLagZ_cdbM(d\b\Ze_glgh
_ hij_^_e_gb_lh aZ mkeh\gZlZ _gljhiby < agZ_cdb ; l_
H(Y/X)=H(HY)–+;GZc-k_lg_k_hij_^_ey\aZbfgZ_gljhibyf_`^m;
b<dZlh
H(X:Y)≡ –∑pi,jlog2pi:j = H(X)+H(Y)–H(XY),
dt^_lhSi:j=pipj/pi,j_\aZbfgZlZ\_jhylghklgZLbMLyb]jZ_jheylZgZ
\aZbfgZlZbgnhjfZpbyf_`^m;b<lh_klbgnhjfZpbylZhlghkgh;
dhylh _ ij_^Z^_gZ hl < beb gZfZey\Zg_lh gZ _gljhibylZ gZ ;
^te`Zshk_gZagZgb_lhgZ<bebh[jZlghlh
H(X:Y)=H(X)–H(X/Y)=H(Y)–H(Y/X).
 >ZjZa]e_^Zf_k_]ZbgnhjfZpbhggh-l_hj_lbqghlhhibkZgb_gZ
^\mqZklbqdh\Z d\Zglh\Z kbkl_fZ ;< dt^_lh ; b < kthl\_lkl\m\Zl gZ
^\_ d\Zglh\b ijhf_geb\b beb kl_i_gb gZ k\h[h^Z gZij ]–
dhfihg_glZlZgZqZklbpZktkkibgBa\_klgh_q__^bgd\Zglh\h-
bgnhjfZpbhg_g l_hj_lbq_g nhjfZebatf dhclh kthl\_lkl\m\Z
R_gtgh\ZlZ_gljhibyk_hkgh\Z\ZgZnhgGhcfZgh\ZlZ_gljhibyijb
dhylh jZaij_^_e_gb_lh gZ \_jhylghkllZ k_ aZf_kl\Z hl fZljbpZlZ gZ
ietlghkllZ b kj_^gbl_ klhcghklb k_ aZf_kl\Zl ktk klhcghklbl_ gZ
d\Zglh\hlh hqZd\Zg_ AZ d\Zglh\ZlZ nhg GhcfZgh\Z _gljhiby gZ O
bfZf_
S(X)≡–TrX(ρXlog2ρX),
dt^_lh ρX _ fZljbpZlZ gZ ietlghkllZ oZjZdl_jbabjZsZ ktklhygb_lh
gZ;FZljbpZlZgZietlghkllZk_ihemqZ\ZdZlhqZklbqgZke_^Z\tjom
ijhf_geb\ZlZ < l_ UX=TrY(ρXY dt^_lh ρXY _ fZljbpZlZ gZ
kt\f_klgZlZ ietlghkl hibk\ZsZ ;< Ih^h[gZ ^_nbgbpby \Z`b aZ
6< hkgh\Z\Zcdb k_ gZ ρY b aZ kt\f_klgZlZ _gljhiby 6;< Ihke_
fh`_ ^Z k_ ^_nbgbjZ d\Zglh\ZlZ nhg GhcfZgh\ZlZ mkeh\gZ
_gljhiby
S(X/Y)≡–TrXY(ρXYlog2ρX/Y)=S(XY)–S(Y),
hkgh\Z\Zcdbk_gZfZljbpZlZgZmkeh\gZlZietlghklρX/YIhke_^gZlZ
b]jZ_ jheylZ gZ d\Zglh\Z mkeh\gZ \_jhylghkl b k\b^_l_ekl\m\Z aZ
ihy\ZlZ gZ g_deZkbq_kdb dhj_eZpbb \ kemqZy gZ d\Zglh\b k^\h_gb
ijhf_geb\b ; b < >_ckl\bl_egh fh`_ ^Z k_ ihdZ`_ q_ kh[kl\_gZlZ
klhcghkl gZ U;< fh`_ ^Z gZ^\brb _^gh b ke_^h\Zl_egh d\Zglh\ZlZ
mkeh\gZ_gljhiby6;<fh`_^Z[t^_hljbpZl_egZnZdlhlgZkyg^h
d\Zglh\ZlZ g_k_iZjZ[_eghkl GZijbf_j Zdh ; b < ij_^klZ\yl ^\Z
k^\h_gbd\Zglh\b[blZ\;_eh\hktklhygb_s_bfZf_6;< 6<; –
 [bl Ltc dZlh hljbpZl_egZlZ mkeh\gZ _gljhiby _ aZ[jZg_gZ \
R_gtgh\ZlZ l_hjby Z hljbpZl_egZlZ klhcghkl gZ 6;< hq_\b^gh
\e_q_ d\Zglh\Z g_k_iZjZ[_eghkl h[jZlghlh g_ _ \yjgh Hl ^jm]Z
kljZgZ Zdh ρXY hibk\Z kf_k hl ktklhygby dhylh _ hjlh]hgZegh
ijhba\_^_gb_l_deZkbq_kdZlZkblmZpbylhlh]Z\ZρXY_^bZ]hgZegZ
fZljbpZ k SLM ih ^bZ]hgZeZ b ihke_^ghlh mjZ\g_gb_ k_ j_^mpbjZ ^h
k\hy deZkbq_kdb ^\hcgbd aZ R_gtgh\Z mkeh\gZ _gljhiby =hjgZlZ
^_nbgbpbyke_^h\Zl_eghljy[\Z^Zk_\b^bdZlhd\Zglh\hjZarbj_gb_
gZR_gtgh\ZlZmkeh\gZ_gljhibyihgZqbgdhclh\dexq\Zd\Zglh\hlh
k^\hy\Zg_bdeZkbq_kdZlZmkeh\gZ_gljhibydZlhqZkl_gkemqZc
< kthl\_lkl\b_ k lh\Z _ _kl_kl\_gh ^Z k_ ^_nbgbjZ d\Zglh\Z
nhgGhcfZgh\Z\aZbfgZ_gljhiby
S(X:Y)≡–TrXY(ρXYlog2ρX:Y)=S(X) + S(Y) – S(XY)=
=S(X) – S(X/Y)=S(Y) – S(Y/X),
hkgh\ZgZgZfZljbpZlZgZ\aZbfgZlZietlghklρX:YBgl_jij_lZpbylZ
_ ktsZlZ dZdlh \ R_gtgh\ZlZ bgnhjfZpbhggZ l_hjby b 6;< _
kbf_ljbqgZ \_ebqbgZ Km[Z^blb\ghkllZ gZ d\Zglh\ZlZ _gljhiby l_
S(X:Y) ≤ 6;6< \e_q_ q_ 6;< ≥  lhqgh dZdlh ijb R_gtgh\ZlZ
\aZbfgZ _gljhiby H[Zq_ \ kemqZy gZ d\Zglh\b k^\h_gb ijhf_geb\b
6;< fh`_ ^Z ^hklb]g_ ^\Z itlb ih-]heyfZ klhcghkl hl fZdkbfmfZ
iha\he_g\R_gtgh\ZlZl_hjby
S(X:Y) ≤ 2min [S(X), S(Y)]
GZijbf_j bfZf_ 6;<   [blZ f_`^m qe_gh\_l_ gZ ^\hcdZ
:cgsZcg-Ih^hekdb-Jha_g6;<g__fyjdZgZk^\hy\Zg_\kfbkteq_
ly fh`_ ^Z [t^_ g_gme_\Z aZ deZkbq_kdb k_iZjZ[_egb ktklhygby
Gblh_g_h[oh^bfh^Zk_gZ^\brZ\ZdeZkbq_kdZlZ]hjgZ]jZgbpZPLQ
>6; 6<@ aZ d\Zglh\h k^\h_gb kbkl_fb Ke_^h\Zl_egh 6; < _ ih-
kdhjh d\Zglh\h-f_oZgbqgh jZarbj_gb_ gZ h[bdgh\_gZlZ R_gtgh\Z
\aZbfgZ _gljhiby dhylh baf_j\Z d\Zglh\b ktsh dZdlh b deZkbq_kdb
dhj_eZpbbG_aZ\bkbfhhllh\Zlyb]jZ_\Z`gZjhey\bgnhjfZpbhggh
l_hj_lbqghlh hibkZgb_ gZ d\Zglh\bl_ dZgZeb b dhj_dpby gZ ]j_rdZlZ
(Cerf, Cleve 1997).
 Baihea\Zg_lh gZ l_hjbylZ gZ bgnhjfZpbylZ beb ihgylb_lh aZ
_gljhiby aZ ^Z k_ ZgZebabjZ k^\hy\Zg_lh ihkhq\Z lykgZ \jtadZ k
l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ HlqZklb kthl\_lkl\b_lh k_ ktklhb \ h[sb
^_nbgbpbb lZdb\Z dZlh nhg GhcfZgh\ZlZ _gljhiby HlqZklb
kthl\_lkl\b_lh_nhjfZeghnhjfZegbl_ijbgpbigZl_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ
fh]Zl^Zk_ijbeh`ZlijbbamqZ\Zg_gZk^\hy\Zg_lh3RSHVNX5RKUOLFK
 jZa\b\Zl lh\Z nhjfZegh kthl\_lkl\b_ Dh]Zlh :cgsZcg ltjkb
mgb\_jkZe_g nhjfZe_g ijbgpbi hl dhclh ^Z ba\_^_ gh\ZlZ f_oZgbdZ
Zbf_gghki_pbZegZlZl_hjbygZhlghkbl_eghkllZlhck_\^togh\y\Z
hl \lhjby ijbgpbi gZ l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ aZdhgbl_ gZ ijbjh^ZlZ kZ
lZdb\Z q_ g_ fh`_ ^Z k_ kta^Z^_ \_q_g ^\b]Zl_e Lhab h[s ijbgpbi
\lhjbyl aZdhg iha\hey\Z gZ DZjgh ^Z ihdZ`_ q_ \kbqdb h[jZlbfb
lhiebggb fZrbgb ^_ckl\m\Zsb f_`^m ^Z^_gb l_fi_jZlmjb 71 b 72 kZ
_^gZd\h_nbdZkgb>ZjZa]e_^Zf_^\_h[jZlbfblhiebggbfZrbgb^Z
ij_^iheh`bfq_^\_l_ih]etsZllhiebgZ41ijb71bhl^Z\ZllhiebgZ
Q2 ijb 72 gh _^gZlZ \tjrb jZ[hlZ : Z ^jm]ZlZ - :
!: aZ pbdte
<lhjZlZfZrbgZZdhk_h[tjg__oeZ^begbd -ih]etsZlhiebgZ42ijb
T2 b hl^Z\Z lhiebgZ 41 ijb 71 - b babkd\Z kZfh jZ[hlZ : gZ pbdte
Ke_^h\Zl_egh ^\_l_ fZrbgb aZ_^gh [boZ hkb]mjbeb :
–: jZ[hlZ gZ
pbdte [_a ^Z ijhf_gyl kj_^ZlZ LZdh\Z aZdexq_gb_ ijhlb\hj_qb gZ
\lhjby aZdhg ke_^h\Zl_egh ^\_l_ fZrbgb ljy[\Z ^Z \tjrZl_^gZd\Z
jZ[hlZ NhjfZeghlh kthl\_lkl\b_ ktk k^\hy\Zg_lh _ ke_^ghlh
aZdhgbl_gZijbjh^ZlZkZlZdb\Zq__g_\tafh`gh^Zk_kta^Z^_beb
^Z k_ m\_ebqb k^\hy\Zg_lh qj_a ehdZegb hi_jZpbb D\Zglh\ZlZ
f_oZgbdZ g_ iha\hey\Z ehdZegb hi_jZpbb ^Z kta^Z\Zl k^\hy\Zg_
fZdZj q_ l_ ktojZgy\Zl beb jZajmrZ\Zl k^\hy\Zg_lh Lhab h[s
ijbgpbi _ ZgZeh] gZ \lhjby aZdhg gZ l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ :gZeh]tl gZ
lhiebggZlZ fZrbgZ _ \kydZ h[jZlbfZ ljZgknhjfZpby ktklhysZ k_
kZfhhlehdZegbhi_jZpbbdhylhij_h[jZam\Z_^ghk^\h_ghktklhygb_
\^jm]h
 H[kt`^Zf_ _dki_jbf_gl :ebkZ b ;h[ bfZl h[sZ ^\hcdb
d\Zglh\bkbkl_fb\k^\h_ghktklhygb_bkb]bih^_eyllZdZq__^gZlZ
kbkl_fZhl_^gZ^\hcdZhlb\Zm_^bgbyZ^jm]ZlZm^jm]byHk\_glh\Z
\k_db bfZ ^hklti ^h ^jm]b d\Zglh\b kbkl_fb dhblh g_ kZ
itj\hgZqZegh k^\h_gb EhdZegbl_ hi_jZpbb \dexq\Zl \kydZd\b
baf_j\ZgbybmgblZjgbljZgknhjfZpbbdhblh:ebkZbaitegy\Z\tjom
k\hylZ kbkl_fZ Z ;h[ \tjom k\hylZ L_ fh]Zl ^Z h[f_gyl kth[s_gby
ihdeZkbq_kdbgZqbggh:ebkZgyfZijZ\h^ZbaijZsZgZ;h[gbdZd\Z
kbkl_fZ k^\h_gZ k hgZab k dhylh ly jZaiheZ]Z gblh itd ;h[
kthl\_lgh Ke_^h\Zl_egh l_ g_ fh]Zl ^Z kta^Z^Zl k^\hy\Zg_ f_`^m
k\hbl_ kbkl_fb Fh]Zl ihke_^h\Zl_egh ^Z k_ jZa]e_^Zl \k_ ih-h[sb
kemqZb gh ba\h^tl hklZ\Z \bgZ]b _^bg b kts qj_a ehdZegb ^_ckl\by
\tjom hl^_e_gb kbkl_fb dhblh k_ gZfbjZl \deZkbq_kdZdhfmgbdZpby
g_fh`_^Zk_kta^Z^_k^\hy\Zg_g_ehdZeghkl

G_aZ\bkbfh hl \tafh`ghlh ij_^iheh`_gb_ q_ kts_kl\m\Z

^te[hdZ \jtadZ f_`^m d\Zglh\ZlZ l_e_ihjlZpby b l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ
k^\hy\Zg_lh k_ bajZay\Z ihkj_^kl\hf _gljhibcgZ kljmdlmjZ
dhg\_gpbhgZegZlZ nhg GhcfZgh\Z _gljhiby _^bgkl\_gh \ kemqZy gZ
qbklb ktklhygby *LUDOGL *ULJROLQL  Bah[sh ^_nbgbpbbl_ gZ
k^\hy\Zg_lhijh^bdlm\ZgbhlijhlhdheZgZij_qbkl\Zg_g_k_hlgZkyl
ijydhdtf_gljhibcgbbg^bdZlhjb<_q_k_kihf_gZq__ihdZaZghdZd
nhg GhcfZgh\ZlZ _gljhiby fh`_ ^Z klZg_ hljbpZl_egZ baltd\Zcdb
qj_a lh\Z g_h[bdgh\_gb bgnhjfZpbhggb Zki_dlb gZ d\Zglh\hlh
k^\hy\Zg_ H[Zq_ ijbqbgZlZ aZ ebikZ gZ ijydZ \jtadZ f_`^m
d\Zglh\hlhk^\hy\Zg_gZkf_k_gbktklhygbyb_gljhibcgbylbg^bdZlhj
_ \_jhylghkllZ shlh nhg GhcfZgh\ZlZ _gljhiby ^Z g_ _ gZ^_`^_g
bg^bdZlhj gZ k^\hy\Zg_lh <_q_ k_ _ baltd\ZeZ g_Z^_d\ZlghkllZ gZ
R_gtgh\ZlZ bgnhjfZpby b ke_^h\Zl_egh gZ nhg GhcfZgh\ZlZ
_gljhiby AZ[_e_`bl_egh _ q_ gydhb Z\lhjb babkd\Zl gh\ \b^
bg^bdZlhjgZ_gljhibylZihjZ^b^te[hdZlZjZaebdZf_`^md\Zglh\Zb
deZkbq_kdZ bgnhjfZpby Ijb deZkbq_kdh baf_j\Zg_ R_gtgh\ZlZ
bgnhjfZpby _ _kl_kl\_gZ fyjdZ aZ gZr_lh g_\_`_kl\h hlghkgh
k\hckl\ZlZ gZ kbkl_fZlZ qb_lh kts_kl\m\Zg_ _ g_aZ\bkbfh hl
baf_j\Zg_lhGZijhlb\d\Zglh\hlhbaf_j\Zg_bebg_fh`_^Zl\tj^b
q_ hldjb\Z k\hckl\Z gZ kbkl_fZlZ dhblh g_ kts_kl\m\Zl ij_^b ^Z k_
gZijZ\bbaf_j\Zg_lhbebl_ljy[\Z^ZkZg_h[oh^bfhg_ehdZegbHl
k^\hy\Zg_lh ke_^\Z q_ _^gZ kbkl_fZ g_ fh`_ ^Z k_ jZa^_eb gZ ^\_
g_dhj_ebjZsb ih^kbkl_fb Lh\Z gZ k\hc j_^ ijZ\b [_aihe_agh
babkd\Zg_lh aZ Z^blb\gZ nhjfZ gZ _gljhiby AZlh\Z _ \tafh`gh
g_Z^blb\gZlZ PZebkh\Z _gljhiby ^Z _ ih^oh^ysZ Ba[hjtl gZ
PZebkh\ZlZnhjfZgZg_Z^blb\gZ_gljhibyaZkbkl_fbdhblhg_fh]Zl
^Z k_ jZa^_eyl gZ g_dhj_ebjZsb ih^kbkl_fb g__dkl_gab\gbyl
kemqZcgZihke_^tdk_ih^dj_iyhl^hdZaZgbynZdlq_ljbl_Zdkbhfb
ij_\jtsZsb R_gtgh\ZlZ _gljhiby \mgbdZegZnhjfZgZ_dkl_gab\gh
mkeh\b_fh]Zl^Zk_h[h[sylshk_hlgZky^hPZebkh\Z_gljhibydZlh
mgbdZegZ nhjfZ itd \ g__dkl_gab\gby kemqZc  *LUDOGL *ULJROLQL 
ihdZa\Zlq_\kemqZygZg_baq_a\Zshk^\hy\Zg_PZebkh\ZlZ_gljhiby
_fhghlhggZbgZjZkl\ZsZnmgdpbygZgZjZkl\Zshlhk^\hy\Zg_
K^\hy\Zg_lh _ gZ k\hc j_^ fhghlhggZ b gZjZkl\ZsZ nmgdpby
hl PZebkh\ZlZ _gljhiby ijb hij_^_e_gb mkeh\by G__dkl_gab\gZlZ
nhjfZ gZ _gljhiby fh`_ ^Z k_ hdZ`_ ih^oh^ys bgkljmf_gl aZ
bamqZ\Zg_ gZ d\Zglh\ZlZ l_e_ihjlZpby Lh\Z fh`_ gZ k\hc j_^ ^Z
^hijbg_k_ aZ ih-^te[hdhlh jZa[bjZg_ gZ PZebkh\ZlZ _gljhiby Lhab
bg^bdZlhj gZ _gljhiby g_ k_ jZap_i\Z gZ kmfZ hl ^\_ g_dhj_ebjZsb
ih^kbkl_fb lh\Z ij_^iheZ]Z q_ lhab \b^ _gljhiby [b [be ih^oh^ys
kZfh aZ kemqZb dh]Zlh jZa^_eyg_lh gZ ^\_ g_dhj_ebjZsb qZklb _
g_\tafh`gh D\Zglh\h-f_oZgbqgZlZ kbkl_fZ ih ijbgpbi _ agZqbf
ijbf_j dt^_lh k_ ijbeZ]Z lZab _gljhiby Zdh k_ b]ghjbjZl
\tafh`gbl_ \b^h\_ ^_dho_j_gpby ktk kj_^ZlZ beb ^jm] lbi H[Zq_
g__dkl_gab\gZ nhjfZ gZ _gljhiby [b fh]eZ ^Z klZg_ g__nbdZkgZ
dh]Zlh l_hj_fZlZ aZ g_dehgbjZg_ b ijbgpbitl aZ g_gZjZkl\Zsh
k^\hy\Zg_k_gZjmrbKihj_^Ohjh^_pdbkemq\Zg_lhgZj_Ze_gdheZik
gZ\tegh\ZlZnmgdpbyg_kt\f_klbfhkh]jZgbq_gb_gZ\taijb_fZg_lh
gZ mgblZjgbl_ ljZgknhjfZpbb ijh\hdbjZ jZaqmi\Zg_lh gZ lZab
_d\b\Ze_glghkl

BgnhjfZpby.
=eZ\gbyl \tijhk \t\ \jtadZ k ihgylb_lh bgnhjfZpby \
^bkpbiebgZlZ d\Zglh\Z bgnhjfZpby _ ^Zeb bgnhjfZpbylZ
kts_kl\m\Z\ijbjh^ZlZIbeZgFg_gbylZkj_^ki_pbZebklbl_\
h[eZkllZgZd\Zglh\ZlZbgnhjfZpbykZjZa^_e_gbKj_^j_rbl_egbl_
ih^^jt`gbpb gZ obihl_aZlZ aZ nbabq_kdhlh kts_kl\m\Zg_ gZ
bgnhjfZpbylZ fh]Zl ^Z k_ ihkhqZl EZg^Zm_j BgnhjfZpbylZ _
nbabq_kdZ fZl_fZlbdZlZ b dhfixltjgbl_ gZmdb kZ qZkl hl
nbabdZlZ /DQGDXHU  ljbfZlZ bake_^h\Zl_eb k _^gZd\ZlZ
nZfbeby Ohjh^_pdb Z ktsh PZcebg]_j Pmj_d Z fh`_ [b b j_^bpZ
^jm]b Dtf lyo ke_^\Z ^Z k_ ijbqbkeb b ih^oh^tl gZ %HQLRI 
\^togh\yg hl jZa\blb_lh gZ dho_j_glgZ l_hjby gZ fZl_fZlbdZlZ b
nbabdZlZ aZ_^gh ijb dhclh _kl_kl\_gbl_ qbkeZ k_ ^_nbgbjZl gZ
hkgh\ZlZ gZ d\Zglh\b kbkl_fb hibk\Zgb qj_a Obe[_jlh\b
ijhkljZgkl\Z Dhedhlh b iZjZ^hdkZegh ^Z ba]e_`^Z lh\Z g_dZ kb
ij_^klZ\bf _^gh jZamfgh d\Zglh\h kts_kl\h b k_ aZiblZf_ dZd\b
fZl_fZlbq_kdbbnbabq_kdbihgylb_[b[beh_kl_kl\_gh^Zkbkta^Z^_
lh Beb dZd gZ hkgh\ZlZ gZ k^\hy\Zg_lh fh`_ ^Z k_ ^_nbgbjZ
g_k^\hy\Zg_lh^Zij_^eh`bfdh_lhktshlhedh\Zs_]hbamfbke_^
dZlh]hhldjb_dhedhlhgZkk^\hy\Zg_lhhl^jm]ZkljZgZZdhijb_f_f
bgnhjfZpbylZ aZ ^Z^_gZ dZd ke_^\Z ^Z k_ hij_^_eb _g_j]bylZ b
\_s_kl\hlh"
 G_\tafh`ghkllZ aZ dehgbjZg_ beb baqbkl\Zg_ gZ d\Zglh\ZlZ
bgnhjfZpby fh`_ ^Z k_ jZa]e_`^Z \ dZq_kl\hlh gZ _^bg aZdhg aZ
aZiZa\Zg_ gZ bgnhjfZpbylZ ih^h[_g gZ l_ab aZ \_s_kl\hlh b
_g_j]bylZ
G_aZ\bkbfh hl j_^bpZlZ qm^_kgb _dki_jbf_glZegb b
l_hj_lbqgb j_amelZlb \tjom k^\hy\Zg_lh \k_ hs_ bfZ ljm^ghklb \
jZa[bjZg_lhgZlhabijhp_kBa]e_`^Zlh\Z_hljZ`_gb_gZhkgh\gbl_
ljm^ghklb gZke_^_gb \ bgl_jij_lZpbylZ gZ  d\Zglh\by nhjfZebatf
dZdlh bgZd\Zglh\h-deZkbq_kdZlZob[jb^ghkl\gZr_lh\taijbylb_gZ
ijbjh^ZlZ AZ ^Z k_ ij_h^he__ ihke_^ghlh +RURUGHFNL Horodecki,
+RURGHFNL  ihklmebjZl q_ kts_kl\m\Zg_lh gZ mgblZjgh
bgnhjfZpbhgghihe__g_h[oh^bfhmkeh\b_aZdZd\Z^Z_dhfmgbdZpby
beb dhj_eZpby Hk\_g lh\Z fh`_ ^Z k_ jZa]e_^Z bgnhjfZpbhggZ
bgl_jij_lZpby gZ d\Zglh\ZlZ \tegh\Z nmgdpby Lh\Z k_ hkgh\Z\Z gZ
h[sZlZ bgnhjfZpbhggZ iZjZ^b]fZ kihj_^ dhylh ihgylb_lh aZ
bgnhjfZpby ij_^klZ\ey\Z hkgh\gZ dZl_]hjby b fh`_ ^Z [t^_
hij_^_e_gZ g_aZ\bkbfh hl \kydZd\Z \_jhylghkl Hl lh\Z ke_^\Z q_
ijbjh^ZlZ _ g_jZa^_egZ pyehkl H[Zq_ kihj_^ ^\hcgZlZ
obe_fhjnbqgZ ijbjh^Z gZ mgblZjghlh bgnhjfZpbhggh ihe_ bfZ ^\_
\aZbfgh k\tjaZgb jZ\gbsZ gZ nbabq_kdZ j_Zeghkl \ ijbjh^ZlZ
eh]bq_kdh bgnhjfZpbhggh ^te`Zsh k_ gZ ihl_gpbZeghlh ihe_ hl
Zel_jgZlb\b b _g_j]_lbqgh ^tj`Zsh k_ gZ ihe_lh hl ^_ckl\by
kt[blby Hl ]e_^gZ lhqdZ gZ h[sZlZ bgnhjfZpbhggZ iZjZ^b]fZ
d\Zglh\byl nhjfZebatf _ ijhklh fgh`_kl\h hl djZcgh ihe_agb
bgnhjfZpbhggb Ze]hjblfb hibk\Zsb ]hj_kihf_gZlbl_ ^hitegbl_egb
Zki_dlb gZ _^bgghlh ^_ckl\bl_egh kts_kl\m\Zsh mgblZjgh
bgnhjfZpbhgghihe_
< ih-jZggZ jZ[hlZ +RURGHFNL  \ lZab \jtadZ k_ h[kt`^Z
ihgylb_lh bgnhjfZpbhggh dho_j_glgZ kbkl_fZ G_dZ jZa]e_^Zf_ 1-
dhfihg_glgZd\Zglh\Zkbkl_fZ∑ANdt^_lh$ $1, A2, ... ANkZbf_gZ
gZjZaebqgbih^kbkl_fb>Zij_^iheh`bfq_kbkl_fZlZ_ih^]hl\_gZ
qj_akf_k\Zg_gZhjlh]hgZegbktklhygbybq_kbkl_fZlZfh`_^Z[t^_
hibkZgZ \ l_jfbgbl_ gZ nhjfZebafZ aZ klZg^Zjlgh obe[_jlh\h
ijhkljZgkl\h
+=⊗Nn=1+n k jZaf_jghkl P dt^_lh +n k_ hlgZky ^h Q-lZlZ
ih^kbkl_fZ Fh`_ ^Z k_ ihdZ`_ q_ ZdkbhfZlbqgZlZ ^_nbgbpby gZ
d\Zglh\Z bgnhjfZpby \h^b ^h nhg GhcfZgh\Z _gljhiby 6N=–
TrAρNlnρN dt^_lh ρN hagZqZ\Z itegbyl hi_jZlhj gZ ietlghkllZ gZ
kbkl_fZlZ bahfhjn_g gZ _^gh fgh`_kl\h hl hqZd\Zgb klhcghklb hl
ebg_cgh g_aZ\bkbfb gZ[ex^Z_fb \ + Ktklhygb_lh gZ Q-lZlZ
ih^kbkl_fZ k_ hibk\Z hl j_^mpbjZgby hi_jZlhj gZ ietlghkllZ ρAn ≡
ρn Q     1 dhgkljmbjZg hl itegby hi_jZlhj dZlh k_ \a_f_
ke_^ZlZ ih \kbqdb hklZgZeb dhfihg_glb gZ kbkl_fZlZ $~: rn=TrA~ρN.
Lh\Z _ _d\b\Ze_glgh gZ ij_g_[j_]\Zg_lh gZ pyeZlZ _dki_jbf_glZegh
^hkltigZ bgnhjfZpby hlghkgh k\tjaZgbl_ k\hckl\Z gZ 1-lZlZ
ih^kbkl_fZ kt^tj`ZsZ k_ \ ρN Lh]Z\Z fh`_ ^Z k_ dZ`_ q_ bfZ
^_dho_j_gpby gZ 1-lZlZ dhfihg_glZ gZ bgnhjfZpbhggh-dho_j_glgZlZ
kbkl_fZ ∑AN dhylh k_ hibk\Z nhjfZegh ihkj_^kl\hf hi_jZlhjZ gZ
j_^mpbjZgZlZ ietlghkl gZ jZa]e_`^Zgbl_ ih^kbkl_fb J_^mpbjZgZlZ
qZklbqgZ_gljhibygZQ-lZlZih^kbkl_fZ6nhjfbjZgZqj_ahi_jZlhjZ
gZ j_^mpbjZgZlZ ietlghkl ρn k_ ^Z\Z qj_a 6n=–TrAnρn Baihea\Zcdb
ihke_^gbl_ ljb jZ\_gkl\Z k_ ^_nbgbjZ Z[khexlgZlZ fyjdZ gZ
bgnhjfZpbhggZlZ dho_j_glghkl gZ kbkl_fZlZ ∑AN: IN=∑Sn-SN
Q 1Kbkl_fZlZ∑ANk_gZjbqZbgnhjfZpbhgghdho_j_glgZj_ki
k_iZjZ[_egZ Zdh ,N !  j_ki ,N  Hl ]e_^gZ lhqdZ gZ
bgnhjfZpbhggZlZ dho_j_glghkl iZjZ^hdktl gZ :cgsZcg Ih^hekdb b
Jha_g b g_jZ\_gkl\ZlZ gZ ;_e k_ hk\_ley\Zl qj_a ij_h[jZam\Zg_ gZ
^mZeghkllZ d\Zglh\hkl-deZkbqghkl \ ^mZeghkllZ d\Zglh\Z-deZkbq_kdZ
bgnhjfZpby hkh[_gh j_e_ngh baitd\Zsh ijb y\e_gbylZ gZ
l_e_ihjlZpby DeZkbq_kdZlZ ^_nbgbpby gZ bgnhjfZpby \dexq\Z k_
hkgh\Z\Z gZ ^himkdZg_lh q_ kbkl_fZlZ ijbl_`Z\Z h[_dlb\gb ehdZegb
k\hckl\Z g_aZ\bkbfb hl gZ[ex^_gb_lh H[Zq_ lZdh\Z ^himkdZg_ g_
\ebaZ\ZdkbhfZlbqgZlZhkgh\ZgZd\Zglh\ZlZbgnhjfZpbyKe_^dZlh
b d\Zglh\ZlZ b deZkbq_kdZlZ bgnhjfZpby fh]Zl ^Z kts_kl\m\Zl
aZ_^gh \t\ nbabq_kdbl_ kbkl_fb g_ _ badexq_gh q_ hkgh\ZlZ gZ
\kbqdb y\e_gby h[kt`^Zgb \ d\Zglh\ZlZ bgnhjfZpby ^Z e_`b \t\
\aZbfh^_ckl\b_lh gZ deZkbq_kdh b d\Zglh\h jZ\gbs_ Lh]Z\Z h[Zq_
\tagbd\Zl\tijhkbl_aZnbabq_kdZlZbeb\tjom^hk_]Zrgbl_l_jfbgb
bgl_jij_lZpby gZ d\Zglh\ZlZ b deZkbq_kdZlZ bgnhjfZpby dZdlh b aZ
l_ogby_kl_kl\_gijhbaoh^
>Z k_ \tjg_f dtf klZlbylZ +RURGHFNL +RURGHFNL +RURGHFNL
Lh\Zih_kl_kl\_ggZqbg\h^b^hZgZeh]byf_`^mbgnhjfZpbylZ
k^\hy\Zg_lh b _g_j]bylZ [b\Zsb g_ g_sh ^jm]h Z j_ne_dkby gZ
_^bgkl\hlh gZ ijbjh^ZlZ Nbabpbl_ kfylZl q_ [b ljy[\Zeh ^Z
kts_kl\m\Zl aZdhgb mijZ\ey\Zsb ijhp_kZ gZ k^\hy\Zg_ \ d\Zglh\h-
dhfmgbdZpbhggbl_ kbkl_fb dhblh kZ ZgZeh]bqgb gZ l_ab \
l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ LZdZ gZijbf_j ;_g_l ij_^eZ]Z \tafh`gZ
g_h[jZlbfhkl gZ ijhp_kZ gZ ^_klbeZpby gZ k^\hy\Zg_lh Ihi_kdm b
Jhjebo baltd\Zl ZgZeh]bylZ f_`^m ^_klbeZpbhgghlh nhjfbjZg_ gZ
qbklb k^\h_gb ktklhygby b pbdteZ gZ DZjgh L_ab Z\lhjb nhjfmebjZl
ijbgpbiZ gZ k^\hy\Zg_lh ZgZeh]bq_g gZ \lhjby ijbgpbi gZ
l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ K^\hy\Zg_lh g_ fh`_ ^Z gZjZkg_ ijb ehdZegb
d\Zglh\b hi_jZpbb b deZkbq_kdZ dhfmgbdZpby <_^jZe b Ie_gbh
jZa]e_`^Zl ijbgpbiZ \ ^_lZceb b baltd\Zl q_ bfZ gydhb fZdZj b
g_itegb ZgZeh]bb f_`^m dh_nbpb_glZ gZ ihe_agh ^_ckl\b_ gZ
^_klbeZpbylZ b lhab gZ pbdteZ gZ DZjgh >jm]b Z\lhjb jZa\b\Zl
ZgZeh]bylZ k^\hy\Zg_-_g_j]by b k_ ihklmebjZ aZiZa\Zg_ gZ
bgnhjfZpbylZ ih ZgZeh]by k itj\by ijbgpbi gZ l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ
k^\hy\Zg_lhgZktklZ\gbkbkl_fbg_fh`_^Zk_ijhf_gbijbmgblZj_g
ijhp_k \tjom _^gZ hl ih^kbkl_fbl_ +RURGHFNL +RURGHFNL +RURGHFNL
ih^dj_iylZgZeh]bylZf_`^mk^\hy\Zg_b_g_j]bybihdZa\Zlq_
\ aZl\hj_gbl_ kbkl_fb hl ^\_ qZklb k d\Zglh\Z dhfmgbdZpby
bgnhjfZpbylZk_aZiZa\Zijbdh_lhbaihea\ZlnhjfZeghhibkZgb_gZ
[ZeZgkZgZd\Zglh\ZlZbgnhjfZpby\dexq\ZshihgylbyaZnbabq_kdZ
beh]bq_kdZjZ[hlZdZdlhbaZihe_agZeh]bq_kdZjZ[hlZb[ZeZgkZgZ
bgnhjfZpbylZ ijb l_e_ihjlZpby b ^_klbeZpby Baf_j\Zg_lh k_
jZa]e_`^Z dZlh ijhp_k gZ g_h[jZlbfh k^\hy\Zg_ k gydZd\Z kj_^Z b
jheylZgZkj_^ZlZ_^Z]ZjZglbjZlZabg_h[jZlbfhklAZ^Zhij_^_eyl
[ZeZgkZ gZ bgnhjfZpbylZ \ aZl\hj_gZ kbkl_fZ l_ \taijb_fZl ^\Z
hkgh\gb ihklmeZlZ L k^\hy\Zg_lh _ nhjfZ gZ d\Zglh\Z bgnhjfZpby
kthl\_lklm\Z\sZ gZ \tlj_rgZ _g_j]by LL baijZsZg_lh gZ dx[blh\_
kthl\l_kl\m\Z gZ jZ[hlZ Kihj_^ itj\by ihklmeZl bgnhjfZpbylZ _
nbabq_kdZ\_ebqbgZdhylh\qZklghkl[bljy[\Zeh^Zk_ktojZgy\Z\
aZl\hj_gb d\Zglh\b kbkl_fb ih^h[gh gZ _g_j]bylZ <lhjbyl ihklmeZl
iha\hey\Z ^Z k_ [hjZ\b k dhfmgbdZpbylZ dZlh ijhp_k \
l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZjZ[hlZlZ_nmgdpbhgZehlijhp_kAZ^Zk_ihemqb
[ZeZgk l_ab bgnhjfZpbhggb _g_j]by b jZ[hlZ k_ ^_nbgbjZl
dhebq_kl\_gh BgnhjfZpbhgghlh kt^tj`Zgb_ gZ _^gh ktklhygb_ k_
^_nbgbjZ dZlh ^\hbq_g eh]Zjbltf jZaebdZlZ hl jZaf_jghkllZ gZ
obe[_jlh\hlh ijhkljZgkl\h ke_^h\Zl_egh k_ ijb_fZ q_ _ djZcgh b
nhg GhcfZgh\ZlZ _gljhiby gZ ktklhygb_lh gZ kbkl_fZlZ Ijb dh_lh
bgnhjfZpbhgghlhkt^tj`Zgb_gZfZdkbfZeghkf_k_ghlhktklhygb__
gmeZ Z gZ fZdkbfZegh qbklhlh ktklhygb_ ^\hbq_g eh]Zjbltf hl
jZaf_jghkllZgZobe[_jlh\hlhijhkljZgkl\h<kydh^jm]hktklhygb__
f_`^ml_ab^\_djZcgbklhcghklbNhgGhcfZgh\ZlZ_gljhibybaf_j\Z
bgnhjfZpbylZ ihemq_gZ ke_^ baf_j\Zg_lh ^hdZlh ijb\_^_ghlh
hij_^_e_gb_kthl\_lkl\m\ZgZbgnhjfZpbylZij_^bbaf_j\Zg_lhb\
qZklghkl _ fZdkbfZegZ Zdh kbkl_fZlZ _ \ qbklh ktklhygb_ Ih-
gZlZltd k_ jZa]e_`^Zl nbabq_kdZ jZ[hlZ baitegy\Z hl kbkl_fZlZ aZ
baijZsZg_ gZ qZklbpb :gZeh]bqgh kbkl_fZlZ baitegy\Z eh]bq_kdZ
jZ[hlZ ijb gZjZkl\Zg_ gZ bgnhjfZpbhgghlh kt^tj`Zgb_ gZ
ihemqZl_ey Lh]Z\Z fh`_ ^Z k_ jZa]e_`^Z nbabq_kdZlZ jZ[hlZ dZlh
baijZsZg_ gZ fZl_jby Z eh]bq_kdZlZ jZ[hlZ dZlh baijZsZg_ gZ
nhjfZ dh_lh k_ kt]eZkm\Z k ^himkgZlZlZ obe_fhjnbqgZ ijbjh^Z gZ
bgnhjfZpbhgghlh ihe_ K ^jm]b ^mfb \ mgblZjghlh bgnhjfZpbhggh
ihe_eh]bdZlZb_g_j]bylZb]jZyljheylZgZkm[klZgpbykthl\_lghgZ
nhjfZ b gZ fZl_jby Kth[jZagh k itj\by ihklmeZl gZqZeghlh b
djZcghlh k^\hy\Zg_ gZ kbkl_fZlZ kZ ijhklh itj\hgZqZegZ b djZcgZ
ihl_gpbZegZ bgnhjfZpby gZ kbkl_fZlZ >Z ij_^iheh`bf q_ :ebkZ
baijZsZ g_k^\h_g dx[bl gZ kbkl_fZlZ ^h ;h[ Lh]Z\Z nbabq_kdZlZ
jZ[hlZ _ jZ\gZ gZ _^bg dx[bl DZlh j_amelZl bgnhjfZpbhgghlh
kt^tj`Zgb_gZkbkl_fZlZgZ;h[gZjZkl\Zk_^bgbpZbke_^h\Zl_egh
eh]bq_kdZlZ jZ[hlZ ktsh \taebaZ gZ _^bg dx[bl < lhab kemqZc
gZqZeghlhbdjZcghlhk^\hy\Zg__jZ\ghgZ_^bgbpZ
>Z ij_^iheh`bf k_]Z q_ :ebkZ baijZsZ fZdkbfZegh k^\h_g
dx[bl gZ ;h[ Lmd hlgh\h nbabq_kdZlZ jZ[hlZ _ _^bg dx[bl b gyfZ
itj\hgZqZegh k^\hy\Zg_ H[Zq_ djZcghlh k^\hy\Zg_ _ _^bg H-ELW b
eh]bq_kdZlZjZ[hlZ_gmeZaZshlhktklhygb_lhgZkbkl_fZlZgZ;h[_
gZiteghkf_k_gh
JZaebdZlZ f_`^m eh]bq_kdZlZ b nbabq_kdZlZ jZ[hlZ k_ ^te`b
gZk^\hy\Zg_lh
< k\hy ih-jZggZ jZ[hlZ +RURGHFNL +RURGHFNL +RURGHFNL 
aZ dhylh \_q_ klZgZ ^mfZ \t\ \jtadZ k ^_klbeZpbylZ gZ k^\hy\Zg_lh
k_ h[kt`^Z nZdlZ q_ kts_kl\m\Z k^\hy\Zg_ dh_lh g_ fh`_ ^Z k_
baihea\ZaZij_gZkyg_gZd\Zglh\ZlZbgnhjfZpbyqj_al_e_ihjlZpby
Baihea\Zcdb \_q_ kihf_gZlZlZ ZgZeh]by k l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ
k^\hy\Zg_lh fh`_ kZ jZa]e_^Z dZlh ^\hcgbd gZ _g_j]bylZ Z
baijZsZg_lh gZ d\Zglh\Z bgnhjfZpby dZlh \b^ bgnhjfZpbhggZ
jZ[hlZKe_^h\Zl_eghk_jZa]e_`^Zk\h[h^ghk^\hy\Zg_?freedh_lh
fh`_ ^Z k_ ^_klbebjZ b k\tjaZgh k^\hy\Zg_ ?bound < qZklghkl
k\h[h^ghlh k^\hy\Zg_ _ _kl_kl\_gh ^Z k_ hlt`^_kl\b k
^_klbebjm_fhlh k^\hy\Zg_ ' ^hdhedhlh ihke_^ghlh hl]h\Zjy gZ
\tijhkZ dhedh dx[blZ fh]Zl ^Z k_ l_e_ihjlbjZl gZ^_`^gh qj_a
kf_k_gh ktklhygb_ Lhab \b^ k^\hy\Zg_ fh`_ \bgZ]b ^Z k_ ij_\tjg_
qj_a ^_klbeZpbhg_g ijhlhdhe \ Zdlb\gZ kbg]e_lgZ nhjfZ AZ ^Z k_
aZ\tjrb ZgZeh]bylZ fh`_ ^Z k_ jZa]e_^Z Zkbfilhlbqgbyl [jhc
kbg]e_lb dhblh kZ g_h[oh^bfb ^Z k_ kta^Z^_ ^Z^_gh kf_k_gh
ktklhygb_ dZlh \tlj_rgh k^\hy\Zg_ ?int ZgZeh] gZ \tlj_rgZlZ
_g_j]by Lh]Z\Z k\tjaZghlh k^\hy\Zg_ fh`_ ^Z k_ ^_nbgbjZ
dhebq_kl\_gh qj_a ke_^ghlh jZ\_gkl\h ?int ?free  ?bound <
qZklghkl aZ qbklb ktklhygby bfZf_ ?int ?free b (bound=0.
>_ckl\bl_egh qbklbl_ nhjfb fh]Zl ^Z k_ ij_\tjgZl [_a aZ]m[b \
Zdlb\gb kbg]e_lgb nhjfb < lZab kb jZ[hlZ +RURGHFNL +RURGHFNL
+RURGHFNL  ihdZa\Zl q_ kts_kl\m\Zlg_k_iZjZ[_egbktklhygbyk
j_pbijhqgbk\hckl\ZAZlZdb\Zktklhygby?int ?boundb?free Ijb
lh\Z hq_\b^gh kts_kl\m\Zl ^\_ \tafh`ghklb ?int   beb ?int ≠  B
^\ZlZ kemqZy kZ l\tj^_ kljZggb b ex[hiblgb < itj\by kemqZc kZ
gZebp_ g_hl^_ebfb ktklhygby dhblh fh]Zl ^Z k_ kta^Z^Zl hl
Zkbfilhlbqghgme_\[jhckbg]e_lgb^\hcdbHllh\Z[bke_^\ZehgZ
k\hcj_^q_k^\hy\Zg_lhgZh[jZam\Zgb_lhg__Z^blb\gZnmgdpbygZ
ktklhygbylZ ihg_`_ ih ^_nbgbpby lh g_ fh`_ ^Z baq_ag_ aZ gbdh_
g_k_iZjZ[_egh ktklhygb_ <t\ \lhjby kemqZc [bof_ bfZeb kljZggb
ktklhygbydhblh^ZZ[khj[bjZlk^\hy\Zg_ihg_h[jZlbfgZqbgGhZdh
\_^gt` ktklhygbylZ k_ kta^Z^Zl lh gyfZ gZqbg ^Z k_ \taklZgh\b
dZd\Zlh b ^Z _ ^hjb fZedZ qZkl hl itj\hgZqZeghlh k^\hy\Zg_
Ihke_^ghlh _ gZitegh aZ]m[_gh ?kl_kl\_gbyl ijh[e_f dhclh
\tagbd\Z\dhgl_dklZgZij_^klZ\_gbyj_amelZl_dZd\Z_nbabq_kdZlZ
ijbqbgZ ihjZ^b dhylh ij_gZkyg_lh gZ qZklb ^Z _ k\tjaZgh k
^_klbebjm_fhkllZ Ih fg_gb_lh gZ +RURGHFNL +RURGHFNL +RURGHFNL
 \j_f_lh _ dh_lh k\tja\Z ^\_l_ g_sZ LjZgkihabpbylZ fh`_ ^Z
k_bgl_jij_lbjZdZlhhi_jZpbyihh[jtsZg_gZ\j_f_lh
>Z k_ \tjg_f hlgh\h dtf jZ[hlZlZ +RURGHFNL +RURGHFNL
+RURGHFNL  <tagbd\Z \tijhktl ^Zeb [ZeZgktl gZ bgnhjfZpbylZ
jZa]jZgbqZ\Zd\Zglh\ZlZbdeZkbq_kdZlZdhfmgbdZpbyHl^_nbgbpbylZ
gZnbabq_kdZlZjZ[hlZke_^\Zq_qj_ag_yg_fh]Zl^Zk_jZa]jZgbqZl
l_ablbih\_dhfmgbdZpby:eh]bq_kdZlZjZ[hlZ">Zij_^iheh`bfq_
:ebkZ baijZsZ gZ ;h[ qZklbpZ hl kbkl_fZlZ \ qbklh ktklhygb_ Gh \
baihea\Zgby fh^_e lZdh\Z ktklhygb_ g_ [b\Z ih^eh`_gh gZ
^_dho_j_gpby Ke_^h\Zl_egh eh]bq_kdZlZ jZ[hlZ _ jZ\gZ gZ _^bg
dx[bl Lh\Z g_ _ d\Zglh\Z dhfmgbdZpby Ke_^h\Zl_egh eh]bq_kdZlZ
jZ[hlZ g_ _ ihe_agZ \ lhab kemqZc Ijb d\Zglh\Z dhfmgbdZpby
bgl_j_ktlh[bdgh\_gh_gZkhq_gdtfbaijZsZg_gZ^_`^ghgZdZd\b^Z
_ kmi_jihabpbb [_a ^_dho_j_gpby Ke_^h\Zl_egh _ m^h[gh ^Z k_
\t\_^_ ihgylb_lh aZ ihe_agZ eh]bq_kdZ jZ[hlZ Ihe_agZlZ jZ[hlZ _
dhebq_kl\hlhdx[blh\_gZkbkl_fZlZij_gZkygb[_a^_dho_j_gpbyb_
jZ\gZ gZ ^\hbq_g eh]Zjbltf hl jZaf_jghkllZ gZ Obe[_jlh\hlh
ijhkljZgkl\h ij_gZkygb Zkbfilhlbqgh gZ^_`^gh Ihke_^ghlh
hagZqZ\Zq_\kydhktklhygb_gZlh\ZijhkljZgkl\hs_[t^_ij_gZkygh
Zkbfilhlbqgh k itegZ gZ^_`^ghkl <b`^Zf_ q_ jZ[hlZlZ
baitegy\ZgZ\ij_^brgbyijbf_jg__ihe_agZltcdZlh\dZq_kl\hlh
gZj_amelZlgZijhp_kZkZfh^\_l_hjlh]hgZegbktklhygbyfh]Zl^Zk_
ij_gZkylgZ^_`^gh
Fh`_ ^Z k_ ihdZ`_ q_ qj_a ehdZegb ^_ckl\by deZkbq_kdZ
dhfmgbdZpby b d\Zglh\Z dhfmgbdZpby gZ 1 dx[blZ k^\hy\Zg_lh g_
fh`_^ZgZjZkg_kih\_q_hl1_-[blZ
 :dhk_[hjZ\bk[ZeZgkZgZbgnhjfZpbylZ\d\Zglh\bktklZ\gb
kbkl_fb lh _ _kl_kl\_gh ^Z k_ ihiblZ hlghkgh h[_dlb\ghkllZ gZ
_^bgbpZlZ dhylh k_ d\ZebnbpbjZ Lhab \tijhk _ _kl_kl\_gh ^Z k_
h[kt`^Z \ dhgl_dklZ gZ l_hjbylZ gZ d\Zglh\ZlZ bgnhjfZpby b
ijh[e_fbl_ gZ bgl_jij_lZpbylZ gZ d\Zglh\ZlZ f_oZgbdZ +RURGHFNL
+RURGHFNL+RURGHFNLdhgklZlbjZlq_g_aZ\bkbfhhl^bgZfbqghlh
jZa\blb_ gZ bgl_j^bkpbiebgZjgZlZ h[eZkl d\Zglh\Z bgnhjfZpby
ebik\Z g_cgh \ebygb_ \tjom bgl_jij_lZpbhggbl_ ijh[e_fb < lhab
dhgl_dkl \tagbd\Z _^bg hkgh\_g \tijhk >Zeb y\e_gbylZ gZ d\Zglh\Z
bgnhjfZpby hkb]mjy\Zl h[_dlb\gZ hq_\b^ghkl aZ kts_kl\m\Zg_lh gZ
_kl_kl\_gZhglheh]byijbktsZgZd\Zglh\ZlZf_oZgbdZ"Bgl_j_kgh
q_ hl gZkdhjh hldjblbl_ d\Zglh\b _n_dlb _^bgkl\_gh d\Zglh\ZlZ
djbilh]jZnby ^Z\Z iheh`bl_e_g hl]h\hj AZ ^Z klZg_ ih-ykgh ^Z
jZa]e_^Zf_ ijhlhdheZ ijb d\Zglh\Z djbilh]jZnby J_rZ\Zshlh
gZ[ex^_gb_ _ q_ \tafh`ghkllZ aZ kih^_eyg_ gZ lZcgby dexq k_
^te`b gZ nZdlZ q_ baijZsZf_ kZfbl_ d\Zglh\b ktklhygby Z g_
ijhklh deZkbq_kdZ bgnhjfZpby aZ lyo Ih ^jm] gZqbg dZaZgh
ihke_^gZlZ fh`_ ^Z k_ ^m[ebjZ ihjZ^b dhylh ijbqbgZ \kbqdb
deZkbq_kdb djbilh]jZnkdb kbkl_fb ih ijbgpbi g_ kZ gZ^_`^gb
Ke_^h\Zl_egh mihlj_[ZlZ gZ dx[blh\_ _ j_rZ\Zsh Zdh bkdZf_ ^Z
ihemqbf gydZd\h ij_^bfkl\h hl gh\bl_ \tafh`ghklb ij_^eZ]Zgb hl
l_hjbylZ gZ d\Zglh\ZlZ bgnhjfZpby Ihg_`_ bf_ _dki_jbf_glZegb
hkts_kl\y\Zgby gZ ijhlhdheb gZ d\Zglh\Z bgnhjfZpby ke_^\Z q_
d\Zglh\ZlZ bgnhjfZpby _ h[_dlb\gZ b fh`_ ^Z hkb]mjb hglheh]bqgZ
hkgh\Z aZ bgl_jij_lZpby gZ d\Zglh\ZlZ f_oZgbdZ D\Zglh\bl_
ktklhygby ghkyl ^\Z ^hitegbl_egb \b^Z bgnhjfZpby deZkbq_kdZ
\dexq\ZsZ d\Zglh\b baf_j\Zgby b d\Zglh\Z bgnhjfZpby dhylh g_
fh`_ ^Z k_ dehgbjZ beb b baqbklb Lh\Z k_ kt]eZkm\Z ^h[j_ k
bgnhjfZpbhggZlZ bgl_jij_lZpby ij_^eh`_gZ ih-]hj_ gZ \tegh\ZlZ
nmgdpby \ l_jfbgbl_ gZ h[_dlb\gh bgnhjfZpbhggh kt^tj`Zgb_ Hl
^jm]Z kljZgZ \ ijhlb\hj_qb_ k dhi_goZ]_gkdZlZ bgl_jij_lZpby
kihj_^ dhylh \tegh\ZlZ nmgdpby gyfZ h[_dlb\gh agZq_gb_ b
_^bgkl\_gZlZ j_Zeghkl _ j_amelZltl hl baf_j\Zg_lh AZ[_e_`bl_egh
_q_]hjgZlZbgnhjfZpbhggZbgl_jij_lZpbygZd\Zglh\bktklhygby_
kt\f_klbfZk]hj_kihf_gZlZlZdhgp_ipbyaZmgblZjghbgnhjfZpbhggh
ihe_dhylhk_hkgh\Z\ZgZ^himkdZg_lhq_bgnhjfZpbylZ_nbabq_kdZ
b fh`_ ^Z k_ ^_nbgbjZ g_aZ\bkbfh hl kZfZlZ \_jhylghkl Itj\ZlZ
ZdkbhfZlbqgZ ^_nbgbpby gZ deZkbq_kdZ bgnhjfZpby [_a
\_jhylghklb_jZa]e_^ZgZhlBg]Zj^_gbMj[ZgbdD\Zglh\Z\_jkbygZ
^_nbgbpbylZ _ \t\_^_gZ hl Bg]Zj^_g b DhkZdh\kdb Hl ^jm]Z kljZgZ
Dhefh]hjh\ Khefh\ b KZclbg \t\_`^Zl ihgylb_lh aZ deZkbq_kdZ
Ze]hjblfbqgZ bgnhjfZpby beb keh`ghkl GZkdhjh deZkbq_kdZlZ
Ze]hjblfbqgZbgnhjfZpbyk_bgdhjihjbjZ\hij_^_e_gb_lhaZlgZj
nbabq_kdZ _gljhiby Kt\k_f gZkdhjh l_hjbylZ gZ Ze]hjblfbqgZlZ
bgnhjfZpbyk_jZarbjbihjZaebqgbgZqbgb^hd\Zglh\bktklhygbyhl
<blZgbchl_^gZkljZgZb;_jlbZmf_
Ij_gZkyg_lh gZ bgnhjfZpby _ p_elZ gZ baf_j\Zl_egby ijhp_k b _
g_ba[_`gh ke_^kl\b_ hl ih\_q_lh \aZbfh^_ckl\by Lh\Z klZ\Z \ oh^Z
gZ ^_dho_j_gpbylZ Bgl_j_k_g _ \tijhktl aZ p_gZlZ gZ _^bg [bl
bgnhjfZpbyl_dZd\h_g_h[oh^bfhlhnbabq_kdh^_ckl\b_aZ^Zk_
ihemqb _^bg [bl bgnhjfZpby \ _^bgbpb ^_ckl\b_ j_ki \ _^bgbpb
dhgklZglZ gZ IeZgd =XUHN  ihdZa\Z q_ lZab p_gZ \ _^bgbpb gZ
IeZgd _ L≈p/2.log21 dt^_lh 1 _ ^bf_gkbylZ gZ Obe[_jlh\hlh
ijhkljZgkl\hgZih-fZedhlhhl^\_l_k^\h_gbkbkl_fbKe_^h\Zl_egh
p_gZlZ gZ [bl bgnhjfZpby gZfZey\Z k gZjZkl\Zg_lh gZ 1 Lhab
j_amelZl _ _^gh\j_f_ggh baykgy\Zs b jZahqZjh\Zs Lhc ihdZa\Z q_
p_gZlZgZbgnhjfZpbhgghlhij_gZkyg_g__nbdkbjZgZ<ktsghklk_
hdZa\Z q_ gZc-fZedhlh h[sh dhebq_kl\h ^_ckl\b_ g_h[oh^bfh aZ
iteghk^\hy\Zg__ihg_ZkbfilhlbqghnbdkbjZghKe_^h\Zl_eghgZc-
fZedZlZ p_gZ aZ [bl gZfZey\Z dh]Zlh bgnhjfZpbylZ k_ ij_gZky gZ
_^jh l_ dh]Zlh 1 _ ]heyfh <k_ iZd lhab j_amelZl _ baykgy\Zs
ihg_`_ ihdZa\Z aZsh deZkbq_kdbyl g_ij_dtkgZl k\yl dt^_lh 1 H
nZdlbq_kdb [_adjZcgh lZab p_gZ fh`_ ^Z k_ b]ghjbjZ b ^Z kf_
m[_^_gbq_bgnhjfZpbylZ_[_aieZlgZ
<t\\jtadZkZgZeh]bylZkl_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ_ex[hiblgh^Zk_
jZa]e_^Z _^bg d\Zglh\h-f_oZgbq_g FZdkm_eh\ ^_fhg /ORLG  <
 ] FZdkm_e aZ[_eya\Z q_ _^gh kts_kl\h dh_lh [b fh]eh ^Z
baf_j\Z kdhjhkllZ gZ hl^_egbl_ fhe_dmeb \ ]Za [b fh]eh ^Z jZa^_ey
[tjabl_ fhe_dmeb \ _^bg dhgl_cg_j Z [Z\gbl_ \ ^jm] qj_a lh\Z
kta^Z\Zcdb jZaebdZ \ l_fi_jZlmjZlZ f_`^m ^\ZlZ dhgl_cg_jZ \
hq_\b^gh gZjmr_gb_ gZ \lhjby aZdhg gZ l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ D_e\bg
gZjbqZ lh\Z kts_kl\h ^_fhg ihemqZ\Zcdb bgnhjfZpby b agZ_cdb dZd
^Z y baihea\Z lZdt\ ^_fhg ih ijbgpbi \tjrb ihe_agZ jZ[hlZ Hl
kt\j_f_ggZ ]e_^gZ lhqdZ ^_fhgtl ^_ckl\bl_egh ba\tjr\Z ihe_agZ
jZ[hlZNB7OQaZ\k_dbihemq_g[blghljy[\Z^Zm\_ebqb_gljhibylZ
ihg_kNBOQaZ\k_dbbaljbl[blDZlhj_amelZl^_fhgtldhclhjZ[hlb
pbdebqgh baljb\Zcdb [blh\_l_ ke_^ dZlh ]b baihea\Z dh_lh _
g_ba[_`gh kihj_^ l gZj ijbgpbi gZ EZg^Zm_j g_ fh`_ ^Z gZjmrb
\lhjby ijbgpbi gZ l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ /OR\G  ij_^eZ]Z
_dki_jbf_glZegZ d\Zglh\hf_oZgbqgZ j_ZebaZpby gZ FZdkm_eh\by
^_fhg hkgh\Zg gZ d\Zglh\ZlZ kibgh\Z b hilbqgZ _e_dljh^bgZfbdZ b
baitegy\Zsite_gpbdtehll_jfh^bgZfbqgbhi_jZpbbih]etsZg_gZ
lhiebgZ baf_j\Zg_ beb ^_dho_j_gpby ba\tjr\Zg_ gZ jZ[hlZ b
gZdjZy baljb\Zg_ <f_klh ^Z gZjmrZ\Z \lhjby ijbgpbi gZ
l_jfh^bgZfbdZlZ^_fhgtl^_ckl\m\ZdZlhd\Zglh\ZlhiebggZfZrbgZ
\tjr_cdb jZ[hlZ ^hdZlh baihfi\Z lhiebgZ hl ]hj_sh dtf klm^_gh
_e_dljhfZ]gblgh ihe_ LZdZ k_ ^_fhgkljbjZ q_ d\Zglh\h baf_j\Zg_
beb ^_dho_j_gpby m\_ebqZ\Z_gljhibylZbgZfZey\Zl_jfh^bgZfbqgZ
ihe_aghkl gZ ^_fhgZ DZlh j_amelZl d\Zglh\byl ^_fhg b d\Zglh\ZlZ
lhiebggZ fZrbgZ kljZ^Zl hl ki_pbnbqgb d\Zglh\b balhqgbpb gZ
gZfZey\Zg_dh_nbpb_glZgZihe_agh^_ckl\b_\k_db[blbgnhjfZpby
\t\_^_g qj_a baf_j\Zg_ beb ^_dho_j_gpby m\_ebqZ\Z _gljhibylZ k
kBln2.
6SUHHXZ  baihea\Z ZgZeh]by gZ d\Zglh\h-
bgnhjfZpbhggby ijhp_k hkgh\ZgZ gZ deZkbq_kdb hilbqgb \tegb
Lhabih^oh^k_\^togh\y\ZhlgZ[ex^_gb_lhq_gydhbhlktsghklgbl_
k\hckl\ZgZd\Zglh\ZlZbgnhjfZpbykZnZdlbq_kdb\tegh\bk\hckl\Z
ijb dh_lh \tegZlZ gyfZ gm`^Z ^Z [t^_ d\Zglh\Z Ih lhab gZqbg k_
baykgy\Zl nbgbl_ gh ^te[hdb jZaebdb f_`^m d\Zglh\ZlZ kbkl_fZ b
deZkbq_kdZlZ \tegh\Z kbkl_fZ D\Zglh\bl_ [blh\_ beb dx[blh\_ kZ
jZaebqgb hl deZkbq_kdbl_ [blh\_ ih gydhedh \Z`gb gZqbgZ Itj\ZlZ
\Z`gZ jZaebdZ _ q_ dx[bltl fh`_ ^Z kts_kl\m\Z \ kmi_jihabpby gZ
^\_ [bgZjgb ktklhygby <lhjZlZ j_rZ\ZsZ jZaebdZ _ q_ dx[blh\_l_
fh]Zl ^Z [t^Zl k^\h_gb Kmi_jihabpbylZ _ ^h[j_ ihagZlZ aZ
deZkbq_kdb \tegb lZdZ q_ ly g_ _ badexqbl_egh d\Zglh\hf_oZgbqgZ.
K^\hy\Zg_lh hl ^jm]Z kljZgZ k_ ijb_fZ dZlh ktsghkl_g d\Zglh\
n_ghf_g Baihea\ZgZlZ ZgZeh]by kt^tj`Z ih\_q_lh q_jlb, lbibqgh
ZkhpbbjZgb ktk k^\hy\Zg_lh H[Zq_ ZgZeh]bylZ g_ mkiy\Z ^Z
ijh^mpbjZ_n_dlbgZd\Zglh\Zg_ehdZeghklklh\Zkb]gZebabjZcdbaZ
^te[hdZ jZaebdZ f_`^m ^\Z lbiZ k^\hy\Zg_  bklbggh
fgh]hqZklbqdh\h k^\hy\Zg_ b  _^gZ ih-keZ[Z nhjfZ gZ k^\hy\Zg_
f_`^mjZaebqgbkl_i_gbgZk\h[h^ZgZ_^bgbqgZqZklbpZ<tij_dbq_
l_ab ^\Z lbiZ ba]e_`^Zl l\tj^_ ih^h[gb \ fgh]h hlghr_gby kZfh
itj\bylbifh`_^Zkta^Z^_g_ehdZegbdhj_eZpbb^hdZlhkZfhlbi
bfZ deZkbq_kdZ ZgZeh]by Ke_^h\Zl_egh nbabq_kdb kts_kl\m\ZsZlZ
bgnhjfZpby ktsh lZdZ gyfZ deZkbq_kdb ZgZeh] b fh`_ ^Z k_ ijhy\b
_^\Z gZ d\Zglh\h jZ\gbs_ ijb lh\Z ij_^b \kbqdh ijb g_ehdZegh
\aZbfh^_ckl\b_ gZ ^\_ qZklbpb gh g_ f_`^m jZaebqgb kl_i_gb gZ
k\h[h^ZgZ_^gZbktsZqZklbpZGhlmd_kl_kl\_g_\tijhktl^Zebg_
\aZbfh^_ckl\m\Zl g_l_fihjZegh ktklhygbylZ gZ qZklbpZ \ jZaebqgb
fhf_glb hl \j_f_lh Lh_kl dZd\h _ hlghr_gb_lh f_`^m nbabq_kdb
kts_kl\m\ZsZlZ bgnhjfZpby dtf baf_g_gb_lh beb aZiZa\Zg_lh \t\
\j_f_lh
Ba\_klgh _ q_ d\Zglh\hlh aZ jZaebdZ hl deZkbq_kdhlh
baf_j\Zg_kfmsZ\Zktklhygb_lhgZbaf_j\Zgbyh[_dlIZmebibr_q_
\k_dbZdlgZgZ[ex^_gb__bgl_jn_j_gpby\g_hij_^_ebfZkl_i_gk
bgkljmf_glbl_ gZ gZ[ex^_gb_ dZdlh b k gZ[ex^Z\ZgZlZ kbkl_fZ b
ij_dtk\Z ijbqbggZlZ \jtadZ f_`^m ij_^r_kl\m\Zsbl_ b ke_^\Zsbl_
y\e_gby3DXOL<tijhktl_kdZd\hbgl_jn_jbjZbebdZd\h
kfmsZ\Z \ baf_j\Zg_lh" )XFKV -DFREV  :dh bfZr_ kdjblb
ijhf_geb\blhbaf_j\Zg_lhs_r_^ZgZjmrZ\Zbeb^Zbgl_jn_jbjZk
lyoghlh fgh`_kl\h DZd h[Zq_ fh`_ ^Z k_ kfmsZ\Z g_sh dh_lh g_
kts_kl\m\Z ij_^b baf_j\Zg_lh" L_ab \tijhkb aZ_lb hl
Zj]mf_glZpbylZgZl_hjbbl_ktkkdjblbijhf_geb\bh[Zq_fh]Zl^Zk_
ijb_fZl dZlh dhk\_g ^h\h^ \ ih^dj_iZ gZ nbabq_kdhlh kts_kl\m\Zg_
gZ bgnhjfZpbylZ Lh_kl lh\Z dh_lh gZjmrZ\Z baf_j\Zg_lh _
ktklhygb_lh gZ qZklbpZlZ jZa]e_^Zgh kZfh \ dZq_kl\hlh gZ
bgnhjfZpbyij_fbgZ\Zk_hld\Zglh\ZbgnhjfZpbydtfdeZkbq_kdZb
lh\Z _ ktsghkllZ gZ gZjmr_gb_lh beb gZ bgl_jn_j_gpbylZ k
baf_j\ZgZlZkbkl_fZ
&KHIOHV *LOVRQ %DUQHWW   h[kt`^Zl bgnhjfZpbylZ \t\
\jtadZktkk\hckl\ZlZgZdhe_dlb\gbd\Zglh\bhi_jZpbbbaitegy\Zgb
\tjom ijhkljZgkl\_gh hl^_e_gb d\Zglh\b kbkl_fb JZa]e_`^Z k_
fj_`Z hl 1 ijhkljZgkl\_gh hl^_e_gb eZ[hjZlhjbb \kydZ hl dhblh
kt^tj`Z_^bgdx[blFj_`ZlZ_kgZ[^_gZkmkljhckl\ZaZdeZkbq_kdZ
dhfmgbdZpby b ehdZegb d\Zglh\b hi_jZpbb b \ykdZ ^\hcdZ
eZ[hjZlhjbb kih^_ey ^\mqZklbqdh\h qbklh k^\hy\Zg_ HdZa\Z k_ q_
djZcghlh ktklhygb_ gZ \kydZ kbkl_fZ s_ aZ\bkb hl itj\hgZqZeghlh
ktklhygb_ gZ ^jm]bl_ ?\hexpbylZ ke_^h\Zl_egh babkd\Z ^Z k_
jZaf_gybgnhjfZpbyf_`^mkbkl_fbl_<deZkbq_kdZlZnbabdZlh\Z_
ijhklh deZkbq_kdZlZ bgnhjfZpby :dh kbkl_fbl_ kZ
d\Zglh\hf_oZgbqgb lh]Z\Z _ g_h[oh^bfZ jZafygZlZ gZ d\Zglh\Z
bgnhjfZpby Ij_gZkyg_lh gZ d\Zglh\Z bgnhjfZpby hl _^gh
f_klhiheh`_gb_ ^h ^jm]h fh`_ ^Z k_ ihklb]g_ qj_a baijZsZg_ gZ
d\Zglh\bkbkl_fbbebqj_ad\Zglh\Zl_e_ihjlZpby
Fh`_ ^Z k_ \t\_^_ b ihgylb_ aZdho_j_glgZbgnhjfZpbydZlh
ZgZeh] gZ \aZbfgZlZ bgnhjfZpby \ deZkbq_kdZlZ bgnhjfZpbhggZ
l_hjbylyk_^_nbgbjZdZlh,c = Sout–Sedt^_lh6out__gljhibylZgZ
baoh^ZgZbgnhjfZpbhggbydZgZeD6eH_gljhibcgZlZh[fygZf_`^m
dZgZeZ b g_]h\by j_a_j\hZj :dh  6out–Se> lh]Z\Z bajZa_gh \
dx[blh\_ ,c hibk\Z ^\hbqgby eh]Zjbltf gZ baf_j_gb_lh gZ
Obe[_jlh\hlh ijhkljZgkl\h \kbqdb ktklhygby gZ dh_lh k_ i_jgZkyl k
\_jhylghkl S  \ jZfdbl_ gZ [_adjZcgh]heyf_j]h^bq_gZgkZf[te<
ijhlb\_g kemqZc k_ iheZ]Z ,c=0. (GrishaQLQ =DGNRY  ihdZa\Zl q_
ihgylb_lhaZdho_j_glgZbgnhjfZpbyfh`_^Zk_baihea\Z_n_dlb\gh
dZlh dhebq_kl\_gZ fyjdZ gZ \aZbfh^_ckl\b_lh f_`^m ^\_ j_Zegb
d\Zglh\b kbkl_fb dhblh \ h[sby kemqZc fh]Zl ^Z bfZl ktsghklgh
jZaebqgbobe[_jlh\bijhkljZgkl\Zbbaykgy\ZljheylZgZd\Zglh\ZlZ
dho_j_glghklki_pbnbqgZaZk\tjaZgbkbkl_fb
+DOO  jZa]e_`^Z ]_hf_ljbq_g ih^oh^ dtf
g_hij_^_e_ghkllZ _gljhibylZ b bgnhjfZpbylZ <kydh fgh`_kl\h
g_aZ\bkbfh ^Zeb deZkbq_kdh d\Zglh\h ^bkdj_lgh beb g_ij_dtkgZlh
bfZ ih kts_kl\h _^gZ _^bgkl\_gZ fyjdZ gZ h[_fZ aZ_fZg hl
fgh`_kl\hlhdhclhh[_f_kt\f_klbfkhkgh\gb]_hf_ljbqgbihgylby
H[_ftl gZ fgh`_kl\hlh k_ hdZa\Z q_ _ ijhihjpbhgZe_g gZ
_dkihg_glZlZ hl _gljhibylZ gZ fgh`_kl\hlh 2UORZVNL  h[jtsZ
\gbfZgb_q_bgnhjfZpbhggZlZ_gljhiby_]hjgZfyjdZgZd\Zglh\ZlZ
g_hij_^_e_ghklkihj_^kthlghr_gb_lhgZOZca_g[_j]
Hkh[_gh fyklh aZ_fZ bgnhjfZpbylZ \ ih^oh^Z gZ
dhgkbkl_glgbl_ bklhjbb < klZg^ZjlgZlZ d\Zglh\Z l_hjby gZ
_^bgbqghlh \j_f_ ltc dZlh ih^oh^tl gZ dhgkbkl_glgbl_ bklhjbb
jZa]e_`^Zfgh`_kl\hhl\j_f_gZbgnhjfZpbhggZlZ_gljhibyk_^Z\Z
dZlh ,single–time=tr(ρlnρ dt^_lh ρ _ fZljbpZ gZ ietlghkllZ b
bgnhjfZpbhggZlZ _gljhiby _ fbgbfZegZ aZ qbklb ktklhygby ,VKDP
/LQGHQ  ltjkyl ihgylb_aZbgnhjfZpbhggZ_gljhibydh_lhfh`_
^Z k_ baihea\Z \ h[h[s_gZlZ d\Zglh\Z l_hjby gZ dhgkbkl_glgbl_
bklhjbb < qZklghkl ^_nbgbpbylZ ljy[\Z ^Z [t^_ ijbeh`bfZ dtf
kbkl_fb\dhblhihgylb_lhaZ\j_f_g__nmg^Zf_glZeghIh-gZlZltd
^hjb Zdh kbkl_fZlZ bfZ klZg^Zjlgh ihgylb_ aZ \j_f_
bgnhjfZpbhggZlZ _gljhiby - dhylh dh^bjZ [jhy [blh\_ g_h[oh^bfb
^Z k_ hibr_ kbkl_fZlZ - fh`_ ^Z g_ _ g_h[oh^bfh ^Z^_gZ \
itj\hgZqZeghlhktklhygb_HibkZgb_lhgZ_^gZkbkl_fZ\kihf_gZlby
h[h[s_g lbi d\Zglh\Z l_hjby k_ ^Z\Z gZitegh \ l_jfbgbl_ gZ
fgh`_kl\hlh ijhihabpbb b klhcghklb gZ nmgdpbbl_ gZ ^_dho_j_gpby
lZdZ q_ fyjdZlZ bgnhjfZpbhggZlZ _gljhiby ljy[\Z ^Z fh`_ ^Z k_
ihkljhb kZfh hl lyo BgnhjfZpbhggZlZ _gljhiby k_ hkgh\Z\Z gZ
ihgylb_lh aZ baf_j_gby gZ _^gZ bklhjby JZaebqgb ih^oh^b ijb
hij_^_eyg_ gZ bgnhjfZpbylZ \ jZfdbl_ gZ h[h[s_gZlZ d\Zglh\Z
l_hjbygZdhgkbkl_glgbl_bklhjbbb\0F(OZDLQH

PBLBJ:G:B>HITEGBL?EG:EBL?J:LMJ::
;Zj]Zlbg, B., ;. =jbrZgbg, <. AZ^dh\. AZimlZggu_ d\Zglh\u_ khklhygby
Zlhfguo kbkl_f. - Mki_ob nbabq_kdbo gZmd. Lhf 171 (2001), N 6, 625-
646.
>bch^hg_, @. M\h^ \ kt\j_f_ggby ZgZeba. K., 1972.
>hgp_\, <. Kbklheu gZ ]jmiZo =_ca_g[_j]Z k f_ljbdZfb DZjgh-
DZjZl_h^hjb. - FZl_fZlbq_kdbc k[jhgbd. Lhf 192 (2001), N 3, k. 27-54.
>j_fbg, B., H. B\Zgh\, <. G_qblZceh. <_c\e_lu b bo bkihevah\Zgb_.
- Mki_ob nbabq_kdbo gZmd. Lhf 171 (2001), N 5, 465-501.
DZefudh\, K., X. Rhdbg b A. Xe^Zr_\. F_lh^u bgl_j\Zevgh]h
ZgZebaZ. Gh\hkb[bjkd, 1986.
Dbebg, K. D\Zglh\Zy bgnhjfZpby. – Mki_nb nbabq_kdbo gZmd. Lhf 169
(1999), N 5, 507-527.
Ebidbg, :. Kms_kl\m_l eb y\e_gb_ "j_^mdpbb \hegh\hc nmgdpbb" ijb
baf_j_gbb \ d\Zglh\hc f_oZgbd_? - Mki_ob nbabq_kdbo gZmd. Lhf 171
(2001), N 4, k. 437-441.
F_gkdbc, F. D\Zglh\Zy f_oZgbdZ: gh\u_ wdki_jbf_glu, gh\u_
ijbeh`_gby b gh\u_ nhjfmebjh\db klZjuo \hijhkh\. - Mki_ob
nbabq_kdbo gZmd. Lhf 170 (2000), N 6, k. 631-647.
F_gkdbc, F. D\Zglh\h_ baf_j_gb_: ^_dh]_j_gpby b khagZgb_. - Mki_ob
nbabq_kdbo gZmd. Lhf 171 (2001), N 4, k. 459-462.
GZofZgkhg, J. Nbabq_kdZy bgl_jij_lZpby d\Zglh\hc f_oZgbdb. -
Mki_ob nbabq_kdbo gZmd. Lhf 171 (2001), N 4, k. 437-444.
G_\_, @. FZl_fZlbq_kdb_ hkgh\u l_hjbb \_jhylghkl_c. Fhkd\Z, 1969.
IZgh\, :. H ijh[e_f_ \u[hjZ Zevl_jgZlb\u \ d\Zglh\hc baf_j_gbb. -
- Mki_ob nbabq_kdbo gZmd. Lhf 171 (2001), N 4, k. 447-451.
IbeZg, :. >_ckl\bl_eghklv b ]eZ\guc \hijhk h d\Zglh\hc
bgnhjfZpbb. - Mki_ob nbabq_kdbo gZmd. Lhf 171 (2001), N 4, k. 444-447.
N_cgfZg, J. D\Zglh\hf_oZgbq_kdby W<F. - Mki_ob nbabq_kdbo gZmd.
Lhf 140 (1986), N 4, 671–688.
P_ofbkljh, B. BfiebdZlb\gh-eh]bq_kdZy ijbjh^Z d\Zglh\uo
dhjj_eypbb. - Mki_ob nbabq_kdbo gZmd. Lhf 171 (2001), N 4, k. 452-458.
Q`wgv Rwg-rwgv. Dhfie_dkgu_ fgh]hh[jZaby. F. 1961.
Aharonov, Y. and L. Vaidman. Nonlocal aspects of a quantum wave. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 5, 052108-1-11.
Albert, D. Quantum Mechanics and Experience. Cambridge, MA, 1996.
Antoniou, I., E. Karpov, G. Orinko, and E. Yarevski. Quantum Zeno anti-
Zeno effects in the Friedrichs model. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N
6, 062110-1-10.
Aspect, A., P. Grangier, and G. Roger. Experimental tests of realistic local
theories via Bell's theorem. - Physical Review Letters. Vol. 47 (1981) N 7,
460–463.
Aspect, A., P. Grangier, and G. Roger. Experimental Realization of
Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen–Bohm Gedanken experiment: A New Violation of
Bell's Inequalities. - Physical Review Letters. Vol. 49, N 2 (1982), 91–94.
Ballentine, L. and S. McRae. Moment equations for probability distributions
in classical and quantum mechanics. - Physical Review A. Vol. 58 (1998), N
3, 1799(11).
Barnum, H., M. Nielsen, and B. Scumacher. Information transmission
through a noisy quantum channel. – Physiscal Review A. Vol. 57, N 6
(1998), 4153(23).
Bartlett, S. and D. Rice, B. Sanders, J. Dabool, H. de Guise. Unitari
transformations for testing Bell inequalites. – Physiscal Review A. Vol. 63, N
4 (2001), 042310(10).
Baute, A., I. Egusquiza, J. Muga and R. Mayato. Time-of-arrival
distributions from positron-momentum and energy-time joint measurements.
- Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 5, 052111-1-11.
Beige, A. and G. Hegerfeldt. Projection postulate and atomic quantum
Zeno effect. – Physical Review A. Vol. 53 (1996), N 1, 53(13).
Bell, J. On the Problem of Hidden Variables in quantum Mechanics. –
Review of Modern Physics. Vol. 38 (1966), N 3, 447–452.
Benioff, P. Representation of natural numbers in quantum mechanics. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 3, 032305-1-11.
Benjamin, S. and P. Hayden. Multiplayer uantum games. – Physical
Review A. Vol. 64 (2001), N 3, 030301-1-4.
Bennett, J., G. Brassard, C. Crepcau, R. Jozsa, A. Peres, W. Wootters.
Teleporting an Unknoun State via Dual Classical and Einstein–Podolsky–
Rosen Channels. - Physical Review Letters. Vol. 70 (1993), N 2, 1895–
1899.
Bennett, C., D. DiVincenzo, C. Fuchs, T. Mor, E. Rains, P. Shor, J.
Smolin, and W. Wootters. Quantum nonlocality without entanglement. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 2, 1070(22).
Bennett, C., D. Divincenzo, J. Smolin, and W. Wootters. Mixed–state
entanglement and quantum error correction. – Physical Review A. Vol. 54
(1996), N 2, 3824(28).
Bertlmann, R. and B. Hiesmayr. Bell inequalities for entangled kaons and
their unitary time evolution. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 6,
062112(11).
Biham, E., O. Biham, D. Biron, M. Grassl, and D. Lidar. Grover's
quantum search algorithm for an arbitrary initial amplitude distribution. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 4, 2742(4).
Biham, E., O. Biham, D. Biron, M. Grassl, D. Lidar, and D. Shapira.
Analysis of generalized Grover quantum search algorithms using recursion
equations. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2000), N 1, 012310(8).
Blatter, G. Schrpdinger's cat is now fat. – Nature. Vol. 406 (2000), 25–26.
Bohm, A. Time-asymmetric quantum physics. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60
(1999), N 2, 861(16).
Bowen, G. Classical information capacity of superdense coding. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 2, 022302(4).
Brun, T. Continuous measurements, quantum trajectories and decoherent
histories. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 4, 042107-1-17.
Bruββ, D., J. Calsamiglia and N. Lvtkenhaus. Quantum cloning and
distributed measurements. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 4,
042308-1-9.
Buzek, V. and M. Hillery. Quantum copying: Beyond the no–cloning
theorem. – Physical Review A. Vol. 54 (1996), N 3, 1844(9).
Bub, J. Secure key distribution via pre- and postselected quantum states. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 3, 032309-1-3.
Caban, P. and J. Rembielinski. Lorentz-covariant quantum mechanics and
preferred frame. - Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 6, 4187(10).
Cabello, A. "All versus nothing" Inseparability for two Observers. Physiscal
Review Letters. Vol. 87 (2001), N 1, 010403(4).
Cabello, A. Nonlocality without inequalites has not been proved for
maximally entangled states. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2001), N 2,
022119-1-6.
Cabello, A. Quantum correlations are not local elements of reality. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 1, 113(3).
Cerf, N. and C. Adami. Entropic Bell inequalities. - Physical Review A. Vol.
55 (1997), N 5, 3371(4).
Cerf, N. and C. Adami. Quantum extension of conditional probability. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 2, 893(5).
Cerf, N. and R. Cleve. Information–theoretic interpretation of quantum
error-correcting codes. - Physical Review A. Vol. 56 (1997), N 3, 1721(12).
Cerf, N., C. Adami, and R. Gingrich. Reduction criterion for separability. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 2, 898(12).
Chefles, A., C. Gilson and S. Barnett. Entanglement, information and
multiparticle quantum operations. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 3,
032314-1-15.
Clauser, J., Horne, M. Experimental consequences of objectiv local
theories. – Physiscal Review D. Vol. 10 (1974), N 2, 526–534.
Clauser, J., M. Horne, A. Shimony, R. Holt. Proposed experiment to test
local hidden–variable theories. – Physical Review Letters. Vol. 23 (1969), N
15, 880–884.
Cleve, R. and H. Buhram. Substituting quantum entanglement for
communication. - Physical Review A. Vol. 56 (1997), N 2, 1201(4).
Clifton, R., H. Halvorson, A. Kent. Nonlocal correlations are generic in
infinite-dimensional bipartite systems. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000),
N 4, 042101-1-7.
Cochanski, P. and K. Wodkiewicz. Operational time of arrival in quantum
phase space. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 4, 2689(11).
Cohen, O. and B. Hiley. Reexamining the assumption that elements of
reality can be Lorentz invariant. – Physical Review A. Vol. 52 (1995), N 4,
76(6).
Curado, E., M. Rego-Montiero, and H. Nazareno. Heisenberg-type
structures of one-dimensional quantum Hamiltonians. - Physical Review A.
Vol. 64 (2001), N 1, 012105-1-5.
Delgado, V. Quantum probability distribution of arrival times and probability
current density. - Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 2, 1010(11).
Diosi, L., N. Gisin, and W. Strunz. Quantum approach to coupling
classical and quantum dynamics. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 2,
022108-1-4.
Doherty, A., K. Jakobs, and G. Jungman. Information, diturbance, and
Hamiltonian quantum feedback control. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001),
N 6, 062306-1-13.
Dragan, A., K. Banaszek. Homodyne Bell's inequalites for entangled
mesoscopic superpositions. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 6,
062306-1-13.
Dvr, W. and J. Cirac. Nonlocal operations: Purification, storage,
compression, tomography, and probabilistic implementation. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 64 (2001), N 1, 012317-1-14.
Dusek, M., O. Haderka, M. Hendrich, and R. Myska. Quantum
identification system. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 1, 149(8).
Elitzur, A., S. Dolev. Nonlocal effects of partial measurements and
quantum erasure. - - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 6, 062109(14).
Emerson, J. and L. Ballentine. Characteristics of quantum-classical
correspondence for two intwracting spins. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63
(2001), N 5, 052103-1-16.
Englman, R. and :. Yahalom. Reciprocity beween moduli and phases in
time-dependent wave functions. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 3,
1802(9).
van Enk, S., H. Kimble, J. Cirac, and P. Zoller. Quantum communication
with dark photons. - Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 4, 2659(6).
Facchi, P., A. Mariano, and S. Pascazio. Decoherence versus enthropy in
neutron interforemetry. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 5, 052108-1-
9.
Feinman, R. Simulating Physiscs with Computers. – International Journal of
theoretical Physics. Vol. 21, (1982), N 6–7, 467–488.
Feng Mang, Zhu Xi–Wen, Gao Ke–Lin, Shi Lei. Quantum Computation by
Pairing Trapped Ultracold Ions. - Chinese Physiscal Letters. Vol. 18, N 6
(2001), 718–720.
Fischer, M.C., B.Gutierrez–Medina, and M.G.Raizen. Observation of the
Quantum Zeno and Anti–Zeno Effects in an Unstable System. - Physical
Review Letters. Vol. 87 (2001), N 4, 040402(4).
Foadi, R. and F. Selleri. Quantum mechanics versus local realism for
neutral kaon pairs. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 1, 012106-1-6.
Ford, G. and R. O'Connell. Exact result for the force autocorelation in the
rotating-wave approximation. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 6,
062102-1-6.
Ford, G., J. Lewis and R. O'Connell. Quantum measurement and
decoherence. – Physical Review A. Vol. 64 (2001), 032101(4).
Franke-Arnold, S., E. Anderson, S. Barnett, and S. Stenholm.
Generalized measurements of atomic qubits. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63
(2001), N 5, 052301-1-8.
Freedman, J., J. Clauser. Experimental tests of local hidden variable
theories. – Physical Review Letters. Vol. 28 (1972), 938-941.
Fuchs, C. and K. Jacobs. Information-tradeoff relations for finite-strength
quantum measurements. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 6, 062305-
1-15.
Gea-Banaciole, J. Qubit-qubit interaction in quantum computers. II. Adder
algorithm with diagonal and off-diagonal interactions. - Physical Review A.
Vol. 60 (1999), N 1, 185(9).
Garcia-Calderon, G., A. Rubio, J. Villavicencio. Low-energy relativistic
effects and nonlocality in time-dependent tunneling. - Physical Review A.
Vol. 59 (1999), N 3, 1785(4).
Garuccio, A. Hardy's approach, Eberhard's inequality, and supplementary
assumptions. - Physical Review A. Vol. 52 (1995), N 4, 2535(3).
Genovese, M. Proposal of an experimental scheme for realizing a
translucent eavesdropping on a quantum cryptographic channel. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 4, 044303(4).
Giraldi, F. and P. Grigolini. Quantum entanglement and entropy. –
Physiscal Review A. Vol. 64 (2001) N 3, 032310(10).
Gisin, N., V. Scarani, W. Tittel and H. Zbinden. Optical tests of quantum
nonlovality: from EPR-Bell tests towards experiments with moving
observers. - Annalen der Physik. Vol. 512 (ser 8, vol. 9) (2000), N 11-12,
pp. 831-841.
Gottesman, D. and J. Preskill. Secure quantum key distribution using
squeezed states. – Physical Review A. Vol 63 (2001), N 3, 022309(18).
Greenberger, D., A. Horne, A. Shimony, A. Zeilinger. Bell's theorem
without inequalities. – American Journal of Physiscs. Vol. 58 (1990), N 12,
1131–1143.
Griffiths, R. Choice of consistent family, and quantum incompatibility. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 57 (1998), N 3, 1604(15).
Griffiths, R. Consistent histories and quantum reasoning. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 54 (1996), N 4, 2759(16).
Grishanin, B. and V. Zadkov. Coherent-information analysis of quantum
channels in simple quantum systems. - Physical Review A. Vol. 62 (2000),
N 3, 032303-1-12.
Grunhaus, J., S. Popesku, and D. Rohrlich. Jamming nonlocal quantum
correlations. - Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 4, 2602(14).
Hall, M. Universal geometric approach to uncertainty, entropy, and
information. - Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 4, 2602(14).
Hardy, L. Nonlocality for Two Particles without Inequalities for Almost All
Entangled States. – Physiscal Review Letters. Vol. 71 (1993), N 11,
1665(4).
Hardy, L. Quantum Mechanics, Local Realistic Theories, and Lorentz–
Invariant Realistic Rheories. – Physiscal Review Letters. Vol. 68 (1992), N
20, 2981–2984.
Hardy, L. and W. van Dam. Quantum communication using a nonlocal
Zeno effect. - Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 4, 2635(6).
Hillery, M., B. Zurke & D. Stoler. Upper and lower bounds on maximal
violation of local realism in a Hardy-type test using continuous variables. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 6, 062111(4).
Horodecki, M., P. Horodecki, R. Horodecki. Mixed–state Entanglement
and Distilation: Is there a "Bound" Entanglement in Nature? – Physical
Review Letters. Vol. 80 (1998), N 24, 5239–5242.
Horodecki, P. "Interaction-free" interaction: Entangling evolution coming
from the possibility of detection. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 2,
022108-1-5.
Horordecki, R. Informationally coherent quantum systems. – Physiss
Letters A. Vol. 187 (1994) 145–150.
Horodecki, R., M. Horodecki and P. Horodecki. Balance of information in
bipartial quantum communication systems: Entanglement-energy analogy. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 2, 022310-1-8.
Horodecki, R., M. Horodecki. Information–theoretic aspects of
inseparability of mixed states. - Physical Review A. Vol. 54 (1996), N 3,
1838(6).
Horodecki, R., P. Horodecki. Quantum redundancies and local realism. –
Physics Letters A. Vol. 194 (1994), 147–152.
Horodecki, R., P. Horodecki, M. Horodecki. Quantum a–entropy
inequalities: independent condition for local realism. – Physics Letters A.
Vol. 210 (1996), 377–381.
Isham, C. J, N. Linden. Information entropy and the space of decoherence
functions in generalized quantum theory. - Physical Review A. Vol. 55
(1997), N 6, 4030(11)
Je-Young Choi, Seok-In Hong. Supersymmetric quantum mechanics with
nonlocal potentials. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 2, 796(4).
Jindong Zhou and Guang Hou, Yongde Zhang. Telepotation scheme of
S-level quantum pure states by two-level Einstein-Pododlski-Rosen states. -
Physical Review A, Vol. 64, 012301-1-4.
Johnson, N. Playing a quantum game with a corrupted source. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 2, 020302(4).
Jordan, T. Quantum correlation violate Einstein-Podolski-Rosen
assumptions. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 4, 2726(3).
Kaszlikowski, D. and M. Zukowski. Bell theorem involving all possible
local measurements. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 2, 022114-1-6.
Kaulakys, B. and V. Gontis. Quantum anty–Zeno effect. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 56 (1997), N 2, 1131(7).
Kawabata, Shiro. Test of Bell's Inequality using the Spin Filter Effect in
Ferromagnetic Semicoductor Microstructures. - Journal of the Physical
Society of Japan. Vol. 70, N 5, 1210-1213.
Kempe, J., D. Bacon, D. Lidar, and K. Whaley. Theory of decoherence–
free fault–tolerant universal quantum computation. - Physical Review A. Vol.
63 (2001), N 4, 042307-1-29.
Kempe, J., C. Simon, and G. Weihs. Optimal photon cloning. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 62 (2000), N 3, 032302-1-8.
Ken-Ichi Aoki, Atsushi Horikoshi, and Etsuko Nakamura. Time of arrival
through interacting environments: Tunneling processes. - Physical Review
A. Vol. 62 (2000), N 2, 022101-1-9.
Kent, A. Noncontextual Hidden Variables and Physical Measurements.
Physiscal Review Letters. Vol. 83, N 19 (1999), 3755(3).
Kent, A. Remarks on Consitent Histories and Bohmian Mechanics. – In:
Bohmian Mechanics and Quantum Theory: an appraisal. Boston Studies in
the Phylososphy of Science. Vol. 184. Dordrecht, Boston, London, 1996.
Kim, M. and Jinhyoung Lee. Test of quantum nonlocality for cavity fields. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 4, 042102-1-5.
Kitano, M. Quantum Zeno effect and adiabatic change. - Physical Review
A. Vol. 56 (1997), N 4, 1138(4).
Klyshko, D. The Bell and GHZ theorems: a possible three–photon
interference experiment and the queszion of nonlocality. - Physics Letters A.
Vol. 172 (1993), 399-403.
Kochen, S. & E. Specker. The problem of hidden variables in quantum
mechanics. - Physical Review A. Vol. 17 (1967), N 1, 59-87.
Kofman, A., G. Kurizki and T. Opatrny. Zeno and anti-Zeno for photon
polarization dephasing. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 4, 042108-1-
11.
Kono, N. Decoherence and dephasing in a quantum measuerement
process. – Physical Review A. Vol. 54 (1996), N 2, 1064(23).
Krenn, G., A. Zeilinger. Enatangled entanglement. – Physical Review A.
Vol. 54 (1996), N 3, 1793(5).
Landauer, R. The physiscal nature of information. – Physics Letters A. Vol.
217 (1996), 188-193.
Lewenstein, M., B. Kraus, P. Horodecki, and J.Cirac. Characterization of
separable states and entanglement witnesses. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63
(2000), N 4, 022105-1-4.
Levenstein, M. and K. Rzazewski. Quantum anti-Zeno effect. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 2, 022105-1-5.
Linden, N and S. Popescu. Bound entanglement and teleportation. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (2001), N 1, 137(4).
Lloyd, S. Quantum–mechanical Maxwell's demon. – Physical Review A.
Vol. 63 (2001), N 5, 3374(9).
van Loock, P., S. Braunstein. Greenberg-Horne-Zeilinger nonlocality in
phase space. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 2, 022310-1-6.
Luis, A. Complementary and certainty relations for two dimensional
systems. - Physical Review A. Vol. 64 (2001), N 1, 012103-1-6.
Luis, A. Quantum-state preparation and control via Zeno effect. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 5, 052112-1-6.
Mancini, S and R. Bonifacio. Nondissipative decoherence bounds on
quantum computation. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 3, 0323106.
Massar, S., D. Bacon, N. Cerf, and R. Cleve. Classsical simulation of
quantum entanglement without local hidden variables. - Physical Review A.
Vol. 63 (2001), N 5, 052305-1-8.
McElwaine, J. Appoximate and exact consistency of histories. – Physical
Review A. Vol. 53 (1996), N 4, 2021(12).
McElwain, J. Maximum information and quantum prediction algorithms. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 56 (1997), N 3, 1756(11).
Milburn, G. and S. Braunstein. Quantum teleportation with squeezed
vacuum states. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 2, 937(6).
Misra, B. and E. Sudarshan. The Zeno's paradox in quantum theory. –
Journal of Mathematical Physics. Vol. 18 (1977), N 4, 756–763.
Mor, T. Sufficient conditions for a disentanglement. - Physical Review A.
Vol. 60 (1999), N 6, 4341(3).
Munro, W. Optimal states for Bell-inequaluty violations using quadratur_-
phase homodyne measurements. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 6,
4197(5).
Nelson, R., D. Cory, and S. Lloyd. Experimental demonstration of
Greenberg-Horne-Zeilinger correlations using nuclear magnetic resonance.
- Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 2, 022106-1-5.
Olavo, L. Foundations of quantum mechanics: Connection with stochastic
processes. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 5, 052109-1-14.
2PQbV 5. general theory of the decoherence effect in quantum
mechanics. - Physical Review A. Vol. 56 (1997), N 5, 3383(12).
Oppenheim, J., B. Reznik, and W. Unruh. Time-of-arrival states. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 3, 1804(5).
Orlowski, A. Informatiom entropy and squeezing of quantum fluctuations. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 56 (1997), N 4, 2545(4).
Parkins, A. and H. Kimble. Position-momentum Einstein-Podolski-Rosen
state of distantly separated trapped atoms. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61
(2000), N 5, 052104-1-5.
Pauli, W. General Principles of Quantum Mechanics. Springer–Verlag,
1980.
Pauli, W. Writings on Philosophy and Physics. Berlin, 1995.
Peres, A. Collective tests for quantum nonlocality. – Physical Review A.
Vol. 54 (1996), N 4, 2685(5).
Petrovski, T., G. Ordonez, and I. Prigogine. Quantum transitions and
nonlocality. - Physical Review A. Vol. 62 (2000), N 4, 042106-1-15.
Ping-Xing Chen and Lin-Mei Liang, Cheng-Zu Li, Ming-Qui Huang.
Necessary and sufficient condition of separability of any system. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 5, 052306(5).
Polzik, E. Einstein-Pododlski-Rosen corelated atomic enesembles. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 6, 4202(4).
Ponomarenko, S. and E. Wolf. Correlations in open quantum systems and
associated uncertainty relations. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 6,
062106(5).
Popesku, S. Bell's Inequalities and Density Matrices: Revealing "Hidden"
Nonlocality. – Physiscal Review Letters. Vol. 74 (1995), N 14, 2619(4).
Popesku, S. Thermodynsmics and the measure of entanglement. –
Physiscal Review A. Vol. 56 (1997), N 5, 3319(3).
Power, E. and T. Thirunamachandran. Analysis of the causal behavior in
energy transfer between atoms. – Physical Review A. Vol. 56 (1997), N 5,
3395(14).
Rains, E. Bound on distillable entanglement. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60
(1999), N 1, 179(6)
Rains, E. Rigorous treatment of distillable entanglement. - Physical Review
A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 1, 173(6).
Rajagopal, A. Quantum entanglement and maximum-enthropy states from
the Jaynes principle. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 6, 4338(3).
Rajagopal, A. and R. Rendell. Decoherence, correlation, and
entanglement in a pair of coupled quantum dissioative oscilators. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 2, 022116-1-11.
Reid, M. Violations of Bell inequalities for measurements with macroscopic
uncertainties: What it means to violate macroscopic realism. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 62 (2000), N 2, 022110-1-10.
Reynaud, S., P.A. Maia Neto, A. Lambrecht and M.-T. Jaekel.
Gravitational decoherence of planetary motions. - Europhysics Letters. Vol.
54 (2001), N 2, 135-140.
Reznik, B. and Y. Aharonov. Time–symmetric formulation of quantum
mechanics. - Physical Review A. Vol. 52 (1995), N 4, 2538(13).
Rudolf, O. Temporal quantum theory. - Physical Review A. Vol. 59 (1999),
N 2, 1045(11).
Ruseckas, J. and B. Kaulakys. Real measurements and the quantum
Zeno effect. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 6, 062103(9).
Schleich, W. Engineering decoherence. – Nature, Vol. 403 (2000), 256–
257.
Schlienz, J. and C. Mahler. Description of entanglement. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 52 (1995), N 6, 4396(9).
Schmidt, P., P. Kwiat, and B.-G. Englert. Quantative wave-oarticle duality
and nonerasing quantum erasure. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 6,
4285(6).
Schumacher, B. Sending entanglement through noisy quantum channels. –
- Physical Review A. Vol. 54 (1999), N 4, 2614(15).
Schumacher, B. and M. Nielsen. Quantum data processing and error
correction. – Physiscal Review A. Quantum data processing and error
correction. – Physical Review A. Vol. 54 (1996), N 4, 2629(7).
Shengjun Wu and Yongde Zhang. Multipartite pure-state entanglement
and the generalized Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states. - Physical Review
A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 1, 012308-1-7.
Shih, Y. Quantum entanglement and quantum teleportation. - Annalen der
Physik. Vol. 513 (ser 8, vol. 10) (2001), N 1-2, pp. 19-34. - Physical Review
A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 1, 012102-1-8.
Simon, C, C. Brukner, and A. Zeilinger. Hidden Variable theorems for
Real Experiments. Physical Review Letters. Vol. 86, N 20 (2001), 4427(4).
Spreeuw, R. Classical wave-optics analogy of quantum-infomation
processing. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 6, 062302(8).
Strekalov, D., Yoon-Ho Kim, Yanhua Shih. Experimental study of a
subsistem in an entangled two-photon state. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60
(1999), N 4, 2685(4).
Sumiyoshi Abe and A.Rajagopal. Quantum entanglement inferred by the
principle of maximum nonaditive entropy. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60
(1999), N 5, 2685(4).
Sun, C. and H. Zhan, X. Liu. Decoherence and relevaht universality in
quantum algorithms via a dinamic theory for quantum measurement. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 58 (1988), N 3, 1810(12).
Tan, S. Confirming entanglement in continuous variable quantum
teleportation. - Physical Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 4, 2752(7).
Teufel, S., K. Berndl, and D. Dvrr, S. Goldstein. Locality and causality in
hidden-variables models of quantum theory. – Physical Review A. Vol. 56
(1997), N 2, 1217(11).
Tittel, W., J. Brendel, N. Gisin and H. Zbinden. Long-distance Bell-type
tests using energy-time entangled phozons. - Physical Review A. Vol. 59
(1999), N 6, 4150(14).
Toller, M. Localization of events in space-time. - Physical Review A. Vol. 59
(1999), N 2, 960(11)
Untuh, W. Nonlocality, counterfactuals, and quantum mechanics. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 1, 126(5).
Vaidman, L. and N. Yoran. Methods for reliable teleportation. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 59 (1999), N 1, 116(10).
Venugopalan, A. Pointer states via decoherence in a quantum
measurement. -
Vilas-Boas, C., N de Almeida, and M. Moussa. Teleportation of a zero-
and one photon running-wave state by projection synthesis. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 4, 2759(5).
Werner, R. and M. Wolf. Bell's inequalities for states with positive partial
transpose. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 6, 062102-1-4.
Wootters, W., W. Zurek. - Nature. Vol. 299 (1982), 802-803.
Wu, J. Violation of Bell's inequalites and two-mode quantum-optical state
measurement. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 2, 022111-1-5.
Xiaoguang Wang. Entanglement in the quantum Heisenberg XY model. -
Physical Review A. Vol. 64 (2001), N 1, 012313-1-7.
Yamada, N. Probabilities for histories in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics.
– Physical Review A. Vol. 54 (1996), N 1, 182(22).
Yang Chui-Ping, Guo Guang-Can. Multiparticle Generalization of
Teleportation. - Chinese Physics Letters. Vol. 17 (2000), N 3, 162-164.
Yi, X., G. Jin, and D. Zhou. Creating Bell states and decoherence efects in
a quantum-dot system. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63 (2001), N 6, 062307-1-
4.
Yu Shi. Early Gedanken experiments of quantum mechanics revisited. -
Annalen der Physik. Vol. 512 (ser 8, vol. 9) (2000), N 8, pp. 637-648.
Zalka, C. Grover's quantum searching algorithm is optimal. - Physical
Review A. Vol. 60 (1999), N 4, 2746(6).
Zhong-yang Wang, Xun-li Feng, Shang-qing, and Zhi-zhan Hu. Atomic-
state teleportation by using a quantum switch. - Physical Review A. Vol. 63
(2001), N 6, 062308-1-7.
Zukowski, M and Dagomir Kaszlikowski. Greenberg-Horne-Zeilinger
paradoxes with symmetric multiport beam splitters. - Physical Review A.
Vol. 59 (1999), N 5, 3200(4).
Zukowski, M. Violations of local realism in multiphoton interference
experiments. - Physical Review A. Vol. 61 (2000), N 2, 022109-1-5.
Zurek, W. Schrpdinger's sheep. – Nature. Vol. 404 (2000), 130–131.