Many teachers encounter students from different walks of life that each bring about a different experience. Each unique student also serves to test a teacher's ability to handle diversity. The students that pose the biggest test to teachers are those with different disabilities. Students with disabilities force a teacher to utilize each aspect of their training and education to come up with a plan to best provide an educational atmosphere for the child with the disability. However, it is children with rare disabilities that truly force a teacher to not only utilize their experience and education, but also their resources to identify what will best serve the educational needs of the student. Rare disabilities need to be researched along with the physical, emotional, philosophical, social, and intellectual developments in order to properly educate the student. The following case study will analyze each area of development for a student with the rare syndrome known as Lesch Nyhan Syndrome. This student in this case study is a 14 year old, Hispanic, male in the 8th grade. For identification purposes, the student will be referred to as Radio. Radio is approximately 5'4" and weighs 95 pounds. He has had all of his teeth surgically removed due to self-mutilation of lips and fingers. This is common with Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome and will be discussed in a later section. Radio is non-mobile and in a wheelchair. His arms and legs are Kept in restraints as per doctor order and strapped into the wheelchair at all times for his own protection. He also wears a helmet during transitions and a surgical face mask at all times to prevent him from spitting on other people. PHYSICAL DEVELOPMENT Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome (LNS) is extremely rare for example, "in a country the size of the United Kingdom, population 56 million, only 4 new cases will occur each year." (McCarthy, 2004) LNS is a deficit of the "enzyme of purine metabolism
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 3
Hypoxanthine-Guanine Phosphoribosyl Transferase (HPRT)." (McCarthy, 2004) The deficit causes neurological damage that result in a variety of issues. LNS also occurs in males because the it is an "X chromosome linked recessive disorder" (Nyhan et al, 1967). Although it occurs in males, "transmission always occurred through the female" (Nyhan, 2004). "In the baby, the clinical signs are developmental delay, hypotonia, irritability, feeding difficulties and 'sand' or orange crystals in the diaper." (McCarthy, 2004) As the child gets older, some symptoms include crying and self-mutilating of the lips and fingers through biting. Initially some children may be misdiagnosed with cerebral palsy because of developmental delays. "Persons with LND wear restraints and other protective devices most of the time, invariably suffer from severe motor abnormalities, and sometimes receive anxiolytic or other medications to reduce their risk of self-injury" (David, 2005). As they get older, patients also have issues maintaining an appropriate weight due to vitamin deficiencies. Patients also have spinal cord degeneration. They are unable to "walk or even sit without support" (Nyhan, 2004). Patients with LND often have renal failure, are prone to kidney stones, and loss of bowel function. The child also experiences excessive muscle tension that leads to spontaneous spams. Those same muscle spasms debilitate their speech muscles and other muscles that are essential for digestion. Many patients also have problems sleeping and can develop sleep apnoea. As they grow into puberty the HPRT deficiency causes their testes to decrease in size and lose function, known as testicular atrophy. In addition to testicular atrophy, many LNS patients may also experience severe acid reflux and hernias. The life expectancy of LND patients is in the mid-forties, however many die prior to that age because of other complications such as renal failure and "respiratory failure." (McCarthy, 2004) Additionally, patients may also have
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 4
complication from severe acid reflux and vomiting. Some may even die from accidentally swallowing vomit. Radio does show some of the physical attributes of Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome. Radio is constantly having muscle spasms as because of that is kept strapped into his wheelchair at all times. He also has to eat pureed food because he has no teeth. He has a limited vocabulary and can typically say words that are one syllable. When changing his soiled diapers, occasionally crystals can be spotted. Radio also cries frequently. The charts on page eleven compare Radio's height and weight to that of an average 14-year-old boy. All data was gathered from the Centers for Disease and Control Prevention published in 2000. EMOTIONAL/BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT Parents of children with or without disabilities are curious as to what to expect in the behavioral and emotional development of their child. Parents of children with disabilities become far more curious because they must plan for the care of their child far beyond the child reaching an adult age. "Mental retardation of severe degree is considered in nearly all published reports to be the cardinal feature of the Lesch-Nyhan syndrome" (Scherzer, 1969). In addition to mental retardation, patients also experience significant emotional and behavioral developmental consequences. Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome is a metabolism disorder; however "this was the first example of a well-defined disorder of metabolism in which there was a recognizable pattern of abnormal behavior." (Nyhan 2004) One of the major concerns for LNS patients is that they inflict self-harm and selfmutilation. This type of behavior "occurs in 85% of cases... [and] can start at any time, on average at 3 years." (McCarthy, 2004) Some of the self-inflicted harm can include
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 5
severe biting of the lips and fingers. This type of behavior is also "compulsive and distressing and appears to be biologically driven." (McCarthy, 2004) Some of this distressing behavior can be managed by using good communication, relaxation techniques and consistent caretaker relationships. Patients with LNS respond better when the people who they are used to being taken care of are consistent not only with their expectations and the way they treat the child but also the people are consistent and there are no frequent changes in who is taking care of them. According to McCarthy, a study done in 2003 revealed that biting of the lips and fingers was the most common self-mutilation at approximately 53%. However, "48% had oral or facial damage, 25% damage to the hands, and 42% had some or all of their teeth removed." (McCarthy,2004) The harm and injury these patients experience is not only on themselves, they are also prone to injure others around them, however they do not enjoy this. Many LNS patients are severely depressed and should be medicated. In addition to depression, LNS patients also show signs of stress. Their speech impediments and spasms are stress induced. Although Radio can communicate some things, he is considered non-verbal. He may only speak limited single-syllable words and has a hard time remembering things. You can clearly tell when he is happy or sad. He cries often and you can tell he is sad when he does. At times when Radio is upset, you can tell what triggered the emotion, however he often cries for no obvious reason. He is able to recognize the need to respond with appropriate terms for personal care such as indicating his diaper needing to be changed, responding when someone sneezes with "Bless you" or saying "Excuse me" following a burp. Radio also has a personality similar to that of a fourteen-year-old boy with no developmental syndromes. For example, Radio is particularly attracted to
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 6
females, if his arms are not fully strapped down and a female walks past him, he will touch her buttocks. He will only do this with females. When he does this, he typically smiles and does not show any signs of it being an uncontrollable spasm. Radio also openly and distinctly expresses which caretakers he is partial to. When Mr. Bonnet, commonly known as Coach Mo, walks into the room Radio immediately recognizes him and starts repeatedly calling out to him saying, "Mo!" He continues to do this until Mr. Bonnet greets him. Radio currently has a vocabulary of 100 words as determined by direct observation. Information in the following chart was gathered from McGraw Hill, HigherEd. Radio has his pleasant moments when he is happy; he also shows signs of depression as stated above with the frequent crying. He also inflicts self-harm upon himself and has to be securely strapped at all times. He has arm and leg restraints as well as a seatbelt on his wheel chair. When the class is practicing motor exercises on the mat, he is also strapped to the mat. The most significant behavior that Radio exhibits is his muscle spasm. Knowing that muscle spasms are stress induced can be a great tool to educators. For one, educators and support staff can work together to be properly trained on relaxation techniques to use in order to help Radio stay calm. Identifying and avoiding situations that cause Radio stress can also be helpful. In addition to avoiding stressful situations, knowing when a situation will cause Radio stress and proactively working on relaxation techniques around the time those situations arise can minimize unavoidable stress. With respect to Radio's inappropriate behavior towards females, making sure that his arms are properly restrained when a female is nearby could be helpful. Research indicates that LNS patients should be encouraged to use natural restraints such as sitting on their arms or hands. Training
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 7
Radio on this can be beneficial as it allows him to develop a new set of behaviors and begin to learn self-control. PHILOSOPHICAL/MORAL DEVELOPMENT LNS patients have significant developmental impediments but also have areas in which they can develop quite well. Although LNS patients each exhibit a multitude of behaviors that some would consider inappropriate or reckless, many of the behaviors they exhibit are uncontrollable but not without remorse. They understand that while they cannot control their behaviors, their behaviors are unacceptable. "Many psychologists think that in children, the seeds of moral values are emotional, not intellectual" (Kantrowitz & Namuth, 1991). Children with LNS can clearly demonstrate emotions such as happiness, sadness, excitement, etc. Their emotional development aids their development with moral values. Moral values do not only include a sense of what is acceptable and what is not, but also how they will act towards and with others. LNS patients clearly know right from wrong. The same way that an LNS patient would hurt his or her-self, they would also hurt another. However, their mobility is impaired and the impact is not as great. "When the child is successful in hurting another, he displays considerable remorse, just as he does when he succeeds in hurting himself. These patients are compulsively driven to behave in ways that they do not at all enjoy" (Nyhan, 2004). Radio clearly exhibits a sense of right and wrong. When he performs an act, which is unacceptable such as inappropriately touching a female, he understands that the behavior is inappropriate. When Radio touches a girl's buttocks, he will not make eye contact, he blushes, and smiles.. Radio also spits frequently. He has to wear a surgical facemask at all times to prevent from spitting on other people. When he spits
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 8
on others, staff tries to redirect him to blow kisses. When he spits on someone else and staff says no, he immediately begins to blow kisses and shows signs of remorse. In the same fashion when he touches a female's buttocks and is told no, he will also begin to blow kisses. Radio clearly understands what is appropriate and what is not. Using a method of redirection with Radio is definitely effective. Because staff is consistent with expressing what is appropriate and what is not and asks that Radio blow kisses instead, he also knows what to expect. The challenge with Radio is not his lack of moral knowledge, but getting him to make better moral choices. It is good that he recognizes what is right and wrong when he does something inappropriate, however staff is currently trying to work with Radio so that he learns not to do the undesired behavior. Staff uses positive reinforcement and redirection to encourage this in Radio. SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT LNS patients not only have developmental barriers but those same barriers can lead to other difficulties. LNS patients have a severe lack of motor skills. They have little to no muscles in their mouth and can say very few and limited words. The limited words that they do know come across with a "slurring of speech sounds" (Nyhan, 2004). As a result, they are unable to communicate on a regular basis with others. Because LNS also causes self-mutilation and harm, patients are restrained at all times. Even in an environment where social interaction would be encouraged, patients with LNS would be unable to participate with others as they cannot be left unrestrained. The "LN[S] behavioral phenotype extends beyond self-injury to include aggression and other behavioral abnormalities" (David, 2005). As they get upset easily, they may also lash out and act aggressively towards others easily. From moral development also comes the notion of "learning how to interact" (Boulton-Lewis et al, 2011). This means
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 9
that patients with LNS must learn to interact with others even though they may not necessarily have significant contact with other people. The people who are used to interacting with LNS patients are aware of their own unique personalities. "Patients with LN[S] have been described as engaging, curious, good humored,manipulative, obstinate, irritable, apologetic, and distractible" (David, 2005). Currently, Radio is in a self-contained classroom. While there are other students in the classroom, Radio does not get to play and socialize with other children. He is constantly restrained and has limited speech and as a result cannot hold a conversation with others. He also has frequent and uncontrollable muscle spasms and outbursts of injury towards himself and others. Radio, if left unrestrained, will hit others. Radio also constantly spits. Holding any sort of social interaction with people other than the ones who are accustomed to interacting and working with him is highly difficult. When Radio does interact with new people he shows excitement. Average children, are able to freely interact with a multitude of peers in a variety of scenarios, it is important to bring that element to children with Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome. INTELLECTUAL/ACADEMIC DEVELOPMENT There are several stages to literacy and they include the "pre-reading, or Stage 0 (ages birth to 6 years and prior to first grade), refers to emergent literacy during which students are exposed to print, learn graphemes, and memorize labels and signs in the environment" (Skebo etal, 2013). By the time a normal child reaches "Stage 3 (ages 10-12 years; fourth through eighth grades), incorporates the transition from learning to read to reading to learn. In this stage, students are able to use reading as a tool for learning new information" (Skebo et al, 2013). Achild with LNS is unable to read at the appropriate level for his or her age range. They do not have the cognitive
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 10
function or the muscle strength to formulate words. Patients with LNS have "impairment of temporal lobe orientation and recognition memory, severe impairment of auditory divided attention and free recall on word list learning and moderately severe impairment on tests of reasoning and intelligence" (McCarthy, 2004). Patients with LNS as a result have a short attention span, have difficulty learning vocabulary words, and may have trouble with their memory. Radio shows significant developmental delays in his intelligence. Radio is approximately at a Stage 0 in literacy. He is unable to read and comprehend books. Many of the stories told to Radio focus on building his vocabulary with small words and include mostly pictures. Many times, it can be difficult to continue to expand his vocabulary as he has a short attention span. As a tool, an iPad is used. With the iPad, Radio's attention span seems to improve slightly. Although his attention span improves he has difficulty maneuvering on the iPad, but does enjoy it. The iPad is utilized to encourage Radio to draw shapes and refine his sensory motor skills. Staff engages Radio with flash cards to test his knowledge on vocabulary. Staff also utilizes flash cards to communicate with Radio. He has flash cards for when he likes something or does not. If staff is unable to tell what Radio is feeling they may ask him, "Do you feel bad?" while holding up a flashcard with a sad face. If Radio is not feeling well, he will say yes. If something else is bothering him, he will say no. A challenge that is constantly present for staff is that Radio has a severe and rare developmental syndrome. Staff could be more proactive about educating Radio instead of simply watching over him. Staff at times can be complacent and can seem to focus on making sure that Radio spends his time at school entertained and in a pleasant mood. If he is feeling tired or is uncooperative, they tend to not push him too much and not work on
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 11
his word list or other educational needs. For long term sustainability with Radio's educational development, it would be best to work on a routine of education daily. PHYSICAL DEVELOPMENT GRAPH
EMOTIONAL/BEHAVIORAL DEVELOPMENT GRAPH
RECOMMENDATIONS/ CONCLUSION
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 12
Recommendations for Physical development ensure that the child receive anxiolytic or other medications to reduce their risk of self-injury. Recommendation for his Emotional and Behavioral development Parents should avoid stressful situations, they should know when a situation will cause Radio stress and proactively working on relaxation techniques around the time those situations arise can minimize unavoidable stress.Recommendation for Philosophical and Moral Development the parents and the teacher is to use the redirection method.In order to improve his Social Development recommendation for his development is working in partnership with traditional students and having them read a story to Radio so that he has interaction with other children and it is in a controlled environment. Recommendation for the patients Intellectual and Academical Development is for the parent and teacher to focus on building the patients vocabulary with small words and include pictures. Overall, Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome is an extremely rare developmental disease that impact several aspects of a child's development. It impacts primarily the purine metabolism in a patient, however can lead to renal failure, respiratory failure, severe acid reflux, uncontrollable muscle spasms, self-mutilation and harm, and severe mental retardation. Patients with LNS die at young ages although they are expected to live into their forties. Their quality of life is limited as they spend most of their time restrained. For several patients, self-mutilation is common. They are kept restrained into their wheelchairs or beds at all times. Although they do inflict harm on themselves and others, they do not want to but they cannot control themselves. They are also unable to properly communicate and have limited vocabulary and speech. Even with all of their delays, LNS patients seem to have a strong sense of emotions. They also suffer from depression and cry out often.
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 13
The case study done on Radio, a 14 year old male with LNS, revealed that his development was consistent what that of a typical LNS patient but below that of an average student. Although he has developmental delays, he has clear and distinct likes and dislikes. The team that works with him on a regular basis is aware of his needs and could implement some minor changes that would benefit the development of Radio.
REFERENCES
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 14
Boulton-Lewis, G., Brownlee, J., Walker, S., Cobb-Moore, C., & Johansson, E. (2011). Moral and social development: Teachers' knowledge of children's learning and teaching strategies in the early years. Australasian Journal Of Early Childhood, 36(4), 6-14. David J, S., Julianna, W., Stephen M, M., Jonathan, Y., Juan G, P., William L, N., & ... James C, H. (2005). Behavioral aspects of LeschNyhan disease and its variants. Developmental Medicine & Child Neurology, 47(10), 673-677. Kantrowitz, B. B., & Namuth, T. T. (1991). The good, the bad, and the difference. (Cover story). Newsweek, 11 7(22), 48. McCarthy, G. (2004). Medical Diagnosis, Management and Treatment of Lesch Nyhan Disease.Nucleosides, Nucleotides & Nucleic Acids, 23(8/9), 1147-1152. doi:10.1081/NCN-200027395. Nyhan, W. (2005). Lesch-Nyhan Disease. Journal Of The History Of The Neurosciences, 14(1), 1-10. doi:10.1080/096470490512490. Nyhan, W. L. (2008). Lesch-Nyhan Disease. Nucleosides, Nucleotides & Nucleic Acids, 27(6/7), 559-563. doi:10.1080/15257770802135745. Scherzer, A. L., & Ilson, J. B. (1969). Normal Intelligence in the Lesch-Nyhan Syndrome. Pediatrics, 44(1), 116. Skebo, C. M., Lewis, B. A., Freebairn, L. A., Tag, J., Ciesla, A., Stein, C. M., & ... Marinellie, S.(2013). Reading Skills of Students With Speech Sound Disorders at Three Stages of Literacy Development. Language, Speech & Hearing Services In Schools, 44(4), 360-373. doi:10.1044/0161-1461(2013/12-0015)
LESCH- NYHAN PEPSI 15
Stall, J. N., Hawley, D. A., Hagen, M. C., Bull, M. J., & Hattab, E. M. (2010). Posterior column degeneration in the cervical/thoracic spinal cord in Lesch-Nyhan syndrome (LNS): a casereport Scientific correspondence Scientific correspondence. Neuropathology & Applied Neurobiology, 36(7), 680-684. doi:10.1111/.1365-2990.2010.01125.x
Raising Mentally Strong Kids: How to Combine the Power of Neuroscience with Love and Logic to Grow Confident, Kind, Responsible, and Resilient Children and Young Adults
Dark Psychology & Manipulation: Discover How To Analyze People and Master Human Behaviour Using Emotional Influence Techniques, Body Language Secrets, Covert NLP, Speed Reading, and Hypnosis.
Empath: The Survival Guide For Highly Sensitive People: Protect Yourself From Narcissists & Toxic Relationships. Discover How to Stop Absorbing Other People's Pain
Dark Psychology: Learn To Influence Anyone Using Mind Control, Manipulation And Deception With Secret Techniques Of Dark Persuasion, Undetected Mind Control, Mind Games, Hypnotism And Brainwashing