24 May 2009

BNPP bill loses authors; FDC continues its opposition

MANILA, Philippines – In the course of consolidating the proposed House Bill to immediately
rehabilitate and operate the Bataan Nuclear Power Plant (BNPP) with related bills, 60 endorsers
and supporters disappeared along the way.

The Freedom from Debt Coalition (FDC), a member of the Network Opposed to the BNPP (NO
to BNPP), sees this as the result – in part – of the “People Are Watching You” campaign – a
people’s direct engagement and vigilant watch over of legislators and urging them to withdraw
support from the BNPP bill.

“We, note with interest that there is a significant reduction of endorsers on the proposed
consolidated bill than on the original mother bill,” said FDC acting president Etta Rosales. “In
response to our campaign, and because of the questions about this dangerous bill that have
been there from the beginning, groups and communities across the country have been raising
their grave concerns regarding this piece of legislation.”

The proposed bill (HB 6300), sponsored Pampanga Rep. Mickey Aroyo and principally authored
by Pangasinan Rep. Mark Cojuangco, calls for the “immediate rehabilitation and commissioning”
of the Bataan Nuclear Power Plant. The original bill (HB 4631) listed 185 co-authors. The
current consolidated bill lists only 125 co-authors.

The BNPP was mothballed in 1986 over concerns about safety and has never been operated.
The plant was built in an earthquake fault zone and on the slope of an ancient volcano in
Morong, Bataan.

Congress will go into marathon session starting Monday, May 25. The BNPP bill is one of the
“priority bills” to be debated. For its part, FDC continues its campaign and its critique of the bill
to legislators. While raising substantive issues about the plant’s unknown costs and potential
safety hazards, the central issue in the critique of HB 6300 is that there has been no recent
feasibility study concerning the rehabilitation of the plant, and the bill does not make reference
to any of the feasibility studies that were conducted before or after the plant was

mothballed 22 years ago.

Buried in the bill is a provision for conducting a feasibility study with a P100-M appropriation.

“The bill really contradicts itself,” said Rosales. “A feasibility study should be conducted before
such a bill is taken up. Without a recent feasibility study we have no idea what the costs might
be, and to what risk we are placing the people of Bataan and the rest of the country.”

Also on Monday, at 9:00 a.m., cyclists from Morong, Bataan will be welcomed at Quezon City
Hall by members of the Freedom from Debt Coalition and the NOtoBNPP. From there they will
all make the final leg of the journey to the House of Representatives. -30-
__._,_.___
PRESS RELEASE
Please refer to:
Loretta Ann Pargas-Rosales, FDC vice president, +63 918 933 43 56
Bobby Diciembre, FDC media campaigner, +63 920 905 98 56

27 May 2009

FDC ramps up campaign vs. Bataan nuke plant even as BNPP consolidated
bill loses steam

MANILA, Philippines – Despite indications that the move to immediately rehabilitate and
operate the Bataan Nuclear Power Plant (BNPP) is losing steam, the Freedom from Debt
Coalition continues to ramp up its campaign to derail the effort.

In an open letter to Energy Secretary Angelo Reyes, FDC, a lead member of the Network
Opposed to BNPP (NO to BNPP), concurred with statements he made last week which seemed
to question the rush by some members of Congress to rehabilitate the BNPP.

Reyes noted that all stakeholders need to be on board if the plant is to be revived. There is in
fact considerable opposition to the facility from the community, including a resolution against
rehabilitating BNPP passed by the Bataan Provincial Board on March 2, this year.

Reyes also stated that it would take 15 years before the Philippines could build up the technical
capacity necessary to operate a nuclear power plant.

Reyes was referring to a legislation in Congress (HB 6300) introduced by Pangasinan Rep.
Mark Cojuangco for the “immediate rehabilitation and commissioning” of the controversial
nuclear power plant.

BNPP was mothballed in 1986 over concerns about safety. It is located in an earthquake zone
in Morong, Bataan, and was built on the slopes of an ancient volcano. The plant was never
operated.

Cojuangco and Pampanga Rep. Mickey Arroyo first introduced the legislation in February to
rehabilitate the plant (HB 4631).. That bill listed 185 co-authors. The consolidated bill, HB
6300, now contains only 125 co-authors.

“This indicates that support for this bill is wearing away” said FDC vice president Etta Rosales, a
former party-list representative, adding “that doesn’t mean, however, that we can be
complacent.”

Rosales said that this dwindling support is, at least in part, due to the “People Are Watching You
Campaign” that FDC and the NO to BNPP launched on April 1. Members of the FDC network
nationwide have been vigilantly watching over their representative regarding the bill.

In both the open letter to Reyes, and in a critique of HB 6300, FDC anchored its concern on the
bill’s lack of a feasibility study. There is no feasibility study and the bill has no reference to
scientific studies conducted before or after BNPP was mothballed in 1986.

“There are serious issues here regarding the cost of rehabilitating BNPP, and the health and
safety aspects. These issues cannot be debated by Congress in a meaningful way without a
feasibility study, otherwise they are being asked to vote on something without knowing the cost,
and without knowing the risks,” Rosales said.

Westinghouse was originally contracted to build BNPP as a two-reactor plant for $600,000. In
the end, a single reactor plant was built for $2.3 billion, not including debt service.

Philippine energy plans, FDC says in its letter to Reyes, should be consistent with the
Renewable Energy Act of 2008. With its recently approved Implementing Rules and Regulations
(IRR), the said law is considered the first and most comprehensive renewable energy legislation
in Southeast Asia..

After passing the committee on rules last week, HB 6300 is among the “priority bills” to be
debated by Congress in its remaining sessions before it adjourns on June 5.

FDC concludes its letter to Reyes by urging the Department of Energy to protect the people’s
right to “live safely and securely against the dangers and economic costs threatened by any
rehabilitation and operation of the BNPP.” -30-