Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ajay J. Kirtane
2. Improve Prognosis
It is generally accepted that revascularization makes symptomatic patients feel better but it is also a FACT that The Presence of Severe CAD is Prognostically Important!
Mortality
Medical Rx
Cardiac Death Rate
8%
Revasc
P <.0001
6.7%
6%
4.8%
4%
3.7% 2.9%
3.3% 2.0%
2%
1.8% 1.0%
0%
1331 56
718 109
545 243
252 267
1- 5%
5-10%
11-20%
>20%
40 35
OMT (n=155)
Mean = -0.5%
30 25
30 25
20
15
p<0.0001 20
15
10
5 0
8.2%
5.5%
(4.7%-6.3%)
10
5 0
8.6%
8.1%
(6.9%-9.4%)
Pre-Rx
6-18m
Pre-Rx
6-18m
A study of prophylactic revascularization among patients with no definite need for invasive intervention
IP = insulin provision IS = insulin sensitization
100
Revascularization
100 80 60 40 20 0 0 1
Revascularization
77.6
Medical Therapy
Medical Therapy
83.6
69.5
P=0.33
P=0.01
2 3 4 5
Years
N at Risk 763 734 718 692 586 333 N at Risk 763 668
Years
634 568 421 230
Prior MI
Proximal LAD disease Pts without prior procedures N lesions 50% DS, mean N lesions 70% DS, mean N of diseased vessels -0 -1 -2
30.1%
10.3% 2.1 1.5 0.8 1.0 4% 41% 36%
36.0%
19.4% 3.6 1.7 1.7 1.3 1% 9% 37%
<0.0001
-3
Any total occlusions
19%
7%
53%
14% <0.0001 <0.0001
Jeopardy index, %
38 22
61 21
The BARI 2D Study Group. NEJM 2009;360:2503-15 Schwartz L et al. AJC 2009;103:632638
NO
RANDOMIZE
100
90 80 70 5-year D/MI/CVA PCI vs. CABG 16.7% vs. 16.9%, P=0.69 HR [95%CI] = 0.96 [0.79-1.16]
PCI 83.3%
CABG 83.1%
PLR = 0.64
60
50
365
730
1095
1460
1825
Days
Daemen J et al. Circulation 2008;118:1146-1154
CABG PCI
35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0
Mortality (%)
20 15 10 5 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
No. of patients*
CABG PCI 3889 3923 3767 3675 3798 3709
Years of follow-up
3415 3431 3180 3205 2693 2658 1853 1828 1609 1576 1477 1452 CABG PCI 3695 3725 3369 3269 3419 3310
Years of follow-up
3001 3023 2763 2797 2294 2267 1501 1491 1269 1253 1161 1150
25
20 15
10
5 0 0 1
3169 587 3217 574
Number of patients* CABG no diabetes 3263 CABG diabetes 615 PCI no diabetes 3298 PCI diabetes 618
2 3 4 5 6 Years of follow-up
3089 575 3148 555 2877 532 2918 508 2677 498 2725 475 2267 421 2281 373 1592 257 1608 218
7
1380 225 1393 179
8
1274 200 1288 160
23 US Sites
Heart Team (surgeon & interventionalist) All Pts with de novo 3VD and/or
Amenable for both Amenable for only one treatment options treatment approach Treatment preference (9.4%)
Stratification: Referring MD or pts. refused Stratification: LM and informed consent (7.0%) LM and Diabetes Diabetes Inclusion/exclusion (4.7%) RandomizedWithdrew Arms before consent Two Registry Arms (4.3%) N=1800Other (1.8%) N=1275 Randomized Arms * Two Registry Arms Medical treatment (1.2%) PCI CABG PCI CABG CABG n=1800 TAXUS CABG TAXUS vs all captured w/ 2500 N=903 N=198 N=1077 N=897 n=1077 n=897 n=903 n=198 follow up 750 w/ f/u no f/u 71% 5yr f/u LM vs 3VD 3VD LM enrolled * TAXUS Express n=428 n=649 (N=3,075) 66.3% 33.7% 65.4% 34.6%
TAXUS (N=903)
20
8.6% 6.7%
0
0 12 24 Months Since Allocation 36
Cumulative KM Event Rate 1.5 SE; log-rank P value;*Binary rates Event Rate 1.5 SE. * Fishers Exact Test
TAXUS (N=903)
20
14.1% 12.0%
0
0 12 24 Months Since Allocation 36
ITT population
Cumulative KM Event Rate 1.5 SE; log-rank P value;*Binary rates Event Rate 1.5 SE. * Fishers Exact Test
TAXUS (N=903)
2-3 years* 4.8% vs 6.7% P=0.10
28.0%
20
20.2%
Cumulative KM Event Rate 1.5 SE; log-rank P value;*Binary rates Event Rate 1.5 SE. * Fishers Exact Test
TAXUS (N=903)
19.7%
20
10.7%
0
0 12 24 Months Since Allocation 36
ITT population
Cumulative KM Event Rate 1.5 SE; log-rank P value;*Binary rates Event Rate 1.5 SE. * Fishers Exact Test
50
50
45
40
40
35
P<0.001
P=0.50 P=0.07
30
30
Baseline
1 month
6 months
12 months
Baseline
1 month
6 months
12 months
PCI
CABG
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
Baseline
1 month
6 months
12 months
SAQ-AF: Angina-Free*
100%
PCI
80%
CABG
P=0.05
P=NS
68.5% 72.0% 71.6% 76.3%
P=NS
64.4%
61.6%
60%
40%
20%
40
30
20
10
0 10 20 30 40 50
CABG (N=275)
TAXUS (N=299)
P=0.98
22.7%
20
22.5%
0
0 12 24 Months Since Allocation 36
Calculated by core laboratory; ITT population
Cumulative KM Event Rate 1.5 SE; log-rank P value;*Binary rates Event Rate 1.5 SE. * Fishers Exact Test
CABG (N=300)
P=0.02
20 18.9%
0
0 12 24 Months Since Allocation 36
Calculated by core laboratory; ITT population
Cumulative KM Event Rate 1.5 SE; log-rank P value;*Binary rates Event Rate 1.5 SE. * Fishers Exact Test
CABG (N=315)
TAXUS (N=290)
34.1%
P<0.001
20 19.5%
0
0 12 24 Months Since Allocation 36
Calculated by core laboratory; ITT population
Cumulative KM Event Rate 1.5 SE; log-rank P value;*Binary rates Event Rate 1.5 SE. * Fishers Exact Test
Indications for CABG vs PCI in stable patients with lesions suitable for both procedures and low predicted surgical mortality
Subset of CAD by anatomy 1VD or 2VD non proximal LAD 1VD or 2VD proximal LAD 3VD simple lesions, full functional revascularization achievable with PCI, SYNTAX score 22 Favours CABG IIb C IA IA IA IA IA IA IA Favours PCI IC IIa B IIa B III A IIa B IIb B IIb B III B
3VD complex lesions, incomplete revascularizarion achievable with PCI, SYNTAX score > 22
Left main (isolated or 1VD, ostium/shaft) Left main (isolated or 1VD, bifurcation) Left main + 2VD or 3VD, SYNTAX score 32 Left main + 2VD or 3VD, SYNTAX score 33
Does not include any subset of lesions (i.e. in-stent restenosis, stenotic bypass grafts, coronary anomalies, muscular bridges, aneurysms)
Does not account for patient choice!
Capodanno, et al. Am Heart J 2011;161:462-70
In observational registries, the intermediate tertile is frequently poorly calibrated with respect to the outcomes of the high and low tertiles
1-year MACCE 1-year MACE 32-month MACE 3-year MACCE
+14.0%
-11.2%
+6.5%
SYNTAX
Circulation 2010
Capodanno et al.
Circ Card Interv 2009
Brito et al.
EuroPCR 2010
MAIN COMPARE
JACC Interv 2010
0.85
0.80 0.75
180 days Angio-guided 4.9% 360 days (n=496) 5.3% MACE 13.3% vs. 18.2% P=0.02
60 120 180 240 300 360
0.70
0
Days
Tonino PAL et al. NEJM 2009;360:21324
FFR
1-VD 2-VD
1-VD
160 (32%)
166 (34%)
95 (19%)
119 (24%)
281 (57%)
170 (35%)
Without FFR
With FFR
NO
RANDOMIZE (n=1600)
OMT Alone
SPIRIT II, III, IV and COMPARE trials Pooled database analysis (n=6,789) Ischemic TLR
10
4.7%
4.1%
2.3%
0 0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24
Time in Months
Number at risk XIENCE TAXUS 4247 2542 4143 2416 4004 2328 3891 2260 3363 2018
SPIRIT II, III, IV and COMPARE trials Pooled database analysis (n=6,789) Stent thrombosis (ARC definite/probable)
3
0.7%
0 0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24
Time in Months
Number at risk XIENCE TAXUS 4247 2542 4177 2463 4082 2408 3998 2350 3479 2110
28.0%
30%
20.2%
20
Cumulative KM Event Rate 1.5 SE; log-rank P value; * Binary rates Event Rate 1.5 SE. * Fishers Exact Test
PRIMARY Endpoint: 3-year death, MI, stroke SECONDARY Endpoints: 12-month MACCE, 3-year Quality of Life PI: Valentin Fuster