9/25/2016

Modern Technology Unlocks Secrets of a Damaged Biblical Scroll - The New York Times

http://nyti.ms/2d07TEo

SCIENCE

Modern Technology Unlocks Secrets of a

Damaged Biblical Scroll
By NICHOLAS WADE

SEPT. 21, 2016

Nearly half a century ago, archaeologists found a charred ancient scroll in the ark of
a synagogue on the western shore of the Dead Sea.
The lump of carbonized parchment could not be opened or read. Its curators did
nothing but conserve it, hoping that new technology might one day emerge to make
the scroll legible.
Just such a technology has now been perfected by computer scientists at the
University of Kentucky. Working with biblical scholars in Jerusalem, they have used
a computer to unfurl a digital image of the scroll.
It turns out to hold a fragment identical to the Masoretic text of the Hebrew
Bible and, at nearly 2,000 years old, is the earliest instance of the text.
The writing retrieved by the computer from the digital image of the unopened
scroll is amazingly clear and legible, in contrast to the scrolls blackened and beatenup exterior. Never in our wildest dreams did we think anything would come of it,
said Pnina Shor, the head of the Dead Sea Scrolls Project at the Israel Antiquities
Authority.
Scholars say this remarkable new technique may make it possible to read other
scrolls too brittle to be unrolled.

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/22/science/ancient-sea-scrolls-bible.html?action=click&contentCollection=science&region=rank&module=package&version=highli 1/4

9/25/2016

Modern Technology Unlocks Secrets of a Damaged Biblical Scroll - The New York Times

The scrolls content, the first two chapters of the Book of Leviticus, has
consonants early Hebrew texts didnt specify vowels that are identical to those
of the Masoretic text, the authoritative version of the Hebrew Bible and the one often
used as the basis for translations of the Old Testament in Protestant Bibles.
The Dead Sea scrolls, those found at Qumran and elsewhere around the Dead Sea,
contain versions quite similar to the Masoretic text but with many small differences.
The text in the scroll found at the En-Gedi excavation site in Israel decades ago has
none, according to Emanuel Tov, an expert on the Dead Sea scrolls at the Hebrew
University of Jerusalem.
We have never found something as striking as this, Dr. Tov said.
This is the earliest evidence of the exact form of the medieval text, he said,
referring to the Masoretic text.
The experts say this new method may make it possible to read other ancient
scrolls, including several Dead Sea scrolls and about 300 carbonized ones from
Herculaneum, which were destroyed by the volcanic eruption of Mount Vesuvius in
A.D. 79.
The date of the En-Gedi scroll is the subject of conflicting evidence. A carbon-14
measurement indicates that the scroll was copied around A.D. 300. But the style of
the ancient script suggests a date nearer to A.D. 100. We may safely date this scroll
to between A.D. 50 and 100, wrote Ada Yardeni, an expert on Hebrew paleography,
in an article in the journal Textus. Dr. Tov said he was inclined toward a firstcentury date, based on paleography.
The feat of recovering the text was made possible by software programs
developed by W. Brent Seales, a computer scientist at the University of Kentucky.
Inspired by the hope of reading the many charred and unopenable scrolls found at
Herculaneum, near Pompeii in Italy, Dr. Seales has been working for the last 13
years on ways to read the text inside an ancient scroll.
Methods like CT scans can pick out blobs of ink inside a charred scroll, but the
jumble of letters is unreadable unless each letter can be assigned to the surface on

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/22/science/ancient-sea-scrolls-bible.html?action=click&contentCollection=science&region=rank&module=package&version=highli 2/4

9/25/2016

Modern Technology Unlocks Secrets of a Damaged Biblical Scroll - The New York Times

which it is written. Dr. Seales realized that the writing surface of the scroll had first
to be reconstructed and the letters then stuck back to it.
He succeeded in 2009 in working out the physical structure of the ruffled layers
of papyrus in a Herculaneum scroll.
He has since developed a method, called virtual unwrapping, to model the
surface of an ancient scroll in the form of a mesh of tiny triangles. Each triangle can
be resized by the computer until the virtual surface makes the best fit to the internal
structure of the scroll, as revealed by the scanning method. The blobs of ink are
assigned to their right place on the structure, and the computer then unfolds the
whole 3-D structure into a 2-D sheet.
The suite of software programs, called Volume Cartography, will become open
source when Dr. Sealess current government grant ends, he said.
The En-Gedi scroll was brought to Dr. Sealess attention by Dr. Shor. A
colleague, Sefi Porat, who had helped excavate the En-Gedi synagogue in 1970, was
preparing a final publication of the findings.
He asked Dr. Shor to scan the scroll and other artifacts as part of a project to
create images of all Dead Sea scroll material, and showed her a box full of lumps of
charcoal.
I said, There is nothing we can do because our system isnt geared toward
these chunks, she said. But because she was submitting other objects for a highresolution scan, she put one of the lumps in with other items.
Dr. Shor had the lump scanned by a commercially available, X-ray based,
micro-computed tomography machine, of the kind used for fine-resolution scanning
of biological tissues. Knowing of Dr. Sealess work, she sent him the scan and asked
him to analyze it.
Both were surprised when, after several refinements, an image emerged with
clear and legible script. We were amazed at the quality of the images much of the
text is as readable as that of unharmed Dead Sea scrolls, said Michael Segal, a
biblical scholar at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, who helped analyze the text.

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/22/science/ancient-sea-scrolls-bible.html?action=click&contentCollection=science&region=rank&module=package&version=highli 3/4

9/25/2016

Modern Technology Unlocks Secrets of a Damaged Biblical Scroll - The New York Times

The surviving content of the En-Gedi scroll, the first two chapters of Leviticus, is
part of a listing of the various sacrifices that were performed in biblical times at the
temple in Jerusalem. Although some text has previously been identified in ancient
artifacts, the En-Gedi manuscript represents the first severely damaged, ink-based
scroll to be unrolled and identified noninvasively, Dr. Seales and his colleagues
write in the journal Science Advances.
Richard Janko, a classical scholar at the University of Michigan, said the
carbonized scrolls from Herculaneum were a small section of a much larger library
at a grand villa probably owned by Julius Caesars father-in-law, Lucius Calpurnius
Piso.
Much of the villa is still unexcavated, and its library could contain long-lost
works of Latin and Greek literature. Successful reading of even a single scroll from
Herculaneum with Dr. Sealess method would spur excavation of the rest of Pisos
villa, Dr. Janko said.
Both Dr. Tov and Dr. Segal said that scholars might come to consider the EnGedi manuscript as a Dead Sea scroll, especially if the early date indicated by
paleography is confirmed.
It doesnt tell us what was the original text, only that the Masoretic text is a
very ancient text in all of its details, Dr. Segal said. And we now have evidence that
this text was being used from a very early date by Jews in the land of Israel.
Correction:September23,2016
An article on Thursday about the use of computer technology to unfurl a digital image of
an ancient scroll misidentified the journal in which the research appears and misstated
the date of publication. It was published in Science Advances on Wednesday, not in the
Thursday issue of Science.
Like the Science Times page on Facebook. | Sign up for the Science Times newsletter.
AversionofthisarticleappearsinprintonSeptember22,2016,onpageA12oftheNewYorkedition
withtheheadline:TechnologyUnlocksSecretsofaBiblicalScroll.

2016TheNewYorkTimesCompany

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/22/science/ancient-sea-scrolls-bible.html?action=click&contentCollection=science&region=rank&module=package&version=highli 4/4