You are on page 1of 51

Fuel Cells for a Sustainable Energy Future

Sossina M. Haile
Materials Science / Chemical Engineering California Institute of Technology
Graduate Students: Peter Babilo, William Chueh, Lisa Cowan, Mary Louie, Justin Ho, Wei Lai, Mikhail Kislitsyn, Kenji Sasaki, Ayako Ikeda Former Participants: Dane Boysen, Calum Chisholm, Tetsuya Uda, Zongping Shao, Mary Thundathil Funding: National Science Foundation, Department of Energy, Office of Naval Research, (past: Kirsch Foundation, Powell Foundation)

Contents
The Problem of Energy
Growing consumption Consequences Sustainable energy resources

Fuel Cell Technology Overview


Principle of operation Types of fuel cells and their characteristics

Recent (Caltech) Advances


Too many to cover

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

The Problem of Energy


The Problem
Diminishing supply? Resources in unfriendly locations? Environmental damage?

The Solution
Adequate domestic supply Environmentally benign Conveniently transported Conveniently used

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

World Energy Consumption


(annual)
Source: US Energy Information Agency

264 211 158 106 52 0

8.4 6.7

5.0 3.3 1.7 0

1999 totals: 2020 projections:

400 Q-Btu, 422 EJ, 630 Q-Btu, 665 EJ,

13TW 21TW

90% fossil

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Equivalent Power (TW, 1012)

Exa Joules (1018)

Fossil Fuel Supplies


Source: US Energy Information Agency

00 0 . E+ 0 00 0 . E+ 0 (Exa)J 00 0 . E+ 0 00 0 . E+ 0 00 0 . E+ 0

Rsv = Reserves (90%) Rsc = Resources (50%)

Unconv Conv

Oil Rsv
Source
Oil Gas Coal

Oil Rsc

Gas Rsv

Gas Rsc

Coal Rsv

Coal Rsc
Total, yrs 23 - 55 18 - 65 300

Reserves, yrs 13 - 20 11 - 25 32

Resources, yrs 10 35 7 40 270

> 400 yrs

56-77
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

287-345

US Energy Imports/Exports: 1949-2004


Source: US Energy Information Agency

35 30 Quad BTU 25 20 15 10

Imports
Quad BTU Total

6 5 4 3 2 1

Exports
Total

Coal

5 0 1950 1960 1970 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 1950

Petroleum 1980 1990 2000

Petroleum 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000

0 1950

Net

65% of known petroleum reserves in Middle East 3% of reserves in USA, but 25% of world consumption

Quad BTU

1957: Net Importer

1960

1970

1980

1990

2000

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Environmental Outlook
Global CO2 levels
11 1 00 0 00 0 11 1 00 0 11 1 11 1 00 0

atmospheric CO0 [ppm]

2004: 378 ppm Projections: 500-700 ppm by 2020

Anthropogenic
Fossil fuel (75%) Land use (25%)

Industrial Revolution

00 00

11 11

11 11

11 11

11 11

00 00

Source: Oak Ridge National Laboratory


Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

year

Environmental Outlook
CO2 CH4 (ppmv) (ppmv) 800 325 300 275 250 225 200 175 700 600 500 400 300 400 300 200 100 0

CO2 in 2004: 378 ppmv


-- CO2 -- CH4 -- T +4 0 -4 -8

Thousands of years before present (Ky BP)


Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 2001; http://www.ipcc.ch N. Oreskes, Science 306, 1686, 2004; D. A. Stainforth et al, Nature 433, 403, 2005 Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

T relative to present (C)

Energy Outlook
Supply Fossil energy sufficient for world demand into the forseeable future High geopolitical risk Rising costs Environmental Impact Target
Stabilize CO2 at 550 ppm By 2050

Requires
20 TW carbon-free power One 1-GW power plant daily from now until then

Urgency Transport of CO2 or heat into deep oceans:


400-1000 years; CO2 build-up is cummulative

Must make dramatic changes within next few years

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

The Energy Solution


1.2 x 10 TW at Earth surface 600 TW practical
5

Solar

The need: ~ 20 TW by 2050

2-4 TW extractable

Wind

Tide/Ocean Currents
2 TW gross

5-7 TW gross all cultivatable land not used for food

Biomass

Geothermal
12 TW gross over land small fraction recoverable

Hydroelectric
4.6 1.6 0.9 0.6 TW TW TW TW gross technically feasible economically feasible installed capacity

Waste disposal

Nuclear

1% / yr leakage -> lost in 100 yrs


Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Fossil with sequestration

The Energy Solution


Sufficient Domestic Supply
Coal, Nuclear, Solar

Environmentally Sustainable Supply


Solar (Nuclear?)

Suitable Carrier
Electricity? Hydrogen? Hydrocarbon?

Challenges
Convert solar (nuclear) to convenient chemical form Efficient consumption of chemical fuel

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

A Sustainable Energy Cycle


C-free Source Capture
eSolar or nuclear power plants ??? H2O, CO2

H2

Storage

Batteries

Hydrocarbon

Hydrides? Liquid H2?

Delivery

e-

Utilization
Fuel cell
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

H2O + CO2

A Few Words on Hydrogen Fuel Cells


Hydrogen energy density
High energy content per unit mass of hydrogen But best storage technologies are at ~ 5 wt% H2 5x the weight of gasoline (for same energy content)

Conventional hydrogen fuel cells require Pt


DOE target: 1 g/kW (0.75 g/hp) 100 hp engine 75g Pt $3,169 93% of US Pt is imported 80% of world reserves in one mine complex in SA
Another 15% in one mine complex in Russia

Converting US autos would double world consumption 4 yr auto lifetime, 20% recycling out in 40 yrs
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Fuel Cells: Part of the Solution?


High efficiency
0 0 automotive engine: 11 kW - 11

low CO2 emissions

efficiency [%]

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Size independent

Fuel Cells
Co
0

Various applications
stationary automotive portable electronics

ngines E ustion mb
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Controlled reactions
Zero Emissions

power plant size [MW]

Operable on hydrogen
(if suitably produced)

*Can be as high as 80-90% with co-generation


Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Fuel Cell: Principle of Operation


best of batteries, combustion engines conversion device, not energy source

Anode

Cathode

eH2 H2 2H+ + 2eH+ O2 O2 + 2H+ + 2e- H2O

Electrolyte
Overall: H2 + O2 H2O
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Fuel Cell Performance


H2 + O2 H2O
1.17 Volts (@ no current) 1.0

1.2

cross-over

0.8 theoretical voltage

fuel cross-over reaction kinetics electrolyte resistance slow mass diffusion

Voltage [V]

0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0.0 0.0 0.4

peak power 0.4 electrolyte resistance slow mass diffusion 0.8 1.2

0.2

power = I*V peak efficiency at low I peak power at mid I

0.0 1.6

Current [A / cm2 ]

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Power [W / cm2]

voltage losses

slow reaction kinetics

0.6

Fuel Cell Components


Components
Electrolyte (Membrane)
Transport ions Block electrons, gases electrodes catalyst

Electrodes
Catalyze reactions Transport
Ions, electrons, gases

May be a composite
(electro)Catalyst + Conductors + Pore former

sealant electrolyte

Membrane-Electrode Assembly (MEA)

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Fuel Cell Types


Types differentiated by electrolyte, temperature of operation
Low T H2 or MeOH; High T higher hydrocarbons (HC) Efficiency tends to as T , due to faster electrocatalysis Type C
[F]

PEM 90-110
[200-230]

AFC 100-250
[212-500]

PAFC 150-220
[300-430]

MCFC
500-700
[930-1300]

SOFC
700-1000
[1300-1800]

Fuel
Electrolyte

H2 + H2O

H2 KOH OH-
O2 + H2O

H2 H3PO4 H+ O2

HC + CO

HC + CO

Ion Oxidant

Nafion H3O+ O2

Na2CO3 CO32-
O2 + CO2

Y-ZrO2 O2- O2

By-products: H2O, CO2

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Fuel Cell Choices


Temperature sets operational parameters & fuel choice
Ambient Temperature
Rapid start-up H2 or CH3OH as fuels Catalysts easily poisoned

High Temperature
Fuel flexible Very high efficiencies Long start-up

Applications
Portable power Many on/off cycles Small size

Applications
Stationary power Auxiliary power in portable systems

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Technology Status
Many, many demonstrate sites and vehicles
Stationary PAFC (200 kW) at military sites since 1995 Stationary SOFC (100 kW) operated for 20,000 hrs Toyota and Honda PEM FC vehicles released 2002 DaimlerChrysler, Ford and GM, 2005; Hyundai planned

Legislation is a key driver


California zero emissions automotive standards China set for tough CAFE standards

Cost is a major barrier


Precious metal catalysts, fabrication, complexity

Uncertainty in future fuel infrastructure


Gasoline for how long? Hydrogen? Methanol?
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Fuel Cell System Complexity


Membrane electrode assembly
sealant electrolyte electrodes catalyst

Electrolyte

System
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Stack

Philosophy
Challenge Limitation of fuel cell materials places severe design constraints on fuel cell systems Approach Material modification for improved performance and system simplification New materials discovery for next generation fuel cell systems Novel system designs
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Fuel Cell Innovations


New Electrolytes
Intermediate temperature operation
Lower the temperature below solid oxide fuel cells Raise the temperature above polymer fuel cells

New Catalysts
Enhance reaction kinetics (improve efficiency) Reduce susceptibility to poisons (reduce complexity)

Novel integrated designs


Dramatically improve thermal management Utilize micromachining technologies micro fuel cells

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

New Electrolytes: Solid Acids


NSF & DOE Sponsored Program (past ONR support)

PEM Fuel Cells


Proton Exchange Membrane or Polymer Electrolyte Membrane
H(H2O)n+ H2O
SO3- + (H2O)nH+
1 nm

Nafion (Dupont) saturate with H2O


inverse micelle structure

H(H2O)n+ ion transport High conductivity Flexible, high strength Requires humidification & water management Operation below 90C Permeable to methanol

(CF2)n

Kreuer, J Membr Sci 2 (2001) 185.

Target: 120-300C; examine inorganic H+ conductors


Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Solid Acids
Chemical intermediates between normal salts and normal acids: acid salts
(Cs2SO4) + (H2SO4) CsHSO4

d is o r d e r e d s tru c tu re
lo g ( c o n d u c t iv it y )

p o ly m e r

Physically similar to salts Structural disorder at warm temperatures Properties


Direct H+ transport Humidity insensitive Impermeable Water soluble!! Brittle
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

n o rm a l s tru c tu re s tru c tu ra l t r a n s it io n
T 0/ T
.

Proton Transport Mechanism

H S O Sulfate group reorientation 10-11 seconds

Proton transfer 10-9 seconds

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Conductivity of Solid Acids


CsHSO4 [Baranov, 1982] CsHSeO4 [Baranov, 1982] (NH4)3H(SO4)2
[Ramasastry, 1981] 00 0 C 00 00 0 C 0 C 1 C 0 C 1 0

-0

log(conductivity) [S / cm]

-0 -0 -0 -0 -0 -0 -0

Superprotonic transition

Rb3H(SeO4)2
[Pawlowski, 1988]

Cs2(HSO4)(H2PO4)
[Chisholm & Haile, 2000]

-Cs3(HSO4)2(H2PO4)
[Haile et al., 1997]

K3H(SO4)2
[Chisholm & Haile, 2001]

00 11 00 11 00 00 . 0 . 1 . 0 . 1 . 0 . 0

0 0 /T K 00

-0

But sulfates and selenates are unstable under reducing conditions

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Solid Acid Properties


The Good H+ transport only
No electro-osmotic drag No electron transport Alcohol impermeable

The Bad Known compounds are water soluble


Operate at T 100C Insoluble analogs?

Humidity insensitive conductivity Stable to ~ 250C Inexpensive Chemically non-aggressive

Few are chemically stable The Ugly Poor processability and mechanical properties
Composite membranes with inert polymers

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

CsH2PO4 as a Fuel Cell Electrolyte


Expected to have chemical stability
3CsH2PO4 + 11H2 Cs3PO4 + 3H3P + 8H2O dG(rxn) >> 0

But does it have high conductivity? Does it have sufficient thermal stability? Literature dispute
High conductivity on heating due to H2O loss High conductivity due to transition to a cubic phase

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

CsH2PO4 Dehydration
CsH2PO4 CsPO3 + H2O
pressure detector

11 .
CsH2PO4 + H2O

Tc = 230

Toper = 250C

0 0 0 0

00 . 00 . 11 . 00 . 00 0

P(H2O) operation

Cs H

2-2 x

PO

0 0 0 0

11 1

00 0

Cs

11 1

00 0

Temperature (C)

Use water partial pressure to suppress dehydration


Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Water temperature ( C)

Equilibrium pH O(atm)

PO

4-x

Conductivity of CsH2PO4
Temperature [ C]
00 0 11 1 00 0 00 0 00 0 00 0 0 heating st 0 cooling st 0 heating nd 0 cooling nd
Humidified air p[H2O] = 0.4 atm
o

0.42 eV

log(conductivity) [ cm ]
-0 -0

-0

-0

-0

230 C

00 .

00 .

00 .

00 .
-0

11 .

11 .

0 0 /T [K ] 00
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Proof of Principle
H2O, H2 | Cell | O2, H2O
T = 235C
00 .

50 mW/cm2
before after

0 0 0 0 0 0

Power density (mW cm )

-0

Cell voltage (V)

11 . 11 . 11 . 00 . 00 . 0 voltage power

Compared to polymers High open circuit voltage


Theoretical: 1.15V Measured: 1.00 V Polymers: 0.8-0.9 V

0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Power density
Polymers: > 1 W/cm2

0 0

00 00 00 00 00 0 0 0 0 0
-0

Current density (mA cm )


260m membrane; 18 mg Pt/cm2

Platinum content
Polymers: ~ 0.1 mg/cm2

D. A. Boysen, T. Uda, C. R.I. Chisholm and S. M. Haile, Science 303, 68-70 (2004)
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Fuel Cell Longevity: Stable Performance


00 .

H2, H2O | cell | O2, H2O


260 m thick CsH2PO4 electrolyte T = 235C Current = 100 mA/cm2

Cell voltage (V)

11 . 11 . 11 . 11 . 00 .

on, 000 mA/cm

off

0 0

0 0

0 0

0 0

00 0

Time (h)
CsH2PO4 no degradation in 110 hr measurement CsHSO4 functions for only ~ 30 mins (recoverable degradation)
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

3rd Generation Fuel Cell


Fine CsH2PO4
H2, H2O | cell | O2, H2O
T = 248C 8 mg Pt/cm2

2 m

Slurry deposit

10-40 m pores, ~40% porosity Open circuit voltage: 0.9-1.0 V


Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

T. Uda & S.M. Haile, Electrochem & Solid State Lett. 8 (2005) A245-A246

Peak power density: 285-415 mW/cm2

Impact
S. M. Haile, D. A. Boysen, C. R. I. Chisholm and R. B. Merle, Solid Acids as Fuel Cell Electrolytes, Nature 410, 910-913 (2001).

The promise of protonics Some Like It Medium Hot

Solid Acids Show Promise...

Nature: News & Views Science Now Magazine


Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Physics Today Online

Fuel Cell Stack

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Direct Alcohol Fuel Cells


Methanol in proton exchange membrane fuel cells
CH3OH + H2O 6H+ + CO2 + 6eCH3OH + H2O 3H2 + CO2

SAFCS ideal thermal match


Reforming rxn: 200 300C Electrolyte: 240 280C Steam reforming: endothermic Fuel cell rxns: exothermic

Integrated design
Incorporate alcohol reforming catalyst in anode chamber

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Direct Methanol Fuel Cells


With reformer
00 .
T = 260 C; 47 m membrane

Without reformer

Cell voltage (V)

11 . 11 . 00 . 00 .

hydrogen hydrogen reformate methanol


42 vol% 1%CO 24%CO2

11 . 11 . 11 .
methanol

00 . 00 .

11 .

00 .

00 . 00 1.5 .

00 .
0

00 .

00 .

00 .

Current density (A/cm )


Methanol power ~ 85% H2 power For polymer fuel cells ~ 10% Reformate power ~ 90% H2 power Methanol power ~ 45% H2 power

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Power density (W /cm )

T = 240 C; 34 m membrane

11 .

Direct Alcohol Fuel Cells


With reformer
T = 260 C; 47 m membrane

80 proof

Vodka

36 vol%

ethanol

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Ethanol power ~ 40% H2 power

New Cathodes for Solid Oxide Fuel Cells


NSF & DOE Sponsored Program (past DARPA support)

State-of-the-Art SOFCs
Component Materials
cathode (air electrode) electrolyte anode (fuel electrode) (La,Sr)MnO3 Zr0.92Y0.08O2.96 = yttria stabilized zirconia (YSZ) Ni + YSZ composite

Operation: ~1000 C Fuel flexible, efficient But


All high temp materials Costly (manufacture) Poor thermal cyclability

Goal: 500 800 C Challenges


Slower kinetics Electrolyte resistance Poor anode activity Poor cathode activity

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Cathodes


Traditional cathodes
A3+B3+O3 perovskites Poor O2- transport Limited reaction sites
(Ba0.5Sr0.5)(Co0.8Fe0.2)O2.3

Our approach
High O2- flux materials Extended reaction sites A2+B4+O3 perovskites triple-point path
O2 Oad O2Oad 2eO2

almost 1 in 4 vacant

electrode bulk path


Oad 2ecathode O2-

cathode electrolyte

O2-

electrolyte

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Cathode Electrocatalysis
O2 2e
-

+
Electrolyte cathode layers

Symmetric cell resistance measurements

O2, Ar, (CO2) Ag current collectors

O=

2e O2

Equivalent circuit
Distinguish resistance contributions using frequency dependent measurements

Rcathode Relectrolyte Rcathode

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Cathode Electrocatalysis
Temperature (C)
o

.cm 0)

0 0

00 0 0 00 00 00 0 0 00 0 0 0 0

00 0

00 0

0 0

O2 slow fast

Oad
2eO2O2-

cathode electrolyte

P(O2) = 0.21 atm


0 0

Cathode area specific resistance (

Ea same as oxygen surface exchange (113 kJ.mol-1)

00 .

0.5 0.6 cm2

00 .

Ea=000 kJ.mol
00 . 0

-0

Bulk diffusion is fast (46 kJ.mol-1) Other advanced cathodes (PrSm)CoO3: 5.5 cm2 (LaSr)(CoFe)O3: 48 cm2

Symmetric cell0 -electrode) ( Half cell 0-electrode) (


00 . 00 . 11 . 11 .
-0

00 . 0

11 .

11 .

0 0/T (K ) 00
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Cell Fabrication
Anode supported NiO + SDC (Ce0.85Sm0.15O2) Dual dry press SDC NiO + SDC Calcine, 950oC 5h, inert gas Spray cathode Sinter, 1350oC 5h

600oC 5h, 15%H2

cathode electrolyte anode Anode: 700 m

Porous anode

Electrolyte surface

0.71 cm2

~ 20m Electrolyte Cathode: 20 m


2 m

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

1.3 cm

Fuel Cell Power Output


H2, 3% H2O | fuel cell | Air
00 . 11 . 11 . 00 . 00 . 00 . 0

> 1 W/cm2 at 600C!!!

00 0 00 0 0

00 00

00 00

00 00
-0

00 00

Current density (mA.cm )


Comparison: literature cathode material 350 mW/cm2 at 600C
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Power density (mW.cm )

Voltage (Volts)

000 C 00 00 o 000 C o 000 C o 0 000 0 0 C o 000 C 00 0

-0

Impact
Cooler Material Boosts Fuel Cells
Z. Shao and S. M. Haile, A High Performance Cathode for the Next Generation Solid-Oxide Fuel Cells, Nature 431, 170-173 (2004).

SOFC cathode is hot stuff Next generation of fuel cells

Tech Research News R & D Focus


Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Fuel Cell Works

Summary & Conclusions


Sustainable energy is the grand challenge of the 21st century
Solutions must meet the need, not the hype Fuel cells can play an important role

Solid acid fuel cells


Radical alternatives to state-of-the-art Viability demonstrated; spin-off company established

Solid oxide fuel cells


Promising alternative cathode discovered

Still plenty of need for fundamental research


The stone age didnt end because we ran out of stones.
-Anonymous
Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Acknowledgments
The people
Tetsuya Mary Justin Zongping

Wei

Calum

Dane Kenji

The agencies
National Science Foundation, Office of Naval Research, DARPA, California Energy Commission, Department of Energy, Kirsch Foundation, Powell Foundation

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

Selected Relevant Publications


T. Uda, D. A. Boysen, C. R. I. Chisholm and S. M. Haile, Alcohol Fuel Cells at Optimal Temperatures, Electrochem. Solid State Lett. 9, A261-A264 (2006). T. Uda and S. M. Haile, Thin-Membrane Solid-Acid Fuel Cell, Electrochem. Solid State Lett. 8, A245-A246 (2005). D. A. Boysen, T. Uda, C. R.I. Chisholm and S. M. Haile, High performance Solid Acid Fuel Cells through humidity stabilization, Science Online Express, Nov 20, 2003; Science 303, 68-70 (2004). D. A. Boysen, S. M. Haile, H. Lui and R. A. Secco High-temperature Behavior of CsH2PO4 under both Ambient and High Pressure Conditions, Chem. Mat. 15, 727-736 (2003). R. B. Merle, C. R. I. Chisholm, D. A. Boysen and S. M. Haile, Instability of Sulfate and Selenate Solid Acids in Fuel Cell Environments, Energy and Fuels 17, 210215 (2003). S. M. Haile, D. A. Boysen, C. R. I. Chisholm and R. B. Merle, Solid Acids as Fuel Cell Electrolytes, Nature 410, 910-913 (2001). Z. P. Shao, S. M. Haile, J. M. Ahn, P.D. Ronney, Z. L. Zhan and S. A. Barnett, A thermally self-sustained micro Solid-Oxide Fuel Cell stack with high power density, Nature 435, 795-798 (2005). Z. Shao and S. M. Haile, A High Performance Cathode for the Next Generation Solid-Oxide Fuel Cells, Nature 431, 170-173 (2004). S. M. Haile, Fuel Cell Materials and Components, (invited) Acta. Met. 51, 59816000 (2003). S. M. Haile, Materials for Fuel Cells, (invited) Materials Today 18, 24-29 (2003).

Towards a Sustainable Energy Future

You might also like